Revealing the Twohorns' of Taurus with GAIA
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
https://www.overleaf.com/project/5c86a42f0afdb00df4174248 Draft version January 30, 2020 Typeset using LATEX default style in AASTeX62 Revealing the Two `Horns' of Taurus with Gaia DR2 Graham D. Fleming,1 Jason M. Kirk,1 Derek Ward-Thompson,1 and Kate M. Pattle2, 3 1Jeremiah Horrocks Institute, University of Central Lancashire, Preston, PR1 2HE, UK 2Institute for Astronomy and Department of Physics, National Tsing Hua University, No. 101, Section 2, Guangfu Road, Hsinchu 30013, Taiwan 3Centre for Astronomy, School of Physics, National University of Ireland Galway, University Road, Galway, Ireland Submitted to ApJ ABSTRACT We investigate the spatial properties of sources from the Gaia catalogue previously identified as being members of the Taurus star forming region and which appear in the Spitzer catalogue. We study an area of sky of 10◦×15◦, centred on Right Ascension (2000.0)=68.5◦ and Declination (2000.0)=27.0◦, this being an area surrounding the Taurus molecular cloud. We use data obtained from the Gaia DR2 release. By using an inversion of Gaia parallax measurements to obtain distance values and by defining limits to the proper motions of the Taurus moving group, we are able to show that there are substantial differences in depth within the Taurus complex. Our results suggest that the Taurus cloud has significant depth and that there are two main associations centred at ∼130±6 pc and ∼160±4 pc at 1σ. These two associations also have different proper motions, of 24.5±2.8 and 20.1±2.4 mas yr−1 respectively. We here label them the `Two Horns' of Taurus. Keywords: ISM: individual objects (Taurus molecular cloud) - stars: distances - parallaxes - proper motions 1. INTRODUCTION The Taurus molecular cloud (TMC) is one of the closest low-mass star-forming regions, lying at a commonly accepted distance of roughly 140 pc (Elias 1978). The region covers some 10 to 15 degrees in extent which equates to about 25 to 30 pc at this distance. This makes comprehensive studies of the entire stellar population of the region difficult and few comprehensive studies of the three-dimensional structure of the cloud complex have previously been conducted (e.g. Luhman 2018). Situated within the TMC are numerous filaments and smaller cloud structures (Hartmann 2002; Schmalzl et al. 2010; Kirk et al. 2013; Panopoulou et al. 2014; Marsh et al. 2016). Previous studies have shown that young stars are grouped in and around these smaller structures (Gomez et al. 1993; Kirk et al. 2013). Early distance measurements (McCuskey 1939) determined a distance of 142 pc to the Taurus star-forming region, whilst arXiv:1904.06980v3 [astro-ph.SR] 29 Jan 2020 later studies (Straizys & Meistas 1980; Meistas & Straizys 1981) of a number of Lynds dark clouds in the region (Lynds 1962) indicated that the TMC is more extended and exists between about 140 and 175 pc. +21 A study by Bertout et al.(1999) of three distinct regions of the complex placed the Lynds cloud L1495 at 125.6 −16 pc, +16 +42 the Auriga region at 140−13 pc, and the southern region at 168−28 pc. The investigation of early-type O and A stars located in the Taurus-Auriga molecular cloud (Mooley et al. 2013) within 1σ parallax error of 6.2< π <7.8 milli-arcsec (128 to 162 pc), identified a significant number of previously unidentified A5 or earlier stars within the region. Mooley et al.(2013) also noted in their study that even their new Corresponding author: Graham D. Fleming gdfl[email protected] 2 distribution fell far short of the expected number of such stars if a standard log-normal IMF distribution is assumed for the region, adding to the discussion previously noted by Goodwin et al.(2004) and other researchers (e.g. Kraus et al. 2017). In their study, Bertout & Genova(2006) derived kinematic parallaxes of 67 members of the Taurus moving group +42 with typical errors of 20% and identified weak-line and classical T Tauri stars spread over distances between 106−24 +61 and 259−42 pc. Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA) parallax observations of the Taurus star-forming regions conducted by Torres et al.(2007, 2009) showed a difference in the distances to separate regions of the Taurus complex by studying a small sample of individual sources. They noted a distance of 161.2±0.9 pc for the star HP Tau/G2 and 146±0.6 pc for T Tau (from Loinard et al.(2007)) in the eastern part of the complex, and 130 pc to the central area of the star-forming complex, by observing the T Tau-type stars Hubble 4 (V* V1023 Tau) at 132±0.5 pc and HDE 283572 at 128.5±0.6 pc. A multi-wavelength photometric study of the Taurus region Gudel et al.(2007) using Spitzer and XMM- Newton data produced large-scale maps detailing the stellar and substellar distribution of the region, and in a similar survey of the TMC conducted by Rebull et al.(2010), pre-main sequence members of the Taurus molecular clouds were identified using the Spitzer Space Telescope Taurus project (SSTtau) catalogue (http://cds.u-strasbg.fr/cgi- bin/Dic-Simbad?SSTtau) and Two-Micron All-Sky Survey (2MASS) data (http://vizier.u-strasbg.fr/cgi-bin/VizieR?- source=B/2mass). In other, more recent research, planetary-mass brown dwarfs in the Taurus and Perseus star-forming regions have been investigated using photometric and proper motion data from a number of space and ground-based platforms including Spitzer and Gaia DR1 (Esplin & Luhman 2017). Galli et al.(2018) presents trigonometric parallax and proper motion observations of Young Stellar Objects (YSOs) in the Taurus region as part of the Gould Belt Distances Survey using the VLBA. Their data suggest a significant difference between the closest and farthest stars in their sample of about 36 pc with the closest lying at 126.6±1.7 and the most distant at 162.7±0.8 pc. Within this range they noted that the central portion of the L1495 dark cloud is at 129.5±0.3 pc, whilst the supposedly associated B216 structure lies at 158.1±1.2 pc. The more recent comparison of Gaia DR2 and VLBI astrometry results (Galli et al. 2019) revise these distances but again confirm the existance of significant depth effects within the TMC. Contemporary studies of the TMC using Gaia DR2 data conducted by (Luhman 2018; Esplin & Luhman 2019), present comprehensive studies of the stellar membership of the Taurus region. In both studies extensive reference is made to earlier works with regard to the stellar membership of specific cloud complexes within the TMC and the kinematics of their members. No evidence for an older population of stars previously identified by Kraus et al.(2017) and Zhang et al.(2018) is found, however the existence of a possible moving group of stars at a distance of 116 to 127 pc with ages of ∼40 Myr first identified in the Gaia DR1 data by Oh et al.(2017) is suggested. Previous studies such as those listed above have identified significant distance dispersion among the stellar members of various regions within the TMC star-forming complex, and have further suggested considerable depth effects within the cloud. In contrast to more recent studies, we revisit the coherent catalogue of sources identified by Rebull et al. (2010) in the Spitzer SSTtau catalogue and use the newly available data from Gaia data release 2 to model the characteristics and detailed internal distribution of sources within the region as a whole (Brown et al. 2018; Luhman 2018). Where our studies overlap, we note that our findings are consistent with those of Luhman(2018) and Galli et al.(2019) and consider them complementary to the results of these studies. Section2 provides a brief overview of the Gaia mission and some of the relevant issues concerning DR2. The acquisition of data and its subsequent analysis are discussed in x3 with particular attention being paid to the statistical treatment of the data. Section4 presents a discussion of our data which is briefly summarised in x5. A compendium of the sources discussed in this study are presented in the Appendix. 2. GAIA The European Space Agency Gaia astrometric space observatory (Lindegren & Perryman 1996) was launched in December 2013. The spacecraft is designed to measure the parallax, positions and proper motions of stars, with the ambitious goal of producing a three-dimensional map of most of our Galaxy. Gaia is not designed to measure distances directly, but they can be inferred through the determination of stellar parallax. The Gaia Archive1 is a relational database which can be accessed through an interactive user interface and interrogated using conditional queries. 1 http://gea.esac.esa.int/archive/ 3 The second Gaia data release (DR2) occurred in April 2018 with a five-parameter astrometric solution for more than 1.33×109 sources (Brown et al. 2018). DR2 parallax uncertainties are in the range of up to 0.04 milli-arcseconds (mas) for sources with a broad-band, white-light magnitude (G) <15 and in the order of 0.7 mas at G=20. Coupled with proper motion measurements from DR2, a detailed investigation of the internal kinematics of the Taurus star-forming region can be made. Due to the relative proximity of the Taurus star-forming region, where the parallaxes are positive and relative uncertainties are small, a Bayesian prior is not employed in this study (Bailer-Jones 2015; Bailer-Jones et al. 2018; Luri et al. 2018), and a straightforward inversion of parallax is used to infer distance.