THE DIAPASON FEBRUARY, 2008
First Presbyterian Church Lexington, Kentucky Cover feature on pages 30–31
Feb 08 Cover - adjusted.indd 1 1/10/08 9:37:50 AM The acclaimed young English organist William Whitehead is Organ Professor at Trinity College of Music and Music director at St. Mary’s Church, Bourne Street, both in London. Previous posi- tions included seven years teaching at the Royal Academy of Music in London, service on the music staff of Westminster Abbey and later of Rochester Cathedral, and assisting John Eliot Gardiner with the famed Monteverdi Choir. “Whitehead’s compelling He won À rst prize at the playing represents Odense International advocacy of a high Organ Competition in Denmark in 2004, order.” and holds many other (BBC Music Magazine) awards and honors. He has performed in South “Whitehead plays Africa, France, Denmark Russia, Scotland, as well with clarity and au- as extensively in Eng- thority...rhythmically land at major venues and incisive playing.” festivals including those (MusicWeb International) in LitchÀ eld, Chelten- ham, and Hampstead and Highgate. “England seems to have a knack of de- He is a graduate of Uni- versity College, Oxford, veloping young or- where he was Organ ganists who become Scholar, and of the Royal quickly proÀ cient in Academy of Music, with a further gradu- the French literature. ate degree from King’s I hope to hear more College London. Organ from this excellent teachers have included Dame Gillian Weir, Naji talent.” Hakim, David Sanger, David Hill, James (American Record Guide) O’Donnell, and David Titterington.
His seventh compact disc release, “Dances of Life and Death” on the Chandos label, won Five Stars from the magazine BBC Music, the Diapason Découverte award in France, and was his À rst entirely solo recording. His next solo CD was released by Herald late in 2007 and coincided with a feature article on the organist in the interna- tional journal Choir & Organ. striking innovative rhythms, dance, and The good news is that a comprehen- theatrics. Often during my tenure as sive organ is fi nally in place at Trinity THE DIAPASON editor in chief to the forerunner of The Wall Street, and according to the distin- A Scranton Gillette Publication American Organist (MUSIC/The AGO guished director of music, Dr. Burdick, Ninety-ninth Year: No. 2, Whole No. 1179 FEBRUARY, 2008 Magazine), I would attend concerts and “it’s the only perfect answer for a church services at both the cathedral as well as of our design and execution. It is musi- Established in 1909 ISSN 0012-2378 Trinity Parish, especially aware of the cal, organist-friendly, and of great inter- An International Monthly Devoted to the Organ, organ profi le at Trinity with its obvious est to our growing community.” the Harpsichord, Carillon, and Church Music limitations in design, placement, and less From the caverns of Manhattan’s fi - than satisfactory acoustics. nancial district in lower Manhattan, the Rick Tripodi would have us believe Trinity soundscape rises up in glory with that this organ is a “magnifi cent, historic, its magnifi cent, historic, virtual, double CONTENTS Editor & Publisher JEROME BUTERA [email protected] one-of-a-kind” formerly in the hands organ, a solid achievement for Marshall FEATURES 847/391-1045 of a “consummate musician” and pres- & Ogletree, in collaboration with the ently “in real jeopardy under the cur- towering brilliance and monumental A conversation with James Kibbie rent musical director, who has a degree leadership of Owen Burdick, Ph.D., by Joyce Johnson Robinson 21 Associate Editor JOYCE ROBINSON in electronic music.” The reality is that Trinity’s energetic, enterprising, and in- [email protected] the original instrument—as cited by the genious organist and director of music OHS 52nd Annual National Convention 847/391-1044 administration and consultants—with its for these past seventeen years. July 11–17, 2007, Central Indiana drastic reconfi gurations over the years, Peter J. Basch by Frank Rippl 24 Contributing Editors LARRY PALMER can no longer be considered an Aeolian- Hoboken, New Jersey Skinner organ! NEWS & DEPARTMENTS Harpsichord A published appraisal of the former AIO convention Letters to the Editor 3 JAMES MCCRAY instrument follows: It was with great delight to have read Here & There 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10 Choral Music 1) It does not deliver the musical per- the December installment of John Bish- Nunc Dimittis 6 formance of an instrument half its size. op’s “In the wind . . . ” BRIAN SWAGER Carillon News by Brian Swager 12 2) It lacks variety and tonal color in Having been to several AIO conven- Carillon both solo and accompanimental stops. tions over the years (my fi rst one was Harpsichord News by Larry Palmer 12 3) Diapason and reed choruses are in- in 1980), the one this year in Philadel- In the wind . . . by John Bishop 14 HERBERT L. HUESTIS OrganNet Forum adequate. phia was truly magical, one of the best On Teaching by Gavin Black 15 Osiris Organ Archive 4) At soft and medium volume levels I ever attended. For those 263 of us (at- www.mdi.ca/hhuestis/osiris the tone is generally bland; at high power tendance count was mentioned at one REVIEWS e-mail: [email protected] the tone is harsh and unbalanced. point during the convention) we not only Music for Voices and Organ 16 5) It lacks the most basic qualities of came away with a great learning experi- a good Anglican church organ: a warm, ence, but an opportunity to hear some Book Reviews 17 Prepress Operations DAN SOLTIS rich, noble ensemble undergirded by a instruments that one might not get to New Recordings 18 solid, deep bass. hear under the circumstances that we New Organ Music 19 6) The pipework is badly out of regu- had (such as the private concert at the THE DIAPASON (ISSN 0012-2378) is published monthly by Scranton Gillette Communications, Inc., 3030 W. Salt lation. Wanamaker’s store). NEW ORGANS 32 Creek Lane, Suite 201, Arlington Heights, IL 60005-5025. 7) Out of 105 stops, only 21 would be Personally, I always come away from Phone 847/391-1045. Fax 847/390-0408. Telex: 206041 good enough to include in a new organ. the conventions and workshops of the CALENDAR 33 MSG RLY. E-mail:
Wesley recording to install such an instrument, when the I was pleased and gratifi ed to read the church could have had its Aeolian-Skin- Here & There recent review of my recording of organ ner restored and reconfi gured in any way works by Samuel Wesley (The Diapason, the current music director wished. Mr. October 2007, pp. 19–20). With the goal Tripodi is also quite correct when he re- The Cathedral of St. Philip, Atlanta, series: February 10, Paul Jacobs; March of giving credit where it’s due, may I men- minds us that the current music direc- Georgia, continues its music series: Feb- 2, St. Lorenz Wind Ensemble; April 25, tion one small correction? The reviewer tor will not be there forever, and pipe ruary 3, Christopher Harrell; 2/10, Leon Alleluia! Ringers; May 1–5, 2nd annual suggests that the program notes were organs generally last far longer than the W. Couch, III; 2/17, Marko Petricic; Bach Week; 5/1, Ascension Day Bach written by me. In fact, these are the work humans who play them, or should if they 2/24, David Brock; March 2, Albert Ahl- Vespers. For information: 989/652-6141; of Francis Routh, noted London-based are properly cared for. strom; 3/9, Atlanta Flute Ensemble; 3/16
FEBRUARY, 2008 3
Feb 08 pp. 2-20.indd 3 1/10/08 8:42:06 AM St. Paul, Minnesota. The program will fo- 20, Gail Archer, all Messiaen. For infor- cus on the music of Duke Ellington. For mation: 212/744-2080 x114. information:
4 THE DIAPASON
Feb 08 pp. 2-20.indd 4 1/10/08 8:42:30 AM as director of music and lecturer in litur- the Liturgy and Music of the Church.” clinician for numerous educational enti- gical music at Seabury-Western Theo- He did summer post-doctoral conduct- ties, including the Episcopal Diocese of logical Seminary from 1991 to 2004. He ing studies with Wilhelm Ehmann and California’s summer Youth Choir Camp, has been a regular guest conductor for Helmuth Rilling. Since 1996 Finster has the Evergreen Conference in Colorado, Ars Musica Chicago and has taught an- been an annual visiting fellow at St. Vlad- the Three-Choir Festival in Fort Worth, nual master classes in Gregorian Chant imir’s Orthodox Theological Seminary the Diocese of Texas Youth Choir Fes- and Renaissance and Baroque perfor- in Crestwood, New York, where he has tival, and the National Pastoral Musi- mance styles. pursued research in the liturgical theol- cians Association Conference, and was Finster began piano instruction at ogy, spirituality, and music of the Eastern a member of the Episcopal Church’s the age of fi ve, and organ at fourteen. Orthodox Church, particularly the tradi- Standing Commission on Church Music He graduated in 1961 from Occidental tions of the Russian Church. 1974–1976. He is a life member of Phi College in Los Angeles. His early organ Finster has held organist and choirmas- Mu Alpha Sinfonia Music Fraternity, an study was with Robert Pritchard and the ter positions in Episcopal, United Meth- honorary trustee of the Ruth and Clar- late Clarence Mader. Undergraduate odist, Presbyterian, and Roman Catholic ence Mader Memorial Scholarship choral study was with the late Howard S. churches in California, New York, Colo- Fund, and has been an active member Swan. Under a three-year NDEA IV fel- rado, Texas, and Illinois. The major ven- of the Association of Anglican Musicians Robert M. Finster lowship at the Eastman School of Music, ues served include a six-year tenure at and the American Guild of Organists. He Finster majored in church music, study- St. John’s Episcopal Cathedral, Denver, has served or serves on the boards of the sory capacity as director of church music ing organ with David Craighead, church and nine years at St. Luke’s Episcopal American Guild of Organists, the Royal at St. Paul’s Parish, Riverside, Illinois. In music history with the late M. Alfred Church, San Antonio. In 1976 he founded School of Church Music in America January, Finster and his wife Mary Lew Bichsel, and conducting with the late A. the Texas Bach Choir in San Antonio. The (Midwest Chapter), four Episcopal dioc- moved to San Antonio, Texas, where he Clyde Roller. He received his Master of choir of 48 professional and semi-profes- esan music and liturgy commissions, the accepted an appointment as part-time Music degree in 1963, and his DMA in sional singers toured central Europe in advisory committee for the Leadership organist and choirmaster of St. Francis church music in 1969. 1985 and again in 1990, and produced a Program for Musicians in the Episcopal by the Lake Episcopal Church in Can- In 1968 Finster was the recipient recording of the Rachmaninoff All-Night Diocese of Chicago, and the board of Ars yon Lake, Texas. of the Presiding Bishop’s Award of the Vigil (Vespers) in 1987. Musica Chicago. He is an editorial assis- While in Evanston, Finster also served Episcopal Church: “Fully qualifi ed in Finster has served as musical director- tant for Psalm Journal (“PSALM,” Pan-
thth ConcertArtistCooperative 20ANNIVERSARY
Colin Andrews Cristina Garcia Banegas Emanuele Cardi Shin-Ae Chun Maurice Clerc Organist/Lecturer/ Organist/Harpsichordist/Conductor Organist/Lecturer/ Organist/Harpsichordist/ Interpreter/Improviser/ Recording Artist Organ Faculty and Chair Recording Artist Recording Artist Recording Artist Lecturer, Organ Performance University of the Republic Organ and Soprano with Director of Music and Organist Titular Organist & Sacred Music Studies Conductor, De Profundis Polina Balva (St. Petersburg) Redeemer Lutheran Church St. Benigne’s Cathedral East Carolina University Vocal/Instrumental Ensemble Titular Organist St. Clair Shores, Michigan Faculty School of Music Director, International Organ Festival St. Maria della Speranza National Conservatory Greenville, North Carolina Montevideo, Uruguay Battipaglia, Italy Dijon, France
Leon Couch Laura Ellis Faythe Freese Johan Hermans Michael Kaminski Organist/Lecturer Organist Organist/Lecturer Organist / Lecturer / Organist College Organist Associate Professor of Associate Professor of Organ Recording Artist Director of Music Ministries Assistant Professor of Organ Organ and Carillon School of Music Conservatory of Music Saint Francis Xavier Church and Music Theory University of Florida University of Alabama St. Quintinus Cathedral Brooklyn College Faculty Converse College Gainesville, Florida Tuscaloosa, Alabama Organ Concert Series St. Francis College Faculty Spartanburg, South Carolina Civic Organist Brooklyn, New York Hasselt, Belgium
Angela Kraft Cross William Kuhlman Tong-Soon Kwak David K. Lamb Maija Lehtonen Organist/Pianist/Composer/ Organist Organist Organist/Choral Conductor/ Organist/Pianist/ Recording Artist Professor of Music Emeritus Professor of Organ Oratorio Accompanist Recording Artist Organist Luther College College of Music Director of Music/Organist Senior Lecturer, Organ Faculty Congregational Church Decorah, Iowa Yonsei University First United Methodist Church Oulu Polytechnic San Mateo, California Artistic Director Columbus, Indiana Organ and Violin Torch International Organ Academy with Manfred Grasbeck Seoul, Korea Helsinki, Finland
www.ConcertArtistCooperative.com Beth Zucchino, Founder and Director 7710 Lynch Road, Sebastopol, CA 95472 PH: (707) 824-5611 FX: (707) 824-0956 Established in 1988
FEBRUARY, 2008 5
Feb 08 pp. 2-20.indd 5 1/10/08 8:42:57 AM Orthodox Society for the Advancement history, design and care of the organ at of Liturgical Music). Saint-Ouen. Numerous photos are in- cluded in the booklet along with notes In anticipation of the 100th anniver- by Stephen Tharp and an essay by Joe sary of the birth of Olivier Messiaen, the Vitacco on the week the JAV team spent organ studio of the University of Texas at in the town of Rouen. For information: Austin, under the direction of Drs. Ju-
Aaron David Miller
Scott Lamlein tin, Minnesota, on February 24, with the John Scott composer at the organ. United Methodist Church, Worcester, First Presbyterian Church of Lock- John Scott is featured on a new re- Massachusetts, the program includes port, New York, has commissioned a cording, On a Sunday Afternoon, Vol- works by Kodály (Organoedia ad missam new anthem based on Maltbie Babcock’s ume 7, on the JAV label. Recorded live lectam), Bach, Brahms, Shearing, Du- familiar poem, “This Is My Father’s during a recital at Washington National Christopher Houlihan rufl é (Veni creator), and Innes. Lamlein World.” Pastor Babcock was minister Cathedral on June 25, 2006, the pro- is director of music ministries at Wes- of First Presbyterian Church in the late gram includes works by Wagner, Handel, Christopher Houlihan is featured on ley UMC and is represented by Ingras- 19th century. The anthem, My Father’s Bach, Mozart, Harvey, Reger, Jongen, a new recording, Louis Vierne: Second sia Artist Management. For information: World, will be premiered this spring. A Wammes, and Vierne. For information: Symphony for Organ, on the Towerhill la-
6 THE DIAPASON
Feb 08 pp. 2-20.indd 6 1/10/08 8:43:24 AM www.ioti.com VirtuosoPIPE ORGAN CONTROL SYSTEM 877 462 4684
In 1938, the Basilica In 2007, the of St. Peter and Paul Basilica chose the in Lewiston, Maine Virtuoso Pipe Organ chose Casavant. Control System. drals and churches. In 2004, she made H. Wiley Hitchcock, musicologist, a gift of a new Holtkamp organ for the author, teacher, editor and scholar of cathedral. Dr. Cambon was interviewed American as well as baroque music, died by Marijim Thoene for The Diapason December 5 at the age of 84. In 1971 (“Her Best Friends Were Archbishops— he founded the Institute for Studies in An interview with Elise Cambon, organ- American Music at Brooklyn College ist of New Orleans’ St. Louis Cathedral of the City of New York, and in 1986 for 62 years,” October 2004). he edited, with Stanley Sadie, the New Grove Dictionary of American Music. Anita Jeanne Shifl ett Graves died He retired from CUNY in 1993 as a Dis- September 16, 2007, at age 86. Born tinguished Professor, but maintained a September 20, 1920, in Lincoln, Illinois, consulting relationship with ISAM until she attended Macalester College in St. the end. Paul, Minnesota, and earned a master’s Born on September 28, 1923, in De- degree in music at Northwestern Univer- troit, Michigan, Hitchcock earned his sity. She had worked as a church organist, B.A. in 1944 from Dartmouth College choir director and funeral home organist, and served in the military during WW and taught at Drake University and San II. After the war he studied music with Jose State University. A funeral service Nadia Boulanger at the Conservatoire was held at Campbell United Methodist Américan and at the University of Michi- W. G. Marigold Church in Campbell, California. gan, from which he earned his Ph.D. in 1954. His dissertation was on the sacred installation of a new organ by Randall Lübeck,” Dec 1969; Kay Wood Haley died July 10, 2007, music of Marc-Antoine Charpentier. Dyer in 1991. He retired as professor “A visit to Preetz, Germany,” April at age 90 in Fairhope, Alabama. Born He started teaching in 1950 at Michi- emeritus of German in 1991, and moved 1971; March 26, 1917, in Sumner, Illinois, gan and in 1961 moved to Hunter Col- to Urbana, Illinois. “Some interesting organs in Sweden,” she began playing for church services in lege in New York. A decade later he went Dr. Marigold received his musical May 1971; Flora, Alabama, at age 14. She attended to Brooklyn College and became found- training in piano, organ, and voice at the “Organs and organ music of South Stephens College in Columbia, Mis- ing director of ISAM. In his honor, the Royal Conservatory of Music in Toronto, Germany,” Oct 1974; souri, and then transferred to the East- ISAM is to be renamed the Hitchcock and in Munich. He served as organist at “Organs in Braunschweig: some prob- man School of Music, where she studied Institute for Studies in American Music. churches in Toronto, at First Method- lems of organ placement,” Aug 1982; with Harold Gleason and graduated in In addition to his work on Grove, Hitch- ist Church in Charlottesville, Virginia, “18th-century organs in Kloster Muri, 1938. From 1939–1983, Mrs. Haley was cock edited numerous publications. His where he gave an annual series of recit- Switzerland,” Feb 1986; organist at Judson College in Marion, Al- last book, Charles Ives: 129 Songs (Mu- als, and churches in Columbus, Ohio. He “Organ and church music activity in abama, and at First Baptist, First Presby- sic of the United States of America), was was heard in radio organ recitals broad- Munich during the European Year of terian, and St. Paul’s Episcopal churches, published by A-R Editions in 2004. cast by station WOSU in Columbus, and Music,” Aug 1986; all in Selma, Alabama. She helped found played on the annual Bach recital at St. “A variety of recent German organs,” the Selma Choral Society and the Selma Everett W. Leonard died June 9, Andrew’s Lutheran Church in Cham- April 1989; Civic Chorus, and helped lead the Ala- 2007, in Katy, Texas, at age 96. Born paign, Illinois. “Dyer organ for Union College, Bar- bama Church Music Workshop. March 4, 1911, in Franklin, New Hamp- Professor Marigold was an interna- bourville, KY,” Dec 1991. shire, he began piano lessons at age nine tionally known scholar of German Ba- (Dr. Marigold continued to write re- Gerald W. Herman Sr. died August and organ lessons in high school. He roque literature and music, and author views to within weeks of his death. THE 25, 2007 at age 81 in Gainesville, Florida. worked for 40 years for the U.S. Postal of fi ve books, countless articles in schol- DIAPASON will publish these reviews post- Born November 9, 1925, he began his Service in Washington, DC. In addition, arly journals (including The Diapason, humously.—Ed.) 61-year organist career on April 28, 1946, he served as organist at Central Presby- Musical Opinion, and The Organ), hun- at Rockville United Brethren Church in terian Church and Mount Olivet Meth- dreds of reviews of German literature Johnette Eakin Schuller died Sep- Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, and played for odist Church, both in Arlington, Virginia, for Germanic Notes and Reviews, and tember 21, 2007, at age 66 in Brewster, several other churches in the area. A job and at the Episcopal Church of the Good countless reviews of recordings and Massachusetts. She earned degrees from transfer with Nationwide Insurance in Shepherd, Punta Gorda, Florida, and at books for The Diapason. He was a the College of Wooster, Ohio, and the 1979 brought him to Gainesville, Florida, the Lutheran Church of the Cross, Port recipient of many research grants for Eastman School of Music. She and her where he served as organist at Kanapaha Charlotte, Florida. A longtime member study and research in Germany. husband, Rodney D. Schuller, served Presbyterian Church and then at Beth- of the AGO, he served as dean of the Dr. Marigold is survived by his wife for 31 years as ministers of sacred music lehem Presbyterian Church in Archer, District of Columbia chapter. Constance Young Marigold, whom he and organists at the Reformed Church of Florida. He is survived by his wife of 61 married on August 22, 1953. A Requiem Bronxville, New York. Johnette Schul- years, Charlotte, a daughter, and a son. W. Gordon Marigold, longtime au- Eucharist was celebrated on December ler also held positions at Andrew Price thor and reviewer for The Diapason, 1 at the Chapel of St. John the Divine in Memorial United Methodist Church in Theodore C. Herzel died Septem- died November 25, 2007, in Urbana, Il- Champaign, Illinois. Linda Buzard, parish Nashville, Tennessee; the Presbyterian ber 28, 2007, in York, Pennsylvania. Born linois. Born May 24, 1926, in Toronto, organist and choirmaster, provided music Church in Bound Brook, New Jersey; the October 10, 1927, in Conshohocken, he earned a B.A. and Ph.D. from the by Bach, Purcell, Byrd, and Willan, along Post Chapel in Fort George G. Meade, Pennsylvania, he held church positions in University of Toronto, and earned an with hymns Lobe den Herren, Aus- Maryland; and Calvary Lutheran Church Lynchburg, Virginia, and Detroit, Michi- M.A. from Ohio State University. He tria, Slane, and Darwall’s 148th. in Verona, New Jersey. gan, and served as organist-director of also studied in Munich, Germany. Dr. In addition to numerous reviews of music for 28 years at First Presbyterian Marigold taught German at the Univer- new recordings and books, Dr. Mari- Church, York, Pennsylvania, retiring in sity of Western Ontario, Trinity College gold’s Diapason bibliography includes: 1988. He earned a bachelor’s degree at Schools, the University of Virginia, and “Max Drischner and his organ writ- Here & There Westminster Choir College and a mas- at Union College in Barbourville, Ken- ings: a neglected modern,” Oct 1955; ter’s at the Eastman School of Music. He tucky. At Union College, he was a de- “Austrian church music experiences was an active member of the York AGO partment head, division chairman, and extensive revival,” May 1956; Bärenreiter announces the release chapter and the Matinee Music Club. college organist, and he supervised the “The organs at the Marienkirche at of Choralvorspiele des 19. Jahrhunderts; Band IV: Alphabetische Liederanfänge M–Z (BA 8455). The collection, edited by Andreas Rockstroh, offers chorale /44/ (%533 /2'!. 0!243 4RADITION AND 0ROGRESS EHGLHQWRUJDQFRP &OR