DOCSLIB.ORG

CROSSING BORDERS: Remaking Gay Fatherhood in the Global Market

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
CROSSING BORDERS: Remaking Gay Fatherhood in the Global Market CROSSING BORDERS: Remaking Gay Fatherhood in the Global Market A thesis submitted to the University of Manchester for the degree of PhD Sociology in the Faculty of Humanities, School of Social Sciences. Adi Moreno 2016 Department of Sociology. CONTENTS Contents ............................................................................................................................................... 2 1. Orientation ..................................................................................................................................... 11 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 11 Introducing the Field ...................................................................................................................... 14 The state of Israel: Zionist history and state reproduction ideology .......................................... 14 LGBT Politics in Israel .............................................................................................................. 17 Israeli Surrogacy Regulations .................................................................................................... 19 Cross-Border Surrogacy ............................................................................................................. 20 Research Motivation ...................................................................................................................... 23 Research Questions and Method .................................................................................................... 26 Linguistic Considerations .............................................................................................................. 30 Dissertation outline ........................................................................................................................ 31 2. Manufacturing Families ................................................................................................................. 37 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 37 Social-Material Assemblages ......................................................................................................... 39 Doing Families ............................................................................................................................... 42 Remaking Reproduction ................................................................................................................ 48 The Politics of Life and Death ....................................................................................................... 58 Conclusion: Surrogacy Assemblages ............................................................................................. 62 2 3. Studying Gay Surrogacy ................................................................................................................ 63 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 63 Research Questions ........................................................................................................................ 64 Data and Method ............................................................................................................................ 65 Data Types and Modes of Inquiry.............................................................................................. 65 Method Boundaries and Potential Limitation ............................................................................ 69 Entering the Field ....................................................................................................................... 70 Collecting Documents ................................................................................................................ 73 Sampling and Recruitment ......................................................................................................... 74 Interviewing ............................................................................................................................... 79 Participant Observation .............................................................................................................. 82 Analysis .......................................................................................................................................... 84 A Note on Translation ................................................................................................................ 86 The Ethical and Political Dimensions of Doing Research ............................................................. 87 Summary ........................................................................................................................................ 90 4. Surrogacy Tales.............................................................................................................................. 92 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 92 Yuval .............................................................................................................................................. 93 Elad .............................................................................................................................................. 101 3 Understanding Surrogacy ............................................................................................................. 109 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................... 118 5. The Most Natural Family ............................................................................................................. 120 Paths to Fatherhood ...................................................................................................................... 122 Seeking Gender Equality ............................................................................................................. 127 Remaking Nature ......................................................................................................................... 134 Equality, Continuity and Belonging............................................................................................. 139 Conclusion: Surrogacy families ................................................................................................... 142 6. At the Border ................................................................................................................................ 145 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 145 Globalization, Mobility and Borders ........................................................................................... 146 Bordered Reproduction: The case of Israel .................................................................................. 149 Stuck in India ............................................................................................................................... 155 Changing Routes .......................................................................................................................... 160 Between Objects and Subjects ..................................................................................................... 167 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................... 170 7. Reproducing the Nation ............................................................................................................... 172 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 172 Normativity and the Nation.......................................................................................................... 174 Reproducing the Borders of the Nation ....................................................................................... 177 4 Assimilation and Exclusion ......................................................................................................... 186 Conclusion: Between Biopolitics and Necropolitics ................................................................... 188 8. Reproduction Markets .................................................................................................................. 190 Markets, Bodies and Relationships .............................................................................................. 192 Playing the Game ......................................................................................................................... 196 We Exchange Pain with Hope ..................................................................................................... 199 Intimate Strangers ........................................................................................................................ 203 Embodied Contracts ..................................................................................................................... 209 Conclusion: Kinship, Affect and Commodity Relations ............................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Sociology of the Family
    *Enrollment* This course is currently over‐enrolled, so I will be taking attendance during each class during the first two weeks, dropping students who miss two consecutive classes without notifying me, and adding in students from the waitlist. This applies to enrolled and waitlisted students, so make sure you sign in! Sociology 111 –Sociology of the Family UC Berkeley, Spring 2012 227 Cory, MWF 10‐11 Instructor: Joanna Reed, Ph.D. Office hours: Wed. 1‐3 and by appointment, 472 Barrows [email protected] Course Description We all are part of families, for better and for worse. Families are universally important social institutions, past and present. Although the majority of families around the world have certain things in common—relating people biologically and socially, organizing care and residence, the specifics of how these things are accomplished may vary substantially across time and space. This course focuses on families in the contemporary U.S. It will introduce you to how sociologists study families and along with them, topics that seem very personal, emotional and important to many of us—ideals about love, marriage, gender, parenthood, sex and sexuality—scientifically. We consider both the “public” and “private” dimensions of families over the course of the semester‐‐ families as settings for socially important tasks such as raising children and caring for family members, and a focus for public policy and as the place where we experience much of our private lives. A central theme will be diversity and change, as we consider the many ways families have changed over the last 60 years in particular in the U.S., and the myriad forms of family diversity that surround us.
    [Show full text]
  • Family and Intimate Relationships: a Review of the Sociological Research
    Families Family and Intimate Relationships: A Review of the Sociological Research Val Gillies Families & Social Capital ESRC Research Group South Bank University 103 Borough Road London SE1 0AA June 2003 Published by South Bank University © Families & Social Capital ESRC Research Group ISBN 1-874418-33-0 Families & Social Capital ESRC Research Group Working Paper No. 2 FAMILY AND INTIMATE RELATIONSHIPS: A REVIEW OF THE SOCIOLOGICAL RESEARCH Val Gillies Page Introduction 2 Models of Families, Kinship and Change 3 From Social Obligations to Negotiated Change 9 Breakdown, Democratisation or Continuity 15 Intimacy as Social Capital 16 Researching Intimate Relationships 18 References 19 1 Introduction The phrase ‘intimate relationship’ is a broad and fluid term, in that it can encompass numerous different associations between friends, sexual partners, family and kin. This working paper examines how sociological constructions of family and intimate relations have shifted over the years, exploring how particular bodies of literature have documented and shaped understandings of social connectedness. It will be argued that there are three major sociological perspectives on contemporary personal relations, with theorists emphasising breakdown, democratisation or continuity. Having reviewed the available research and outlined each perspective, this paper moves on to contextualise the three different interpretations, relating them to current debates around the concept of social capital. As Lynn Jamieson (1998) notes, the word ‘intimacy’ has come to replace what would previously have been termed ‘primary relationships’, signifying a new focus on the quality as opposed to the structure of such relationships. Within the field of sociology the term intimacy has taken on a particular significance, describing a theoretical stance that has emerged and colonised topics of interest that were previously viewed from the perspectives of family or community studies.
    [Show full text]
  • Transracial Parenting in Foster Care and Adoption
    Transracial Parenting in Foster Care & Adoption - Strengthening Your Bicultural Family This guidebook was created to help parents and children in transracial homes learn how to thrive in and celebrate their bicultural family; and for children to gain a strong sense of racial identity and cultural connections. 1 Transracial Parenting in Foster Care & Adoption - Strengthening Your Bicultural Family 2 Transracial Parenting in Foster Care & Adoption - Strengthening Your Bicultural Family Table of Contents: Page # INTRODUCTION 4 A TRANSRACIALLY-ADOPTED CHILD’S BILL OF RIGHTS 5 TRANSRACIAL PARENTING PLEDGE 6 WHAT DOES IT MEAN TO BE A TRANSRACIAL FAMILY? 7 HOW FAR HAVE WE COME? THE HISTORY OF TRANSRACIAL FAMILIES 8 - 10 GENERAL PARENTING TASKS FOR TRANSRACIAL PARENTS 11 - 14 HOW TO CONNECT YOUR CHILD TO THEIR CULTURE - 15 - 16 AND HOW TO BECOME A BICULTURAL FAMILY THE VOICES OF ADULT TRANSRACIAL ADOPTEES 17 - 24 RACISM AND DISCRIMINATION – FOSTERING RACIAL COPING SKILLS 25 - 28 ANSWERING TOUGH QUESTIONS 28 - 29 SKIN CARE & HAIR CARE 30 - 32 RESOURCES 33 - 46 General Transracial Resources Online Help, Books, Videos, Toys & Dolls Organizations & Internet Resources Cultural Camps African American Resources Asian American Resources Native American Resources Hispanic Resources European American Resources Arab American Resources Language & Self-assessment tools 3 Transracial Parenting in Foster Care & Adoption - Strengthening Your Bicultural Family INTRODUCTION According to transracial adoption expert Joseph Crumbley, all foster children, whether in a transracial placement or not, worry “Will I be accepted in this home, even if I am from a different (biological) family?” Children in transracial homes also worry “Will I be accepted even if I’m from a different race?” This booklet will help you understand the importance of race and culture for your family; and share helpful hints, parenting tips and resources for you on the culturally rich journey of transracial parenting.
    [Show full text]
  • The Making and Unmaking of Ethnic Boundaries: a Multilevel Process Theory1
    The Making and Unmaking of Ethnic Boundaries: A Multilevel Process Theory1 Andreas Wimmer University of California, Los Angeles Primordialist and constructivist authors have debated the nature of ethnicity “as such” and therefore failed to explain why its charac- teristics vary so dramatically across cases, displaying different de- grees of social closure, political salience, cultural distinctiveness, and historical stability. The author introduces a multilevel process theory to understand how these characteristics are generated and trans- formed over time. The theory assumes that ethnic boundaries are the outcome of the classificatory struggles and negotiations between actors situated in a social field. Three characteristics of a field—the institutional order, distribution of power, and political networks— determine which actors will adopt which strategy of ethnic boundary making. The author then discusses the conditions under which these negotiations will lead to a shared understanding of the location and meaning of boundaries. The nature of this consensus explains the particular characteristics of an ethnic boundary. A final section iden- tifies endogenous and exogenous mechanisms of change. TOWARD A COMPARATIVE SOCIOLOGY OF ETHNIC BOUNDARIES Beyond Constructivism The comparative study of ethnicity rests firmly on the ground established by Fredrik Barth (1969b) in his well-known introduction to a collection 1 Various versions of this article were presented at UCLA’s Department of Sociology, the Institute for Migration Research and Intercultural Studies of the University of Osnabru¨ ck, Harvard’s Center for European Studies, the Center for Comparative Re- search of Yale University, the Association for the Study of Ethnicity at the London School of Economics, the Center for Ethnicity and Citizenship of the University of Bristol, the Department of Political Science and International Relations of University College Dublin, and the Department of Sociology of the University of Go¨ttingen.
    [Show full text]
  • Ethnic Sensitive Social Work Practice: the State of the Art
    The Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare Volume 22 Issue 1 March - Special Issue on Social Work Article 4 with Minority and Ethnic Groups March 1995 Ethnic Sensitive Social Work Practice: The State of the Art Elfriede G. Schlesinger Rutgers University Wynetta Devore Syracuse University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/jssw Part of the Social Work Commons Recommended Citation Schlesinger, Elfriede G. and Devore, Wynetta (1995) "Ethnic Sensitive Social Work Practice: The State of the Art," The Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare: Vol. 22 : Iss. 1 , Article 4. Available at: https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/jssw/vol22/iss1/4 This Article is brought to you by the Western Michigan University School of Social Work. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Ethnic Sensitive Social Work Practice: The State of the Art ELFRIEDE G. SCHLESINGER Rutgers University WYNETrA DEVORE Syracuse University The social work literature of the past ten years has paid increasing attention to the ideological, theoretical and practice issues related to eth- nic sensitive practice. Major focus has been on the life styles, needs and oppression of people of color, with minimal attention paid to other ethnic groups. A literature focused on adapting prevailing practice modalities to work with diverse groups is beginning to emerge. In the preface to the first edition of Ethnic Sensitive Social Work Practice (1981) we suggested that the time had arrived when social work could comfortably integrate the profession's long standing commitment to the uniqueness of individuals with knowledge about ethnic and class related response. We also suggested then that as a result of the ferment of the 60's social work was finally paying more attention to poverty, to the liberation struggles of various groups and to how minority status, ethnic group membership, and social class status affect problem generation and resolution.
    [Show full text]
  • Kinship and Gender in South and Southeast Asia: Patterns and Contrasts /By Leela Dube
    Kinship and Gender in South and Southeast Asia: patterns and Contrasts /by Leela Dube. 1994. 45p. (9th J.P. Naik Memorial Lecture, 1994 ). Kinship and Gender in South and Southeast Asia: Patterns and Contrasts I am honoured to have been asked to deliver the Ninth J.P. Naik Memorial Lecture. My sense of gratitude to Naik Sahab has a twofold immediacy today. I worked closely with him. To many of us it is painful to put the words 'the late' before his name. So much dynamism, energy and vitality cannot just wither away. His example and inspiration survive with us. Naik Sahab was a thinker and a doer: reflection became meaningful when it led to action. The debts that we owe him are many and in diverse fields; but for women with a cause he will always occupy a special place. I salute the legacy of J.P. Naik. He is much more than a memory, not mere sepia-tinted nostalgia. Second, this presentation is based on a manuscript which had its beginnings in the comparative project on 'Women's Work and Family Strategies' and was conceived of and written to provide a background for grasping the differences between South and Southeast Asia. It gave me the opportunity to travel across the two regions, explore relevant literature and meet scholars and common people. I am beholden to Vina Mazumdar and Hanna Papanek, the two directors of the project. I also thank Lotika, Kumud, Malavika and Narayan for their help. I gratefully remember a number of people spread over South and Southeast Asia.
    [Show full text]
  • Discouraging Racial Preferences in Adoptions
    Discouraging Racial Preferences in Adoptions Solangel Maldonado* More than 20,000 white Americans go abroad each year to adopt children from other countries, the majority of whom are not white. At the same time, there are more African American children available for adoption than there are African American families seeking to adopt them. While Americans claim there are few healthy infants available for adoption in the United States, hundreds of African American newborns each year are placed with white families in Canada and other countries. Tracing the history of transracial adoption in the United States, this Article argues that one reason why Americans go abroad to adopt is race. The racial hierarchy in the adoption market places white children at the top, African American children at the bottom, and children of other races in between, thereby rendering Asian or Latin American children more desirable to adoptive parents than African American children. Drawing on the rich literature on cognitive bias, this Article debunks the myths about domestic and international adoptions and shows that racial preferences, even if unconscious, play a role in many Americans’ decisions to adopt internationally. This Article proposes that the law discourage adoptions based on racial preferences by requiring that Americans seeking to adopt internationally, while there are available children in the United States who meet their non-race-based criteria, show non-race-based reasons for going abroad. * Associate Professor, Seton Hall University School of Law. J.D. 1996, Columbia Law School. I am grateful to Michelle Adams, Mark Alexander, Ruby Andrew, Carlos Bellido, Carl Coleman, Kevin Kelly, Jason Gardner, Timothy Glynn, Tristin Green, Rachel Godsil, Charlie Sullivan, the participants in the 12th International Society of Family Law Conference in Salt Lake City, the participants in the Second National POC in Washington, D.C., and the participants in the LatCrit X Conference in San Juan, Puerto Rico, for their helpful comments.
    [Show full text]
  • Mapping LGBTQ Organizations in Israel
    Mapping LGBTQ Organizations in Israel Summary Report Researched and Written by: Prof. Israel Katz, Adi Maoz, Dana Alfassi, Nir Levy Professional Management: Ohad Hizki & Ronit Levy June 2018 1 The following mapping was written for, about and in collaboration with, the LGBTQ organizations in Israel: 2 Table of Contents 1. Introduction .............................................................................................. 4 2. Executive Summary ................................................................................. 6 3. Mapping of LGBTQ Organizations in Israel ...................................... 14 Findings of the Organizational Survey .................................................................... 14 Other Activities ........................................................................................................ 20 4. Analysis of the LGBTQ Organizational Sphere ................................. 24 Boundaries—of the LGBTQ Field, Community, and Activities ............................... 24 Organizational Characteristics and Activities......................................................... 28 Inter-Organizational Collaboration ........................................................................ 32 Attitudes toward the Establishment ......................................................................... 38 5. Conclusion .............................................................................................. 43 Main Recommendations ..........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Education Sector Responses to Homophobic Bullying
    United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization GOOD POLICY AND PRACTICE IN HIV AND HEALTH EDUCATION BOOKLET 8 Education Sector Responses to Homophobic Bullying GOOD POLICY AND PRACTICE IN HIV AND HEALTH EDUCATION Booklet 8 EDUCATION SECTOR RESPONSES TO HOMOPHOBIC BULLYING Published in 2012 by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization 7, place de Fontenoy, 75352 Paris 07 SP, France © UNESCO 2012 All rights reserved ISBN XXXXXX-X The designations employed and the presentation of material throughout this publication do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of UNESCO concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. The ideas and opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors; they are not necessarily those of UNESCO and do not commit the Organization. Cover photos: © 2005 Gay and Lesbian Memory in Action (GALA)/J. Bloch © 2006 Gay and Lesbian Memory in Action (GALA)/H. McDonald © 2005 Gay and Lesbian Memory in Action (GALA)/J. Bloch © 2005 Gay and Lesbian Memory in Action (GALA)/Z. Muholi © 2011 BeLonG To Youth Services, Ireland © P. Pothipun © 2005 Gay and Lesbian Memory in Action (GALA)/J. Bloch © UNESCO/K. Benjamaneepairoj Designed & printed by UNESCO Printed in France CONTENTS Acronyms ............................................................................................................................4 Acknowledgements .............................................................................................................5
    [Show full text]
  • ANNUAL REPORT INTERNATIONAL LESBIAN GAY BISEXUAL TRANS and INTERSEX ASSOCIATION Table of Contents
    2012 ANNUAL REPORT INTERNATIONAL LESBIAN GAY BISEXUAL TRANS AND INTERSEX ASSOCIATION TABLE OF CONTENTS 02 Vision, Mission and Strategic objectives 03 Thanks and acknowledgements Foreword from the Secretaries Generals 04 by Gloria Careaga and Renato Sabbadini A message from the Executive Director 07 by Sebastian Rocca Your Global LGBTI federation: Embracing the movement! Stockholm: global movement meets in the snow for a 09 warm and successful world conference Membership: ILGA reaches 1005 members and “talks” to 4500 LGBTI 13 organisations worldwide! Supporting the growth of LGBTI movements in 15 the Global South: ILGA’s Regional Development and Communication Project 18 World Pride in London: ILGA under the spotlight! Your voice at the United Nations: LGBTI rights are human rights! 2012 at the UN: ILGA deepens its engagement at the 19 United Nations Activism! Tools for change for the L, G, B, T and I communities 24 Second Forum on Intersex Organising 6th edition of the State Sponsored Homophobia 26 report 27 Global maps go… local! 29 ILGA stands up for lesbian rights! Activism! Tools for change for the L, G, B, T and I communities 30 Financial information 32 ILGA Executive Board and its members in 2012 FRIC AN A A IL P GA S T L H E S G I B R I A N N A * M G U A Y H * E B R I A S T E X H U G I A R L * T R R E A T N N S I * ILGA ANNUAL REPORT 2012 THIS REPort OUTLINES THE WORK undertaKEN BY ILGA staFF, board, MEMBERS AND Volunteers FroM January – DECEMBER 2012.
    [Show full text]
  • Stonewall Global Workplace Briefings Europe, Middle East and Africa Pack
    STONEWALL GLOBAL WORKPLACE BRIEFINGS EMEA EUROPE, MIDDLE EAST AND AFRICA PACK Belgium, Czech Republic, France, Germany, Hungary, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Kenya, Nigeria, Poland, Qatar, Russia, South Africa, Spain, Turkey, Uganda, United Arab Emirates and United Kingdom STONEWALL GLOBAL WORKPLACE BRIEFINGS 2018 BELGIUM Population: 11+ million Stonewall Global Diversity Champions: 55 THE LEGAL LANDSCAPE In Stonewall’s Global Workplace Equality Index, broad legal zoning is used to group the differing challenges faced by organisations across their global operations. Belgium is classified as a Zone 1 country, which means sexual acts between people of the same sex are legal and clear national employment protections exist for lesbian, gay, and bi people. Two further zones exist. In Zone 2 countries, sexual acts between people of the same sex are legal but no clear national employment protections exist on grounds of sexual orientation. In Zone 3 countries, sexual acts between people of the same sex are illegal. FREEDOM OF FAMILY AND EQUALITY AND EMPLOYMENT GENDER IDENTITY IMMIGRATION EXPRESSION, RELATIONSHIPS ASSOCIATION AND ASSEMBLY Articles 19 and 25 Sexual acts between Article 3 of the federal The Federal Transgender Law The Aliens Act enables of the Constitution people of the same sex are Anti-Discrimination Law of of 25 June 2017 provides trans family reunification include the right to are legal. 10 May 2007 explicitly prohibits and intersex people the right to between same-sex freedom of speech discrimination on the grounds of change their legal gender to partners. Under and expression. There is an equal age of sexual orientation and gender. male or female as well as to the Belgian Code of Articles 26 and 27 consent of 16 years for This includes discrimination change their first name.
    [Show full text]
  • Transracial Families, Race, and Whiteness in Sweden
    genealogy Article Transracial Families, Race, and Whiteness in Sweden Sayaka Osanami Törngren 1,*, Carolina Jonsson Malm 2 and Tobias Hübinette 3 1 Malmö Institute for Studies of Migration, Diversity and Welfare, Malmö University, 205 06 Malmö, Sweden 2 University Executive Office, Malmö University, 205 06 Malmö, Sweden; [email protected] 3 Department of Language, Literature and Intercultural Studies, Karlstad University, 651 88 Karlstad, Sweden; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected]; Tel.: +46-40-665-7227 Received: 24 August 2018; Accepted: 3 December 2018; Published: 11 December 2018 Abstract: In this article, we use the results from two studies, one on interracial relationship and the other on transnational adoption, to explore how notions of race and ethnicity shape family policies, family building and everyday life in Sweden. Transnational adoption and interracial marriage in Sweden have previously never been compared in research, even though they both are about transracial family formation. By bringing these two topics together in a critical race theory framework we got a deeper understanding of how transracial families are perceived and affected by societal beliefs and norms. The analysis revealed a somewhat contradictory and complex picture on the norms of family formation. The color-blind ideology that characterizes the Swedes’ self-understanding, together with the privileged position of whiteness in relation to Swedishness, makes the attitude towards different forms of transracial families ambivalent and contradictory. Transracial children and their parents are perceived differently depending on their origin and degree of visible differences and non-whiteness, but also based on the historical and social context.
    [Show full text]