A Comparison of African Evangelicalism with South African Black Theology and Indian Dalit Theology
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
I A COMPARISON OF AFRICAN EVANGELICALISM WITH SOUTH AFRICAN BLACK THEOLOGY AND INDIAN DALIT THEOLOGY BY REV VICTOR NAKAH Submitted in fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF THEOLOGY at the UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH AFRICA SUPERVISOR: Prof EVAN NIEKERK JOINT SUPERVISOR: Prof T S MALULEKE JUNE 2002 1 1 1 1 1 1 11 11 1 1 1 1 I1l1' ll1' ll1! ll1 1l 11 l1 11111 1 11!11' 11111 llllJ 1111 11 I 0001955873 II SUMMARY Evangelicals have an unquestionable heritage for involvement in the world and its social problems and the Bible provides a basis for a liberative gospel. For the God of the Bible is not only a God of love and peace, but also of justice and he is therefore on the side of the poor, oppressed and suffering. He has given us a spirit of engagement with the world as salt and light and not escapism. As we give serious consideration to the challenges of liberation theologies, we need to hear the voice of him who calls his people in every age to go out into the lost and lonely world (as he did), in order to live and love, to witness and serve like him and for him and that is what African Evangelicalism is all about. III KEYWORDS 1. Evangelicalism 2. African Evangelicalism 3. Latin American Liberation Theology 4. American Black Theology 5. Indian Caste System 6. Dalit Theology 7. Evangelical Theology of Liberation 8. Contextualization 9. Dualism IV ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I owe it to my wife who encouraged me to endure the long nights and my daughters who kept asking me when I would finish. My colleagues at the Theological College of Zimbabwe, especially Dr Burgess who created an environment that made it impossible for me to give up. Most of all I owe it to God who gave me a passion for the gospel truth and Systematic theology. UNISA LIBRARY 1007 -0)· 3 0 Class ................... Access 11 11111111111111111111111 0001955873 270.82 NAKA v TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER Page Introduction 1 1. Challenges Facing Evangelicalism Today. 4 1.1 Defining Evangelicalism 11 2. African Evangelicalism -The Challenge to Contextualize24 2.1 Is there a Biblical Basis for Contextualization? 33 3. The Basis for an African Evangelical Liberation Theology. 37 3.1 A Fuller Doctrine of God 38 3.2 A Fuller Doctrine of Man 44 3.3 A Fuller Doctrine of Christ 46 3.4 A Fuller Doctrine of Salvation 49 3.5 A Fuller Doctrine of the Church 52 3.6 The Evangelical Heritage for Social Concerns 53 3.7 Reason for the 'Great Reversal' 59 4. Latin American Liberation Theology 62 4.1 Types of Liberation Theologies 66 4.2 Impact of Liberation Theology on South African Black Theology 67 4.3 Tracing the roots of South African Black Theology 69 4.4 South African Black Theology - Definition 73 VI 4.5 North American and South African Black Theologies (Link) 81 5. Towards a Definition of Dalit Theology. 84 5.1 The Roots of Dalit Theology - The Caste System in India 84 5.1.1 Religious Mystical theories 85 5.1.2 The Biological Theory 88 5.1.3 The Socio-historical Theory 89 5.2 The Caste System in Modern Day India 93 5.3 Indian Dalit Theology - Definition 96 5.4 Comments on Dalit Theology 100 6. Analysis of Contexts: South African Black Theology and Dal it Theology 102 6.1 Context of Dalit Theology 102 6.2 Context of Black Theology 103 7. Interplay of Contexts and Victims 106 7.1 Effects of Context on Dalits 106 7.2 Effects on Context on Blacks 108 7.3 Factors Responsible for the emergence of Dalit Theology 109 7.4 Factors Responsible for the emergence of Black Theology 113 8. Substances of Dalit and South African Black Theology. 117 8.1 Theological Methodologies: Dalit Theology 117 8.2 Theological Methodologies: Black Theology 119 VII 8.3 Re-occurring Themes in Dalit Theology 121 8.3.1 Identity and Selfhood 121 8.3.2 Suffering 123 8.3.3 Total Human and Societal Liberation 124 8.3.4 Concept of Power 125 8.3.5 Concept of Community and Church 125 8.3.6 View of God 126 8.3.7 View of Christ 127 8.3.8 View of Women 128 8.4 Re-occurring Themes in Black Theology 129 8.4.1 Wholeness of Life 129 8.4.2 Poverty and Suffering 130 8.4.3 Liberation 130 8.4.4 Concept of Power 132 8.4.5 Concept of Community and Church 133 8.4.6 Concept of God and Christ 135 8.5 Similarities 137 8.5.1 Rejection of Dominant Theologies 137 8.5.2 Re-reading of the Bible in the light of the struggles of the poor for freedom. 138 VIII 8.5.3 De-emphasis of the Western theological traditional and an affirmation of their own cultural traditions. 138 8.5.4 Marxism as a tool for social analysis 139 8.5.5 Comparative Analysis 139 8.5.6 Thrust and Contribution to World wide Theology 142 9. Personal Reflection 145 9.1 God on the side of the poor and oppressed 150 9.2 He works in History to cast down the rich and exalt the poor. 153 9.3 The people of God on the side of the poor and oppressed 155 9.4 Evangelical Theology - Unbiblical and Heretical? 159 9.5 Criticism of Dualism 161 Bibliography 165 1 Introduction There is unquestionable consensus amongst most theologians that the most significant theological development of recent years has been the emergence of theologies of liberation. According to James Cone, all theologies of Liberation began as a reaction to the dominant theologies of Europe and North America. (Cone and Wilmore 1993:388) This development, according to Cone signals the rejection of the missionary theologies by Third World Churches and seminaries. What is so obvious amongst Third World Churches and Seminaries is a passionate quest for a contextual theology that brings about liberation. Third world people have been oppressed and subjugated for too long and they will not accept anything less than total liberation. At the heart of South African Black theology and Dalit theology is the attempt to fundamentally rethink theology from the standpoint of the poor and the oppressed. What is common amongst Black and Dalit theologians is a special interest in liberation, which they understand as the attempt of the poor and oppressed people to gain their freedom. The central theological foundation of this approach is the thesis that God is on the side of the poor and the oppressed. This foundational thinking is in fact a reaction to the missionary over-emphasis of spiritual salvation, as if the gospel of Jesus Christ had no interest in the material conditions of life. (Cone and Wilmore 1993:388) It is this basic thesis that I would want to probe further as I look at two non-Western theologies of liberation from an African Evangelical perspective. The two non-Western theologies that will form the bulk of this thesis share the same theological foundation as all the other liberation theologies. The 2 thread that will run through this thesis is a response to the question, 'How biblical is the view that God is on the side of the poor and the oppressed?' How accurate is the realization that the Bible is concerned about the salvation of the whole person, including his or her physical well-being? To what extent does evangelical Christianity authenticate the claim that God is on the side of the poor and the oppressed and what does it mean? The purpose of this thesis is therefore two fold. Firstly I would want to make an analytical comparison (themes, context, methodology) of Indian Dalit Theology and South African Black theology, two theologies which share this central theological foundation of Liberation. Furthermore, I will examine the factors responsible for their emergence focusing on the inter-relatedness of the content of the two theologies to existential and other factors in their contexts. The major themes would then be highlighted to portray similarities and differences between them. Secondly, I would want to relate all this to African Evangelicalism primarily to make the point that it is possible to develop a comprehensive African Evangelical theology of liberation. My thesis is therefore a theological reflection on Indian Dalit theology and South African Black theology as two theologies attempting to rethink theology from the standpoint of the poor and oppressed and Evangelical theology as a theology that can be developed into a comprehensive liberation theology. 3 To do justice to these two non-Western theologies, I will attempt to explore how they have been influenced by other similar theologies or systems. In the case of South African Black theology, I would like to demonstrate its roots in the American Black theology as well as the impact of Latin American Liberation theology. Indian Dalit theology cannot be understood apart from the Indian Caste system and so I will attempt to do a caste analysis with the assumption that this will help us to have a deeper appreciation of where Dalit theology has come from. In order to establish the evangelical basis from which I will look at these two theologies, I would like to begin by highlighting the basic contemporary challenges facing evangelicalism in Africa today and then argue that this theology has a historically proven heritage for social involvement and can therefore be developed into a comprehensive African Evangelical theology of liberation. 4 CHAPTER ONE 1.