Earth Can Survive Without Us; Could We Survive Anywhere Else?

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Earth Can Survive Without Us; Could We Survive Anywhere Else? Features The Samuel Alexander Lecture 2015 Earth can survive without us; could we survive anywhere else? (L-R): Cameron Ensor and Eloise Bagnara, Glen Waverley Captains, Germaine Greer, Helen Drennen, Aimee Bowles and Nick Williamson, St Kilda Road Captains Play word association with the name Germaine Greer Greer takes issue with Hawking’s belief in our future resting and ideas like noted feminist or The Female Eunuch might on space colonisation and is happily scathing about this silly immediately spring to mind. However, if you were lucky enough thing going on about settling Mars. She doesn’t see it as viable, to attend her sold out Samuel Alexander Lecture at St Kilda painting a colourful picture of attempts at survival on Mars and Road’s Adamson Hall in April, you may well volunteer such stressing its certain failure. She observes that we don’t need to words as endosymbiosis, enviro-poisons and slime moulds… go out to reach the universe, we’re part of it here on Earth. She and you’d be justified, for while Greer’s engaging lecture Earth argues that our planet has existed around a 1000 times longer can survive without us; could we survive anywhere else? that humans have: Earth did without us for billions of years – certainly had a feminist thread, the focus was very much on the could we survive anywhere else? ecology of our planet, and in particular the micro-organisms we rely upon for our survival. Here Greer displays a strong knowledge of biological processes, and she conveys our dependence on the natural Greer is not a woman to stand intellectually still, and this was world via the dynamic activities of the microbes that exist all never more evident with her assertion that the fate of humankind around us and within us. She opposes the use of the everyday (or earthlings, as she puts it) is tied to this planet, not with any products (enviro-poisons) marketed to us for our homes and space adventure as suggested by Stephen Hawking. Hawking’s gardens which kill bacteria and germs construed as harmful. argument is that Earth has only about 1,000 habitable years left, According to Greer, many of these micro-organisms are often and so the human race must colonise space if it is to survive. necessary to our lives and health. She critiques the female But let’s go back a bit to start… obsession with cleanliness (women are in a jam – they have got to be clean!), urging that less energy be devoted to eliminating Nowadays, Greer’s feminism is very much grounded in germs, which help our auto-immune systems to develop, and eco-feminism, and typically, she is engaging with this on both some of which protect against asthma. Thus in ignorance a personal and a philosophical level. She has acquired a tract and zeal, despite best intentions, women too are agents of of land in South East Queensland which she is replanting into destroying nature. rainforest, and in doing so she feels she is “replanting herself”. On the philosophical level, she sees a fundamental antagonism Audience questions put to Greer following her lecture between masculine power structures and the planet, and sees concerned our capacity for change (we’re clever we humans, women as more connected to the earth than men, in large part we’re resourceful and we can learn), capitalism as a destroyer of due to woman’s tradition role as “gatherers” in our early hunter- nature (action by groups and individuals can guard against the gatherer system of survival. She argues that female attitudes excesses of capitalism) and the ethics of eating animals (yes, and values can save our planet, if allowed to be expressed it’s OK to eat an animal – as long as you eat all of it…preying on and enacted. animals for sport is just wrong). Lion - August 2015 5.
Recommended publications
  • Germaine Greer on Shakespeare's Wife >>P 2
    FREE MARCH 2008 Readings Monthly 9/52).$%0%.$%.4"//+ -53)#!.$$6$.%73,%44%2s%6%.43s.%72%,%!3%3s2%6)%73 IMAGE FROM GERMAINE GREER’S SEE EVENT P2 SHAKESPEARE’S WIFE (BLOOMSBURY) Germaine Greer on Shakespeare’s Wife >>p 2 March book, CD & DVD new releases. More inside >> POP CD CLASSICAL Nick Cave and Vivaldi Concerti and Cantate the Bad Seeds. Polverelli/L’Astree Normally $29.95 Normally $34.95. FICTION NON-FICTION NON-FICTION DVD Our price $24.95 Our price $12.95 Normally $29.95 Normally $49.95 Normally $89.95 Control >>p28 >>p30 Our price $24.95 Our price $39.95 Our price $69.95 $29.95 >>p8 >>p8 >>p18 >>p25 March event highlights. More Readings events inside >> TONI JORDAN MARK SEYMOUR THE VERY HUNGRY AT READINGS AT READINGS CATERPILLAR HAWTHORN CARLTON AT READINGS PORT MELBOURNE !,,3(/03/0%.$!93sCARLTON 309 LYGON 34sHAWTHORN 701 GLENFERRIE RD 9819 1917 s MALVERN 185 GLENFERRIE RD 9509 1952 s PORT MELBOURNE 253 BAY ST 9681 9255 s ST KILDA 112 ACLAND ST 9525 3852 s WWW.READINGS.COM.AU s EMAIL [email protected] Readings Events in March All our events are free, unless otherwise stated. For more information, please call the shop where the event is to be held, or the booking number provided. 5 MYER BLOOM 6 SIRI HUSTVEDT Shakespeare’s Wife (Bloomsbury, cation. The Incoming Tide (John Le- LAUNCH & PAUL AUSTER PB, $35), we are honoured to have onard, PB, $24.95) was shortlisted Germaine with us in our celebra- for the 2007 Queensland Premier’s Myer Bloom has interviewed many IN CONVERSATION WITH tion of International Women’s Literary Awards.
    [Show full text]
  • Greer's 'Bad Sex' and the Future of Consent
    Sexuality & Culture https://doi.org/10.1007/s12119-019-09671-x ORIGINAL PAPER Greer’s ‘Bad Sex’ and the Future of Consent Victoria Brooks1 © The Author(s) 2019 Abstract Germaine Greer’s polemic ‘On Rape’ has proved controversial and has served to further divide feminist opinion on the way to move forward from #MeToo in consent reform. Greer’s work, along with other second wave feminists, has been rejected by third wave feminist scholarship for simultaneously minimising the harm caused to victims of sexual violence and claiming that rape is not ‘catastrophic’, with Naomi Wolf being Greer’s most vocal and powerful opponent. Yet, I claim that in maintain- ing this position in opposition to Greer we are missing the real transformative power of Greer’s revival of second-wave arguments in relation to reforming our laws on consent post #MeToo. The consent framework and the defnition of consent under the Sexual Ofences Act 2003 has been readily criticised for its vague defnition of ‘freedom’ and ‘capacity’ in that such a defnition misses the subtler, yet powerful, ways in which victims are coerced and abused—those which are most insidious, since they are embedded within the fabric of our society, and within the ‘tissue’ of heterosex. Greer’s position that rape is ‘bad sex’ may well hold some truth— since bad sex for women has long been accepted as part of life albeit reduced to suferance and duty. Inevitably, this leads us to the conclusion that there are many more instances of rape than we thought, and many more women sufering, than we thought.
    [Show full text]
  • Safer Spaces DELLER, Ruth A
    Safer spaces DELLER, Ruth A. <http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4935-980X> Available from Sheffield Hallam University Research Archive (SHURA) at: http://shura.shu.ac.uk/24485/ This document is the author deposited version. You are advised to consult the publisher's version if you wish to cite from it. Published version DELLER, Ruth A. (2019). Safer spaces. In: KINNA, Ruth and GORDON, Uri, (eds.) Routledge handbook of radical politics. New York, Routledge. Copyright and re-use policy See http://shura.shu.ac.uk/information.html Sheffield Hallam University Research Archive http://shura.shu.ac.uk 2.6 SAFER SPACES Ruth A. Deller Introduction In this chapter, I explore the notions of ‘safer spaces’ – places where people from different marginalised groups can gather, speak and be resourced in safety. Safer spaces can be physical, but they are also cultural – framed by a series of boundaries, principles and practices designed to support members of the group(s) needing the safer space. I explore here some of the moti- vations and underlying principles of safer spaces, and the roles they can play in radical politics. This chapter focuses predominantly on examples relating to gender, sex, ethnicity, health and dis/ability although the cultivation of safer spaces can also include practices such as creating equality and diversity policies; providing appropriate dietary options for vegetarians, vegans, members of different faith groups and those with food allergies or other medical conditions; health and safety policies that ensure the physical safety of events and organisations, and ethics policies that ensure appropriate research and professional conduct in a variety of con- texts.
    [Show full text]
  • Art Monthly 1 L S TR II, I I
    --L/ f -~ ..... .I \ I ( I !' I ' \ I .I Denis Freney Memorial Scholarships Up to $10,000 AUSTRALIAN Applicatio ns are in vited from people currentl y engaged BOOK REVIEW in (or about to commence) a research, writing or cultural project whi ch is judged to make a contributio n to the labour and progressive moveme nts in Australi a. MAY: The SEARC H Foundation wi ll award scho larships to assist wi th the costs o f such a project. Priority will be An essay by Terry Collits g iven to pro jects which have good prospects of pu blicati on or othe r public use of th e results, but A double review of Germaine Greer's whi ch do not have access to other funding. The Whole Woman by S EA RC H is an inde pendent, non-pro fit fo undati on Jenna Mead and Peter Craven established to assist acti vities whi ch pro mote social j usti ce and the development of a more democrati c and Dorothy Hewett on Jm·die Albiston's egalitari an society. Deta il s of its aim s and objecti ves are avail able on request. The Hanging ofJean Lee Suitabl y qualified applicants should contact SEA RCH Susan Lever on David Foster's essays for deta il ed applicati o n g uidelines. Applications must be received by July 20, 1999 and his new novel, Social Education and Research In the New Country Concerning Humanity (SEARCH) Foundation Rm 610,3 Smail Street, BROADWAY NSW 2007 Andrew Riemer on Ph : (02) 921 I 4164; Fax: (02) 921 I 1407 James Bradley's The Deep Field SEARCH FOUNDATION New Subscribers $55 for ten issues plus a free book ACN 050 096 976 Ph (03) 9429 6700 or Fax (03) 9429 2288 in the footsteps of Dam Gregory Murray, Joseph Gelineau SJ and Richard Connolly MUSIC FOR SUNG MASS GREGORIAN CHANT New rhythmic edition with organ accompaniment Introduction: 'Looking towards 21st century Gregorian Chant' Short Mass (Advent, Lent), Gloria XV, Mass VIII (de Angelis), Credo III $25 WORKS FOR THE ENGLISH LITURGY (including Mass settings approved by the National Liturgical Commission) 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Working Paper Series
    WORKING PAPER SERIES Women in marine science: The efficacy of ecofeminist theory in the wake of historical critique BY SAM PERRIN AND RAPTI SIRIWARDANE-DE ZOYSA Working Paper #3 ISSN 0000-0000 August, 2017 DOI: 10.21244/zmt.2017.004 Photo: Lucy G. Gillis 1 Abstract Ecofeminism at its simplest is the combination of ecological and feminist principles with a strong grounding in social movements. As in the case of most philosophical paradigms and socio-political agendas, it has also been the subject of criticism from feminists of diverse schools of thought since its conception in the 1970s. As the offspring of a social movement as diverse as feminism, this is not unexpected. As it came to prominence in the seventies, an era in which second-wave feminism flourished, it shared many of the same criticisms. It was seen as vague and poorly defined, often only explained as the sum of its parts, and also as appealing mainly to white, middle-class women. It also struggled with criticisms of essentialism – in this context the notion that “woman” (in its singularity) shares an affinity with nature and is therefore better positioned to speak on its behalf. These criticisms and conflicts have, however, helped ecofeminism to evolve into a conceptual framework, grounded in ecological principles and feminist theory combined with local perspectives. Pressing forward, we examine the value of this conceptual framework through surveying a selection of diverse female marine scientists based in Germany, and show that ecofeminism is a valuable scholarly lens through which to view contemporary forms of androcentrism and of gendered discrimination in the marine scientific community, among others.
    [Show full text]
  • Migration in Britain
    MIGRATION IN BRITAIN: WhAT ARe OuR CulTuRAl IdeNTITIes? This learning resource for teachers and students of Secondary Art and A Level Art focuses on a selection of portraits from the Collection of the National Portrait Gallery, London. The resource could also be relevant for those studying Art History, History and Citizenship. Camila Batmanghelidjh by Dean Marsh oil on plywood panel, 2008 NPG 6845 2/32 MIGRATION IN BRITAIN ABOuT ThIs ResOuRCe This resource tackles the question of what British cultural identities can mean and how people who constitute that sector of our society have and do contribute to it in a variety of different ways. This resource relates to another resource in on our website entitled Image and Identity. See: www. npg.org.uk/learning Each portrait is viewed and examined in a number of different ways with discussion questions and factual information relating directly to the works. The material in this resource can be used in the classroom or in conjunction with a visit to the Gallery. Students will learn about British culture through the ideas, methods and approaches used by portrait artists and their sitters over the last four hundred years. The contextual information provides background material that can be fed into the students' work as required. The guided discussion gives questions for the teacher to ask a group or class, it may be necessary to pose further questions around what culture can mean today to help explore and develop ideas more fully. Students should have the opportunity to pose their own questions, too. Each section contains the following: an introduction to each portrait, definitions, key words, questions and two art projects.
    [Show full text]
  • Bitch the Politics of Angry Women
    Bitch The Politics of Angry Women Kylie Murphy Bachelor of Arts with First Class Honours in Communication Studies This thesis is presented for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of Murdoch University 2002. DECLARATION I declare that this thesis is my own account of my research and contains as its main content work which has not previously been submitted for a degree at any tertiary education institution. Kylie Murphy ii ABSTRACT ‘Bitch: the Politics of Angry Women’ investigates the scholarly challenges and strengths in retheorising popular culture and feminism. It traces the connections and schisms between academic feminism and the feminism that punctuates popular culture. By tracing a series of specific bitch trajectories, this thesis accesses an archaeology of women’s battle to gain power. Feminism is a large and brawling paradigm that struggles to incorporate a diversity of feminist voices. This thesis joins the fight. It argues that feminism is partly constituted through popular cultural representations. The separation between the academy and popular culture is damaging theoretically and politically. Academic feminism needs to work with the popular, as opposed to undermining or dismissing its relevancy. Cultural studies provides the tools necessary to interpret popular modes of feminism. It allows a consideration of the discourses of race, gender, age and class that plait their way through any construction of feminism. I do not present an easy identity politics. These bitches refuse simple narratives. The chapters clash and interrogate one another, allowing difference its own space. I mine a series of sites for feminist meanings and potential, ranging across television, popular music, governmental politics, feminist books and journals, magazines and the popular press.
    [Show full text]
  • Essential Texts in Feminist Theory & Feminist Thought
    Women’s History Month El Camino College Library March 2014 Essential Texts in Feminist Theory & Feminist Thought Backlash: The Undeclared War Against Women / Susan Faludi HQ 1426 F35 Faludi's 1991 best seller got down and dirty with all the antifeminism backlash that she asserted was still keeping women second-class citizens in the work force and in greater society in general. Library Journal The Beauty Myth / Naomi Wolf HQ 1219 W65 A valuable study, documenting societal pressures on women to conform to a standard of beauty. Publishers Weekly Big Girls Don't Cry: The Election That Changed Everything For American Women / Rebecca Traister K 276 2008 T73 Traister (Salon.com) here reflects on women's impact on the political process in 2008, the candidates, the media's sometimes sexist attention to Clinton and Palin, and voters' reactions to the candidates and campaigns. Library Journal The Dialectic Of Sex: The Case For Feminist Revolution / Shulamith Firestone HQ 1426 F68 The Dialectic of Sex was the first book of the women's liberation movement to put forth a feminist theory of politics. Book annotation The Female Eunuch / Germaine Greer HQ 1206 G77 Greer looks at the inherent and unalterable biological differences between men and women as well as at the profound psychological differences that result from social conditioning. Book Annotation Female Masculinity / Judith Halbertam HQ 75.5 H33 Halberstam (Univ. of California, San Diego) examines how society perceives masculinity differently when it is a characteristic of women, not men. Choice The Feminine Mystique / Betty Friedan HQ 1426 F83 By the founder of the National Organization for Women (NOW) in 1964, a ground-breaking book that analyzes and attacks the attempts to convince women that their place is in the home.
    [Show full text]
  • Between Two Constitutions: Feminism and Pornography
    BETWEEN TWO CONSTITUTIONS: FEMINISM AND PORNOGRAPHY .David Bryden • Any one who knows what the worth of family affection is among the lower classes, and who has seen the array of little portraits stuck over a labourer's fire­ place, still gathering into one the "Home" that life is always paning-the boy that has "gone to Canada," the girl "out at service," the little one with the golden hair that sleeps under the daisies, the old grandfather in the country-will perhaps feel with me that in counteracting the tendencies, social and industrial, which every day are sapping the healthier family affections, the sixpenny photograph is doing more for the poor than all the philanthropists in the world. (Macmillan's Maga­ zine, Sept. 1871). To photograph people is to violate them, by seeing them as they never see them­ selves, by having knowledge of them they can never have; it turns people into objects that can be symbolically possessed. Just as the camera is a sublimation of the gun, to photograph someone is a sublimated murder-a soft murder, appro­ priate to a sad, frightened time. (Susan Sontag, On Photography, 1977) For reasons that remain obscure, the University of Minnesota Law School has been extraordinarily productive of theories about pornography. Not so long ago, former Dean William Lockhart and Professor Robert McClure wrote several influential articles on the subject. Then Dean Lockhart chaired the United States Com­ mission on Pornography and Obscenity, whose report in 1970 recommended legalizing the sale of pornography to adults. The commission took an empirical approach to the subject, and found no substantial evidence that exposure to pornography leads to an­ tisocial behavior.
    [Show full text]
  • Morgan, Sylvia (2017) Constructing Identities, Reclaiming Subjectivities, Reconstructing Selves: an Interpretative Study of Transgender Practices in Scotland
    Morgan, Sylvia (2017) Constructing identities, reclaiming subjectivities, reconstructing selves: an interpretative study of transgender practices in Scotland. PhD thesis. http://theses.gla.ac.uk/8073/ Copyright and moral rights for this work are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge This work cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Glasgow Theses Service http://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] Constructing identities, reclaiming subjectivities, reconstructing selves: an interpretative study of transgender practices in Scotland A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy By Sylvia Morgan (M.Litt, M.Ed) School of Social and Political Sciences, The College Social Sciences University of Glasgow, Scotland January 2017 Author’s Declaration I declare that the original work presented in this thesis is the work of the author Sylvia Morgan. I have been responsible for all aspects of the study unless where explicit reference is made to the contribution of others. This work has not been submitted for any other course or qualification on a previous occasion to University of Glasgow or any other institution. Sylvia Morgan Signed: ……………………………………………… Date:……………………………………………….. ABSTRACT This thesis provides a sociologically informed understanding of the intersubjective meanings of historical and emergent transgender identities and practices in Scotland.
    [Show full text]
  • Ecofeminism: an ETHICS of ENVIRONMENT
    eCOFEMINISM: AN ETHICS OF ENVIRONMENT . THESIS SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN PHILOSOPHY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF NORTH BENGAL Submitted By UTPAL I<ALITA Under the Supervision of Dr. Kanti La/ Da$ Professor of Philosophy DEPARTMENT OF PHILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH BENGAL RAJA RAMMOHUNPUR DARJEELING-734013 2011 / ··1"'~, ~ C)il.\ I 2 ~ fl,~e ,··, '"J I' 250 Os;,l 10 MAY Z013 ··~ PiJeduxded uP my~ . ·. ff ~~~o/mydl'~ ~ffrDMha ...... TABLE OF CONTENTS Preface Acknowledgement v Introduction 1 Chapter One Ecofeminism and Deep Ecology 13 Chapter Two Ecofeminism and Social Ecology 36 Chapter Three Ecofeminism and the Value ofNature 76 Chapter Four Feminism: Dainism: Justice: Ecofeminism 103 Chapter Five Concluding Remarks 151 Select Bibliography 170 e. PREFACE Believers and theologians will go on tracing the roots of environmental crises in human departures from scriptural mandates, and therefore identifying the prospects ofenvironmental reform in a renewed adherence to them. For the historians, however, environmentalism is principally a product of and reaction to the Industrial Revolution. Industrial Revolution with concomitant revolution in agriculture, colonization for augmentation in productivity search for new resources caused unprecedented damage to nature both in scale and intensity. However, with industrialization a civilizational environmental crisis arose. This alarmed some writers and thinkers, who began to search for ways. Thus was born environmental movement. There was no environmentalism before industrialization; there were only the elements of environmental sensibility. There were tribes who pursed a species to extinction; there was a tribe who harvested its preys prudently so as not to deplete the pray population in the long run.
    [Show full text]
  • The House of Representatives Standing Committee on Social Policy and Legal Affairs 25 October 2019
    Inquiry into age verification for online wagering and online pornography The House of Representatives Standing Committee on Social Policy and Legal Affairs 25 October 2019 Dads4Kids Fatherhood Foundation Unit 1/33 Central Rd Unanderra NSW 2526 02 - 4272 6677 www.fatherhood.org.au 25 October 2019 Dear Committee Secretary and Committee Members, Enclosed is our submission in response to the Inquiry into age verification for online wagering and online pornography. This submission tries to address the terms laid out, with reference to Australia’s international Treaties & the need for Sexual Integrity. While we are in favour of age verification laws for both online wagering and pornography under 18 years of age, our submission enclosed principally addresses the issue of pornography. Our submission reflects the concerns of Fathers all over Australia. Dads4kids is a community of people who have a vision for a healthier Australia. We believe that children are precious and valuable, and it is in our best interests to provide a safe place for their healthy development and growth. Dads4Kids commenced in May 2002 and is a tax-deductible harm prevention charity. Dads4Kids helps children by promoting excellence in fathering. Excellent fathers are in word and deed: responsible, involved, protective, loving and committed to the well- being of their children and their children's mother. Mission: To equip, encourage and inspire fathers, strengthen and support families and engage with community, church, business and government to see our children thrive. Our submission deals with three main areas, Harms of Pornography, a short summary of our UN obligations and 16 Arguments for Sexual Integrity.
    [Show full text]