In Response to a Recent Outbreak of Gang Warfare Violence at the Robert

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

In response to a recent outbreak of gang warfare violence at the Robert Taylor Homes in Chicago that left ten people dead over a weekend, the Director of the Chicago Housing Authority, Vincent Lane, wanted to have the Chicago police conduct a warrantless sweep search of the Taylor Homes, and to require residents to agree to such searches as a condition in their housing leases. The ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union) has challenged the constitutionality of the sweep search Director Lane wanted. The ACLU also indicated that it would vigorously challenge in court any policy of the Chicago Housing Authority that makes agreement to warrantless searches a condition of living in public housing. Under the circumstances prevailing at the Robert Taylor Homes would warrantless police sweep searches of tenants' apartments be morally justifiable? ANSWER: No: This is a difficult question that requires balancing the fundamental interest of public housing residents in security from life threatening violent criminal behavior and their basic moral right to privacy in their homes. In this case it seems that the balance must be struck in favor of the right of privacy. Given the widespread possession and easy availability of guns in the United States, it is uncertain how effective warrantless sweep searches would be, even if done frequently. On the other hand, the searches would have to be very thorough and intrusive in light of the ease with which a person can hide a gun. The situation at the Robert Taylor Homes is tragic and frightening, but dispensing with a warrant requirement for searches of apartment is not an ethically appropriate response to it. Intercollegiate Ethics Bowl, 1994 © Robert Ladenson, Illinois Institute of Technology, 1994 .

Copy Link

Recommended publications

11.941 Learning by Comparison: First World/Third World Cities Fall 2008
MIT OpenCourseWare http://ocw.mit.edu 11.941 Learning by Comparison: First World/Third World Cities Fall 2008 For information about citing these materials or our Terms of Use, visit: http://ocw.mit.edu/terms. DESIGN Principles & Practices: An International Journal Volume 3, Number 4 The Impact of Urban Design Elements on the Successes and Failures of Modern Multi-family Housing: A Comparative Study of Robert Taylor Homes, Chicago and HanGang Apart Complex, Seoul Jae Seung Lee www.design-journal.com DESIGN PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICES: AN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL http://www.DesignJournal.com First published in 2009 in Melbourne, Australia by Common Ground Publishing Pty Ltd www.CommonGroundPublishing.com. © 2009 (individual papers), the author(s) © 2009 (selection and editorial matter) Common Ground Authors are responsible for the accuracy of citations, quotations, diagrams, tables and maps. All rights reserved. Apart from fair use for the purposes of study, research, criticism or review as permitted under the Copyright Act (Australia), no part of this work may be reproduced without written permission from the publisher. For permissions and other inquiries, please contact <cg[email protected]>. ISSN: 18331874 Publisher Site: http://www.DesignJournal.com DESIGN PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICES: AN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL is peer reviewed, supported by rigorous processes of criterionreferenced article ranking and qualitative commentary, ensuring that only intellectual work of the greatest substance and highest significance is published. Typeset in Common Ground Markup Language using CGCreator multichannel typesetting system http://www.commongroundpublishing.com/software/ The Impact of Urban Design Elements on the Successes and Failures of Modern Multi-family Housing: A Comparative Study of Robert Taylor Homes, Chicago and HanGang Apart Complex, Seoul Jae Seung Lee, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Massachusetts, USA Abstract: This study explores the role of urban design in the successes and failures of modern multi- family housing developments.
[Show full text]
EVALUATION of the URBAN INITIATIVES: Anti-Crime
f U.u-(;(;L40b.+ Contract HC-5231 EVALUATION OF THE URBAN INITIATIVES ANTI-CRIME PROGRAM CHICAGO, IL, CASE STUDY 1984 Prepared for: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Office of Policy Development and Research Prepared by: Police Foundation John F. Kennedy School of Government The views and conclusions presented in this report are those of the author and not necessarily those of the Department of Housing and Urban Development or of the United States Government I This report is one in a series that comprises a comprehensive evaluation of the Public Housing Urban Initiatives Anti-Crime Demonstration. The Final Report provides an integrated analysis of the design, implementation and impact of the entire demonstration, and each of the 15 site-specific case studies analyzes the implementation and impact of the programs at individual partici pating local housing authorities. The complete set of reports includes: Evaluation of the Urban Initiatives Anti-Crime Program: Final Report Evaluation of the Urban Initiatives Anti-Crime Program: Baltimore, MD, Case Study Charlotte, NC, Case Study Chicago, IL, Case Study Cleveland, OH, Case Study Dade County, FL, Case Stu~ Hampton, VA, Case Study Hartford, CT, Case Stu~ Jackson,1 , Case Study Jersey City, NJ, Case Study Louisville, KY, Case Study Oxnard County, CA, Case Study San Antonio, TX, Case Study Seattle, WA, Case Study Tampa, FL, Case Study Toledo, OH, Case Study Each of the above reports is available from HUD USER for a handling charge. For information contact: HUD USER Post Office Box 280 Germantown, MD 20874 (301) 251-5154 -. II PREFACE The Urban Initiatives Anti-Crime Demonstration was created by the Public Housing Security Demonstration Act of 1978.
[Show full text]
The Chicago Housing Authority 10
the ,~ i J. Popkin,Victoria E. Gwiasda,Lynn M. Olson,[_) inis P. Rosenbaum,and LarryBuron FOREWORD BY REBECCA M. BLANK J The Hidden War 1£4/-7~ The Hidden War Crime and the Tragedy of Public Housing in Chicago SUSAN J. POPKIN VICTORIA E. GWIASDA LYNN M. OLSON DENNIS P. ROSENBAUM LARRY BURON .-- IPF~QRERYY ©f~ ~ation~l @iminal Justics Roi~o~c~ 8onii@ (t~¢jR8) Box 6000 Rockville, ~E) 20849o6000 RUTGERS UNIVERSITY PRESS New Brunswick, New Jersey, and London Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data The hidden war : crime and the tragedy of public housing in Chicago / Susan J. Popkin... let al.]. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-8135-2832-1 (cloth : alk. paper) -- ISBN 0-8135-2833-X (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Chicago Housing Authority. 2. Housing authorities--Illinois-- Chicago. 3. Public housing--Illinois--Chicago. I. Popkin, Susan J. HD7288.78.U52 C44 2000 363.5'85'0977311--dc21 99-056789 British Cataloging-in-Publication data for this book is available from the British Library Copyright © 2000 by Susan J. Popkin All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the publisher. Please contact Rutgers University Press, 100 Joyce Kilmer Avenue, Piscataway, NJ 08854-8099. The only exception to this prohibition is "fair use" as defined by U.S. copyright law. Manufactured in the United States of America - Contents LIST OF PHOTOS, FIGURES, AND TABLES VII FOREWORD BY REBECCA M.
[Show full text]
"Tarred with the Exceptional Image": Public Housing and Popular Discourse, 1950-1990
"Tarred with the Exceptional Image": Public Housing and Popular Discourse, 1950-1990 A. Scott Henderson I In 1986, readers of a major news magazine learned about Desire, a New Orleans housing project. Presumably open to all of New Orleans' "poor people," most of Desire's residents—as the text and photographs made clear—were African-Americans. Out of the project's population of 7,800, almost 3,000 were children, some of whom represented a "third generation of poverty " characterized by an "inexorable cycle of crime, welfare dependency and dimmed hopes." Moreover, Desire was a "world without order, cleanliness, privacy or parental supervision," where school drop-outs, teenage fathers, and unwed mothers were common. But if Desire conformed to a grim yet all too familiar image of public housing, its residents' behaviors, which included "violence," drug use, and random sex, were identified as the chief causes.1 While Desire typified the image of public housing presented by the periodi cal press in the 1980s, the issues of race and tenant behavior had not always framed depictions of housing projects. Between 1950 and the early 1960s,afairly positive conception of low-income subsidized housing dominated popular cov erage, a dialogue that stressed slum clearance and the dearth of affordable housing. By the late 1960s, though, a highly problematic image—based largely on race—had come to dominate the popular press, obscuring alternative represen tations that would have more accurately depicted the range and variety of public housing throughout America. Indeed, national datafor 1989 indicated that public housing was neither racially monolithic (one out of every three units was 0026-3079/93/3601-031$! .50/0 31 classified as white), nor occupied primarily by welfare recipients (35 percent reported wages and 45 percent reported social security/pensions as income sources).
[Show full text]
An Analysis of Historic Preservation Debates in Chicago
Illinois State University ISU ReD: Research and eData Theses and Dissertations 4-14-2014 Modernism on Trial: An Analysis of Historic Preservation Debates in Chicago Stephen M. Mitchell Illinois State University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.library.illinoisstate.edu/etd Part of the Architecture Commons, and the History Commons Recommended Citation Mitchell, Stephen M., "Modernism on Trial: An Analysis of Historic Preservation Debates in Chicago" (2014). Theses and Dissertations. 163. https://ir.library.illinoisstate.edu/etd/163 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by ISU ReD: Research and eData. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ISU ReD: Research and eData. For more information, please contact [email protected]. MODERNISM ON TRIAL: AN ANALYSIS OF HISTORIC PRESERVATION DEBATES IN CHICAGO Stephen M. Mitchell 119 Pages May 2014 This thesis explores preservation issues regarding modernist architecture in Chicago. As urban and public history research, the project examines the new questions brought to the forefront by recent controversies over the preservation of modernist architecture. Modernism, and an “all concrete” variant known as “Brutalism,” popular in the mid-twentieth century, aimed to remove ornament and historical references common in neoclassical, neo-Gothic, Beaux Arts, and Art Deco architecture and replace them with minimal, clean, glass-and-steel buildings. Modernists who, on principle, did not believe in preservation of past forms are now in the unlikely position of making such an argument for their own buildings. Never widely embraced in the first place, Brutalism’s concrete façades seemed less and less to reflect aesthetic tastes as architects turned back toward historicist styles by the 1980s.
[Show full text]
Public Housing That Worked: New York in the Twentieth Century by Nicholas Dagen Bloom
I Book Reviews I 515 the Boomers’ interest in selling their (inflated) housing assets. But Myers was writing before the housing bubble burst, which might have relieved some of the pressure that had been building under housing prices. Myers also stresses the link between “demographic self-interest” and needed public policy, but he does little to explain what, besides public awareness, will bridge the distance between them. “Could” is not the same as “is” or “will” (as he acknowledges in Chapter 2). He does not directly address the merits of any specific approaches to immigration policy (e.g., how should we deal with people who are in this country illegally?). Further, his analysis of policy focuses mostly on the intergenerational transfer between older (usually White) middle-class Boomers and younger (usually Hispanic) upwardly mobile immigrants. He ignores the impact of this scenario on the low- and moderate-income native-born workers (also typically White, but many are Black), and the equity issues that it raises. Is it ethical, as a policy position, to shore up the retirement of elderly middle-class Whites by importing immigrant workers at the expense of resident lower-class citizens? But these are cavils about the policy recommendations he draws from his analysis; the analysis itself is excellent. This is an admirable piece of work, well written, well documented, and well argued. While it is aimed at citizen-voters and taxpayers, it should also prove thought provoking for a subset of that group, students of urban affairs. Anthony Filipovitch Minnesota State University Mankato [email protected] Nicholas Dagen Bloom, Public Housing That Worked: New York in the Twentieth Century (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2008).
[Show full text]
Chicago Housing Authority
SCATTERED SITES NORTH CENTRAL ALTGELD GARDENS SENIOR HOUSING SOUTH SCATTERED SITES NORTH EAST BRIDGEPORT HOMES SENIOR HOUSING NORTH SCATTERED SITES SOUTH WEST DEARBORN HOMES SENIOR HOUSING CENTRAL SCATTERED SITES WEST SCATTERED SITES SOUTH EAST ICKES HOMES LATHROP HOMES LAWNDALE GARDENS LECLAIRE COURTS EXTENSION LOWDEN HOMES PHILLIP MURRAY HOMES RANDOLPH TOWERS TRUMBULL PARK HOMES WENTWORTH GARDENS LEGENDS SOUTH GRACE ABBOTT HOMES ROBERT H. BROOKS HOMES AND EXTENSION JANE ADDAMS HOMES FRANCIS CABRINI HOMES AND EXTENSIONS WILLIAM GREEN HOMES HENRY HORNER HOMES LAKE MICHIGAN HOMES MADDEN PARK HOMES IDA B. WELLS HOMES AND EXTENSION CLARENCE DARROW HOMES ROBERT TAYLOR HOMES ROCKWELL GARDENS STATEWAY GARDENS WASHINGTON PARK HOMES ROOSEVELT SQUARE DOMAIN LOFTS OLD TOWN VILLAGE EAST RIVER VILLAGE OLD TOWN VILLAGE WEST ORCHARD PARK MOHAWK NORTH RENAISSANCE NORTH MOHAWK INFILL OLD TOWN SQUARE CENTRUM I VILLAGE NORTH RAYMOND M. HILLIARD CENTER WESTHAVEN PARK LAKEFRONT REPLACEMENT HOUSING LAKE PARK CRESCENT HUTCHINSON’S ROW JAZZ ON THE BOULEVARD OAKWOOD SHORES THE LANGSTON QUINCY HOMES MOUNT VERNON ARCHER COURTS THE PERSHING PARK BOULEVARD ST. EDMUND’S MEADOWS PRAIRIE COURTS EXTENSION SOUTH PARK PLAZA DO YOU HAVE A VISION FOR CHANGE? SCATTERED SITES NORTH CENTRAL ALTGELD GARDENS SENIOR HOUSING SOUTH SCATTERED SITES NORTH EAST BRIDGEPORT HOMES SENIOR HOUSING NORTH SCATTERED SITES SOUTH WEST DEABORN HOMES SENIOR HOUSING CENTRAL SCATTERED SITES WEST SCATTERED SITES SOUTH EAST HAROLD ICKES HOMES LATHROP HOMES LAWNDALE GARDENS LECLAIRE COURTS EXTENSION LOWDEN HOMES PHILLIP MURRAY HOMES RANDOLPH TOWERS TRUMBULL PARK HOMES WENTWORTH GARDENS LEGENDS SOUTH GRACE ABBOTT HOMES ROBERT H. BROOKS HOMES AND EXTENSION JANE ADDAMS HOMES FRANCIS CABRINI HOMES AND EXTENSIONS WILLIAM GREEN HOMES HENRY HORNER HOMES LAKE MICHIGAN HOMES MADDEN PARK HOMES IDA B.
[Show full text]
After the Towers: the Destruction of Public Housing and the Remaking
After the Towers: The Destruction of Public Housing and the Remaking of Chicago by Andrea Field A Dissertation Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy Approved March 2017 by the Graduate Supervisory Committee: Philip Vandermeer, Chair Deirdre Pfeiffer Victoria Thompson ARIZONA STATE UNIVERSITY May 2017 ©2017 Andrea Field All Rights Reserved ABSTRACT This dissertation examines the history of Cabrini-Green through the lens of placemaking. Cabrini-Green was one of the nation's most notorious public housing developments, known for sensational murders of police officers and children, and broadcast to the nation as a place to be avoided. Understanding Cabrini-Green as a place also requires appreciation for how residents created and defended their community. These two visions—Cabrini-Green as a primary example of a failed public housing program and architecture and Cabrini-Green as a place people called home—clashed throughout the site's history, but came into focus with its planned demolition in the Chicago Housing Authority's Plan for Transformation. Demolition and reconstruction of Cabrini-Green was supposed to create a model for public housing renewal in Chicago. But residents feared that this was simply an effort to remove them from valuable land on Chicago's Near North Side and deprive them of new neighborhood improvements. The imminent destruction of the CHA’s high-rises uncovered desires to commemorate the public housing developments like Cabrini-Green and the people who lived there through a variety of public history and public art projects. This dissertation explores place from multiple perspectives including architecture, city planning, neighborhood development, and public and oral history.
[Show full text]
Public Housing: an Introspective Study on Public Housing and Its Effects on Health and Well-Being
Public Housing: An Introspective Study on Public Housing and Its Effects on Health and Well-being Janna Traeger and Victoria Phillips Senior Project; Winter 2013 Professor Bickel 1 The federal public housing program in the United States has had the reputation of being a bleak wasteland used to abandon some of our nation’s poorest families. Since its creation in the nineteenth and early twentieth century, the United States’ programs to house the poor have been in crisis. We have historically had serious issues when it comes to housing and taking care of our needy population. In recent years, things have since been worse for the underprivileged as we are currently facing the economic downturn of our once strong economy. Programs helping low-income families are getting cut and budgets continue to become bigger problems. The United Nations Human Settlements Program states that: By the beginning of the third millennium, it is estimated that 1.1 billion people live in inadequate housing conditions in urban areas alone. In many cities of developing countries, more than half of the population lives in informal settlements, without security of tenure and in conditions that can be described as life and health threatening. Among an estimated 100 million homeless people around the world, available data suggests that increasing proportions are women and children (Berkowitz & Brownlee, 2013). The above statistics suggest the importance and the pressing need for quality housing throughout the world. Quality housing does not just include a safe and decent place to live, but also something affordable within reach of grocery stores, work and/or school.
[Show full text]
Fy2006 Moving to Workannualplan
FY2006 MOVING TO WORK ANNUAL PLAN PLAN FOR TRANSFORMATION YEAR 7 OCTOBER 31, 2005 DIRECTORY CHICAGO HOUSING AUTHORITY EXECUTIVE OFFICE 626 West Jackson Boulevard Terry Peterson, Chief Executive Officer Adrienne G. Minley, Chief of Staff Chicago, Illinois 60661 Evelyn Maultsby-Bynum, Deputy Chief of Staff Gail Niemann, General Counsel PHONE: 312.742.8500 Darnetta Tyus, Managing Director of the Board of Commissioners WEBSITE: www.thecha.org Veronica Alanis, Special Assistant to the CEO DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT William Little, Managing Director Carl Byrd, Director - 312.742.8300 BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS FINANCE Miroslava Mejia-Krug, Chief Financial Officer Sharon Gist Gilliam Michael J. Gurgone, Treasurer - 312.742.5223 Margaret Jones, Director of Grant Administration - 312.742.4978 Chairperson Marvin Walton, Director of Budget and Management - 312.742.8611 David Burns, Comptroller – 312.742.4049 INTERNAL/EXTERNAL COMMUNICATIONS Lori Healey Derek Hill, Press Secretary - 312.742.9876 Vice Chairperson Kristen Hamer, Assistant Director of Resource Development - 312.742.8558 Kellye A. Keyes, Director of Management Analysis and Planning - 312.742.8550 Debra Moo-Young, ADA/Section 504 Compliance Coordinator – 312.742.2979 Otis Wright, Director of Intergovernmental Affairs – 312.742.0568 Hallie Amey INTERNAL SUPPORT Earnest Gates Cheryl Straughter, Managing Director Barbara Banks, Chief Information Officer - 312.742.2787 Dr. Mildred Harris A. Tish Mercer, Director of Human Resources - 312.742.8500 Michael Ivers Albert Murillo, Director of Procurement
[Show full text]
Firmoftheyearaward Landonbo
LANDON BONE BAKER ARCHITECTS Good design is for everyone. 01 FIRM PROFILE OUR PRACTICE IS COMMITTED TO THE ROLE OF HOUSING IN CREATING COMPREHENSIVE, SUSTAINABLE, AND PROGRESSIVE URBAN DEVELOPMENT. LANDON BONE BAKER ARCHITECTS MISSION STATEMENT LANDON BONE BAKER ARCHITECTS When Peter Landon founded Landon Architects in 1987, he was on the front line of social change. Rather than focusing on high-end homes, he intended to design housing for segments of the population generally overlooked—individuals and families whose economic status dictate their lifestyles and surroundings, and who generally don’t have the luxury of choice. As the firm built its early portfolio of both public and private housing, it was exposed to clients with varying capacities, a wide range of resident expectations and needs, and challenging, yet exciting, urban conditions. The firm found common ground where none was thought to exist and defined a visual language that can be shared by all. The work resonated with a sense of social equality and economy of means—a willingness to take risks to find an appropriate architectural response. Through it all, a central theme emerged that has guided the firm for over 25 years. Good design is for everyone. As gentrification in Chicago swept northwest and pushed affordability southwest, the mission grew stronger to provide architecturally significant, yet affordable options to as many people as possible. The firm was willing to take a stand and engage in the political struggles that are often necessary when working with minority and low-income communities. Across Chicago, in areas like Roseland, Lawndale, West Humboldt Park, Chinatown, and Uptown, the firm built close connections with community residents, activists, and organizations.
[Show full text]
Race, Segregation and the Chicago Housing Authority David T
The College of Wooster Libraries Open Works Senior Independent Study Theses 2013 Chicago's Wall: Race, Segregation and the Chicago Housing Authority David T. Greetham The College of Wooster, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://openworks.wooster.edu/independentstudy Part of the African American Studies Commons, and the Urban Studies Commons Recommended Citation Greetham, David T., "Chicago's Wall: Race, Segregation and the Chicago Housing Authority" (2013). Senior Independent Study Theses. Paper 3801. https://openworks.wooster.edu/independentstudy/3801 This Senior Independent Study Thesis Exemplar is brought to you by Open Works, a service of The oC llege of Wooster Libraries. It has been accepted for inclusion in Senior Independent Study Theses by an authorized administrator of Open Works. For more information, please contact [email protected]. © Copyright 2013 David T. Greetham The College of Wooster Chicago’s Wall: Race, Segregation and the Chicago Housing Authority by David Greetham Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements of Senior Independent Study Supervised by Jeff Roche Department of History Spring 2013 TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements i List of Figures ii Introduction 1 Chapter One: Contestation, Expansion and Confinement: A History of Chicago 8 Chapter Two: Political Hijacking: The 1949-1950 Site Selection Controversy 34 Chapter Three: Trumbull Park: The Collapse of the Chicago Housing Authority 65 Chapter Four: A Pyrrhic Victory: Gautreaux v. Chicago Housing Authority 86 Conclusion 124 Annotated Bibliography 130 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would not have been able to complete this work without the help of my advisor Jeff Roche. Throughout the process, Professor Roche helped me narrow my interests, provided thoughtful questions and responses, and always was ready to suggest ways to make my thesis better.
[Show full text]