1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27

Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 1 of 117 Page ID #:1379

1 PAULA TRIPP VICTOR (Bar No. 113050) [email protected] 2 ERIC A. SCHNEIDER (Bar No. 94574) [email protected] 3 PETER B. RUSTIN (Bar No. 181734) [email protected] 4 ANDERSON, McPHARLIN & CONNERS LLP 707 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 4000 5 Los Angeles, CA 90017-3623 TELEPHONE: (213) 688-0080  FACSIMILE: (213) 622-7594 6 7 Attorneys for Defendant PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY 8 9 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 10 CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA, WESTERN DIVISION P

L 11 4 L 9 S 5 3 0 7 R 2 0 - HALEY VIDECKIS and LAYANA Case No. 2:15-cv-00298-DDP (JCx) E 6 12 0 2 3 N 4 2 - WHITE, individuals, 6 E 7 N T ) 1 I O 3 0 U 13 NOTICE OF MOTION AND 1 C 0 S 2 , 9 (

Plaintiffs, MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 14 TO &

X A R I S A N

A EXCLUDE TESTIMONY FROM I N

R 14 F V E R L E Y O • L

R vs. PLAINTIFFS’ REBUTTAL F I W U A L 0 A O

H EXPERT DR. ELLIOT D. FELMAN; A 8

L 15 B

0 C P E , 0

C PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY, a MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND R - S I E 8 H M L

S 8 16 corporation doing business in AUTHORITIES; DECLARATION , E L 6 I G N )

N California, OF PAULA TRIPP VICTOR IN W 3 O A

1 S 7

S SUPPORT THEREOF 2 17 0 R ( O

7 E

L Defendant. D E T N 18 (Filed concurrently with [Proposed] A Order) 19 Date: May 15, 2017 20 Time: 10:00 a.m. Crtrm.: 9C 21 Trial Date: May 23, 2017 22 23 24 TO PLAINTIFFS AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD HEREIN: 25 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on May 15, 2017, at 10:00 a.m. in 26 Courtroom 9C located at 350 West 1st Street, Los Angeles, California, Defendant 27 Pepperdine University (“Pepperdine”) will and hereby does move for an order 28 excluding testimony at trial from Plaintiffs’ Rebuttal Expert, Dr. Elliot Felman.

1609848.1 05764-048 PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 14 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 2 of 117 Page ID #:1380

1 EVIDENCE SOUGHT TO BE EXCLUDED: Testimony of rebuttal 2 expert, Dr. Elliot Felman, on the grounds that based on his curriculum vitae, he is 3 not qualified to serve as an expert in this case. 4 GROUNDS FOR MOTION: Pepperdine brings this motion, pursuant to 5 Federal Rules of Evidence 702 because Dr. Felman is not qualified to render an 6 opinion concerning NCAA medical issues. Thus, such testimony should not be 7 admissible at trial. 8 BASIS FOR MOTION: This motion is based on this Notice, the 9 memorandum of points and authorities filed concurrently herein, the entire file and 10 pleadings in this action, the Declaration of Paula Tripp Victor, and any other P

L 11 evidence or argument offered. 4 L 9 S 5 3 0 7 R 2 0 - E 6 12 0 2 3 N 4 2 -

6 E 7 N T ) 1 I O 3 0 U 13 DATED: April 24, 2017 ANDERSON, McPHARLIN & CONNERS LLP 1 C 0 S 2 , 9 (

X A R I S A N A I N

R 14 F V E R L E Y O • L R F I W U A L 0 A O H A 8

L 15 B

0 C P E , 0 C R - S I By: /s/ Paula Tripp Victor E 8 H M L

S 8 16 , E L 6 I G N

) Paula Tripp Victor N W 3 O A

1 S 7 S

2 17

0 Eric A. Schneider R ( O

7 E

L L D E Peter B. Rustin T N 18 A Attorneys for Defendant PEPPERDINE 19 UNIVERSITY 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 1609848.1 05764-048 2 PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 14 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 3 of 117 Page ID #:1381

1 MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES 2 I. INTRODUCTION AND FACTUAL BACKGROUND 3 On April 4, 2017, Pepperdine timely provided its Expert Designations to 4 Plaintiff. See Decl. of Paula Tripp Victor, Exh. 1 (Pepperdine’s Expert 5 Designations). One of Pepperdine’s designated experts is Sourav Poddar, M.D., a 6 primary sports medicine physician employed by the University of Colorado and who 7 serves as Colorado’s team physician for its sports teams. Dr. Poddar will provide 8 testimony concerning whether the Pepperdine athletic training staff and team 9 physician had legitimate, non-discriminatory reasons for the way in which it handled 10 the various issues raised by Plaintiffs in this case, and specifically whether P

L 11 Plaintiffs’ medical records requested by the Pepperdine staff were records needed in 4 L 9 S 5 3 0 7 R 2 0 - E 6 12 order to insure Plaintiffs were safe to play basketball. 0 2 3 N 4 2 -

6 E 7 N T ) 1 I O 3 0 U 13 On April 14, 2017, Plaintiffs served their counter expert designation, listing 1 C 0 S 2 , 9 (

X A R I S A N A

I N two experts. See Decl. of Paula Tripp Victor, Exh. 2 (Plaintiffs’ Counter Expert

R 14 F V E R L E Y O • L R F I W U A L 0 A O H A 8

L 15 Designations). One of these experts, Dr. Elliot Felman, is designated to “offer B

0 C P E , 0 C R - S I E 8 H M L

S 8 16 rebuttal testimony regarding requests for medical information.” His one-page CV, , E L 6 I G N ) N W 3 O A

1 S 7 S

2 17 which is attached to the rebuttal designation, lists his specialty as family medicine. 0 R ( O

7 E

L L D E T N 18 See Declaration of Paula Tripp Victor, Exh. 2. Although the parties agreed to A 19 exchange reports one week in advance of the scheduled expert depositions, Dr. 20 Felman lists no trial or deposition experience, or any publications, on his CV. His 21 CV notes that he is certified with the American Board of Family Physicians, and is 22 affiliated with both the American Academy of Family Physicians and the 23 International Society of Travel Medicine. Nowhere on Dr. Felman’s CV is there 24 any indication that he is competent and qualified to testify in rebuttal to 25 Pepperdine’s expert’s designated testimony. 26 II. APPLICABLE LEGAL STANDARD 27 The Federal Rules of Evidence provide for the testimony of an expert witness 28 who is “qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or 1609848.1 05764-048 3 PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 14 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 4 of 117 Page ID #:1382

1 education.” F.R.E. 702. The witness “may testify in the form of an opinion or 2 otherwise if: (a) the expert's scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge 3 will help the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue; 4 (b) the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data; (c) the testimony is the product 5 of reliable principles and methods; and (d) the expert has reliably applied the 6 principles and methods to the facts of the case.” Fed.R.Evid. 702. 7 Expert testimony that is both relevant and reliable is admissible pursuant to 8 Rule 702. Elsayed Mukhtar v. California State University, Hayward, 299 F.3d 9 1053, 1063 (9th Cir. 2002). Under the Federal Rules, the trial court has the role of 10 gatekeeper to make sure that the dual concerns of reliability and helpfulness are met, P

L 11 and it must exclude testimony that does not meet these goals. Stilwell v. Smith & 4 L 9 S 5 3 0 7 R 2 0 - E 6 12 Nephew, Inc., 482 F.3d 1187, 1992 (9th Cir. 2007). 0 2 3 N 4 2 -

6 E 7 N T ) 1 I O 3 0 U 13 III. ARGUMENT 1 C 0 S 2 , 9 (

X A R I S A N A

I N In this case, there is no indication that Dr. Felman has any relevant experience

R 14 F V E R L E Y O • L R F I W U A L 0 A O H A 8

L 15 in the area of sports medicine. Dr. Felman appears to be a primary care physician, B

0 C P E , 0 C R - S I E 8 H M L

S 8 16 not a specialist in interpreting NCAA medical issues. While Dr. Felman’s , E L 6 I G N ) N W 3 O A

1 S 7 S

2 17 deposition will bear this out, there is a notable void of experience on Dr. Felman’s 0 R ( O

7 E

L L D E T N 18 CV that would permit Dr. Felman to serve as an adequate expert in the area of sports A 19 medicine or the interpretation of NCAA medical issues. 20 Accordingly, Dr. Felman should not be permitted to testify as a rebuttal 21 expert at trial regarding any issues that do not relate to the general practice of family 22 medicine, and specifically, should not be permitted to provide rebuttal testimony 23 regarding the interpretation of NCAA medical issues. See, e.g., Oyarzo v. Tuolumne 24 Fire Dist., 2013 WL 5718882, * 16 (E.D. Cal. Oct. 18, 2013) (precluding expert 25 from testifying in areas in which he did not have experience). Dr. Felman has no 26 qualifications in this regard. 27 /// 28 /// 1609848.1 05764-048 4 PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 14 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 5 of 117 Page ID #:1383

1 IV. CONCLUSION 2 For the reasons discussed above, Pepperdine respectfully requests that the 3 Court exclude the trial testimony of Plaintiff’s rebuttal expert, Dr. Felman. 4 5 DATED: April 24, 2017 ANDERSON, McPHARLIN & CONNERS LLP 6 7 By: /s/ Paula Tripp Victor 8 Paula Tripp Victor 9 Eric A. Schneider Peter B. Rustin 10 Attorneys for Defendant PEPPERDINE P

L 11 UNIVERSITY 4 L 9 S 5 3 0 7 R 2 0 - E 6 12 0 2 3 N 4 2 -

6 E 7 N T ) 1 I O 3 0 U 13 1 C 0 S 2 , 9 (

X A R I S A N A I N

R 14 F V E R L E Y O • L R F I W U A L 0 A O H A 8

L 15 B

0 C P E , 0 C R - S I E 8 H M L

S 8 16 , E L 6 I G N ) N W 3 O A

1 S 7 S

2 17 0 R ( O

7 E

L L D E T N 18 A 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 1609848.1 05764-048 5 PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 14 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 6 of 117 Page ID #:1384

1 DECLARATION OF PAULA TRIPP VICTOR 2 I, Paula Tripp Victor, declare as follows: 3 1. I am an attorney-at-law duly licensed to practice before all courts in the 4 State of California and am a partner with the law firm of Anderson, McPharlin & 5 Conners LLP, attorneys of record for Defendant PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY 6 (“Pepperdine”) in the above-entitled action. I have personal knowledge as to all 7 matters set forth in this Declaration and would competently testify to them under 8 oath if called as a witness. I make this declaration in support of Pepperdine’s 9 Motion in Limine No. 14 to Exclude Testimony From Plaintiffs’ Rebuttal Expert Dr. 10 Elliot D. Felman. P

L 11 2. On April 4, 2017, Pepperdine timely provided its Expert Designations 4 L 9 S 5 3 0 7 R 2 0 - E 6 12 to Plaintiff. A true and correct copy of Pepperdine’s Expert Disclosures is attached 0 2 3 N 4 2 -

6 E 7 N T ) 1 I O 3 0 U 13 hereto as Exhibit 1. 1 C 0 S 2 , 9 (

X A R I S A N A

I N 3. On April 14, 2017, Plaintiffs served their counter expert designation,

R 14 F V E R L E Y O • L R F I W U A L 0 A O H A 8

L 15 listing two experts. A true and correct copy of Plaintiffs’ Counter Expert B

0 C P E , 0 C R - S I E 8 H M L

S 8 16 Designation is attached hereto as Exhibit 2. , E L 6 I G N ) N W 3 O A

1 S 7 S

2 17 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of United States of America 0 R ( O

7 E

L L D E T N 18 that the foregoing is true and correct and that this declaration was executed on A 19 April 24, 2017. 20 21 /s/ Paula Tripp Victor Paula Tripp Victor 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 1609848.1 05764-048 6 PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 14 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 7 of 117 Page ID #:1385

EXHIBIT 1

7 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 8 of 117 Page ID #:1386

1 PAULA TRIPP VICTOR(Bar No. 113050) [email protected] 2 PETER B. RUSTIN (Bar No. 181734) [email protected] 3 ANDERSON, McPHARI.IN & CONNERS LLP 707 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 4000 4 Los Angeles, CA 90017-3623 TELEPHONE:(213) 688-0080 ♦FACSIMILE: (213) 622-7594 5 6 ~ Attorneys for Defendant PEPPERDINE iJNIVERSITY 7 s UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 9 CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA, WESTERN DIVISION 10

a 11 HALEY VIDECI~TS and LAYANA Case No. 2:15-cv-00298-DDP (JCx) a ~ WHITE, individuals, ~ ON E IZ DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE z d ~'? N Plaintiffs, [TNIVERSITY'S DISCLOSURE OF vo 'o~~~"' 13 EXPERT WITNESSES ~ ~ N V.S. ~,°Q~ 14 Trial Date: May 23, 2017 za ~WWIaZ~. ~ ~ J O PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY, a 15 corporation doing business in ~ ~m~o U W o California, ~ ~~ 16 z J Z~W ~ Defendant. ~ n Q m 17 w~ O N N W ^ J 7~ ~ 1g

19 TO THE PLAINTIFFS AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD: ~~i~ Defendant Pepperdine University ("Pepperdine"), pursuant to the terms and 21 provisions of Federal Rules of Civil Procedure ("FRCP"), Rule 26(a)(2), hereby 22 discloses the following retained and non-retained experts whose opinions 23 Pepperdine expects to use at trial: 24 WITNESSES DISCLOSED UNDER FRCP 26(a)(2)(B) 25 1. Jody Shipper, 3507 Foxridge Court, Napa, CA 94558. 26 Ms. Shipper is the co-founder and principal of Project IX. Her expertise is in 27 the field of developing policies and procedures for colleges and universities relating 28 to Title IX and other related federal regulations and for providing training to those

1599656.1 DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE UNNERSITY'S8 DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 9 of 117 Page ID #:1387

11 involved in investigating claims of gender-based discrimination and harassment. 2 Ms. Shipper's cumculum vitae is attached as Exhibit 1. 3 Ms. Shipper is expected to offer opinions in this case regarding whether the 4 conduct of the Pepperdine employees charged with investigating and responding to 5 the claim of harassment and discrimination by the plaintiffs was reasonable. Her 6 opinions and the bases therefor will be included in her written report to be produced 7 at the time agreed upon by counsel in this case. 8 Ms. Shipper charges $275 per hour for providing deposition testimony. 9 2. Mark Levy, M.D.lRonald Roberts, Ph.D., Forensic Psychiatric l0 Associates Medical Corporation, 655 Redwood Highway, Suite 271, Mill Valley, 11 CA 94941. a ~m ~ gN~ 12 Dr. Levy is a Board Certified Psychiatrist whose curriculum vitae is attached ~ m N 0v 'aF ~ ~`" 13 ~ as Exhibit 2. Dr. Roberts is a Board Certified Forensic Psychologist whose ~ p~jN z W ~¢~ 14 curriculum vitae is attached as Exhibit 3. ~ ~~o. ~ ~mQ~ 15 Drs. Levy and Roberts are expected to offer opinions regarding the nature, a W Uo V o ~ =W~ 16 extent and cause of any of the emotional damages being claimed by the plaintiffs in z J W ~ o ~Zm 1 written N N 7 ~ this case. Their opinions and the bases therefor will be included in their

W O O J Q W 18 report to be produced at the time agreed upon by counsel in this case. 19 Dr. Levy and Dr. Roberts charge $700 per hour and $600 per hour, 20 ~~ respectively, for providing deposition testimony. 21 3. Richard J. Mouw,Ph.D., Fuller Theological Seminary, Pasadena, CA. 22 Dr. Mouw is a professor of Christian philosophy and ethics. His curriculum 23 vitae is attached as Exhibit 4. 24 Dr. Mouw is expected to opine on how areligiously-affiliated institution of 25 higher education supports all of its community, including LGBTQ+ students, faculty 26 and staff, in a manner that is consistent with and reflects the religious mission and 27 heritage of that institution. These issues include, but are not limited to, how 28 Pepperdine University, as an independent, private Chrisrian university, can adhere to

1599656.1 DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S9 DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 10 of 117 Page ID #:1388

1 certain Biblical principles while serving, including and supporting with dignity and 2 respect in all manners and aspects students who identify as LGBTQ+ and whether it 3 did so in the time frame relevant to this litigation. 4 Dr. Mouw charges $350 per hour for providing deposition testimony. 5 4. Chris Schoemann, Bond, Schoenecic &King, 7500 College Blvd., Suite 6 910, Overland Park, KS 66210. 7 Mr. Schoemann is a Compliance Consultant in the Collegiate Sports practice s group of Bond Schoenecic &King and has expertise with regard to NCAA 9 compliance issues. Prior to joining the firm in December, 2000, he was a member l0 of the NCAA legislative services staff for five years and then served as the Director

a 11 of Compliance at the University of Minnesota for four years. Mr. Schoemann ~ ~rn ~ ~~ :u oNr r~►a obtained his M.ED. from Springfield College in 1989. z ~F nsmN 13 Mr. Schoemann is expected to testify with regard to whether there were V ~ ~ N 7 NW ;~~.Q Q 14 legitimate and reasonable bases for Pepperdine's handling of various issues ~ ~o. ~ gm Q~ 15 involving the plaintiffs that related to NCAA rules and regulations. These issues a W vo ~ ~ ~i = W~ 16 limited to stipend issues, NCAA year-in-residency waiver, J W ~ include, but may not be O ~ Z m 17 limited to the ~ o~N the purpose and use of NCAA publications including, but not W ~ J J Q w a ~ Igl "Champions of Respect" publication, NCAA mandatory drug testing and banned 19 substances, academic integrity issues and clearance to play issues. Mr. Schoemann 20 is also expected to testify regarding the plaintiffs' alleged damages to the extent that 21 they are impacted by whether the plaintiffs could have been eligible to play 22 basketball and receive a scholarship after they left Pepperdine. Mr. Schoemann's 23 opinions and the bases therefor will be included in his written report to be produced 24 at the time agreed upon by counsel in this case. 25 Mr. Schoemann charges $285 per hour for providing deposition testimony. 26 5. Barbara C. Luna, Senior Partner, White, Zuckerman, Warsayslcy, Luna 27 ~ &Hunt, LLP, 15490 Ventura Blvd Suite 300, Sherman Oaks, CA 91403. 2s / //

1599656.1 DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE LJNNERSITY'S10 DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 11 of 117 Page ID #:1389

1 Dr. Luna is an economist in the accounting and litigation services firm of 2 White, Zuckerman, Warsaysky, Luna &Hunt, LLP. Her resume and list of 3 published articles are attached as Exhibit 5. 4 Dr. Luna is expected to testify regarding the value and cause of the economic 5 damages alleged by the plaintiffs including, but not limited to issues involving 6 educational and living expenses and lost earnings. Dr. Luna's opinions and the 7 bases therefor will be included in her written report to be produced at the time 8 agreed upon by counsel in this case. 9 Dr. Luna charges $495 per hour for deposition testimony. 10 6. Sourav Poddar, M.D., Associate Professor, Family Medicine, 11 University of Colorado, Denver, CO. .aa ~ ~ 0~ N n 12 Dr. Poddar is the Director of Primary Care Sports Medicine and the Team z ~ mN o ~~~ 13 ~ Doctor and Medical Director for the University of Colorado Buffaloes. His V ~no~ p~ N w;~~Q ~a 14 curriculum vitae and list of articles published are attached as Exhibit 6. ~ ~ ~ o . ~ 3mQ~ 15 ~, Dr. Poddar is expected to testify regarding whether there were reasonable and a W Uo0 w o0 16 legitimate reasons for the manner in which the plaintiffs' medical conditions, z J W ~ o ~Z~ 17 Pepperdine were handled and made ~ o~N injuries and decisions while student athletes at w ~ J J Q W 18 by Pepperdine's athletic training staff and team physician. The issues expected to 19 be addressed by Dr. Poddar include, but are not limited to, the need for the medical 20 information and documentation requested by Karissa Schemer and the training staff, 21 the importance of following certain procedures within the athletic training facility, 22 and the decisions regarding clearing or not clearing the plaintiffs for practice and 23 play during their tenure at Pepperdine. Dr. Poddar's opinions and the bases therefor 24 will be included in his written report to be produced at the time agreed upon by 25 counsel in this case. 26 Dr. Poddar charges $900 per hour for deposition testimony. 27 7. M. Dianne Murphy, Ph.D., Senior Partner, The PICTOR Group, 28 Leland, NC.

1599656.1 DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S11 DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 12 of 117 Page ID #:1390

1 ' Dr. Murphy was the Athletic Director at the University of Denver from 1998 2 to 2004 and at Columbia University from 2004-2015. She also coached collegiate 3 women's basketball for 13 years. Her profile is attached as Exhibit 7. 4 Dr. Murphy is expected to testify regarding whether there were reasonable 5 and legitimate reasons for the manner in which the Pepperdine coaching staff and 6I administration handled the situations that arose with the plaintiffs, and specifically 7 the issues as set forth in the Third Amended Complaint and in discovery in this 8 litigation. The issues on which she is expected to offer opinions include, but are not 9 limited to, the coaches' handling of complaints or concerns addressed by the 10 plaintiffs' teammates, including asking players if the plaintiffs were dating, the 11 treatment by and interactions with Pepperdine's athletic training staff, concerns a ~ ~ oN~ 12 raised by the plaintiffs regarding the academic adviser, Layana White's request for a z ~ `~" o ~~~ 13 waiver of the year-in-residency requirement, team disciplinary measures, U °o~ c'n p~ N 14 departure from the Pepperdine women's z ~°s~~ a z ~ Pepperdine's handling of the plaintiffs' ,:~a ~~w W ¢o. 15 basketball team including what effects, if any, that had regarding their scholarships, ~ gm~o V W O = W~ 16 and clearance to play issues. Dr. Murphy is also expected to testify regarding z J ~w `°~ o ~Zm ~n nay women basketball players in the W p J N 17 statistics relating to salaries earned by professional Q w 18 WNBA,the average longevity of those players and whether the plaintiffs possessed 19 the skill and qualities to be successful professional players. 20 Dr. Murphy's opinions and the bases therefor will be included in her written 21 report to be produced at the time agreed upon by counsel in this case. 22 Dr. Murphy charges $400 per hour for deposition testimony. 23 WITNESSES DISCLOSED UNDER FRCP 26(a)(2)(C) 24 1. Brian Barrio 25 Mr. Barrio is expected to offer opinion testimony regarding the reasonable 26 bases for Pepperdine's handling o£ (1} Layana White's request for a waiver of the 27 NCAA year-in-residency requirement;(2) concerns raised by Adi Conlogue that the 2s plaintiffs may have engaged in academic dishonesty;(3) the reporting to the NCAA

1599656.1 DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S12 DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 13 of 117 Page ID #:1391

1 of the fact that a stipend check issued to Haley Videckis was deposited by her twice; 2 and(4) other issues relating to compliance that may become relevant at the trial in 3 this matter (See Brian Barrio's deposition testimony for the general bases for his 4 opinions). Mr. Barrio's opinions are based on his experience as the Director of 5 Compliance for several colleges and universities and his current position as Senior 6 Associate Athletics Director at the University of Nevada, Reno. 71 2. Ryan Weisenberg 8 Mr. Weisenberg is expected to offer opinion testimony regarding the plaintiffs 9 not possessing sufficient skill and qualities to be successful professional basketball to players. His opinions are based on his experience as a coach in the WNBA and for a 11 other professional teams and college teams, and his familiarity with the professional a ~rn 'Nw a NM ~n 12 opportunities available to women collegiate basketball players. ~ ~ N ~ F ~ ~ 13 3. Jordan Smith U `~ ~ ~ N N [ffoQ ZQ ,~ 14 Ms. Smith is expected to offer opinion testimony regarding the plaintiffs not ~ ~~W WIo. 15 possessing sufficient skill and qualities to be successful professional basketball m U o = w~ ~ N O 16 players. Her opinions are based on her experience as a collegiate basketball coach, z N W ~ o ~Q~ professional opportunities W p J N 17 1 as a player in the WNBA and her familiarity with the Q w 18 collegiate basketball players. ¢~ ~ available to women 19 4. Trisha Raniewicz 20 Ms. Raniewicz is expected to offer opinion testimony regarding the plaintiffs 21 not possessing sufficient skill and qualities to be successful professional basketball 22 players. Her opinions are based on her experience as a collegiate basketball coach 23 and her familiarity with the professional opportunities available to women collegiate 24 basketball players. 25 5. Mallorie Winn 26 Ms. Winn is expected to offer opinion testimony regarding the plaintiffs not 27 possessing sufficient skill and qualities to be successful professional basketball 28 players. Her opinions are based on her experience as a collegiate basketball coach

1599656.1 DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE UNNERSIT'Y'S13 DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 14 of 117 Page ID #:1392

1 and her familiarity with the professional opportunities available to women collegiate 2 ~ basketball players. 3 6. Steve Potts 4 Dr. Potts is expected to offer opinion testimony as to the reasonable bases for 5 Pepperdine's handling of: (1) Layana White's request for a waiver of the NCAA 6 year-in-residency requirement;(2) concerns raised by Adi Conlogue that the 7 plaintiffs may have engaged in academic dishonesty;(3) the reporting to the NCAA 8 of the fact that a stipend check issued to Haley Videckis was deposited by her twice; 9 (4)the athletic trainers' request for plaintiffs' medical records and decisions made to regarding clearing plaintiffs for play and practice;(5} concerns raised by the a 11 plaintiffs' teammates' about the plaintiffs;(6) the plaintiffs' departure from the ~ ~rn ~ ~ N n 12 Pepperdine women's basketball team; and (7) other issues relating to collegiate d' M N ~ F~~ 13 thletics administration that may become relevant at the trial in this matter. His V a N p~jN 14 Cr• W~¢~i opinions will be based on his experience as a collegiate athletics administrator. p~ r ~ O 15 7. Karina Herold a J mW ooQ W ~ =Wro 16 Ms. Herold is expected to offer opinion testimony as to the reasonable bases z J w ~ 0 3zMQ W p~N 17 for Pepperdine's handling of: (1)Layana White's request for a waiver of the NCAA Q w 18 year-in-residency requirement;(2) concerns raised by Adi Conlogue that the 19 plaintiffs may have engaged in academic dishonesty;(3) the reporting to the NCAA ~~i~ of the fact that a stipend check issued to Haley Videckis was deposited by her twice; 21 (4)the athletic trainers' request for plaintiffs' medical records and decisions made 22 regarding clearing plaintiffs for play and practice;(5) concerns raised by the 23 plaintiffs' teammates' about the plaintiffs;(6) the plaintiffs' departure from the 24 Pepperdine women's basketball team; and (7) other issues relating to collegiate 25 athletics administration that may become relevant at the trial in this matter. Her 26 opinions will be based on her experience as a collegiate athletics administrator. 27 ///

28 ///

1599656.1 DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE UNNERSITY'S14 DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 15 of 117 Page ID #:1393

1 8. Tabatha Jones Jolivet 2 Dr. Jones Jolivet is expected to offer opinion testimony as to the bases for her 3 conclusions that there was not sufficient evidence to support a finding of 4 harassment, discrimination and retaliation based on sexual orientation, including but 5 not limited to opinions based on her training as a social scientist in oppression 6 theory and other relevant theories. 7 9. Mark Davis 8 Dr. Davis is expected to offer opinion testimony as to how a Christian 9 educational institution such as Pepperdine can adhere to a particular Biblical view of 10 homosexuality and still treat its students who identify as LGBTQ+ with dignity and a 11 respect as well other relevant issues that may arise at trial with regard to handling a ~ u= oN" 12 concerns of college students regarding LGBTQ+ issues. z ~MN o ~~~ 13 10. Kevin Wright U 'o~`~ mQ p~ N c~ z~ W ~~~ 14 Mr. Wright is expected to offer opinion testimony as to the reasonableness of ~ ~~ o. 15 the requests made of the plaintiffs by Karissa Schemer for plaintiffs' medical records ~ gm~o U W o ~ NWT 16 and Ms. Schemer's handling of concerns raised by the plaintiffs in this litigation. z J Z~w ~

tea' oQN cv 17 His opinions are based on his education, training and experience as a certified W n J v ~7 ~ 18 athletic trainer and head athletic trainer, his lrnowledge of what is required and 19 requested by doctors when assessing whether a player should be cleared to play and 20 what the NCAA requires and requests with regard to medications taken by student 21 athletes. 22 11. Karissa Schemer 23 Ms. Schemer is expected to offer opinion testimony as to the reasonableness 24 ~~ of the requests made of the plaintiffs for their medical records and her handling of 25 concerns raised by the plaintiffs in this litigation. Her opinions are based on her 26 education, training and experience as a certified athletic trainer, her knowledge of 27 what is required and requested by doctors when assessing whether a player should

28 ///

1599656.1 DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S15 DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 16 of 117 Page ID #:1394

1 be cleared to play and what the NCAA requires and requests with regard to 2 medications taken by student athletes. 3 12. Gary Green, M.D. 4 Dr. Green is expected to offer opinion testimony regarding whether there 5 were reasonable and legitimate reasons for the manner in which the plaintiffs' 6 medical conditions, injuries and decisions while student athletes at Pepperdine were 7 handled and made by Pepperdine's athleric training staff. The issues expected to be 8 addressed by Dr. Green include, but are not limited to, the need for the medical 9 information and documentation requested by Karissa Schemer and the haining staff, 10 the importance of following certain procedures within the athletic training facility, a 11 and the decisions regarding clearing or not clearing the plaintiffs for practice and a ~ ~ ~Nn 12 play during their tenure at Pepperdine. Dr. Green's opinions are based on his W ~~N F ~ ~ 13 ducation, training and experience as a medical doctor specializing in sports U NQ ~OMN e ~ ~,~Q~W W~~ 14 medicine, his lrnowledge of what is required and requested by doctors when J O IS assessing whether a player should be cleared to play and what the NCAA requires ~ 3mUo U W O ~ Nw~ 16 and requests with regard to medications taken by student athletes. z J Z~w ~ ~ oaN 17 Pepperdine reserves the right, pursuant to FRCP 26 (a)(2)(D)(ii) and (e)(2) w rte" a7,, IW 1$ ~ and all other applicable legal authority, to call further experts and to supplement or 19 amend the reports produced as necessary. 20 21 ~ DATED: Apri14, 2017 ANDERSON, McPHARLIN &CONKERS LLP 22

r 23 ~G~'~~~ 24 BY: ,aC~~v~,?~ I v Paula Tripp Victor 25 Peter B. Rustin Attorneys for Defendant PEPPERDINE 26 Ur]IVERSITY 27'

1599656.1 DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S16 DISCLOSiJRE OF EXPERT WITNESSES Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 17 of 117 Page ID #:1395

EXHIBIT 1

17 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 18 of 117 Page ID #:1396

Jody L. Shipper 3507 Fo~-idge Court Napa, California 94558 (310)696-1124 [email protected]

Relevant Work Experience

Project IX, Napa, CA 2016 -present Co-Founder/Principal

Co-founded "Project IX," anon-profit corporation, focusing on providing comprehensive services for smaller or under-resourced secondary and post-secondary institutions in crafting policies and procedures designed to meet the specific institutional requirements of: Title IX, VAWA,Cleiy Act and SVSH regulations. Develop policies and procedures specific to each institution designed to meet the prevention, response, investigation and adjudication needs of the institution, bringing into balance each institution's unique values, mission and culture. Identify strengths and limitations of current institutional programming, policy and processes, while assisting in the development and creation of compliance plans, programming and policy designed to both meet and exceed regulatory demands and campus community expectations and needs.

Unive~~sity of California, Office ofthe President, Oaklmzd, CA 2015 - 2016 Systemwide Director Title IX/VAWA/Clery/Sexual Violence, Sexual Assault

Ensured compliance with Title IX, VAWA,Clery Act, SVSH policies and procedures, and other related federal regulations. Responsible for directing and facilitiating Title IX, Clery Act and VAWA compliance for the UC and all of its affiliated campuses. Oversaw systemwide compliance reviews and evaluations, conducted active monitoring of campus processes and effectiveness, including on-site reviews to ensure consistent institutional responses. Assisted campuses with implementation of new policies and procedures. Provided advice and guidance to the Office of the President and campuses as needed. Coordinated trainuig and policy implementation trainings. Represented the UC system at national conferences.

U~ziversity ofSouthern California, Los Angeles, CA 2004 — 2015 Executive Director of the Office of Equity and Diversity 'Title IX Coordinator

Served as the university's Title IX Coordinator, Chief Diversity Officer, Section 504 Coordinator, ADA Coordinator. Provided leadership, support and advice on issues of the prevention of, and response to, prohibited discrimination and harassment, including sexual assault. Responsible for ensuring policies were up to date, craft university procedures and design campus-wide trainings related to issues of diversity, sexual harassment, sexual assault, and violence in the workplace. Provided oversight and management of investigations related to sexual harassment, sexual assault, protected class complaints, violence in the workplace, allegations of unfair treatment, and employee grievances. Create and review reports to examuie systemic issues, identify patterns, and work collaboratively with campus partners to craft solutions. • Provided leadership, guidance and support on gender issues; created audit process for campus-wide gender concerns; work closely with multiple constituencies, including faculty leaders, senior administrators, Student Affairs, campus security, key student groups (athletics, Greek community, LGBT Center), mental health providers, to examine objectives and perceptions (internal and external) on gender issues; developed framework to translate those concerns into action plans; revise policy language and procedures to better advance the mission, goals and objectives of the university • Created and designed the first campus-wide program to address issues involving the university's interaction with minors on campus: led series of campus-wide conversations to determine needs and concerns; designed the framework to incorporate campus feedback and translate community conversations into new policies and

18 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 19 of 117 Page ID #:1397

procedures; and, created a series of proactive measures to ensure positive incorporation of sensitive policies that reflect the university's overall mission and goals. Oversaw implementation of campus-wide plan and roll-out of initiatives • Monitored university policies for compliance with the law, including Title IX, Violence Against Women Act, Clery Act; strategize with senior leaders and key campus groups to assure that policies and procedures best represent university commitments and goals relating to diversity, prohibited discrimination, and harassment; lead discussions throughout university community to foster greater understanding of intersection between legal compliance, policies, and university commitments and goals; work with campus administration to craft and set strategic initiatives. • Repositioned and re-shaped office into strategic partner with senior leadership; work closely with senior leaders to shape discussions relating to diversity and equitable treatment of faculty, staff, students, and community partners. • Create training programs to address prevention education efforts, provide nainuig and support to campus constituencies (faculty, staff, campus safety personnel, Campus Security Authorities, students, medical centers). • Created new campus-wide Threat Assessment Team and implemented new tiu~eat assessment training and management procedures. • Oversaw Affirmative Acrion, VETS-100 and employment-related compliance.

Cooper, White &Cooper, LLP, San Francisco, CA 2003 —2004 arzd 1999-2001 Senior Employment Law Associate

Counseled employers, including multiple universities, on all aspects of employment and higher education law including: Title IX, proper procedures for investigating employee complaints, best practices, employment policies, wage and hour regulations, leaves of absence, Americans with Disabiliries Act, workers' compensation, wrongful termination, and compliance with local, state and federal employment laws. Frequently conducted investigations on behalf of clients. Advised employers on cra8ing policies to reflect strategic vision and create strong aligmnent between policies, procedures, and mission statements and goals. Represented employers in all phases of state and federal litigation before state and federal administrative agencies.

YValden Hoarse, Inc., San Francisco, CA 2001— 2003 $50 million dollar non profit clinical and residential addiction treatment agency General Counsel

Oversaw all employment law matters, and executive-level personnel matters. Supervised human resources department. • Advised Board of Directors and executive staff on corporate, employment and labor ]aw, development and implementation of employment policies, risk management, and best business practices • Chief investigator for all claims brought by employees, clients, patients, students, teachers, contracting agencies, government oversight agencies(DFEH, EEOC, California Attorney General) including claims of discrimination, harassment, allegations of inappropriate conduct by treatment providers, and all other claims of misconduct • Represented agency in legal proceedings involving employees, clients or other third parties, including state court and administrative hearings • Prepared and conducted sexual harassment avoidance and employment-law trainings for executives and line staff

LittlerMerldelso~i, San Francisco, CA 1995 —1999 Associate and Summer Associate

Represented employers in all aspects of employment law, including state and federal court and administrative hearings. Successfully argued motions in state and federal trial courts. Argued before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Handled pro bono cases assigned directly by Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

19 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 20 of 117 Page ID #:1398

• Drafted successful brief and served on litigation team for California Supreme Court appeal in matter of Cotraiz v. Rollins Hudig Hall, which set the standard for workplace investigations in California

Recent Presentations, Webinars & Trainings

NACUA YYorkshop, Washington, DC Feb 2012 "Title IX Coordinators: Selection, Responsibilities &Training"

United Educato~~s Webinar Jun 2012 "Conducting Student Sexual Assault Investigarions" Over 750 participants from risk management and general counsel offices at UE member institutions.

ATIXA Annual Title IX Conference, Chicago, IL Jun 2012 "Title IX Compliance Review" "Women Who Lead" luncheon speaker

NACUA Annual Conference, Chicago, IL Jtiuz 2012 "The Role of Attorneys in Threat Assessment'

Uiaive~~sit~~ of Califorr2ia Offtce of the President mzd Stanford University Jatl 2012 Special2-day Training Seminar: advanced interviewing techniques and best practices regarding Title IX investigations and rape and sexual assault cases

NACUA Virtual Semi~aar Jul 2012 "Conducting Campus Sexual Assault Investigations" Oct 2012 Sponsored in connection with American Council on Education(ACE)

Biola University Jacn 2012 Conducted sexual assault training for all faculty and staff Aug 2012

NACUA Virtual Seminar Aug 2013 "Always Be Prepared: The OFCCP Audit and Enforcement Survival Guide"

Washington University, St. Louis Sept. 2013 Conducted University Sexual Assault Investigations Board (USAIB)training

Texas Higher Eda~catio~i Hummi Resoacrces Association Conference Jan 2014 "OFCCP Audit and Enforcement Guidance"

Scl2ool Law and Policy Institute, Stanford, CA Jan 2014 Prevention Strategies and Legal Updates on Sexual Misconduct

NACUA Winter CLE Workshop, Miami, FL Mar 2014 Student Sexual Misconduct Hearings: The (Un)due Burden of Due Process

NACUA Annual Co~zfere~ice, Denver, CD Jiuz 2014 Challenging Title IX Issues? Ask the Experts!

NACUA Annual Conference, Washington, D.C. Jun 201S Annual conference planning committee Moderator

NACUA Winter CLE Worlrshop, Nashville, TN Jan 2016

20 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 21 of 117 Page ID #:1399

Member, planning committee Moderator: The Special Concerns of Domestic Violence Investigations

United Educato~~s Webinar Ma~~, June ared Sept. 2016 Ask a Title IX Expert, Lead Presenter

URMIA A~xnual Conference, Smi Diego, CA Sept 2016 Title IX, VAWA,and Clery: Are you REALLY in Compliance? Lessons Learned and Trends Arising from Claims Brought by Students

United Educators' Title IX Now, Washington, D.C. Nov 2016 Conducted 2-day training for 120 attendees

NACUA Webinar Dec 2016 Ethical Obligations of Lawyers who Work Inside and Outside of the General Counsel's Office

(upcomin~ NACUA An~aual Co~zference June 2017 Member, planning committee

Publication

Shipper, J.. Workplace Investigations: The HR Manager's Step-by-Step Gzcide. Brentwood, California: M. Lee South, 2008.

Additional Professional Experience and Associations

ATIXA, Association of Title IX Administrators 2012 - 2014 Advisory Board Member

Califor~aia Associatio~i of Workplace Investigators (CAOWI, now AWI) 2009 - 2012 Founding board member Past Chair, Certification Committee Member, Best Practices Committee

Lorrnan Educatio~x Services 2001 — 2004 Conducted seminars for attorneys on basic and advanced harassment investigation techniques and best practices.

Education

JD, Hastings College of the Law, San Francisco, CA, 1997 AnTJacr Award, Pre-Trial Practice Dean's Discussion Group Leader, Contracts Managing Editor, Constitutional Law Quarterly Internship, California Supreme Court

BSFS, International Relations, Georgetown University, 1982 Certificate of proficiency, Chinese

Universite de Geneve, Geneva, Switzerland 1981 Smith College, Junior Year Abroad Program

21 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 22 of 117 Page ID #:1400

EXHIBIT 2

22 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 23 of 117 Page ID #:1401

f y `~f` ¢ ~ , 'yft! ~' 'f E 4

L/ ~

655 Redwood Highway Suite 271 Mifl Valley, CA 94941 Te I: 415 -388-8040 Fax: 41 5-834-2400

e~~mail: [email protected] [email protected] url: www.fgamed.com

CUI~rICU~UCYI vl~dE as of August 31, 2015

Education

• 1963-1957 A.B. Columbia College, Columbia University, New Yorl<, NY; • 1967-1971 M.D. College of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia University; 1 977 -1972 Internship Mount Zion Hospital and Medical Center, San Francisco, CA (currently UCS~ -University cif California, San Francisco, School of Medicine); • 1972-1975 Psychiatric Residency Mount Zion Hospital and Medical Center (currently University of Ca4ifornia, San Francisco);

23 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 24 of 117 Page ID #:1402

• 1973-1984 Psychoanalytic Training San Francisco Psychoanalytic Institute (2006 renamed San Francisco Center for Psychoanalysis); • 1998, 2004, 2008 Forensic Psychiatric Board Review Course American Academy of Psvchiatry and Law. • 1999 Forensic Psychiatric Qaard Review Course Tl~e ~sler institute. • Ongoing continuous medical education (CME) courses at University of California San Francisco, School of Medicine, Department of Psychiatry; American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law; American Psychiatric Association; Northern California Psychiatric Society.

Licenses

• 1972 to present Physician and Surgeon State of California since #G226478; 2004 to present State of Hawaii #I3Q59 • 2014 to present State of North Carolina #F201 4-02 35 3 • 1975 to present Drug Enforcement Aciministratian ~I~AL51 50658; • National Provider Identifier: NPI #1 68981 1 739 Drug Enforcement Administration ~FAL51 50658 • 1993 - 1996 (currently inactive) Qualified Medical Examiner ("QME"), State of California, Department of Industrial Relations, Industrial Medical Council.

Malpractice insurance

• Malpractice Insurer -- Medical Insurance Exchange -- MIEC Policy ~`DRQ3-Qd257(

Board Certification

• 1971 to present Diplomate of National board of Medical 2

24 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 25 of 117 Page ID #:1403

Examiners. 1 981 to present Diplomate of the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurologv in Psychiatry Certificate #21909. 1 999 trecertification 2009, Dipfomate of the American Board of PsvchiatrV and Neurology in Forensic Psychiatry, certificate #1088.

25 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 26 of 117 Page ID #:1404

Professional activities

• 1975 to present -Full-time outpatient practice of general R~ forensic psychiatry aa~►d p5ycl7oanalysis, Mill Valley , CA. ; • 1976 to present - Clinical Faculty (Currently Assistant Clinical Professor) University of California, San Francisco, Department ofi Psychiatry, (current teaching: Law 8~ Psychiatry Fellowship). 2008 to present -China America Psychoanalytic /111iance (CPA), clinical treatment and supervision of Chinese mental hezlth prafes5ianals. 1 993 - 2006 Founder, Former President and Chairman of the San Francisco Foundation far Psychoanalysis. • 1986-1X90 Treasurer, San Francisco Psychoanalytic Institute. • 1975 - 1990 -Psychiatric Disability Consultant, State of California Department of Vocational Rehabilitation; 1 975 -present -Psychiatric Disability Consultant, U.S. Social Security Administration, Department of 5ocia[ Services, Disability Evaluation bivi5ion, Sacramento; • 19F~Q to present - Independent Psychiatric Disability Consultant providing Independent Medical (Psychiatric} Examinations ("IME's"} on behalf of individual claimants and insurance companies; • 1998 to present -Forensic Psychiatric Consultant to the United States Department of Justice (Offices of United States Attorney in various jurisdictions; Civil Rights Qivision; Tax Enfo►~cement Division) 2048 to present -faculty member China American Psychoanalytic Alliance - CAPA - {teaching, supervising and treating Chinese mental health professionals in China via SI

26 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 27 of 117 Page ID #:1405

San Francisco.

27 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 28 of 117 Page ID #:1406

• Forensic Psychiatric Consultant to various governmental ayencies including California State Agencies (e.g., California Department of TransE~ortation} • Forensic Psychiatric Consultant to County Counsel from various California counties, including Marin, San Francisco, Kern Counties). • Formerly.on the board of Advisors: Better Legal 8c business Practice for Psychiatrists and Psychotherapists Formerly on Scientific Advisory Qoard, the SapEing Project.

Teaching experience

1 976 to present -Department of Psychiatry, School of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, currently Assistant Clinical Professor (teaching Forensic Psychiatry Fellows). 2Q08 to present -China American Psychoanalytic Alliance (CAPA) providing psychotherapeutic supervision and treafirnent to mental health professionals in china. • 1984 to present -Faculty, San Francisco Center for Psychoanalysis (formerly San Francisco Psychoanalytic Institute renamed in 2006), (taught courses on psychopathology of the neuroses end character pathology to psychoanalytic candidat:es}. 1 990's San Francisco Psychoanalytic Institute Cxtension Division Committee on Law and Psychoanalysis, founding member, produced educational programs for the legal community including with the Bar Association of San Francisco). • 1997, 1999 -Hastings College of Law, University of California, faculty College of Tria{ Advocacy; 1 995 -Hastings College of Law, University ofi California and guest lecturer to "Psychiatry and Law" course taught by Melissa Nell

28 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 29 of 117 Page ID #:1407

Professional Presentations

~~~~ L~ac~~ic~r~ ~c~p~i~

7/2/201 ~i S~yFarth Shaw Assessing Carnplex Litigation Cmotionai C~omr~nitte~ -- Damages National 1"ele Viclea C~lai~ns In Con~erenLe Mass "1'c~rts San Francisco, Cl~

~/25/2(~l 5 UCSF, Farensi~ Case Canf~r~r~~e Psycl7iatn,~ Fellows

ZJ~3/IC}1 fi tJ~S~, Fo~~ensfe Sra~~in~ a Privare 'sychiatry~ Fellows Practice

~/~/~014 U~SF, Forensic Case Canfere~~c~ ['sychia~ry 1=eliows

~f i 9!2014 UCS~, Forensic Stagy°[inch a Pr'sva.te Psychiatry 1=eliows Practice

2/1 1 j2014 International Assn. cif Assessing Defert~e ~c~unsei !Al~C Mass-Tc~i't Psyc:f~a Carlsbad, CA Daniag~s Claims

G/7 0/~Q13 UCSF, forensic Case Con(erer~rce €~sychia~try f=elira~~rs

i 1 /16/101 2 UCSF, Forensic Estai~lishing ~ I3uilc~inq F~SyC~11~311`y (~P~~C3W5 ~`OUi" ~~Vf1 ~4)Y~Yt41C Psychiatric Pr~c:tie~

1/7_G/~Ol Z fimerican Cai~ferei~ce Litigati~~g C~is~bilit~{ In5131'3i1CC~ institute, dew Yot'I<, NY Cf~in~s - Analyzinc~ ~ Interpreting -fhe IME's ~val~~ation ~ ~T-he Treating Coctor's C~~ainic~~~ ate: DisaL~iiity

~i/2~T/201 7 UCS~, Forensic ~stala{ishfa~g 8 B~aildi~~c~ 7

29 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 30 of 117 Page ID #:1408

Ps~/chiatry Fel{Duos Your Uwn Forensic. Psychiatric ~~~ac~ice

2 /i L/2fll 1 i~itchelf, Silbc~rE3erg Assessing n~ienta.l & Knup~ Gisarders in Litigatic~~z

1 1 /13/20I0 I33.Y' ~SSQCIr1YlOtlr San Child Custod;~ & Ctiuc~rce Francisco, F~a~r~ily L.aw Section

Ei/~~/ZQ10 American Conf~rcnce 5ubj~ctive Disore~e~~s Institute, costa€~, MA C){Sc1~Ilfty Cl~li"i'iS: A55@551~tc~ Conditios~s, ~Creatt~e~~t Modalities

6/~/7_~l f1 UCSF, Forensic Estak~lishine~ ~ ~isilc~~~zc~ Psyef~~iatry ~~fl~ws Your C)vun ~arensic Psychia~rir. Practice

1 Q/Z~/~t~t~9 EC~JU (astern china (~ase ~r~sentatior~ ~ E~ISC;U55101"1 Norr~~a{ iJniversity) Shanghai, China

30 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 31 of 117 Page ID #:1409

Ifi/Z7/~009 1~i~ahan Zhangde Nos~i~tal Y~Ihat is Psychoat~alysi~ & ~i+lhat Wuha~i, China is Tr~~nsference?

I O/2ziZ009 f=irst Peop{e.'s Hc>s~ital ~l ra~~~sre~~ence ~inalysis ~i' Are, China

C~J25/Z(}O~J De~~~rttnent c~~ Hamelanc! Cveiything Yn~~ Aivrays l~lant~ci See~~rit~I, IrnmicJratior~ ~~ to I

~/] 5/lC~fJ~ ~rrterican Crs~~f~r~nnc~~ l.it"sg~~ii~y disability lnstiiute (RCI} -Boston; Clair~~s: S~al~jec€:ire ~isof~c~er: MA Provi~~c~ ~ [~is~~rovin~ the institute E(ei~n~nts in a Perioc, ❑f Incr~e~~~c~ Clai~~ns

~j2~3/2009 Seyfarth 5hav~~ LLP ~~Shrinl«" C}n -The ~c~uc_~T: De~asinc~ Ment~il k~iealtl~ Ex~ee-ts

~/30/20Q9 UCSF, Law ~ Psychiatry The Art Qf Testirnr~n~~: hiovv ~e[lows, With Richard to Make Ex~€rt ~`e~~imony Gerry, Esq, Partner, Po~nrerfui, Effective ~ QeEiev~I~ic cif

1 0/'1 ~j2008 C)f#ice ~f lhca 5a~~i Neck Of i~ ~J~l~! Franc;iscc~ City Attot~ney iJi~d

~Jt 3/2Q08 l~n~ericar~ Conference L.itigatinc~ aisGxbiiity Institute - ~r>ston, Mkt ~lai~~5 -f=orensic PsychiattYic Ex~a~rt i~~ Trai Sir~~~~iati~n

6/ i ;?/2{~Ofi /~m~rican Cc~nfer~nce 5ubjeetive L7isoi~ders: Institute - [~oston, MR I~ractical Tips for Utili~i~~g the Medical Facts i» Disai~ility Litigation

Sl14lZOp8 IJCSF, Forensic Estalafishinc~ 8z [3~iilding Psychiztry Fellows Your O~vn For~r~sic Psychiatric Praetice

31 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 32 of 117 Page ID #:1410

1 /~/20Q8 State ~f Califarnia, ~ec~< afi ~ ~a~~ CJFfice €~f TI~Ee Atfo~~ney Understanding ~ ~ss~s~>i~ty ~en~rai, Ua.l:far~d, f~~t Emot:icrial Damages Claims in Em~~loya~~~~t Litigakir~n

1 j8/Z00~ tsar Assaeiariaf~ Gf The Last C~a~~ce: San (=rancisco ~(-c~st:an~entary Ca~~acity c~ lJt~c~ue Influence

1(3/1/Zaf~7 University C)f CaliF€~rnia, -l~oxic Torts forensic. Psychiatry ~eilo~~s Sari Francisco Meclica► Center

3j4/2007 P>ar Asocial"snr7 of Shrinks a~~ the Coy;cl~: San Francisco Depc7sislg iVlent~i Health ~~x~a~rts

f~/7/LOO7 American ~onrerence R~SCfIVll1~ {~lSd~~l{t~~ lr~stitut~~. {~~I) - f€~~~arar~c~~ t~ Cl~.irr~s 1~oston, i~A Litigation

1 1;~/~fl05 i~ellon ?_C105 {ntellcet~sal ~a~ifiai Luncraccan inteliect~ral Capita! Who SEiot the Co-~Vr~rfcers~ L_~in~;her~~~ 5er~ies Przrs'sng !_i~i~ility anc~ Dat~n~~c~es in t}~e Rfter~r~atf7

5/30/~00~ Liar f~ssociatic~n of Un the Essentials for Liti~~~ing San Francisco {'l-SCJ (Past Tra«r~iatic Stress Disorder) ~la'ss~~ (f'awerPaint Slide Shc~vv)

Z/~4/2003 San Francisco General "Sound anti Fury" ;gin F~os~ital DepartEne~~t of Examination of a `Bung ~'sychiatry -Clinical Ian`s C~irst Crealc Case Confe~•enc:e 5ei•ies

4/~6/200Z (3ar ~,ssr~c:iaiion (7f S~r7 Personality aisorclers o~~ Francisco Litig~~tiur~ (Puv~~er4~oi«t Slicf~ She~w)

] 1 /Y 6/L00i association of Defe~lse The 1rn}~ortance cif Per~~~~ality Ce~ui7sel ❑f Northern ~isorciers, Dec~pt:io~~~ 8~ California ~}eposing Psychiatric Ex~er~ts ifs Psychcalc~gieai Injury Cases

32 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 33 of 117 Page ID #:1411

5/17/2001 Litter, Mendelsan Lavv The frn~~arta~nce of ~irtr~ ~'c=.rst3i~ality L~i~n:~ders V~Jhen ~.7€~7g51t1 J ~'SyChldl'CIC ~X[J~i'Y5 !!~ FsychoEc~gical Injury Cases

1 /19/2 01 Cc3nsortiu~r of 7 Public "trauma in the ~/orl€place: I~nti Private /~ge~~cies, ~n All Day Symp~siur~ Medford, Qty

1 l_J4%ZOOQ U~SF ~chvol Ofi~ Medicine, Psychiatric. Disab+liti~~ ~ Qepartmeni Qf f'sy~hi~tsy, the A(~/-~ Forensic Psyehiatr~,~ FelEo~;vs

9/19/~C70Q fZou~~td~~t:~ie C3inncr ~'TS[~: Fc3rensk !'c=_rs~~ective S~~~nsored ~y E~fiz~r, Int:. Discussion

~?/g/2~~C) Los Angeles, C:A Western R~csion~i Cc?n~er~nt~e c~rr I'sycilc>r.~nalysis Presentation e~~ l,+~~a.rd to R~k~in G€~een aid iv1iC

3/x4/2000 ~ssaciati~~n of f~e~et~se Medicine 1 C}Z - Po~i'rrauma~ic Cc~~.~ns~.! of t~lortherr~ Stress aisarder. What ii California Is anc~ Us1~~~t It !s [~~ot

Z/3J1993 Seyfarth Shawn ~'osttra~~imatic dress i~is~rcl~r: San ~~r~~~cisco, CA W1~tal it Is ~~~7d What it {s i~lc~t

1 1 /1 /1 ~3~9 Herbst l"17eater City Arts and Lectures San Frat~ciscn, CA li-~tervie4ti of English Psychoanalyst, lidan~ P~tilli~~

8/1/1999 laastings Scl~r~ol Of La4~r Faculty, I999 college of advocacy

4/4/ 199P QeEancy 5tt~eet Fauric~atir~n ~uc:[:ermar7 Fi1ni/[~5,~. ~;err~inar San Francisca, CA F~nel I~iscus~ian on "~lien'~

33 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 34 of 117 Page ID #:1412

t 2/9/19 77 Animation 5aci~h~ "Ar7alysts C7ri Anirnatic~r~" V~Jsth San I-ranciscc5 ~Naodi~e~w Dailov{~r~, IUD

1 1 %ZO/19~'7 Sa~~ firancisco, C~ l~ef~nse SZesc~~rch Instituts~ Hovv tca cr~oose ~tf~ci lJ^;~ ~~ Psyc~~iatric ~x{pert: Nou+! tc~ Cross-Examine a f'laint:iff's Psychiatric Exert

i 1 /~3/1 997 Sir Francisco Psycl~~aanalytie Annual Leet~.ir~: f rier~r~s of l nstituCe 5FPI San ~rancisca, CA 1~loder~tar: "The ~~iind in thr-. ~Iet - Hut~r~anJCQm~uz~r f~~~d~ICl~t5~11~"

~J5/1 X97 L)efancy Strc~~t Founc4atic~n ZGst:l

1J29/1 ~9~i del Coronacic~ Hc~t~l D~fi~ns~ Research Enstitt~tc~, San Diega, C~ Inc. - 3i}d ~1~~n~.tal I~ati~i~~l VFlornen's ~efen5~ ,~tto~~ney~ 5en~i~~ar, ;~-Clue EX~7Ci"T V'VI~Yi~55: Hove You PreparE= ..Chem ~r~~! They ~'r~pare You - D~fic9nclir~g A E~TSQ Clait~~.

1 0/2 t /t 9~5 San F~~ancisco Syiv~~c~siurr~: Psychoanalytic (nstit«te '~Druc~s anti Psychoanalysis~~ san rr~ncisco, c!~

~% I /i 995 San Franc:isc:U, ~A ir~terna.tic~nal Psycho~~~alytic Associatir~n (1~'1~) '1935 - C:c7n~ress - f~i~ciassic~r~ ~f Ft-~incis fiord Coppr~la's Fi(n~ "~13e Convc~rsatic~n"

4/6/1995 Hastings LaW 5Ch001 west Lec~ure~~ on "PT~C~" San ~Yc1ilClSCOy CA i~lelissa Welkin, Esq,'s ~o~trse

~/~4/l X95 Sang Rosa, C!~ tZedwr~oci Ei'Yl~ll'~ PSYC{14c~~YIC c~ Y1CI Psycholar~ica~ l~ssc~cia~ions "Adventures of a Fc~rerisic Psychiatric Fx~~~~t"

34 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 35 of 117 Page ID #:1413

i 1/1 5I19~3~ San ~ranr_isco, CA Bar Association Of San Francisco - "Amuse In the Home: l ip, Fc~r family Law Attorneys"

5/1 7/7 ~3~4 San F-ranciscca, CA Corbett and Ka~-~e "Employn~€~nt l...atN Semir~~r ,~~ab Stress°

'7/1 ~~~ ~~~ ~~tl ~YZf1CiSC0, ~~ Stale Ba~~ of C~lif~rnia :~Poten~i~l(y Violent CI€ent5: UVI~o Are ~I hey and ~~;V~at f~~ri Vt~e [~o?"

3/25/1 X94 Sa~Z Francisco, C~1 Bar Association of San Francisco - "}ob Scr~ss: Disease o1- ~t~t~e ~~t:h C:~ntury"

3/E!1994 Woodland Hilfs, Cl~ Fir~emari's F=uf~d - Lc~r~ta f'rieta Car-thqual

1 2/2/1993 San ~rancisca, CA Bar Association of San Francisco - "(i~eognirir~g Qepressiori In Your Clients, ~a-warl

1 1 /l b/1 393 San FE~anciscc~, CR Bar Association of San Francisco "1tVr~r4t Piave Saf~Yy anc~ S~cf~rit~~"

1 {?/28/193 San Francisco, CA Bar Association of San Francisco - "PT5L7"

35 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 36 of 117 Page ID #:1414

~~-i in~i ~r~i~~~~:

1. "5tressin~ the Point: When Are Posfi Traumatic Str~esa Cl~ir,~s Legitiri~at:e...a~~ci Where are tl~ie~~ Not?'~ F-vr the L~~.fe~rs~,

Rlc~vernne~~ 19 5, ~aurnal of the DC'~E'i'lSE' ReSC-'_cifCI'7 jY15~1TLf'kC'. 2. "O~ti~~q O at cif Nanag~cf C:are.,~~ Psychigt~ric Times, ~e~~t~n-~I~er 1 995. 3. "i~anagec) Care anci 1~1e~~r~af HealCl~,,~ Op. Ecl., S~~i ftranci.sr.r~ Examiner, f~ovei~tl~~r 20, 1X95. ~, "I~epi}ession ~s ,~ Possible Ac1~Jeese Effect of ~~i~latanin.~: Currevrts, February 199f~. 5. "Cornme~t: Cri~icisrrt and l,E=yal Analysis - Ment:~zl I-~iealih Ce~nfidential,,~ _ "Patient C~arific~entiafity R.fier Jaffee v. Redrno~~d, El.S. Suprrrr~e Court GecisiUi~,~~ The I~~c~vrc~~r, ~4i{~1 24, 19~F.i. ~. '~5l~rink in the C.c~ur-trac>m: ~cr~an~ic 6'sychi~itry a►-~d l_~~~~v„ published in Sran Frc~f~ci.sta /1ttUrney I~cr~c~z:€~e., f~ecen~I~ee~ 2t7Q0 -January 2001, pul~lishe~i by the Bar ~lssocia~io~~ ~f San Fr~~zcisc~o.

7. "Mental Illness !n the Wor-I

7 D. "l- f~e `Eggs~~ell Plaintiff' I~EVISt~E'C~: Cc~LfSc1~lOC1 cai~ fvlental Damages in Civil Litigation by I~ari< i. Levy, MD, FAF'!~ anti Saul E. Rosenberg, Phb, April 2003 issue of The At~rerirr~~7 Bar

36 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 37 of 117 Page ID #:1415

,~ssociati~rr Cvn~t~rlssio~ are h~Ee~tcf! c~nc~ Physiciral ~israbifrry Lr~~r Reporter. 1 1. "Unwarranted Restrictions an the lrrcle~endent Examina~ivn cif Emc~tionai Darnac~es," by Sa~I Rosen~~err~, 1'hD and Ivtar!

1 2. "Post P~rtt~~r~ L7C~?C~5Sic7i1, Psychosis and ln~anticid~,° Thy Encyciopedira of C~ornestic lfiof~r~ce, Routledge, ~QOG.

1 3. "A55~551l1~ T~1H -I YULYI: l-IC1bV FOi'~f1S1(: !'sychtatrists {~nci

~75~CE"1t}It)~15YS Evaluate Litigants,', ~iarl< 1. Levy, n~L), i~LF~P!-~ end I:anald Fi. fto~~rt5, Pht~., R~P~', _Scan F~~€~lcis-cc~ ,~ttvrnr~~~, Bar ~ssc~ci~tinn of Sai~ ~;ancisco, 5~arii~q ~00€~. 14. "Assessing the Damages in !V(ulti-Plaintiff Litic~atic~n,° fas~ ~1~e U~fer~se, Qeceiml~er 21, 2010. T 5. "fob Stress ar~d Ha~v to !-landle it,° ,=acts & Fin~i~r~s, ~`cr~e.

C{'IPDYfICIP.. ~~ ~ ~. 16. "~~hen Choosing a Forensic F~sychiatr~ie Expert," 5~ar~ Fra~cisca ~ittva~t~ey Magazine (Bar Association of S~~r, Fr~~~rciscc~7, Summer 2~~ z. T 7. "T~~e fmpo~~tar,ce of Psychalayicai ~"estinc~ Cvaluati~~n~; cai~ Fn7o~ianai Distress Clain~s in Em~,lay~~ne~nt Litic~alioi-~,,, v~~ri~t~~~ with Sara} Ha11, 1'h~, 2Q1 ?_ (E~republicatie~n}. ] 8. "TYie Else of Fc~~-ensic ~sychiat~y in C~tastrc~~hic Inji,iry and Multi-Pa~~ty Litigagioi7," w~~itten ~nrith Michael fox, Csq., glantri(a~t~g GN,4 It~sigbris, (Vol. 1 3, Nc~. Z3) X23, Decerr~laer 9, 201 3.

37 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 38 of 117 Page ID #:1416

EXHIBIT 3

38 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 39 of 117 Page ID #:1417

RONALD H. ROBERTS,Ph.D., ABPP 2000 Van Ness Ave., Suite 512 San Francisco, CA 94109 Tel.(415) 776-2000 [email protected] Fax (415) 776-2001

CURRICULUM VITAE (January, 2015)

PSYCHOLOGY LICENSE: JANUARY,1984

The Board of Medical Quality Assurance, Deparhnent of Consumer Affairs State of California. Licensed Psychologist PSY8334.

EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND

PSYCHOLOGY GRADUATE SCHOOL

California School of Professional Psychology, Berkeley, California

Awarded M.A. in Psychology, July, 1980

Pre-doctoral internships:

1978-1979: Cabrillo Elementary School, Fremont, CA 1979-1980: Palo Alto Mental Health Center, Palo Alto, CA

Awarded Ph.D. in Psychology, July, 1982

Pre-doctoral internships:

1980-1981: The Institute of Epidemiology and Behavioral Medicine, Institutes of Medical Sciences, Pacific Medical Center, San Francisco 1981-1982: Letterman Army Medical Center, San Francisco

POST GRADUATE TRAINING

Neuropsychology Fellowship Training Program: 1982-1983

Veteran's Administration Hospital, Fort Miley, San Francisco, CA

Registered Psychologist, 1982-1983

Institute of Epidemiology and Behavioral Medicine, Institutes of Medical Sciences, Pacific Medical Center, San Francisco, CA. Research consultant.

39 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 40 of 117 Page ID #:1418

Curriculum Vitae Ronald H. Roberts, Ph.D., ABPP Page 2

COLLEGE

University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado

Psychology Major, Awarded B.A. in Psychology, 1978

1975-1976: Peer Counselor, Vocational Counselor and Human Sexuality Counselor 1977-1978: Veterans Counselor; developed Veterans Peer Counseling Program. Volunteer Intake worker at Boulder Community Mental Health Center

U.S. ARMY

Neuropsychiatric Technician Basic Procedures Course, 1972 Fort San Houston, San Antonio, Texas

Neuropsychiatric Technician, 1972 -1974 Fort Leonard Wood, Missouri, Inpatient psychiatric ui7it, 1972 97th General Army Hospital, Frankfurt, Germany, 1972-1974, Psychiatric, drug and alcohol units.

CURRENT PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE

Private Practice: January, 1984 —Present

Psychotherapy: long term clients and referrals from colleagues.

Neuropsychology: Evaluation of Forensic &Clinical problems including brain injury, toxic exposure, mold injury, electrocution, dementia and geriatric conditions, learning disabilities, chronic pain, drug and alcohol addiction, vocational ability and disability evaluation.

Forensic Psychology: Brain Injury, Personal Injury, Mental Competency, Mental Capacity, Testamentary Capacity, Sanity(Mens Rea), Sexual Harassment, Wrongful Termination, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, Discrimination, Drug and Alcohol Addiction.

Veterans Consultation: Certified Veterans Evaluator for Disabilities related to PTSD and Traumatic Brain Injury.

Educational: Seminars for Attorneys in Forensic Psychology. Certified Provider of Continuing Education for the State Bar of California.

RECENT SENIINAR PRESENTATIONS

Me~ital Disorders, Substance Abuse and Ofher Limited Conditions —Tackling the Clzalle~Tges ofH~ndli►ig MentaUNervous Claims andEstablishing Objective Proof of "Non-Visible" COIYI~Itl012S

American Conference Institute (ACn, Philadelphia, PA, panel presentation, 1/22/15

40 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 41 of 117 Page ID #:1419

Curriculum Vitae Ronald H. Roberts, Ph.D., Inc. Page 3

Tackling the IME's Evaluation, Treating Physician's Opinion:, the FCE,Neicropsych Evaluations, Medical Records a~zd More.

American Conference Institute(ACn, Philadelphia, PA, panel presentation, 1/22/15.

Effective Use ofForensic Psychiatry in Catastrophic LZjury, Toxic Torts, and Ma~lti-Party Litigation

International Association of Defense Counsel(IADC), Carlsbad, CA, panel presentation, 2/11/14

Forensic Psych Assessment ofEirzotional Injuries in Litigation

Mitchell, Silberberg & Knupp, Los Angeles, CA, panel presentation (FPAMED), 1/12/11

Subjective Disorders: Proving &Disproving the Elements in a Period ofIncreased Claims

American Conference Institute(ACn, Boston, MA,panel presentation, 6/15/09

Subjective Disorders: Practical Tipsfor UtiCizing tlae Medical Facts in Litigation

American Conference Institute (ACI), Boston, MA, panel presentation, 6/12/08

"Hecl~ of a Job!" Understanding &Assessing Emotional Damage Clain~.s in Ehiploynte~zt Litigation

Office of the Attorney General, State of California, Oakland, CA, panel presentation, (FPAMED) 1/9/08

The Last Dance: Forensic Psychiatric Expertise i~z Testame~itary Capacity, Undue lizflc~e~tce and Will Contests

Bar Association of San Francisco, panel presentation, 1/8/08

"Shrinks" on the Coucl:: Deposing Mental Health Professionals

Bar Association of San Francisco, panel presentation, 9/12/0.

Role ofForensic Psychiatric Experts in Employment Litigation

California State Department of Transportation, Morro Bay, CA, panel presentation, 7/9/07

Examination ofPsychological Witnesses and Standards ofPractice

San Francisco District Attorney's, 2/22/07.

PAST PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE

Consulting Psvcholo~ist and Neuropsycholo~ist: 1984-1994

41 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 42 of 117 Page ID #:1420

Curriculum Vitae Ronald H. Roberts, Ph.D., ABPP Page 4

Crystal Springs Rehabilitation Center, San Mateo, CA

Long term gero-psychiatric care facility for those with severe mental disorders such as schizophrenia, major affective disorders and dementias.

Consulting Psychologist and Neuropsvcholo~ist: 1984-1992

Drake House, Lafayette, CA. Long Term Treatment Facility for adolescents.

Consulting Psychologist and Neuropsvcholo~ist: 1982-1992

Canyon Manor, Novato, CA

Sub-Acute and Long Term Psychiatric Care Facility for those with severe mental disorders such as schizophrenia, major affective disorders and dementias.

Forensic Psvcholo~ist & Neuropsvcholo~ist: April, 1984 -April, 1987

Stephen M. Raffle, M.D., Inc., Oakland, CA

Forensic specialization in Workers' Compensation and Personal Injury law. Primary Focus: Evaluation and Treatment of Disabled Individuals.

POST GRADUATE TEACHING EXPERIENCE

Forensic Psvcholo~v Instructor: Winter, 1996

San Francisco School of Psychology, San Francisco, CA

Psycho(o~ical Assessment Instructor: September, 1987 -June, 1989

California School of Professional Psychology, Berkeley and Alameda, CA

Psychological Assessment Instructor: September 1987 -December, 1988

Pacific Graduate School of Psychology, Palo Alto, CA

Psvcholo~ical Assessment Instructor: September, 1987 -August, 1988

Center for Psychological Studies, Albany, CA

NeuroAsvcholo~y Assessment Instructor: June, 1983 -Sept. 1984

California Graduate School of Marital and Family Therapy, San Rafael, CA

Psvcholo~ical Assessment Instructor: June, 1982 -September 1983

42 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 43 of 117 Page ID #:1421

Curriculum Vitae Ronald H. Roberts, Ph.D., Inc. Page 5

California Graduate School of Marital and Family Therapy, San Rafael, CA

Psvcholo~ical Assessment Laboratory Instructor, 1980-1982 California School of Professional Psychology, Berkeley, CA

Psychological Assessment Laboratory Instructor, 1980-1982 California Graduate School of Marital and Family Therapy, San Rafael, CA

MEMBERSHIPS AND AFFILIATIONS

Member, American Psychological Association. Division 40: Society for Clinical Neuropsychology Division 41: American Psychology-Law Society

Member, California Psychological Association.

Member, National Academy of Neuropsychology.

Member, American College of Forensic Psychology.

Member, Council for the National Register of Health Service Providers in Psychology. Registered Health Service Provider in Psychology.

Member, Society for Personality Assessment.

Member, Association of State and Provincial Psychology Boards (ASPPB), Certificate of Professional Qualification in Psychology(CPQ)

BOARD CERTIFICATIONS

Diplomate-Fellow in Psychopharmacology of the Prescribing Psychologists' Register (FPPR),International College of Prescribing Psychologists and Prescribing Psychologists Register, 1997.

Diplomate, American Academy of Experts in Traumatic Stress, 1996.

Diplomate in Forensic Psychology, American Board of Professional Psychology, 1994. Diploma Number 4510.

Diplomate of the American Board of Disability Consultants, 1992.

Diplomate of the American Board of Vocational Neuropsychology, 1992.

Diplomate of the American Academy of Pain Management, 1992.

Diplomate and Fellow of the American Board of Medical Psychotherapy, 1989.

43 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 44 of 117 Page ID #:1422

EXHIBIT 4

44 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 45 of 117 Page ID #:1423

DR. RICHARD J. MOUW VITA

President and Professor of Christian Philosophy, Fuller Theological Seminary, 1993-2013. Professor of Faith and Public Life, Fuller Theological Seminary, 2013- Disinguished Visiting Scholar, Pepperdine University, 2013-2014

Education

A.A. Northwestern Junior College, 1959

B.A. Houghton College, 1961 Major: English

M.A. University of Alberta, 1965 Major: Philosophy

Ph.D. University of Chicago, 1971 Major: Philosophy

Experience

Teaching Assistant, University of Alberta, 1963-1965 Visiting Instructor, University of Alberta, 1967, 1971 (summers) Teaching Assistant, University of Illinois, 1965-1967 Part-time Instructor, Elmhurst College, 1967-1968 Taught at Calvin College, 1968-1985; appointed full professor in 1974 Visiting Lecturer, Calvin Theological Seminary, 1971-1972 Member, Graduate Faculty, Aquinas Institute of Religious Studies, 1973, 1974(summers) Visiting Lecturer, Calvin Theological Seminary, 1979-1980 J. Omar Good Visiting Distinguished Professor of Evangelical Christianity, Juniata College, 1980-1981 Professor, Young Life Institute, Summer 1982 Visiting Professor, Free University, Amsterdam, Fall 1982 Visiting Professor, New College, Berkeley, 1983 Professor of Christian Philosophy and Ethics, Fuller Theological Seminary, 1985-present Provost, Fuller Theological Seminary, September 1989-June 1993, and President-elect, June 1992-June 1993 President, Fuller Theological Seminary, June 1993-2013

Memberships in Professional Societies

American Academy of Religion Society of Biblical Literature Society of Christian Ethics Society of Christian Philosophers Vereniging voor Calvinisfische Wijsbegeerte (Association for Calvinistic Philosophy)

Other Educationa//Professional Experience

1599818.1 45 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 46 of 117 Page ID #:1424

2 University Fellow, University of Chicago, 1966-1968 Member of Editorial Staff ofEthics, 1966-1968 Participant in Carnegie Suimner Institute in Ethical Theory, Notre Dame University, Summer 1972 Consultant to Rockefeller Foundation Study on University-Related Theological Education, 1974 Chair, Michigan Academy of Arts, Science and Letters, Philosophy Division, 1974-1975 National Endowment for the Humanities Fellow in Sociology, Princeton University, 1975-1976 Member of Faith and Order Commission, National Council of Churches, 1977-1981 Fellow at the Center for Theological Inquiry, Princeton Theological Seminary, 1982-1983 An Editor of the Reformed Journal, 1972-1991 Member of the Commission on Accrediting, Association of Theological Schools, 1990-1996 (Chair, 1995-1996) Member of Editorial Board ofLaity Exchange, 1977-present Member of Board of the Institute for Ecumenical and Cultural Research, 1985-1997 Member of Editorial Board of.Iournal ofReligious Ethics, 1985-1999 Co-Chair, Official Reformed-Catholic Dialogue (representing the Presbyterian ChOurch(USA), 2004-present Member of Editorial Board of Books and Culture, 1996-present Harvard Divinity School Board of Visitation, 1996-present Member of Board of Advisors, International Justice Mission, 1996-present Member of Board of Advisors, Religion and Ethics News Weekly, 1996-present Member of The Council on Civil Society, 1996-1998 Member of Advisory Board of the American Jewish Conunittee's Skirball Institute, 1997-present Columnist,"BeliefNeY' Web Magazine, 1999-present Member of Board of Advisors, International Center for Religion and Diplomacy, 1999-present Vics President, Association of Theological Schools in the United States and Canada

Married, with a son, daughter-in-law, and two grandchildren.

Publications

Books

Political Evarrgelisrrr. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1973.(Korean tr. Jeon-Seop Moon, Chungchee wa chundo [Politics and Evangelism]. Seoul, Korea: The Christian Literature Society, 1975. Swedish tr. L. Larson, Politik och evangelisation. Orebro, Sweden: Bokfdrlaget Libris,1977. Korean tr. Jung-Suc Rhee, Chungchee chundo [Political Evangelism]. Seoul, Korea: Nabi Chulpansa, 1988.)

Politics and the Biblical Drama. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1976. Reprint, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Book House, 1983.(Korean tr. Seoul, Korea: Korea Christian Book Service, 1999.)

Called to Holy Worldliness. Philadelphia: Forness Press, 1980.

Objections to Christianity. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Bible Way, 1981.

When the Kings Come Mm•ching In: Isaiah and the New Jerusalem. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1983. (French tr. Jacques Buchhold,La Culture et le Monde a Venir. Miry-sur-Oise, France: Les Editions Sator, 1988. Korean tr., Mirai ui ch'on'guk kwa hyonjai ui munhwa. Seoul, Korea: Tyrannus Press, 1986.)

Stained Glass: World Views and Social Science [conference papers, Calvin College, Grand Rapids, Michigan, July 1985], edited with Paul A. Marshall and Sander Griffioen. Christian Studies Today Series. Lanham, Maxyland: University Press of America, 1989.

Distorted Truth: What Every Christian Needs to Know About the Battlefor the Mind. San Francisco: Harper and Row, 1989.

TITe God Who Commands: A Study in Divine Co»~mand Ethics. Notre Dame,Indiana: University of Notre Dame Press, 1990. Reprint, Notre Dame, Indiana: University of Notre Dame Press, 2004.

Uncommon Decency.' ClTristian Civility in an Uncivil Wo~•ld. Downers Grove, Illinois: InterVarsity Press, 1992. Reprinted, Downers Grove, Illinois: InterVarsity Press, 2010.(Korean tr. Seoul, Korea: Korea Intervarsity Press, 2004. Reprinted, Seoul, Korea: Korea Intervarsity Press, 2014.) 1599818.1 46 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 47 of 117 Page ID #:1425

Pluralis»zs and Horizons: An Essay in Christian Public Philosophy (with Sander Griffioen). Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1993. Reprinted, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, May 1994.

Consulting the Faithful.• What Christian Intellectuals Caiz Learnfrom Popular Religion. Crrand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1994.

The Snaell ofSawdust: What Evangelicals Can Learn,from Their Fundamentalist Heritage. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan, 2000.

He Shines in All That's Fair: Culture and Comn~orr Grace. The 2000 Stob Lectures. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 2000. Paperback edition, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 2002.

Wonderful Words ofLife: Hyn7ns in American protestant History and Theology. Edited by Richard J. Moues and Mark A. Noll. Crrand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 2004.

Calvinism in the Las Yegas Airport: Making Connections in Today's World. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan, 2004.

Praying at Burger King. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 2007. (Korean tr. Seoul, Korea: Korea Intervarsity Press, 2009.)

Abraham Kuypers A Short and Personal Introduction. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 2011.(Japanese tr. Seoul, Republic of Korea: rMaeng2, 2012.

The Challenges ofCultural Discipleship: Essays in the Line ofAbraham Kuyper. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 2012.

Called to the Life oftl~e Mind: Some Advicefor Evangelical Scholars. Grand Rapids Michigan: Eerdmans, 2014.

Scholarly Essays

"The Status of God's Moral Judgments." Canadian Journal ofTheology 16(1-2):61-66 (1970).

"Policies, Procedures and the Public Interest." Interdisciplinary Essays, 4(Spring 1975).

"New Alignments: Hartford and the Future of Evangelicalism." In Against the Worldfor the World: The Hartford Appeal and the Future ofAmerican Religion, edited by Peter Berger and Richard John Neuhaus, 99-125. New York: Seabury, 1976.

"Evangelicals in Search of Maturity." Theology Today, 35:42-51 (April 1978). Also published in.Iournal ofTheology for Southern Africa, 22:47-55 (March 1978).

"Biblical Revelation and Medical Decisions." The Journal ofMedicine and Philosophy 4(4):367-382(December 1979). Reprinted in Changing Perspectives in Moral Philosophy: Revisions, edited by Stanley Hauerwas and Alasdair C. MacIntyre. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1983. Reprinted in On Moral Medicine: Theological Perspectives in Medical Ethics, edited by Stephen E. Lairuners and Allen Verhey. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1986.

"Providence and Politics." In Life is Religion: Essays in Honor ofH. Evan Runner, edited by Henry Vander Goot, 207-220. St. Catherine's, Ontario: Paidea Press, 1981.

"Evangelism and Social Ethics." Perkins Journal, 35:12-17 (Fall 1981). Reprinted in Theological Students Fellowship Bulletin, 5(3): 6-9(January -February 1982).

"Individualism and Christian Faith." Theology Today, 38:450-457 (January 1982).

"The Bible in Twentieth Century Protestantism: A Preliminary Ta~conomy." In The Bible in America: Essays in Cultural History, edited by Nathan O. Hatch and Mark A. Noll. New York: Oxford Press, 1982.

1599818.1 47 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 48 of 117 Page ID #:1426

4 "Biblical Justice and Peace: Toward an Evangelical-Roman Catholic Rapprochement." In Evangelicals and the Bishops'Pastoral Letter, edited by Dean C. Curry, 32-48. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1984. Portions reprinted in the Reformed Journal, 34(3):12-19(March 1984).

"Christianity and Pacifism." Faith and Philosophy: Journal ofthe Society ofChristian Philosophers, 2(2):105-111 (April 1985).

"Alasdair MacInTyre on Reformation Ethics." Journal ofReligioa~s Ethics, 13:243-257 (Fall 1985).

"Evangelicalism and Philosophy." Theology Today, 44329-337(October 1987).

"Thorn-In-The-Flesh Decision Making: A Christian Overview of the Ethics of Treatment." In On Moral Medicine: Theological Perspectives in Medical Ethics, edited by Stephen E. Lammers and Allen Verhey. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1986.

"Alternative Christian Approaches to Political Science: Toward a More Comprehensive Perspective." In The Reality ofChristian Learning, edited by Harold Heie and David L. Wolfe, 38-52. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1987.

"Spiritual Identity and Churchly Praxis." Theological Education, 23 Supplement: 88-112 (1987).

"Christian Theology and Cultural Plurality." The Sco#ish Bulletin ofEvangelical Theology, 5:185-196(Autumn 1987).

"Christian Philosophy and Cultural Diversity." Christian Scholars Review, 17(2):109-121 (December 1987).

"Knowing and Doing: The Christian College in Contemporary Society." In Making Higher Education Christian, edited by Joel A. Carpenter and Kenneth W. Shipps, 217-230. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1987.

"Life in the Spirit in an Unjust World." Pneuma: The .Iournal ofthe Society ofPentecostal Studies, 9:109-128 (Fall 1987). Reprinted in The Holy Spirit.• Renewing and Empowering Presence, edited by George Vandervelde. Winfield, British Columbia: Wood Lake Books, 1989.

"State Theology." In The Kairos Covenant: Standing with South Afi°ican Christians, edited by Willis W.Logan, 50- 58. New York: Friendship Press (1988).

"Toward an Evangelical Theology of Poverty." In Christian Faitl: and Practice in the Modern World, edited by Mark A. Noll and D. Wells, 218-238. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1988.

"Reflections on Individualism I." In Social Science in Chr-istian Perspective, edited by Paul A. Marshall and Robert E. Vander Vennen, 63-81. Boston: University Press of America, 1988.

"Dutch Calvinist Philosophical Influences in North America." Calvin Theological Journal, 24:93-120 (April 1989).

"Thinking about the Poor: What Evangelicals Can Learn from the Bishops." In Prophetic Visions and Economic Realities, edited by Charles R. Strain, 20-34. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1989.

"Evangelical Ethics and the Anabaptist-Reformed Dialogue." Tlae Journal ofReligious Ethics, 17:121-137 (Fall 1989).

"Of Household and Economies." In Biblical Principles &Economics.• The Foundations. Series: Christians in the Market Place, Vol. 2. Edited by Richard C. Chewning. Colorado Springs, CO: NavPress, 1989.

"Normativity and Contextuality in the Social Sciences: Lessons from Dutch Villages." In Norm and Context in t1~e Social Sciences, edited by Sander Griffioen and Jan Verhoogt. Lanham, Maryland: University Press of America, 1990.

"Jesus and Political Authority." In Pe~•spectives On Christology, edited by Marguerite Shuster and Richard Muller, 253-267. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan, 1991.

L599818.1 48 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 49 of 117 Page ID #:1427

5 "The Good Society: Religious Conviction and Public Civility ." In Ethics, Religion, and the Good Society, edited by Joseph Runzo, 95-109. Louisville, Kentucky: Westminster/John Knox Press, 1992.

"Israel and the Church in the World." In Studies in Old Testament Theology: Historical and Co~tempor•ary Images of God and God's People, Festschr~for David Allen Hubbard, edited by Robert L. Hubbard, Jr., Robert K. Johnston and Robert P. Meye, 243-261. Dallas: Word Publishing, 1992.

"Creational Politics: Some Calvinist Amendments." Christian Scholars Review, 23(2): 181-193 (1993).

"On Creation's `Several Parts'; Modal Diversity in Dooyeweerd's Social Thought." In Christian Philosophy at the Close ofthe Tiventieth Century, Edited by Sander Griffioen and Bert M.Balk, 175-183. Kampen: Kok, 1995.

"Religieus-wijsgerige achtergronden van het milieuprobleem." In Chrr'stel~ke Filosofie in Beweging, edited by R.J.A. Doomenbal and A. Zijlstra-Amsterdam: Buijten & Schipperheijn, 1996.

"Learning From the `Splits': Some Reflections on Dutch Calvinist Diversity." Calvin Theological Journal, 31:182- 195 (April 1996)

"Pentecostal Evangelism." Word &World, 16:354-365 (Suuuner 1996).

"Challenge of Evangelical Theological Education." In Theological Education in the Evangelical Tradition ,edited by Darryl G. Hart and R. Albert Mohler, Jr., 284-289. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker, 1996.

"Christian Scholarship: The Difference a Worldview Makes." The Cresset, Special Issue, Lilly Fellows Program in Humanities and the Arts: Valparaiso University, 60(7):5 (1997).

"Evangelical Civility and the Academic Calling." In Should God Get Tenure? Essays on Religion and Higher Education, Edited by David W. Gill, 116-128. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1997.

"Violence, Abuse and the Reformed Understanding of the Atonement." Theology Matters, 3(4):1-5 (July/August 1997).

"Evangelism: The Very Idea!" Pro Ecclesia, A Journal ofCatholic and Evangelical Theology, 7:172 (Spring 1998).

"Some Reflections on Sphere Sovereignty."(Lecture presented at Princeton Theological Seminary, 1998 Stone Lectures,"Religion, Pluralism and Public Life: Abraham Kuyper's Legacy for the 215 Century," February 25- 28, 1998) The Princeton Seminary Bulletin, New Series 19(2):160-182, 1998. Also published in Religion, Pluralism, and the Public Life: Abraham Kuyper's Legacyfor the Twenty-First Century, edited by Luis E. Lugo, 87-109. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 2000.

"Another Look at the Infra/Supralapsarian bebate."(Lecture presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Religion, November 22, 1998.) Calvin Journal of Theology, 35 (1): 136-152 (Apri12000).

"The Problem of Authority in Evangelical Christianity." In Church Unity and the Papal Office: An Ecumenical Dialogue on .7olan Pau1II's Encyclical Ut Unum Sint." Edited by Carl E. Braaten and Robert W. Jenson, 124-141. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2001.

"The Challenge ofInteneligious Truth Telling", in No Other Gods Before Me? Evangelicals and the Challenge of World Religions. Edited by John G. Stackhouse, Jr., 171-177. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2001.

"Assessing Christian Scholarship: Where We've Been and Where We're Going",in Christian Scholarship...for What? Edited by Susan M.Felch, 7-22. Grand Rapids: Calvin College, 2003.

"Educational Choice and Pillarization: Some lessons for Americans from the Dutch experiment in `Affirniative Impartiality"'. Sclaool Choice. Edited by Alan Wolfe, 155-172, Princeton University Press: New Jersey, 2003. "Where Are We Going?: Eschatology" in Essentials of Christian Tl~eology. Edited by William C. Placher, 329-347. London: Westminster John Knox Press, 2003.

Articles

"Hanging in There: Why Conservatives Need Liberals," The Christian Century, pp. 22- 25, January 13, 2004.

1599818.1 49 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 50 of 117 Page ID #:1428

"The Task of Christian Social Ethics. "Christianity Today, 12:3-5 (January 5, 1968).

"The Vietnam Moratorium, 1969." Reformed Journal, 20(1): 6-8 (January 1970).

"The Bunny and the Madonna: Philosophizing on the Freeway." Christianity Today, 14(3):12(March 27, 1970).

"An Open Letter from the Underground Church." The Banner, Dec. 4, 1970.

"Personal Evangelism." Reformed Journal, 12(4):14-15 (April 1971).

"Commands for Grown-ups." Worldview, 1538-42(July 1972) Reprinted in The Use ofScripture in Moral Theology, Readings in Moral Theology, vol. 4, edited by Chazles E. Curran and Richard A. McCormick,66-77. New York: Paulist Press, 1984.

"Catholic Pentecostalism Today." Reformed.7our -nal, 22(6):8 (July-August 1972).

"Miraculous Healing." The Banner, November 17 and November 24, 1972.

"Evangelicals and Political Activism." Christian Century, 89:1316-1319(December 27, 1972).

"Some Guidelines for the Christian Study of Man." Christianity Today, 17:22-24,(March 30, 1973).

"In Search of a Theology of Politics." Christian Century, 90:501-502(May 2, 1973).

"Political Evangelism:'The Post American, 3:18-19 (April 1974).

"The Evangelicals." Ne~v Covenant, 3(3):17-19 (September 1973).

"Evangelical Senators Don't Fit Simple Molds." Christian Century, 91:882-883 (September 25, 1974).

"Sexual Politics." PostAmerican, 3:18-25 (August-September 1974).

"Why Go to Church?" Refo►~med Journal, 25(3):21-25 (March 1975).

"Weaving a Coherent Pattern of Discipleship." Christian Century, 92:728-731 (August 20-27, 1975).

"Who Then Is This?" The Banner, Oct. 3, 1975.

"The Zacchaeus Connection." Vanguard, (November-December 1975).

"Seeking Political Discernment." Cross-Talk, (September-October 1976).

"Saving Our Ship." Sojourners, 6(5):34 (May 1977). Reprinted as "Critic's Corner: Saving Our Ship." Theology Today, 34(3):303-304 (October 1977).

"Politics and the Pulpit." Calvinist Contact, November 11, 1977.

"Political Action and the Kingdom of God." The Other Side, 13(7):45-47 (November 1977).

"What about Civil Religion?" Messenger, February 1978.

"The Corporate Calling of the Laity." In The New Laity: Between Church and YYorld, edited by Ralph D. Bucy, 103- 119. Waco, Texas: Word Books, 1978.

"WhyI Support Nuclear Disarmament." Vanguard, March-April 1979.

"Education Under the King." Calvinist Contact, October 5, 1979.

"CRC: A Multiracial Community." The Banner, 115(42):9 (November 3, 1980).

L599818.1 50 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 51 of 117 Page ID #:1429

"Being with the Lamb: a Sermon [Rev 17:14]." Sojourners, 10:20-22(March 1981). Reprinted in Waging Peace: A Handbookfor the Struggle to Abolish Nzrclear Weapons, edited by Jim Wallis, 168-173. San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1983.

"Promiscuously and Without Distinction." The Banner, 116(]7):20-21 (Apri127, 1981).

"What Are the Ships of Tarshish Doing Here?" Crux, 17(2):20-26(June 1981).

"Defending `Creation'." Ecumenical Trends, September 1981.

"Secret, and Not-So-Secret, Societies." The Banner, 116(39):1213 (October 12, 1981).

"Jesus and the Poor: Unity in Christ in an Unjust World." Reformed.Iournal, 30(5):8-13(May 1980). Reprinted in Mid Stream, 20:409-419(October 1981).

"Born of a Virgin." Reformed.Iournal, 31(11):6-7 (November-December 1981).

"Assessing the Moral Majority." Reforn7ed Journal, 31(6):13-15 (June 1981). Reprinted in Zadok Centre News, March 1,982.

"God's Norm for Justice." Catalyst: Contemporary Evangelical Perspectives For United Methodist Seminarians, September 1982.

"Goblins or Grace." The Banne~~, 117(41):17(October 25, 1982).

"The Earth is the Lord's." Catalyst: Contemporary Evangelical Perspectives For United Methodist Seminarians, October-November 1982.

"Christelijk Realism en de Organisatie." Beweging, December 1982.

"The Call to Be Peacemakers." Catalyst: Contemporary Evangelical Perspectives For United Methodist Seminarians, February 1983.

"Evangelical Historians." Reformed Journal, 33(5):4-5(May 1983).

"Conflicting Forces at WCC Vancouver Assembly: Three Opposing Positions that also exist among Evangelicals." Christianity Today, 27(8):52 (Apri122, 1983).

"Essays in Response to the Data." In Faith and Ferment: An Interdisciplinary Study ofChristian Beliefs and Practices, edited by Joan Chittister, Martin Mariy and Robert S. Bilheimer, 290-295. Minneapolis, Minnesota: Augsburg Pub. House, 1983.

"Can War Bring Peace: A Reexamination ofthe Just-War Theory in the Nuclear Age." In Perspectives o~~ Peacemaking: Biblical Options in the Nuclear Age, edited by John A. Bernbaum, 191-208. Ventura: Regal Books, 1984.

"A Reformed Theological Perspective on Politics." In Signs ofthe Kingdom in tlae Secular City, edited by Helen Uvarosy, 37-43. Chicago: Covenant Press, 1984.

"Spirituality and the Minishy of the Laity." Laity Exchange, 24(June 1985).

"Abandoning the Typology: A Reformed Assist." Theological Students Fellowship Bulletin, 8(5):7-10(May -June 1985).

"Keeping the Words." One World, 118:16(August -September 1986).

"Evangelicalism and the CRC." The Banner, 121(23):14-17 (June 16, 1986).

"Clergy Liability: A Theological Perspective." Theology News and Notes, 33(2):18-21 (October 1986).

"Why I Went to the Party at All." Reformed Journal, 37:21-22(March 1987).

15998] 8.1 51 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 52 of 117 Page ID #:1430

"Just War Doctrine: Some Neglected Basics." The Evangelical Round Table, 3:101ff.(1987)

"Gaining Strength: The Long Term Prospects for the American Laity." The 1986 Vesper Audenshaw Lecture. Laity Exchange, 31 (August 1987).

"The Waning of Hell." The Banner, 122(29):12-14(August 24, 1987).

"Partnership in the Gospel: A Journey." Newsletter: The Comr~aitteefor YYonaen in the CRC, September-October 1987.

"Understanding the Fundamentalists' Retreat." Neiv Oxford Review, 54(7):11-15 (September 1987).

"Response" [to W.Bouwsma, `Calvin and the dilemma ofhypocrisy', pp.l-13]. In Calvin and Christian Ethics: Papers and Responses Presented at the Fiftlz Colloquium on Calvin and Calvin Studies Sponsored by the Calvin Studies Society held at Calvin Theological Sen~inaiy, May 8-9, 1985. Edited by Peter De Klerk, 15-18. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Calvin Studies Society, 1987.

"The Spiritual Thrust of Just War Doctrine." New Oxford Review, 55(2):11-14(March 1988).

"Evangelical Ecumenism." Theology News and Notes, 35(1):8-11 (March 1988).

"Convicted Civility." In Annual ofthe Society of Christian Ethics, edited by D. Yeager, 259-261. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press, 1989.

"The Call to Holy Worldliness." Reformed Journal, 39:8-14 (January 1989).

"Selfhood with Boundaries." Reformed .Iournal, 39:3-4(Summer 1989)

"The Dragon of Arrogance." The Banner, 124(32):8-9(September 18, 1989).

"The Danger of Alien Loyalties: Civic Symbols Present a Real Challenge to the Faithfulness of the Church's Worship," Reformed Worship, 15:8-9(March 1990).

"Humility, Hope and the Divine Slowness."("How My Mind Has Changed" Series.) Christian Century, 107364-368 (April 11, 1990).

"Missionaries To The Dark Continents of Politics." Spectrum: Journal ofthe Association ofAdventist Forums , 20(3):10-14 (April 1990).

"A Kinder, Gentler Calvinism." Reformed Journal, 40:11-13 (October 1990).

"Why Do Evangelicals Need The Academy?" Christianity Today, 86, 90-93 (October 8, 1990)

"Preaching Christ or Packaging Jesus?" Christianity Today, 35:29-32(Feb. 11, 1991).

"Lutherans from a Reformed Perspective." Word and World, 11(3): 301-304(Summer 1991).

"Faculty as Scholars and Teachers." Theological Education, 28:76-79 (Autumn 1991).

"Inter-Religious Dialogue: Implications for Ministry in the Contemporary World." Insights, 107:37-44 (Fall 1991).

"Giving The Devil His Due." Decision, 32(9):12-14 (September 1991).

"John Locke's Christian Individualism." Faith and P/~ilosophy, 8(4):448-460(October 1991).

"Is Religious Liberty a Human Right?" CM~istianiry Today, 3636-37 (July 20, 1992).

"The Reckless Tongue"[excerpt from Uncommon Decency, 1992]. Christianity Today, 36:42-45 (October 5, 1992).

"Natural Spirituality." Perspectives, 7:4 (October 1992).

1599818.1 52 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 53 of 117 Page ID #:1431

E "Sister Helen's Tears." Perspectives, 7:4-5 (December, 1992).

"Theological and Ethical Dimensions of American Evangelicals." In Southern Baptists &American Evangelicals: The Conversation Continues, edited by David S. Dockery, 138-148. Broadman &Holman Publishers, 1993.

"Educating For the Kingdom." Fuller Theological Seminary Presidential Inaugural Address, November 9, 1993. Theology News and Notes, 41(1):4-7(March 1994).

"Some Theological Assumptions for the Planning Process." Theology News and Notes, 41(1}:8-11 (March 1994).

"He was No Angel." Theology News and Notes, 41(2):4-7 (June 1994).

"On Switching Churches." Perspectives, 9:6(May 1994).

"Ending the Cold War Between Theologians and Laypeople: Why Christian Scholars Don't Trust Laypeople, and What Can be Done to Make the Relationship Better." Excerpt from Consulting the Faithful, 1994. Christianity Today 38:26-31 (July 18, 1994).

"Embracing Bad Taste: In Defense of Tacky Theology." Excerpt from Consulting the Faithful, 1994. Christian Century, 111:740-742(August 10-17, 1994).

"Should Mother Teresa Have Gone to Seminary?" Perspectives, 9:4-6 (October 1994).

"Iron Sharpening Iron: Exchange on Directional Pluralism." Co-authored with Sander Griffioen. Philosopl~ia Reforn~ata 60(1): 63-65 (1995).

"What the Old Dispensationalists Taught Me." Christianity Today 3934(March 6, 1995).

"Embrace of a Loving Savior." Decision, 36(10)32 (October 1995).

"`Evangelical': Pietistic Roots, Commihnent to Reform." Catalyst: Contemporary Evangelical Perspectives For United Methodist Seminarians, 22(1)(November 1995).

"Evangelicals and Roman Catholics in Dialogue." The Catholic World, 238(1428):259-264(November -December 1995).

"The Maturity Mandate: A Sermon." In Keeping Faith.• Embracing the Tensions in Christian Higher Education, edited by Ronald A. Wells, 1-7. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1996.

"Tolerance Without Compromise: Christian Engagement in an Era of Political Rancor." Christianity Today, 4033-35 (July 15, 1996).

"How to Choose a Seminary." In The 1996 Senainaiy and Graduate School Handbook. Evanston, Illinois: Berry Publishing Services, 1996.

"What If There Is Life On Mars?" Christian Reader, 57-58(May -June 1997).

"An Incarnational Administrator." Theology Neivs and Notes, 43(4):4-7 (June 1997).

"How Can I Find God?" In How Can IFind God?: The Famous and the Not-So-Fmnous Consider the Quintessential Question, edited by James Martin, 24-25. Liguori, Missouri: Triumph Books, 1997.

"For God Alone Is Good." In Living Lights Shining Stars: Ten Secrets to Becoming the Light ofthe World, by Dr. M. Norvel Young with Mary Hollingsworth, 185. West Monroe, La.: Howard Publishing Co., 1997.

"The Growing Edge of Evangelism." Theology News and Notes, 44(1)3 (March 1998).

"Babel Undone." First Things, 83:9-11 (May 1998).

"It's Time for Charismatic Calvinism." The Banner, 133(11):18-19(May 25, 1998).

1599818.] 53 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 54 of 117 Page ID #:1432

10 "The Protestant Theology of Abraham Kuyper." The Weekly Standard, 4(16):28-31 (January 4/January 11).

"The Women at the Concord Tomb." Books and Culture 5(1):34 (January-February 1999).

"Response to `Evangelicalism, Proselytism, and Common Witness." Pneuma: The Journal oftlae Societyfor Pentecostal Studies 21 (1): 75-77 (Spring 1999).

"Evangelical Ethics." In Where Shall My Wond'ring Soul Begin? The Landscape ofEvangelical Piety and Thought, edited by Mark A. Noll and Ronald F. Thiemann, 71-86. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 2000.

"Reflections on My Encounter with the Anabaptist-Methodist Tradition." The Mennonite Quarterly Review 74 (4): 571-576(October 2000).

"Violence and the Atonement." Books and Culture 7(1): 12-17(January/February 2001).

"The Chosen People Puzzle." Christianity Today, 45(4): 70-78(March 5, 2001).

"Looking through the Eyes of Parents: A Response to Kathryn Tanner." Theology Today 58 (1): 51-57 (Apri12001).

"A Bit of a Gadfly." In Serving the Clai»as ofJustice: The Thoughts ofPaul B. Henry, edited by Douglas L. Koopman, 115-119. Grrand Rapids, MI: Calvin College, 2001.

"Delete the `Post' from `Postconservative'." Books and Culture 7(3): 21-22(May/June 2001).

"Reflections on My Encounter with the Anabaptist-Mennonite Tradition." Engaging Anabaptism. Conversations with a Radical Tradition. Edited by John D. Roth, 117-124. Scottdale, Pa: Herald Press. 2001

"Response to Gundry." Evangelical Studies Bulletin. 19 (1): 2-3 (Spring, 2002).

"Christian Thinking about War and Peace". Theology, News and Notes. Fa112002

"The Sovereignty of God: Living Together in a Troubled Church and Broken World. Theology, News and Notes. Winter, 2003.

"Arguing about God, Arguing with God: Remembering Lew Smedes". Books and Culture 9(3):6 (March/April 2003).

"What Can Learning do to Us?"Pasadena Star News.com. www.pasadenastarnews,com/Stories/, October 17, 2003.

Book Reviews

Review of"The Unformed Conscience of Evangelicalism: Recovering the Church's Moral Vision," by J. Daryl Charles. Religious Studies Review, 29(4): 357-358 (October 2003).

"White Power, Black Power, God Power." Review ofBlack Power and Christian Responsibility, by C. Freeman Sleeper. Reformed Journal, 19(8):22-23 (October 1969).

Review ofFacts, Values and Ethics: A Confrontation with Tiventieth-Century British Mo~•al Philosophy i~7 Particular G.E. Moore, by James H. Olthuis. Calvin Theological Journal, 5(2):239-245 (November 1970).

"Christian Ethics." Review of The Ch~~istian New Morality, by O. Sydney Barr and Jesus mid Ethics: Four Interpretations, by Richard H. Hiers. Reformed Journal, 21(4):27-28 (April 1971).

Review ofBorn Again, by Charles Colson. Worldview, 19:50-51 (October 1976).

Review of The Evangelicals: What They Believe, Who They Are, YVhere They A~~e Changing, edited by David F. Wells and John D. Woodbridge. Calvin Theological Journal, 11:260-264(November 1976).

Review of Politics, Americanism and Christianity, by Perry C. Cotham. Westn~inste~~ Theological Journal, 40:170-172 (Fall 1977).

1599818.1 54 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 55 of 117 Page ID #:1433

11 Review of God and the Good: Essays in Honor ofHenry Stob, edited by Clifton Orlebeke and Lewis Smedes. Calvin TheologicalTournal, 12:188-190,(November 1977).

Review ofA Christian Declaration on Human Rights, edited by Allen O. Miller. Theology Today, 35(2):224-225 (July 1978).

`Black and Reformed." Review of Farewell to Innocence: A Socio-Ethical Study on Black Theology acrd Power, by Allan Boesak. Reformed Journal, 28(12):28-30 (December 1978).

Review of Social Theory and Practice, Crosscuts and Perspectives: Philosophical Essays in Honour ofProf. J.A.L. Talaard, edited by H. Conradie et al. Christian Scholars Review, 8(1):76-77 (1978).

Review of TFce Worldly Evangelicals: Has Success Spoiled America's Born Again Christians?, by Richard Quebedeaux. Worldview, 22:50 (April 1979).

Review of Christ and Violence, by Ronald J. Sider. Theology Today, 37(2):281-282 (July 1980).

"Civility and Commitment." Review ofBy Way ofResponse, by Martin E. Marty. Reformed.Tournal, 31(6):26-27 (June 1981).

"Appreciative Questions." Review ofLiberation 77aeology: An Evangelical Viewfrom the Third World, by 7. Andrew Kirk. Reformed Journal, 31(8):21-22(August 1981).

Review of God's People in God's World, by John Gladwin. Theological Students Fellowship Bulletin, 4(5):19-20 (April 1981).

Review of Roots of Western Culture: Pagan, Secular and Christian Options, by Herman Dooyeweerd. Christian Scholars Review, 10(4)349-352(1981).

Review of Hearing and Doing, edited by John Kraay and Anthony Tol. Calvin Theological Journal, 16:98-99 (April 1981).

"Politics and Religion." Review of The Naked Public Square: Religion and Democracy in America, by Richard John Neuhaus. Tl~e Banner, 119(37):20 (October 15, 1984}.

Review ofDivine Co~nlnands and Morality, edited by Paul Helm. Transformation, 1(3):29 (July-September 1984).

"No Easy Blueprint." Review of Christians in the Crisis: Toward Responsible CiCizenship, by Gerald Vandezande. The Banner, 120(39):20(November 4, 1985).

Review of YVhen War Is Unjust: Being Honest in Just-War Thinking, by John H. Yoder. Mennonite Quarterly Review, 59:415-416 (October 1985).

Review of God and Caesar: Christian Faith and Political Action, by John Eidsmoe. Calvin Theological.7ournal 22(1):123-126 (April 1987).

Review of After Fundamentalism: the Future ofEvangelical T7zeology, by Bernard L. Ramm. Calvin Theological Journal, 22(1):181 (April 1987).

"Ethics and Story." Review ofEthics: Systematic Theology, Vol. 1, by James W. McClendon, Jr. Reformed Journal, 3~(g~:aa-z~ ~a~gust i9s~~.

Review of Everything is Politics but Politics Is not Everything, by H.M. Kuitert, translated by John Bowden. This World, 18:116-119(Sumner 1987).

"The Quest for the Mormon tradition." Review ofEarly Mormonism and the Magic YYorld View, by Michael D. Quinn, and of Mormon Neo-O~~thodoxy: A Crisis Theology, by O. Kendall White, Jr. Reformed Journal, 38:20- 22(August 1988).

Review ofPublic Theology and Political Econon7y: Ch~~isfian Stewardship in Modern Society, by Max L. Stackhouse. International Bulletin ofMissionary Research, 12:22-24 (January, 1988).

1599815.1 55 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 56 of 117 Page ID #:1434

Review ofPeople ofthe Truth: The Power ofthe YYorshipping Community in the Modern Woi•ld, by Robert E. Webber and Rodney Clapp. The Princeton Seminary Bulletin 10(3):295-296 (1989).

"Solomonic Theology." Review of The Reshaping ofCatholicism: Current Challenges in the Theology ofChurch, by Avery Dulles. Reformed Journal, 39:22-23 (August 1989).

Review of American and Catholic: The New Debate, edited by Joe Holland and Anne Barsanti. Journal ofChurch and State 32(1):155-156(Winter 1990).

"The Mormon Murders." Review of Salamander: The Story ofthe Mon~~on Forgery Murders, by Linda Sillitoe and Allen D. Roberts, and of A Gathering ofSaints: A True Story ofMoney, Murder, and Deceit, by Robert Lindsey, and of The Mormon Mu~~ders: A True Story of Greed, Forgery, Deceit, and Death, by Steven Naifeh and Gregory W. Smith. Reforrraed Journal, 40: 30-31 (February 1990).

"Considering the `What' and the `Who' of Ecclesial Authority." Review ofPeter and Paul in the Church ofRome: The Ecumenical Potential ofa Forgotten Perspective, by William R. Farmer and Roch Kereszty. The New Oxford Review, 25-27(May 1991).

Review ofPower Religion: The Selling Out ofthe Evangelical Church? Edited by Michael Scott Horton. Christianity Today, 3737-38(March 8, 1993).

Review ofLuther and Calvin on SecularAutho~•ity, edited by Harro Hopfl. Canadian Philosophical Review, 13(1) Feb. 1993

"Reflections of a Wounded Lover." Review of The Scandal ofthe Evangelical Mind, by Mark A. Noll. Perspectives, 10:22-23 (February 1995).

"The Born-Again Identity: Alister McGrath's Sober But Hopeful Vision for the Future of Evangelicalism." Review of Evangelicalism and the Future of Christianity, by Alister McGrath. Christianity Today, 39(5):23-34(Apri124, 1995).

Review of Why Waco? Cults and the Battlefor Religious Freedom in America, by James D. Tabor and Eugene V. Gallagher. Books &Culture, 1 (1) 7-8 (January-February 1995).

"The Case for Christian Kitsch." Review of Maierial Christianity.• Religion and Popular Culture in America, by Colleen McDannell. Christianity Today, 40(5) 26-28 (Apri129, 1996).

Review of"Confessions ofa SexAddict". Michael Ryan. Books and Cultm•e, 3 (1): 20(January -February 1997).

Review of"Boychiks In The Hood: Travels in the Hasidic Dnderground". Robert Eisenberg. Christianity Today, p.21 (Apri128, 1997).

"Can a Real Mormon Believe in Jesus?" Review of"How Wide the Divide?" A Mo~•mon and an Evangelical in Conve~~sation, by Craig L. Blomberg and Stephen E. Robinson. Books and Culture, 3 (5):11 (September- October 1997).

"Science with Baloney Detectors." Review of Redeeming Culture: American Religion in an Age ofScience, by James Gilbert, and of Defeating Darwinism by Opening Minds, by Phillip E. Johnson. Christianity Today, 41(14):48- 50(December 8, 1997).

Review ofRevive Us Again: 77ie Reawakerxing ofAmerican Fundamentalism, by Joel Carpenter. The Weekly Standard, p35-36(February 2, 1998).

"Dogbert V. Machiavelli." Review of The Dilbert Principle, by Scott Adams, of Machiavelli's Virtue, by Harvey C. Mansfield, and of The P~•ince, by Niccolo Machiavelli. Books &Culture, 4(3)32-33 (May -June 1998)

Review of"Calvin in Context", by David Steinmetz. Pro Ecclesia: A Journal of Catlaolic ¢nd Evangelical Theology, 7(3): 370-371 Summer, 1998.

1599818.1 56 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 57 of 117 Page ID #:1435

13 "Where Civility Begins." Review of Civility: Manners, Morals and tlae Etiquette ofDemocracy by Steve L. Carter. Religion and Values in Pzrblic Life, 6(4):9(Summer 1998).

"Public Religion through Thick and Thin." Review of Politics, Religion, and the Coninzon Good: Advancing a Distinctly American Conversation about Religion in Our Shared Life, by Martin Marty, with Jonathan Moore. The Christian Century 117 (18): 648-651 (June 7-14, 2000).

"Booklines." Review ofJew vs. Jew—T7ie Strugglefor the Soul ofAmerican Jewry, by Samuel G. Freedman; The Lord Will Gather Me In—My Journey into Jewish Orthodoxy, by David Klinghoffer; A. J. Ayer: A Life, by Ben Rogers; The Knox Brothers, by Penelope Fox; and 7`lre Parting ofFriends —The Wilberforces and Henry Manning, by David Newsome. In The Cresset 64(4): 40-41 (Lent 2001).

" Resisting Church Divorce." Review of The Convictions that Drive Us and Divide Us, by Jack Haberer. Christianity Today. p.99 (June 11, 2001).

"Christians and Politics beyond the Culture Wars: An agendafor Engagement". Edited by David P. Gushee, Grand Rapids: Baker ,2000 in Theology Today, vol. 58, no.4 ,2002

"The Case for Paradise." Review of Heaven: The Logic ofEternal Joy. Jerry L . Walls. OUP. First Things, no: 131, March 2003

Review of"The Uninformed Conscience ofEvangelicalism: Recovering the Church's Moral Vision". J. Daryl Charles. Downers Grove, Il: Intervarsity Press. 2002. Religious Studies Review . March 2003

Review of"Choosing the Good: Christian Ethics in a Complex World". Denver P. Hollinger. Grand Rapids: Baker . 2002, in Religious Studies Review, vol. 29:2. Apri12003

Review of"The Younger Evangelicals: Facing the Challenges of the New World". Robert E. Webber, Grand Rapids: Baker 2002. Theology Today. Apri12003

Editorials

"The Church and Social Specifics." Reformed Journal, 14(6):2-4 (July-August 1969).

"Bertrand Russell, 1872-1970." Refo~~med Journal, 20(5):3-4(May -June 1970).

"Graham and Hope." Reformed Journal, 20(7):4 (September 1970).

"Calvinist--What's In a Name?" Reformed Journal, 21(2)3-4(February 1971).

"Technology: The Impossible and the Possible." Reformed Journal, 21(6):7-8 (July-August 1971).

`Emotion In the Christian Life." Reformed Journal, 22(3): 4-5 (March 1972).

"Peace, Peace...." Reformed Journal, 22(10):5-6 (December 1972).

"On Criticizing Billy Graham." Reformed Jotmnal, 23(5)3-4(May-)une 1973).

"Synod and Waz."Reformed.journal, 23(5):7-8(May -June 1973).

"Conscience in Church and State." Reformed .journal, 23(7):5-6 (September 1973).

"Where I'm At." Reforn~ed Journal, 23(10):3-4(December 1973).

"Far As the Curse is Found." Reformed Journal, 23(10):4-5 (December 1973).

"Limiting the Atonement." Reformed Journal, 23(2):4-5 (February 1974).

"Echoes from the `20s."Reformed Journal, 24(3):7-8 (March 1974).

159981 B.1 57 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 58 of 117 Page ID #:1436

14 "A Call to Repent."(With Nicholas Wolterstorff.) Reformed Journal, 24(4):3-5 (April 1974).

"Evangelical `Liberals' and `Religious Language'." Reformed Journal, 24(6):45 (July-August 1974). Reprinted as "The Evangelical Senators Don't Fit Simple Molds." Christian Century, 91(32):882-883 (September 25, 1974).

"Evangelical Social Concern: Why I Signed." Reformed Journal, 24(7):6-7 (September 1974).

"Some Remarks on the Pardon." Refornsed Journal, 24(8)3-4(October 1974).

"On Scholarship and Discipleship." Reformed Journal, 25(1):6-7 (January 1975).

"Calvinists and Catholic Renewal." Reformed Journal, 25(2):6-7 (February 1975).

"Such Talk!" Reformed Journal, 25(4):3-4(April 1975).

"Our National Headphones." Reformed.Iournal, 25(5):4-5(May -June 1975).

"Dispensationalism and Political Theology." Reformed Journal, 25(6):2-3 (July-August 1975).

"Dealing With the `Women's Issue'." Reformed Journal, 25(9):2-3 (November 1975).

"Conspiracies All Around?" Reformed Journal, 25(10):5-6(December 1975).

"On Being Permissive About Filth." Reformed Journal, 26(2):3-5 (February 1976).

"Long Live (?)the Flag!" Reformed Journal, 26(7):5 (September 1976).

"Bad Sermons." Refoi~n2ed Journal, 26(9):4-5 (November 1976).

"He Noticed!" Reformed Journal, 26(10):2-3 (December 1976).

"The Brainwashing of Merylee Kreshower." Reformed Journal, 27(1):2-3 (January 1977).

"Possibility Thinking." Reformed Journal, 27(6):2-3 (June 1977).

"Baptismal Politics." Reformed Journal, 28(7)2-3 (July 1978).

"Calvinists in Witzieshoek." Reformed.Iournal, 28(9):2 (September 1978).

"What Do We Disdain?" Reformed .Iournal, 28(12):2-4(December 1978).

"Marketing and Mission." Reformed,Iournal, 29(1)3-4 (January 1979). Reprinted in The Marketplace(May -June 1986).

"An Easter Meditation." Reformed Journal, 29(4):2-3 (April 1979).

"Impossible Deadlines." Reformed Journal, 29(7):2-3 (July 1979).

"The Authorities as Ministers." Reformed Journal, 30(7):2-3 (July 1980).

"Another Reformation." Reformed Journal, 30(11):3-4(November 1980).

"Marital Lust." Reformed Journal, 30(12):6 (December 1980).

"Presidential Debate." Reformed Journal, 31(1):2-3 (January 1981).

"Reversing a Pattern." Reformed Journal, 31(2):2-3 (February 1981).

"`And By Thy Blood'." Reformed Journal, 31(3):3-5 (March 1981).

"The Wages of Sin." Reformed .Ioz~~•nal, 31(4):4 (April 1981).

]599818.1 58 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 59 of 117 Page ID #:1437

"Jubilee 1981." Reformed Journal, 31(4):6 (April 1981).

"Realism and the Bomb." Reforr~aed.7ournal, 31(5):4(May 1981).

"Giant Heresies:' Reformed Journal, 31(6):5-6 (June 1981).

"Gay and Straight." Reformed Journal, 31(8):3-4 (August 1981). Reprinted in Christian Living (January 1982).

"Dutch Pillars." Reformed Journal, 32(5):2-3(May 1982).

"Airport Evangelism." Refo~~med Journal, 32(6):5 (June 1982).

"Sectarian Religiosity." Reformed Journal, 33(4):2-3 (April 1983).

"Evangelical Historians." Reformed Journal, 33(5):4-5(May 1983). Reprinted in The Bulletin (November-December 1983).

"Learning from the Bishops." Reformed Journal, 33(7):2-3 (July 1983).

"Rethinking Ecumenism." Refor~ned.7ournal, 33(9):2-4 (September 1983).

"Of Churches and Confessions." Refo~~med Journal, 34(5):2-3(May 1984).

"Christian Love for Homosexuals." The Banner, 119(33):6-7 (September 17, 1984).

"Following the Church Year(s)." Reformed Journal, 35(3):4-5 (March 1985).

"Popery and Potpourri." Reformed Tournal, 35(6):2-3 (June 1985).

"Prayer Before Breakfast." Reformed Journal, 36(5):2-3(May 1986).

"Bishop Dinah." Reformed Journal, 36(1):'5 (January 1986).

"The Lesson of Haiti." Reformed Journal, 37(2):4-5 (February 1987).

"Those Surprising Ashes." Refon~aed Journal, 37(3):2-3 (March 1987).

"Our Only Comfort." Reformed Journal, 37(5):4-5(May 1987).

"Busy." Reformed Journal, 37(5)3-4(May 1987).

"Calvinists at Bethlehem7" The Banner, 122(45):6-7(December 21, 1987).

"Selfhood with Boundaries." Reformed Journal, 39(9)3-4(September 1989).

"`Natural' Spirituality." Perspectives 7:4 Oct. 1992.

"To The Jew First: Witnessing to the Jews is Nonnegotiable." Christianity Today, 41(9):12-13 (August 11, 1997). Reprint in Circuit Rider, (7anuary-February 1997).

Other: Responses, Symposia, Articles in Dictionaries, Introductions, Etc.

"Response to Carvill and Forbes." Reforn7ed Journal, 21(7):32(September 1971).

"Language, Ethical." In Baker's Dictionary of Christian Ethics, edited by Carl F. H. Henry, 377-379. Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1973.

"If a Choice is Necessary." Worldview 17(12):9-10 (December 1974).

1599818.1 59 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 60 of 117 Page ID #:1438

16 "Reaction to Two Book Reviews." Christian Scholars Review, 4(2):140 (1974).

"Of Sanity and Judgment." Worldview, 18(6):42-44(June 1975).

"Are `Bad Sermons' Possible?"(with Nicholas Wolterstorf~ Reformed Journal, 27(11):8-11 (November 1977).

Response to "Toward a Biblical View of `Human Rights'," by Gordon Spykman. RES Theological Forum, 7(1) (December 1979).

"Christian Faith in a World of Autonomous Disciplines." Proceedings of the Conference on Faith and Learning, Bethel College, Kansas, 1980.

"Reply to R.7. Neuhaus." Center• Journal, 1(3):60-65 (Summer 1982).

"A Thoughtful Approach: Understanding the Discipline of Communal Dialogue." Evangelical Newsletter, Nov. 11, 1983.

"Richard Mouw: A Christian Reformed Teacher." In Peacemakers: Christian Voices Frons the New Abolitionist Movement, edited by Jim Wallis, 129-134. San Francisco: Harper &Row, 1983.

"Christians in North America." In Christianity: A World Faith, edited by Robin Keeley and Robert J. Banks. Trig, Australia: Lion Publishing, 1985.

"An Evangelical Response." Response to E. Sullivan,"Reception: Factor and Moment in Ecumenism," pp.105-110. Ecumenical Trends, 15(7):113-115 (July-August 1986).

Forward to The Illuminating Icon, by Anthony Ugolnik, viii-xi. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1989.

"The Ethics of Teaching Ethics: A Round Table Discussion," edited by G. Meilaender. In Annual ofthe Society of Christian Ethics, edited by D. Yeager. Washington D.C.: Georgetown University Press, 1989.

"Some Neglected Factors In Soteriological Debate." Ecumenical Ti~ends, 19/2:24-27 (February 1990).

"The Life of Bondage in the Light of Grace." Christianity Today, 32:41-44 (Dec. 9, 1988). Reprinted in Steps, 11- 12:6-7 (Fall 1990).

"Social Ethics." In Dictionary of Christianity in America. Edited by Daniel G. Reid, Robert D. Linder, Bruce L. Shelley, and Harry S. Stout, 1101-1104. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 1990.

"Political Theology." In Dictionary ofChristianity in fimer•ica. Edited by Daniel G. Reid, Robert D. Linder, Bruce L. Shelley, and Harry S. Stout, 915-916. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 1990.

"Reformed and Presbyterian Churches." In Dictionary of Christianity in America. Edited by Daniel G. Reid, Robert D. Linder, Bruce L. Shelley, and Harry S. Stout, 1024-1033. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 1990.

"Iron Sharpening Iron: Exchange on Directional Pluralism." With Sander GrifFioen. Philosophia Reformata, 60(1): 63-66 (January 1995).

"Scandal? A Forum On the Evangelical Mind." Christianity Today, 39:21-27 (August 14, 1995).

"Foreword." In Theological Education in the Evangelical Tradition, edited R. Albert Mohler, Jr. and Darryl G. Hart, 7. Grand Rapids, Michigan, Baker Books, 1996.

"Seminary Leaders Speak Out: Theological Education in a Turbulent World." Christianity Today, 40(2):47-72 (February 5, 1996).

"Religion and MoraliTy" In Routledge Encyclopedia ofPhilosophy, edited by Edward Craig, et. al., 8.218-224. London/New York: Routledge, 1998.

"Recommended Readings." Christianity Today, 42(5)35 (April 27, 1998).

1599818.1 60 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 61 of 117 Page ID #:1439

17 Foreword to Catholics and Evangelicals: Do They Share a Common Future?, edited by Thomas P. Rausch. New York: Paulist Press, 2000.

Foreword to The Calvinistic Concept ofCulture, by Henry R. Van Til, ix-xvi. Grand Rapids: Baker Books,[1959, 1972] 2001.

Forward to Front Rebellion to Redemption. A Journey through the Great Themes of Christian Faith. Randal Working. Colorado Springs: NavPress. 2001.

Foreword to reprint of The Uneasy Conscience Mode~~n Fundamentalism, by Carl F. H. Henry. Grand Rapids, Michigan: William B., Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2003

Fuller Publications

"A Word from the President." The Fuller Focus, Spring 1994.

"Memo from the President." The Fuller Focus, Winter 1995.

"The President's Focus: The Center ofthe Universe." The Fuller Focus, Spring 1995.

"Be Ye Restless: Some Parting Words to Our Graduates." The Semi, Spring Week 10, 1995.

"Vision to Action: The Big Picture." The Fuller Focus, Fall 1995.

"Psychology and Faith at Fuller: AThirty-Year Journey." The Fuller Focus, Spring 1996.

"Our Continuing Assignment." The Semi, May 1996.

"To All the Tribes and Peoples and Nations." The Fuller Focus, Summer 1996.

"Preaching Worth Pondering." The Fuller Focus, Fall 1996.

"David Allan Hubbard: His Life and Legacy." The Semi, July 1996.

"Lord of the Classroom." The Semi, Fall 1996.

Untitled. The Semi, September 1996.

"A Year of Questions and Weavings." The Semi, Spring 1997.

"An Incarnational Administrator." Fuller Theology, News, and Notes, June 1997.

"The Growing Edge of Evagelicalism." Fuller• Theology, News, and Nodes, October 1997.

"A Celebration of Faithfulness: Words from Gary Demarest, Trustee, and FTS President Richard J. Mouw." The Senti, Fall, 1997.

"Oversize Religion." The Fuller Focus, Winter 1998.

"Living in the Age of `Afters'." The Fuller Focus, Spring 1998.

"Keeping the Vision." The Senri, Spring Quarter, 1998.

"To Tell the Old, Old Story." The Fuller Focz~s, Fall 1998.

"An Imperialist Welcome." The Semi, Fall 1998.

"Brother Ray's `Christian Stuff'." The Farller Focus, Winter 1999.

"Learning in a Time of War." The Semi, Spring 1999.

1599818.1 61 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 62 of 117 Page ID #:1440

"Of Rivers and Seminaries." The Fuller Focus, Summer 1999.

"Do We Need Seminaries?" The Fuller Focus, Fall 1999.

"Prepping for E.R." The Semi, Fall 1999.

"A Sense of Calling." The Fuller Focus, Spring 2000.

"Feeling Our Identity." The Semi, September 2000.

"Keep Thinking!" The Semi, Fa112001.

"Theory and Practice." The Fuller Focus, Winter 2001.

"Loving and Grace-full Theological Education." The Fuller Focus, Spring 2001.

"The `Jesus Factor'." The Fuller Focus, Fa112001.

"The One Who Is the Answer." The Fuller Focus, Spring 2002.

"A Presidential Word to a Gifted Community." The Semi, Spring 2002.

"Mercy and Accountability." The Fuller Focus, Summer 2002.

"On `Manifold Ministries'." The Fuller Focus, Fa112002.

"Large Vision, Steady Focus." The Semi, Fa112002.

"Christian Thinking About War and Peace." Fuller Theology, News, and Notes, Fa112002.

"Do Something Religious!" The Senai, Spring 2003.

"Grace is Everywhere." The Fuller Focus, Summer 2003.

"Visualization." The Semi, Fa112003.

"Mormons and Evangelicals: A Dialogue Whose Time Has Come." The Senai, Winter 2003.

"The Sovereignty of God: Living Together in a Troubled Church and Broken World." Fuller Theology, News, and Notes, Winter 2003.

"Seeking and Serving." The Fuller Focus, Winter 2004.

"Taken aback by Fuller's `fame'." The Fuller Focus, Spring 2004.

"Seeking the Lost." Farller Theology, News, and Notes, Spring 2004.

"In Search of `Saints and Poets'." The Fuller Foczrs, Fa112004.

"'Talk to Max'." The Fuller Focus, Winter 2005.

"Leading Change: Partnering for the Future." The Fuller Focus, Spring 2005.

"'A Story to Tell to the Nations'." The Fuller Focus, Fa112005.

"The Excitement Continues!" The Fuller Foca~s, Winter 2006.

"Spiritual Eyesight." The Fuller• Focus, Spring 2006.

"God Also Cares about What We Are." The Fuller Focus, Fa112006.

1599818.1 62 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 63 of 117 Page ID #:1441

T "Reflecting on `Hidden Abuses'." The Senii, Fa112006.

"Acting Justly, Loving Mercy, Walking Humbly." The Fuller Focus, Winter 2007.

"Educating and Blessing:'The Fuller Focus, Spring 2007.

"The Journey is Part ofthe Gift." Fuller Theology, Neias, and Notes, Spring 2007.

"A Micah 6:8 Year." Tlie Sen7i, Spring 2007.

"In Our 60`'' Year: Still Uneasy." The Fuller Focus, Fall 2007.

"Pursuing our Mission Beyond the Mission." The Fuller Focus, Winter 2008.

"'Going Further." The Fuller Focus, Spring 2008.

"Times of Crisis." The Fuller Focus, Winter 2009.

"An Apostolic Mandate." The Fuller Focus, Spring 2009.

"Witnessing, Learning, and Cooperating: Fuller's Commihnent to Dialogue." The Fulle~~ Focus, Fa112009.

"The Heart of the Matter: Seminary and Church in a Changing World." The Fuller Focus, Winter 2010.

"Fuller in the World: Thinking Theologically about Culture." The Fuller Focus, Spring 2010.

"To the Ends of the Earth: Fuller's Global Mission." The Fuller Focus, Fa112010.

"Fuller and Leadership: Preparing Servants for the Kingdom." The Fzrller Focus, Winter 2011.

"Evangelism: Keeping it High on the List." The Fuller Focus, Spring 2011.

"Integration at Fuller: A Trialogue Favoring Gerunds over Nouns." 77ze Fuller Focus, Fall 2011.

"Biblical Scholarship: Linking the Core and the Edge." The Fuller Focus, Spring 2012.

Online

Presidents Blog

"Launching a New Blog — MySpace." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, enhy posted December 4, 2006

"Jesus and Santa Claus." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted December 11, 2006.

"N.I.L. Initiative for Peace in the Middle East." Mouw's Musings: The President s Blog, entry posted January 2, 2007.

"Economic Decisions." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted January 4, 2007.

"Saddam's Execution — Is It Justified?" Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted January 9, 2007.

"Jack Bauer Is Bacic." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted January 19, 2007.

"God and the Super Bowl." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted January 29, 2007.

"Tears at the Car Wash." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 5, 2007.

1599818.1 63 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 64 of 117 Page ID #:1442

"Saying Something Theological." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 12, 2007.

"Discussing Evolution with Care." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 23, 2007.

"A Larger View of T'heocracy." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted, March 8, 2007.

"No More Divisions?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted March 19, 2007.

"Calvinism and Sewage." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted March 26, 2007.

"Woodbine Willie." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted Apri13, 2007.

"Thoughts about the Lord's Table." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted Apri19, 2007.

"Asking Good Questions." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted April 16, 2007.

"Warrior Monks?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted Apri123, 2007.

"Reflections from South Korea." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, enhy posted May 1, 2007.

"Anneal Rights." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog entry posted May 7, 2007.

"Preaching at Virginia Tech." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 14, 2007.

"Talking Past Each Other." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 23, 2007.

"A Theology of Cuteness." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 29, 2007.

"No Problem?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted June 6, 2007.

"Critical Thinking." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted June 18, 2007.

"A Plain Truth Itony?" Mouw's Musings: T'he President's Blog, entry posted June 25, 2007.

"Worship and National Holidays." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted June 29, 2007.

"On How We Hold These Truths." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted July 8, 2007.

"Understanding the Prosperity Gospel." Mouw's Musings: T'he President's Blog, entry posted July 18, 2007.

"The One True Church(es)." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted July 25, 2007.

"Supporting Israel." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted August 2, 2007.

"T'he Lesson of Ancient Seas." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted August 8, 2007.

"False Teachers and False Teachings." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted August 22, 2007.

"Toward a Theology of Hugging." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted September 4, 2007.

"Evangelical Manners." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted September 21, 2007.

"Never Mind!" Mouw's Musings:'The Presidents Blog, entry posted October 11, 2007.

"Halloween and the Reformation." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted October 29, 2007.

"The First Biggest Threat" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 6, 2007. 1599818.1 64 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 65 of 117 Page ID #:1443

"A Teaching Moment for Mormonism?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Slog, enhy posted November 12, 2007.

"Norman Mailers Labeling System." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 20, 2007.

"The Importance of Is." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 27, 2007.

"Thoughts about Rudolph and Company." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted December 13, 2007.

"2008 — A Year for Beholding." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted January 4, 2008.

"The Cross and Capital Punishment." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted January 11, 2008.

"Thinking about Tourism." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted January 22, 2008.

"Hymns as Compacted Theology." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 4, 2008.

"Of Chocolates and Sermons." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 12, 2008.

"Apologizing to Muslims." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 18, 2008.

"Spiritual Nurture and the Local Church." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted March 10, 2008.

"Seeker-Sensitive Preaching and Karl Barth." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted March 18, 2008.

"Lectures in Korea." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted March 26, 2008.

"Traditional or Seeker-Sensitive?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted Apri18, 2008.

"Singing the Good News: At Fuller Seminary and on American Idol." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted April 14, 2008.

"Reflecting on the Pope's Visit." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted Apri121, 2008.

"Dealing with Divorce." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted Apri128, 2008.

"Evangelism and Public Discipleship." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 8, 2008.

"A Forgetful Messiah?" Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, enhy posted May 23, 2008.

"The Politics of Nurture." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted June 1, 2008.

"Influential Books." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted June 12, 2008.

"Seeds of Rebellion." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted June 16, 2008.

"Mamage —the Public Debate." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted June 25, 2008.

"Dealing with Alterations." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted July 9, 2008.

"On Being a Van Tilian." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted July 16, 2008.

"Honoring the Washerwoman." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted July 21, 2008.

"Waiting for the One." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted July 28, 2008.

"The Attributes of God." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted August 14, 2008.

1599818.1 65 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 66 of 117 Page ID #:1444

22 "In Touch with Angels." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted August 19, 2008.

"Predictive Prophecy as Motivation." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted August 25, 2008.

"Toward a Theology of Cremation." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted September 2, 2008.

"Death as the Defeated Enemy." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted September 8, 2008.

"The Difficulty ofSelf-Knowledge." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted September 15, 2008.

"Governor Palin's Prayer Request." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted September 22, 2008.

"Cheer and Gloom." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted September 29, 2008.

"Being Nice to Catholics." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted October 7, 2008.

"Church Properly Disputes:' Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted October 13, 2008.

"Belonging to Jesus." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted October 20, 2008.

"Unknown Leaders." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted October 29, 2008.

"You Never Know!" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 10, 2008.

"Evangelicals Are Celebrating Obama, Too." Mouw's Musings: T'he President's Blog, entry posted November 13, 2008.

"Evangelical Ecumenism." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, enhy posted December 1, 2008.

"More from the Cesspool about Catholicism." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted December 6, 2008.

"Holy Competition?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted December 23, 2008.

"Sex, Stealing and Scripture." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, enhy posted January 26, 2009.

"The President as a Nursing King?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted January 29, 2009.

"Calvinism at the National Prayer Breakfast." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 12, 2009.

"Avoiding Solipsism." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 23, 2009.

"Giving Gethsemane its Due." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, enhy posted March 9, 2009.

"Money Talks." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted March 17, 2009.

"Fool-osophy." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted March 25, 2009.

"Allan Boesak —Earlier versus Later." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted Apri121, 2009.

"Reflections on a Formative Friendship." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 6, 2009.

"Prayers —Closeted or otherwise?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 18, 2009.

"Spelling Bees —the Larger Lessons." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted May 29, 2009.

"Can the Coleopterists Help?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted June 8, 2009. 1599818.1 66 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 67 of 117 Page ID #:1445

"About Being a Movement." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted June 22, 2009.

"Turkish Delight?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted July 10, 2009.

"Evangelical Students —Are We Ready for Them?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted July 30, 2009.

"Thoughts about Hell." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted August 17, 2009.

"Teenage Vampires." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted August 31, 2009.

"A Bavinck Revival —May it Spread!" Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted September 9, 2009.

"Looking for the Name." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted September 21, 2009.

"A Time for Singing Kumbaya?" Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted September 30, 2009.

"More on Belhar." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted October 9, 2009.

"Calvinist' does not mean "grim." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted October 22, 2009.

"Honoring Ancestors." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted October 26, 2009.

"Advertising the Gospel?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted October 29, 2009.

"A Covenanter Commemoration." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 9, 2009.

"A Vatican Investigation." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 18, 2009.

"Thoughts from New Orleans." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 22, 2009.

"Speaking of Gods Judgment." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 30, 2009.

"Witnessing Where the Masons Gather." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted December 5, 2009.

"A Vote for a Poetic Revision." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted January 3, 2010.

"On Seminaries and Dinosaurs." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted January 13, 2010.

"The Devil in Haiti." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted January 19, 2010.

"Computers, Chess and the Heart" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 7, 2010.

"Atheism and Liberal Theology." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 14, 2010.

"Two Cheers for the Free Market." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 22, 2010.

"Staying Faithful to Genesis 1." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted March 5, 2010.

"A Final Word (from me at least) on Belhar." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted March 10, 2010.

"Gratuitous Praying." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted May 13, 2010.

"On Being Creepy." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 18, 2010.

"Some 24 'Theology?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 26, 2010.

1599818.1 67 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 68 of 117 Page ID #:1446

24 "What Constantine Had Right." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted June 6, 2010.

"A Cure for Empathy Deficiency." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, enhy posted June 14, 2010.

"Small People, Little People." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, enhy posted June 22, 2010.

"T'he Burga and the Habit" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, enhy posted July 6, 2010.

"Gods Two Books." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, enhy posted July 11, 2010.

"Meeting Billy Berger." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted July 19, 2010.

"Using the Atonement Putter." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted July 29, 2010.

"Multifaceted Witnessing." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted August 5, 2010.

"Christ Without the Church?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted August 9, 2010.

"Gods Grammatical Preferences." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted August 12, 2010.

"What Difference does it make to open class with prayer? Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, enhy posted August 18, 2010.

"Glenn Becks Mormonism." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted September 1, 2010.

"Celebrating Newman." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted September 10, 2010.

"How to Bring Joy to Harry and David." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted September 29, 2010.

"Halloween —Gargoyles and Pumpkins." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted October 18, 2010.

"Cultural `Engagement."' Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted October 29, 2010.

"Conviction and Civility in American Public Discourse." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted November 7, 2010.

"On Humility." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 17, ZO10.

"Vernon Grounds, RIP." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 23, 2010.

"Religion as Socially `Useful."' Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 29, 2010.

"Measuring the Ark." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted December 15, 2010.

"Pietism —Weaknesses and Strengths." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted January 15, 2011.

"When the Animals Will Form a Choir." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted January 30, 2011.

"What to Look For in the Super Bowl." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 2, 2011.

"Gods Preferential Option for the Poor." Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted February 8, 2011.

"Why Don't Jews `Evangelize' Jews?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted February 20, 2011.

"The Orthodoxy of Rob Bell." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted March 15, 2011.

"More Thoughts about `Generous Orthodo~cy."' Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted March 29, 2011. 1599818.1 68 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 69 of 117 Page ID #:1447

"Hindus in Heaven —How Many?" Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, enhy posted Apri18, 2011.

"Diverse Gifts — In the Academy Also." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted Apri130, 2011.

"Our Heavenly `Home."' Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 5, 2011.

"Post Rapture Theological Education? Just in Case." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 9, 2011.

"Osama Bin Laden: Heaven and Hell Questions." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 13, 2011.

"Failed Prophecy." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted May 30, 2011.

"My `Bible Prophecy'(And Violin Playing) Past." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted June 23, 2011.

"The `Not Proven' Option." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted July 11, 2011.

"Praying and Talking about a `Calling."' Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted July 26, 2011.

"A Meal with John Stott." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted July 28, 2011.

"Wisdom from Steve Jobs7" Mouw's Musings: The Presidents Blog, entry posted October 6,2011.

"Ice Cream a8er Funerals." Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 4, 2011.

"'Knowing Mormons."' Mouw's Musings: The President's Blog, entry posted November 24, 2011.

"Babel Undone." Web Exclusives, First Things. http://www.firstthings.com/article/1998/OS/002-babel-undone [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Heaven: the Logic of Eternal Joy." Web Exclusives, First Things. http•//www.firsttlungs.coin/article/2003/03/heaventhe-logic-of-eternal-jov [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Surprised by Calvin." Web Exclusives, First Things. http://www.firstthings.com/article/2009/03/002-surprised-bv- calvin [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Young and Irresponsible." Web Exclusives, First Things, http://www.firstthin~s.com/web- exclusives/2009/03/voun~and-irresponsible [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Surveillance Technologies and Bible Prophecy." Web Exclusives, First Things. http://www.firstthings.com/web- exclusives/2013107/surveillance-tecluiolo~ies-and-bible-prophecy [accessed November 19, 2014].

"What I Learned from Robert Bellah." Web Exclusives, First Things. http://www.firstthin~s.com/web- exclusives/2013/08/what-i-learned-fiom-robert-bellah [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Halloween and the Power of Evil." Web Exclusives, First Things. http://www.firstthin~s.com/web- exclusives/2013/10/halloween-and-flee-power-of-evil [accessed November 19, 2014].

"On Not Being Prophetic." Web Exclusives, First Things. http://www.firstthings.com/web-exclusives/2014/O 1/on-not- beingprophetic [accessed November 19, 20]4].

"Mormon Catholicism." Web Exclusives, First Things. http://www.firstthin~s.com/article/2014/OS/mormon- catholicisin [accessed November 19, 2014].

1599818.1 69 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 70 of 117 Page ID #:1448

"Our Slippery Slopes." Web Exclusives, First Things. http://www.firstthings.com/blogs/firsfthou~hts/2014/07/our- sliuperv-slopes [accessed November 19, 2014].

"The Evangelical Community." Web Exclusive, First Things. htt~//wv✓w.firstthings.com/web-exclusives/2014/08/the- evan~elical-academy [accessed November 19, 2014].

"My Favorite Heretic." Web Exclusive, First Things. http://www.firstthin~s.com/web-exclusives/2014/09/mv- favorite-heretic [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Retirement Home Christianity." Web Exclusive, First Things. http://www.fustthings.com/web- exclusives/2014/10/retirement-home-christianity [accessed November 19, 2014].

"A New Opportunity for Mormonism?" Beliefnet. http•//www.beliefnet.con~/Faiths/Christianity/2008/06/A-New- Ovuortuiuty-For-Mormonism.as~x [accessed November 19, 2014].

"A Christmas Message for those Sore Afraid." Beliefnet. http://www.beliefnet.com/Faiths/Christianity/2002/12/A- Cluist~nas-Message-For-Those-Sore-Afiaid.aspx [accessed November 19, 2014].

"A Modest Defense ofPolygamy." Beliefnet. http:Nwww.beliefnet.coul/Faiths/Christianity/Latter-Day- Saints/2001/OS/A-Modest-Defense-Of-Polygamy.asux [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Exploring the Deeper Magic." Beliefnet. http://www.beliefiiet.com/Entertainment/Movies/The-Chronicles-Of- Namia-Prince-Caspian/Exploring-Tl~e-Deeper-Ma ~ic.aspx?~=1 [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Dinner with God: Tofu or Steak?" Beliefnet. htt~//www.beliefnet.com/Faiths/2003/06/Dinner-With-God-Tofu-Or- Steak.aspx?p=3 [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Does God Love Forests More Than Cities?" Beliefnet. httQ/h~vww.beliefnet.com/Faiths/Clu7stianity/2006/04/Does- God-Love-Forests-More-Than-Cities.aspx [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Machiavelli and Christian Leadership." Faith and Leadership. http://www.faithandleadership.con~/content/richard-j- mouw-machiavelli-and-Christian-leadership [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Put on the Attire of Leadership." Faith and Leadership. http://www.faithandleadershi~con~/content/richard-j-mouw- put-the-attire-leadership [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Leadership: it's not only for administrators." Faith and Leadership. http•//www faithandleadership.com/content/richard-j-moues-leadership-its-not-only-for-administrators [accessed November 19, 2014].

`Engaging both high and low culture." Faith and Leadership. htt~//www.faithandleaderslup.coin/content/richard-i- mouw-enga~uig-both-high-and-low-culture [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Congregants long for pastors to understand their work lives." Faith and Leadership. http•//www faithandleadersh~ con~/contendrichardj-moues-conQregants-lon~for-pastors-understand-their- work-lives [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Varieties of leadership?" Faith and Leadership. http://www.faithandleadership.com/blog/04-04-2011/richard-j- mouw-varieties-leaderships [accessed November 19, 2014].

"The theological significance of grits." Faith and Leadership, http://www.faithandleadership.com/blog/02-03- 2011/richardj-moues-the-theolo~cal_significance- mer its [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Don't panic, improvise." Faith and Leadership. http://www.faitl~andleadership.com/blo~[11-29-2010/richard-j- mouw-dont-panic-unprovise [accessed November 19, 2014].

1599818.1 70 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 71 of 117 Page ID #:1449

2~ "What difference does it make to open class with prayer?" Faith and Leadership. http•//www faithandleadership com/blo~/08-17-2010/richardJ-inouw-what-difference-does-it-make-open-class- prayer [accessed November 19, 2014

"Civility declines when we stop eating together." Faith and Leadership. http://~~vvvvv.faithandleadership.com/blo 242010/richard-moues-civility-declines-when-we-stop-eating-together [accessed November 19, 2014].

"What makes for an `indigenous' hymn?" Faith and Leadership. http://~~ww.faithandleadership.com/blo 03-30- 2010/richard-j-moues-what-makes-for-indigenous-hymn [accessed November 19, 2014].

"How to speak out interreligiously." Faith and Leadership. http://vvww.faithandleadership.com/blo 02-17- 2010/richard-j-moues-how-speak-out-inteireli giously [accessed November 19, 2014].

"We need more religious zeal, not less." Faith and Leadership. http://w~vw.faithandleadership.com/blo 12-21- 2009/richard-j-moues-we-need-more-relieious-zeal-not-less [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Is Faith a matter of feeling or formation?" Faith and Leadership. http:/h~vww.faithandleadership.com/blo~/12-01- 20091richard-i-moues-faith-matter-feeling-or-formation [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Advertising the gospel?" Faith and Leadership. http://www.faithandleadersl~ip.com/blo~/10-28-2009/richard-j- mouw-advertising-the-gospel [accessed November 19, 2014].

"'Calvinist' does not mean `grim'." Faith and Leadership. http://www.faithandleadersl~i~com/blog/09-14- 2009/richardj -moues-Calvinist-does-not-mean-grim [accessed November 19, 2014].

com/blog/08-28-2009/richardj-inouw- "For a civil parking lot." Faith and Leadership. httu•//vw✓w faithandleadership for-civil-parking-lot [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Where is Sartre when you need him?" Faith and Leadership. http://www.faitliandleadership.com/blog/06-26- 2009/richard-inouw-where-sartre-when-you-need-hun [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Prayers, closeted or otherwise?" Faith and Leadership. http://www.faithandleadership.com/blo~,/OS-18-2009/richard- tnouw-prayers-closeted-or-otherwise [accessed November 19, 2014].

"A Prayer in Beijing." Faith and Leadership. http://www.faithandleadership.com/blog/03-31-2009/richard-mouw- praver-beijin~ [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Wesley for Calvinists." Faith and Leadership. http://www.faithandleadershi~.com/blo~/03-18-2009/richard-mouw- wesley-for-calvu~ists [accessed November 19, 2014].

"What to say about the downturn." Faith and Leadership. http://~u~~vw.faithandleadership.com/blo 02-24- 2009/richard-,Lmouw-what-say-about-the-downturn [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Calvinism at the National Prayer Breakfast." Faith and Leadership. http://www.faithandleadership.com/blog/02-17- 2009/richard-moues-calviiusm-the-national-prayer-breakfast [accessed November 19, 2014].

"The president as a nursing king?" Faith and Leadership. http://www.faithandleadership.com/blo~/01-28- 2009/richard-moues-the-president-nursingking [accessed November 19, 2014].

"Getting to the Crux of Calvary." Christianity Today. l~tt~://www.christianitvtoda~com/ct/2012/may/betting-to-the- crux-of-calvarv.html [accessed November 25, 2014].

"An Open-Handed Gospel." Chrisrianity Today. htt~://www.christianiTytodaY.com/ct/2008/apriV15.44.htm1 [accessed November 25, 2014].

"Carl Henry Was Right." Christianity Today. hrip://www.christianitytoda~com/ct/2010/januai~25.301ihnl [accessed November 25, 2014].

] 599818.1 71 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 72 of 117 Page ID #:1450

EXHIBIT 5

72 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 73 of 117 Page ID #:1451

BARBARA C. LUNA

Barbara C. Luna is a Senior Partner in the accounting and litigation services firm of White, Zuckerman, Warsayslcy, Luna &Hunt, LLP. She has served as an expert witness for over thirty years in business and personal injury litigation and bankruptcy matters. Dr. Luna analyzes financial, accounting, economic, business, real estate and valuation issues relating to liability and damages in litigation matters and reorganization of businesses. The matters she has been involved in include breach of contract, intellectual property, unfair competition, construction and real estate, business interruption, business dissolutions, bankruptcy, partnership disputes, professional malpractice, fraud and misrepresentations, securities, trusts and estates, bad faith, alter ego, wrongful termination, personal injury, products liability and marital dissolution. She has testified on numerous occasions in U.S. District Court, Superior Court, Banla-uptcy Court, arbitrations and depositions.

Prior to joining White, Zucl{erman, Warsaysky, Luna &Hunt, LLP, Dr. Luna was a Partner with Coopers &Lybrand specializing in litigation and financial advisory services. Prior thereto, she was the National Director of Litigation Consulting for Kenneth Leventhal &Company, where she was responsible for directing the litigation services practice nationwide. Previously, Dr. Luna was a Partner with Pannell Kerr Forster, where she was responsible for providing litigation and reorganization services, and she was a Senior Manager with Price Waterhouse specializing uz litigation services. Before focusing on litigation services, she was an investment banker specializing in corporate finance.

Dr. Luna has taught graduate and undergraduate cotuses in worlung capital management, business finance, forensic accounting and intermediate accoiulting at the UCLA Graduate School of Management, California State University at Northridge and Pepperdine University. She has addressed numerous audiences and has appeared on several professional panels. She obtained her MS and PhD degrees in Applied Mathematics from Harvard University and her BA degree from Wellesley College.

Dr. Luna is a Certified Public Accountant, a Certified Fraud Examiner, Certified in Financial Forensics, a Master Analyst in Financial Forensics, an Accredited Senior Appraiser in Business Valuation, Accredited in Business Valuation, a Certified Valuation Analyst, a Certified General Real Estate Appraiser, a Certified Commercial Real Estate Appraiser, a Certified Residential Real Estate Appraiser, a Certified Management Consultant, and a Diplomate Board Certified Forensic Examiner and Accountant. She is a member of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (and holds the AICPA's CFF and ABV designations), the California Society of Certified Public Accountants(and the Society's Economic Damages,Fraud and Business Valuation Common I~iterest Member Services Committees),the Arizona Society of Certified Public Accountants,the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, the Association of Business Trial Lawyers (and the Association's Committee on Experts), the National Association ofForensic Economists,the American Boards of Forensic Examiners and Accountants, the American Society of Appraisers,the National Association of Certified Valuation Analysts, the National Association ofReal Estate Appraisers, and the Institute of Management Consultants and an associate member of the Appraisal Institute.

$Lip{' 6;1'ik~~`4~

Wna Hunt ....

73 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 74 of 117 Page ID #:1452

BARBARA LUNA'S ARTICLES AND PUBLICATIONS

"Analyzing Damages -Perspectives of Plaintiffs and Defendants," ABTL Report, November 1989

2. "Proposition 103 -Determining the Appropriate Responses," Coopers &Lybrand Insurance Newsletter, December 1989

3. "Generators of Hazardous Waste," Chapter 12, Enviromnental Dispute Handbook -Liability and Claims, John Wiley &Sons,Inc.

4. "Determining Damages In Medical Malpractice Cases," Coopers &Lybrand Briefs

5. "Analyzing Fraudulent Conveyances and Solvency," Coopers &Lybrand Briefs

6. "Valuing Businesses," Coopers &Lybrand Briefs

7. "Using Accountants as Expert Witnesses In Personal Injury Matters," 1996 Expert Witness Update, John Wiley &Sons,Inc.

"Unjust Enrichment - An Alternative to Lost Profits," Witness Chair, December 1997

9. "Employment Discrimination and Wrongful Termination," Measuring Damages Involving Individuals - A CPA's Service Guide with Case Studies, AICPA

10. "What is a Reasonable Time for Future Damages? Should Lost Profits or Lost Value of the Business Be Claimed?" White, Zuckerman, Warsaysky, Luna, Wolf &Hunt Newsletter, November 2004

11. "Valuing and Selling a Law Practice," Guide for Senior Lawyers, Los Angeles County Bar Association, September 2008

74 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 75 of 117 Page ID #:1453

EXHIBIT 6

75 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 76 of 117 Page ID #:1454

CURRICULUM VITAE SOURAV K.PODDAR, NID

OFFICE 1: OFFICE 2: CU Sports Medicine UFM-Westminster

PRESENT POSITION: Associate Director of Primary Care Sports Medicine Fellowship, University of Colorado, Denver, Colorado, September 2001 to present

Assistant Professor, Deparhnent of Family Medicine and Division of Sports Medicine in Department of Orthopedics, University of Colorado,Denver, Colorado, July 2003 to present

Director, Optimum Performance Team, University of Colorado Athletic Department Boulder, Colorado, August 2003 to present

Consultant, San Francisco Giants Baseball Club, May 2004 to present

Director, Primary Care Sports Medicine, Department of Family Medicine, University of Colorado School of Medicine, current

EDUCATION: High School: Clear Lake High School, Houston, TX, 1989 Magna Cum Laude

Undergraduate: Rice University Houston, TX 1989-1993 Biochemistry, B.A.

Medical School: University of Texas- Southwestern Dallas, TX 1993-1997 Graduated with Honors

Residency: Rose Family Medicine Residency University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO 1997-2000

Fellowship: Primary Care Sports Medicine University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO 2000-2001

Sourav Poddar, MD,Vitae 1 76 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 77 of 117 Page ID #:1455

BOARD CERTIFICATION: American Board of Family Practice 2000, 2007 Certificate of Added Qualifications in Sports Medicine 2002

MEDICAL LICEN5iJRE: Colorado #37379 Active

PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATIONS: 1993-1997 Texas Medical Association 1993-2001 .American Medical Association 1997-2001 American Heart Association Advanced Cardiac Life Support Recertified —September 2008-2010 1999-2000 American Academy of Family Physicians 1999-2000 Colorado Academy of Family Physicians Resident Representative to the Board 2001-2003 Society of Teachers in Family Medicine 2001-2003 American College of Sports Medicine 2004-present American Society of Sports Medicine 2007-2009 American College of Sports Medicine 2007-2009 Colorado Medical Scoeity

UNIVERSITY APPOINTMENTS: 8/2001-6/2003 Instructor, Department of Family Medicine and Department of Orthopedics, Division of Sports Medicine, University of Colorado Denver 9/2001-present Associate Director of Primary Care Sports Medicine Fellowship, University of Colorado, Denver 7/2003-present Assistant Professor, Department of Family Medicine and Department of Orthopedics, Division of Sports Medicine, University of Colorado Denver 2008-present Director, Primary Care Sports Medicine, Department of Family Medicine 2008-present Clinical Faculty, University of Colorado Denver School of Nursing

HOSPITAL APPOINTMENTS: 2001-present Rose Medical Center, Denver, Colorado Sports Medicine Program —Family Medicine Section 2001-present University of Colorado Hospital, Denver, Colorado

HONORS,AWARDS and LISTINGS: 1989 Grand Award, International Science and Engineering Fair, Pittsburg, PA 1991 President's Honor Roll, Rice University 2000 Family Medicine Resident Physician of the Year, Rose Family Medicine Residency 2000 Resident Teacher of the Year, Rose Family Medicine Residency 2000 Chief Resident, Rose Family Medicine Residency 2002 Teacher Development Award, American Academy of Family Physicians 2005 Physicians Recognition Award, American Medical Association

Sourav Poddar, MD, Vitae 2 77 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 78 of 117 Page ID #:1456

2006 Community Preceptor of the Year, Rose Family Medicine Residency 2006-2009 Best Family Doctors in American 2006, 2009 Who's Who Executives and Professionals 2009 Nominee, Big XII Conference Representation, NCAA,Competition and Safeguards Committee

Athletic Experience High School: Varsity Letter in Soccer College: Men's Soccer Team Medical School: Voted most Athletic, Class of 1997 UT-Southwestern Men's Soccer Team Intramural Champion, 1995-1997 Team Physician and Onsite Event Coverage University of Colorado Buffaloes Director, Optimum Performance Team Head Medical Team Physician University of Denver Pioneers Team Physician Consultant,Professional Athletics San Francisco Giants

Sports Medicine Fellowship Associate Director of University of Colorado Primary Care Sports Medicine Fellowship, Affiliated with: University of Colorado Buffaloes, NCA.A Division 1 University of Denver Pioneers, NCAA Division 1

InternationaUNational Conferences Attended 2001 ACSM Advanced Team Physician 2001-2002, ACSM Annual Meeting 2006-2009 2001 ACSM Team Physician —Part 1 2002 ACSM Team Physician —Part 2 2003-2009 AMSSM Annual Meeting 2004-2009 Bi~ XII Team Physicians Meeting 2008 2" World Congress on Sports Injury Prevention

PUBLICATIONS:(BOOK CHAPTERS) Deutchman M."Family Medicine Review Software" Poddar 5K,Reviewer, Challenger Corporation, Denver, CO 2000.

Poddar S, Richburg A. Glenohumeral Dislocation, Anterior. S Minute Sports Medicine Consultant, Bracker MD, 1St ed. Lippincott, Williams &Wilkins, Baltimore, MD. 2001.

Sourav Poddar, MD, Vitae 3 78 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 79 of 117 Page ID #:1457

Poddar S, Richburg A. Glenohumeral Dislocation, Anterior. 5 Minute Sports Medicine Consultant CD-ROM, Bracker MD,1 St ed. Lippincott, Williams &Wilkins, Baltimore, MD. 2002.

Poddar SK, Glowney J. Glenohumeral Dislocation, Anterior. S Minute Sports Medicine Consultant, 2nd ed. Lippincott, Williams & Willcins, in press 2009 .

Poddar SK."Sports Pharmacology of Pain and Inflammation Control in Athletes." Netter Sports Medicine. Lippincott, Williams &Wilkins, in press 2009.

PUBLICATIONS:(PEER REVIEWED) Mehta R,Poddar S, Kalidas M,Gomez -Flores R, Dulski K. Role of macrophages in the candidacidal activity of liposomal amphotericin B. Jlnfect Dis. 1997 Jan;175(1):214-7.

Poddar SK, Hill JC, Loeffler RD.Elbow Pain in a Twenty year- old Football Player. Medicine &Science in Sports &Exercise, May 2001;33:SS, 44.

Hill JC,Poddar 5K. Neck Injury -Football Medicine &Science in Sports &Exercise, May 2002;34:SS, 127.

Thompson C, Kelsberg G, St Anna L, Poddar S. Heat or ice for acute ankle sprain? J Fam Pract. 2003 Aug;52(8):642-3.

Poddar S. Does injection of steroids and lidocaine in the shoulder relieve bursitis? Evidence Based Answer —Peer Review. JFam Pract. 2004 Jun;53(6):488-92.

Mazzola TJ, McCarty, Hill JC,Poddar SK,Bartz RL "Lateral Ankle Pain —Fall down stairs" Medicine &Science in Sports &Exercise, June 2004;36:65, 149.

Poddar, SK,"Does yoga speed healing for patients with low back pain. Evidence Based Answer —Peer Review. JFam Prac 53(8): August, 2004.

Mazzola TJ, Poddar SK, Hill JC. Complex regional pain syndrome I in the upper extremity. Current Sports Med Rep. 2004; Oct:3(5): 261-6.

Robertson N, Hale W, Mackler L, Poddar S. "Does quinine reduce leg cramps for young athletes?," JFamPract. 2005 Jan; 54(1):76-8.

Bean MA,Poddar SK, Wolcott M,Hill JC,"Knee Injury -Basketball" Medicine & Science in Sports &Exercise, June 2005;37:65

Hill JC, Mazzola TJ, Poddar SK,"~illary Arm Pain in a Cyclist" Medicine &Science in Sports &Exercise, June 2005;37:SS

Akhavan A,Flores C, Green S, Hackett J, Nguyen M,Kerns JW,Knight K,Poddar S. "How should we follow athletes after a concussion?," JFam Pract. 2005 Oct;54(10):902- 4.

Sourav Poddar, MD,Vitae 4 79 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 80 of 117 Page ID #:1458

Hart WM,Poddar SK, McCarty EC, Hill JC ,"Patellar Tendinopathy in a College Football Player", Medicine &Science in Sports &Exercise, June 2006;37:6S.

Hart WM,Poddar SK,Bartz R,"Creative Supplementation," Orthopedics Hyperguide, 2006.

Poddar SK,Bartz R,"Evaluation and Management of Concussion in Athletes," Orthopedics Hyperguide, 2006.

Marshall P, Poddar SK,"Do Glucosamine and Chondroitin Worsen Blood Sugar Control in Diabetics?," JFam Pract. 2006 Dec; 55(12):1091-3. Review

Carlson CJ, Poddar SK,Hill J, "Fatigue and Dyspnea in an Active Male Cyclist," Medicine & 5cience in Sports &Exercise, June 2007 (supp).

Glaser T, Poddar S, Tweed B, Webb CW."What's the Best Way to Treat Achilles Tendinopathy?," JFam Pract. 2008 Apr;57(4):261-263.

Marshall PD,Poddar SK, Hi117, "Shoulder Injury- Mountain Biking," Medicine & Science in Sports &Exercise, June 2008 (Supp).

Baldea J, Khodaee M, Poddar SK, Hill J, Johnson J, "Training Patterns, Non-Steroidal Anti-inflammatory Medication Use, and Effects on High-Altitude Ultramarathon Performance," Medicine &Science in Sports &Exercise, May 2009; 41: SS.

McCarty E, Poddar SK, McGee K, Oliviero J, Baldea J, "Review Article: Return to Play After Sports Injuries," Minerva Ortop Traumatol, 2009;60:353-68.

Schreiber K, Khodaee M,Poddar SK,"What are the Most Effective Treatment Options for Morton's Neuroma?," JFam Pract., pending 2009.

Poddar SK, Leiszler M,"Will serum uric acid levels necessarily be elevated with acute gout?," JFam Pract., pending 2009.

PUBLICATIONS:(Non -peer reviewed) Poddar S, "Evaluation and Management of Concussion in Athletes,"The Colorado Pediatrician, Fa112006.

Poddar SK,"Heat lllness: A Preventable Condition," Mile High Sports Magazine, August 2007. Poddar SK,"Baseball Injuries of the Upper Extremities in Children," Mile High Sports Magazine, Apri12008.

Poddar SK,"Ask the Doctor- Hand Numbness in Cyclists," Rocky Mountain Sports Magazine, July 2008.

Sourav Poddar, MD,Vitae j 80 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 81 of 117 Page ID #:1459

RESEARCH AND WRITING IN PROGRESS: Poddar SK, Glowney J,"Bone Stress Injury in Division I Collegiate Long-Distance Runners: A Five Year Retrospective Analysis," in progress.

Poddar 5K,Glowney J, Leiszler M,"Incidence of Anemia and Iron Deficiency in Collegiate Endurance Athletes," in progress.

Hernandez T,Poddar SK, Rueda M,"Effect of Accupressure on Stress Resilience of Athletes On and Off the Field," to be submitted for Innovative Seed Grant Program, CU Boulder

Carlson C, Poddar SK,"Effectiveness of Weight Reduction Guidelines on Colorado High School Wrestlers," in progress.

"Effect of External Rotation Sling Use in First-Time Shoulder Dislocators," MOON Shoulder Group, in progress, collaborator.

"Non-Operative Management of Rotator Cuff Tears," MOON Shoulder Group, in progress, collaborator.

NATIONAL RESEARCH PRESENTATIONSlPOSTERS AT SCIENTIFIC SESSIONS: Poddar SK, Hill JC, Loeffler R.D."Elbow Pain in a Twenty Year Old Football Player" 48th Annual American College of Sports Medicine International Meeting, Baltimore, MD. May 30, 2001.

Poddar SK,Hill JC, Loeffler RD."Elbow Pain in a Twenty Year Old Football Player" 48~' Annual American College of Sports Medicine International Meeting, Baltimore, MD. May 30, 2001.

Hill JC, Poddar SK."Neck Injury in NCAA Division 1 Football" 49~' Annual American College of Sports Medicine International Meeting, St. Louis, MO. May 30, 2002.

Mazzola TJ,Poddar SK,Hill JC,"Lateral Ankle Pain —Fall down stairs." 51st Annual American College of Sports Medicine International Meeting, Indianapolis, IN, June 4, 2004.

Mazzola TJ, Poddar SK, Hill JC,"Medial Elbow Pain in the Adolescent Thrower" 13~` Annual American Medical Society for Sports Medicine Meeting, Vancouver, Canada April 17, 2004.

Bean MA,Poddar SK, Wolcott M,Hill JC,"Knee Injury in NCAA Division 1 Women's Basketball", 52nd Annual American College of Sports Medicine International Meeting, Nashville, TN, June 4, 2005.

Hill JC, Mazzola TJ, Poddar SK,"A~cillary Arm Pain in a Cyclist" 52"d Annual American College of Sports Medicine International Meeting, Nashville, TN, June 3, 2005.

Sourav Poddar, MD,Vitae 6 81 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 82 of 117 Page ID #:1460

Carlson CJ, Poddar SK, Hill J,"Leg Weakness in a Collegiate Football Player," 16~' Annual Meeting of AMSSM,Apr 2007.

Marshall PD,Poddar SK,Hill J, "Shoulder Injury- Mountain Biking," SSt~ Annual American College of Sports Medicine International Meeting, Indianapolis, IN, June 2008.

Baldea J, Poddar SK,Hill J, McCarty E,"A Real Shot in the Arm," 18~' Annual Meeting of AMSSM,Apri12009.

NATIONAL PRESENTATIONS AND INVITED LECTURES: "Primary Care of Foot and Ankle Injuries," Sports Medicine for the Primary Care Provider Continuing Medical Education Conference, Breckenridge, CO,July 27-29, 2000.

"NSAIDs Use in Athletes," Big XII Team Physician Conference, 2005.

Expert Panelist. Case Presentation Session. 15~ Annual American Medical Society for Sports Medicine, 2006.

Expert Panelist. Case Presentation Session. 16~' Annual American Medical Society for Sports Medicine, Albequerque, NM 2007.

"MRSA in Sport." Big XII Team Physician Conference, Phoenix, AZ 2007.

Expert Panelist. Case Presentation Session. 17~' Annual American Medical Society for Sports Medicine, Las Vegas, NV 2008.

"Current Concepts in Viscosupplementation." Big XII Team Physician Conference, San Diego, CA 2008.

Moderator, Case Presentation Session, 18~' Annual American Medical Society for Sports Medicine, Tampa Bay, FL, 2009.

"MRSA- Eliminating it in the Locker Room," AAOS/AOSSM Team Physician Conference, Steamboat, CO March 2009.

"Pre-Participation Exam," AAOS/AOSSM Team Physician Conference, Steamboat, CO March 2009.

"Knee Exam and Injection Workshop," ACSM t-lnnual Meeting, Seattle, WA,May 2009

"Concussion in Sports: Current Issues," Big XII Team Physician Conference, San Antonio, TX 2009.

"Ergogenic Aids in Sport," Family Medicine CME Review Course, Estes Park, CO June 2009.

Sourav Poddar, MD,Vitae 7 82 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 83 of 117 Page ID #:1461

"Current Concepts in Evaluation and Management of Concussion," Family Medicine CME Review Course, Estes Park, CO June 2009.

"Ergogenic Aids in Sport," Family Medicine CME Review Course, Aurora, CO Nov. 2009.

"Current Concepts in Evaluation and Management of Concussion," Family Medicine CME Review Course, Aurora, CO Nov. 2009.

REGIONAL PRESENTATIONS AND INVITED LECTURES "Sports Medicine Approach to the Knee and Shoulder Exam," Grand Rounds, Dept. of Fam Med, UCHSC, Jan 2004.

"Ergogenics and Nutrition for Athletes," SECAHEC,"For the Health of It" Symposium, Pueblo, CO,March 2005.

"The Shoulder Exam Made Simple," Office-Based Sports Medicine for the Primary Care Physician, May 2005.

"Evaluation and Management of Concussion in Athletes," Rocky Mountain Society of Adolescent Medicine Quarterly Meeting, Aug. 2006.

"Non-Operative Management of the Active Degenerative Knee," University of Colorado Sports Medicine Fall Symposium, Sept. 2006.

"Current Concepts in the Management of Concussion," Office-Based Sports Medicine for the Primary Care Physician, May 2007.

"Emergency Action Plan- Who's In Charge?," On-the-Field Management of the Injured Athlete Symposium, August 2007.

"Osteoarthritis and the Role of Viscosupplementation," Office-Based Sports Medicine for the Primary Care Physician, May 2008.

"Pain Management in Athletes," 2nd Annual On the Field Management of the Injured Athlete Symposium, August 2008.

"I~Ton-Operative Medical Management of the Active Degenerative Shoulder," University of Colorado Sports Medicine Fall Symposium, Sept. 2008. "Osteoarthritis and the Aging Athlete," Office-Based Sports Medicine for the Primary Care Physician, May 2009.

"Managing an Emergency: Emergency Action Plan!" 3ra Annual On-the-Field Management of the Injured Athlete Symposium, August 2009.

"Update on Non-Operative Management of the Active Degenerative Knee," University of Colorado Sports Medicine Fall Symposium, Sept. 2009.

Sourav Poddar, NID, Vitae g 83 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 84 of 117 Page ID #:1462

"Concussion Management in Athletes," University of Colorado School of Medicine LEADS Program, Sept. 2009.

LOCAL PRESENTATIONS AND INVITED LECTURES: "Shoulder, Knee, and Ankle Pain," Rose Family Medicine Center, Aug. 2000.

"Differential Diagnosis of Elbow Pain," Rose Family Medicine Center, Nov. 2000.

"Nutrition and Supplements in Athletics," Rose Family Medicine Center, Feb. 2001

`Evaluating Foot and Ankle Injuries," CHA/PA Core Curriculum Lecture, UCHSC, Aug 2001.

"Heat Illness," Orthopedic Conference, UCHSC, Oct. 2001.

"Sports Supplements," Orthopedic Conference, UCHSC,Apr. 2002.

"Distal Fibular Fractures: Radiographic Review," Rose Medical Center, Nov. 2002.

"Evaluating Knee Injuries," CHA/PA Core Curriculum Lecture, UCHSC, Apr 2003.

"Concussions: Current Concepts," Orthopedic Conference, UCHSC, Sept. 2003.

"Nutrition and Hydration in Athletes," Univ. of Colorado Life Skills Class, Oct. 2003.

"Medical Topics for Athletes," PC Sports Medicine Lecture Series, RFMC, Feb. 2004.

"Sports Supplements," Orthopedic Lecture Series, UCHSC Apr. 2004.

"Pre-Season Physical and Cardiac Evaluation," Orthopedic Lecture Series, UCHSC Aug. 2004.

"Concussions in Athletics," PC Sports Medicine Lecture Series, RFMC, Oct 2004.

"Sports Hydration," Univ. of Colorado Life Skills Class, Oct. 2004.

"Shoulder Exam Made Simple," FMIG,CU Med. School, Feb. 2005.

"Sports Injuries," FMIG, CU Med. School, March 2005.

"Lower-Extremity Overuse Injuries," PC Sports Medicine Lecture Series, RFMC,Oct. 2006.

"Spinal Issues in Athletes," PC Sports Medicine Lecture Series, RFMC March 2007.

"Acute Knee Injuries," PC Sports Medicine Lecture Series, RFMC,Sept. 2007.

Sourav Poddar, MD,Vitae g 84 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 85 of 117 Page ID #:1463

"SLAP Tears," PC Sports Medicine Lecture Series, RFMC,Feb. 2008.

"Platelet Rich Plasma," CUSM Conference, Oct. 2008.

"Common Sports Medicine Injuries," PC Sports Medicine Lecture Series, RFMC,Jan 2009.

"Sports Supplements and Nutrition in Athletes," Orthopedic Lecture Series, UCHSC, Oct. 2009.

Sourav Poddar, MD,Vitae 10 85 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 86 of 117 Page ID #:1464

L~:/:11.3~_~7

86 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 87 of 117 Page ID #:1465

Dr. M. Dianne Murphy p~Es~dzd z,V~~,~n~of {he most surcess;ut periods in i Columbia University Athletics history d~,rirg Eger 11-year tenurz i?OGG-iCi5t. She je;ined 9 ' `~' Th~PictarGroupas ~ senior partner in .4pri 2r ib_ t '`?F k) :, ;:= During the 2D1 i 5 academic year, six CoEuM~ia cr~aches ~~rere rsamec !tif League Ccrac~ cif , the Year, the mer, end women's squash proorams firaisF~ed with their best national finish in ~j~' sch~l histor~~, the rnen's ter:~is pr~c~ram iin~shed the season rar~k~d' 4tF in the country, advancing tci th=s~ second straight NCAA S:•~2ci 16, the baseball team ttcn its±bird consecutive I~~y L~.gu~ tit~a, and llE Ctj~i}IT~13 Fencing team earned the ~~~ngram's 14th M. €3ianne Murphy NCAA7~arn Cf3ar~pi~nship. Senior Partner Itl Ir, December 2013, C,olumt a P.th(etics corr~~teted the largess fundraising effort in the history of t" he a}hieiics pragrarcz, Thy C~lumo~~ Carn~aign for Athtetic~: kchieving Excellence. During the Campeign: Caiumbia Athletics raised more than $100 f~'lillion in s+~ppn~e of Pe~~pte, Ptaces and Pragrarns. Gol;;mbia dedicated ii -,e Campbell Sports Center in Goober 2G12. The Carnpbef. Spa;is Center, the. fynchpin of the Campaign, is the `;rst nee: tzuildin4 built for afh~etics at Columbia in mc•~re ~~an b0 years.

~' prr~minent ar~d active zdminisErator on thz r:~tiondl c~Legiate atF~letics landscape. h~urony ~~~as named ~' ~~ ;h~ NCG.R ~iviston i 1Nt men's Basl.~;bal! Committee in February 2D? .she also developed an elite :eaters;ip-training program far college women's Basketball coaches,i he Gen*sr ft.~r Coaching ExcEll~r~e,'n cnnjunctian r,~ith fhe Vdomzn's vaske~ball Cc~acf~es kss~c~a.ion ttti~CA!.

ColumLia teams e~csl(ed during her t>nur~ as ~otumbie ~~~~cin ti ti~tal e* ~0 wa League titles in 11 differen. e.~~-rts including baseE;all, m::^'s cross enlntry, i^roman`s cress co~~try, men's fencing, °:zromen'~ fencing. men's ~nlf, ;ic~mzr~s gaff, women's soccer, ~~romeris indoor track ana Meld, rnen's tennis end ;v~?men's tennis.

Col~m~ia te3-nz ~:rcn five IE~v League Ch~mp;~ ships in 2013-74 vaith men's crass country, men's fencing, ^tar's guff, men's tennis and 6~se5al! each hatiino recer3-szttirg years. Men's tress c~~.:ntry <<,~as ranked as high as eighth in tna netic+r~, while -ran s fencing earned a Nn. 1 ~~tionel ranking aurng the: ecular s~as~n. lNr~m~n's tenr:;s earned its first- evzr at-lsrge Lid tcj tha CAA Champi~inships `feels tennis tk~ent und~fe~iad in the !vy for League, ranked as =iiah as 16fh nationotl~, are ad~rance~ to tl•~e NCA.4 5~✓eat 16 ;hz fleet time [n s:ho~i h'ss,r,sy_

~t C:~urn~ia, sie helped i^iti=te the Univer~i*,'= Spirts hi~ra~ement rnasl:r's cagree prcyram end his =csuc„' as s member a7 its fat;;: y. Murphy holds a Ph.L7_ in adrninistrat~on and curriculum'ram I=.,,ride State t198D?, and master's i1973i sr:d L-achal~'s 4'-4i"c= degrees from Tennessee T=chnolc~gicat UnivFrsity. The Tznr=ss=z'e~h Alumni Associattan honored her;:ith its Z~G5 iiist ngc;;shce ~;lumr~e AErcrd. !=iorida State pr-_eentzd her v✓ith its'Gred'+1sde Good" at aid ~i its 2Ct;~ ~omec~m'sng.

In 2^12-1? men's vaske:b3tl ild~ lt4 fTIOSt SJCCe55u~i seas-yn in mare than, ~Q years, w~in~;ing 2i dames. and arl:•ancing tc? the o:~arterfir:-_ls in tie Co[(t~elnsicar.com Pc~s;se3saz Tournament. Baseball evan the Ivy League Championship and qualified €ar thz NC~~ Iour[:.3ment . or tl~e record carsec~tive ycsr_

In 2~i2-13 haseba(l ~;~on its second IVV LEogu2 ti c and ~'+on a game in the I~CAk ?~visio i 6asebn€l C ampiarshipa fog the first time +n school history. Women's tennis Avon its- fsrst Icy Leag;:e ~tle in suhoot histary~ ar.d produc:~d the schoo~s first-e~.~ar vromen's tennis Iti~ LzaguE Player ~;theY~~r.

Murphy bean her ath~Eetics administrative eare~r in 14E'-$& a~ the assn€ant akh(etics direc4~r at Kenfuc~.y State University. From 1486 to 1988, she chaired Ehe schaoCs Division of HeaEth, ?hysicak ~ducatirfn and R=_create^r., any served ~s an associate pro-fess^r.

87 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 88 of 117 Page ID #:1466

Pricr ~~3 6~~rning an athletics admi~i=trator, Murphy cn~ched t,~sketbo'far 13 ;ears_ She v;~as the hezd ~vamen's t~asket6eU coach at Shorter College ~19?3=l6). Fta~~fd~ 5tata Unilersih X1976-79i and Eastern KerYucky UnE~~ersity !14;9-Eb;.

hfurphy ~+~•as ??amed the Women's 8aske Lal: Coaches Associa:ian (1h16CA) Acmirist!ator o~ tha Yzar it 2CD4. She chaired the NCAA ~ivi_~on 16~si:e;hall Dues Committee from 2002 k~ 2~Q4 and served as a mEmber of the State ~zrm Wadif rophy VVcmEn'_ Erik=ioefl P'a~r cf !ha Year Cnmr:rnitte~ €rom ~U~3 to ~C13.5he also serled ~r the NC~,A Certificetinn and Diversity Comm'tt.ee ana the Board of ~Jireccars fay ti~-~e 1'JnmEn's Collegiate Sp~~r*.s Awsrds. the r,-ganization ghat presents the Honca Awarc and tha Honda-Errdcnck Cup.

She is active ire se~~eral national arganizaiirns. ir~cdu~ing the Natior-at Asseciatiar: or C~~l':egiate VJomert r`,ihletiu ti~ministratc~rs NA~iNf,A7: the h~ir,~el Asst~cie:ian c~* College ~ircc:ars r,*Athletics itvACCA.?and the VJ6CA. She +•~a= named NAC4VAA's ]ivisi~~n t (Fcotbzil Champi:,zr;ship Suadivisiart Vati~ral Ad,:~inistrator aTthe Yea; fr~r 2008 anrJ'vd~5 52~GCtCd I\A~WA?'s ~ivisir,n i AAA National d.~ministrat~r r,i the Y_ar for 2(101. She serval as tiAClnlAA's prasiden; ~urin~ ZQO?-C3. fn 2C1~4, Nr.CQ4 hcnnred her as }he General Sports T ~rf Witt P,th[2`ics DirEctor of ihz Year, The Y,il- A~mini<_trator Arnericar~ F ~t~ati Foundation has prrs2n'ed nos v✓ith iF:~ Szr:~or Sporis A~a~ard and the van~ral P,r~'~er` n. ?~~ lansf ~3~istandina ~:thlerics director Ava~r~ in 2CL17.

88 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 89 of 117 Page ID #:1467

PROOF OF SERVICE

~a STATE OF CALIFORNIA,COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES 3 I am employed in the County of Los Angeles, State of California. I am over 4 the age of eighteen years and not a party to the within action; my business address is 707 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 4000, Los Angeles, California 90017-3623. 5

6 On April 4, 2017, I served the following documents) described as DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY'S DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT . 7 WITNESSES on the interested parties in this action by placing true copies thereof 8 enclosed in sealed envelopes addressed as follows: 9 Jeremy J. Gray, Esq. Attorneys for Jeffrey J. Zuber, Esq. Plaintiffs 10 Jayesh Patel, Esq. 11 Robert W. Dickerson, Esq. .aa ~ Agnes Markarian Sullivan, Esq. ~ oN~ IZ z M Zuber Lawler &Del Duca, LLP ,~ w~(D O ~`'M 13 Figueroa Street, Suite 3700 U ~~ N 777 S Los Angeles, CA 90017 cn~g~ 14 aWc aW IZ~ Telephone:(213) 596-5620; Facsimile:(213) 596-5621 J O 5 m Q~ 15 E-Mails: [email protected];[email protected]; w W c.~o = W~ [email protected]; [email protected] ~ ~"~N W 00 16 [email protected]; [email protected] o ~Z~ ~ oNN 17 W ~ J BY ELECTRONIC MAIL TRANSMISSION: Based on an agreement of the Q w 18 parties to accept electronic service, I served the above-referenced documents)by 19 electronic mail transmission from [email protected], by transmitting a PDF format copy of such documents)to each such person at the e-mail address listed below 20 their address(es). The documents) was/were transmitted by electronic transmission 21 and such transmission was- reported as complete and without error.

22 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California on Apri14, 2017, at Los Angeles, 23 that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed California. 24 ~' 7 ~' r 25 Irma L. Raygoza 26

1599656.1 DEFENDANT PEPPERDINE iJNIVERSITY'S89 DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 90 of 117 Page ID #:1468

EXHIBIT 2

90 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 91 of 117 Page ID #:1469

JAYESH PAT~L,(SBI~I 1X2939) ~' X14 l ~~ ~v.?'.4 ~~patel (a; %uberlaw. corm r, f 2 J.E.FFR~J. ZUBER(SBN 22080) j~~ib~r'c~~uberlu►~j. com P ~ 20th 3 ROBER'TrW. DI~KERSQN JR. (SBN 893b7j ~~~~z ~ rdickerson~a,zuberla~~v.com ~~ f-~ :~ _ .______4 ZUBER LAR~LER &DEL DUCA LLP 77'7 S. Fi ueroa Street, 37th Floor ct} 5 Los Ange~es, California 90017 USA. Telephone: (~21 ~) 596-5620 6 Facsimile: (213) 546-Sb21 7 Attarnevs for Plaintiffs Haley ~ideckis and Layana White S 9 ti~1~I~TED STATES DISTRICT COURT 10 CENTRAL DISTRICT QF (GALIFORI~;IA, WESTER'~1 DII~ISION 11 ~z I-~:ALEY VIDEeI~`1S and LAYANA CASE I~T4. 2:l S-CV-Q~298-DDF (JCx) WHITE, individuals, 13 PLAINTIFFS HALEY VIDECKIS Plaintiffs, AND L~Y~NA WHITE'S 14 CDUIV'TEIt EXPERT v. DESIGNATION 1S PEI'PERDI~E UNIVERSITY, a 1b corporation doing business in Discovery Cut-C)ff: A~pril 2$S 2017 California; Exert Cut-Off: May 9, 2017 17 l~Iot~on Cat Off: ~pri13, ~~17 Defendant. Fri-Trial Canf.: May 8, 2Q 17 18 Trial Date: 11rlay 23, 2017 lg 20 At the trial. in tl~e above-entitled matter, Plaintiffs Haley Videckis and Layana 21 W1~ite (hereinafter collectively referred to as "Plaintiffs") will call as rebuttal expert 22 witnesses the persons listed below. Follawin~ the ~1ame of the person is the 23 ~ substance of fhe person's testimony. 24 1. Dr. Elliot D. Felman: This witness will testify on the subject matter of ~S internal medicine. He will offer rebutkal testimony regarding requests 26 for medical information. Dr. Felman's CV is enclosed here~~th as 27 Exhibit A.

1 cue ~rfl. z:i~-cv-ooz9s-vvP (~c~;> HALEY ViDEC f 15 AtiI~ L.AYANA Wk{ITE'S F3~PER"C W"IT'~IESS DISCLQSI'KE 91 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 92 of 117 Page ID #:1470

1 2. Brett A, S~kc~law: This witness ~~~iil testify can the subject matter and 2 offer rebuttal testimony regarding Tide I~. Mr. Saleolaw's C'V anc~ list 3 representative engagements are enclosed herewith as Exhit~ t B. 4 5 6 7 Dated; April 14,, ?017 Respectful}~7 submitted, 8 ZUB~R LA~1'LER &DAL l)l1'CA I.LI' JAYESH PATEL 1L1=FFLEY ~. LiJBrR l0 RC3BERT W.DICKERSt7N li ~~_~~~e_ 12 ~r,~ 13 By: Attorneys for Plaintiffs Haley Videckis and 1~ Lay~ana White 15 16 1.7 18 19' 20 21 22 z~~ 24'~ 2S 26 27 28 2 case r~o. z:i 5-cv-oazss-DDP {Jcx> 2{374-1iHl2' F7G414..1. PLAi'vTIPF'S HALE't'iDECI;IS A'v'D LAYANA WHITE'S F?~PERT V4'ITT41~5S DISCI.QSUIRE 92 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 93 of 117 Page ID #:1471

FRoo~ a~ ~Exv~e~ Videckis &White v. Pepperdine Case Na,2..15-CV-04298-DDI' (JCx) 3 STATE OF CALIFORNIA,C(3LNT1' QF LOS ANGF,LES 4 At the time of service, i was o`Ter 1$ years of ale and not a party to this action. I am 5 employed in the Gounty~ of Los Angeles, State of California. IVIy business address is 777 S. Figueroa Sii-eet, 37th Floor, Los Angeles, CA X0017, USA. 6 C?n Aprii 14,2017, I served true copies ofthe follt~wing documents} described as 7 PLAINTIFF A.~LEY VIDECKIS AND LAYANA WHITE'S COtiNTER EXPERT DESIGNA'T'ION an the interested parties in this action as follows: 8 Paula Tripp Victor 9 ptv czamclalv.com Peter B. Rustin 10 pbr(ir_,amclav~r.coYn Eric A. Sclineitler, Esq. fil eas~amclaw.com ANDERSON, McPI~ARLIN &CONKERS 12 LLP 707 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 4Q04 13 Los Angeles, California 90U71-29Q1 Telephone:(2l3) 688-0080 14 Facsimile; {?13) b22-7594 Atiomeys for Defendant Pepperdine zs LTnversity 16 BY M~iIL: I enclosed the documents) in a sealed en~~elope or package addressed to the persons at the addresses listed in the Ser~~ice List and. placed the envelope far collection and 17 mailing,. following our ordinary business practices.: I am readily familiar with the practice of Luber Lawler &Del Duca LLP for collecting and processing correspondence for mailing. Qn the. 18 same da}% that correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is deposited in the ordinar}= course of business with the Lnited States Postal Service, in a sealed envelope with posi:age fu11y 14 prepaid. I am a resident or employed in the co~nt~ where the mailing occurred. The envelope was placed in the mail at Los Angeles, California. 20 BY E-MAIL QR ELECTRONIC TRANSMISSION: I caused a capy of the 21 docurnent(s) to be sent from email address msmitht"c~r~'zuberlaw.com to the persons at the e-snail addresses listed in the Service List. I did not receive, within.a reasonable time after the 22 transmission, any electronic message or other indication that the transmission was unsuccessful.

23 I declare under penalt}~ of perjury under the Taws of the United States of America that the foregoing is true and correct and that I am employed in the office of a member of the bar of this 24 Court at whose direction the .service was made.

25 Executed on April 14, 2017, at Los Angeles, California.

27 /.c!Meredith Sntitlr Meredith A. Smith 2£~

~o~v_~~rz!beta; u 93 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 94 of 117 Page ID #:1472

EXHIBIT A

94 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 95 of 117 Page ID #:1473

FJi3Gt !~. ~al~Tl~tY, 11PE.D. t7fptvmate ~f tie Amer c2n Board of famii~± h±tedic)ne 1$Z1 ~'~lfshtre 8lwci., Suk~ 301 5a~ta Mr~nlca, ~A. 9ft~Cl 'fax !D 95-34 4936 ds#elma ~ C~ eartF+tnk.net P-31f~26C~~535 F310-26(3-7575

CL~RRiCULtl1M U`ITAE f)Ccu~ation; Physician S~eciatty: Fam!!y Medicine

ticense: ~ Catih~mia Ed ucatian: 1961-1965 College: Un1vers'rty caf Pennsylvania Degree. B~chebr ofActs

Medical Schoai 1965 —1959 liahn~mann Medial(:otlege Philade~phfa, Pe~nsytvanla De~r~e: ~'1ed[cal E3octor

Past G~adwat~ Treening fntemshep 2969 -1870 Gut's-5in~i Medical Center Los;Angeies,G~fifarr►ia

Profess'sonaf Activ~y: Private Practice, w570 -1975 tns Angeles, Caiifomia private Practice, X976 to present Sanfia Monica, Califnrni

C~e~t fications: C3#plorrxate AmerEe~n BoarEi of Fatuity Med c~~e 1977 R~certifiec ; 1984, X391. 1.498.2th'75, ~t175

~rofi~ssig~al Orga~3zatfons: Am~ritan Academy of Farrslly F~hySitians Intematib~tai'Sotfety of Travet Mec1€c ~e

Hosp~ta! AflilEatfarts: 5afnt lohn'~ Hos¢ 1 and HeaPth Center

Teaching Appointments. Gin(cat EacultY. UCLA MEDICAL ~haol Glinicai faculty, Western Un v+erstty of Heatth 5cier~ces

Medlt~l Consultant: C2u~21fled F~cpert f~evJewer, Medfca! 6o~r€~ cat GA 1994 — 2fyf?1,

tviedcal Reeard Revt~w 54aiJ.Os~ per Hr. ~epositinn &Testimony $6(}0.00 per Hr. Triaf'festtmony $25Q~O.f1a Hal# Qay $SQOQ.W Full [?ay

95 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 96 of 117 Page ID #:1474

96 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 97 of 117 Page ID #:1475

~~- ~- - ~

~i ~~ ~ ~~j us r . '.r 1.~ ,, "i~ `~:` Systerr~__ s,~i~vel_ ~~c~~~n~ `i~:~~ ~~r~`s~ht~ols and- c~m~uses'~ "

Brett A. Sakolow, £sq. Fr~sdent and CECI

~~a~~,culum Vitae

Brett A. Svkalow is one of the i~ading national experCs on high-risk campus and schc~ot prevention, health and safety issues. H~ is widely ec~nsidered t~ t~~e one of the. foremast experts on Tide IX compliance in the country.

Soko~low serves as the President and CEO of Tie NC#~ERM Group, LL+C, arse o~the nation's largest higher educatian law risk.. management consulting firms. The NGHERM Groug serves as legal caunsef to more than. sevenCy-five X75) colleges end universities, and has served a~ cpun~el tt~ more than ESQ campuses since the arm was fflunded in ~Ot~~_ Tn add iian to its legal represen~:ation. The. N~f~ERh~ Group provides consulting services trr an addiC t~3~a140Q+ campuses and sehoots etch year.

Mr. Sokolaty is a risk manaetne~jt consultant. author,editor, and higher ed~catio~ ~ttvrney admitted to the Pennsyit~ania and New.Jersey bars. Ne hails a Bachelor of Arts. degree in East Asian Studies from the ~oll~ge of William anc~ +nary (19 3), and a juris Q~ctc~rate from the V llanava University Schaal cif Law {1437)_ In addition to his law ar~d co~suItirag rile with The NCHRM Group,Sokotow's otherproFess~ona[ aFfiliations include:

Sokolov ~ the Board Chair, f~►urider and 2Q(39.2U1U President of NaB1TA, the National Behavioral Int~rventie~n Team Ass~ciatian (y~+wvu.nahit~.orE}, a membership organization ref 1,1QU co[lege~, universities and schac~ls addressing violence prevention ~rt~! threat assessment He served as the Executive Director €ram 2(} 19-2015. Sokal~w is tie executive Darector and fou~tder aFATIXA, the Association of Title 1X Administrators (tvww.atixa.arg~, a membership association Qf ►Hare than 6,QOC} campus and school Title IX administrators. Through its training and certification program, ATIXA has certified mare than 3,U(~D Ti le IX Coordinators at~ci mare than ~,U00 Title !X/civil rights investigators sine 2011.

97 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 98 of 117 Page ID #:1476

The i~CH~RM Group specializes in training, compliance, gublicatians, and consultation reEated to:

'r SexuaF Violence, Harassment and Discrimination Intimate Partner Violence and Stalking "r `title IX and VAWA Section 304 Compliance Y Clery Act and FERPA Compliance Y Student Conduct and Training Culture Change and. Prevention Strategies r Confidential lnvestigatic~ns r College/Univ. Defense Litigation ~ Campus Safety and .Security ~ Behavioral interventirrn and Threat Assessment r Suicide & Psychala~gical Distress A Disruptive Students and ~lassro~m ManagemenE Expert Witness Services 1~~ Amendm~~t and Academic Freedom ;- NazEng and Student Organization Risk Management i Problem drinking and drugs

Mr. Sokalow holds memberships to:

• The National Associatia~ o€StudenE Personnel Administrators (IVASPAa • The Assacaatic~n for Student Conduct Administratgrs(ASCA, formerly ASJA) • The. University Risk Management and Insut`ance Association [URMlA) • The {nternationat Association ofCampus [.aw Enfe~rcement Agencies(IACLEA) • The American College Personnel Association (A~PA, where he served from 2007-2008 as Vice President For Education of Directorate Bady of the Commission far Campus Judie ai Affa es and Legal fssu2s and way a Directorate member far the Cammiss ors on Student.Conduct and Legal Issues until 2 12} + The Councit on Law in Nigher Education (CLHE). where lie served as a member of the Board of Trustees as Vice-President for Campus.Security.

Professional Accomplishments:

The NCHERM Group has provided services to over 3,Qt}0 school, college and university clients, including training programs for campus and school district administrators, faculty and staff training, sexual assautand'ftte I~ case management,risk management for fiaternities and sororities, workshops and seminars. In addition to his consulting activities, Sokofow has aEso pravid~d awareness and education programs for students. at aver 2,(}00 coiteges, high schools and military institutions. Sokolov has published twelve books and mare than 250 articles on student affairs, preventive law and risk management topic. Ne provides expert witness services, and lobbying efforts €or campus crime and sexual assault-related legislation.

98 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 99 of 117 Page ID #:1477

Svkalaw formerly was Legai Issues ~ditQr of the CLHE atudent Affairs Law &policy VVe~kl~. • Ne ~s Ed tpr Emeritus c~Fthe Report ran Cam~~rsSa~ietya~d Student D~~~elop►arent published by tl~~ Civic Research Institute. * He served on the Editorial Advisory Board t~f the ~olle,~e and Unf~~ersit~f Legal Advfsor, also pub{fished by the Civic Research Institute. • He is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of The PJ~HEF~iul Chrcrni~le of Camps Canduet; ~rvhich is r ow gut-of:print • Solcoiaw ~s on the advi~ary b~ar~ of the lVationa! Hazing Prevent Qn CaElabat-ative, • Sokoln~~ is an the Board ~€ Llirecto~s o~ the Ni~SPA Ent~ugh is E~tt~ugh Violence Prevention Campaign. Scrkt~lc~kv is recognized for his expertise in campus conduct training and authoring cods of conduct He teas trained conduct admia~istrator5 frarn o~rer $(~0 coll~eg~ campuses, end }gas created an ~caderny for advanced conduct tt~aining, SaIsolQw has alstr authored ar revised the conduct caries of over 1(~0 colleges. • The ~ICHERM Group's Organ ~atians provide an active ~rhedule of mare 5U annual serr~inars and trainings hosted theou~;Iiout the United Mates, Sokoiow and. NCHERh9 C;coup Partner Val. Scott Lewis pioneered the NaBITA rn~ciel fnr campus Behan or~~l Intervention Tarns, end co-authored the v~liclated N~$1TA i'hreat Assessment Tool, the most widely used campus risk assessment. r~b~ie. An extendet~ 3isting cif professionat accomplishments can be arces~ed at; ~'!/wwwncherm org,[~vorcEnCPS`~,~v~+~-ec~ntentfu,~I~~t351202Zf02f1~-SlJh'fM~RY-t~F- NCHFRM-GR(}UY-LEADERSHIP~~-1NN£}VATlghl-SiN~E-z997.ndf

Mr, SokoSaw hay presented at r~e~ic~nal and national ronf~rences through4~t the country, including:

• North Carrolina A&T Campus Safety C~r~ference, 1 98 • N#ississiFpi Coalition Against Sera] Assault Annual Conference, 1998 s Keynote, Response ko Sexuai Assault; Everyone's Responsibiiity, Bowling Green Stag University, 1998 s 8th Student Conference an C~~pus: Sexual Violence, 199' Fraternity Executive Associatican Annuat Meeting, 1999 • Council vn Law in Higher Education (CLH:E~ Forum, „Clery Aet Camptiance;' 1~9 NASPI~ Clery pct Aud aserninar with Cheryl Lcavell & Ds~uglas Tuttle,I X99 • NASPA Clery Act Audioseminar with Qonalci Gehrirt~, ~d.D., 1999 s North Carolina Coalition Against Sexu~1 Assault Annul Conference, 1999 • Lambda Chi Alpha Fraternity An~ua! M~etin~,194'9 • Sigma Phi Epsilon ~raterr~ity Conclave, 1999 North Carolina A&T Campus Safety conference, 1999 N~H~RM Seminar "Rules of Evidence fir the Cart~pus ~udtcial Process"-- at the College of the- Holy Cross, witF~ Robb Flowers & B~v~rly LedbeEter, Esq., 1499 • New `~4ric State judi~ a! Affairs Conference, "Sexual Misconduct Liability;' X999 • )nstitute For Higher Ed. Management (IH~1~9) Clery Act Seminar, 2~0~

99 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 100 of 117 Page ID #:1478

• AssociatrtQn for ~tude~t judicial Aff~~rs [ASJA} ~r►n~a1 C+~nf~rence, 2~Q4 htC}iEFtivl Videoser~inar "Sexual Miscariciuct juciiciaE Training" at Haverford C~~le~e, 2000 • California Coalition Against Sexual Assault Institute, "Creating Proactive Campus sexual Niiscc~nduct Policies," ar:d "Comprehensive Sexual Misccsr~duct J:u~iiciai Procedures; 2~QOCI Zeta Tau :Alpha Annual Conference,. 2t~(}Ll «~ ~GHERM Seminar, .'sexual Assault, Sexual Harassment and Tide I [~"lanaging the RisEt on Campus'" at Grinnelt Callege, Zt~OQ • tVational Associaci~n of Student I~ersrannei Administrators ~[tiA5Pr1} Annual Cr~nfe:~nce, "Sexual Assault, .Sexual }harassment and Tine iX: M~t~aging tl~~ Aisk gn Campus" ~vi~h Dennis Gregory, ZOQI • California Caalit crn Against Sex~raJ Assault Institute, 2 02 • tVCHERM Videos~rnin~r "Campus Judicial "Training' with W. Scott Lewis, JD, P~9ary Louise Anteau, j3~ ane! Linda P. Rowe, Ph. D: 20Q1 • t~CHERM,/URMI11 Webseminar, "1n~t 11#ng Principles of Risk Management into the Daily Practice of Student Affairs;with Edward FD. Spencer. Et3.D., Dennis ~regary, Ed.D., john Wesley Lowery, Ph.D<, and ~everly Costello, ARM.. X002, • Internatia~~al Assoeiativn of f arr~pus Law Enf€~reerrtent Agencies (IACLEAj ~lnnua! CvnFerertce. Pt~n~ry add s, 2001. • hlCNERM/Arthur J. G~ilagher & Cc~. Invitational Seminar, "Sexual Harassment and Title IX: #dCana~;ing the Risk ~n Campus," Ripen ~oliege, 20Q1 • NGHERF~ JRrthur J. Gallagher&. Ccr. lnvitat anal Seminar, "Campus Liability Summit,"' Denver CQ, ZU01 NCH ERMf Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. lnvitat an~i S~rriinar, "Sexual Harassment and Title IX: Managing the Risk can Campus," Col~e~e of St. Benedict/Sc. jfl~ans Univ~rsit}r. 20U2 NCH~RM/Arthur J. Ga lagh~r & Co. Invitational Seminar,_ "Sexual Ffarassment and Title !~: h~lanaging the ~t sk on ~arnp~s,,, ~3absan College, 2QU2 Fr~ateen ty Risk ivlanagement `Frusk, Risk Mtanagernent College. "He Said—She Sa€d," 2~}fl2. • Cal Forma Coalition Against Sexual Assault IrtskitUte, "'Carnp~,~s judicial Affairs Legal Llgc ate" with Edward N. Stoner, f 1, 20U2 • NCHERM~Arthur ). Gatlagh~r & Ca, Invitational Seminar, "Sexual Harassrr►ent an~'Title iX: Managing Che Risk can Gampus," Balciw€n-Wallace College, 2002 • National Cr~nference on Scude~t Services. G~ncurren[ session on He Said-5h~ Said. Miami, FL, 2Dp~. • 'Wisconsin A~soe anon of Independent Colleges ar~d U n very ties Student Affairs Meeting,. "Risk l~anagemen~ in student Affairs,"' 20132 Associ.at an f+~r Student judicial Affairs (ASJA) Annual ~onferene~, "'Best ~r~ctices for Camps:s Sexua[ Misconduct Adjudication,", "Re-Examining the Campus Llisc plinar}~ Appears P'rflcess" and "Student Rights in the Balance," with Mary Louise Anticau, jD, ~c~a~ • N~HERM Judicaal T7ecsien-Maker Training Academy, St. Johns Ur+~v~ersity (MN), ~~Q~ • Eratern ~y Risk Management Trust Risk k~tanagement College, ZCt~2 • NCHERM )udiciat Decision-Maker Tra►ning Academy, Marist College, 2002

100 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 101 of 117 Page ID #:1479

• Safe 5~hr~a)s, Th~'i'ure}fth Interr~ati~na~ Ct~r►ference can S~xua! Assau~Cand Harassment on Campus, 2UfJZ NCN~RM Judicial 1~ecision-Makes Training Academy, Fitzer Col[e~e 2Q02 • Ftoeky Mountain allege Health Assaciati~n Annual Meeting, "Best Practices ft~r-Title IX Compliance anti Sexual Assa~ilt Victimization }lssistance," 2Q02 NCHERM )uct vial Decision-Maker TrainingAcadert~y, I3e~xe1 University, 2UO2 A~s~ciation far Student judicial Affairs {ASJA) Annu~~ Conference, "Best Pta~tic~s for Campus Sexual Misconduct Adjudicatic~t~," anc~ "[~run~ S+ex—Hc~t~k-up, Bad Sex, ar Date Rape?,• 2UU3 NCHERf~(Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. lnvitationai Seminar,.. "Campus Liahilit~t Summit," Kenyan C~tlege, OH, 2003 • C~~HERM judicial Decision-Maker Training Aead~my, SauEherr► t~le[hodisE Unsversit);, 2003 NGHERM judicial ~eci~ on-Maker Training Academy, Lewis Se Clark College, 2(3Q3 • C~CHERM judgeial ~ecisian-Maker Training Aea~temy, University of Maine, Z~(3 • h1CNERF~ Judicial Decision-Nlaker'TrainingAeaderny, Colorado College, 2CF0.3 • NCHERM Judicial D~csian-Maker Trainir~~Academy, G'rinn~l~ Coll'e~e, 2~(.}3 • NCH~RP~} Judicial Decision-.Maker Training Acad~r~y, St. Johns Univ, ~MN), 2003 • NC~IEFtM Judicial Decision-NakerTrainngAcademyt 5t. Nor~aert~olle~e, 2103 NCHERNf Judicial Deeisio~-i4'iaker Training Academy, University of San Diego! 2U(~3 • TlCKI C~r~terence for a iNarl~i Withaot Rape, Hauerford PdA, 2.003,. • URIti'i[A Annul Conference---The University Risk Management and Insurance Association. Concurrent session an Risk. Management Fn Student Affairs. New Orleans, LAS, 2t~0~, ~ ASjA Circuit C3rive-in ]u~licial Training conference at Bentley Cc~ll~ge in Vtil~lt~am, h~A, Legal Liability. T5sue~ in Campus Judicial Affairs, 2(?02-Z(~03, • Safe Schoc~Js Conference. Conrurrent session, "Drunk Sex or'IIate Rape: Can You Tell the Difference?„ Concurrent sessifln "Legislation and Liti,~at can Update for Ccslleges and. ilniversiti~s nn ~exua Assault and Sexual Harassment." Panelist at the closing Plenary session. (}rlando, Florida, (?ctc~ber, 2QD3 • Higher Education Lav,~ &Policy Institute, San Diego, CAS Concurrent session on The Standard of Prt~c~f in Bate Rape and Sexual Assault Cases; Concurrent session on Strategies fear Successful Ad}udication of Campus Conduct Violations, Concurrent sessran an Deploying Risk Management St~~ate~ies Effectively Vv'ithn Student Affairs:. hlavember, 2003_ • Maryland Coal elan Aga~n~t Sexual Assault Regional Conference. Pier~ary session Drunk Sex or Date Rapp; Can You Tell. tote Difference? Concurrent session on Sexual Assault, Sexual Harassment and Title IX: ~°I~naging the Ris4~ on Campus. Concurrent session on L feLessons Online: Sexual Assacalt 101. 'EVov~mber, 2f~0~. • NCIIERM Judicial Decision-Mak~rTraining Academy, Woodb+~ry Un~verstg; CA, 2Oa3. • NCHERM Judicial Decisi€~n-P~ aker Training Academy, Gc~ucher College, MD, 2003. • N~HERN1 Judicial Decision-hAa~Cer'rraning Academy. Tutane University, f,A, ~0{~3. • NCHERM Judicial Decision-I~akerTraning Acac#emy. Fariegh Dickinson University, Nj, 2003.

101 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 102 of 117 Page ID #:1480

• NCHERM )ud~eia) Decis an-Maker Training academy,Transylvania university, tC~`, 2(?Q3. ~ AICH~F~~'S Judicial Decision-Maker Training ~Cau~emy, Georgia State I:lniversify, GA,ZOa3. NCH~R1~ J~diciaE Deei~ion-Maker Training P►eac~erny, Kenyon C~Itege, OH, ~Otl~. + NCHEKi~i ~~eminar--Campus Sexual Assault ar,ci Alcohol Issues: ScT-~tegies f~rr Culture Change. Clniver~ity of Ca}iFornia, Irvine, ZaU3_ • Association fQr Student Judicial Affairs (ASJA) Annual Can€erense. Ha1~-day Fre- canf~rence session vn Best Practices forAdjudicatic~n o~Campus Sexual Misconduct. Ca~n~urren~ session on Understanding the Consent ~onstrurt. February, 2t)1~4. • NCHERIVi Seminar--Campus Sexual Assault and ~fcahoi Issues: Strategies far culture Change, presented with A}an Berkawitz, Ph,D, Union College, ~iY. January, 20Q4. ■ NCHERI~1 Semrnar--Camps Sexual Assault and A{cc~h~il .Issues:: Stz-ategies for Culture Change, presented with Aian Berkowitz, Fh.D. Thamas je~ferson University. March, 2 Qtl4. NCHE~tM Seminar--Risk Management for Student and judicial Affairs—An Advanced Seminar. Adel hi Uinver~ity [~Y. March, ~~04. NCHERM Seminar---Sexual Assault. Sexu~[ Harassment and Title t Managing the Risk on Campus. University of ~3enver. March, 2QOA~. • AssariaCion fir Student Persc~~rne[ Adrnitt str~tars (ACPA~ ~nnu~l Conference.. Cancurrent Session an LifeLessans online: Sexual Assault 1()1. Ganeurrent Session ~n Ela6arating a Risk Management EramewQ~c for Hearing t~onduet Appea?s. April, 20Q4. • NCNERM judicial' ~ecisior.-Maker Training Academy, St. Leo`Coilege, FI,. 2t10~. • NCHERA7 Judicial Decision-Maker Training Academy, Central College, IA, 2004. • "Campus ~~dicial Training and Leal Cssues." N) Means of Students Association Annual Me~king, NJ., June Zf?44. • "'Sexual Assault Prevention Best Practices; ~Creat rig a Safer Comrcaun ty." Cc~nFerence at University of Uklahoma, August 2Oi~~. • ..[)rank Six car I}ate Rape: Can. Yflu Tell the [}~fference~.', Plenary Address, Vk~CASA Gonferenc~ c~t~ Sexual Vialenc~ and the Cotl~ge Campus, Stevens Paint, Wl., September 2004: • "Drunk Sex Qr Date Rage: C~~ You Tell the I3ifference?.' Conference Sponsor, Opening Keync~t~ Address and two concurrent sessions at Safe St~ciety Zone—The ~Eatio~al ~vnference on Sexual Assault in tour Schools, Oclar~~lo, FL., t3ctober Z~Q4. ASIA Cit~uit 3 Sexual I~iseortduct Conference, Keynote ;address a nd p~net st, YorEc ~olleg~ of PA, December 2Ofl4. NCHERM Intensive Institute—Crafting a Code of Conduct for the 22~[ Century College at Lewis &Clark College, Portland, t?R, i}ecemher, 2Da4. • NCHERM lideoserninar--Best Practices for Campus Sexual fv~ seondutt Judiei~l Training, at the University of Qaytc~n. Ca-pe~se~ced with Sattnclr~ Schuster, Esq. September 2~30~. • ~1CHERM Seminar--~ampu~ Sexuak Assault and Alcohol Issues: Strategies for Culture Change, presentees with Alan Berkowitz, PhD. Catawba College, February 2Q~15. • NCHERM Aud oseminar—A Civil R ghCs Approach to Campus Sexual Violence, ca~ presented with Saundra Schuster. Esq. April 20C?5. N'CHEftM Aud oseminar—Crafting a Ct~de of Conduct ft~r the Zi~i Century Ca~le~e, April SOUS:

102 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 103 of 117 Page ID #:1481

•~ t~CHERM Audiosernirtar—The Challenge of Educating Students on High-Risk Health and Safety Issues. Co-presented with Alan Berkowitz, Ph.D., June ZQUS. • lVCHERM Autiioseminar—Best practices for Balancing Rights in Campus Conduc[ Processes, dune 2x05. • Association for Student Judicia4 Affairs [ASJA) A`ttnual Conference, Conference Sponsor, All-Day Fre~conferenee and half-day post-conference presentations with ar. Linda ~' Rowe, February 2005. • Guardian Conference,:Keynote Address "Drunk Sex or Date Rape: Can. You.Tell the [}fference?" University of Central Oklahoma,June 2UQ5. • ASjA Donald Gehring Judicial Training institute,. Facutty. The University of Utah, June 20fl5. CUPA-HR Annual. Conference, Concurrent Session,"Sexual Assault, Seacual Rarass€n~nt and Title IX. Managing the Risk ~n Campus:' Orlando, Florida, September ZOf}5. • Safe Society Zone—The National. Ct~nference on Sexual Assault in Our Schools, Orlando, FL., actaber 2005. Four concurrent sessions. • "Risk Management Strategies for Student and Judicial Affairs" and "Risk Management Strategies far Student Organizations,° The National Conference on Student Leadership, Orlando, FL. November, 2005. e The Higher Education. Law & Poiic~r Institute, Institute Sponsoring Partner, Opening Plenary Panelist and eo-presenter of tvvo concurrent sessions. San Diego, CA. 1?ecember,205. CLH~ Visehinar "Due Process for Campus Conduct Proceedings." December, 2005.. • Missouri(and Kansas} College and University Personnel Association Annual Meeting. Keynote and concurrent presenter. Kansas City, January 20{?6. • NCHERM Senninar "l.ega! Issues 2005", co-presented with Saundra.Schuster, ~sq. at Catawba College, NC. February, 2UQ6. • NCHERM Seminar,"Best. P~ctices far Response to Student Suic dality", co-presented with Saundra Schuster, Esq. at Catawba College, NC. February, 2Q06. Association for Student Judicial Affairs ~ASjA) Annual Conference,conference Sponsor; Pre-conference presenCation "Ntisson Impossib{e? Protecting and Promoting Freedot~ of Expression while Protecting and Promoting Civility and Freedom from Harassmene" and two concurrent sessions,"Addressing. the Intersection of Campus Complaints with Criminal Trials" and "The Main Event: A Debate an the Role of Evidence in Campus Hearings." February, 20U6. * Association for Student Personnel Administrators(ACPA) Annual. G~nFerence. Pre- ranference "Advanced Judicial Training Academy." March, 20Qb. • West Virginia Four►d~tion far Rape Information and Serrices Annual Conference. Keynote '"Drunk Sex or.Date Rape" and concurrent sessions "A Conversation on Consent" and "Strategies far Campus Culture Change an Sexual Misconduct" April, 200fs. • NCHERM Seminar "Legal Issues 2x05", eo-presented with W. Scott Lewis, J.D. at Concordia University, WI. April, 2UOb. • NCHERM Seminar, "Best Practie~s for Addressing Student Sucidality", co-presented with W, Scott Lewis, J.D. at Concordia University, WI. April, 2Q06. NCHERM Webinar, "Student Suicide: What College. and University Administrators Need

103 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 104 of 117 Page ID #:1482

to Know About the Law a nd Best Practices.0 $rett Sokolov, JD,Saundra Sehu~ter, Esq. and W Scott L~wts, JD, June, ZOa6. + ASJA Circuit Three &Pennsylvania College personnel Assoeiatican (PCPAj Jc~ rat Rriue-In, Pane}rst "Risk J~lanagement in Campus Contlu~t Administration" Lehigh University,. PA. July, 240b. • NCHERM'Wehinar,"Seudent Suicide: Best Prac~ice~ far Student AFfairs Administratr~rs, Co~tnsetors aid Gampvs Health Service Providers." Brett ~okalow, JD, Saundr-~ Schuster, Esq. Richard.Kadison, M.~., and W.Scan I,~w s JD. August 2(}~fi. • CUPA-HR Annual Canferenee, Concurrent S~ssi~azi ca-presented v+rith Saundra 5chus~er, Esq.f .,Best Prat yes for Campus Civil Rights Investigations." San Diego, CA,Ss~ptemb~r Z~06. • Penrtsyluania CoElegQ Perscannel Association (P~,:FA) Fal!' Keystone West, featured Speaker,"Nfentai NealCh ~n our Camps. +current Trends &Campus Responses" St. Vincent Cc~liege, PA. TVovernber 2t~06. • Pennsyluania Ct~llege Personnel Association (PCPA) Fall Keystgn~ fast, Featured Speaker,"Mental Health on vur ~amp+~s: C~rr~nt Trends ~C G~m~us Responses•,' Yark College, PA. December,. ZD06. NCNERIM Seminar,•'Student Suicide: W~iatCollege and University Administrators Need t4 Know about the l aw anti hest Practices:' Notre I}arne c3e tJamur University, CA. September, 20 6. • N~HERM Webinar,"Evaluating Sexual Miscond~u~t Cc~mpl~ints: Force,(;onsent and Incapacity. C~ctc~ber, 2C~~b. • ~1C;HERM ~J1lebit~ar, "C~rr~pus Sexuat Miscc~nduc~ and the Law_" Ca-presented with Saundra Schuster, Esq. t3ctober, 2Q06. • IVCHERM Webinar, "Special Consderatiar~s in Hearing Sexual MiscQnduet Ct~mplaints'° Co-presen~~d with W'. Scott Lewis, JCS, C~ctaher, ~OQ6. • iVational feet n~ an Aicohoi and Other Drug Abuse ~t~d Violence Prevention in hi ghee E~e~~~ation. Concurrent session cc>-presented ~vit;~ Marlene Regan and Ann Mah n on "Best Practices for Campus S~xua! r ssault Res~c~nse FmtQct~ls:' Arl ngtQn,'~A. Qctober ~Q06. • Safe Society Zone--The E~atianai Conference on Sexual Assault is~ t?ur SchQvts. Keynote ..Best Practices for Campus sexual ivtiseor~duct Culture C~iac;ge"end concurrent sessions. Tampa. FL., t3etr~ber 2046,. CALCASA Institute,"Best Practices for Sexual Misconduct Judi~ial Training'• Columbus, C}H. {}ctober, 20Q6.

Pubtcatians .R~

Thy X994 ,~le~y Act ~,C~m,~us S~~curit}r Act} Compliance Manual. Bretti4. Sok~low,JD. (C~ 2flfla, The National CenFer ft~r Higher Education Risk fv(anagement).

Thy C~tncaus Sexual Misconduct Jur~ial Trainirt~ Manual. Brett A. Sokt~lvw, ]D•(Q 20Q0, The National Center for Higher Education Risk Management)-

104 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 105 of 117 Page ID #:1483

? A Model Campus Sexual Misconduct Response Protacc~l. Brett A. Sakolow,jD anci Katk~erine H. Koestner. {Qc 2001, The National Center for Higher Education Risk. Management).

The Rt~ht to counsel rn Eam pus t~iscj,~~,jna~y Hearings• Now Much Process Is,t~ue?' Brett A,Sokc~Iow, JD.(OO 2000,The National Center for Higher Education Risk Pvlanagernent).

r Rules of Evidence for the Campus judicial Process. Brett A. Soktalow, jD.(O 2(}Ot}, The National Center for Higher Education Risk Management).

r Creating.a proactive Campus Sexual Misconduct Foticy.(D 2001, The f3ationai Center far Higher Education Risk Management}.

r C~rrr~prehensive Campus Sexual Misconduct Judicial Procedures, (Q 20QI,The N~tiana) Center for Higher Education Risk Manager►~e~t}.

r The Elements of Colaege Judicial Jurisdiction. (U~ 20010, The Natianaf Center for Higher Education Risk Management)..

~ Sexual Misconduct on Campus with Katherine H. Koestner (p 1999, Campus Qutreach JEt~tIC@S~ ~11C,~.

r Total Sexual Assault Risk Management Strategies for Colleges with Katherine H. Koestner (cU 1998, Campus Outreach Services, lnc.)

,'► Instilling Principles of Risk Management into the Daily Practice of Student Affairs. Edited by Brett A. Sakoiaw, JD, width chapter contributions by Brett A, Sok~la~v, JD, John Wesley Lowery, Ph.D, Troy Harris, Beverly Costello, Dennis Gregory,. Ed.D, and Edward. Spencer, Ed.D. (O 2Q01, The National Center far Higher Eduction Risk Management).

r The N~HERM Judicial Training Manual. Edited by Brett A. Sokolow, JD, with chapter contributions by Brett A. 5akalow, JD, Mary Louise Antieau, JD, W. Scott Lewis, jQ, and Linda P. Rowe, Ed.D. {(c~ 2fl02, The Nations! Center for Higher Education Risk Management).

Chapters

r "Sexual Violence: The Legal.. Front,"' a chapter in the anthology, Just Sex (Rovaiman and Liitlefietd, 2~U~};

A "Sexual Assault Risk Management Strategies for Colleges: ~4 Uses`s Guide Tn Fleshing 4~t the Campus Security Act"'published as a chapter in Volume 3 of he Complete Workr~lare Valence Preventign Manual (fames Publishing, 1998).

9 `°Proactive Violence Prevention far Colleges and Universities" published as a chapter in

L`7

105 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 106 of 117 Page ID #:1484

Vr~lume b cif The Workplace V~s~lence Prevenkit~n Gu~c~e (Sped alty Techr~ ea{ Publishers, 2~~3~.

"Risk Management for Comrrtunity Ct~lleges" in Legal Issues in the Comrr~ur~ ty Catlege ( dew 17irections for Community Colie~es, Jassey-Bass, 2D04).

Artr`c1es

"Tt~e Ri~t~t t~ Counsel in College pisciplinary Hearings and Due Prices Considerations" in Crime Victims' L C[gat on Qu~rCerly, Vol. 3, too. ~. Naticanat Victim Cer►ter, May 1996.

t "CoClege Risk ~[anagement: Creating a Sexaal Assault Response Network ~rotocal " Vol 3 ~'3Jc~rkplace Violence Preuenti~n e Qrter 12. Jamies Publishing, Inc. Dec, 1997.

•,The Elements of CQtle~e Jud~ci~! Jurisdiction" in The Re~rc~rt c~ra Campus ~~rr~mt~n t S~f~ty, 1~~01.1 #~. The Civic F~ese~re~ ~n~t[tut~.

"Someone Yau Should Know: Daa-en Bakst, Esq," in The Report an Campus ~ore~munE~}r Sae Vol_ 1 #Z. NY: The Civic Research [~lstitute.

"Confidentiality and Mandatory Reporting of Sexual Assault Under Title lY'° in yTh R~pr~rt an C~mnus Com~t~n SafeC~, VoI.1 #4, The Civic R~eseareh Institute

"Eliminating ~'t~rse from Camgus Scxuak ~9isconduet Pg9ieies: The Rise of 7'he Consent Construct" in The Re~ori pan Cam~ys Safety and Student T~evelot~men~. Val,: ~ #2. NY The Civic Research institute (ro-authQr~;

r "Disciplinary appeals: Getting Stic~i~r bn Campus" in The ~e~ort nra G~rnpus Sa€eta end Student (7evelopment Vc~l. Z #2. NY: Tl~e Civic Research Institute.

➢ "Sexua11~1 isconducc Policy Interactive (quiz {with Katie KcresCner).'in ;The Report an Carr€vus Safety and ~tu~~r~t 1?evelonmerL, Vol. Z #3. NY: Thy Civic. Research Instftute.

"~ "Title TX I~f andates: What Dais RecQnt Case Law Mean:for Cn~titut~Qns in Cases cif Student-on-~tudenC Sexual Assault" in The Report on Gamous Safety and Stud~n~. l~evelo~rrcent,~ V~1.2 #4. PJ'Y: The Civic Research institute.

'"Same,~ne Yc~u Should Know: Joel Epstein, Esq." in The Re~rirt can Can~~us Safety and Stud~n~ ~evPln~m~~t. VoL 2 ##4. N~~ 'I'he Civic Research Institute.

"What Is ~ Burden of Proof Requirement Doing in Your Campus judicial Procedures?•' in Thy R~~►ort ~n Campus Safety anti Student Devela ment Vot, ~ #~5. IVY: The Civic R~se~rch Institute,

"Student flfF~nder: Educate or Eliminate?" in The Re~~rt on Garn~, s Safe and

106 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 107 of 117 Page ID #:1485

S[udent ~ev~lo~ittten~, VoL 2 #~S. NY: The Civic Research Institute.

~- "Complying With the C1ety Act. 'I`he Ad~ranc~d Gaurse (with Jahn Wesl~;,~ Lo~•ery, Ph.t~., ~nt~ Dai~glas'Futtle, N1PA~,• In: Thy Re~rorz ran Ca~tj~us Safe and Student l~evelo~►ment. l~ol. 3 #l. NY: "'f'heCivie Research Institute.

i- "Samec~ne You Should FCncaw: An lntery ew!Nittt Katie Koestner." in'T`he R~~ort €gin ~amn~,s Sat~e~-~nd ~t~~at [3evelc~~m~nt. VII. ~ #3. h1Y The Civic Research Inst~tut~.

'.'- "Balancing Legat sm and i7evelt~prn~nCal sm in Campus Judicial ~'rc~ce~d ngs:' in R~r~ort o~1 G,a~}~as Safi ia d ~t~den~ C~evela~m~nt. Vc~l. 3 #4, NY: The Ci~i~ R~sear~h Institute.

"`St~rneone Yflu Should Knew: Alan D. ~erltowitz, Ph_D." in T ,~P,eporr on Campus. f~t~ aid Student l7eve,~~ ~n , Vol. 3 #~4. ICY: The C vie ~es~arch Mnstttute:

%~ .A Fevv Random h~ot~s From the Editor forfurAnnual Sexual Assau9t lssue.,~ in Report can Campus Safe and S~udent t7evelogmen~s Vcat. 3 #5, f~Y: The Civic Research Institute_

r "Nar3rard Pc~iicy Change Politicizes Rape:' ire The ~,er~c~rt ~n C~r~~pus 5afe~y and St~tden~ evelc~pmen~, Vol. 3 #b. NY; The Civic Research lnstiCute.

r "W~shir~gt~n ~Ilr~rd" in 7'he Report on ~am~s Safety end Student I~eveEapment, Vc~l. 3 #6. NY: The Civic Research Institute.

;- "S~meone Yc~u Should Know, Ann. Pcrsta~n." in Thy R~a_~~a~ Campus Safety and St~c~~nt Devela~rnenC. VoI. ~ ##2. NY: The Civic Research InstituEe.

•• "1Nhs~'s Helpir►g Wham: Are Our Sexua} Assault R~spons~ Prc~tc~Gols Working?" in ~er~vrt on Carn~us Safe and Stunt Develo~m~nt V~[. 4 #S. h1Y; The Citric Research. Institute.

v "Training ~atnpus ~anduct Boards fir Sexual Misconduct Ftearit~gs" in Thy Renork on Campus ~af~e and Student D~velc~ meat, Yol. 4 #5. N`~': Tie Civic Research lnstitut~.

"Crafting a Code of Conduct far the 21~~ Century College:" to The Report on Campus Safety and Student f?e~eGopment. Val. ~ #5. ~iY The Civic Research Institute.

Casen~te Corrtrnent: „lnterestirtg Case with Campus Crime Reporting Irnpl ~~t~ons." Ire The Report on Campus Safety and Student ~evelr~pment, Val, 6 #3. NY; The Civic Research Institute,

"'Thy Typo[~r~ of Campus SexuaE Misct~nciuct Complaints," In The Report an Campus Safety and Stut~ent development. Vol. 5 ~4, NY; The Civic Research Institute.

107 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 108 of 117 Page ID #:1486

"Mis~ian tr~p~ssible: Cart Colleges Protect anti Promate Freed~rn of Expression Wh fe Pt`€ltecti~g and Promoting Civility and Freedom Erc~m ~farassrnent"?" with L r►da 1P. Rowe, Ed.D, In The Report ~n ~~tnpus ~a~ety an€~ Student De~felopn~ent, Vol 6 ##5 NY. T3~ C uic Research Institute.

r~ '"Al! FJRE'd UP." In The NCHERM Chrnr~icle ofCam~us ~onduc~. Vol. 1, Issue 1. Fet►ruary 18~h, 2005. ~fC!-1~RM: M~lverrt, ~'A.

r~- "Al1 ~ERPE'd UP." In The NCB-I~RM Chra~n cis a€Campus Conduct. Vc~l. 1, Issue 1. Fet~ruaey 18~ti, Z~D~5, fV~HEKMt: Malvern, f'A.

"W~rds Have Weight." [n The NCH~Rh~1 Chron'e1e o~C~ us Cot,~t uck. Vt~l. 1, Issue 2. February ZS~~.Qtl5. N(:HERM: Malvern, PA.

`~ '"Standards cif Provfin Campus Canc~uet Hearings" ]n 1'h~ NC_H~RM ChrQn c[e r ~am~us conduct_ Vol. 1, Issue 3. March. Sth, 2Qt~5. NC;HERh'I: IvCalvern, ~A.

'"Yc~u N'~ajc the. Right t~ Remain Silent. I~on'C YQ~.r, In The ~NCHFRM C~r~n cle of C~ml3.us Conduct. 4►~1. 1, Issue ~. March 1Zt~, 2t~05. NCHERM: Malvern, PA.

"The Self-Defense tiefense" In `Tj7e N(:HFRM Ghrnni~le o~Catnor,~s Cpn~~„ Vol, 1, Issue 5. I~arc~ 18~h, ~00~. F~CHERt~i: Malvern. PA.

"Settling Complaints—Very Unsettling:' in The t~CHERM Chrr~nicte cif C~m~us ~` n [. ~fat.1, Issue 5, March T8;~, 20f~5. h1CH~RM Malvern, PA.

."~ "E?e1[berat~ Ir~diff~rene~ UnderTitle 1X: ~~ntra~ting ~[liarns v. ~a'r~t w►th hauls v. F ~rc~ ~aun,~y." In The t~CHERI~i ChrQt~icle oFCampus Conduct. Vol, 1, Issue 6. March 25z~, 2t}~OS. NCHERM: Malvern, PA.

>~- "'The Challenge of Ab~jsive Aff~l~at can." to Thy hJ(;HFk~N1 Chror~i~.~e. _ ~f Campus Cc~n~ uct. Vot,1, ls~ue 7. Agri1 15t„ 2005. NCHERM: Malvern,: PA:

"OCR Findings in its 2[~D4 ~nv+es[igation cif Gea~rgetc~wn University.•, In Thy NGH~RM ~. ~n`ele caf Gam~us Conduct. 'poi. ~, Issue 8. April 8R~, 2005. N~HERM. Malvern, PR.

i~ "Mediation and Tilde IX`" Ir► The IvC[~~$Iv~~.~yo le of Carn~us Co~~3uct. Val_ I, Issue 9. March 22~, 2[?{~S. CHERt~I- Malvern, PA,

"The FERPA IQTesG" Cn The NCHERM Chronicle of Campus Conduct_ Val. ]., Issue it1. AQril 22na, ~QDS. NCHERM: Malvern,: PA.

:~ ,•I~o We Have to...Addcess Sexua! Misconduct can l7ur Campuses" In The ~YC~~.~t~1. Chronicle'of Cam.R u~s Conduct. Vol. 1, Issue 1I, iviay 6~~, 20fl5, hiCHER~"1: Ma}ugrn, pA.

i~ "The Redemptive Reversal." In The NGN~RM Chronicle ~rf Campu___Cionduct. Vo}. 1, ~ z

108 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 109 of 117 Page ID #:1487

Issue 11. May fish, X005. NCH~RM,; Malvern, P~.

r "hest Practices ft~r Addressing the CQn~uence off' Campus Com}~iarnts with criminal firiat~." In The N~:HERM Chraniele of Campus ~c~nd~~ct. Vai. 1, lssue'13. May 2[~4h, ~ZOa~. NCHERh~I~ [v~alvern, PA.

'r` "'itevoking an Offer o~Admiss on: Leal Issues and Best Prackices." ~n The NCli~R[+~f Chronicle of Campus Conduct. Vai,1, Issue 14, May 2'7t~, 2005, NC}~~RM: Malv~rnf PA.

r "Toc~ Much Civility? The Right to Confront ire Campus Conduct Hearings," ~ditar'sNote to main article. In The NC}iFRR9 Chr~„~~cI~~.C~,i~. ~uS Gon~uc~;. Vail. 1,[ssue 1S. jun;e 3r~, ~(}i15. NCHERh~I: N(alvern, Phi.

r "tNe Need tea Teach Students F3t~ Co Drink:" In The ~i~FRM Chroniclearr~nu raf~ Cc~n Bret. Vol.1, Issue 17. June l~~ti, 20fl5. NCH~RM: Nlatv~rn, ~~#.

i "Tl~ie Challenge ~f Educating Students on High-disk Healtk~ aid Safety (sues:' Ise ~e N('HERM Chronicle of Camnvs Cn c . WoL 1, Essue 18'f 19. jurre 24~~, X005, NCHERM: lv~alvesn~ PA.

~ "i~t'.I.T. Is Guilty...aF Being Nice:' In The CHERh~1 Ghrc~nicle of Gamnus Canduct. V+~L 1. Issue ~1. August 12t~, ZOOS. NCHEFM: ~lalv'ern, Pr's.

' ~ "Better Late Than Never; The Nat~d~ook for Campus Crime Re~artng,, In The NC~IERh'f Chronicle of Campus ~~nc~u~t. Vol, 1, Issue 22. August 1'9Eh, 2Qa5. NCHERM: N[alvern, PA.

r "Sha~uld ln~titutionai Employees Have a Duty to 2epart Campus Crime?,. In }~~RM Chror~~cle of Gam~us innduct. ~aL I, Issue 23..August 26~~, 2{}fl5. NCHERt~t; Malvern, PA.

r "What Rite Should Flutes of Evidence ~'iay in Campus Cont3uetTrain ng~" 1'n T e 1~CHERM Chronicle of Campus Conduct: tlt~i'. 1, issue 2b. September 16~~, 2tl{l5. NCHER~vI: ~+Ialvern, PA.

"Best Practices: 'What Dc~ You Qo Nthen>.. A Student. Reports a Sexual F►ssault but Thin asks That No Action Se Taken?"' In Thy NCN Ft~M ~h~~ni~le cif Campus GQnduct. Vol. 3, Issue 27. Septest~h~r 23~. 2{~t~5. t+~CHERM: Malvern, PA.

"The Primacy of Policy.,' In TEL I~CHF.RM ~f~ran cl~a~C~mpus Conduct. Val.1, Issue ~'9. ~7ctaber 7th. Z{~0~. NCHER[+9: Ma[~ern. PA,

~ "'The [VCHERM 5-P Made1 for Campus Culture Change," to g.RlCHERN~ Chran cl~ Qf Carr~gus Car~duct. Vol, 1, Fssue 3~. ~ctc~ber 14~h, 2i~t}5. NCHER~vt; Malvern, PA.

l' 3

109 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 110 of 117 Page ID #:1488

r .`Sanctioning far Sexual 4~fisconduct:"' In ~'he NCHERM Chrgn cle cif('arn~u~ Conduct. ~e~L 1, Issue 3~. (3ctober 21~~, ZOflS. I3CHERM. Maluern. ~'A.

r 'The Role of Expert Wi~ne~ses in campus Hearings" In The t~CI~ERNI Chronicle of mr~ s CantEuct. Val. 1, issue 32. (7ctaber 28~h, 2~3(3S. NCHERM: Malvern, PA.

"The Victim's Rights Paradigm far campus N~arings." to The NCHERM Chr~nic'e Campus Conduct. tool. 1, issue 33. Navember 4~~, 2005.. NCHERM. 1~1aiv~rn, F~_

,•]s it ~efamatary to Accuse a Student of a Conduct Violatiun?., In The I~CH~RML Chr~ni~le of Campus Cc~r~duct; Vol. I, Issue 37. December 9~h, 2~Q5. NCHE~.M. Malvern, pA.

r "`Campus `Fire' Safety.•, In The C~C~tERJ~.~hron cte a#'Gatnpus C€~nducC. Vol. 2. Issue 1. January bah, 2t}Of~. NCHERM: Malvern, P~.

~- '~1Neb-based Approaches to Aleot~crl and (utter Drug lnteeventian'' f?auglas Van Sickle, Ph.D. and BretT A, Sc~kotow, JIB in cue F~er~o n Cam~u~ SaEet~ and Studen Devetopmer►t dal. 7, #4. januar~, 24706. NY: The Civic F~Qsearch Institute.

i~ "base Studer" 1n The NCN~RM Chr€~nicie of Campus Cond~et: Vfll. Z, Issue 8. 3~Iarch 3~, 2t1Q6. NCH~RM: INalvern, PA.

~, ,;The Alcohol B'lackou't: A Bcaok Re~ie~N." Tn `f'he T~~N~R1vi ~hrc~ncl~ of Campus uc .Vol. 2, [ssue 9. Maech 10~ 2t3~6. NCHFRI~i; Malvern, PA.

..Risk Management in the College SeCting" In The NCH tM Chronici~ of Campu s can ct_ Vol. 2, issuel0. March 17~n, ~OOb. ~CHERM: Malvern, PA.

"'uVeb-Based Agpraaches to A:lcvh4l and. Other Drug lt~tervent an"With Dauglas E.. Vans ckle. In Tie NCHERM Chronicle of Camgus Conduct. V41. 2, issue 13. April 71h, Zg05. 'tVCHERNl; Malvern, PA.

r~ "hest Practices far Supportin; Stiic dal Students With[n ~ Risk Management Frame t~rk" In The 1~~F~FR°' C~r~nic4e ~afCam,~us Conduct. Vol.. 2, Issrae 17. May 5~h, 2.006. N~HERM: Malvern, PA. ~ "l atnos~xuafs Untnrelcvme Here...The Lav+r of Diser min~tiort by Recognised Student Organizations." In The f~CftFRM Ghrnni~le~f Campus Conduct. V+~1.2, Issue 18. h3ay 12~n, 20Q6, I~CHERM: Malvern, PA.

::~ '.Clet-yAct Quiz, Part one:' in `['he tVCN~R Chronicle of ~aangus Conduct. Vol. 2, Issue I9. Nlay 19th, 206. I~CHERM: Malvern. PA.

r "'Clery Act Quiz, Part Two°' In T1~e NCH~RM Chra~icle of Campus Conduct Vot. 2, lssu~ 20. May C6~h, 2x06. NCHERM: Malvern, FA.

110 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 111 of 117 Page ID #:1489

.~ "`Cler}> Act Quiz; Part'f'hree." ln't"he ~ICHEFtM ~:hrnnicle ~►f Cana~us ~nnd~€ct. Vol. Z, [sue Zl. June 2~~, 2E~~16. NCH~~~: Malvern, PA.

r "The Clery Act Quiz" in the R~nrt ~n Ca►npus Safe~~..t}r.~Stt~de~~I?eveln,prnent Vct3. ~, #1. May, ZOQ~, NY: The Civic Research Institute.

Edt+~r Th~.89►~ct.,1;~(':~r Rt~.~,~,' and Student ~evelo~sment (former' titled the Re~Qrt on ~arnnu~ C~m~nunity Safe~v~. published bimonthly by the Civic Research` Ir~stitu~e, ~Vew York. 2000-Present.

Founder and Editor-in-Chief: The lVCliERM Chronicle of i,~r~~pus Ccrrtduct, published. vueekky via email. NGHERM, N(alv~rn FA. .February 2Q05-July,ZO~b.

Legal issues Editor, The Student Affairs Law and Policy ~eekl~; published ~y the Council ran I.aw ~n Higher Educ~tiQn. July 21106-presene.

White Papers

~- Co-author, Guidance for Irrst4tuk ohs in Cases r~F S;~dent-an-Student Sexual l arassmer~t anci Sexua! Assault. (Q 1~9~, Campus outreach Services, Inc.]..:

r Title 1X Nl~n+dates What Does Rec~~se I.,a~~+ iulean for tn~,~it~tjc~ns in Cases of Student-on-student sexual RssaulC? (~ 2 300, ~`he Nat dt~at C~~[er fc►r Higher Education Risk Management}.

r (~ 2tl(~1, The Pdatonal Genker fc~r Higher Educatit~n Risk.. Maraagement~.

Cc~m~Iv,~g With t he ~'(~~,r Act: '~~e ,advanced Caurs~ ( eth John Wesley L~w~ry, Ph.E3., and Douglas TuttE~, ~A PA). ~Q ~CiC}'L, The lVatir~nal Center ~`or Higher ~ducat~on Risk Management).

r instilling Risk M'anagemert Principles into the Deity Practice of Student AFFairs. {C~7 ZOC12. "Fhe t~aCk~nal Center for Fligher Ec~ucatior~ Risk R~tanagem+~nt).

r it's NQt That e C?r~n't Know Nc~w to Think—if's That We Lacy Dialectical Skills (t 2x(33, Thy National Center far Higher Ed~tcatiQn Risk Management).

A bode of ~ond~ct ftrr the 21~R Century C~Ileg~. [~ 24i?4. The National Center for Higher Education Risk Management)..

3~= The Typology ~~Campus Sexual Misconduct Ca Plaints. (QQ 200 = 7'he National Center for Higher Edacation Risk Man~gerner~t).

our Duty C}F Care is a Duty TC~ Care. (~ 2~} 5, fihe National Center for Higher Edu+eaton Risk Management}.

111 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 112 of 117 Page ID #:1490

Same Kind of Hearing. (O 2(347. The National Center for Higher Edueatican ~tisk Management).

r The, NCI ERM Seh~v Arai lr~tet'v~nttdn and Threat Assessment "I~eat~t CUY3iT Modef{U ~t}C1~. The rational Genter foe Higher Etiucati~n Ris~C Management).

Videos

'The 2C3{~4 NCHERM Sexual M sce~nduct judicial Training V~deoser~ir~ar. Four hour tape of s~teli to semin~r.Cl(tJ 20QU. The t~atianal Center for Higher ~d'u~:ati~n Risk ~+lanagerrient).

= The 2d(ll tVCHERM judicial Training Videvsemirsar. fix hour tape +af satellite seminar. (~c 2(}.01. The National Center for H ~E~er ~drxcatian it sk Mar~agernent}.

~- Instilling Risk t~~[<~nagernent Principles into the Daily Fracti~e of~tudent Affair. Four hair tape c~(~~~eb-seminar. (~ 2002. T ie ~Iaticxna! CenCer for Nigher Education Risk A~anagement).

'the 2003 ~ICI~ERM f udiciat Decision-Maker Training Academy. Four=hour cape €~f tiialet gal skill-building training academy with mock cases on sexual ~ss~ult and ccrrrtputer ]jarassment. (Cc? 20(}3. The National CentEc for Higher Education Risk Manageme~t~.

~= The ~Q{}4 hest Practices;for Campus Sexual Miscc~nriuet Jud ciat Tra~r~ing V deoseminar, witf~ Saundt~a Schuster,.. Esq. Four hour [ape of s~te~lite=broadcast j~~~i~iat training from the University ~f £~ayton, i7M. ~Q 20G4. The Nt~ci~anal Center fr~r Hi~h~r Ed~catic~n R6sk Manag~rner~t).

AutiFoseminars an C~D-r~0~vl

N~HERivI At~dioseminar—A Civil Righ~~ Approach tc~ Campv~ Sexual Violence, co- presentetl with Saundra Schuster, Esc{.. 91J minutes,

? i~CHERNI Audiosem nor—Crating a Code of Conduct f~~'the 21$i Century ~~Jleg~. 9t} CCtiT1L1~~S,

~- tJCHERM Audios~minar—The Ch~ilenge cif Educating Students ran Nigh-Risk Health and Safety Issues. Two 90-minute sessions. Cv-presented with A[an Berkowitz, Ph,D,

~ tVCHERM Aud aseminar—Best PracCices fQr ~alanc ng Rights in Campus Conduct ~'rocesses. 9~ minuCes.

NGHERM Aud bserra nor--t~Basic fairness and ProceecEings--ion Gehring and Brett

112 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 113 of 117 Page ID #:1491

Sokoiaw Offer a basic introduetior~ to procedural fairness and decision-making, including the legat underpinnings of fundamental fairness and dae praeess. ~}0 minutes,

r NCHERM Audioserninar--The Skill o/`Anafyzrny vnd Apptyr"ng Polic}F--offers participants a chance to work with Brett Soko[ow and Saundra Schuser on pvEey analysis, complex complaints,.multiple viotatian complaints an~i group vicatations. 90 minutes.

r WCHERM Autlioseminar--Deliberaticarr Skills and ~anctianing Principles--Don: Gehring. and BreEt Sokolov talk about the philosophy of using progressive,.developmental sanetions. Deliberation ski!)s and three. models of deliberation (Adversarial, Consensus and Eiierarchical~ arepresented. 9U minutes..

➢ NCHERM Audioseminar--Sexua(MscanduetJudicic~l fi'rainng-- Brett Sok~low and. Saundra Schuster focus on speeia! considerations For sexual misconduct cotnplai~t~: 90 minutes.

NGHERM Audiasem nor--Qtrestron ng Skrl]s and Gesties--Brett Solcolflw and Scan Lewis discuss,the science of interpreting body language and affect and the skill of questioning witnesses. 9tl minutes.

NCHERM Aucfiaseminar--evaluating and Weighing Evidence--Mary Lc3u Antieau aid Breft SokQlow talk about simple, informal evidence rules to guide decision-making in campus hearings. 9Q minutes.

r NCHERM Suicide Webnar Part i; Student Suicide: What College and University Administrators Need to Know About the.Law and Best Practices. Brett Sokolov, JD. Saundra Schuster, Esq. and t+'V. Scott Lewis, JD. 90 minutes.

iVCHERM Suicide 1Nebinar Part lf: Student Suicide: Best Practices for Student Affairs Administrators, Counselors anti Campus Health Service Providers. BreCt Sokolov, JD, Saundra Schuster, Esq. Richard Kadison, A~t,D., ar~d W. Scott Lewis,.jD. 12f~ minutes,.

113 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 114 of 117 Page ID #:1492

expert Crises

Current rate: $7Qa.OQ/hr. ofd-site or $I4l.f}t}€~.tlQ pervn site day.

• jar~e T oe v, ~auth~astern University ~ DeF~nse expert fair ur~iv~rsit~ in negligence action by student injured during a 'i`ug-oF Wat` orentatian activity. c~ Settled. Na report :`~o elepas tic~rr. • 1~hn e v. the L)niversi t~~Si. Thomas ~MN.~. ;7()1~, a Flainti~f's ~x~ert in a due process and `f'itle IK suit by a s€udent accused of s~xuat~ssault, c~ C1r~gvng.lVt~ report. No depasitiort tQ c-~ate. Jahn Boe v. duke U~versi~y. 2i~~6 c~ Plair~tiFfs expert in a due }~racess and Title I~t suit try a student accused cif sexual ns~auit. o Ongoing. l4~G report,. Nca de~Qsitian Co date. • Jame goes 1.-F~ ~ the Universi~ c~F'I"ennessee Knoxvi9le 2(31 f, o Plaintiff` expert in negligence ar~d ~'i~le IK ~laitr~s arising from sexual assaults and a hostile envirvnm~~~t created by the athletics ~rogratn. a Settled'~2U16, ~'2.48r,~a. It o report. Nr~ dep~sitivn_ • ,J~n~ C~~e v,.5~. P~~ai'~ $c~t~~J. Zd16 o Plair~tifPs exp~~-t in a negligence claim against the schc~al by a wi~tim of sexual violence. c~ (1ng~inq. l~v r~pQr~ No de~rasitian to dote. • j~~; 17ae v Susq~~ehanna Twn~ Schaal Dish. o DeFens~ expert to a f~A school district in a Title IX claim ir~volvir~g an inappragriate relationship between a school official and a student. c~ C7rrgoirr~.Report,October2t11S • ~r~~ 17ae. u. University afArizana. 2f1~5 o Plaintiffs exert far victim in Title tX sexual harassmer~fassault/r~egl gertce lawsuit (~:rngioyee ct~arh perpetrator). o tangoing. rVv cam~rlarntfiled to state. • lata~ doe ~~. Baylor lJniversit~. 2fl1 o Plaintiffs expert €aruict m in Title [X sexual harassment/assault/negligence lawsuit. o Settled. No corrr~luirrtfried. john [3oe an~i Richard Rae'v Un~versity ~f ~indiay 2t~~ o Plaintiff's expert for two students expelled from un tiers ry in a Title IX sexual assauitf negligencefdefarnat ot~ lawsuit a Or~goirtg, Complaintfried.

114 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 115 of 117 Page ID #:1493

• j:~~e Dog{s) v. Rust ~all+~,~~. Z~l~~. o Plaintiffs expert for victim ire Title IX sex~aC harassment/assault lawsuiC (FactsltY Perpetrator). ~ Settled: R~part Auy~~t z~1~, L~epased Septe~2ber ~Q2S. s john ~c3e. v. Recd ~olle~e. 2t}15. o P'laintiff's expert for accused student in sexual misc~r~duct/Title I lawsuit o .Settled... Nt~ report r~o d~positic~n to date. • o n I7ae y. B~tc~n ~alle~e. 2015 c; Piainti€f`s experk for accused student ire sexual misconduct/Title ~X Lawsuit c~ Qnyoing. Report evrnpleted .tfI6, deposed c?(l1 ~i. M~[rvn tv disrrrr`ss being a~pea led. • Chet~ea G~dFrey lj errum G~lle~_ 2~1~. 0 4~efense expert tca the cc~]le~;e in a Title iX lawsuit by student victim of sexual. Pf115G01'1{~UC~. o .Settiecl. N€r report. !~'o de~rasiticrn. A~ttavi~ Jane Die v V~"gir►i~ W~s~~y,~n Univet'si~. ZQ1~. o DeFense expert its Title IX lavusuit E~y sexual misconduct victim agairYs~ university. o ReporC Nt~vern6er Z~t1S and depasitic~n, December ~t?IS, 7'rr`~i 1~#ay. 2~1~+~. Defense verd ct'ot trial. s 'i K~t~a Alpha v: El~rit~a SCate'Universi . ~a14: a expert for Pi Kappa Alpha. in hazing/sexual assault allegat ~n~ v ~esalwed'. N~ report,. no de~aositfort. • ,P~manda Lx~~na u. Delta U~sikon Frat~rl i . 2t~14~, o PlaintifFs expert. in dQmesti~: violence/alcoht~l/fraternity duty negligence ease. ~ Resr~lved. Report. Deposed. Sealed. • Andrew Caero u. 1.arnbcia ~~i A1~. 2014. c~ Plaintiffs expert to hate crime aktack v ctsm in negligence case against Fraternity, national, o Repore. 1?~posed. Settfeci. • Keifer ~ahnson v. WestQrn Colorado State Univ~rsity: 2D13-ZC?14. o plaintiffs expert to student accused cif sexual misconduct ire 7'ikle IX/negEigence/defamation suit aganse university. o Report fl srniss~d. • erica ~n$man v. Florida St~t~ University. Z't314. cs Taint E'~s exp~rC in fiitle 1X lawsuit against Flaric~a State University and OC[ cc~rnplaint by campus sexual rn scanduct victim;.. c~ Sealedfor$9.5l~,[?OiJ. No repvr~. t~fo depQsftron. • Dezmine Wefts v. Xavier Uniuers~- 2013.

115 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 116 of 117 Page ID #:1494

o Befer►se consultant to university in lawsuit by student expelled for s~xuaf m scandueG Title [X/negligence/defamation. o Settled. No report No deposition. + Jahn Doe v. arexel University. 2014. a PlaintifFs expert to a student accused of sexual misconduct in preparatit~n for a campus conduct process in Pennsylvania.. o Resolve'. • Eichorn v. Sigma Nu. 2014. o Plaintiffs expert in a lawsuit regarding anon-:fatal fall in a fraternity house, o Settled. ReparG Deposition. • Plaintiffs v. UnzversitX ref Colorado. Denver.. 2.013 o Subject matter expert to Perkins Co e, LLP in ids investigation of the James HDlmes shooting far the iJniversity of Colorado, Denver. o Resolved. R~par~ No depvsitr'on. • Craz~rv. Phi Sigma KaRR~- ZQ13. o PiaintifYs expert. in a lawsuit involving a fatal fall in a fraternity house. o SeCtted. Re~r~ Depasitior~. Crabtree v. Tres Settle. et a1.. A~fcLean (KY~ Circuit Caurt. 2Q13 a Plaintiffs experk in sehoc~l negligent injury case. o No report. Na deposition. Settled. • Hof~}~s v. Gonzaga[ xllnv~rsity 201 , Q Defense expert €~n behalf of Gonzaga UniversiEy in the Title iX ma[ter. a Settled: Report Nn depositrnn. • C~p~ic,n t~mitted h~►Con~det~ti I Setti~ment. 24312 o DeFet~se expert an behalf of a private. college in Pennsylvania in a negligence case involving the injury of a student.. 0 5~ttfecl. Report fYo c~e~rositian, • Caption miEted by Court Seel. Z~I2 o Defense expert ors behalf of a private college in Pennsylvania in a wrongful death case. o Settled. Repar~ No deposition. • E N. v. Susquehanna Two. Sch, gist. 2010-11. o Plaintiff's expert in lawsuit suing a Pennsy3~ania school district under Title IX far sexual assault/harassrnenc and retaliation action. o Settled. Report No depo~it~on. • iahn Doe et a! v Sewanee the University of the South a Plaintiffs expert witness `in a student discipline and negligence action in federal court. o Jury verdict for pfarntiff. Report, deposition and j~ery testimony. • .C..h~~ya v Anne Arundel GounCv Bd of Educ. 2021 o Plaintiffs expert in fall From equipment; negEigent supervision lawsuit.

116 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92 Filed 04/24/17 Page 117 of 117 Page ID #:1495

o Settled. Dep~sitian. Na r~pQr~. • ~? tan Campbell' v. Coy Calle~~. 201f3, a pefense expert witness vn behalf cif Cc~~ Caliege in a premises lia~;iit~, negligence action against tl~~ cDllege and the pros dent is his per$onal capacity; ~ Settled. R~por~ no deposition. +~ t~ucein a +~. Ru~h~rE+~rd B~. of ~duc. 2Q11 o Defense expert witness in a K-12 school security and.negt gersc~ action involving k#~e sexual assault of a student; c Settled. Report No depc~sitron. Lana an v. Ch'" Fsi 1n~ 201t ~ Defense expert to Chi Psi Fraternity natidna! and. alumni chapter in a wrongful death., hazing. and alec~h~l action. o Se~tlecf. #teport. ➢epasitiarz. • Iane ~c~~ v. West ~'i~~inia 1t~'e~l~Y~n ~l niv~rs~ty. ZQfl7. c~ Defense exert in a campus security and premises laabilit}T negligence actian for a skudent sexual assault. Q Fettled. No report. No deposit ~~. padivar v~ AEC~M..Inc. 2005 Plaintiff's expert in appeal of a s~uc3ent ciiscipt ne ex~~ls vn and allegation of sexual orientation discrimination. a L't~se disr~tls~ed on pracedural,}rpe~nds. Na rept~rt~ tea depQsrcian. o Candace Mir~ea~ u S g~ta Ka~~a St~rpr~y Jn~ ~iema i~ap~a Sorority Delta U~sila~n Chi~t ~r, Sigm--.--a Ka~~~tat oval Hnusing C:c~r~c~rat can. Inc., 2004. o Plaintiff's expert in a negligence action Far fnJuries resulting from a sarc~rity initiation. o Settled: l?~^persita~n: 11Io report.

117 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92-1 Filed 04/24/17 Page 1 of 2 Page ID #:1496

1 2 3 4 5 6 Attorneys for Defendant PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY 7 8 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 9 CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA, WESTERN DIVISION 10

P HALEY VIDECKIS and LAYANA Case No. 2:15-cv-00298-DDP (JCx)

L 11 4 L 9 WHITE, individuals, S 5 3 0 7 R 2 0 - [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING E 6 12 0 2 3 N 4 2 - Plaintiffs, DEFENDANT'S MOTION IN 6 E 7 N T ) 1 I O 3 0 U 13 LIMINE NO. 14 TO EXCLUDE 1 C 0 S 2 , 9 (

vs. TESTIMONY FROM PLAINTIFF’S &

X A R I S A N

A REBUTTAL EXPERT DR. ELLIOT I N

R 14 F V E R L E Y O • L

R PEPPERDINE UNIVERSITY, a D. FELMAN F I W U A L 0 A O

H corporation doing business in A 8

L 15 B

0 C P E , 0

C California, Date: May 15, 2017 R - S I E 8 H M L

S 8 16 Time: 10:00 a.m. , E L 6 I G N )

N Defendant. Crtrm.: 9C W 3 O A

1 S 7 S

2 17 0 R ( O

7 E

L Trial Date: May 23, 2017 D E T N 18 A 19 20 The Court, having considered Defendants’ Motion in Limine No. 14 to 21 exclude any testimony from Plaintiff’s rebuttal expert Dr. Elliot Felman, and all 22 papers filed in connection therewith; 23 /// 24 /// 25 /// 26 /// 27 /// 28 ///

1610942.1 05764-048 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 14 Case 2:15-cv-00298-DDP-JC Document 92-1 Filed 04/24/17 Page 2 of 2 Page ID #:1497

1 AND GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREFOR, hereby orders that: 2 Defendant’s Motion is hereby granted. No testimony from Plaintiff’s rebuttal 3 expert Dr. Elliot Felman may be presented. 4 . 5 6 DATED: May ___, 2017 7 8 9 Dean D. Pregerson 10 United States District Judge P

L 11 4 L 9 S 5 3 0 7 R 2 0 - E 6 12 0 2 3 N 4 2 -

6 E 7 N T ) 1 I O 3 0 U 13 1 C 0 S 2 , 9 (

X A R I S A N A I N

R 14 F V E R L E Y O • L R F I W U A L 0 A O H A 8

L 15 B

0 C P E , 0 C R - S I E 8 H M L

S 8 16 , E L 6 I G N ) N W 3 O A

1 S 7 S

2 17 0 R ( O

7 E

L L D E T N 18 A 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 1610942.1 05764-048 2 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 7