DOCSLIB.ORG

Landscape Report on Early Grade Literacy

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Landscape Report on Early Grade Literacy Landscape Report on Early Grade Literacy Landscape Report on Early Grade Literacy August 26, 2016 Young-Suk Grace Kim,1 Helen N. Boyle,2 Stephanie Simmons Zuilkowski,2 and Pooja Nakamura3 1 School of Education, University of California at Irvine 2 College of Education and Learning Systems Institute, Florida State University 3 American Institutes for Research Suggested citation: Kim, Y.-S. G., Boyle, H. N., Zuilkowski, S. S., & Nakamura, P. (2016). Landscape Report on Early Grade Literacy. Washington, D.C.: USAID. Disclaimer The views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the United States Agency for International Development. RIGHTS AND PERMISSIONS — This work is available under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 IGO license (CC BY 3.0 IGO) http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo. Under the Creative Commons Attribution license, you are free to copy, distribute, transmit and adapt this work, including for commercial purposes, under the following conditions: Attribution—Please cite the work as follows: LICENSE: Creative Commons Attribution CC BY 3.0 IGO TRANSLATIONS — If you create a translation of this work, please add the following disclaimer along with the attribution: This translation was not created by USAID and should not be considered an official USAID translation. USAID shall not be liable for any content or error in this translation. ADAPTATIONS — If you create an adaptation of this work, please add the following disclaimer along with the attribution: This is an adaptation of an original work by USAID. Views and opinions expressed in the adaptation are the sole responsibility of the author or authors of the adaptation and are not endorsed by USAID. THIRD-PARTY CONTENT — USAID does not necessarily own each component of the content contained within the work. USAID therefore does not warrant that the use of any third party–owned individual component or part contained in the work will not infringe on the rights of those third parties. The risk of claims resulting from such infringement rests solely with you. If you wish to reuse a component of the work, it is your responsibility to determine whether permission is needed for that reuse and to obtain permission from the copyright owner. Examples of components can include, but are not limited to, tables, figures or images. Acknowledgments he authors of this report wish to thank the GRN Communication Coordinator, Newsha N. Learning Systems Institute at Florida State Aboughaddareh, who worked on the graphics for the T University, University Research Co., LLC– report, and Kurt Mulholland, Director of Media at Center for Human Services (URC-CHS), especially URC, for his work in designing the report. Reading within Reach Community of Practice, the “thought leaders” within the international This report was enriched by the careful review and development and early grade reading worlds who feedback offered by our Advisory Board members: consented to be interviewed for this report, the Dr. Daniel Wagner of the University of Pennsylvania, Landscape Report Advisory Board, and USAID. Dr. Catherine Snow of Harvard University, and Ms. Norma A. Evans of Evans and Associates Education The Learning Systems Institute is the leading Consulting. We are grateful for the careful and institution in Florida State University’s work in thorough review of the report in its first and second international education and we are grateful for its draft stages. leadership and contractual management services. We also want to thank Kaitlyn Hicks and Alexandra We also thank the 15 “thought leaders” from various Rosenbaum for their help with identifying and parts of the international development/early grade compiling studies and documents. Gratitude is also reading community for taking the time to participate due to Dr. Marion Fesmire who contributed in the in interviews drawing on knowledge from their initial stage of the work. hands-on experience in the field. These interviews were informative and in several cases led us to URC-CHS has provided invaluable support as the additional reports and literature to examine. contracting organization for this report with strong leadership and unceasing advocacy for this work. Finally, we thank USAID, in particular, Dr. Penelope In particular, we thank Sakil Malik, Community Bender, Dr. Marcia Davidson, and Ms. Rebecca of Practice Director, for his skillful management Rhodes, for their critical and constructive feedback of this award. We are also grateful to Dr. Kim at each stage of the process. Foulds, GRN’s Research Manager, Mary Ciambrone, iii Table of Contents Acknowledgments ............................................................................................................................... iii Executive Summary ........................................................................................................................... 1 Chapter 1. Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 3 Section A. Overview ...................................................................................................................... 3 Section B. Methods and levels of evidence .....................................................................................4 Section C. Situational and constraining factors to keep in mind ......................................................6 Section D. Organization of the report .............................................................................................6 Chapter 2. Key areas to successfully promote improved early grade literacy skills: Overview ................8 Section A. A framework for understanding reading development ......................................................8 Section B. Cross-cutting factors in literacy instruction ....................................................................9 Chapter 3. Key areas to successfully promote improved early grade literacy skills: Content ................. 17 Section A. Emergent literacy skills: Foundations for word reading and spelling ................................ 17 Section B. Oral language skills: Foundations for reading comprehension ......................................... 25 Section C. Reading fluency: Foundation for reading comprehension ................................................ 30 Section D. Reading comprehension ................................................................................................33 Section E. Writing for meaning .................................................................................................... 37 Chapter 4. Key factors and actors responsible for improving early grade literacy skills in developing country contexts ........................................................................................................ 43 Section A. Promoting literacy in multilingual environments .......................................................... 43 Section B. Teacher knowledge and teacher education ..................................................................... 49 Section C. Parental and community engagement ........................................................................... 57 Chapter 5. Long-run considerations of literacy programs: Costs, financing, scaling up, and sustainability............................................................................................................................ 59 Chapter 6. Conclusion .......................................................................................................................61 References ...................................................................................................................................... 64 v vi Executive Summary he goal of this landscape report is to review “Once you learn to read, you and summarize available empirical evidence Ton early grade literacy acquisition and will be forever free.” instruction in developing countries. To achieve this goal, papers with empirical data were searched, — Frederick Douglass identified, screened, and reviewed on topics that promote the higher-order, long-term goals of literacy included student-level factors (e.g., emergent literacy, acquisition and instruction—reading comprehension oral language), larger contextual factors within and writing (written composition). which the student is embedded (e.g., home literacy environment, language of instruction, and larger Some directions for the future include a focus on system issues such as teacher education), and long- long-term perspectives and efforts. Although the run considerations (e.g., sustainability, costs, and need to improve students' literacy skills is dire scaling up). The available empirical evidence was, and immediate, changing behavior (e.g., teachers’ then, rated by topic as strong, moderate, emerging instructional practices; student’s learning) takes or limited. The vast majority of studies reviewed a long time (Cochran-Smith & Zeichner, 2005) and were project-based work with a comprehensive, therefore, requires sustained efforts. Furthermore, multicomponent approach, incorporating the 5Ts— reading comprehension and writing are high-order teaching, time, texts, tongue, and test. The Big 5 skills identified in the National Reading Panel Table 1. Levels of evidence for the various areas Report (National Institute of Child Health and reviewed in the this report Human Development [NICHD], 2000)—phonological awareness, phonics, reading fluency, vocabulary, Topic
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Family Literacy Practices: Traditions and Transitions
    27 Family Literacy Practices: Traditions and Transitions Althea Duren Florida Memorial University, USA Cynthia Januszka Florida International University, USA Abstract: Family literacy practices are discussed from a historical perspective, highlighting the similarities and differences from ancient to modern times. The content of a family literacy workshop is discussed and scripted lessons for parents are presented. From ancient times to the present, literacy has taken on different forms, beginning with functional literacy requiring a minimum knowledge of reading and writing (e.g., reading signs, writing letters) to academic literacy, which is usually learned in a school environment. The teaching of literacy was initially a household responsibility, but with the passage of time, it has become a school responsibility. Yet, for some minority students in particular, these school experiences have not yielded sufficient literacy development (Delpit, 2003). Literacy tools that can be used in the home may be useful in alleviating this problem. In a study discussed in this article that investigated parents’ perceptions of home literacy, a checklist of specific book- sharing behaviors was used as a parental tool during times they read to their children. The examples of scripted lessons included are additional tools that will be used in future research, as a guide for parents to engage their children in best reading practice techniques related to phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary, fluency, and comprehension. The purpose of this article is to discuss family literacy practices and propose some that can be useful in today’s society. First, a discussion of the ancient and early American literacy traditions is presented. Then a discussion of the contemporary family literacy movement follows.
    [Show full text]
  • Family-School Partnerships: Essential Elements of Literacy Instruction In
    parents home children Adopted by the Board of Directors, family literacy support Related Resources From January 2002 the International Reading Association Board of Directors at Time of Adoption Family-School Books Families at School: A Guide for Educators, by Adele Thomas, Donna M. Ogle, President Partnerships: Lynn Fazio, & Betty L. Stiefelmeyer (1999) Jerry L. Johns, President-Elect Families at School: A Handbook for Parents, by Adele Lesley Mandel Morrow, Vice President Essential Elements Thomas, Lynn Fazio, & Betty L. Stiefelmeyer (1999) Alan E. Farstrup, Executive Director of Literacy Instruction Family Literacy Connections in Schools and Communities, edited by Lesley Mandel Morrow (1995) Gregg M. Kurek in the United States What Should We Expect of Family Literacy? Experiences of Jeanne R. Paratore home Latino Children Whose Parents Participate in an Lori L. Rog Intergenerational Literacy Project, by Jeanne R. Paratore, Carol Minnick Santa Gigliana Melzi, & Barbara Krol-Sinclair (1999) Rebecca L. Olness Doris Walker-Dalhouse training Brochures Patricia L. Anders Timothy V. Rasinski Family Literacy and the School Community: A Partnership for Lifelong Learning Ann-Sofie Selin What Is Family Literacy? Getting Involved in Your Child’s teachers Literacy Learning This brochure may be purchased from the International Reading Association in bulk quantities, Articles prepaid only. (Please contact the Association for pricing support Cairney, T.H. (1995). Developing parent partnerships in information.) Single copies are free upon request by secondary literacy learning. Journal of Reading, 38, sending a self-addressed, stamped envelope. Requests 520–526. from outside the U.S. should include an envelope, but Flood, J., Lapp, D., Tinajero, J.V., & Nagel, G.
    [Show full text]
  • Full-Day Kindergarten: a Missing Link in the Prekindergarten Through Third Grade (P-3) Continuum for Many Students
    BACKGROUNDER: Full-day Kindergarten: A Missing Link in the Prekindergarten through Third Grade (P-3) Continuum for Many Students ull-day kindergarten provides an essential bridge Too Few States Require Districts to Offer Fbetween prekindergarten (preK) and the primary Full-day Kindergarten grades. In kindergarten classrooms, students develop the academic, social, and emotional skills they need to ``Currently, only 11 states and the District of be successful later in school. These benefits seem to be Columbia require districts to offer at least five hours greater for children from disadvantaged backgrounds. of kindergarten per day.1 However, far too many children have no access to full- ``Forty-five states require that school districts provide day kindergarten, and not enough has been done in the at least half-day kindergarten. last decade to provide more children with access to this `` critical link between early childhood and K-12 education. There are five states that do not require districts to offer any type of kindergarten program, although many school districts offer half-day kindergarten Why is Full-day Kindergarten Important? at a minimum. ``Thirty-five states do not require children to attend In recent years, state and federal initiatives have greatly kindergarten. expanded access to prekindergarten programs for three- and four-year-old children. This expansion provides many more children with access to high-quality, full-day, The Amount of Instructional Time Students and often, full-year preK programs. Unfortunately, too Receive in Full-day Kindergarten Matters many children will follow full-day preK with half-day kindergarten which may jeopardize the important As in all grades, the amounts of instructional time academic and social gains made in preK.
    [Show full text]
  • Initiatives from Preschool to Third Grade a POLICYMAKER's GUIDE
    FEB 2018 Initiatives From Preschool to Third Grade A POLICYMAKER'S GUIDE BRUCE ATCHISON LOUISA DIFFEY SPECIAL REPORT www.ecs.org | @EdCommission 2 he period between preschool and third grade is a tipping point in a Tchild’s journey toward lifelong learning — from “learning to read” Of the 2.5 million to “reading to learn.”1 If children do not have proficient reading skills by third grade, their ability to progress through school and meet grade-level students who dropped expectations diminishes significantly. While all areas of children’s learning and development are critical for school success, the predictive power of out of high school last a child’s third-grade reading proficiency on high school graduation and year, about 1.6 million dropout rates is startling.2 Consider: were firmly set on that J Children who are not reading proficiently by third grade are four times less likely to graduate from high school on time. trajectory when they were 8 years old. J If they live in poverty, they are 13 times less likely to graduate on time. J In 2016, they comprised more than half of all students (63 percent) who did not graduate on time. Pair that with the knowledge that about 30 percent of all fourth-graders and 50 percent of African-American and Hispanic fourth-graders nationwide are In 2016-17, 30 states reading below grade-level. Over half are likely to drop out or will not graduate on time. increased funding for If policymakers are to make a significant impact on the readiness of our pre-K, demonstrating nation’s future workforce, interventions and strategies to address gaps in overall support for learning must begin much earlier than third grade.
    [Show full text]
  • Stats in Brief: Instructional Time for Third- and Eighth-Graders in Public and Private Schools
    The amount of time students spend in learning environments, as well STATS IN BRIEF as the amount of time that students U.S. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION FEBRUARY 2017 NCES 2017–076 are exposed to instruction in particular subjects, have been topics of debate and concern in education policy and practitioner circles (McMurrer 2008; Instructional Time National Academy of Education 2009). Indeed, an early but foundational review of literature on instructional time highlighted for Third- and its importance for student learning (Berliner 1990). Differences in the use of time, however, make instructional time Eighth-Graders difficult to study. For instance, allocated time—or the time that schools or teachers schedule for instruction in particular in Public and subjects—is distinct from the time that students spend actively engaged with and learning from instructional materials Private Schools: (Berliner 1990). Despite the difficulties in studying instructional time in its varied forms, researchers have agreed that it is School Year 2011–12 important to study the amount of time that students in different grades have been AUTHORS PROJECT OFFICER exposed to particular subjects (Coates Kathleen Mulvaney Hoyer John Ralph Dinah Sparks National Center for Education Statistics 2003; Lanahan, Princiotta, and Enyeart Activate Research, Inc. 2006; Long 2014; Morton and Dalton 2007; Perie, Baker, and Bobbitt 1997). Statistics in Brief publications present descriptive data in tabular formats to provide useful information to a broad audience, including members of the general public. They address topical issues and questions. They do not investigate more complex hypotheses, account for inter-relationships among variables, or support causal inferences. We This publication was prepared for NCES encourage readers who are interested in more complex questions and in- under Contract No.
    [Show full text]
  • Seven Research-Based Ways That Families Promote Early Literacy
    Seven Research-Based Ways That Families Promote Early Literacy Margaret Caspe and M. Elena Lopez | September 2017 RESEARCH-TO-PRACTICE BRIEFS Global Family Research Project introduces a series of occasional research-to-practice reviews laying out high-leverage areas for family engagement. High- leverage areas are those processes and practices that have the greatest effect on student learning and development. They could be processes such as the transition to school, and practices such as engaging families in early math and early literacy. Family engagement is key in building strong pathways that lead to children’s healthy development, school readiness, graduation, and subsequent success. Our reviews and related blogs include examples of research and practice and ways organizations are building family engagement in high-leverage areas, as well as links to additional resources. This research-to- practice brief focuses on early literacy. 1 The notion that families play a critical role in promoting children’s literacy development is undisputed. Literacy, or the ability to read and write, is composed of a variety of skills that range from letter recognition and phonemic awareness, to oral language, vocabulary, story comprehension, and motivation. These skills begin developing at birth, and a substantial and solid research base confirms that families play an important role in promoting them.1 Positive early-literacy experiences—whether at home, in early-childhood programs, schools, or libraries—set children on a trajectory to become confident readers by the time they reach third grade, which is an important milestone on the pathway toward high school graduation. This review outlines seven practices that research shows families use to effectively promote early literacy.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    Introduction The 2017 Computer Science Standards of Learning for Virginia Public Schools identify academic content for essential components of the computer science curriculum at different grade levels. Information from Computer Science Teachers Association, K-12 Computer Science Framework, College Board Advanced Placement Computer Science courses, Exploring Computer Science, were considered in identifying computer science content necessary for success for all students in postsecondary pursuits. Standards are identified for kindergarten through grade eight, with an optional selection of electives modules at the middle school level, and a sequence of high school courses. The standards are organized into the following content strands: Computing Systems, Networks and the Internet, Cybersecurity, Data and Analysis, Algorithms and Programming, and Impacts of Computing. The Standards of Learning within each strand progress in complexity throughout the grade levels and into high school course content. While the standards are organized by strand and identified numerically, local curricula and pacing guides should determine the instructional sequence of the content. The K - 8 standards were designed to be integrated into instruction in multiple subject areas including mathematics, science, history, English, fine arts, and career and technology courses. The middle school and high school electives are separate courses and modules, but where appropriate, connections are made to content in other disciplines. The high school standards are designed to provide flexibility in application of core ideas to various contexts. The core practices of computer science, including collaboration, communication, and fostering an inclusive culture, describe the behaviors and ways of thinking that computationally literate students use to fully engage in today’s data-rich and interconnected world.
    [Show full text]
  • Family Literacy for Languag
    FAMILY LITERACY FOR LANGUAGE MINORITY FAMILIES: 1 NCBE Program Information Guide Series, Number 17, Summer 1994 Margaret Mulhern, Flora V. Rodriguez-Brown, Timothy Shanahan INTRODUCTION: THE ROLE OF THE FAMILY IN CHILDREN'S LEARNING Faced with the challenge of educating an increasingly diverse student population, educators are looking beyond the school walls toward families and communities as resources for fostering academic success for all. Although families have always played an important role in promoting the academic success of their children (Swap 1993), changing demographics have forced schools to rethink the ways in which they reach out to families. Parents play many roles in their children's education. They provide for their children's physical and emotional needs and assure their attendance at school. Through communication with the school, they act as liaisons for their children as they cross home-school boundaries. They provide materials and space for their children's homework and model the use of literacy and other knowledge. Parents also play the role of teacher, either directly (by teaching their children to count or write their names, for example) or indirectly (such as by reading and talking to their children). They also play important roles within the school as volunteers or by participating in school governance activities . Several factors can disrupt or prevent parents from assuming these roles. According to Swap (1993), barriers to involvement include difficult family circumstances, school norms that do not support partnerships, limited resources, and the lack of information on establishing successful home-school relations. Family literacy programs have great potential for overcoming these barriers, particularly for families who are not currently well served in America's schools.
    [Show full text]
  • Host Or Sponsor a Family Literacy Celebration in Your Community
    HOST OR SPONSOR A FAMILY LITERACY CELEBRATION IN YOUR COMMUNITY Did you know? Early language and literacy development is a critical school-readiness factor. What is a family literacy celebration? Families play a critical role in promoting children’s literacy development: Family literacy celebrations (literacy fairs, family literacy nights, etc.) are events for families and children to participate in fun early literacy activities together. Caregivers learn fun ways to promote literacy and learning and babies, toddlers and preschoolers get to learn through play. Family literacy events feature hands-on learning stations, information from early learning experts, make-and- take activities and access to books and other resources to support learning at home. They can be hosted at schools, libraries or other places where community members gather. How do literacy events support literacy? Literacy events help caregivers build the knowledge, confidence and skills they need to promote literacy development in young children by modeling behaviors and sharing activities and ideas that they can replicate at home. By showing parents and caregivers how to model reading and early literacy-building skills and sharing activities they can replicate at home, these events help make reading enjoyable for the whole family and foster a passion and love for reading that can last a lifetime. Steps to planning your literacy event: Set the date, location and theme. Be creative and look for books that align with the chosen theme. Get suggestions or input from your local children’s librarian. Partner with a local agency that serves young children and families. You may also want to consider inviting local kindergarten teachers who can share information about what students should know and be able to do once they start kindergarten.
    [Show full text]
  • Supporting English and Spanish Literacy Through a Family Literacy Program Stephanie Wessels University of Nebraska-Lincoln, [email protected]
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Faculty Publications: Department of Teaching, Department of Teaching, Learning and Teacher Learning and Teacher Education Education 2014 Supporting English and Spanish Literacy Through a Family Literacy Program Stephanie Wessels University of Nebraska-Lincoln, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/teachlearnfacpub Wessels, Stephanie, "Supporting English and Spanish Literacy Through a Family Literacy Program" (2014). Faculty Publications: Department of Teaching, Learning and Teacher Education. 184. http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/teachlearnfacpub/184 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of Teaching, Learning and Teacher Education at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Publications: Department of Teaching, Learning and Teacher Education by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. Supporting English and Spanish Literacy Through a Family Literacy Program Stephanie Wessels Abstract Family literacy studies have shown that the role of parental storybook read- ing has an impact on children’s success in school-based literacy instruction. However, many children who are English language learners come from homes or cultures where storybook readings are not common practice. The purpose of this qualitative research study explored the effects of an eight-week bilingual family literacy program for Latino, English learning families. Triangulation was assured through multiple sources of data: semistructured interviews conduct- ed with participating parents; parent evaluation surveys; and researcher field notes. During the implementation of the bilingual family literacy program and the analysis of the data, three themes emerged: maintaining the first language, practicing what I have been taught, and the importance of time.
    [Show full text]
  • Complete Third-Grade Curriculum
    A Look at… Third Grade in California Public Schools and the Common Core State Standards CURRICULUM FRAMEWORKS AND INSTRUCTIONAL RESOURCES DIVISION INSTRUCTION AND LEARNING SUPPORT BRANCH CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION October 2011 Edition Contents Page Third-Grade Curriculum .................................................................................................................................. 3.1 English Language Arts ...................................................................................................................................... 3.2 Overview .......................................................................................................................................................... 3.2 What Third-Grade Students Should Know ...................................................................................................... 3.2 What Students Learn in Third Grade ............................................................................................................... 3.3 Reading ........................................................................................................................................................ 3.3 Writing ......................................................................................................................................................... 3.5 Speaking and Listening ................................................................................................................................ 3.5 Language .....................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Mrs. Paulson's Class Syllabus Third Grade
    Mrs. Paulson’s Class Syllabus Third Grade Mountainside Elementary School Class Time: 7:30 – 2:25 Location: Room #201 Classroom Teacher: Mrs. K. Paulson Email: [email protected] Location: Room # 201 Phone: 719-382-1430 Afterschool hours: 2:30- 3:10 (Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday). What can you expect from your third grader? We here at Mountainside knows that a quality that tends to show up in a third grader is positive energy. Most third graders are usually always willing to try something new, and they are truly excited about the idea of learning new things. Interestingly enough this same never ending energy is also a third graders biggest challenge. They often love new ideas and projects but they don’t have the attention span to complete the project or often loose interests or become overwhelmed by the project. Although this is often the case, you must remember that every student is unique and all develop at their own pace. A Third Graders Typical Characteristics: Socially you can expect your third grader to enjoy making friends and doing group projects. They are often concerned with fairness and justice. Physically you may notice that your third grader has a lot of energy, play hard and tire out quickly and often seem in a hurry. Academically your third grader may become captivated by an activity or topic. They enjoy using hands on activities to learn new concepts or explain their ideas. The will often ask a lot of questions focusing on the process and the product, and they are often enthusiastic for peer or adult approval.
    [Show full text]