DOCSLIB.ORG

The Economic Impact and Effectiveness of Development Aid

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Economic Impact and Effectiveness of Development Aid SELECT COMMITTEE ON ECONOMIC AFFAIRS The Economic Impact and Effectiveness of Development Aid Oral and Written Evidence Contents Actis, Adam Smith International and Ashmore Investment Management Ltd—(QQ 252-283)4 Adam Smith International—Written evidence ..................................................................................... 5 Adam Smith International, Actis and Ashmore Investment Management Ltd—(QQ 252-283) ...................................................................................................................................................................... 15 Africa Delivers—Written evidence ..................................................................................................... 39 Ashmore Investment Management Ltd, Actis and Adam Smith International—(QQ 252-283) ...................................................................................................................................................................... 42 Jan Dehn, Ashmore Investment Management Ltd—Supplementary written evidence ............ 43 Jean-Paul Azam, University of Toulouse—Written evidence ........................................................ 49 Embassy of Bangladesh—Written evidence ....................................................................................... 52 Aid Effectiveness Unit of Economic Relations Division, Bangladesh—Written evidence ........ 55 Mr Matt Berkley—Written evidence .................................................................................................. 61 Professor Philip Booth and Richard Manning—Oral evidence (QQ 284-337) .......................... 72 Gordon Bridger—Written evidence ................................................................................................. 102 Patrick Carter and Jonathan Temple—Written evidence ............................................................ 104 Center for Global Development—Written evidence ................................................................... 107 Mr John Chown, Chown Dewhurst LLP—Written evidence ...................................................... 115 Embassy of China—Written evidence .............................................................................................. 119 Christian Aid—Written evidence ...................................................................................................... 122 Christian Aid, Practical Action, Save the Children and Oxfam—Oral evidence (QQ 206-251) .................................................................................................................................................................... 129 Christian Aid—Supplementary written evidence ........................................................................... 130 Sir Edward Clay—Written evidence ................................................................................................. 136 Sir Edward Clay, Sir Tim Lankester and Lord Jay of Ewelme—Oral evidence (QQ51-81) .. 143 Sir Edward Clay—Supplementary written evidence ...................................................................... 163 Sir Edward Clay—Further Supplementary written evidence ....................................................... 164 Sir Edward Clay – Further supplementary written evidence ....................................................... 165 Professor Paul Collier—Oral evidence (QQ 317-337) ................................................................. 167 Professor Paul Collier—Supplementary written evidence ........................................................... 168 Department for International Development—Written evidence ............................................... 169 Andrew Mitchell MP, Secretary of State, Department for International Development— Written evidence ................................................................................................................................... 196 Department for International Development—Oral evidence (QQ 122-168) ......................... 197 Department for International Development—Supplementary written evidence.................... 221 Department for International Development; Foreign and Commonwealth Office; and the Ministry of Defence—Written evidence .......................................................................................... 227 Department for International Development; Foreign and Commonwealth Office; and the Ministry of Defence—Oral evidence (QQ 169-205) ..................................................................... 231 Department for International Development (Conflict Pool)—Supplementary written evidence .................................................................................................................................................... 250 Economic Affairs Division, Government of Pakistan—Written evidence................................. 259 Foreign and Commonwealth Office; Department for International Development; and the Ministry of Defence—Written evidence .......................................................................................... 265 Independent Commission for Aid Impact—Supplementary written evidence ......................... 266 Institute of Economic Affairs—Written evidence .......................................................................... 270 Lord Jay of Ewelme, Sir Edward Clay and Sir Tim Lankester —Oral evidence (QQ51-81) . 277 Kenya High Commission—Written evidence ................................................................................. 278 Sir Tim Lankester, Sir Edward Clay and Lord Jay of Ewelme—Oral evidence (QQ51-81) .. 282 Legatum Institute—Written evidence ............................................................................................... 283 Ministry of Defence; Department for International Development; and the Foreign and Commonwealth Office—Written evidence ..................................................................................... 291 Rt Hon Andrew Mitchell MP, Department for International Development ............................. 292 Professor Oliver Morrissey, CREDIT and School of Economics, University of Nottingham— Written evidence ................................................................................................................................... 297 National Audit Office—Oral evidence (QQ 365-398) .................................................................. 301 National Audit Office—Supplementary written evidence ............................................................ 318 Professor Benno Ndulu and Professor Robert Picciotto—Oral evidence (QQ 31-50) ........ 321 Nigeria High Commission—Written evidence ............................................................................... 334 ONE—Written evidence ..................................................................................................................... 338 Stephen Booth, Research Director, on behalf of Open Europe—Written evidence ............ 343 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development—Written evidence ................. 349 Overseas Development Institute—Written evidence ................................................................... 355 Overseas Development Institute—Oral evidence (QQ 82-121) ............................................... 362 Oxfam, Practical Action, Christian Aid and Save the Children—(QQ 206-251) .................... 385 2 Oxfam— Supplementary written evidence ...................................................................................... 386 Professor Alan Penney—Written evidence ..................................................................................... 389 Professor Robert Picciotto, King’s College, London—Written evidence ................................ 390 Professor Robert Picciotto and Professor Benno Ndulu—Oral evidence (QQ31-50) ......... 396 Professor Robert Picciotto, King’s College, London—Supplementary written evidence ..... 397 Practical Action, Christian Aid, Save the Children and Oxfam—Oral evidence (QQ 206-251) .................................................................................................................................................................... 402 Practical Action—Supplementary written evidence ....................................................................... 426 Publish What You Fund—Written evidence ................................................................................... 428 Mr Roger Riddell and Professor Aiden Wood—Oral evidence (QQ 1-30) ............................ 431 Professor Jeffrey Sachs, Columbia University—Oral evidence (QQ 460-479) ....................... 450 Save the Children—Written evidence .............................................................................................. 468 Save the Children, Practical Action, Christian Aid and Oxfam—Oral evidence (QQ 206-251) .................................................................................................................................................................... 478 Save the Children—Supplementary written evidence ................................................................... 479 Rt Hon Rory Stewart MP—Oral evidence (QQ 338-364) ........................................................... 481 Mr Finn Tarp—Written evidence ...................................................................................................... 500 Jonathan Temple and Patrick Carter—Written evidence ............................................................ 504 Transparency International
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Postmaster and the Merton Record 2019
    Postmaster & The Merton Record 2019 Merton College Oxford OX1 4JD Telephone +44 (0)1865 276310 www.merton.ox.ac.uk Contents College News Edited by Timothy Foot (2011), Claire Spence-Parsons, Dr Duncan From the Acting Warden......................................................................4 Barker and Philippa Logan. JCR News .................................................................................................6 Front cover image MCR News ...............................................................................................8 St Alban’s Quad from the JCR, during the Merton Merton Sport ........................................................................................10 Society Garden Party 2019. Photograph by John Cairns. Hockey, Rugby, Tennis, Men’s Rowing, Women’s Rowing, Athletics, Cricket, Sports Overview, Blues & Haigh Awards Additional images (unless credited) 4: Ian Wallman Clubs & Societies ................................................................................22 8, 33: Valerian Chen (2016) Halsbury Society, History Society, Roger Bacon Society, 10, 13, 36, 37, 40, 86, 95, 116: John Cairns (www. Neave Society, Christian Union, Bodley Club, Mathematics Society, johncairns.co.uk) Tinbergen Society 12: Callum Schafer (Mansfield, 2017) 14, 15: Maria Salaru (St Antony’s, 2011) Interdisciplinary Groups ....................................................................32 16, 22, 23, 24, 80: Joseph Rhee (2018) Ockham Lectures, History of the Book Group 28, 32, 99, 103, 104, 108, 109: Timothy Foot
    [Show full text]
  • Oxford Pre-Master's Courses
    Oxford Pre-Master’s Courses Advanced Diploma in British & European Studies 2015/2016 The University of Oxford’s pre-Master’s courses are ideal for graduates and working professionals who would like to prepare for entry to Master’s degree courses at leading British universities. Why study at Oxford? Global Reputation: One of the oldest and most prestigious universities in the world with an unparalleled academic reputation. Valued Qualifications: Recognised and valued by institutions and employers worldwide. Quality of Teaching: Your course will prove both academically challenging and intellectually rewarding. Personal Attention: Individual weekly tutorials and a high degree of personal attention throughout your course. Modern Study Facilities: Access some of the finest library and study facilities in the world. Perfect Location: Just an hour away from London, Oxford is one of Britain’s most glorious cities. International Outlook: A truly international community with students from 138 countries. A unique learning experience Course benefits • Expert tutors The Oxford pre-Master’s courses are offered by the Department for Continuing • Small class sizes Education and are taught at Rewley House in the heart of Oxford. Aimed at students who intend to pursue Master’s degree studies at leading British • First-class academic support universities, they combine academic study across a number of disciplines with • Individual weekly tutorials an intensive English language enhancement programme. • Regular feedback • High degree of personal attention Our courses not only help students to communicate confidently and fluently in • Full pastoral support spoken and written English, but also to develop superior analytical, critical thinking • World-class library resources and presentation skills.
    [Show full text]
  • Oxford Graduate School
    Omega Graduate School 2020-2021 Catalog OMEGA GRADUATE SCHOOL ACADEMIC CATALOG 2020-2021 President & CEO Joshua Reichard, DPhil, PhD, EdS, CCS 500 Oxford Drive Dayton, Tennessee 37321-6736 423-775-6596 800-933-6188 Fax: 423-775-6599 http://www.ogs.edu Omega Graduate School is a member of the Transnational Association of Christian Colleges and Schools (TRACS) [P.O. Box 328, Forest, VA 24551; Telephone 434.525.9539; e-mail: [email protected]] having been awarded Accredited status as a Category IV institution by the TRACS Accreditation Commission. TRACS is recognized by the U. S. Department of Education (USDE), the Counc il for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA), and the International Network for Quality Assurance Agencies in Higher Education (INQAAHE). According to the Omega Graduate School policy regarding Board of Regents’ approval of all revisions to publications, revisions to the Omega Graduate School Catalog were approved by the Board of Regents. Omega Graduate School is authorized by the Tennessee Higher Education Commission (THEC) to offer Master of Letters and Doctor of Philosophy degrees. This authorization must be renewed each year and is based on an evaluation by minimum standards concerning quality of education, ethical business practices, health and safety, and fiscal responsibility. Omega Graduate School is also approved by THEC for training of veterans. Eligible veterans enrolled in either the master’s or doctoral programs may receive veteran’s benefits. Catalog effective September 1, 2020 Rev. 4/6/21 1 Omega Graduate School 2020-2021 Catalog Table of Contents 1. History and Purpose of Institution ............................................................................ 5 2. Mission Statement and Objectives .........................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 2016 Contested Spaces in Cities As Politicised As Jerusalem?
    PROFILE HANNA BAUMANN DIVIDED CITY Hanna Baumann Can culture act as a bridge to connect groups who are in conflict? How do divided cities operate on a day to day basis? AndYEARBOOK how do people negotiate2016 contested spaces in cities as politicised as Jerusalem? Hanna Baumann [2012] has been fascinated by the subject of divided cities since she was young. Her PhD in Architecture will build on her undergraduate and Master’s research, which focused on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict as well as on work she has been doing in for the United Nations on minority cultural rights in conflict affected areas. Hanna showed an early interest in the intersection between culture and conflict. Growing up in what was then East Berlin, she was five when the Berlin Wall fell. “In some ways, it was a formative experience,” she says, “and was part of my interest in divided cities. Even after the Wall came down I could see the long-term effects on family and friends.” “I could feel the tension in the After graduating from Barnard, Hanna returned to the Middle streets of the old city, where East to work with Iraqi refugees in Jordan through the UNHCR. She then joined the humanitarian organisation ACTED in Jews and Muslims uneasily shared Jerusalem, working on agriculture, shelter and food security spaces holy to both groups,” projects. She says it was striking to see how in the Israel- Palestine context even seemingly innocuous activities like As an undergraduate at Barnard College, Columbia University, agriculture were deeply intertwined with questions of belonging she completed a dual major in Art History and the History of the and ownership.
    [Show full text]
  • Exeter Plans More Schols for Indians
    Page 4 CAREERS IN FOCUS Education Mail, New Delhi, Tuesday, December 21, 2010 ON THE SHELF Frances Cairncross, rector Are you getting ready to enter of Oxford University’s the job market or planning to go abroad for higher education? fourth oldest college, was SAUMYA PANT reviews four useful books that will prepare in Delhi and Mumbai to you for the big plunge, covering areas as diverse as getting your resume right to how to crack tap funds for scholarships the International English aimed exclusively at Language Testing System (IELTS). Indian graduate students JOB AT FIRST SIGHT: THE ULTIMATE GUIDE TO YOUR FIRST JOB By RADHIKA MADHAVAN; RUPA, `95 If you’re doing your course RADHIKA MADHAVAN is a professional consultant work seriously, you’ll barely and trainer based in ‘ Bengaluru. In her 15-year get six hours to sleep. We career, she has worked in would like our students not research, communica- ‘ tions and HR. Having to worry constantly about interviewed, hired and trained thousands of col- working after completing lege students over the years, she shares her their academic work. experiences and insights into the art of FRANCES CAIRNCROSS, Rector, Exeter College, University of Oxford getting one’s first job. The book covers the entire job hunt, from giving step-by- step directions on how to write an By Sourish Bhattacharyya impressive resume to advice on ways of developing and using one’s networking skills. Madhavan has made the book very easy to read by peppering it with exam- HAT was common to ples that give the reader an idea of how Pakistan’s first prime min- to prepare or conduct oneself to get ister Liaquat Ali Khan, one’s dream job.
    [Show full text]
  • Merton College Handbook for Junior Members 2021-22
    MERTON COLLEGE HANDBOOK FOR JUNIOR MEMBERS 2021-22 The College Handbook is divided into four sections. The first section contains the text of a contract governing the relationship between the College and its junior members and should be read in conjunction with the comparable contract provided by the University of Oxford. Junior members will be asked to confirm their acceptance of both contracts by signature when they are admitted to the College and the University. The second section contains information about: (i) The status of junior members; (ii) The organisation and management of the College; (iii) Provision of an academic, financial, welfare, domestic or recreational nature made by the College for junior members, and policies and procedures that apply to dealings between the College and junior members; (iv) Statutory, contractual and other legal obligations that are placed on the College in its dealings with junior members. The third section contains detailed regulations that apply to junior members in their dealings with the College, including statutory, contractual and other legal obligations. The fourth section contains the text of the agreement that governs the provision of accommodation by the College to junior members. Many of the regulations, agreements and undertakings contained in the College Handbook create legally binding obligations on the College and on junior members. All legal obligations are governed by English Law. Before coming into residence at the College, junior members must sign and return a statement that they have read and understood these regulations and agreements and undertake to abide by them. All junior members should therefore read the College Handbook carefully and seek advice where necessary.
    [Show full text]
  • A New Master 1 Farewell To
    NEWS AND FEATURES FROM THE BALLIOL COMMUNITY | JUNE 2018 A NEW MASTER 1 Visit from the Met Commissioner 9 Social media: a threat to democracy? 20 FAREWELL TO SIR How Balliol won University Challenge 28 DRUMMOND BONE 4 Balliol entrepreneurs 39 34 16 JUNE 2018 FROM THE MASTER 1 COLLEGE NEWS 30 New Fellows 2 A class act 4 Portrait of Professor Sir Drummond Bone 6 Deans on display 6 Awards 7 New Domestic Bursar 8 Visit from the Met Commissioner 9 New Outreach Officer 10 Admissions video 10 9 Our Oxford trip 11 Chinese visitors 12 4 Groundbreaking ceremony at the Master’s Field 13 STUDENT NEWS Horses and art in Northern Plains tribes 14 Having a blast in Bangladesh 16 Balliol climbers at BUCS 16 Photo of single atom wins national competition 17 26 Orchestra tour 17 Judo medal 17 JCR introduces CAFG officers 18 First place in an international finance competition 18 BOOKS AND RESEARCH #VoteLeave or #StrongerIn 19 Target democracy 20 Dynamics, vibration and uncertainty 22 Bookshelf 24 14 BALLIOL PAST AND PRESENT Balliol College, Oxford OX1 3BJ Nicholas Crouch reconstructed 26 www.balliol.ox.ac.uk How Balliol won University Challenge 28 Copyright © Balliol College, Oxford, 2018 The Garden Quad in Wartime 30 Tutorials remembered 32 Editor: Anne Askwith (Publications and Web Officer) Walking in the footsteps of Belloc 32 Editorial Adviser: Nicola Trott (Senior Tutor) Design and printing: Ciconi Ltd ALUMNI STORIES Front cover: Balliol’s first female Master, Dame Helen Ghosh DCB Social enterprise in Rwanda 33 (photograph by Rob Judges), who took up her position in April 2018.
    [Show full text]
  • Job Description and Person Specificationselection Criteria
    MATHEMATICAL INSTITUTE ANDREW WILES BUILDING Job Description and Selection Criteria Post Associate Professorship (or Professorship) of Number Theory Department Mathematics Division Mathematical, Physical and Life Sciences College Merton College Contract type Permanent upon completion of a successful review. The review is conducted during the first 5 years. Salary Combined University and College salary from £48,114 p.a. plus substantial additional benefits including either a household allowance of £20,000 p.a. and access to a Joint Equity scheme, or single accommodation in College free of rent and a Residence Allowance of £1,256 p.a., or rent-free house or flat accommodation and household allowance of £2,512 p.a.; a research expenses allowance of up to £3,800 p.a.; a taxable entertainment allowance of £450 p.a.; private medical cover; and a tutorial allowance of £3,000 p.a. An additional allowance of £2,804 p.a. would be payable upon award of Full Professor title. Vacancy number 146034 1. Overview of the post Applications are invited for the post of Associate Professor of Number Theory to be held in the Mathematical Institute (as the University’s Department of Mathematics is known), from 1 September 2021 or as soon as possible thereafter. This is a joint appointment between the University and Merton College and the successful candidate will be appointed to a Tutorial Fellowship at Merton College. Although there are separate employment contracts, they combine to make a single appointment with the duties split as described below. This level of appointment is the standard faculty position in the Mathematical Institute and in the College; it is held by a large majority of the permanent staff, many of whom bear the title of full professor.
    [Show full text]
  • ORGANIZATIONAL CHART | Updated May 2021 MICHAEL GALYEAN Provost
    BOARD OF REGENTS • J. Michael Lewis, Chair • John Steinmetz TEDD L. MITCHELL LAWRENCE SCHOVANEC JODIE BILLINGSLEY • Mark Griffin, Vice Chair • John Walker Texas Tech University System Texas Tech University • Arcilia Acosta • Dustin Womble Chancellor President Asst. Vice President of Human Resources • Cody Campbell • Brooke Walterscheid, Student MATTHEW DEWEY • Pat Gordon Regent GRACE HERNANDEZ Chief Marketing & Communications • Ginger Kerrick Chief of Staff and Vice President Officer for Administration DORI BOSNYAK Communications & Marketing (806) 834-2244 Texas Tech University Health (806) 834-4294 Lead Administrator of Sciences Center Presidential Lecture & Performance Series • Office of Communications & • Human Resources (806) 834-5261 Marketing • Communications & Marketing • Texas Tech Public Media • Title IX Administrator Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center—El Paso • Presidential Lecture & Performance Series KIMBERLY SIMON Title IX Administrator JAMIE HANSARD (806) 834-1949 Vice President for Enrollment Angelo State University Management (806) 834-3603 • Enrollment Management • Office of the Registrar • Student Financial Aid/Scholarships • Undergraduate Admissions • Finance & Administration CAROL SUMNER MICHAEL GALYEAN NOEL SLOAN KIRBY HOCUTT JOSEPH A. HEPPERT BYRON KENNEDY Vice President for Division of Provost and Senior VP of Academic Affairs Vice President for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Director of Athletics Vice President for the Office of Vice President for University Administration & Finance/CFO Research & Innovation
    [Show full text]
  • Balliol College Handbook 2020–2021
    College Handbook 2020–2021 Balliol College Handbook 2020–2021 About this Handbook A new edition of the Handbook is published annually, via consideration at the appropriate College committee; it may also be updated in-year from time to time as necessary. The online version of the College Handbook is to be taken as the authoritative and most up-to-date version. All students accepting a place at Balliol College are deemed to have agreed to be bound by these regulations and any subsequent amendments to them. These regulations shall be posted on the Balliol College website. In this handbook, all references to College premises include the Jowett Walk buildings and the Graduate Centre unless explicitly stated otherwise. The Graduate Centre, also known as the Holywell Manor Complex, comprises Holywell Manor, James Fairfax Yard, and the residential buildings in the Master’s Field Development. ‘College’ also includes Balliol property such as the boathouse, sports pavilion, and land and houses elsewhere in Oxford. Throughout, the word ‘residence’ means ‘residence in Oxford as a registered fee-paying student member of the College and University’. The term ‘junior members’ refers to both undergraduate and graduate members of the College. For the governing documents of the College, members are referred to the College Policies and Statutes, which include a Conflict of Interests Code. The Current Members section of the Balliol website includes some of the information in this handbook, as well as some useful links for College members. This handbook was last updated on 02.09.2020. 2 Balliol College Handbook 2020–2021 Contents 1 GENERAL & WHO’S WHO ............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Ms.F.Cairncross's Presentation
    Appropriate Education for the World’s Youth: the Challenge for the World’s Universities Higher Education in an Age of Global Mobility Hitotsubashi University and the Japan Association of National Universities Frances Cairncross Rector Emeritus, Exeter College, Oxford Exeter College, University of Oxford Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche 1844 - 1900 Changes in the world of universities in the last 25 years • Increase in numbers of young people going to university • Emergence of a global market in university education • University as a place to acquire vocational skills • Online education (e.g. MOOCs) Increase in young people going to university Proportion of young people in tertiary education Source: Mary M Kritz, Cornell University: UN Expert Group Meeting on New Trends in Migration: Demographic Aspects, Population Division A global market in university education Number of students in higher education programmes outside their country of citizenship Source: Mary M Kritz, Cornell University: UN Expert Group Meeting on New Trends in Migration: Demographic Aspects, Population Division A global market in university education (2) Source: The Economist John Henry Newman 1801 - 1890 “A University training aims at raising the intellectual tone of society… It is the education which gives a man a clear conscious view of his own opinions and judgments, a truth in developing them, an eloquence in expressing them, and a force in urging them. It teaches him to see things as they are, to go right to the point, to disentangle a skein of thought…and to discard what is irrelevant. It prepares him to fill any post with credit, and to master any subject with facility… He has a gift which serves him in public, and supports him in retirement.” John Henry Newman University: a place to acquire vocational skills Rising cost of university education Source: The Economist Online education Thank you! .
    [Show full text]
  • Oxford-Haury Scholarship-What to Expect 1612
    What to Expect More Details and Helpful Hints about Attending Linacre College, Oxford University Before you go Schedule The Oxford University academic term starts in early October each year. There are three terms: Michaelmas (Fall), Hilary (Spring), and Trinity (Summer). More information about these aspects is found here: https://www.ox.ac.uk/staff/about_the_university/new_to_the_university/university_year?wssl =1. Terms are 8 weeks long, and incredibly intense, with weekly assignments and in-depth classes. There are gaps of 6 to 8 weeks between terms, during which students are expected to catch up to readings and to work on research and preparation for assessed essays. Students complete their coursework in June, and are often examined on the entire year’s learning then. While assessment varies from course to course, it is not uncommon for there to be no assessment at all until the end of the year, and to have one month during which major papers are submitted and examinations are written to assess the entire year’s learning. In July and August, students work on their dissertation research and writing. Graduation ceremonies depend on degree and are held in September-November each year. Students are required to be in Oxford for the full 8 weeks of each academic term, and are expected to do considerable work between terms: it is advisable to allow an extra week in Oxford after the end of each term to ensure that you have adequate access to library resources for assessed degree work such as essays. The academic calendar and expectations can be found at https://www.ox.ac.uk/staff /about_the_university/new_to_the_university/university_year?wssl=1.
    [Show full text]