Liberty Magazine November 1990
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
November 1990 Vol 4, No 2 ''rJ1te, fiistory of Li6erty is tlie fiistory of{imitations ofgovernment power. 11 - Woodrow Wi[son of one his experiments, possibly the same one Hospers describes so glowing- ly, indicates that he altered his target [ L etters ] numbers after he got a look at the guess- ~==============================~ es of his "psychic" subjects, to produce as many matches as he desired. Specifi- Job's Jobs commercial speech, nor are so-called cally, he changed the numeral 1, which It seems to me, a Christian, that liber "fighting words." These last are words he wrote with a short stroke, into a 4 or tarians and classical liberals could take a which according to the court are "likely 5, as needed. different view ofJob than the angry cyni to provoke the average person to retalia Taras Wolansky cism of David Starkey's poem ("The Sub tion." This might include racial, ethnic or Jersey City, N.J. mission ofJob," September 1990). Job religious slurs and perhaps just calling Final Determinations ended up doubling his wealth (Job 42: someone an S.O.B. Ifin fact Gregory Hospers was very sloppy in his dis 12, 1: 2-3), surely a respectable reward Johnson's flag burning was "speech," it cussion of determinism; if determinism for his suffering. Job was a political lead was certainly "fighting words"-ifthe is true, then doing something because er (1: 3, 29: 7-25), but he probably spent outrage of vast numbers of Americans is one wants to (i.e. one wills it) is impossi as much time running his ranch as run any indication. Indeed, the whole pur ble because antecedent causes have pre ning his country (judging by his ranch pose of the burning was to outrage, to determined what one "wants" (which in ing success); ruling wasn't a full-time job provoke, otherwise why bother? As cludes not only the choices available but even for 1:3's "greatest man ... of the fighting words, this "speech" is not pro also what one will choose). The falseness East" (New International Version). No tected. Simple, huh? of determinism can be revealed when welfare program tried to help him in his Or, try this. The burning of the sym one realizes that one can truly change distress, and no regulations kept him bol ofThe United States of America is one's mind, in spite of powerful existen from regaining prosperity (with Yah obviously the symbolic means of calling tial factors; it is easy to ignore that "val weh's blessing) after his family and for the violent overthrow of the govern ues" can only have meaning to beings friends got him venture capital (42:11). ment thereof. This adheres to our ene who can freely choose them. (I find it What libertarian wouldn't prefer Uz to mies (who also burn American flags), hard tobelieve that it took Ayn Rand so the U.S.? giving them aid and comfort. In short, long to change her mind about Mr. Hos The Job ofStarkey's poem reminds this is an act of treason as recognized by pers and his "Green Party" intuitions.) me ofVan Til's little girl who must sit on Article III, section 3 of the Constitution Alexander N. Knight the Father's lap in order to slap His face. and is clearly not constitutionally pro Rochester, N.Y. Complaints about justice presuppose the tected. Rand Derailed Freedom's Train On the bright side, it is comforting to universal and just God of the Bible; a John Hospers didn't mention it in his know that ifI were to "moon" the Hon lesser deity or none at all reduces com last article about his relationship with plaints to personal pique, and no binding orable Justices as a demonstration of my Ayn Rand, butyears after their last meet standard makes one person's pique bind political displeasure with their decisions, ing when he was running for president ing on another. Tactical prudence might they'd understand and even support my in 1972 as the candidate of the newly elicit compliance, but what god (and I right to do so. formed Libertarian Party, Rand was too am on my Father's lap) would be Warren Michelsen asked at a Ford Hall Forum what she pleased with submission asStarkey'sJob Page, Ariz. thought about Hospers's candidacy. Her offered? Better submit to the Bible's God Randiana qua Libertariana reply was something to the effect that in His way. Maybe Starkey could write Hospers's article on Rand ("Conver Hospers was nothing but a publicity eloquent poetry about submission to Sta sations with Ayn Rand," July 1990) was seeking crank, and that the best candi lin or Social Security, or even (with a dif the best piece of Randiana I've read and date to vote for was Richard M. Nixon, ferent tone) to Yahweh. the best thing I've seen in Liberty. Every for to do otherwise would be to risk Andrew Lohr sentence had the ring of truth, and he sending our nation down the track Lookout Mountain, Ga. was careful to stop where his memory aboard George McGovern's hell-bound stopped. train. Oh Say Can't You See? Like many libertarians, I had been Chester Alan Arthur asserts that the Thomas Porter Reseda, Calif. greatly influenced and inspired by Supreme Court"can't figure a way to Rand's books and articles, but 1also had make flag burning exempt from the very Dotting the I's, Crossing the T's, grown increasingly uneasy with Rand's plain meaning of the First Amendment" Changing the Numbers public inconsistencies-such as when ("Lip-reading," September 1990). Allow John Hospers' approach to philoso she said anti-Vietnam War draft resistors me to offer two. For purposes of this ex phy may be superior to Rand's ("Con should be shipped off to Russia-so her ercise I'll even stipulate that flag burning versations with Ayn Rand [part 2]," Sep flippant rejection of the Libertarian Party is "speech," OK? tember 1990), bUtabout parapsychology was the last straw for me. I also wasn't Not all speech is protected by the she was right and he was wrong. much impressed with her shabby treat First Amendment. There is considerable We now know that S. G. Soal, co ment of Hospers, whom I had met at the (U.S. Supreme Court) precedence hold author of Experiments in Parapsychology, Libertarian Party's founding convention ing that obsce~ty is not protected. Nor is was a fraud. Careful statistical analysis continued on page 4 2 Liberty ed Leb . November 1990 lnSI e 1 erty Volume 4,Number2 2 Letters on Job, John Hospers, Ayn Rand, Ron Paul, and other people. 7 Reflections on things not being what they seem-in particular, Pravda, patriotic thieves, Caucasian Eurasians, friendly ferrets, and (of course) "free market" Republicans. Features 15 Opportunities on Freedom's Frontier Ronald Lipp explores the realities of Eastern Europe and its prospects for liberty. 21 The Search for Home of Truth R. W. Bradford visits the ruins of two failed utopias, one of which died a natural death, and the other of which was murdered. 29 You. Too, Can Be a Junior G-Man David Hudson explains how the War on Drugs has led to the conscription of ordinary people. 33 Smokes. But No Peace Pipe Scott Reid explains how the black market in cigarettes on Canada's Indian reservations has led to a new French and Indian War. 37 Meanwhile. Back at the Farm Leslie Fleming, a farmer from Oklahoma, tells the tale of how the State bought off the farmers. They weren't cheap, but they were easy. 41 How to Profit In an Unfree World Douglas Casey, R. W. Bradford, Richard Stroup and David Friedman tell us how to invest-and how to think about investment advice. 48 Why is Anyone Virtuous? David Friedman gives a positive explanation of why so many people behave morally, even when it would seem to be in their interest to lie, cheat, and steal. 51 Death In the Sands Sheldon Richman kicks sand into the bullies' faces; Stephen Cox, Robert Higgs, and Leland Yeager stir up a little action of their own. 54 Ed Crane An interview with the controversial libertarian activist who brought competence as well as vision to a movement sorely lacking in the former, if not the latter. Reviews 65 Up from Armageddonism Stephen Cox makes the case for optimism by making fun of the pessimists. 68 Sex. Drugs and the Goldberg Variations Richard Kostelanetz explains what went wrong with a biography of Glenn Gould, the late master of the keyboard. 70 The Microcosmic Mind of George Glider Alexander Tabarrok reconsiders George Gilder's obsession with quantum physics, microchips, and God. 73 Rational Man and All the Rest Robert Higgs says eminently reasonable things about irrationality. .75 Classified Ads 77 Notes on Contributors 78 Terra Incognita Volume 4, Number 2 Letters (continued from page 2) in Denver, and whom I considered a cou rageous, generous man for offering to carry the party's banner its first time out. Mark Coleman Honolulu, Hawaii Stimulate Up the Hatch There is a world of good reading in Liberty ... and there has been Everything Brian Doherty wrote in ever since Liberty began publishing! Whether you want to catch up on what "Down the hatch" (September 1990) is you missed, stimulate your mind, or complete your collection, now is a wrong. The attempt to reform the Hatch good time to buy. Enjoy! Act has nothing to do with on-duty polit ical activity.