DOCSLIB.ORG

Physician, Heal Thyself Can the Lancet’S Moral Medical Malpractice Be Fixed?

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Physician, Heal Thyself Can the Lancet’S Moral Medical Malpractice Be Fixed? VIEWPOINT YITZHAK SANTIS Physician, heal thyself Can The Lancet’s moral medical malpractice be fixed? AFTER THE publica- that he “deeply, deep- tion in The Lancet of ly regret[ted] the a mendacious “Open completely unneces- Letter for the People sary polarization that of Gaza,” Richard publication of the Horton, editor in chief letter by Paola Man- of the prestigious Brit- duca caused,” which ish medical journal, “was definitely not visited Israel where my intention.” What he was hosted by Hai- does this mean? Is he fa’s Rambam Medical sanctioning the let- Center. ter’s message, regret- The letter, published ting only the “polar- at the height of this ization” it caused? summer’s conflict In any event, the with Hamas, triggered problems at The Lan- a storm in the medical cet run far deeper. In community and in Is- his Rambam address, rael, with its blanket Horton ignored the indictment of Israeli CENTER MEDICAL RAMBAM COURTESY editorials and nu- doctors coupled with The Lancet editor, Prof. Richard Horton, at Haifa’s Rambam Medical Center merous published wholesale allegations articles in the journal of a “ruthless assault” that amount to a gen- and “massacre” carried out by the Israeli army. eral J’accuse against Israel. This body of work is one result of the The Lancet has published unfounded charges against Israel for Lancet-Palestinian Health Alliance formed under his tutelage. In years, but this was the worst. 2013, this Lancet-guided coalition launched a research publication When NGO Monitor uncovered emails from two of the main au- with Medical Aid for Palestinians (MAP), a group cofounded by thors – Dr. Paola Manduca and Dr. Swee Ang – enthusiastically pro- Swee Ang, bringing us full circle to her promotion of David Duke. moting an anti-Semitic video by American neo-Nazi David Duke, In another example of “what goes around comes around,” Man- the controversy expanded. The major media coverage in the UK was duca co-authored two “scientific” papers published in The Lan- significant and Prof. Horton could no longer ignore the criticism. cet alleging that Israel is responsible for the rise in Gazan birth So, when Horton addressed an assembly of hundreds of Israeli doc- defects. Funding for one of these studies came from Interpal, for tors at Rambam in early October, there was much anticipation. Would which Manduca has also raised money. he address the tainted Gaza letter and would he retract it? Would he The US has designated Interpal as a terrorist entity for being “a apologize? Would he commit to a vetting process based on a serious principal charity utilized to hide the flow of money to Hamas.” The and independent peer review mechanism? BBC describes Interpal as “at the heart of a global coalition of 56 In a carefully worded speech, Horton said some of the right things, Islamic charities called the Union for Good, chaired by the spiri- but left more questions than answers. tual leader of the worldwide Muslim Brotherhood Movement, Dr. When addressing the promotion of the David Duke video by two of Yusuf Qaradawi… [who] has said of the Israeli-Palestinian con- the Gaza letter’s authors he spoke well. He was “personally horrified” flict: ‘We must plant the love of death and the love of martyrdom by the video and its “abhorrent” worldview, it “must be condemned in the Islamic nation.’” How “love of death” accords with medicine and I condemn it” and he made that view “very clear directly to those is inexplicable. two individuals.” Horton has but one moral option – to remove the stain these Yet, despite acknowledging its toxic origins, he said nothing about doctors of hate have brought on The Lancet. To do so, he must retracting the letter. Nor did he commit to barring Manduca and Ang apologize, retract their Gaza letter (and all their other articles), from publishing in The Lancet. He was also silent about another of the and decouple The Lancet institutionally from groups associated letter’s authors who has appeared in The Lancet frequently: Dr. Mads with them, like MAP. Anything less would be tantamount to moral Gilbert, who is on record as approving the 9/11 attacks on America. medical malpractice that will blemish The Lancet for decades. Another question remains unanswered. Does Horton view these people as reliable sources on science and medicine? Yitzhak Santis is Chief Programs Officer at the Jerusalem-based More importantly, he did not apologize for the letter. He only said research institute NGO Monitor 8 THE JERUSALEM REPORT NOVEMBER 3, 2014.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Backgrounder on Hamas
    APPENDIX F International Relief Fund for the Afflicted and Needy (Canada) Backgrounder on Hamas Appendix F – Backgrounder on Hamas1 Hamas is a radical Sunni terrorist organization that employs political and violent means to pursue the goal of establishing an Islamic Palestinian state in Israel.2 The origins of the movement lie with the Muslim Brotherhood,3 an Islamist organization founded in Egypt in 1928, and led by early Islamist figures such as Hassan el-Banna and Sayyid Qutb. Starting in 1967 and continuing throughout the 1970’s, the Palestinian branch of the Brotherhood gained popularity amongst the people of Gaza via communal activism, religious preaching and education.4 With the outbreak of the first intifada5 against Israel in 1987, the Palestinian Muslim Brotherhood moved beyond its basis as a social and religious group establishing Hamas as an Islamist alternative to the secular nationalist resistance led by the PLO. Through its Charter, Hamas clearly states its objectives of establishing an Islamic state in all of Palestine. To realize this goal, the organization relies upon the use of violent jihad, the education of the Palestinian population in its Islamist ideology, providing social services, and promoting the liberation of the “Palestinian land” as an individual duty of Muslims everywhere. Objectives, Strategies, and Structure In its Charter, Hamas describes itself as a “distinct Palestinian Movement which owes its loyalty to Allah, derives from Islam its way of life and strives to raise the banner of Allah over every inch
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 7 of Understanding Islamic Charities
    CHAPTER SEVEN HAMAS RESISTANCE AND THE TRANSFORMATION OF PALESTINIAN SOCIETY* HAIM MALKA Introduction For the Islamic movement Hamas, “resistance” is a way of life. It defines the movement, as its name-Islamic Resistance Movement-suggests, and drives its all-encompassing strategy to establish an Islamic Palestine through the transformation of society. Though the term resistance is most commonly associated with terrorism, for Hamas it is a comprehensive concept embracing military, social, and political activity. Resistance is a rejection of the status quo and an alternative paradigm to the secular-nationalist agenda of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) in every sphere of Palestinian life.1 At the core of this strategy is a diverse network of social welfare institutions linked by personal relationships, shared values, and common interests. This network is most advanced in the Gaza Strip, where the Muslim Brotherhood built an independent infrastructure, as opposed to the movement in the West Bank which was closely linked to the Brotherhood’s Jordanian branch. The network of charitable organizations and services, not unique to Hamas, has not only been an important platform for spreading the movement’s version of Islam but has also provided a supportive infrastructure for military operatives to exploit and has been a major factor in the movement’s electoral victories.2 While political action and military operations may be tactics in pursuit of their overall goals, Hamas’ social services are the key to its broader strategy of transforming society. The movement cannot exist without * Haim Malka is deputy director and senior fellow with the Middle East program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS).
    [Show full text]
  • Islamic Relief Charity / Extremism / Terror
    Islamic Relief Charity / Extremism / Terror meforum.org Contents Executive Summary ................................................................................................................ 1 Introduction ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 3 From Birmingham to Cairo �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 4 Origins ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 7 Branches and Officials ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 9 Government Support ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ 17 Terror Finance ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 20 Hate Speech ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 25 Charity, Extremism & Terror ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 29 What Now? �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 32 Executive Summary What is Islamic Relief? Islamic Relief is one of the largest Islamic charities in the world. Founded in 1984, Islamic Relief today maintains
    [Show full text]
  • Inquiry Report Palestinians Relief and Development Fund (Interpal)
    COMPLIANCE Inquiry Report Palestinians Relief and Development Fund (Interpal) Registered Charity Number 1040094 Contents Introduction 2 The Charity 3 Previous Inquiries 4 Source of new concerns 6 Commission Inquiry and issues 7 Timescale and conduct of the Inquiry 8 Findings 11 Issue 1: Whether particular local partners funded by the Charity were promoting the ideology or the activities of terrorist organisation(s) and therefore would be inappropriate partners for the Charity 11 Issue 2: Whether the Charity’s membership of the Union for Good was appropriate 14 Issue 3: Whether one of the trustees, Dr Essam Mustafa, had any links to terrorist organisations or undertook activities which might make him unsuitable to be a trustee of the Charity 20 Issue 4: Whether the trustees were fulfilling their legal duties and responsibilities, in particular by ensuring that the Charity and its assets were protected from any association with terrorist or inappropriate political activities 23 Summary of conclusions 31 Regulatory action taken and actions required of the trustees 34 Impact of Commission intervention 35 Resources applied 36 Issues for the wider sector 36 Annex 1: The impact of terrorism legislation 43 Annex 2: Summary of the Inquiry regarding the Charity published in the 1996 Annual Report of the Charity Commission for England and Wales 46 Annex 3: Statement of the Results of an Inquiry under section 8 of the Charities Act 1993 conducted in 2003 47 Annex 4: Public statements made by the Union for Good and its representatives (see paragraph 79) 49 1 Introduction 1. There are a number of charities providing aid internationally in high risk situations including conflict and post-conflict environments, natural disasters and other complex emergencies.
    [Show full text]
  • Gaza: Helping Death and Unliveable by Children Destruction 2020 Build Their in the Futures Classroom
    2018 EDITION Annual Helping Palestinians in Need Report Gaza: Helping Death and Unliveable by children destruction 2020 build their in the futures classroom Page 7 Page 19 page 27 ‘Faith, Hope & Charity’ is released to mark Interpal’s 25th year in operation. Available now in your local Interpal branch. Look out for our new book in 2019 Interpal has been a ...Interpal reaches the A heroic little charity vital voice in speaking parts of the Palestinian trusted in equal out against the brutal oppression Territories that other charities measure by donors and the inflicted upon Palestinians... don’t seem to be able to and is Palestinians who rely so heavily (and) plays a vital role in the providing the support, equipment, on the humanitarian aid it struggle for justice to which we help that Palestinians need...” provides.” should all be committed.” Peter Bourne, MA, MD Philip Hollobone, MP Yvonne Ridley Contents 3 A message from our Chairman 4 About Interpal 5 Meet our staff 9 Humanitarian Aid: A vital lifeline for families Gaza: Unliveable 13 Meet our beneficiaries 7 The Zero Stock List by 2020 15 17 Medical Aid: Providing life-saving support 23 Palestine Culture 29 Education Aid: Providing access to quality education 31 On the road to inclusion: A day in the life of an Outreach Bus Driver 34 The Tok-Tok Livelihood project 35 Community Development: Being a Helping to build lasting resilience 37 Palestinian ally 41 Interpal in numbers Death and destruction Helping 27 in the classroom children build their futures 19 A message About from our Interpal chairman Interpal is a specialist charity founded in 1994 to provide humanitarian and development aid to Palestinians in need.
    [Show full text]
  • Holy Land Foundation for Relief and Development: Criminalizing Support for Non-Designated Charities
    Blocking Faith, Freezing Charity CHILLING MUSLIM CHARITABLE GIVING in the “WAR ON TERRORISM FINANCING” Blocking Faith, Freezing Charity: Chilling Muslim Charitable Giving in the “War on Terrorism Financing” PUBLISHED: June 2009 FRONT COVER PHOTOGRAPH: Alex Wong/Getty Images Members of a Muslim congregation in Virginia give Zakat donations for the needy before they enter a mosque for a service to mark the conclusion of the holy month of Ramadan, the height of annual Muslim charitable giving. Zakat is one of the core “five pillars” of Islam and a religious obligation for all observant Muslims. BACK COVER PHOTOGRAPHS: LEFT: Brandon Dill/Memphis Commercial Appeal RIGHT: LIFE for Relief and Development THE AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION is the nation’s premier guardian of liberty, working daily in courts, legislatures and communities to defend and preserve the individual rights and freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution, the laws and treaties of the United States. OFFICERS AND DIRECTORS Susan N. Herman, President Anthony D. Romero, Executive Director Richard Zacks, Treasurer ACLU NATIONAL OFFICE 125 Broad Street, 18th Fl. New York, NY 10004-2400 (212) 549-2500 www.aclu.org Contents I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AND INTRODUCTION ................................................................................ 7 a. Introduction .............................................................................................................................7 b. Executive Summary .................................................................................................................9
    [Show full text]
  • Viva Palestina to the Charity Commission, I Have Been Travelling for Many Weeks in North Africa and the Middle East, Europe, and North America
    Galloway 6/1/04 12:56 AM Page 70 70 Viva Palestina To the Charity Commission, I have been travelling for many weeks in North Africa and the Middle East, Europe, and North America. I have returned to a London address I seldom visit to find a blizzard of correspondence from you. Your correspondence, when read together, as I have just done, seems to represent a wildly George Galloway MP disproportionate and inappropriate reaction to our recent delivery of aid to the suffering Palestinians in Gaza, and must raise the question: Why? The peremptory letters from you, and by you I mean the Charity Commission, are full of bluster and threat, issuing absurd deadlines to people it does not seem to occur to you are not even receiving your letters, either because they are working abroad (Ms Razuki and Mr Al-Mukhtar), travelling abroad on high profile political business (myself), or you are writing to them at the wrong address. In my own case, Easter Saturday opened with your, latest, threat to go before a High Court judge in a bid to force me to appear before you. That will not be necessary. I look forward to telling you to your faces what I think of you. Which is this. I have become increasingly concerned about the abuse of your powers displayed in your brazenly obvious political double George Galloway, standards. About your attempts, under the Member of Parliament for guise of regulating British charities, to police Bethnal Green and Bow, the democratic efforts of political activists in dissects the Charity Britain in a way never envisaged by Commission’s obstruction Parliament.
    [Show full text]
  • Anti-Terrorist Financing Guidelines: Voluntary Best Practices for U.S.-Based Charities1
    U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY ANTI-TERRORIST FINANCING GUIDELINES: VOLUNTARY BEST PRACTICES FOR U.S.-BASED CHARITIES1 Table of Contents I. Introduction………………………………………………………………………….2 II. Fundamental Principles of Good Charitable Practice…………………………….3 III. Governance Accountability and Transparency…....................................................4 IV. Financial Accountability and Transparency............................................................6 V. Programmatic Verification……………………………............................................8 VI. Anti-Terrorist Financing Best Practices...................................................................9 1 This document is a revised version of the original Anti-Terrorist Financing Guidelines: Voluntary Best Practices for U.S.-Based Charities released by the U.S. Department of the Treasury in November 2002. This revised version incorporates comments received in response to the issuance of the draft revised Guidelines released for public comment in December 2005. These Guidelines are designed to assist charities that attempt in good faith to protect themselves from terrorist abuse and are not intended to address the problem of organizations that use the cover of charitable work, whether real or perceived, to provide support to terrorist groups or fronts operating on behalf of terrorist groups. Non- adherence to these Guidelines, in and of itself, does not constitute a violation of existing U.S. law. Conversely, adherence to these Guidelines does not excuse any person (individual or entity) from
    [Show full text]
  • Hewitt V Grunwald QBD 21 Dec 2004
    Neutral Citation Number: [2004] EWHC 2959 (QB) Case No: HQ03X03184 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE QUEEN'S BENCH DIVISION Royal Courts of Justice Strand, London, WC2A 2LL Date: 21/12/2004 Before : THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE EADY - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Between : 1. Ibrahim Hewitt Claimants 2. Shahan Izzat Husain 3. Essam Mustafa 4. Ismail Ginwaller 5. Ghassan Faour 6. Rafiq Vindhani 7. Mahfuzh Safiee and 1. Henry Grunwald Defendants 2. Jerry Lewis 3. Eleanor Lind - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Richard Rampton QC and Anthony Julius (Solicitor Advocate) (instructed by Mishcons) for the Defendants Desmond Browne QC and Justin Rushbrooke (instructed by Carter-Ruck) for the Claimants Hearing dates: 25th to 26th October and 3rd December 2004 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Approved Judgment I direct that pursuant to CPR PD 39A para 6.1 no official shorthand note shall be taken of this Judgment and that copies of this version as handed down may be treated as authentic. ............................. THE HON. MR JUSTICE EADY THE HON. MR JUSTICE EADY Hewitt & ors v Grunwald & ors Approved Judgment Mr Justice Eady: Introduction 1. The serious issues raised in this litigation are important to the parties, and indeed more widely. They are also extremely sensitive in political and religious terms. The Claimants, who are trustees of a charity named ‘Interpal’, claim damages and an injunction arising out of the publication of two items on the website of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, of which the Defendants are honorary officers. These postings occurred respectively on 1st and 5th September 2003. 2. The particulars of claim were served on 23rd January 2004 and the defence on 2nd April.
    [Show full text]
  • The Lancet: a History of Exploiting Medicine for Political Warfare Against Israel
    1 Ben-Maimon Blvd. Jerusalem, Israel 92262 Phone: +972-2-566-1020 Fax: +972-77-511-7030 [email protected] www.ngo-monitor.org August 17, 2014 The Lancet: A History of Exploiting Medicine for Political Warfare Against Israel Background The Lancet is a UK-based medical journal. Richard Horton has served as Editor in Chief since 1995. NGO Monitor’s research demonstrates that, under Horton’s editorship, The Lancet has become a platform for intense political propaganda, particularly targeting Israel. It frequently exploits its academic authority and prestige, providing a scientific veneer to politicized NGO claims, stripping away the context. Often, these articles contain egregious factual errors and legal distortions unconnected to medicine and science. Although the editor of a peer-reviewed journal, Horton has written with disdain on the “system of peer review” calling it “biased, unjust, unaccountable, incomplete, easily fixed, often insulting, usually ignorant, occasionally foolish, and frequently wrong.” Hamas-Israel Gaza War 2014 On July 23, 2014, The Lancet published An Open Letter for the People of Gaza, which accused Israel of “war crimes” while ignoring Hamas’s crimes of rocket fire and terror tunnels from Gaza into Israeli territory. The letter, written by Drs. Mads Gilbert (see below), Paola Manduca, and Swee Ang Chai (see below), ends with the statement, “We declare no competing interests.” Yet, all three authors are associated with highly politicized NGOs. One (Manduca) is associated with Interpal, which is designated as a terrorist entity by the United States.1 Manduca also raises money for Interpal. The letter accused Israel of carrying out a propaganda campaign that “justifies the creation of an emergency to masquerade a massacre.” The Lancet allowed its website to be used to collect over 20,000 email signatures to “support the letter,” demonstrating the editorial board’s active role in backing the letter.
    [Show full text]
  • Jewish Chronicle Apologises to Interpal Trustees
    Interpal Trustees receive £50,000 in damages as Jewish Chronicle apologises for libels 27 August 2019 The Jewish Chronicle has published a full apology to the Trustees of Interpal, a UK-registered charity that provides relief and development aid to Palestinians in need, over the newspaper’s publication of false and defamatory allegations in March 2019. The Jewish Chronicle has agreed to pay £50,000 in damages to the Trustees, and has undertaken not to repeat false allegations that the Trustees are linked to terrorism or extremism. The newspaper is also paying the Trustees’ legal costs. The defamation complaint related to an article published by the Jewish Chronicle on 21 March 2019. In 2003, Interpal was listed by the US as a “specially designated global terrorist organisation” for allegedly funding designated group Hamas - an allegation that Interpal and its Trustees have always vehemently denied. Following a formal legal complaint by Carter-Ruck, the Trustees’ solicitors, the Jewish Chronicle has now accepted that neither Interpal, nor its Trustees, have ever been involved with or provided support for terrorist activity of any kind, and has made clear that the US designation is strongly contested by Interpal and its Trustees. To date and despite repeated requests, neither Interpal, its Trustees nor even the Charity Commission have ever been provided by US authorities with any evidence whatsoever to support the US designation. As well as publishing a full apology, the Jewish Chronicle took the unusual but welcome step of offering to publish an article by Ibrahim Hewitt, Chair of the Trustees of Interpal, in which he sets out Interpal’s 25-year history of providing humanitarian aid “to people in desperate need; no more, no less”.
    [Show full text]
  • Muslim Brotherhood in the UK MICHAEL WHINE
    The Advance of the Muslim Brotherhood in the UK MICHAEL WHINE INCE ITS FORMAL ARRIVAL IN THE UK NINE YEARS AGO, the Mus- lim Brotherhood (Ikhwan al Islami—MB) has grown from having no organizational presence to being perhaps the most dynamic influence Swithin the British Muslim population. It has done so by seizing the initiative on issues of concern to Muslims, whereas more moderate activists have dith- ered or failed to act effectively. In 1996, the first representative of the MB in Britain, Kamal el-Helbawy, an Egyptian, was able to say that “there are not many members here, but many Muslims in Britain intellectually support the aims of the Muslim Brotherhood.”1 He added that at that time, the object of the MB in Britain was only to dissemi- nate information on Islam, Islamic issues and movements, and to rectify the distortions and misunderstandings created by “different forces against Islam.” In September 1999, the MB opened a “global information centre” in Lon- don. A press notice published in Muslim News stated that it would “specialize in promoting the perspectives and stances of the Muslim Brotherhood, and [communicate] between Islamic movements and the global mass media.”2 The Arab Expatriates ondon had been named “Londonistan” by the French security services during the 1990s, when they became alarmed and frustrated by the grow- ingL presence of Algerian Islamists who used London as a rear base from which to conduct their terrorist campaign against France. They were mostly, but by no means all, members of the Armed Islamic Group (Groupe Islamique Armeé—GIA).
    [Show full text]