John Whitmer JOURNAL
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The John Whitmer Historical Association JOURNAL The John Whitmer Historical Association JOURNAL Edited by William D. Morain Fall/Winter 2013 VOVolumeL UME33, Number 230 2010 About This Journal The John Whitmer Historical Association Journal is published semi-annually by the John Whitmer Historical Association. The association’s purposes are to create and encourage interest in Latter Day Saint history, especially the history of the Commu- nity of Christ, to promote communication, research, and publication in the field of Latter Day Saint history, and to provide vehicles for the dissemination of scholarly research to persons interested in Latter Day Saint history. For more information, visit the association website: www.jwha.info. Papers for consideration will be reviewed by the editorial committee and should be submitted in a digital file (preferably MicrosoftWord ) using the most current Chicago Manual of Style format. Send all submissions and queries to the editor via e-mail: [email protected]. © 2013 by the John Whitmer Historical Association Printed in the United States of America ISSN 0739-7852 Copyright for articles and book reviews published in this issue of the John Whitmer Historical Association Journal is held jointly between the author and the association. The association reserves the right to publish an electronic version of the journal. Copies of articles in this journal may be made for teaching and research purposes free of charge and without securing permission, as permitted by sections 107 and 108 of the United States Copyright Law. For all other purposes, permission must be obtained from the author. Cover illustration and design by John C. Hamer. Image courtesy of Community of Christ Archives. The John Whitmer Historical Association Journal Fall/Winter 2013, Vol. 33, No. 2 COURTESY OF COmmuniTY OF CHRIST ARCHIVES John Whitmer (ca. 1870) vi THE JOHN WHITMER HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION JOURNAL EDITORIAL STAFF William D. Morain, Editor Erin B. Metcalfe, Associate Editor William D. Russell, Book Review Editor John C. Hamer, Production Director EDITORIAL BOARD Clyde Forsberg Craig L. Foster David J. Howlett Melvin Johnson H. Michael Marquardt Brent Lee Metcalfe William Shepard Steven L. Shields Barbara B. Walden Biloine W. Young OFFICERS OF THE ASSOCIATION R. Jean Addams, President 2012–13 Lachlan Mackay, President-Elect 2013–14 Steven L. Shields, Immediate Past President 2011–12 Cheryle Grinter, Executive Director Lewis Weigand, Treasurer Biloine W. Young, Endowment Fund Treasurer BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE ASSOCIATION Erin B. Metcalfe, 2010–13 William D. Russell, 2010–13 Christopher Blythe, 2011–14 Craig L. Foster, 2011–14 Jan Marshall, 2012–15 Barbara B. Walden, 2012–15 JOHN WHITMER BOOKS Jan Marshall, Executive Director Vickie Cleverley Speek, Editor Erin B. Metcalfe, Associate Editor John C. Hamer, Publisher and Production Director THE JOHN WHITMER HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION JOURNAL vii PAST PRESIDENTS Robert B. Flanders, 1973–74 Jessie L. Embry, 1995–96 Alma R. Blair, 1975 Danny L. Jorgensen, 1996–97 Kenneth E. Stobaugh, 1976 Ronald E. Romig, 1997–98 William D. Russell, 1977 Barbara J. Bernauer, 1998–99 Barbara J. Higdon, 1978 Edward A. Warner, 1999–2000 Paul M. Edwards, 1979 Alma R. Blair, 2000–01 Clare D. Vlahos, 1980 Michael S. Riggs, 2001–02 W. Grant McMurray, 1981 Biloine W. Young, 2002–03 Thomas J. Morain, 1982 Mark A. Scherer, 2003–04 Norma Derry Hiles, 1983 Jan Shipps, 2004–05 Paul M. Edwards, 1984 Newell G. Bringhurst, 2005–06 Richard P. Howard, 1985 Alexander L. Baugh, 2006–07 Wayne Ham, 1986 Barbara B. Walden, 2007–08 Robert C. Mesle, 1987 William Shepard, 2008–09 Linda King Newell, 1988 Jeanne Murphey, 2009–10 Maurice L. Draper, 1989–90 John C. Hamer, 2010–11 Roger D. Launius, 1991–92 Steven L. Shields, 2011–12 Isleta L. Pement, 1993–94 Table of Contents Articles Editor’s Note: Our Legacy in Print William D. Morain xi The editor reviews forty years of the contents of theJohn Whitmer Histori- cal Association Journal. Mormonism, Mitt Romney, and Race in the 2012 Presidential Campaign Newell G. Bringhurst 1 Newell Bringhurst addresses two key questions concerning Governor Mitt Romney’s 2012 Presidential campaign: (1) How much did Romney’s Mor- mon religion and its troubling race history hurt Romney among African American voters? (2) How much did Romney’s performance as a candi- date influence African Americans to vote overwhelmingly for President Obama? President Obama’s RLDS Ancestor: Roots of a World Leader Were Nurtured in Deloit, Iowa Velton Peabody 16 Velton Peabody traces the lineage of RLDS member Anna Childress, great-great-great grandmother of President Barack Obama through five direct generations, exhibiting a veritable kaleidoscope of occupations, re- ligions, personalities, and behaviors so distinctive of the American social spectrum. Table of Contents ix J. Charles Jensen: Homosexual Friend of David H. Smith Lewis Weigand 44 Drawing largely on existent letters from David Smith to his friend J. Charles Jensen, Lewis Weigand reviews the evidence that Jensen most likely was of same-sex orientation. The Writings of Oliver H. Olney: Early Mormon Dissident; Would-be Reformer Richard G. Moore 58 Richard Moore rigorously chronicles the dissident activities of Oliver Olney, who viewed Joseph Smith Jr., and his Nauvoo confidants as licen- tious, greedy, elitist and power-hungry. Disfellowshipped, bitter, penu- rious, and unable to persuade others of his own mystic visions, Olney disappeared from Nauvoo shortly before Smith was murdered. “Marshaled and Disciplined for War”: A Documentary Chro- nology of Conflict in Hancock County, Illinois 1839–1845 William Shepard 79 William Shepard provides a detailed chronicle of events relating to con- flicts between Mormons and anti-Mormons in Hancock County, Illi- nois, over six critical years. He discusses the conflicting cultures, politi- cal intolerances, and nuclei of violence that led to the inevitable dénoue- ment. The Role of “Prophet”: Variability within the Smith-Rigdon Movement Steven L. Shields 132 Steven Shields outlines the various understandings of “prophet” among the various factions arising from Mormonism’s diaspora, with special emphasis on the Church of Christ (Temple Lot). William T. Blue: A Lonely Spokesman for Black Saints William D. Russell 144 William Russell describes the struggle for equal rights of African Amer- icans in LDS and RLDS denominations with particular attention to RLDS elder William Blue, whose many indignities suffered over the years did not deter his commitment to his church. x THE JOHN WHITMER HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION JOURNAL Perla Wild, Foe of Women’s Silence Dan Kelty 167 Dan Kelty traces the eventful life of nineteenth-century RLDS writer “Perla Wild,” whose puzzles, poetry, uplifting short stories, and passion- ate arguments graced the pages of RLDS publications for nearly thirty years despite difficult personal sacrifices. Book Reviews Brian C. Hales. Joseph Smith’s Polygamy, 3 vols Reviewed by Gary James Bergera 188 Earl M. Wunderli. An Imperfect Book: What the Book of Mormon Tells Us about Itself Reviewed by William D. Morain 198 John G. Turner. Brigham Young: Pioneer Prophet Reviewed by Susanna Morrill 202 John J. Hammond. The Quest for the New Jerusalem: A Mormon Generational Saga, 4 vols Reviewed by Henry H. Goldman 205 John S. Dinger, ed. The Nauvoo City and High Council Minutes Reviewed by Steven L. Shields 206 EDITOR’S NOTE Our Legacy in Print William D. Morain On the wall of the Surgery Library where I trained years ago there hung a yel- lowed sign reading: We see only what we look for. We look for only what we know. Curious about what we at the John Whitmer Historical Association have been knowing, seeing, and looking for over our forty years of existence, I recently sat down to review the articles appearing on the Table of Contents of every single back issue of the John Whitmer Historical Association Journal to find out. While the more theologi- cal papers presented at meetings saw print in other venues, particularly Restoration Studies, the list should fairly reflect the historical content of JWHA meetings. Though there have been some trends in certain subject areas, a steady under- lying pattern has predominated over the years. As might be expected, the greatest number of articles were those related to the earliest days of the Mormon movement, forty-four papers in all. Close behind at forty-three were biographies, twenty-five of LDS figures and eighteen of RLDS. Next at twenty-eight were a growing series of thoughtful papers related to recent developments in the evolution of RLDS/Com- munity of Christ historiography, liturgy, and schism. Papers on Joseph Smith Jr., were tied with early articles on RLDS history at eighteen, followed by manuscripts on historiographic topics at seventeen. Articles on Mormon denominations other than the two largest followed at sixteen, along with contrasts/comparisons between LDS and RLDS groups at fifteen. Women’s issues showed the greatest increase in publication over the past decade with ten papers in all. A handful of topics appearing less frequently included current LDS matters, polygamy, the Book of Mormon, and racial issues, among others. The most recent additions to the list included hymnody, same-sex issues, DNA analysis, and Mitt Romney. In general, papers on LDS topics have increased proportionally over time, re- flecting expanding membership and participation on the part of LDS colleagues. And much scholarly work has been represented on the part of several senior authors xi xii THE JOHN WHITMER HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION JOURNAL whose consistent pursuits in specific research areas has been part of a lifetime focus of interest. But nowhere did I see evidence, in the titles at least, of personal animus or uncivil confrontation of one participant against another. We’ll leave that to Congress and continue doing things our own way. Mormonism, Mitt Romney, and Race in the 2012 Presidential Campaign Newell G. Bringhurst uring the early stages of the 2012 presidential campaign after W.