Integrative Medicine and Systemic Outcomes Research Issues in the Emergence of a New Model for Primary Health Care

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Integrative Medicine and Systemic Outcomes Research Issues in the Emergence of a New Model for Primary Health Care SPECIAL ARTICLE Integrative Medicine and Systemic Outcomes Research Issues in the Emergence of a New Model for Primary Health Care Iris R. Bell, MD, MD(H), PhD; Opher Caspi, MD; Gary E. R. Schwartz, PhD; Kathryn L. Grant, PharmD; Tracy W. Gaudet, MD; David Rychener, PhD; Victoria Maizes, MD; Andrew Weil, MD linicians and researchers are increasingly using the term integrative medicine to refer to the merging of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) with conventional bio- medicine. However, combination medicine (CAM added to conventional) is not inte- grative. Integrative medicine represents a higher-order system of systems of care that Cemphasizes wellness and healing of the entire person (bio-psycho-socio-spiritual dimensions) as pri- mary goals, drawing on both conventional and CAM approaches in the context of a supportive and effective physician-patient relationship. Using the context of integrative medicine, this article out- lines the relevance of complex systems theory as an approach to health outcomes research. In this view, health is an emergent property of the person as a complex living system. Within this concep- tualization, the whole may exhibit properties that its separate parts do not possess. Thus, unlike bio- medical research that typically examines parts of health care and parts of the individual, one at a time, but not the complete system, integrative outcomes research advocates the study of the whole. The whole system includes the patient-provider relationship, multiple conventional and CAM treatments, and the philosophical context of care as the intervention. The systemic outcomes encompass the si- multaneous, interactive changes within the whole person. Arch Intern Med. 2002;162:133-140 Any intelligent person can study medical INTEGRATION VS ASSIMILATION literature and understand when or when not to use various treatments. What is so difficult, The term integrative medicine is often used even for a skilled physician, is to apply this to refer to blending the best of conven- knowledge in individual cases. For those who tional (allopathic) and complementary and know nothing about the fundamentals of alternative medicine (CAM). At face value, healing and treat it casually and talk a lot, nothing seems difficult. They don’t think there this goal seems straightforward and prom- is any illness that requires careful deliberation. ises an improved package of medical care The common run of people thinks medicine can for the consumer. However, a closer exami- be learned quite easily, whereas it is really nation of the process of this integration extremely difficult to master even for a raises a number of complex practical and conscientious physician. conceptual issues with which medicine as a field must grapple. This article deals with Maimonides (1135-1204) this process of integration and discusses im- The Regimen of Health Care; 4:7-8 plications for health care outcomes re- search. We suggest that by adopting a world- view derived from complex systems theory From the Program in Integrative Medicine, Departments of Medicine (Drs Bell, Caspi, in which the whole equals more than the Schwartz, Grant, Gaudet, Rychener, Maizes, and Weil), Psychiatry (Drs Bell and sum of its parts, a new perspective for medi- Schwartz), Psychology (Drs Bell, Caspi, and Schwartz), Neurology (Dr Schwartz), Family & Community Medicine (Drs Bell and Weil), Obstetrics and Gynecology cine and health care research emerges. 1 (Dr Gaudet), and Pharmacy Practice (Dr Grant), The University of Arizona Colleges The dictionary defines integrate as “to of Medicine and Pharmacy, and the Southern Arizona Veterans Affairs Health Care unite with something else,” “to incorpo- System (Dr Bell), Tucson. Dr Gaudet is now with Duke University Center rate into a larger unit.” Although the dic- for Integrative Medicine, Durham, NC. tionary definition of the noun integration (REPRINTED) ARCH INTERN MED/ VOL 162, JAN 28, 2002 WWW.ARCHINTERNMED.COM 133 ©2002 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. includes “the incorporation of Within conventional care, some nal contexts to fit a few of these equals into society,”1 it is evident multidisciplinary approaches to pa- smaller pieces into the dominant that the assumption implicit in the tient care have already laid a founda- model of conventional care and merger process for mainstream tion for the more fully integrative medical research. For example, nu- medicine is of an initial inequality medicine that could emerge: for ex- merous studies have investigated the in power and worthiness between ample, (1) in geriatrics, developing efficacy of acupuncture for various conventional and CAM approaches. multidisciplinary special care teams9 Western disorders,22,23 but virtu- That is, the politically dominant and end-of-life programs to optimize ally no studies examine the effec- “larger unit” (ie, conventional quality of life in hospice care10; (2) in tiveness of the sum total of Chinese medicine in the Western world; see chronic pain treatment programs, medicine as practiced. In acupunc- Zollman and Vickers2) carries the applying multidisciplinary care to ture-only research, the effect sizes are values, culture, and conceptual improve individual self-efficacy and often modest.24,25 Yet, traditionally, framework into which it expects the quality of life11; (3) in psychiatry, Chinese medicine uses a coordi- smaller unit (ie, CAM) to assimi- blending social supports, psycho- nated and individualized program late. It operates from the assump- therapy, and medications12 as well that includes various combinations tion that each CAM intervention, as emphasizing the patient’s respon- of diet, botanicals, acupuncture, acu- once tested and proven effective, can sibility for his or her own recovery13; pressure, qi gong, and environmen- be incorporated into conventional (4) in family medicine, valuing good tal interventions to address the care as now practiced.2 physician-patient relationships14 and unique, systemic disturbance pat- preventive interventions15; and (5) in terns in a given patient.18 It is a test- INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE behavioral medicine/health psychol- able hypothesis that the effect sizes IS NOT CAM ogy, using behavioral interventions of the full treatment program could to foster self-care and self-efficacy in be much larger and more clinically However, much of the conventional patients with diabetes16 or arthritis.17 significant if the entire Chinese contemporary practice of physicians, Although these examples of care- medicine treatment program were especially for the treatment of patients beyond-the-lesion offer important studied as used.26 with chronic diseases, has continued models for a more ideal form of medi- Moreover, Western medical re- to focus on a specific somatic disease cine, even these models are not nec- search usually assumes that its ap- process at the end organ rather than essarily widely available and/or acces- proach to diagnosis is the preferred on healing the individual person. Dis- sible within the current health care way to label a patient. It requires ho- affection with how physicians provide system. mogeneous groups of patients with conventional care and rely on phar- As it evolves, truly integrative conventional diagnoses for study. maceutical medicine continues to medicine also depends for its philo- But each system of CAM has its own grow among consumers and physi- sophical foundation and patient- theory-driven method for categoriz- cians alike.3,4 Integrative medicine is centered approach on systems of ing patients. Within a group of pa- acomprehensive,primarycaresystem CAM that emphasize healing the per- tients with asthma, for example, each that emphasizes wellness and healing son as a whole (eg, traditional Chi- CAM system is likely to identify of the whole person5 (bio-psycho- nese medicine, Ayurvedic medi- several different subtypes, each re- socio-spiritual dimensions) as major cine, and classic homeopathy).18 quiring a unique set of interven- goals, above and beyond suppression These CAM systems diverge the most tions for optimal treatment re- of a specific somatic disease.6,7 In the in philosophy, diagnosis, and treat- sponse (Figure 1A). In classic ideal situation, the patient and the in- ment technique from conventional homeopathy, for instance, each of 4 tegrative practitioner are partners in medicine,18 and thus remain margin- different patients with chronic the effort to develop and implement alized. Using philosophy-driven asthma might respond to only 1 rem- a comprehensive treatment plan for frameworks that seek balance, har- edy type chosen on the basis of his issues that extend far beyond the im- mony, and proper flow throughout or her individualized symptom pat- mediate chief complaint and/or con- the patient, they diagnose and treat tern (eg, Arsenicum album or Kali ventional diagnostic category.6 Truly patterns of dysfunction within the en- carbonicum or Medorrhinum or Na- integrative medicine draws from con- tire person as an indivisible sys- trum sulphuricum). In other words, ventional and alternative techniques tem.19 From the perspective of West- homogeneity of sample selection to facilitate healing and to empower ern science, such CAM systems offer from a conventional medical per- the patient because healing is believed (1) virtually no commonly used, re- spective is likely to break down into to originate within the patient rather ductionist, scientific methods by heterogeneous diagnoses from each than from the physician.6 Thus, the which
Recommended publications
  • “Wellness Cruises” with Dr. Andrew Weil, Bound for Arabia in 2019 and Australia/New Zealand in 2020
    Seabourn Announces “Wellness Cruises” with Dr. Andrew Weil, Bound for Arabia in 2019 and Australia/New Zealand in 2020 March 7, 2019 SEATTLE, March 7, 2019 – Based on the success of its 2018 Wellness Voyages Seabourn, the world's finest ultra- luxury travel experience, is setting its sights on mindful, healthy living in the year ahead by announcing two content rich Wellness Cruises bound for Arabia and the South Pacific. Inspired by the rising interest in wellness that is transforming travel and lifestyles around the globe, each wellness cruise is being fashioned with input from celebrated physician, best-selling author and Seabourn partner Dr. Andrew Weil, whose exclusive mindful living program, Spa & Wellness with Dr. Andrew Weil is a popular offering on every vessel and every voyage in the Seabourn fleet. With renowned Seabourn service, diverse itineraries and culturally rich destinations as a backdrop, the Wellness Cruises will be highly informative, enjoyable, and unforgettable. These specific itineraries will include lectures, discussions, classes, and demonstrations led by Dr. Weil and an additional four experts in Integrative Medicine and packed with information on how guests can enrich their lives for better mental and physical health. "Wellness is a growing phenomenon – and rightly so – as people around the world seek to live better, healthier, and more mindfully for the benefit of their overall wellbeing," noted Richard Meadows, president of Seabourn. "We have had great success with Spa & Wellness with Dr. Andrew Weil on Seabourn voyages around the world, and we're excited to follow up our past two wellness cruises with these new opportunities to learn from a group of highly regarded experts." The Ancient Path to Wellness The next Seabourn Wellness Cruise will launch with Route to Ancient Wellness aboard Seabourn Ovation, scheduled November 13-December 2, 2019.
    [Show full text]
  • Strategic Leadership Workshop
    Strategic Leadership Workshop The MindBodySpirit Process: How to Coach Yourself and Others Towards Positive Behavioral Change October 17, 2009 9:00 AM – noon, Room 121 Abessinio Bldg Workshop Leaders: Dr. Jeff Kaplan and Dr. Robert Bulgarelli Neumann University’s Strategic Leadership Program , in partnership with The Habit Change Company , will sponsor a free workshop for current students and alumni. The Habit Change Company helps students, managers, executives, hospital patients, and others do something very hard …choose and sustain healthy behaviors over unhealthy behaviors. This 3-hour experiential workshop taps into key processes taken from a proprietary 15-month habit change process. Delivered by two of The Habit Change Company’s founders, this program is designed to help you increase your performance and your health. During this program you will take a deep and honest look at your habits in the areas of work, time management, sleep, stress management, nutrition and exercise. At the completion of the program, you will have taken the first steps towards mapping out a life plan that supports your professional and personal goals. The objectives of this 3-hour experiential workshop are: Learn and practice a technique to reduce stress immediately while increasing self- awareness Understand the reason people struggle with habit change and the 5 barriers that surface when attempting change Learn and use a tool to help you and your clients assess their current habits across 8 life practices Begin to understand the psychological and medical underpinnings around habit change Develop a vision for professional and personal success and begin to map out steps to help achieve this vision The MindBodySpirit (MBS) Process, developed by The Habit Change Company, is a new approach to health and wellness, helping individuals take better control of their health, gain greater vitality, and live longer lives.
    [Show full text]
  • Stress Overload from Modern Living Stress Overload from Modern Living
    Stress Overload from Modern Living Stress Overload from Modern Living Andrew Weil, M.D., a well-known university-based health expert, presented an article recently suggesting that the stresses connected with modern-day living are a cause of much of today’s incidence of clinical depression. He produces two bits of evidence. First depression rates are much lower in less developed countries that do not have the demands of modern living. Second, even in this country, the Amish have much lower rates of depression--they live withour modern conveniences and expectations. Martin Seligman, professor at the University of Pennsylvania, was studied the Old Order Amish. It turns out that they have a clinical depression rate that is one tenth of that of other Americans. Says Seligman--"There seems to be something about modern life that creates a fertile soil for depression." Stephen Ilardi, professor at the University of Kansas, states, "The more 'modern' a society's way of life, the higher its rate of depression. It may seem baffling, but the explanation is simple: the human body was never designed for the modern postindustrial environment." Dr. Weil feels that its the unprecedented demands of modern life that is resulting in this level of stress. He suggests five tips for dealing with the stresses of modern life-- 1. Mindfulness training--a type of mediation that increases a sense of focus and concentration. 2. Sleep well and in complete darkness. 3. More social interaction--make it a priotity. 4. Avoid disturbing sounds--choose to listen to things that have a positive effect on the mood; try to cultivate silence.
    [Show full text]
  • Dr. Andrew Weil MD, Who Was Born in Philadelphia in 1942, Has an A.B
    Why eat Organic Foods? According to the Environmental Working Group Organization (EWG.org), which is a nonprofit organization that advocates for policies that protect global and individual health, the benefits of eating organic foods, is to lower your risk of eating foods contaminated with Pesticides. ​ The United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) noted Pesticide Law defines a pesticide ​ as: *Any substance or mixture of substances intended for preventing, destroying, repelling, or mitigating any pest. *Any substance or mixture of substances intended for use as a plant regulator, defoliant, or desiccant. *Any nitrogen stabilizer Dr. Andrew Weil MD, who was born in Philadelphia in 1942, has an A.B. degree in biology (botany) from Harvard University and an MD from Harvard Medical School, has a partnership with ​ the EWG and advocates the EWG’s Guide to Pesticides in Produce. According to Dr. Weil, you should care about pesticides because the EWG points out that there is a growing consensus in the scientific community that even small amounts of pesticides and other chemicals can have adverse effects on health, especially during vulnerable periods such as fetal development and childhood. The EWG guide is based on the results of pesticide tests performed on produce by several federal agencies. Most of the data took into account how people washed and prepared produce. Of the fruits and vegetable categories tested, a “Clean 15” list and a “Dirty Dozen Plus” list, were developed. The “Clean 15”foods had the lowest pesticide load and are the safest conventionally grown crops to consume from the standpoint of pesticide contamination.
    [Show full text]
  • Timothy Leary's Legacy and the Rebirth of Psychedelic Research
    Timothy Leary’s legacy and the rebirth of psychedelic research The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Lattin, Don. 2019. Timothy Leary’s legacy and the rebirth of psychedelic research. Harvard Library Bulletin 28 (1), Spring 2017: 65-74. Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:41647383 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA Timothy Leary’s Legacy and the Rebirth of Psychedelic Research Don Lattin imothy Leary, the self-proclaimed “high priest” of the psychedelic counterculture of the 1960s, issued countless proclamations and prophecies Tduring his three decades in the public eye. Here’s one he made in San Francisco in 1965, just a couple years afer the fellows at Harvard College dismissed him as a lecturer in clinical psychology:1 “I predict that within one generation we will have across the bay in Berkeley a Department of Psychedelic Studies. Tere will probably be a dean of LSD.» Two generations later, the University of California at Berkeley has yet to establish its Department of Psychedelic Studies. But, as is ofen the case with Timothy Leary, the high priest was half right in his prediction that mainstream academia would someday rediscover the value of psychedelic research. Harvard does not have a dean of LSD, but it now has something called “Te LSD Library.” Tat would be the Ludlow-Santo Domingo Library, an intoxicating collection housed at Harvard Library that includes many items from the Timothy Leary archive.
    [Show full text]
  • From Harvard in 1964 and an M.D
    BRIEF BIOGRAPHY OF ANDREW WEIL Andrew Weil was born in Philadelphia in 1942, received an A.B. degree in biology (botany) from Harvard in 1964 and an M.D. from Harvard Medical School in 1968. After completing a medical internship at Mt. Zion Hospital in San Francisco, he worked a year with the National Institute of Mental Health, then wrote his first book, The Natural Mind. From 1971-75, as a Fellow of the Institute of Current World Affairs, Dr. Weil traveled widely in North and South America and Africa collecting information on drug use in other cultures, medicinal plants, and alternative methods of treating disease. From 1971-84 he was on the research staff of the Harvard Botanical Museum and conducted investigations of medicinal and psychoactive plants. At present Dr. Weil is Director of the Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine at the University of Arizona, where he also holds the Lovell-Jones Endowed Chair in Integrative Rheumatology and is Clinical Professor of Medicine and Professor of Public Health. The Center is the leading effort in the world to develop a comprehensive curriculum in integrative medicine. Graduates serve as directors of integrative medicine programs throughout the United States. Through its Fellowship and Integrative Medicine in Residency curricula, the Center is now training doctors and nurse practitioners around the world. Dr. Weil is the editorial director of the popular website, Dr. Weil.com (www.drweil.com), and appears in video programs featured on PBS. He can be found on Facebook at www.facebook.com/DrWeil and Twitter @drweil. Dr. Weil is the founder and Chairman of the Weil Foundation, and the Chairman of Weil Lifestyle.
    [Show full text]
  • Meditation for Optimum Health: How to Use Mindfulness and Breathing to Heal Pdf, Epub, Ebook
    MEDITATION FOR OPTIMUM HEALTH: HOW TO USE MINDFULNESS AND BREATHING TO HEAL PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Andrew T. Weil,Jon Kabat-Zinn | 2 pages | 01 Feb 2002 | SOUNDS TRUE INC | 9781564558824 | English | Louisville, CO, United States Meditation for Optimum Health: How to Use Mindfulness and Breathing to Heal PDF Book They also give you guided meditations to begin your own practice and real life situations in which your meditative practice can be beneficial to you. Please note: Refund requests over days from the purchase date will receive a check, as funds cannot be returned to the credit card due to fraud protection policies. Show More. Emily's Book of Health Without Drugs. If your life is a roller coast, this smoothes the ride. Want to buy the CE credits only? The authors back up their findings about meditation's ability to ease pain, lower blood pressure and slow heart rate with medical research. Jun 16, Kim rated it it was ok Shelves: health , non-fiction , personal-growth. For those of you who have read or listened to such talks before, there is likely nothing new here. Can anybody do it? Radical Alignment. I learned a lot from this in terms of the scientific benefits behind meditation, and for that I found this book to be eye-opening. I always appreciate Dr. If you are looking for an in-depth discussion on how meditation creates optimum health or for many formal practices, this audiobook is not for you. The large percentage of the book is dedicated to why meditation is good for you, followed by about less than 5 minutes worth of material on the mechanics of meditation, followed by an ending that reiterates why meditation is good for you.
    [Show full text]
  • Balanced Living Annual 2010
    Dr. Weil’s 2010 Annual Balanced Living Edition Your Guide to Living Life Fully HEALTHY EATING 12 Delicious, Nutritious Recipes Foods for Health Concerns The Anti-Infl ammatory Diet 6 Steps to Prevent Alzheimer’s Disease America’s Best-Known Doctor on Getting Better Sleep Boosting Your Mood Women’s & Men’s Health The Importance of Omega-3s 4 WAYS TO BOOST YOUR ENERGY Dr. Weil’s Balanced Living 2010 Annual Edition Dear Reader, I’m delighted to welcome you to this 2010 Annual Edition of Balanced Living, in which you’ll find 12 information-packed issues of my exclusive monthly newsletter. Balanced Living explores healthy living from the perspective of integrative medicine, a healing-oriented medical philosophy that encompasses the whole person: body, mind and spirit. The articles here cover the best, evidence-based therapies from both conventional and alternative practitioners. My aim is simple: to help you achieve and maintain optimum health. Within this issue we’ll examine energy and supplements that boost it without the “crash” that inevitably follows shortcuts such as sugar and caffeine. We’ll explore memory, focusing on safe, healthy ways to limit inappropriate infl ammation in the brain, which is believed to underlie many forms of memory loss. We’ll look at vision and ways to protect it from threats like macular degeneration - an irreversible eye disorder affecting the central part of the retina. And we’ll take on the modern epidemic of depression, focusing on gentle, natural therapies that may be even more effective - and almost certainly safer - than the pharmaceuticals that are all too often prescribed for the condition.
    [Show full text]
  • Dr. Arbaje Is an Internist, Geriatric Medicine Specialist, and Health Services Researcher at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine
    1 Dr. Arbaje is an internist, geriatric medicine specialist, and health services researcher at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine. She is Assistant Professor of Medicine and Director of Transitional Care Research at the Center on Aging and Health. Dr. Arbaje is interested in the problems older adults face as they navigate through the healthcare system. She is leading several studies that aim to develop performance measures, define best practices, and ultimately improve the quality of care of older adults as they leave the hospital. The focus of her research has been on identifying patient populations at risk of experiencing suboptimal care transitions, identifying care processes and hospital characteristics related to readmissions, and developing clinical interventions to improve care transitions and reduce hospital readmissions. She is currently investigating risks to older adults’ safety as they receive skilled home healthcare services after hospital discharge. In addition to her research experience, Dr. Arbaje has consultative experience in working to improve care of older adults. She has served as an invited consultant to the American Geriatrics Society, the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, and the National Institutes of Health. In addition to addressing scientific audiences, Dr. Arbaje has developed media content directly for the public. She has been a health commentator at local, national, and international media outlets, including NBC Nightly News and CNN International, to draw attention to issues facing older adults (available at www.youtube.com/aarbaje). Dr. Arbaje received her undergraduate degree from the University of Kansas. She graduated from Yale School of Medicine and earned her master’s degree in public health at the Harvard School of Public Health.
    [Show full text]
  • FCER Director of Research Testifies at National Institute of Medicine Hearings
    Reprinted from FCER Advance, Spring/Summer 2003 FCER Director of Research Testifies at National Institute Of Medicine Hearings EDITOR’S NOTE: Anthony Rosner, Ph.D., Director of Research and Education for The Foundation for Chiropractic Education and Research, presented testimony on behalf of chiropractic research and practice standards at hearings conducted at the Institute of Medicine (IOM) headquarters in Washington, D.C., on February 27, 2003. The occasion marked the first of six meetings of a study committee planned by the IOM over the next 18 months to explore the scientific and policy implications of the use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) therapies by the American public. The objectives of the study committee are as follows: 1. To describe the use of CAM therapies by the American public, including the populations that use them and what is known about how they are provided; 2. To identify major scientific and policy issues related to CAM research (including gender effects), regulation, interactions with conventional medicine, and training and certification; and 3. To develop conceptual frameworks for guiding decision-making on these issues and questions. The Institute of Medicine is a private, non-governmental organization that initiates studies in areas of medical care out of appropriations made available to federal agencies. It is a branch of the National Academy of Sciences, which was created by the federal government to be an advisor on scientific and technological matters. Following is Dr. Rosner’s presentation to the Institute of Medicine. Copyright ©2003 The Foundation for Chiropractic Education and Research 1 FCER Director of Research Testifies at National Institute of Medicine Hearings Institute Of Medicine: The Use of CAM by the American Public Committee Testimony for Meeting The National Academies, 500 Fifth Street NW, Washington, DC February 27, 2003 Anthony L.
    [Show full text]
  • Professional Resume
    Atlanta, GA Daniel C. (Dan) Rutz, MPH Introduction Dan Rutz joined CDC in the wake of the 2001 terrorist and bio-terrorist attacks on the United States. He was recruited to improve public health communication around emergency and other acute events, and began a second career following 18 years as CNN on-air Medical and Senior Medical Correspondent. At CDC, he moved rapidly into risk communication; strategic public health communication; media training; peer mentoring; behavior change; and academics. In recent years he developed comprehensive demand creation approaches for acceptance of voluntary medical male circumcision (VMMC) as an HIV prevention measure in high-prevalence countries across eastern and southern Africa. He continues these pursuits as an independent agent following his Experience December, 2016 retirement from CDC. 2017 – Dan Rutz, LLC, Marietta, GA • Communication Strategist in behavior change for VMMC and other public health demand creation priorities; partner recruitment and empowerment; optimized clinical services; media engagement; peer recruitment; public health emergency and crisis communication; reputation management; issues resolution • Trainer, Facilitator, Counselor in risk communication practice, domestic violence prevention, responsible, healthy masculinity, news media engagement and management, journalism training, public health communication practice • Academic Instructor, with capacity to plan, and conduct graduate level instruction in classroom, remote (Internet based) and combination formats, both full
    [Show full text]
  • Confidentiality and Disclosure of the Forensic Examination
    Legal Digest Confidentiality and Disclosure privileged under the Mental Health and Develop- mental Disabilities Confidentiality Act (Confiden- of the Forensic Examination tially Act) and was not discoverable in the Weil John K. Northrop, MD, PhD daughter custody proceedings; in 2006 the circuit Fellow in Forensic Psychiatry court ruled in her favor. Robert L. Sadoff, MD In 2007 Ms. Johnston and her parents sued Mr. Clinical Professor of Forensic Psychiatry and Director McCann, his attorneys, the McCann son’s represen- Forensic Psychiatry Fellowship Program tative, Mr. Weil, his attorneys, and the Weil daugh- Department of Psychiatry ter’s representative for damages for disclosing confi- Perelman School of Medicine dential information. Dr. Amabile was not named as a University of Pennsylvania defendant. The defendants filed motions for dis- Philadelphia, PA missal of the complaint as a matter of law. They argued that the contents of Dr. Amabile’s report were A Court-Ordered Forensic Examination in a Child Custody Proceeding Is Not Privileged not privileged under the Confidentiality Act. The Mental Health Information and Is circuit court denied their motion to dismiss and the Discoverable in Subsequent Custody defendants appealed. The appellate court allowed the Proceedings appeal and agreed that the information obtained by In Johnston v. Weil, 946 N.E.2d 329 (Ill. 2011), Dr. Amabile for the § 604(b) report was not confi- the Supreme Court of Illinois held that evaluations, dential and privileged under the Confidentiality Act. communications, reports, and information obtained The plaintiffs then appealed this decision to the Illi- for an independent evaluation to determine custody nois Supreme Court.
    [Show full text]