DOCSLIB.ORG

SOLITARY a Case for Abolition West Coast Prison Justice Society SOLITARY: a CASE for ABOLITION

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
SOLITARY a Case for Abolition West Coast Prison Justice Society SOLITARY: a CASE for ABOLITION WEST COAST PRISON JUSTICE SOCIETY SOLITARY a case for abolition West Coast Prison Justice Society SOLITARY: A CASE FOR ABOLITION November 2016 Dedicated to Chris Roy. Acknowledgements This report was produced by the West Coast Prison Justice Society/Prisoners’ Legal Services with funding from the Law Foundation of British Columbia. The West Coast Prison Justice Society operates Prisoners’ Legal Services, a legal aid clinic for federal and provincial prisoners in British Columbia. This report was written by staff at Prisoners’ Legal Services and was developed with input from our clients. We thank our clients for sharing their experiences with us in support of this report and we hope that in doing so, they may help others to avoid their suffering from being placed in solitary confinement. We also thank Professor Michael Jackson for his invaluable contribution to this report. CONTENTS Executive summary ......................................................................................................................................... 4 Introduction .................................................................................................................................................... 6 Deinstitutionalization .................................................................................................................................... 10 The origins of solitary confinement ................................................................................................................ 11 Solitary confinement in the federal system .................................................................................................... 13 The history of solitary confinement in Canada ...................................................................................................... 13 The Corrections and Conditional Release Act.........................................................................................................15 . The Arbour Report ................................................................................................................................................. 15 The Task Force on Administrative Segregation ....................................................................................................... 17 A Work in Progress report ...................................................................................................................................... 18 The death of Ashley Smith ..................................................................................................................................... 18 The death of Edward Snowshoe ............................................................................................................................. 19 The death of Christopher Roy ................................................................................................................................ 20 The Correctional Investigator’s 2014-2015 Annual Report .................................................................................... 20 The Correctional Service of Canada’s current scheme ........................................................................................... 22 Alternatives to solitary confinement attempted in the federal system .................................................................. 23 Federal prisoner accounts ...................................................................................................................................... 27 Solitary confinement within British Columbia Corrections ............................................................................. 41 The history of solitary confinement in BC prisons .................................................................................................. 41 BC Corrections’ current scheme ............................................................................................................................. 42 Alternatives to solitary confinement attempted within BC Corrections ................................................................. 46 Provincial prisoner accounts .................................................................................................................................. 46 The consequences of solitary confinement .................................................................................................... 54 Mental and physical health effects ........................................................................................................................ 54 The safety and security justification for solitary confinement ............................................................................... 56 Fiscal cost implications ........................................................................................................................................... 57 Canada’s obligation under international law .................................................................................................. 59 Lessons learned from other jurisdictions and contexts ................................................................................... 62 United States .......................................................................................................................................................... 62 United Kingdom ..................................................................................................................................................... 67 Forensic psychiatry – seclusion rooms ................................................................................................................... 69 Legislative and policy transformation needed to abolish the use of solitary confinement .............................. 71 Reducing the number of prisoners in custody and in high security ....................................................................... 73 Procedural fairness and oversight .......................................................................................................................... 75 Prisoners with mental health concerns .................................................................................................................. 78 Mental health support ........................................................................................................................................... 80 Staffing ................................................................................................................................................................... 83 Increased use of dynamic security ......................................................................................................................... 84 Mediation and short-term cell lock-up ................................................................................................................... 85 Work, programs and education .............................................................................................................................. 86 Voluntary segregation ............................................................................................................................................ 86 Trauma-informed corrections ................................................................................................................................ 87 The role of medical professionals in prisons .......................................................................................................... 89 Solitary confinement of youth ....................................................................................................................... 94 Recommendations .......................................................................................................................................... 96 Endnotes ..................................................................................................................................................... 101 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY “[Solitary confinement is]…the most individually destructive, psychologically crippling and socially alienating experience that could conceivably exist with the borders of a country.” Michael Jackson, Q.C. vidence shows that solitary confinement both human and financial, its efficacy and its makes prisoners with existing mental compliance with domestic and international law. disabilities worse, and can cause severe E Although the Correctional Service of Canada psychological symptoms, including self-harm and suicide, in prisoners without existing mental and BC Corrections have taken some measures disabilities.1 Its use on prisoners with mental to limit the use of solitary confinement over the disabilities is considered cruel treatment by years, our clients continue to be held in long- the United Nations, and its use on prisoners term isolation and continue to report disturbing without pre-existing mental disabilities is examples of staff misconduct and conditions considered torture or cruel treatment after only of confinement that violate basic standards of 15 days.2 Solitary confinement does nothing to human dignity. In our view, any scheme that rehabilitate prisoners – in fact, it makes their continues to allow for the solitary confinement successful reintegration back to society more of prisoners for any amount of time would difficult. allow such abuses to continue. Inherent in a scheme that would allow for the isolation of Prisoners’ Legal Services calls for the people without daily meaningful human contact abolishment
Load more

Recommended publications
  • R I T S H O S T a G
    CPO FAMILY Spring 2016 A Publication of The CPO Foundation Vol. 26, No. 1 The former ALCATRAZ FEDERAL PENITENTIARY, now a U.S. National Park Service property, experienced the so-called “Battle of Alcatraz” in May of 1946. This violent incident is one of many escape attempts, riots H and/or sieges that have taken place in prisons or jails nationally -- and internationally -- over the past nine decades. Some of these riots involved the taking of hostages, several with tragic outcomes. See our Cover Story R I O T S starting on page 4. S T A G E S In other places: • Pulau Senang Island, Singapore, July 12, 1963 • Kingston Penitentiary, Canada, April 14-18, 1971 • Fremantle Prison, Australia, January 4, 1988 • Davao Metrodiscom Prison, Philippines, August 13-15, 1989 • Chiang Mai Prison, Thailand, April 30, 2010 • Igoumenitsa Prison, Greece, May 1, 2010 • Uribana Prison, Venezuela, January 25, 2013 1 Field Representatives Jennifer Donaldson Davis Alabama Representative CPO FAMILY Carolyn Kelley Alabama Representative The Correctional Peace Officers Foundation Ned Entwisle Alaska Representative 1346 N. Market Blvd. • Sacramento, CA 95834 Liz Shaffer-Smith Arizona Representative P. O. Box 348390 • Sacramento, CA 95834-8390 Annie Norman Arkansas Representative 916.928.0061 • 800.800.CPOF Connie Summers California Representative cpof.org Charlie Bennett California Representative Guy Edmonds Colorado Representative Directors of The CPO Foundation Kim Blakley Federal Representative Federal Representative Glenn Mueller Chairman/National Director
    [Show full text]
  • 2017 North American Prison Ministry Annual Report
    Order of Malta North American Prison Ministry Apostolate Board 2017 Mike McGarry, KM Vice Chair Collins Whitfield, KM Vice Chair Robert J. Fredericks, Ph.D., GCMOb Chair Emeritus Eileen Bitten, DM-Western Association Roman Ciecwierz, KMOb-Canadian Association Steve Caron, KM-American Association Joe Feitelberg, KMOb-American Association Marion Glennon, DM-American Association Aleksander Johnston, Aux-Federal Association Patrick Portelli, KM-Canadian Association John Santa, KM-American Association Andy Vissicchio, KMOb-American Association Nick Yanicelli, KM-American Association Chaplain, Fr. George Williams, S.J., ChM-American Association 1 Page 2 PRISON MINISTRY Report of Activities—2017 OVERVIEW The North American Prison Ministry Apostolate (“Apostolate”) consists of the leadership of the three United States and Canadian Associations of the Order of Malta. The Apostolate was formed in direct response to the request of the Grand Master of the Order of Malta. Collectively, the work the Apostolate oversees consists of the following; Participants- We have about 1500 Knights, Dames, Auxiliary and Friends devoted to this ministry. We have also affiliated with over 1000 Parish Volunteers to help carry out our work and theirs. Collectively, we believe we are the largest Catholic presence in prison ministry. Locations-We reach inmates in every State, six Canadian Provinces and 38 countries in the Western Hemisphere in some aspect of our ministry. Lists of jails/prisons where we have a presence either by virtue of visits, distribution of religious materials including our Quarterly publication, The Serving Brother or writing to an inmate in one of these facilities, are attached. Meetings-The Apostolate meets semi-annually; this year in Newark, New Jersey and San Quentin Prison, California Religious Materials-We distribute over 12,000 Malta English and 6,000 Malta Spanish bibles and a like number of Malta English and Spanish prayer books and prayer cards.
    [Show full text]
  • Prison Escapes 2
    PRISON ESCAPES 2 17th century • In 1621 Dutch author Hugo Grotius escaped from Loevestein where he was held captive by hiding himself inside a book coffin. He was then smuggled outside. 18th century • Jack Sheppard took to theft and burglary in 1723, and was arrested and imprisoned five times in 1724 but escaped four times, making him a notorious public figure and wildly popular with the poorer classes. • The Italian author and adventurer Giacomo Casanova escaped from prison in 1757. 19th century • Napoleon Bonaparte escaped from his prison on the island Elba in 1815 and returned to Europe in an attempt to restore his Empire. • The notorious outlaw Billy The Kid managed to escape from prison in 1881, but was captured and shot by Pat Garrett only a few months later. 1900-1950 • German Naval Air Service Kapitänleutnant Gunther Plüschow escaped from the Donington Hall prisoner of war camp in 1915. • John Dillinger served time at the Indiana State Penitentiary at Michigan City, until 1933, when he was paroled. Within four months, he was back in jail in Lima, Ohio , but his gang sprang him, killing the jailer, Sheriff Jessie Sarber. Most of the gang was captured again by the end of the year in Tucson, Arizona , due to a fire at the Historic Hotel Congress. Dillinger alone was sent to the Lake County jail in Crown Point, Indiana . He was to face trial for the suspected killing of police officer William O'Malley during a bank shootout in East Chicago, Indiana , some time after his escape from jail. During this time on trial, a famous photograph was taken of Dillinger putting his arm on prosecutor Robert Estill's shoulder when suggested to him by reporters.
    [Show full text]
  • '~O", ~, B" ,0I(1 COMPILED by ______
    If you have issues viewing or accessing this file contact us at NCJRS.gov. c o (~ '~o", ~, b" ,0i(1 COMPILED BY _______..... _____________ _ . " Ti1E AMERICAbJ CORRECTIONAL ASSOCIATION v .~ 0 -----------_---__--_ F,;OUNDED1870 /1 " 4321 HARTWJCK ROAD, SUITE L·208 J COLLEGE PARK, MARYLAND 20740 (301) 864-1070:' o ' (,' o o . " n :;; HE DIRECTORY is presented for general information and guidance. Every Teffort has been made to assure accuracy but the Association cannot assume responsibility beyond the poin t of using the information supplied in response to the questionnaires submitted to departmen ts and institutions. Therefore, ,wherever omissions are noted it is due to the fact that the information was not available or could not be obtained. Occasionally local conditions differ to aiter the meaning of certain terms used. For example, the questionnaire solicited information relative to the type of inmates confined" as follows: "Is your population made up of felons ... mis" demeanants ... others (specify) ...." The intent of the use of the word felons was purely legal to the extent that a felon is ordinarily one convicted of a major crime while a misdemeanant is ordinarily one convicted of a minor crime. This information appears as "Population: .Felons, misdemeanants, etc," The heading "Age limits" indicates the statutory minimum and maximum commitment age limits, as reported through the questionnaire. Figures in parentheses in telephone numbers indicate the Area Code. '. tThis symbol indicates up-dated information was not received. Again we have identified those institutions and agencies which have institutional memberships in the ACA and those facilities conducting work release programs.
    [Show full text]
  • Hard Time Reforming the Penitentiary In
    Hard Time HARD TIME Reforming the Penitentiary in Nineteenth-Century Canada TED McCOY Copyright © 2012 Ted McCoy Published by au Press, Athabasca University 1200, 10011 – 109 Street, Edmonton, AB T5J 3S6 isbn 978-1-926836-96-6 (print) 978-1-926836-97-3 (pdf) 978-1-926836-98-0 (epub) Cover and interior design by Marvin Harder, marvinharder.com. Printed and bound in Canada by Marquis Book Printers. Library and Archives Canada Cataloguing in Publication McCoy, Ted, 1978- Hard time : reforming the penitentiary in nineteenth-century Canada / by Ted McCoy. Includes bibliographical references and index. Issued also in electronic formats. isbn 978-1-926836-96-6 1. Prisons—Canada—History—19th century. 2. Prisoners— Canada—Social conditions—History—19th century. 3. Prison reformers—Canada—History—19th century. 4. Convict labor— Canada—History—19th century. 5. Punishment—Canada—History— 19th century. 6. Criminals—Rehabilitation—Canada—History— 19th century. I. Title. HV9960.C2M34 2012 365'.7097109034 C2012-901606-3 We acknowledge the financial support of the Government of Canada through the Canada Book Fund (cbf) for our publishing activities. Assistance provided by the Government of Alberta, Alberta Multimedia Development Fund. This publication is licensed under a Creative Commons License, Attribution–Noncommercial–No Derivative Works 2.5 Canada: see www.creativecommons.org. The text may be reproduced for non- commercial purposes, provided that credit is given to the original author. To obtain permission for uses beyond those outlined in the Creative
    [Show full text]
  • The Cultural Work of Decommissioned Carceral Sites: Representations
    1 End the Prison The Cultural Work of Decommissioned Carceral Sites: Representations Industrial Complex (EPIC), of Confinement and Punishment at Kingston Penitentiary Closure Is Not Abolition: Perspectives on the Closing Matthew Ferguson, Elizabeth Lay, Justin Piché, Kevin Walby of Kingston Penitentiary (Kingston, 2013), 1. Also see, Justin [Figure 23, p 137] Piché, “Accessing the State of Imprisonment in Canada: On 19 April 2012, the Government of Canada announced Information Barriers and plans to shut down Kingston Penitentiary (KP), a maximum-security Negotiation Strategies,” in prison located in Kingston, Ontario. In operation since 1835, KP was the Brokering Access: Politics, Power, country’s most notorious prison, incarcerating individuals perceived and Freedom of Information in to pose the greatest danger to society before and after Confederation Canada, ed. M. Larsen and K. in 1867. This news shocked many, including the Union of Canadian Walby (Vancouver: UBC Press, 2013), Correctional Officers. Hundreds of workers and members of the public 234–260. protested in front of KP. Many people felt the closure would cripple 2 Carys Mills, the local economy. Workers for KP were upset as plans had yet “Shutdown of Kingston Pen to be made for their relocation. Others, particularly abolitionists, were Clears Path for Alcatraz North,” pleased to see the closure of KP. Although, as noted in a zine by The Globe and Mail, April 22, End the Prison Industrial Complex, this development ”is not a victory 2012, www. theglobeandmail. for abolitionists,“ particularly given that this period ”is a time marked com/news/ politics/shutdown- —1 by massive prison expansion across this stolen land.“ By 30 of-kingston-pen- clears-path-for- September 2013, all prisoners had been transferred to other facilities.
    [Show full text]