DOCSLIB.ORG

Exposed: Obeids' Secret Harbour Deal

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Exposed: Obeids' Secret Harbour Deal Exposed: Obeids' secret harbour deal Date May 19, 2012 Linton Besser, Kate McClymont The former ALP powerbroker Eddie Obeid hid his interests in a lucrative cafe strip. Moses Obeid. Photo: Kate Geraghty FORMER minister Eddie Obeid's family has controlled some of Circular Quay's most prominent publicly- owned properties by hiding its interests behind a front company. A Herald investigation has confirmed that Mr Obeid and his family secured the three prime cafes in 2003 and that for his last nine years in the upper house he failed to inform Parliament about his family's interest in these lucrative government leases. Quay Eatery, Wharf 5. Photo: Mick Tsikas For the first time, senior officials and former cabinet ministers Carl Scully and Eric Roozendaal have confirmed Mr Obeid's intervention in the lease negotiations for the quay properties, including seeking favourable conditions for the cafes, which the Herald can now reveal he then secretly acquired. Crucially, when the former NSW treasurer Michael Costa had charge of the waterfront, he put a stop to a public tender scheduled for 2005 that might have threatened the Obeids' control over two of the properties. Mr Obeid was the most powerful player inside the NSW Labor Party for the past two decades, and was described in 2009 by the deposed premier Nathan Rees as the party's puppet-master. Eddie Obeid. Photo: Jon Reid The Arc Cafe, Quay Eatery and Sorrentino, which are located in blue-ribbon positions on or next to the bustling ferry wharves at the quay, are all run by a $1 company called Circular Quay Restaurants Pty Ltd. On paper, the Circular Quay company is owned by John Abood, Mr Obeid's brother-in-law. However, the Herald has obtained a sworn statement from Mr Obeid's son Moses that was tendered in Court of Appeal proceedings that lists among his $11.3 million assets a $700,000 share of ''Circular Quay Restaurants''. At the Court of Appeal earlier this year, Moses Obeid inadvertently confirmed the long-rumoured involvement of the Obeid family in the restaurants, which was masked by using a discretionary trust. ''The Circular Quay Family Trust owns numerous Circular Quay restaurants,'' Moses Obeid said in his affidavit. All the units in that family trust are owned by another family trust - the Obeid Family Trust No. 2, he stated. Eddie Obeid's other son, Paul Obeid, testified in March this year that: ''In our trusts we have, there [are] nine brothers and sisters, there's two parents and 30 grandchildren.'' A confidential 2007 document from a separate Obeid company seeking government contracts, which was also tendered in the proceedings, noted that the Obeid connection ''provided access to government'' and that it was a big plus ''being able to get to the right person first time''. But the downside was ''media attention and speculation''. It was suggested that this could be avoided by ''the possible remove (sic) of Obeid family name through the use of a discretionary trust''. Previously, when the waterfront leases were still held by the Obeid associate and former Labor Party donor Tony Imad, Carl Scully had rejected an extraordinary request from Mr Obeid to have the leases extended. In the run-up to the Olympics and as part of a plan to remodel the quay, the wharf leases were to be renewed. But Mr Scully sought approval from the Independent Commission Against Corruption specifically to ensure there would be no probity issues. The ICAC gave an opinion that it approved based on the fact that the leases were strictly for five years and were then to be put to a public tender. "But shortly after this process was concluded, Eddie Obeid requested that I give a five-year extension to the lease on the concession held at Circular Quay by a Tony Imad," Mr Scully told the Herald. "I flatly refused this request on the spot without even bothering to get departmental advice. ''I advised Eddie that this whole drawn-out process had been ticked off by ICAC at every step of the way and that there was no way I was going to revisit it. This was not well received and for the first time Eddie became quite angry. I was somewhat surprised at the reaction as for me it was just another policy matter I took a firm stand on." Mr Scully said that "it was only after I left politics that an allegation was made to me that Eddie had at the time in question a direct commercial interest. If the allegation is true, then it would explain the overreaction to my decision but would still leave me feeling very disappointed to say the least. If it is not true, then I would like the Obeid family to provide sufficient evidence or commentary to refute it". A source has confirmed to the Herald that it was the Obeids who paid $2.4 million via a bank cheque for the three cafes and then insisted on an arrangement whereby the restaurants' true owner could not be identified. The source said that under this arrangement Mr Abood would be paid a wage and receive 10 per cent of the profits of the company, and the remainder would flow to the Obeid family via one of its trusts. Other sources report that another of Eddie Obeid's sons, Damien, routinely collects the takings from the three restaurants in person. In 2004, Mr Abood denied he was a front for Mr Obeid, telling the Herald: ''Yes, I am his [Obeid's] brother-in- law, but no way he is involved … I have been here for three years and he has never had anything to do with this business.'' This week, Mr Abood, 56, conceded that the Obeid family had a major interest in the cafes ''but if you think any favours or anything's been done down there for them - definitely not''. ''The Obeids really haven't made any money down there, well we haven't. It's a disaster area,'' Mr Abood said. Banking documents tendered in Moses Obeid's recent court battle with the City of Sydney, in which he has been ordered to pay $12 million, show the Obeid Family Trust 1 made a $100,000 payment to Paul Maroon in October 2010. Mr Maroon is the general manager of Circular Quay Restaurants. In April this year, Mr Maroon signed a formal petition on behalf of the business to seek a further reduction in rent. Having obtained and then hidden his family's interest in the businesses, Eddie Obeid wielded his powers as leader of the dominant faction in the ALP to protect his investment. Most importantly, a competitive tender for the leases that was long scheduled for 2005 was quashed despite repeated pleas from NSW Maritime officials that it proceed. Confidential government documents seen by the Herald show this decision was made despite written advice from multiple probity advisers and the Independent Commission Against Corruption that recommended the public tender go ahead. Maritime's then boss, Chris Oxenbould, told the Herald Mr Costa did not want the tender to proceed, citing the fact that other agencies allowed leaseholders to keep their leases without facing public competition. ''Michael Costa was involved in the discussions around the [expression of interest] process and he made it very clear to me what his position was,'' Mr Oxenbould said. Mr Costa said: ''I don't have a recollection of it, and I'm not going to comment on it, and where you're heading is absurd.'' A former senior Maritime official overseeing commercial property, Zenon Michniewicz, told the Herald the minister refused to allow the leases to be put to the market. ''In 2005 I can say that the minister and the CEO [of Maritime] did not allow it to proceed,'' he said. When Mr Costa was replaced by Eric Roozendaal, a decision was taken by Maritime to not put any of the leases to tender, but to simply roll them over on a month-by-month basis. Mr Roozendaal told the Herald he did discuss the leases at Circular Quay with Mr Obeid when he was the minister. ''Issues with Circular Quay were raised with me by both Eddie Obeid and Michael Costa,'' he said. ''[But] at no time did any member of Parliament declare any interest to me in any properties at Circular Quay. ''I would say that if any MP raised an issue with me and had an interest they didn't declare, it would make me feel very uncomfortable.'' Internal NSW Maritime files show the rent on these Obeid-controlled properties actually decreased from the amount stipulated in the original leases, which were signed six years earlier. In 2006, for example, after negotiations over the rent, the state government took $89,000 less per annum from two of the cafes owned by the Obeid family than the government had intended in 2000. Mr Abood, who said he was a part-owner of the business, claimed the rent reductions had only come about ''because we were all going broke - everybody!'' In 2009, NSW Maritime issued new 10-year leases to the incumbents along the wharves - including to the Obeids' front company - and again without a competitive tender. The minister at the time was Joe Tripodi. Steve Dunn, the former chief executive of Maritime, told the Herald that Mr Tripodi was involved in deciding the matter but claimed it was the department - contrary to the wishes of Mr Tripodi - that decided not to put the leases out to a tender. Such long tenures are worth millions on the open market, and the leases also offered cheaper rent.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Operation Spicer Larceny Charges Recommended Against Former
    NSW SUBSCRIBE LOGIN / SIGN-UP The SydneyNEWS Morning SITE OF Herald THE YEAR News Sport Business World Politics Comment Property Entertainment Lifestyle Travel Cars Search the site NSW News National Environment Health Education Good Weekend Investigations Galleries Clique Photos Victoria News Sydney Traffic Quizzes Home / News / NSW News AUGUST 30 2016 SAVE PRINT LICENSE ARTICLE Operation Spicer: Larceny charges recommended against former minister Chris Hartcher Sean Nicholls, Kate McClymont MORESHARE TWEET Former NSW Liberal minister Chris Hartcher faces potential larceny charges and former Labor minister Joe Tripodi has been found to have engaged in serious corrupt conduct by the Independent Commission Against Corruption following its investigation into political fundraising. The ICAC's Operation Spicer report also says a host of former Liberal MPs including former police minister Mike Gallacher, Mr Hartcher, Tim Owen, Andrew Cornwell, Garry Edwards, Chris Spence as well as former Newcastle Lord Mayor Jeff McCloy "acted with the intention of evading laws" under the Election Funding, Expenditure and Disclosures Act. Operation Spicer's big three findings The Independent Commission Against Corruption has recommended criminal charges following its investigation into political fundraising. Sean Nicholls reports. As well, ICAC has found that Hunter Valley property developer Hilton Grugeon, Mr Hartcher and his former staff member Tim Koelma are among those who "acted with the intention of evading the election funding laws relating to caps on political donations". Former Liberal MPs Craig Baumann and Darren Webber as well as Liberal identity Nick Di Girolamo have been found to have evaded election funding laws relating to disclosure, while another former Liberal MP, Bart Bassett, has been found to have "knowingly solicited a political donation from a property developer".
    [Show full text]
  • Hurlstone Agricultural High School Site Bill 2009
    HURLSTONE AGRICULTURAL HIGH SCHOOL SITE BILL 2009 Second Reading The Hon. CHARLIE LYNN [11.40 a.m.]: I move: That this bill be now read a second time. This is a bill for an Act to require the Hurlstone Agricultural High School site to be retained for educational purposes. The objects of the bill are to ensure that the Hurlstone Agricultural High School site remains in public ownership and to limit the use of the site to that of a government school. Clause 1 sets out the name of the proposed Act. Clause 2 provides for the commencement of the proposed Act on the date of assent to the proposed Act. Clause 3 defines the Hurlstone Agricultural High School site and contains other interpretative provisions. Clause 4 specifies the objects of the proposed Act, as referred to in the overview I have just given. Clause 5 prohibits the Hurlstone Agricultural High School site from being sold, transferred, leased or otherwise alienated. Clause 6 restricts development of the site so that it can be used only for the purposes of a government school. Clause 7 prevents any development of the site from becoming a project to which part 3A of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 applies. Hurlstone Agricultural High School is a selective high school of excellence located in a diminishing green belt on the south-western fringe of the Sydney metropolitan area. The origins of the school are steeped in our history. It began in 1878 with a vision by John Kinloch to establish his own school, the Hurlstone School and College, named in honour of his mother.
    [Show full text]
  • NSW Legislative Council Hansard (Proof)
    Ports Corporatisation and Waterways Management Amendment Bill - 24/10/2006 - 2... Page 1 of 15 Home » Hansard & Papers » Legislative Council » 24/10/2006 » Article 9 of 44 NSW Legislative Council Hansard (Proof) PORTS CORPORATISATION AND WATERWAYS MANAGEMENT AMENDMENT BILL Page: 2 Second Reading The Hon. MICHAEL COSTA (Treasurer, Minister for Infrastructure, and Minister for the Hunter) [2.47 p.m.]: I move: That this bill be now read a second time. I seek leave to incorporate my second reading speech in Hansard. Leave granted. In 1995 the Labor Government introduced the Ports Corporatisation and Waterways Management Act. This groundbreaking legislation dissolved the old Maritime Services Board and created the three port corporations of Sydney, Newcastle and Port Kembla. The port corporations were established with a charter to operate efficiently on a commercial basis, to maximise the State's investment and to promote trade through their facilities. Each of the port corporations are also required to carry out certain port safety functions under their port safety operating licence. The Act introduced new commercial disciplines and management accountabilities. Cross—subsidisation between the major ports has been eliminated. Many benefits have flown from this initiative, including increased efficiencies and a corresponding reduction in costs. Greater trade has been attracted to the ports and the adjacent regions. A clear signal was sent to the business community that this Government is committed to achieving greater economic growth for the State. ———— The ports are an integral link in the freight logistics chain handling $60 Billion of trade in New South Wales. The port of Botany is now the second largest container port in Australia.
    [Show full text]
  • No. 6 Centennial Consultancy
    Submission No 6 INQUIRY INTO MINISTERIAL PROPRIETY IN NEW SOUTH WALES Organisation: Centennial Consultancy Date received: 16/10/2013 Submission to Legislative Council Select Committee Inquiry into Ministerial Propriety in NSW Prepared by Dr Betty Con Walker and Prof Bob Walker _____________________________________________________________________ October 2013 CONTENTS page 1. Introduction 1 2. Ministerial responsibility to Parliament 1 2.1 Examples of failures of ministerial responsibility to Parliament 2 2.2 Recommendations 5 3. Measures to reduce potential conflicts of interest 7 3.1 Failures of ministerial behaviour 7 3.2 Recommendations 8 4. The operation and enforcement of the Lobbying of Government Officials Act 2011 9 4.1 Definition of ‘lobbyist’ – exemption of associations 9 4.2 Definition of ‘lobbyist’ – exemption of certain technical or professional occupations 10 4.3 Definition of ‘lobbyist’ – does not capture in-house government relations advisers 11 4.4 Monitoring compliance and imposing sanctions 11 4.5 Administrative requirements 12 4.6 Recommendations 13 SUBMISSION TO LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL SELECT COMMITTEE INQUIRY INTO MINISTERIAL PROPRIETY IN NSW 1. INTRODUCTION Centennial Consultancy welcomes the opportunity provided by the Committee to make a submission on ministerial propriety in NSW. The submission focuses on the following Terms of Reference: (a) Ministerial responsibility to Parliament, including the doctrine of individual ministerial responsibility (b) Measures to reduce potential conflicts of interest between a minister’s public duties, private interests and membership of a political party, particularly in relation to financial and commercial activities (c) The operation and enforcement of the Lobbying of Government Officials Act 2011, and any associated codes of conduct, registers or administrative arrangements.
    [Show full text]
  • How Labor Factions Broke New South Wales
    10 IPA Review | November 2008 www.ipa.org.au How Labor factions broke New South Wales Outgoing NSW Premier Morris Iemma leaves the caucus meeting were he was deposed as Premier. Sergio Dionisio | AAPImage Sergio deposed as Premier. he was the caucus meeting were Morris Iemma leaves NSW Premier Outgoing NSW’s conservative ALP was good at fending off communism, but now it can’t seem to do anything else, writes Richard Allsop. except NSW which went marginally backwards. n the six months following the At 4.9 per cent in August, New South Wales also 1975 defeat of the Whitlam has the highest unemployment rate. The economic performance has also impacted the budgetary po- Government, Australia’s two sition with projected shortfalls of $90 million per Imost populous states held elections. month in revenue leading to a $1 billion black- hole. In Victoria, the voters re-elected Perhaps even more striking than the ebbs and flows of economic data are the projections that a Liberal government that had been Melbourne will grow to be bigger than Sydney at some time in the second quarter of the twentieth in office for 21 years; in NSW they century. Sydney regained the population lead from rejected one that had been in office Melbourne in the 1890s and just as that decade demonstrated the benefits of free trade liberalism for 11 years. over protectionism so much, the current policy A large part of the reason for those results was voters perceptions of the settings also help explain recent population move- Labor opposition in both states.
    [Show full text]
  • Glebe Society Bulletin 2006 Issue 10
    Premier’s Community Awards - Three Glebe Society members honoured From left to right: Ald Robert Webb; The Premier, Morris Iemma; Jane Spring; Joe Mannix; Minister Sandra Nori; Bruce Davis; Cr Verity Firth. Photo courtesy of the State Government There was a very pleasant surprise at the Glebe Jane Spring was rewarded for her sporting Balmain Community Reception for the NSW achievements in rowing and her ongoing Premier and Cabinet Ministers on Monday 20 promotion of rowing as a sport. November. The Premier’s Community Awards for Joe Mannix was honoured for service to the community service were announced, and no less Seniors in Port Jackson, in particular for his than three of the four recipients are members of work at the Hannaford Seniors Centre and his the Glebe Society. The Glebe Society congratu- tireless efforts with Public Housing tenants. 10/2006 November/December lates them all. The fourth award was given to Leichhardt Bruce Davis received his award for service to the Council Alderman Robert Webb, for service to community of Glebe with the Glebe Society, the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander working for the preservation of the historically Community in the inner western suburbs. significant suburb of Glebe. - Bob Armstrong The Massing of the Boats You’ll find an insert in this Bulletin drawing your our scene. Our role and that of the other local attention to The Massing of the Boats on Rozelle groups is to lend our support from the shore. Bay at 8- 9am on Saturday, 2 December. The best way to do this is to meet in large This activity is being organised by the rowing numbers somewhere in the area around Pope and paddling clubs as a part of the ongoing Paul VI Park and Pavillions to see the skiffs, campaign against the proposed Dry Boat Storage sculls, dragon boats, outriggers, canoes and and Marina on the northern shore of RozelleBay.
    [Show full text]
  • Australasian Parliamentary Review Autumn 2011, Vol. 27, No. 1
    Australasian Parliamentary Review Autumn 2011, Vol. 27, No. 1 FROM YOUR EDITOR Jennifer Aldred 1 ARTICLES 3 # A comparative analysis of rights scrutiny of bills in New Zealand, Australia and the United Kingdom: Is New Zealand lagging behind its peers? Catherine Rodgers 4 # Anti-corruption agencies: Impact on the privileges and immunities of parliament Carly Sheen 18 # Not quite as expected: Victorian Labor and the Legislative Council 2010 Paul Rodan 34 AUSTRALASIAN STUDY OF PARLIAMENT GROUP CONFERENCE 2011: THE EXECUTIVE VERSUS THE PARLIAMENT: WHO WINS? Parliament and the challenge of executive growth 44 Is the traditional role of parliament still valid in our society? Sonia Hornery 45 # Executive growth and the takeover of Australian parliaments Scott Prasser 48 Balancing the need for the executive’s right to govern against the necessity for parliamentary scrutiny 62 A new era of parliamentary reform Judy Spence 63 # Resisting executive control in Queensland’s unicameral legislature — recent developments and the changing role of the speaker in Queensland Kate Jones and Scott Prasser 67 Holding oppositions to account: the slow surrender of parliamentary democracy Jay Tilley 85 Diminishing the efficacy of disallowance motions: quasi-legislation in state jurisdictions Scott Hickie 91 # These papers have been double blind reviewed to academic standards The effects of non-government controlled upper houses on restraining the executive 108 # The impact of multi-party government on parliament-executive relations — examples from Britain and
    [Show full text]
  • BIA Logbook Sep09-Fin
    LOGBOOK NEWSLETTER The official newsletter of the Boating Industry Association of NSW Ltd September 2009 SIBS 2009 Pages 8-24 Excalibur builder jailed Page 4 Print Post Approved PP2411613/00057&8 ACN 000 618 468 September 2009 Excalibur builder LOGBOOK jailed 5 NEWS LETTER The official newsletter of the Marine Rescue NSW 7 Boating Industry Association of NSW Ltd 53 Hume Street SIBS 2009 Offi cial Crows Nest NSW 2065 Aus tral ia Mail to: P.O. Box 1204, Crows Nest NSW 1585 Opening 8 ABN : 61 000 618 468 Telephone: (02) 9438 2077 Facsimile: (02) 9439 3983 Adventurers Wow E-mail: [email protected] Crowds 15 Kiwi skulduggery. Page 17 Web Sites: www.bia.org.au www.sydneyboatshow.com.au Classics & Fame 18 www.boatshows.com.au www.marinedirectory.com.au Photographic Contest 21 Exhibitors win praise 21 Industry throws off yoke of recession 22 Roy Privett – 21 years Kiandra. Page 20 at the Helm 20 General Manager: Roy Privett Marketing & Event Manager: Domenic Genua Ken Evans ‘Mercury Financial Controller: Simon Hazelbrook Marketing Coordinator: Justine Merrony Man’ 28 Members Support & Development: Aaron McKenna BIA Division Manager: Alan Barrett Office Admin: Linda English Division News 36 Publications Coordinator: Christine Howard Event Operations Manager: Belinda Close Coordinator Education & Training: Corrina McMillan Vale John Haines 38 Please send editorial contributions to; Domenic Genua at [email protected] Logbook gratefully acknowledges all that have Riviera Excellence. Page 21 con trib ut ed to this edition. In particular: Roy Privett (Editorial) Front cover: NSW Premier Nathan Rees with Ports & Bob Wonders, Bob Wonders Media Services (07) 5562 2867 Waterways Minister Joe Tripodi.
    [Show full text]
  • Notice Paper
    2201 LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL NOTICE PAPER No. 31 TUESDAY 27 FEBRUARY 2007 The House meets this day at 11.00 am Contents Government Business—Orders of the Day ....................................................................................................... 2202 Private Members’ Business ............................................................................................................................... 2202 Items in the Order of Precedence ........................................................................................................... 2202 Items Outside the Order of Precedence.................................................................................................. 2205 Committee Reports—Orders of the Day ........................................................................................................... 2276 Bills Referred to Select or Standing Committees .............................................................................................. 2281 Contingent Notices of Motions.......................................................................................................................... 2282 2202 Legislative Council Notice Paper No. 31—Tuesday 27 February 2007 GOVERNMENT BUSINESS—ORDERS OF THE DAY 1. Budget Estimates 2006-2007: resumption of the adjourned debate (20 September 2006) of the question on the motion of Mr Della Bosca: That the House take note of the Budget Estimates and related papers for the financial year 2006-2007—Mr Harwin. ____________________ PRIVATE MEMBERS’ BUSINESS
    [Show full text]
  • Investigation Into the Conduct of the Hon Edward Obeid MLC and Others Concerning Circular Quay Retail Lease Policy
    INVESTIGation INTO THE CONDUCT OF THE HON EDWARD OBEID MLC AND OTHERS CONCERNING CIRCULAR QUAY retail LEASE POLICY ICAC REPORT JUNE 2014 INVESTIGation INTO THE CONDUCT OF THE HON EDWARD OBEID MLC AND OTHERS CONCERNING CIRCULAR QUAY retail LEASE POLICY ICAC REPORT JUNE 2014 This publication is available on the Commission’s website www.icac.nsw.gov.au and is available in other formats for the vision-impaired upon request. Please advise of format needed, for example large print or as an ASCII file. ISBN 978-1-921688-54-6 © June 2014 – Copyright in this work is held by the Independent Commission Against Corruption. Division 3 of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cwlth) recognises that limited further use of this material can occur for the purposes of “fair dealing”, for example study, research or criticism, etc. However if you wish to make use of this material other than as permitted by the Copyright Act, please write to the Commission at GPO Box 500 Sydney NSW 2001. Level 21, 133 Castlereagh Street Sydney, NSW, Australia 2000 Postal Address: GPO Box 500, Sydney, NSW, Australia 2001 T: 02 8281 5999 1800 463 909 (toll free for callers outside metropolitan Sydney) TTY: 02 8281 5773 (for hearing-impaired callers only) F: 02 9264 5364 E: [email protected] www.icac.nsw.gov.au Business Hours: 9.00 am - 5.00 pm Monday to Friday © ICAC The Hon Don Harwin MLC The Hon Shelley Hancock MLA President Speaker Legislative Council Legislative Assembly Parliament House Parliament House Sydney NSW 2000 Sydney NSW 2000 Mr President Madam Speaker In accordance with s 74 of the Independent Commission Against Corruption Act 1988 I am pleased to present the Commission’s report on its investigation into the conduct of the Hon Edward Obeid MLC and others concerning the Circular Quay retail lease policy.
    [Show full text]
  • Debunking Dreyfus on Free Speech and Freedom
    Disclaimer : Nothing in this letter should be construed as threatening nor advocating unlawful acts. Suspects are innocent until the facts against them are proven and convicted in a court of justice. This does not discuss the contents of the current super-injunction. Debunking Dreyfus on Free Speech and Freedom Author: Brendan Jones Brisbane, QLD, Australia E-mail: [email protected] Being an Open Letter to ALP Shadow Attorney-General Mark Dreyfus MP QC regarding his speech to the HRC Free Speech 2014 Symposium Cc: Director-General of Security – ASIO, David Irvine (pp. 62-65) Online at: http://victimsofdsto.com/debunking-drefyus/ Page 1 of 66(218) September 10(11), 2014 NoFibs Journalist: “I’m a strong free speech advocate ... So I’m thrilled that shadow Attorney General Mark Dreyfus QC has taken a stand and wish him success in the long hard climb ahead.” 98 Brendan Jones: “Mr. Dreyfus is no advocate for free speech, but the fact that he has convinced you he is – and in just one short speech – has persuaded me he’s a first class barrister.” 98 Journalist Martin Hirst: “I loved that he rubbed their pretty little noses in it. He made the point strongly that the so-called “marketplace of ideas” is a conservative myth that bears little relation to reality.” 98 133 Brendan Jones: “All Dreyfus did was say he rejected it. He never explained why. Google "Sophistry"” 98 131 US Supreme Court Justice Benjamin Cardozo: ‘Freedom of expression is the matrix, the indispensable condition, of nearly every other form of freedom.’ US Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis: “Those who won our independence believed that the final end of the State was to make men free to develop their faculties, and that in its government the deliberative forces should prevail over the arbitrary.
    [Show full text]
  • Sustainability Speaking
    SUSTAINABILITY SPEAKING No 15 Winter 2014 The first issue of Inside Gossip containing Environmentally Speaking appeared in June 2004. Back then the hot topics were the expansion of Port Botany, the destruction of the Orica Hexachlorobenzene(HCB) stockpile at Banksmeadow and regulation of pollution. And the featured quote came from An Illustrated Guide to Sydney 1882 (appearing in Taken for Granted, by Doug Benson & Jocelyn Howell). “ Those who remember the road to Botany in years gone by are not surprised at the name given by the first discoverer(James Cook)....We know most of the wild flower regions of the colony, but none to compare in variety and richness with Botany, as it was.” The Premiers who expanded and ‘sold’ Port Botany 2001 –proposed T3 2008 - turned first sod 2009-fired Ports Minister 2009 - Leased T3 2013 -‘Sold’ the lot and exactly 6 years after the first sod was turned Premier Baird opens the T3 expansion on 24th July, 2014 When the Port was announced on the 29th November 2001 the Ports Minister Carl Scully stated that cargo volumes would more than double over the coming decade from one million to two million containers (expressed as TEU): “If we don't make provision for extra space to move those larger number of containers, we will not be able to sustain economic growth and a growing population." As we now know there was no capacity issue. The existing two terminals could have handled the projected growth, which in the development application was stated as 3.2million TEU. The expansion was to facilitate much greater growth (from 8million+ TEU) as well as the entry of a new stevedore, Hutchison - the largest in the world.
    [Show full text]