PROJECT EVALUATION Belize Community-initiated Agriculture and Resource Management Project Completion Evaluation July 2008 Via Paolo di Dono 44 - 00142 Rome, Italy Tel: +39 06 54592048 - Fax: +39 06 54593048 E-mail:
[email protected] Web: www.ifad.org/evaluation Document of the International Fund for Agricultural Development Belize Community-initiated Agriculture and Resource Management Project Completion Evaluation July 2008 Report No. 1965-BZ EVALUATION TEAM Overall Responsibility Mr Luciano Lavizzari, Director, Office of Evaluation Lead Evaluator Ms Chiara Grimaldi, Associate Professional Officer Administrative Support Ms Melba E. Alvarez Ms Laura Stella Consultants: Team Leader Ms Dorothy Lucks Team Members Mr Jacques Drielsma Technical and Marketing Specialist Mr Raike Quinones Rural Finance Specialist Ms Myra Speelmans Community Development and Gender Specialist Photo on cover page: Otoxha Traditional Mayan Deer Dancers Source: Evaluation Mission 2007 Belize Community-initiated Agriculture and Resource Management Project Loan No. 475-BZ Completion Evaluation Table of Contents Currency Unit and Exchange Rate iii Weights and Measures iii Abbreviations and Acronyms iii Map v Foreword vii Executive Summary ix Agreement at Completion Point xxi I. INTRODUCTION 1 A. Country Background 1 B. The Project 4 C. The Evaluation 6 II. PROJECT PERFORMANCE 7 A. Design Features 7 B. Implementation and Outputs 10 C. Attaining Project Objectives 23 D. Assessment: Relevance, Effectiveness and Efficiency 25 E. Performance of Partners 26 III. PROJECT IMPACT 29 A. Poverty Reduction Impact 29 B. Sustainability and Ownership 31 C. Innovation, Replicability and Scaling-up 32 IV. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS 33 A. Overall Assessment and Conclusions 33 B. Recommendations 36 APPENDICES 1. Logical Frameworks 39 2.