International Students
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
2003 ___________________________________________ Parliament of Tasmania ___________________________________________ LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL SELECT COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS Members of the Committee Mr Tony Fletcher Ms Lin Thorp Mr Jim Wilkinson (Chair) Mr Don Wing Secretary: Mr David Pearce Legislative Council Select Committee on International Students 2 Table of Contents Executive Summary.............................................................. 3 Summary of Recommendations ........................................... 7 Introduction .......................................................................... 11 Part 1 – The Potential .......................................................... 14 Part 2 – Role of Government ............................................... 23 Part 3 – The Impediments ................................................... 41 Part 4 – Marketing and Recruitment .................................... 51 Part 5 – Pastoral Care and Assistance................................ 79 Part 6 – Offshore Activity ..................................................... 92 Part 7 – Primary Economic Driver ...................................... 111 Part 8 – Additional Matters ................................................. 113 Glossary of Terms .............................................................. 120 Attachment 1 – List of Witnesses ....................................... 122 Attachment 2 – List of Submissions.................................... 125 Attachment 3 – List of Documents...................................... 128 Attachment 4 – Minutes of Proceedings............................. 130 Legislative Council Select Committee on International Students 3 Executive Summary Australia is a major provider of international education and training services, and continues to perform strongly against its major competitors, the United States, United Kingdom, Canada and New Zealand. From a national perspective the value of Australian education exports continues to grow. This is in contrast to many other export industries which have faced difficulties brought about by drought, global uncertainty and variations in currency exchange rates. During the 2002 calendar year Australian education exports were worth approximately $4.2 billion, a 2 percent increase on 2001. Education services remains Australia’s third largest exporter in the services sector behind tourism and transportation services. As stated by the International Development Program Education Australia (IDP) Chief Executive, Ms Lindy Hyam earlier this year in a media release – “It is important to remember that Australia’s international education industry contributes much more to this country than simply a financial return. The thousands of international students who choose to study in Australia each year bring immeasurable social, cultural, business, political and diplomatic links and benefits, and help secure Australia’s position around the world, and in particular in this region.”1 The year 2001 final international student numbers published by Australian Education International (AEI) indicate that there were 233,408 international student enrolments with Australian education providers. There has also been a strengthening in the area of offshore higher education enrolments, which numbered nearly 43,000 in 2001. In terms of the performance of other states and territories, in 2001 New South Wales hosted the largest number of onshore international student enrolments with 74,329, followed by Victoria with 48,248 and Queensland with 33,990. These three states increased their share of total onshore overseas student enrolments from eighty-two per cent in 2000 to eighty-three per cent in 2001. Of the total onshore enrolments for the three abovementioned states, forty-two per cent were enrolments in the higher education sector. It seems to the Committee that the higher education institutions with large international student populations can rely far less on marketing and more on reputation alone to attract students. It is against this national backdrop that Tasmania must compete in terms of offering a range of education and associated support services to international students. The benefits of international students studying in Tasmania are 1 IDP Media Release, 28 March 2003 Legislative Council Select Committee on International Students 4 significant. There are benefits from direct spending on tuition, accommodation and other consumption expenditure, estimated to be $20,000 annually for each full-time equivalent student. Whilst not supported by statistics there is anecdotal evidence which suggests that international students here in the State generate a flow of visitors-family and friends, who in turn purchase local goods and services. Benefits are also gained from the formation of international links, together with the exposure of Tasmanians to different cultures, at both the institutional and community levels. It is clear also that greater access to educational opportunities for local students has occurred as a result of the international student enrolment. Various programs and courses offered at all levels are, in many cases, developed and further enhanced. Whilst the number of international students has grown in recent years, Tasmania’s share still remains relatively small. There is no doubt that potential does exist for further and continued growth, although a number of challenges are faced. Tasmania must build upon efforts to date. The profile of Tasmania as an education destination of quality must be raised internationally. Growth in student numbers must be commensurate with the adequate provision of resources and infrastructure necessary to support increased numbers. There are strengths and weaknesses in what our State and education system has to offer. This combined with visa processes and the competition from the higher profile mainland city providers creates a great challenge. Growth may well be incremental in nature. This however, may also be desirable. The larger education providers have become market orientated, customer focused and entrepreneurial in their activities. As a consequence of this type of orientation full-fee paying international students are being attracted to Tasmania. Tasmanian onshore and offshore enrolments as published by AEI were 2,142 in 2001. 1,839 students were enrolled onshore and 303 were enrolled in offshore higher education courses. Tasmania had just under one per cent of all overseas students resident in Australia. Approximately half of the onshore enrolments are in the higher education sector. The Vocational Education and Training (VET) numbers and school numbers have remained relatively steady during the 2000 and 2001 years. The number of English Language Intensive Course of Study (ELICOS) students increased over the same period. In fact ELICOS enrolments in Tasmania increased from 401 to 536 enrolments. The higher education sector in Tasmania, based on 2001 final student numbers, has about a fifty per cent share of the market. The ELICOS sector has a twenty-nine per cent share. The remaining market share is split between the VET and School sectors. Schools account for fifteen per cent with the VET sector holding the remaining six per cent of the international onshore student market. The Committee is of the view that onshore international student numbers can be grown. With the marketing effort becoming increasingly focussed through cooperative arrangements and formal partnership agreements, desired outcomes can be pursued in a strategic way. The Committee cautions against Legislative Council Select Committee on International Students 5 increasing student numbers without the appropriate infrastructure, particularly accommodation, and other support structures and facilities. Clearly there is some capacity in certain areas to immediately increase numbers. However, to double existing numbers, for example, will require a considerably greater level of resources, improved support arrangements and a significant investment in infrastructure. It is the opinion of the Committee that if the number of international students coming to Tasmania is to increase in a significant way then Tasmania’s best interests are served by greater levels of coordination and cooperation. The level of expertise in the field of international education needs to be shared and further developed across all providers. A vision for the future at the broadest level is required. The Committee’s view is that an industry Forum be the vehicle to establish the objectives and consider how best Tasmania can work toward meeting them. The development of a strategy for the future would need to involve all international education providers and include the widest possible range of Tasmania’s sector representatives. It is the Committee’s view that to achieve increased success in the delivery of education to international students, both onshore and offshore, involves the consideration of a range of matters in developing appropriate strategies for the future. In the Committee’s opinion these matters include: ♦ the development of adequate levels and appropriate standards of accommodation to meet the future requirements of students; ♦ the future coordinated and innovative marketing of Tasmania as a destination to obtain quality education and instruction and experience a quality lifestyle opportunity; ♦ the provision of a wide range of coordinated support services for students, particularly services to assist students during the initial settling-in period; ♦ the establishment