Gender, Identity, and the National Football League's Female Fans

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Gender, Identity, and the National Football League's Female Fans University of Tennessee, Knoxville TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange Doctoral Dissertations Graduate School 8-2014 "Game Time is My Time. I Get to Define That:" Gender, Identity, and the National Football League's Female Fans Traci Yates University of Tennessee - Knoxville, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_graddiss Part of the Sports Studies Commons Recommended Citation Yates, Traci, ""Game Time is My Time. I Get to Define That:" Gender, Identity, and the National Football League's Female Fans. " PhD diss., University of Tennessee, 2014. https://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_graddiss/2876 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange. It has been accepted for inclusion in Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized administrator of TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange. For more information, please contact [email protected]. To the Graduate Council: I am submitting herewith a dissertation written by Traci Yates entitled ""Game Time is My Time. I Get to Define That:" Gender, Identity, and the National Football League's Female Fans." I have examined the final electronic copy of this dissertation for form and content and recommend that it be accepted in partial fulfillment of the equirr ements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, with a major in Kinesiology and Sport Studies. Joy T. DeSensi, Major Professor We have read this dissertation and recommend its acceptance: Lars Dzikus, Leslee A. Fisher, Trena M. Paulus Accepted for the Council: Carolyn R. Hodges Vice Provost and Dean of the Graduate School (Original signatures are on file with official studentecor r ds.) “Game Time is My Time. I Get to Define That:” Gender, Identity, and the National Football League’s Female Fans A Dissertation Presented for the Doctor of Philosophy Degree The University of Tennessee, Knoxville Traci Yates August 2014 ii Copyright © 2014 by Traci Yates All rights reserved. iii Dedication This dissertation is dedicated to the memory of James Robert Yates. I love and miss you every day. Scooter iv Acknowledgements Dr. Joy DeSensi: I am forever indebted to you for your guidance and support. When I lost direction and could not see past my own failures, you offered the perfect blend of understanding and encouragement, along with a small kick in the pants. Thank you. Dr. Lars Dzikus: I still vividly remember the first day I met you. Had you not leapt across the hall, I might have decided to wait for another time. And that time may never have come. Your enthusiasm was and is infectious. You, sir, are a rare gem and I am so fortunate to have met you on this journey. Dr. Leslee Fisher: On the rarest of occasions, you find yourself in the right place, surrounded by just the right people, at precisely the right time. This happened for me the semester I walked into your Women, Sport and Culture class. Thank you for providing the space and opportunity to express myself, and for agreeing to be part of this experience. Dr. Trena Paulus: Truth be told, I almost didn’t make it through my first semester in your class, but I am so very glad I did. You taught me not only about methods, but also about life. I have such profound admiration and respect for you, and you deserve every one of the accolades and opportunities coming your way. Thank you for helping me grow. Mom: You are neither football fan nor feminist, but you continue to love and accept me unconditionally. And that is all that ever really matters. Erin Ellen: You are truly one of the most amazing people I know. Thank you for doing your best to keep me sane all these years. #BABF Robert Jerrod: No one challenges me or accepts my challenges quite like you. You, my friend, deserve far more than honorary status. Paul Small: I will never forget how you waited for me to realize what you already knew. Al Dunkleman: My sociological teammate. Thank you for carrying the load so that I could spread my wings. To all the friends, family, and colleagues who listened and waited, they say it takes a village. Thanks for being mine. To those who came and went along the way, this dream was bigger than all of that. v Abstract Based on existing literature relatively little is known about the female football fan in America. Previous research has acknowledged that these women exist, often in startling proportions. It has also identified some of the reasons why they attend the game and some of the perceived benefits of their participation as fans (Clark, Apostolopoulou, & Gladden, 2009; Dietz-Uhler, Harrick, End, & Jacquemotte, 2000). Yet we do not know the value they place on their fan identities, nor how they manage to negotiate being both women and fans in a sport environment that both subtly and not-so-subtly continues to reinforce the model of hegemonic masculinity. Therefore, the purpose of this research was to explore how the identities of female fans of the National Football League (NFL) were constructed and negotiated through the language used to describe their experiences. To that end, 35 blog posts from OnHerGame a website dedicated to female sports fans, during the 2012-2013 NFL season were collected and five women who self-identify as National Football League (NFL) fans and currently write for the site were interviewed for this study; in addition, my own bracketing interview (Pollio, Henley, & Thompson, 1997) was also included. The resulting data were analyzed using feminist poststructural discourse analysis (FPDA), revealing three major patterns of discourse: a) reproduction, b) resistance, and c) reinscription. Reproductive discourse included language that reinforced hegemonic ideas about football as male space (e.g., women as less knowledgeable and primarily heterosexually interested in the men who play), while resistant discourse was often employed in an effort to defy these stereotyped subject positions (e.g., portraying female fans as competent, knowledgeable and authentic). Though women largely produced these two forms in their online posts, interviews with participants revealed a third pattern whereby female fans reinscribed reproductive discourse practices in an effort to differentiate themselves from other women (e.g., assuming other women do not know, are not interested). vi Table of Contents Chapter 1 Introduction .......................................................................................................... 1 Statement of the Problem ............................................................................................................... 2 Purpose Statement ........................................................................................................................... 4 Research Questions .......................................................................................................................... 5 Significance ......................................................................................................................................... 5 Theoretical Frameworks Guiding Research on Female Fans ............................................. 7 Delimitations/Limitations .......................................................................................................... 10 Definition of Terms ....................................................................................................................... 11 Organization .................................................................................................................................... 12 Chapter 2 Literature Review ........................................................................................... 13 Sport .......................................................................................................................................... 13 American Football .......................................................................................................................... 14 Sports Fans ............................................................................................................................. 15 Measuring fandom ......................................................................................................................... 17 A Fan Typology ................................................................................................................................ 19 Fan Socialization ............................................................................................................................ 21 Fan Motivation ................................................................................................................................ 22 Gender ...................................................................................................................................... 23 A Performance ................................................................................................................................. 24 Doing Gender ................................................................................................................................... 26 Female Masculinity ........................................................................................................................ 29 Gender and Fans ................................................................................................................... 35 A Woman’s Place is in the Home ..............................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Development, Evolution, and Bargaining in the National Football League
    DEVELOPMENT, EVOLUTION, AND BARGAINING IN THE NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE Thomas Sisco The National Football League [hereinafter: NFL] is the most popular professional sports organization in the United States, but even with the current popularity and status of the NFL, ratings and the public perception of the on-field product have been on steady decline.1 Many believe this is a byproduct of the NFL being the only one of the 4 major professional sports leagues in the country without a self-controlled system for player development. Major League Baseball [hereinafter: MLB] has a prominent and successful minor league baseball system, the National Hockey League has the American Hockey League and East Coast Hockey League, the National Basketball Association [hereinafter: NBA] has the 22 team development league widely known as “The D- League”, but the NFL relies on the National Collegiate Athletic Association [hereinafter: NCAA] to develop young players for a career in their league. The Canadian Football League and the Arena Football League are generally inadequate in developing players for the NFL as the rules of gameplay and the field dimensions differ from those of NFL football.2 NFL Europe, a developmental league founded by Paul Tagliabue, former NFL Commissioner, has seen minor success.3 NFL Europe, existing by various names during its lifespan, operated from 1991 until it was disbanded in 2007.4 During its existence, the NFL Europe served as a suitable incubator for a 1 Darren Rovell, NFL most popular for 30th year in row, ESPN (January 26, 2014), http://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/10354114/harris-poll-nfl-most-popular-mlb-2nd, .
    [Show full text]
  • Former Panthers in The
    FORMER PANTHERS IN THE NFL EASTERN EARNS TITLE OF 'CRADLE OF COACHES' Tony Romo Dallas Cowboys IN THE NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE Quarterback From 2006-2008, Eastern Illinois University held the distinction of being the new ‘Cradle of Coaches’ in the National Football Romo was a free agent signee League with three alumni serving as head coaches in the NFL and with the Dallas Cowboys in 2003. four more former players serving as assistant coaches. He started his first game with In 2006 and 2007, EIU was matched with USC and San Diego the Cowboys in 2006 earning State as the only three universities with three current NFL head All-Pro honors in 2006 and 2007 coaches as alumni. In 2008 that number was trimmed down to after guiding the team to back-to- just USC and EIU having three head coaches. In 2010 EIU once back NFC playoff appearances again was the "NFL Cradle of Coaches" as Mike Shanahan took including an NFC East title in over as head coach of the Washington Redskins. 2007. He was also an All-Pro following the 2009 season. Former All-American quarterback Sean Payton, Class of 1987, became the newest member of the distinguished club when he was named head coach of the New Orleans Saints early in 2006. Sean Payton He was an All-American quarterback with Eastern from 1983-86, New Orleans Saints and threw for a school record 10,655 yards. He still holds 11 Head Coach single game, season and career passing records. In 2006 he was named the NFL Coach of the Year guiding the Saints to the NFC Payton, a former EIU All-American, Championship game.
    [Show full text]
  • Major League Baseball Team Bankruptcies: Who Wins? Who Loses?
    Loyola of Los Angeles Entertainment Law Review Volume 32 Number 3 Article 2 6-1-2012 Major League Baseball Team Bankruptcies: Who Wins? Who Loses? John Dillon Loyola Law School Los Angeles Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.lmu.edu/elr Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation John Dillon, Major League Baseball Team Bankruptcies: Who Wins? Who Loses?, 32 Loy. L.A. Ent. L. Rev. 297 (2012). Available at: https://digitalcommons.lmu.edu/elr/vol32/iss3/2 This Notes and Comments is brought to you for free and open access by the Law Reviews at Digital Commons @ Loyola Marymount University and Loyola Law School. It has been accepted for inclusion in Loyola of Los Angeles Entertainment Law Review by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons@Loyola Marymount University and Loyola Law School. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 07. DILLON (DO NOT DELETE) 12/30/2012 2:03 AM MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL TEAM BANKRUPTCIES: WHO WINS? WHO LOSES? John Dillon* Baseball is America’s sport. It evokes a sense of tradition and a love for the home team. Like all professional sports teams, however, baseball teams are part of a league, which restricts team ownership through contrac- tual “constitutional” provisions and agreements and limits the number of teams that exist. In this limited and restricted entertainment market, profes- sional sports teams operate highly lucrative businesses that sometimes seek bankruptcy protection through Chapter 11 reorganization. Bankruptcy gen- erally allows the debtor to alter existing contractual rights and restructure its operations to avert the financial crisis that precipitated the bankruptcy filing.
    [Show full text]
  • Administration of Donald J. Trump, 2019 Digest of Other White House
    Administration of Donald J. Trump, 2019 Digest of Other White House Announcements December 31, 2019 The following list includes the President's public schedule and other items of general interest announced by the Office of the Press Secretary and not included elsewhere in this Compilation. January 1 In the afternoon, the President posted to his personal Twitter feed his congratulations to President Jair Messias Bolsonaro of Brazil on his Inauguration. In the evening, the President had a telephone conversation with Republican National Committee Chairwoman Ronna McDaniel. During the day, the President had a telephone conversation with President Abdelfattah Said Elsisi of Egypt to reaffirm Egypt-U.S. relations, including the shared goals of countering terrorism and increasing regional stability, and discuss the upcoming inauguration of the Cathedral of the Nativity and the al-Fatah al-Aleem Mosque in the New Administrative Capital and other efforts to advance religious freedom in Egypt. January 2 In the afternoon, in the Situation Room, the President and Vice President Michael R. Pence participated in a briefing on border security by Secretary of Homeland Security Kirstjen M. Nielsen for congressional leadership. January 3 In the afternoon, the President had separate telephone conversations with Anamika "Mika" Chand-Singh, wife of Newman, CA, police officer Cpl. Ronil Singh, who was killed during a traffic stop on December 26, 2018, Newman Police Chief Randy Richardson, and Stanislaus County, CA, Sheriff Adam Christianson to praise Officer Singh's service to his fellow citizens, offer his condolences, and commend law enforcement's rapid investigation, response, and apprehension of the suspect.
    [Show full text]
  • Origins of the WLAF
    THE COFFIN CORNER: Vol. 14, No. 2 (1992) Origins of the WLAF By Tod Maher When the World League of American Football began its inaugural season last March, it marked the culmination of years of planning by the NFL. If you ask NFL people when they got the idea of putting football teams in Europe (or look in last year’s WLAF media guide for the answer), they’ll probably say 1983. That, of course, is when the Minnesota Vikings and the St. Louis Cardinals played the first NFL exhibition game in London. However, the NFL had planned to place professional teams in Europe as far back as June 5, 1974. That was the day the NFL announced that “it would attempt to introduce pro football to Europe.” The Intercontinental Football League The NFL planned a “satellite” league that would start play in the spring of 1975 and would be called the Intercontinental Football League. The NFL even had nicknames for the six teams. They were the Istanbul Conquerors, the Rome Gladiators, the Munich Lions, the Berlin Bears, the Vienna Lippizzaners (no kidding! ) and the Barcelona Almovogeres (ditto). The NFL also had pre-selected four expansion teams – the Paris Lafayettes, the Copenhagen Vikings, the Rotterdam Flying Dutchmen and the Milan Centurions. The financing and stocking of the teams was to be handled virtually the same as today’s WLAF. The NFL owners were to provide the initial funding, and the league would employ “second-line athletes and rookies from established NFL teams.” Heading the NFL committee that was to put the league together were AI Davis and Tex Schramm.
    [Show full text]
  • Iiauriiratpr Mpralft Manchester — a City of Village Charm
    \ MANCHESTER FOCUS SPORTS Arguments begin Giri Scouts wing Bosox not picky, in Route 6 case across the ocean just are winning^ . ... page 3 ... page 9 ... page 12 I iiauriiratpr Mpralft Manchester — A City of Village Charm Tuesday, July 1,1986 25 Cents J Towns to get ‘New year* nothing to $73 miiiion of celebrate 0 Spending plans^ state surpius . now in effect By Mark A. Dupuis where it was approved 21-13 after Bv John F. Kirch United Press International initial doubt about its fate because Herald Reporter L the House adjourned its special HARTFORD — State lawmak­ session, making Senate changes to Happy new year — fiscal, that is. ers concluded a special session the bill impossible. Although Jan. 1 isstillalongw ay with overwhelming approval early The Senate’s Republican major­ off. today marks the start of a new today of a bill to distribute $73 ity met privately jo discuss round of taxing and spending for miiiion in state surplus funds to whether to go with the House- state and local governments. I* is Connecticut’s 169 cities and towns. passed M l or make changes — a the time for budgets to go into The bill, which won House move tnat would have killed th^ effect, for slate and federal fund­ approval iate Monday after a bill since the House had adjourned ing to .become available and for session stretching over nine hours and could not reconvene to cosider spending on projects to be offi­ anti then was approved by the Senate changes. cially authorized. The bill as approved outlines Senate at 12; SS ^ m .
    [Show full text]
  • CII Fall Conference October 23–25, 2018 Grand Hyatt New York New York, NY PROGRAM 
    CII Fall Conference October 23–25, 2018 Grand Hyatt New York New York, NY PROGRAM CONTENTS 1 Welcome to CII’s 2018 Fall Conference! 2 Thank You to Our Conference Sponsors 4 Conference Information 5 FAQs 11 Agenda CONTENTS 24 CII Education 29 Attendees 44 CII Members 49 CII Staff 51 CII Leadership THANK YOU TO OUR CONFERENCE PROGRAM SPONSOR B www.cii.org WELCOME TO CII’S 2018 FALL CONFERENCE! We are delighted that so many members and guests are joining us for CII’s fall conference — the first in New York City since 2002. We deeply regret any inconvenience we may have caused you by moving the meeting from Boston because of a strike at the conference hotel there. Our program offers insightful, provocative speakers on topics ranging from executive compensation to cryptocurrencies. It also includes a “master class” for governance professionals on evaluating company management of human capital, a forum for 50+ meetings between investor and company members and a roundtable discussion dinner for pension fund trustees. In between, there are several member-hosted events and opportunities WELCOME to network with peers. Looking ahead to 2019, CII is honored to partner with the New York University School of Law on Corporate Governance Bootcamp, a premium educational program for mid-level professionals. We are thrilled that 35+ members are taking advantage of a special CII discount to enroll in the three-day course, set for late January. Our commitment to educating members extends to helping fund trustees stay informed and in touch, too. We are pleased to announce that we will host training for new and experienced trustees at our 2019 spring conference, in partnership with the CFA Institute.
    [Show full text]
  • Hundreds Pack USC Student's Funeral
    NATION: E-cigarettes could trigger seizures A4 SPORTS Ja Morant declares for SERVING SOUTH CAROLINA SINCE OCTOBER 15, 1894 B1 THURSDAY, APRIL 4, 2019 75 CENTS NBA draft Hundreds pack USC student’s funeral Woman’s cousin says Chaim on Wednesday in DNR assisting SLED investigation of crime area her family’s pain after West Windsor, New Jersey, for BY SHARRON HALEY on Friday. additional evidence. killing ‘will never end’ Samantha Joseph- Special to The Sumter Item “We’re not looking for any- Clarendon County native son’s funeral. Jo- thing particular,” said Kaley Nathaniel Rowland has been WEST WINDSOR, N.J. (AP) JOSEPHSON sephson, 21, was NEW ZION — Search Lawrimore with SCDNR. charged in the killing of the — The cousin of a college stu- from nearby Rob- teams with the South Caro- “We are there assisting USC senior near where he dent who authorities said mis- binsville and at- lina Department of Natural SLED.” grew up. She is thought to takenly got into the wrong car tended the University of Resources were assisting Lawrimore said DNR div- have gotten in his vehicle in and was kidnapped and killed South Carolina. the State Law Enforcement ers had been searching a Five Points mistaking it for in South Carolina said the Josephson ordered an Uber Division on Wednesday in pond Wednesday that was lo- her Uber ride. sadness the family is suffering ride early Friday but mistak- investigating the area near cated near where Joseph- Her body was found cov- “will never end.” enly got into a similar car where 21-year-old Samantha son’s body was found and ered in wounds.
    [Show full text]
  • City Hall Ponders Parking Crunch by NICK TABOREK Daily Press Staff Writer
    PIANO & GUITAR LESSONS 2010 Small Business of the Year Award SM $ .00 45 MINUTE CLASSES California Small Business Association (41st District) to ONLY 15 – SIGN-UP NOW! – LAX (310) 453-1928 310-444-4444 20th $30 1901 Santa Monica Blvd. in Santa Monica Hybrid • Mercedes-Benz www.santamonicamusic.com Anniversary not valid from hotels or with other offers • SM residents only • Expires 8/31/10 SantaMonicaTaxi.com TUESDAY, OCTOBER 19, 2010 Volume 9 Issue 293 Santa Monica Daily Press GIANTS LOOK FOR PUNCH SEE PAGE 12 We have you covered THE GOOD CHOICE ISSUE City Hall ponders parking crunch BY NICK TABOREK Daily Press Staff Writer DOWNTOWN The planned renovation of Parking Structure 6, along with the AMC proposal for a new cinema on Fourth Street that would replace Parking Structure 3, Morgan Genser [email protected] could mean a fresh headache for commuters NIFTY MOVE: Santa Monica High School's to Downtown in the form of 681 fewer park- Moriah Faulk makes a move against Canyon ing spaces while construction of both proj- Springs during last season's CIF-SS girls' bas- ects is underway. ketball playoffs. Faulk has made a verbal com- Though both projects are a ways off — mitment to play for UCLA next season. the expected construction overlap isn’t expected until sometime in 2012 — City HIGH SCHOOL GIRLS’ BASKETBALL Hall officials this month are starting to make plans to deal with the eventual reduction in parking space availability. Samohi’s Faulk Parking Structure 6, which has 342 spaces at 1431 Second St., is expected to shut down for renovation sometime in 2011, and will picks UCLA eventually reopen with 710 spaces.
    [Show full text]
  • Jewish Influence: an Introduction
    NOTE: "The list below is available on the internet. A random sampling of the names were found to be generally accurate. Since the source is the internet, the reader is advised to also authenticate. The link is: http://www.subvertednation.net/jew-lists/ The below link from the Jewish Virtual Library contains many of the names identified on pages 36 – 38. http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/US- Israel/obamajews.html Jewish Influence: An Introduction We have been accused of having “Jew on the brain”; of being negatively obsessed with the Jews, and of being “anti-Semitic.” Yet Jewish influence over the affairs of the world are undeniably powerful, far out of proportion to their numbers. Their role in shaping public opinion through their media interests, and their mastering of the world of business and trade is pivotal to the world economy. As a group they are the most successful in terms of income and wealth and they have reached the highest echelons or the pinnacle of power in every field. Jews are the masters of Hollywood, they are the masters of all forms of media, radio, and television. They are masters of trade and commerce and banking, medicine, and law. The following lists we believe prove this reality. Jewish Lists The lists below are available on the internet. A spot check of several of the names found it to be generally accurate, though we cannot vouch for ALL of the names, and some titles may be out of date. The second list claims to be updated in 2012. They are followed by quotes on Jewish control.
    [Show full text]
  • BC High MUN 29 NFL CTE
    BC High MUN 29 NFL CTE Chair: Alex Pinarchick Co- Chair: Luc St. Mary BC High MUN 29 Table of Contents I. Message from Chairs II. Why Have a Committee? III. History of CTE IV. Current Issue V. Profiles VI. Questions to Consider I) Message from Chairs Alex Pinarchick: Hello delegates and welcome to BC High Model UN Conference XXIX. We are very happy to be hosting committees during this strange year and would like to thank you for giving this online thing a shot. I am very excited to be a chair for this specific committee because a few years ago I did a similar committee which was at my first Model UN conference. I have been a part of Model UN for 3 years and have gone to a few high school conferences and two college conferences which includes NAIMUN and WMHSMUN (Georgetown and William & Mary). It was very interesting to hear different things from people across the country instead of the state. I know that we can have a very good discussion on the topic today as NFL CTE. Please send me your position papers at my email address below so that I may consider them for awards. [email protected] Luc St. Mary: 2 BC High MUN 29 Hello delegates welcome all to this BC High Model United Nations. I would like to say we are happy to have you here in this committee to discuss the problems with CTE. I will be the co-chair to this committee and my name is Luc St.
    [Show full text]
  • Chiefs at Patriots (Foxborough) - 3:25 P.M
    Chiefs 1 REGULAR SEASON GAME 13 CHIEFS TRAVEL TO FOXBOROUGH TO TAKE ON NEw england PATRIOTS Kansas City Chiefs (8-4) at New England Patriots (10-2) Sunday, December 8, 2019 • 3:25 p.m. CT vs. Gillette Stadium • Foxborough, Massachusetts • CBS THIS WEEK’S MEDIA AVAILABILITY Date Practice Coach Media Players Tuesday, Dec. 3 No Media Availability Wednesday, Dec. 4 1:20 p.m. Reid 11:45 a.m. 11:45 a.m. The Kansas City Chiefs travel to Foxborough to take on the New England Thursday, Dec. 5 1:20 p.m. Assts. 11:45 a.m. 11:45 a.m. Patriots. Kickoff on Sunday at Gillette Stadium is slated for 3:25 p.m. CT. Friday, Dec. 6 11:45 a.m. Reid 1:00 p.m. 1:00 p.m. The Chiefs have won two of the last three regular season meetings against Saturday, Dec. 7 No Media Availability the Patriots, including a 42-27 road victory on the opening day of the 2017 Sunday, Dec. 8 Chiefs at Patriots (Foxborough) - 3:25 p.m. CT season. Last year the Chiefs and Patriots met twice, including the AFC Championship Game at Arrowhead Stadium. It was the fi rst time in club * All times are approximate and subject to change with little or no notice. history that Kansas City hosted the AFC title game. Since 2015, the Chiefs OC Bieniemy, DC Spagnuolo and assistants will speak Thursday. hold a 43-14 (.754) record against AFC opponents. Last week, KC defeated the Oakland Raiders 40-9. The Chiefs hav tallied a 23-2 (.920) mark against • The opponent conference call with Patriots Head Coach Bill Belichick AFC West opponents in the last 25 games and have won three-straight took place on Tuesday.
    [Show full text]