Geotextile Wrap-Face Wall Using Marginal Backfill
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
GEOTEXTILE WRAP-FACE WALL USING MARGINAL BACKFILL ________________________________________________________________________ A Thesis Presented to The Faculty of the Graduate School University of Missouri-Columbia ________________________________________________________________________ In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Science Civil and Environmental Engineering ________________________________________________________________________ by BRANDON R. PARRISH Dr. John J. Bowders, Jr., Thesis Supervisor DECEMBER 2006 The undersigned, appointed by the Dean of the Graduate School, have examined the thesis entitled GEOTEXTILE WRAP-FACE WALL USING MARGINAL BACKFILL Presented by Brandon R. Parrish A candidate for the degree of Masters of Science in Civil & Environmental Engineering and hereby certify that in their opinion it is worthy of acceptance. __________________________________________ John J. Bowders, PhD, PE Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering __________________________________________ J. Erik Loehr, PhD, PE Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering _________________________________________ Allen Thompson, PhD Department of Biological Engineering ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to think my family and friends for their support and encouragement throughout my life and education. I want to especially thank my parents, Brad and Cora Parrish, for making my education possible. I want to thank Erin Sutton for her patience and support throughout the duration of this project. A special thanks to Dr. John Bowders for his guidance and expertise in the completion of this thesis. I also want to thank the University of Missouri-Columbia faculty for their guidance throughout my graduate education. Completion of this project could not have been possible if it were not for help from fellow students and others associated with project, and I would like to recognize them at this time: Andy Carrigan, Missouri Petroleum; William Hawkins, BBA Nonwovens; Dhani Narejo, GSE; Jeff Bertell, Paul Koenig, Dr. Allen Thompson, Andy Boeckmann, Jianhua Li, Peng Li, Nathan Textor, University of Missouri; Neal Kaplan, North Carolina; Young Kim, Korea; Brad Parrish, Palmerton and Parrish; and Erin Sutton, Missouri State University. ii ABSTRACT A concrete retaining wall was constructed during October/November 2005. The height of the wall was 9 feet with a stem width of 0.83 ft, while the width of the base was 1.83 ft. The backfill was a low plasticity clay (CL). As a result of this design, the wall was not able to withstand the lateral pressures from the backfill and noticeable cracks in the wall developed within one month after backfilling. The backfill soil was then removed to relieve pressures on the wall until a remediation scheme could be developed and implemented. A geotextile wrap-face wall was chosen to reinforce the soil mass behind the existing concrete wall, which now acts as a facade. The geotextile wrap-face wall was designed with a high strength woven geotextile with seven layers of reinforcement. The in-situ soil (CL), a marginally suitable material, was used for the backfill. Extensive drainage was incorporated in the design and construction of the geotextile wrap-face wall to decrease backfill pore pressures. A gap between the face of the geotextile wall and the back of the concrete wall allows for deformation of the wrap- face wall without contacting the concrete wall. Index and compaction tests were performed on the backfill soil and interface shear tests were conducted with the geotextile and soil to provide design parameters. The geotextile wrap-face wall was constructed in July 2006, and the performance was monitored. During the monitoring period, four months post construction, no significant lateral, nor vertical movements have occurred, and the drainage system experienced significant flows. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements..............................................................................................................ii Abstract...............................................................................................................................iii Table of Contents................................................................................................................iv List of Tables....................................................................................................................viii List of Figures......................................................................................................................x 1. Introduction..............................................................................................................1 1.1 Overview/Background.................................................................................1 1.2 Study Project................................................................................................4 1.3 Objective......................................................................................................5 1.4 Scope............................................................................................................5 1.5 Thesis Layout...............................................................................................5 2. Literature Review.....................................................................................................7 2.1 Introduction..................................................................................................7 2.2 Christopher and Stulgis, 2006......................................................................7 2.3 Sandri, 2006.................................................................................................9 2.4 Lawson, 2006.............................................................................................10 2.5 Hatami and Bathhurst, 2006......................................................................10 2.6 Koerner et al., 2006....................................................................................11 2.7 Stulgis, 2006 & Geosynthetics June/July, 2006.........................................11 2.8 Summary of Literature Review..................................................................12 3. Description of Existing Wall and Site Details.......................................................14 3.1 Introduction................................................................................................14 iv 3.2 Issues of Concern for Existing Wall..........................................................20 3.3 Summary of Existing Concrete Wall.........................................................24 4. Geotextile Wrap-face Wall Design and Design Parameters..................................25 4.1 Introduction................................................................................................25 4.2 Backfill Soil Laboratory Testing and Results............................................28 4.3 Geotextile/Clay Interface Testing Results.................................................31 4.4 External Stability of Wrap-face Wall Design............................................45 4.4a Backfill Soil Compaction...............................................................51 4.5 External Stability of Wrap-Face Wall Design...........................................51 4.6 Assumptions Used in Wrap-face Wall Design..........................................54 4.7 Summary of Geotextile Wrap-face Wall and Design Parameters.............57 5. Geotextile Wrap-face Wall Construction Issues....................................................60 5.1 Introduction................................................................................................60 5.2 Construction Issues....................................................................................60 5.3 Temporary Fascia Support.........................................................................60 5.4 Backfill Compaction..................................................................................64 5.5 Drainage.....................................................................................................68 5.6 Geotextile Overlaps...................................................................................70 5.7 Void Between Back of Concrete Wall and Wrap-Face Wall....................72 5.8 Summary of Construction Issues...............................................................73 6. Documentation of the Field Construction of the Geotextile Wall.........................75 6.1 Introduction................................................................................................75 6.2 Photo Documentary of Field Construction................................................76 v 6.3 Actual Field Construction vs. Design Specifications.............................................................................................96 6.3a Change in Stability Resulting from As-Built Conditions..............99 6.3b External Stability of Concrete Wall with Geotextile Wall Contact.....................................................................................................102 6.4 Summary of Geotextile Wrap-Face Wall Field Construction................. 105 7. Field Performance Monitoring System................................................................106 7.1 Introduction..............................................................................................106 7.2 Concrete Wall Crack Monitoring.............................................................106 7.3 Concrete