43 I AM AN OMNIVOROUS READER

Book reviews by DAVID JONES, NICHOLAS UTECHIN and ROGER JOHNSON

Y Cylch Brith - Stori gyntaf Sherlock Holmes yn y is a slight feeling of padding with the BFI’s Nathalie Gymraeg 7KH6SHFNOHG%DQGWKH¿UVW6KHUORFN 0RUULVZULWLQJXS+ROPHV¶VVLOHQW¿OPKLVWRU\ LWZDV Holmes story published in Welsh) by Sir Arthur bad luck that the book was at the binders when the Conan Doyle, translated by Eurwyn Pierce Jones. Y great Gillette discovery was made public!) /ROID . 2014. 60pp. £3.95. (pbk) In production terms, there are some annoying At last a story of the Great Detective has been errors that should have been picked up at the proof- translated into Welsh! All Welsh people speak reading stage; but these are balanced by some lovely English, of course, but the Welsh language is thriving picture reproductions (especially the atmospheric and is spoken by approximately half a million people London photogravures made by Alvin Langdon in Wales and many more throughout the world. The Coburn early last century). selection of this story, Conan Doyle’s favourite, to This is a solid and welcome addition to any EH WKH ¿UVW WUDQVODWHG ZDV PDGH E\ WKH ([HFXWLYH Holmesian library — but I am glad to hear that the Committee of The Deerstalkers of Welshpool, whose Museum may be reconsidering its original decision Chairman, Roy Upton-Holder, and President, Roger not to publish a catalogue of some of the remarkable Llewellyn, must be delighted with its publication by items brought together in the exhibition. Y Lolfa Press of Talybont, Aberystwyth. NU The translation is a triumph. Eurwyn Pierce Jones has produced a readable and exciting modern In The Company of Sherlock Holmes – Stories version of the Victorian-styled English narrative — Inspired by the Holmes Canon edited by Laurie R a daunting challenge! This translation is, I believe, King and Leslie S. Klinger. 3HJDVXV%RRNV . 2014. xii the hundredth language in which one or more of the + 260pp. From £9.81 (hbk) Sherlock Holmes stories are now available. The book Yes, this is WKDW book! The collection of Holmes- will appeal greatly to the young and not so young inspired stories (note: not pastiches) over which the reader and to the serious Holmesian collector and, big court case was fought between Les Klinger and of course, to those students of linguistics who may the Conan Doyle Estate as to whether a fee should be be thinking of studying the oldest living language in paid to the latter. Europe. <JHPV\GGDUGUDHG (The game is afoot!) It is excellent to see a second outing of tales by DJ famous authors — straightaway the names of Sara Sherlock Holmes - The Man Who Never Lived Paretsky, Jeffrey Deaver and Michael Dirda should be and Will Never Die compiled by Alex Werner. (EXU\ recognised. This volume is a follow-up to $6WXG\LQ 3XEOLVKLQJ . 2014. 256pp. £25.00 (hbk) 6KHUORFN and is just as intriguing: in a world replete The title is that of the Museum of London’s with second-rate pastiches that may need listing but Holmes exhibition — Werner is its curator. This often not reviewing, this is a welcome selection of is emphatically not a catalogue of the show but a tales, created — as the editors write — by “men and publication to accompany and publicise it. ZRPHQ >ZKR@ VWLOO ¿QG +ROPHV WKH LGHDO YHVVHO WR The central essay by the eminent historian Sir FDUU\DYDULHW\RIVWRULHVDVSLUDWLRQVUHÀHFWLRQV´ David Cannadine concentrates on the “limitations There are some curios: an uninspiring strip cartoon of Conan Doyle’s mode of metropolitan evocation” adventure by Leah Moore and John Rippon, and 25 and, fascinatingly, the contradiction between Holmes pages that could have been put to more interesting use the superman and Holmes the “ ¿QGHVLqFOH aesthete than updating 7KH+RXQGRIWKH%DVNHUYLOOHV for the and decadent”. Professor John Stokes picks up on the modern social networking scene (by Andrew Grant). Bohemian side and Pat Hardy (Curator of Paintings, To counterbalance: Michael Sims intrigues with his Prints and Drawings at the Museum) contributes an take on the personal memoirs of … Silver Blaze; interesting essay on “The Art of Sherlock Holmes”, and Jeffrey Deaver pulls off so sudden a shift in with an emphasis on illustrations of London. plot and emphasis (“The Adventure of the Laughing +ROPHVLDQVZLOO¿QGOLWWOHWKH\GLGQ¶WDOUHDG\NQRZ Fisherman”) that you’ll scarce believe it’s happened. DERXW 6LGQH\ 3DJHW¶V LQÀXHQFH RQ WKH LFRQRJUDSK\ NU of Holmes in an article by Werner himself; and there 44

How Watson Learned the Trick by Sir Arthur Conan memories, Baltimore area Sherlockians established Doyle. :DONHU%RRNV 5R\DO&ROOHFWLRQ7UXVW . 2014. a :HHNHQG:LWK 6KHUORFN +ROPHV in 1980. The Six 24pp (hbk) Napoleons and the Carlton Club still team up with the $UWKXU&RQDQ'R\OHZDVZKHQKHFKRVHD¿UVW Enoch Pratt Library to present an annual symposium, rate comic writer. In 1896, to help raise funds for and Bill Hyder has selected papers from the remarkable Edinburgh University, he wrote “The Field Bazaar”, variety of canonical scholarship presented at what a clever spoof of his own stories, and in 1922 he has long been 6DWXUGD\ :LWK 6KHUORFN +ROPHV . It’s was one of the authors invited to contribute to the a splendid collection: twenty-eight papers, by names library of Queen Mary’s Dolls’ House. +RZ:DWVRQ familiar (Steven Rothman, Evelyn Herzog, Peter /HDUQHG WKH 7ULFN was the result, a very short self- Calamai, John Pforr) and less so (Sandra J Ailiff, parody, written in his small neat hand on tiny sheets of W Glenn Lieske, Deborah Clarke) on a fascinating paper that were then exquisitely bound for the Dolls’ variety of topics. House. This beautiful facsimile of the unique original is a real treasure. It comes in a lovely gold-stamped Investigating Sherlock Holmes: Solved & Unsolved cloth-bound package, with an attractive, informative Mysteries by Hartley R Nathan and Clifford S booklet. Goldfarb. 0RVDLF3UHVV . 2014. xvi + 209pp. £13.45 (pbk) $ 6KHUORFN +ROPHV 0RQRSRO\ $Q 8QRI¿FLDO Two leading Canadian lawyers also happen to be Guide and Outdoor Activity by JP Sperati. ,UUHJXODU leading Holmesian scholars, whose work has been 6SHFLDO3UHVV . 2014. 199pp. Deluxe full colour edition published in &DQDGLDQ +ROPHV , 7KH %DNHU 6WUHHW £18.99 (pbk) -RXUQDO and elsewhere. Most of the twelve excellent You may think there’s no obvious link between pieces in this book (which include contributions by the great detective and the standard London version Joseph Kessel and John Linsenmeyer) were given as of the game, but as you follow Holmes around the talks to the Bootmakers of Toronto, and they all have locations on the Monopoly board, preferably walking a very engaging freshness. The law naturally features, LQ /RQGRQ ZLWK WKH ERRN LQ \RXU KDQG \RX¶OO ¿QG and since both authors are Jewish they can offer with yourself entranced by the many curious connections DXWKRULW\ SURYLVLRQDO LGHQWL¿FDWLRQV RI WKH ³+HEUHZ that Mr Sperati has uncovered. Splendid photographs rabbi”, “old Abrahams” and Ikey Sanders, as well as a contrast the Victorian scene with today’s, and as a look at Jewish stereotypes in the canon. And did you bonus there’s a cleverly devised Sherlock Holmes know that the solicitor Sir George Lewis, one of the Monopoly treasure hunt, which I fancy will be great few real-life people referred to by name in the stories, fun to play. It’s a winner! was Jewish? This is a very welcome book.

Fan Phenomena: Sherlock Holmes edited by Tom The Real World of Sherlock by BJ Rahn. $PEHUOH\ . 8H  -RQDWKDQ &UDQ¿HOG ,QWHOOHFW %RRNV . 2014. 2014. 256pp. £20.00 (hbk) 153pp. £15.50 (pbk) Just “Sherlock”, so we know which market the Most of the contributors spoke at last summer’s publisher has in mind, but this is actually an absorbing conference 6KHUORFN +ROPHV 3DVW DQG 3UHVHQW : we account of how a Scottish-born member of an artistic have the editors on fan culture, and Holmes and Anglo-Irish family came to create a character that still, Shakespeare, Jonathan Barnes on writing audio QHDUO\  \HDUV ODWHU GH¿QHV WKH *UHDW 'HWHFWLYH drama, Luke Kuhns on pastiche, Benjamin Poore LQWKHSXEOLFPLQG%-5DKQH[DPLQHV¿FWLRQDODQG on Moriarty. The exceptions are Noel Brown on factual antecedents (though she seems unaware of 6KHUORFN+ROPHVLQWKHQG&HQWXU\ , Russell Merritt the disappearance in 1881 of a Mr Stanger, which on Sheldon Reynolds’ 1954 TV series, and Shane was investigated by a detective named Scherer), and Peacock on writing the %R\6KHUORFN+ROPHV novels. compares Sherlock Holmes’s methods with those of There are interviews with the creators of the

Arnold and Michael Price, directors Paul McGuigan (hbk) and Toby Haynes, sfx master Jean-Claude Deguara, After exotic adventures in China and spooky and more, so we get a truly authoritative look at what ones in Ireland, Sherlock is sent to Oxford to study makes 6KHUORFN so successful. There are the scripts of logic under Mycroft’s friend Charles Dodgson. He scenes that were cut, comparisons between passages also attends an anatomy lecture and learns that body from the canon and extracts from the scripts, and any parts are being stolen from the pathology laboratories. number of gorgeous photos — stills, of course, and, Unable to resist investigating, Sherlock is soon more interestingly, pictures taken behind the scenes. grateful for the courage and resourcefulness of his ,W¶VDGH¿QLWLYHFRPSDQLRQWRDZRQGHUIXOVHULHV chum Mattie Arnatt. The mystery is ingenious, the adventure thrilling, and, as we see Sherlock Holmes Benedict Cumberbatch: Transition Completed by develop from a boy to the man we know, we also meet Lynnette Porter. 0;3XEOLVKLQJ . 2014. 286pp. £11.99 the young Reginald Musgrave, and learn something (pbk) about Mortimer Maberley. Like its predecessors, Since %HQHGLFW &XPEHUEDWFK ,Q 7UDQVLWLRQ 6WRQH&ROG is a cracker. Mr C has consolidated his position as both a really important actor and a genuine star. Dr Porter’s new Moriarty by Anthony Horowitz. 2ULRQ . 2014. vi + book continues her survey of his work, his approach 310pp. £19.99 (hbk) to that work, and his fame, in a year that has seen “Does anyone really believe what happened at him on screen in 7KH)LIWK(VWDWH , A Scandal in Bohemia by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, since the Pondicherry Lodge case, make a formidable adapted and illustrated by Petr Kopl. 0;3XEOLVKLQJ . team. (Jones’s epiphany is recounted by Dr Watson 2014. 164pp. £9.99 (pbk) in the story of the Three Monarchs, which forms a There are actually two adventures here, the other neat appendix to the novel.) I confess that I prefer being “The Speckled Band”, and both serve to show 0RULDUW\ to 7KH+RXVHRI6LON . Holmes that women can be just as courageous and intelligent as men — much to Watson’s satisfaction. Sherlock Holmes in Montague Street: Sherlock The result is a feast for the eye and the imagination. Holmes’s Early Investigations by Arthur Morrison, The vivid, exciting text, translated by Paul & Jana edited, Holmes-ed, and with original material by Simpson, is enhanced by artwork that’s by turns David Marcum. 0;3XEOLVKLQJ . 2014. Vol. I, 241pp; deeply atmospheric and devastatingly funny — and Vol. II, 241pp. £9.99 each volume (pbk) often beautiful. The original Czech edition won Petr After “The Final Problem” in December 1893, Kopl the 2013 Fabula Rasa Czech Award for the best 7KH 6WUDQG 0DJD]LQH  ¿OOHG WKH JDS ZLWK GHWHFWLYH script, best artwork and best comic book. stories by Arthur Morrison. It’s been suggested that the sleuth, Martin Hewitt, was the young Mycroft The Hound of the Baskervilles by Sir Arthur Conan Holmes, but Mr Marcum has a more plausible and Doyle, adapted and illustrated by Petr Kopl. 0; attractive theory: that he was Sherlock, early in his 3XEOLVKLQJ . 2014. 164pp. £9.99 (pbk) career as an investigator. With surprisingly little 7KLV LV DFWXDOO\ WKH ¿UVW YROXPH LQ 0U .RSO¶V tweaking, Morrison’s tales are remarkably convincing 9LFWRULD5HJLQD series, of which $6FDQGDOLQ%RKHPLD in their new guise, and, since he was a good writer, LVWKHIRXUWKVRGRQ¶WEHVXUSULVHGWR¿QGWKHQDUUDWLYH the results are very engaging. Meanwhile, the Martin intersecting with the events of 'UDFXOD , 7KH /RVW Hewitt stories still exist in their original state and :RUOG , 'U -HN\OO DQG 0U +\GH and even 5RVVXP¶V DUHQ¶WKDUGWR¿QG 8QLYHUVDO5RERWV , as well as other exploits of Holmes and Watson. Look closely at the illustrations and In brief you’ll see all sorts of unexpected details — though Most earlier collections of parody and pastiche \RXPD\EHWRRHQJURVVHGLQWKHVWRU\RQ¿UVWUHDGLQJ written during Conan Doyle’s lifetime are out of print, so $%HGVLGH%RRNRI(DUO\6KHUORFNLDQ3DURGLHVDQG Young Sherlock: Stone Cold by Andrew Lane. 3DVWLFKHV compiled and edited by Charles Press (MX; 0DFPLOODQ &KLOGUHQ¶V %RRNV . 2014. 320pp. £12.99 £12.99) is very welcome. The stories and snippets 46

include work by JM Barrie, O Henry, Bret Harte, tales from 7KH $GYHQWXUHV RI 6KHUORFN +ROPHV , at Ring Lardner and many others. It’s good to see the £6.99 each. The illustrations by P James Macaluso Wild Wood episode from 7KH :LQG LQ WKH :LOORZV Jr are eccentric, clever, beautifully presented, witty, recognised as a tribute to Sherlock Holmes! and bang up to date, being full-colour photographs of 7KH ¿UVW YROXPH LQ 7KH % &DVHERRN 6HULHV creations in Lego, each a scene depicted by Sidney sets a high standard. 7KH (DUO\ 3XQFK 3DURGLHV RI Paget in 7KH6WUDQG0DJD]LQH . Ideal presents for the 6KHUORFN +ROPHV edited by Bill Peschel (Peschel young Holmesian in your life. Press; £9.56) contains RC Lehmann’s wickedly funny Dan Andriacco’s tales of Sebastian McCabe and exploits of Picklock Holes, with spoofs and satires by Jeff Cody follow an appealing tradition dating back PG Wodehouse, CL Graves, EV Lucas, and Ronald to Anthony Boucher’s 7KH&DVHRIWKH%DNHU6WUHHW .QR[¶VEURWKHU³(YRH´DVZHOODVWKHSUROL¿F$QRQ ,UUHJXODUV . They’re quality fair-play detective stories Verse, reviews, cartoons too, attractively presented, about a Sherlock Holmes devotee. After four novels, with interesting editorial notes. all highly recommended, Dr Andriacco’s latest book Last year the drama company Enter Stage is 5RJXHV*DOOHU\ (MX; £8.99), a collection of witty Right toured south-eastern England with Claire and ingenious short stories. Malcomson’s 7KH +RXQG RI WKH %DVNHUYLOOHV $Q New Sherlock Holmes adventures are being $GDSWDWLRQIRUWKH6WDJH , and will take it on the road published in such quantities that there isn’t space even again in 2015. The story is cleverly and effectively to review all the good ones. The better examples that dramatised, with the legend of the Hound performed have appeared in the last six months include: 6KHUORFN as a folk play, and a neat twist at the end (MX; £9.99). +ROPHV7KH6FRWWLVK4XHVWLRQRU6RQVRIWKH7KLVWOH 7KH (OHPHQWDU\ 6KHUORFN +ROPHV 7KLQJV James Lovegrove (Titan; £7.99); $QQXDO´ and the assertion that the Sherlock Holmes 7KH /DVW &RQIHVVLRQ RI 6KHUORFN +ROPHV by Kieran 0XVHXP¶VDGGUHVVDW%DNHU6WUHHWZDVRI¿FLDOO\ Lyne (MX; £8.99); 6KHUORFN+ROPHV7KH6SLULW%R[ changed to 221B show that it’s not wholly reliable. by George Mann (Titan; £7.99); 7ZR +XQGUHG DQG Following John Gibson’s introduction and Laurie 7ZHQW\2QH %DNHU 6WUHHWV edited by David Thomas R King’s foreword, 3URMHFW7ZRWR2QH%H , edited Moore (Abaddon Books; £7.99); 6KHUORFN +ROPHV by Carrie Carlson & Lynn Gale (MX; £9.99) contains  WKH &DVH RI WKH 7ZDLQ 3DSHUV by Roger Riccard nearly 140 pages of essays, long and short, about (Irregular Special Press; £8.50); $%LDVHG-XGJHPHQW Undershaw, enhanced by photographs and original 7KH6KHUORFN+ROPHV'LDULHV by Geri Schear artwork — some, like Riley Stark’s cover design, (MX; £10.99); 6KHUORFN+ROPHV'LVTXLHWDW$OEDQ\ outstanding. All royalties go to the Undershaw by NM Scott (Book Guild Publishing; £8.99); and campaign. 7KH)LQDO3DJHRI%DNHU6WUHHW by Daniel D Victor To date MX has published new editions of six (MX; £8.99).