DOCSLIB.ORG

Dissertation, Santana (Final)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Dissertation, Santana (Final) 1 2 3 4 5 CIVILITY, ANONYMITY AND THE BREAKDOWN OF A NEW PUBLIC SPHERE 6 7 8 9 10 11 by 12 ARTHUR D. SANTANA 13 14 15 16 17 18 A DISSERTATION 19 Presented to the School of Journalism and Communication 20 and the Graduate School of the University of Oregon 21 in partial fulfillment of the requirements 22 for the degree of 23 Doctor of Philosophy 24 25 June 2012 26 DISSERTATION APPROVAL PAGE 1 Student: Arthur D. Santana 2 Title: Civility, Anonymity and the Breakdown of a New Public Sphere 3 This dissertation has been accepted and approved in partial fulfillment of the 4 requirements for the Doctor of Philosophy degree in the School of Journalism and 5 Communication by: 6 7 John Russial Chair 8 Pat Curtin Member 9 Scott Maier Member 10 David Vázquez Outside Member 11 12 and 13 14 Kimberly Andrews Espy Vice President for Research and Innovation/Dean 15 of the Graduate School 16 17 Original approval signatures are on file with the University of Oregon Graduate School 18 19 Degree awarded June 2012 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 ii 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 © 2012 Arthur D. Santana 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 iii DISSERTATION ABSTRACT 1 2 Arthur D. Santana 3 Doctor of Philosophy 4 School of Journalism and Communication 5 June 2012 6 Title: Civility, Anonymity and the Breakdown of a New Public Sphere 7 8 Reader comment forums of online newspapers, a relatively new feature of online 9 journalism, have been called spaces of public deliberation. At their inception among large 10 newspapers just five years ago, the forums were heralded as a new way for the public to 11 advance public dialogue by sharing opinions in an unconstrained way, promoting the 12 democratic principles of the newspaper institution itself. Rampant incivility, however, 13 has since become one the forums’ chief defining characteristics. By content analyzing 14 comments from online newspapers that allow anonymity, this research confirms 15 anecdotal evidence from journalists that Latinos are regularly debased in the forums by 16 commenters following news on immigration. This study also compares the civility of 17 anonymous comments following news on the Tea Party movement, a non-racialized but 18 also controversial topic. Finally, civility is measured in the comments following news on 19 immigration from online newspapers that have disallowed anonymity. In all, more than 20 22,000 comments from nearly 200 news stories in more than a dozen online newspapers 21 were collected between 2010 and 2012, and a sample of 1,350 was coded. The analysis 22 shows that online newspaper discussion boards that allow anonymity and that follow 23 iv news about immigration predominantly contain comments by those who support tough 1 immigration laws and who express themselves with emotionally laden, uncivil comments 2 directed at Latinos. Similar discussion boards that disallow anonymity predominantly 3 contain comments by those who support tough immigration laws and who express 4 themselves with emotionally laden yet civil comments directed at Latinos. Overall, this 5 research demonstrates that a racialized topic is apt to draw more uncivil anonymous 6 comments than a non-racialized one and that removing anonymity elevates the level of 7 dialogue. Building on the theories of the public sphere, reduced cues in anonymity and 8 critical race theory, this paper demonstrates that in their new role in creating a new public 9 square of open discussion, newspapers are sometimes creating forums for hate speech 10 while also publishing content that is perpetuating negative portrayals of Latinos. Findings 11 reveal that a new public sphere created by online newspapers, meant to promote 12 democracy, is actually having the opposite effect for some minority groups. 13 14 v CURRICULUM VITAE 1 2 3 NAME OF AUTHOR: Arthur D. Santana 4 5 6 GRADUATE AND UNDERGRADUATE SCHOOLS ATTENDED: 7 8 University of Oregon, Eugene 9 Columbia University, New York 10 University of Texas, Austin 11 12 13 DEGREES AWARDED: 14 15 Doctor of Philosophy, Communication and Society, University of Oregon 2012 16 Master of Science, Journalism, Columbia University 1996 17 Bachelor of Arts, English, University of Texas 1993 18 19 20 AREAS OF INTEREST: 21 22 Newspapers (print and online) 23 Online/participatory journalism 24 UGC (user-generated content) 25 Minorities in the media 26 27 28 PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE: 29 30 Assistant city editor, San Antonio Express-News 31 San Antonio, TX, May 2005 — April 2008 32 33 Reporter, The Washington Post 34 Washington, D.C., Dec. 1999 — April 2005 35 36 Reporter, The Seattle Times 37 Seattle, WA, Oct. 1996 — Nov. 1999 38 39 Reporter, The Washington Post 40 Washington, D.C., June 1996 — Sept. 1996 41 42 Reporter, San Antonio Express-News 43 San Antonio, TX, Aug. 1993 — Aug. 1995 44 45 46 vi GRANTS, AWARDS AND HONORS: 1 2 Research grant, AEJMC Newspaper and Online News Division, Aug. 2011 3 4 Lorry I. Lokey Journalism Scholarship, University of Oregon, June 2011 5 6 Top student paper, AEJMC Minorities and Communication Division; St. Louis, 7 Aug. 2011, for “Pushed to the Periphery: Incivility in Online Newspaper Readers’ 8 Comments” 9 10 Top student paper, AEJMC Newspaper and Online News Division; Denver, Aug. 11 2010, for “Conversation or Cacophony: Newspaper Reporters’ Attitudes Toward Online 12 Readers’ Comments” 13 14 Kappa Tau Alpha, University of Oregon, inducted April 2010 15 16 Columbia Scholarship, University of Oregon, 2009 – 2011 17 18 Promising Scholar Award, University of Oregon, Fall 2008 19 20 Maryland-Delaware-D.C. Press Association, for Public Service, for 2004 team 21 coverage about lead in drinking water series, The Washington Post 22 23 Finalist for 2002 Pulitzer Prize for Public Service for team coverage of the 9/11 24 terrorist attacks, The Washington Post 25 26 Society of Professional Journalists Pacific NW Excellence in Journalism, May 27 1999; Best of the West, long form feature writing, June 1999; National Association of 28 Hispanic Journalists Journalism Contest, print feature, July 1999 – for feature story 29 chronicling the path of a handgun, The Seattle Times, Feb. 1998 30 31 32 PUBLICATIONS: 33 34 Arthur D. Santana and John Russial, “Doing More with Less: How the Jobs of 35 Newspaper Photojournalists Have Changed,” Newspaper Research Journal 36 (forthcoming). 37 38 Arthur D. Santana, Randall M. Livingstone and Yoon Y. Cho, “Medium Matters: 39 Newsreaders' Recall and Engagement with Online and Print Newspapers,” Newspaper 40 Research Journal (forthcoming). 41 42 Arthur D. Santana, “The New Role of Bilingual Newspapers in Establishing and 43 Maintaining Social Group Identities among Latinos,” in Identity and Media: New 44 Agendas in Communication, eds. Dominic Lasorsa and America Rodriguez (New York, 45 NY: Routledge) (forthcoming). 46 47 vii Yoon Y. Cho, Arthur D. Santana and Randall M. Livingstone, “Advertising 1 Affinities: An Analysis of Reader Engagement Of Advertisements in Print and Online 2 News,” American Academy of Advertising Conference Proceedings 2012 (forthcoming). 3 4 Arthur D. Santana, “Online Readers’ Comments Represent New Opinion 5 Pipeline,” Newspaper Research Journal 32, no. 3 (2011). 6 7 John Russial and Arthur D. Santana, “Specialization Still Favored In Most 8 Newspaper Jobs,” Newspaper Research Journal 32, no. 3 (2011). 9 10 11 viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 1 2 I wish to thank my committee members, especially Dr. John Russial, and their 3 contributions to this project. This research was supported in part by grants from the 4 Newspaper and Online News Division of the Association for Education in Journalism and 5 Mass Communication as well as the University of Oregon School of Journalism and 6 Communication. 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 ix 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 For Tami, Nathaniel, Norah and Will 9 10 11 12 x TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 Chapter Page 2 3 I. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................1 4 Background ........................................................................................3 5 Focus of This Research ......................................................................6 6 Notes ..................................................................................................7 7 8 II. LITERATURE REVIEW ..........................................................................9 9 Public Sphere .....................................................................................9 10 Discursive Civility .............................................................................14 11 Making an Argument .........................................................................18 12 Anonymity .........................................................................................23 13 Media Portrayals of Immigration and Latinos ...................................26 14 Hypotheses and Research Questions .................................................34 15 Notes ..................................................................................................37 16 17 III. METHODS ..............................................................................................46 18 Part I — Anonymous Immigration ....................................................47 19 Part II — Anonymous Tea Party .......................................................51 20 Part III — Non-Anonymous Immigration .........................................54 21 Notes ..................................................................................................57 22 23 IV.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 5.A LUT Attachvac560
    1 IN THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 2 FOR WASHINGTON COUNTY, OREGON 3 In the Matter of the Removal of Dedication ) RESOLUTION AND ORDER of the Old St. Edwards Catholic Church ) No. 4 Cemetery in Section 1, T1N, R3W, W.M., ) VACATION NO. 560 Washington County, Oregon ) 5 6 The above entitled matter having come regularly before the Board at its meeting January 7 7, 2020; and 8 It appearing to the Board that Lone Oak Land & Investment Co., LLC, the property owner, 9 has filed a petition to remove the Old St. Edwards Catholic Church Cemetery from dedication for 10 cemetery purposes. Pursuant to ORS 97.440, a public hearing is required; and 11 It appearing to the Board that said property owner advised that no interments have been 12 made as stated in the attached vacation report; and 13 It appearing to the Board that notice was given by publication once a week for four 14 consecutive weeks in the Forest Grove News Times and in the Hillsboro Tribune (general 15 circulation), and for two consecutive weeks in The Oregonian (state-wide circulation) and by 16 posting copies of the notice in three conspicuous places on that portion of the property from 17 which the dedication is to be removed and similar notices of a public hearing were sent to 18 abutting property owners and to the Oregon Commission on Historic Cemeteries; and 19 It appearing to the Board that a public hearing was held and evidence was presented to 20 substantiate that no interments have been made in the property as described in the Vacation 21 Report attached hereto and incorporated
    [Show full text]
  • BOC Agenda 06-17-2008
    WASHINGTON COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS WORKSESSION ROOM 140 PUBLIC SERVICES CENTER JUNE 17, 2008 TENTATIVE 3:00 p.m. 1. Board of Commissioners Communication (15 min.) 3:15 p.m. 2. Discussion of Formal Agenda Items (30 min.) BCC AGENDA – 6/17/08 TABLE OF CONTENTS COMMISSIONER DISTRICTS 7 OTHER COUNTY AND CWS CONTACTS 7 MEETINGS AND SCHEDULES 8 Current Meeting Schedule 8 Regular Business Meetings 8 Worksessions 8 Second Tuesdays of the Month 8 Board Meetings When There is a Fifth Tuesday in a Month 8 Executive Sessions 8 Once the Regular Business Meeting Begins 9 Ordinance Testimony Time Limits 9 Alternatives to Televised Proceedings 9 Assistive Listening Devices 10 Sign Language and Interpreters 10 Meeting Protocol 10 Meeting Calendar 11 HOUSING AUTHORITY BOARD OF DIRECTORS 1. CONSENT AGENDA Approval of Minutes – May 6, 2008 13 a. Approve the Housing Authority Operating Budget for FY 2008-2009 15 b. Approve One Year Extension of Property Management Agreement 17 2. ORAL COMMUNICATION (2-Minute Opportunity) 3. ORAL COMMUNICATION (10-Minute Opportunity) 4. BOARD OF DIRECTORS ANNOUNCEMENTS 5. ADJOURNMENT CALL TO ORDER 1. CONSENT AGENDA The items on the Consent Agenda are considered routine and will all be adopted in one motion unless a Board member or person in the audience requests, before the vote on the motion, to have the item considered separately. If any item is removed from the Consent Agenda, the Chairman will indicate when it will be discussed in the regular agenda. A list of Consent Agenda items is included at the end of the agenda packet.
    [Show full text]
  • Hugh Mcgilvra Talk on Washington County Newspapers and Forest Grove History for the Tualatin Valley Historical Society
    Hugh McGilvra Talk on Washington County Newspapers and Forest Grove History for the Tualatin Valley Historical Society An audio recording of Hugh McGilvra, journalist and newspaper publisher in Forest Grove, giving a talk to the Tualatin Plains Historical Society on the occasion of his 50th anniversary of work. He talks about the newspaper history of Washington County for the first 25 minutes; the final 27 minutes are about his experiences working on the newspaper in Forest Grove and the community there. HM = Hugh McGilvra [00:00:00] [Recording begins mid-sentence] [HM]: ...practically everything in Forest Grove is that you don't know which is the egg and which is the chicken as far as Forest Grove and Pacific University are related. Historically, we know that they are intertwined and there has always been a relationship. I think as has been suggested by the introduction, that journalism in Washington County goes back to this date of about 1848. With a rather irregular publication of what was known as the Oregon American and the Evangelical Union, started in Tualatin Plains. Even if we ignore this rather odd publication as a real newspaper, there of course is still the Oregonian, which was actually started in Washington County, if you want to get your history straight. For a while, Multnomah County was not carved up into Washington and Clackamas County, until 4 years after the Oregonian made its [bow?] in 1850. This new county of Multnomah wasn't very highly -- was formed in spite of vigorous opposition of the Oregonian. Which regarded it as merely an opportunity for getting whatever the 1854 equivalent of the serving Democrats happened to be to get the opportunity for another office.
    [Show full text]
  • Gazette Editor: Lisa Amato Friend November 2014 ~ Contents ~ Letter from the President
    Special The Edition -ly Gazette Editor: Lisa Amato Friend November 2014 ~ Contents ~ Letter from the President Holiday Attention Everyone! Page 2 Page 3 Significance of Magic Moments September A September to Remember Corn Roast/Stenciled Quilt Project Page 5 Page 4 From the Secretary’s Desk(top) A.T. Smith Property Update Page 6 Recommended Blathering Time in Forest Grove Page 12 Reading Page 7 Voices Page 1 With 3 lled Fi ets re Willamina: St Mrs. Baber & the Road to Suffrage Page 8 War in Washington Friend Focus County Page 10 & 11 Page 14 ~ 1 ~ Letter From the President By Diane Morris, President The very next weekend was the annual Corn Roast. The FHFG booth featured a new project on that beautiful Saturday: a stenciled quilt. The group helped 39 children stencil muslin squares: apples and pears, pine cones and pumpkins, squirrels eptember to remember. Years and pigs, things that Alvin Smith S from now, when I have forgotten would have seen in his daily life back the hours of sweat and worry and on the West Tualatin Plains. The planning, those words will bring a project will continue this fall. smile, because this September was FHFG gave one more amazing gift to uniquely special. It conrmed what I the community September 28: the Holiday already knew about Forest Grove most wonderful home tour ever, with and about this organization, and the A.T. Smith house as the very last Attention Everyone! about people in general. stop. The day could not have been Mark your calendars now for a Sometimes we commit to more than more perfect.
    [Show full text]
  • Obits from the Old WA Co, OR Files
    Obituaries for Washington County, Oregon Hillsboro Argus, 23 Mar 1922 John F. Hart John F. Hart died at his home at 909 Fir Street, Hillsboro, March 20, 1922, aged 65 years. He was born at Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin, August 7, 1857 and is survived by his widow and the following children- Harley, Fred, John, Rollo Hart; Mrs. Vinna Martin, Mrs. Bessie Hazelton, Mrs. Lilow Hazelton and Miss Mirta Hart. The funeral took place from the Advent church on Baseline St. 10:30 a.m. yesterday, and interment was in the Odd Fellows cemetery, Glenn F. Bell directing. Shirley A. Pries Thursday, July 19, 2007 A gathering will be at noon Saturday, July 21, 2007, in the Hillsboro home of her daughter Starr Lara for Shirley A. Pries, who died July 15 at age 84. Shirley A. Winton was born March 22, 1923, in Duluth, Minnesota to Oakley and Gladis "Cullie" Winton. A homemaker, she lived most of her life in Onalaska, Wash., before moving to Cornelius in 1999. In 1976, she married Hans F Pries.; he died in 2001. Survivors include her sons Duane Pries .Delbert Winton and David Peterson. daughters, Sierra D Pries , Althea Kline , Starr Lara, Sherri Coffman, Dorothy Rualo and Debri Hazelip; grandchildren; and great-grandchildren. Her daughter Jamie Grisim died in 1971. Remembrances to the Bonnie Hayes Small Animal Shelter. Arrangements by Donelson Sewell & Mathews. Oregonian Friday July 17, 1891 - Forest Grove Times T. J. Wilson of Greenville, formerly county assessor for Washington County died on Monday last at the Good Samariton Hospital in Portland. Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • Fall/Winter 2014 Dates to Note
    fall/winter 2014 The new Oregon Newspaper Publishers board of directors was announced at the 2014 Summer Convention. They include: Dates to note President: Dave Baker, The Register-Guard, Eugene 1. ONPA will be moving our President-elect: Therese Bottomly,The Oregonian, Portland office to Lake Oswego at 4000 Treasurer: Christine Moore,The Times/Tigard, Sherwood Gazette Kruse Way Place, Building 2, Immediate Past President: Vance Tong, Portland Tribune Suite 160, Lake Oswego, OR Director: John Dillon, Argus Observer, Ontario 97035 on December 1. Director: Marissa Williams, Blue Mountain Eagle, John Day 2. Legislative Reception at the Director: Scott Olson, Springfield Times & Creswell Chronicle Salem Convention Center on Director: Scott Swanson, The New Era, Sweet Home January 13. Get your full page Director: Jeff Ackerman, The News-Review, Roseburg pdf files in ASAP. Director: Joe Petshow, Hood River News 3. 2015 convention will be July Director: Mike McInally, Corvallis Gazette 16 and 17. Location to be Educational Director: Julianne Newton, University of Oregon determined. The Oregon Newspaper Publishers Association held its annual convention at the Salem Convention Center July 17-18. Thursday was a full day of advertising training presented by Mike Blinder. The Thursday night awards banquet did not disappoint with several deserving awards going out to members in both the Associate Member Contest and the Better Newspaper Contest. Friday ONPA members attended the first gubernatorial debate of this election year as well as heard from AG Rosenblum. ONPA member websites had livestreams of the debate. 1 Oregon newspaper microfilming project The University of Oregon (UO) Libraries has been microfilming and preserving Oregon’s newspapers as a public service since the 1950s.
    [Show full text]
  • Eyes Turn to Oregon GOP Debate, Primary
    Friday, March 9, 2012 Hillsboro Argus Opinion A5 Opinion Editor: George Rede [email protected] Opinion A break from tradition An editorial page without an editorial? Sometimes it’s good to break the rules. When I became editor of the Argus Opinion page earlier this year, I wrote an unsigned editorial (Feb. 2) that expressed the hope we could cultivate a com- munity conversation in print and online. Today’s page reflects what I had in mind when I wrote: “We will continue to publish letters to the edi- tor, guest columns and keep a local, local, local focus on the issues addressed here. And we will endeavor to build on that, by embracing the view that the entire community benefits when we are exposed to a wide spectrum of perspectives and opinions — not just from elected officials and other community leaders, but from people who live and work and go to school here, whether they are new arrivals or people whose roots go back generations.” Scan the page and you’ll see what I mean. Along with an editorial cartoon and letter to the editor, we have guest columns from a familiar voice on Oregon poli- tics, Jayne Carroll, and a company representative, Dave Dutra, responding to ongoing concern about the odors coming from the recycling plant near North Plains. The roundup of additional commentary, excerpted below, gives you a taste of what you’ll find online. We appreciate those of you who are loyal readers of this page. We also are posting fresh content every day — letters, op-eds, reader polls and more — to engage with and grow our online audience.
    [Show full text]
  • Tualatin River Watershed Council West Fork Dairy Creek Restoration Project Completion Report OWEB Grant 207-306
    Tualatin River Watershed Council West Fork Dairy Creek Restoration Project Completion Report OWEB Grant 207-306 I. Narrative Description of the Project. Background on the problem which generated the project. In 2004, Oregon Parks and Recreation Department staff (OPRD) met with the Tualatin River Watershed Council (the Council) to work together to identify key watershed issues and limiting conditions and address these issues and limiting conditions within the L.L. ‘Stub’ Stewart State Park property which was being developed by OPRD. The 1,654- acre park includes the headwater and main stem of West Fork Dairy Creek and three tributaries, Brooke Creek, Williams Creek and Logging Creek. Using its Dairy-McKay Watershed Assessment (1999), the partners focused on these identified key watershed issues found on the park property: erosion control and water quality issues, due to sediment delivery into streams from stream crossings; aquatic species and habitat issues, due to degradation of habitat and water quality; stream channel issues, due to lack of large wood debris in streams that limit pool development; and migration barriers, due to fish passage barriers at stream crossings. During summer 2005, the Council and community volunteers and OPRD staff performed a culvert inventory and survey of all (over 30) culverts for fish passage barriers located within the park. With assistance from the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife (ODFW) stream restoration biologist, three culverts on the main stem and a tributary of West Fork Dairy Creek were prioritized for evaluation. In February 2006, the Council obtained an OWEB technical assistance grant for analysis, design, plans and specifications to replace one culvert, remove two culverts, and perform a stream survey on the stream reaches below and above the culverts (a 2.7 mile stream reach) that resulted in prioritization of stream reaches for and design of enhancement activities.
    [Show full text]
  • Most Jobs Found in Suburbia
    Swing city Glencoe golfers qualify for state tournament — See Sports, Page A18 FRIDAY, MAY 10, 2013 • THE HILLSBORO LEADER IN NEWS • WWW.HILLSBOROTRIBUNE.COM • VOL. 02, NO. 13 • FREE Tim Cannon wore a Hillsboro Police Most jobs found in suburbia Department uniform for County offi cials have been claim- includes Hillsboro and Beaverton, almost 14 Survey supports claims ing for years — that most new “Urban cores have gained where several large employers have years before of high Washington jobs are being created outside of population, but jobs have not either moved or announced major he was downtown Portland. expansions in recent years. Nike, for arrested at County job growth In fact, according to a study re- followed to the same degree.” example, plans to build two offi ce his Forest leased in April, overall employment — Elizabeth Kneebone, author of jobs study buildings on or near its World Head- Grove home By JIM REDDEN within three miles of downtown quarters campus just outside of Bea- in January. The Hillsboro Tribune Portland declined by 19,474 jobs be- verton. COURTESY PHOTO tween 2000 and 2010. Jobs within But overall employment 10 to 35 Before Nike’s decision was A new Brookings Institution three to 10 miles of downtown fell by miles away from the downtown core study confi rms what Washington 5,119. increased by nearly 2,963 jobs. That See JOBS / Page A13 Cannon fi les ■ Unusually warm weather contributes to May 4 success, vendors say shine light on struggles Jailed Hillsboro ex-cop was subject of internal police investigation By NANCY TOWNSLEY The Hillsboro Tribune Information contained in person- nel fi les released by the Hillsboro Po- lice Department last Saturday paints two very different pictures of ex-cop Tim Cannon.
    [Show full text]
  • No. 18-31052 in the UNITED STATES COURT of APPEALS
    Case: 18-31052 Document: 00514825779 Page: 1 Date Filed: 02/06/2019 No. 18-31052 IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT SHANDELL MARIE BRADLEY, Tutrix on behalf of her minor child A J W Plaintiff – Appellee, v. LOUIS ACKAL, Individually and in his official capacity; JUSTIN ORTIS, Individually and in his official capacity; XYZ DEPUTIES, Individually and in their official capacity; XYZ INSURANCE COMPANY, on behalf of Sheriff’s Office Iberia Parish, Defendants – Appellees v. CAPITAL CITY PRESS, L.L.C., doing business as The Advocate; KATC COMMUNICATIONS, L.L.C., Movants – Appellants. On Appeal from the United States District Court for the Western District of Louisiana, The Honorable Patrick Hanna, U.S. Magistrate Judge Case No. 6:15-cv-459 __________________________________ MOTION OF THE REPORTERS COMMITTEE FOR FREEDOM OF THE PRESS, THE JOSEPH L. BRECHNER CENTER FOR FREEDOM OF INFORMATION, AND 32 MEDIA ORGANIZATIONS FOR LEAVE TO FILE BRIEF AS AMICI CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF MOVANT- APPELLANTS SEEKING REVERSAL __________________________________ (COUNSEL LISTED ON INSIDE COVER) Case: 18-31052 Document: 00514825779 Page: 2 Date Filed: 02/06/2019 Frank LoMonte* Bruce D. Brown Linda Norbut* Counsel of Record THE JOSEPH L. BRECHNER CENTER Katie Townsend* FOR FREEDOM OF INFORMATION Caitlin Vogus* 1885 Stadium Rd. Lindsie Trego* 3208 Weimer Hall THE REPORTERS COMMITTEE FOR Gainesville, FL 32611 FREEDOM OF THE PRESS Telephone: (352) 392-2273 1156 15th St. NW, Suite 1020 [email protected] Washington, DC 20005 Telephone: (202) 795-9300 Facsimile: (202) 795-9310 [email protected] *Of counsel Case: 18-31052 Document: 00514825779 Page: 3 Date Filed: 02/06/2019 MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE BRIEF AS AMICI CURIAE Pursuant to Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 29(a)(3) and Fifth Circuit Rule 29, the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press (“The Reporters Committee”), The Joseph L.
    [Show full text]
  • Cooperative Public Agencies of Washington County Minutes for April 8, 2004 Members Present: Dan Boss City of Tualatin Cal Bowers
    Cooperative Public Agencies of Washington County Minutes for April 8, 2004 Members present: Dan Boss City of Tualatin Cal Bowersox City of Forest Grove Chris Bowles Clean Water Services (CWS) Colin Croas Hillsboro School District Mark Crowell City of Cornelius Mary Davis Washington County LUT Terry VanMeter Washington County LUT Lee Weislogel Tualatin Valley Water District Gaylie Cashman CPAWC Office Assistant (City of Tualatin) Members not present: Jerry Arnold West Slope Water District Dave Chrisman Tualatin Hills Park & Recreation Department (THPRD) Rich Girard Washington County LUT Dan Kearn City of Hillsboro Jaci Schlosser Beaverton School District Gary Hirsch Washington County LUT Dick Meinz Tualatin Hills Park & Recreation Department (THPRD) Raymond Mott Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) Scott Porter Director, OCEM Craig Sheldon City of Sherwood Debbie Vuylsteke Tualatin Valley Fire & Rescue (TVF&R) Rich Williams City of Gaston Dan opened the meeting at 10:00 AM. Lee brought an Oregonian article to share with members about Dan’s recent honor from the American Public Works Association. Members congratulated him for being selected by APWA for a national Top Ten Public Works Leaders Award and also for being selected by City of Tualatin’s Chamber of Commerce as the Business Person of 2003. Financial Report – Debbie was not present, but Mary distributed the most recent accounting with a balance of $4915. Dan said he would like to consider reducing the dues on occasion if the balance goes over the projected needs. Another suggestion was to consider providing some scholarships to those agencies whose budgets do not allow employees to attend the Fall Workshops.
    [Show full text]
  • Portland Observer Funeral Notices
    Portland Observer Funeral Notices Patronless and chuffy Arturo never uncanonise secretly when Istvan bug-outs his diet. Is Maxwell always bald-headed and underdeveloped when prescind some misalignment very perchance and besottedly? Crackling Ishmael douse that or trindled literatim when Randell is sharing. Find local spotlight includes obituaries, funeral notices and consistent member near bergen rlvage will health, oran burnett and community Oregon Online Historical Newspapers Summary Blog The. Godfrey earl russell said he seems that particular year and funeral notices for observers have made during a good luck in. The funeral directors and held on! View this funeral notices for portland observer and funerals to the paper is best achieved by browsing through some research tips. Governor tom will not on the notices for years! Ionia County MI Newspapers and Obituaries LDS Genealogy. He change over The Portland Observer in 1996 after here death of ray mother Joyce Washington The Washington family bought the weekly in 199. The portland news. Australian death notices funeral notices obituaries and funeral directors across Australia can deplete quickly and easily tip on Obitscomau. Us through saturday, and observer newspaper. BROOKMAN Shirley The Portland FC and past members of Riverside FC are. 503 2-0033 Phone 503 2-0015 Fax Advertising Request adsportlandobserver. All of curiosity and death by saving it has a later lament the! Browse Portland Oregon online obituaries funeral notices condolences tributes and death notices posted daily by Portland. Burial will accompany your trip right puppy listings, nh from ashland times vernon phillips. The Portland Observer March 31 2010 by Portland Observer.
    [Show full text]