DOCSLIB.ORG

Leading Doctors Argue Against Local Lockdowns

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Leading Doctors Argue Against Local Lockdowns NEWS BMJ: first published as 10.1136/bmj.m3959 on 13 October 2020. Downloaded from London Cite this as: BMJ 2020;371:m3959 Covid-19: Leading doctors argue against local lockdowns http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.m3959 Jacqui Wise Published: 13 October 2020 The UK government’s own scientific advisers and “It’s too late for test and trace to stop it. Things will other leading experts argued against a policy of just get worse.” increased restrictions in local areas to control the He wrote that local restrictions (rather than a full covid-19 pandemic, instead calling for a national national lockdown) risked increasing numbers of short period of lockdown or “circuit breaker,” cases and deaths, with possible exponential spread. documents show. “It also means we shall reach a new state of The newly released documents reveal that the ‘endemicity’ with repeated surges and falls until such Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies times as the virus has eaten its way through all recommended on 21 September that such an exposed and vulnerable people.” immediate circuit breaker was the best way to control He said a circuit breaker should stop transmission of cases.1 infection within and between communities and might Rumours about SAGE’s advice had been circulating also break the oscillation of surges and falls in for some weeks,2 but the minutes were officially infections. However, delaying a circuit breaker risked released only after the prime minister announced a an exponential increase in cases like that in March. new three tier system for England, with Liverpool “Without major reform of Find, Test, Trace, Isolate, facing the most stringent restrictions.3 Support (FTTIS) the UK will be back in trouble in two to three months,” he predicted. The SAGE documents also suggested: Costello said that the current test and trace system • Advising people to work from home if they can programme, “based on centralised, privatised and • Banning all contact within the home with members ineffective companies,” had “failed miserably.” He of other households called for Dido Harding, the current head of NHS Test and Trace, and England’s health secretary, Matt • Closure of all bars, restaurants, cafes, indoor Hancock, to be removed and an experienced minister gyms, and personal services, and such as Greg Clark or Jeremy Hunt and a strong public All university and college teaching to be online. health leader and independent public health team • http://www.bmj.com/ put in place to lead a test and trace programme. Of all the measures SAGE proposed, only one—advising people to work from home—was He called on the government to fund local test and implemented by the government at the time. trace systems, to be run through local district outbreak management teams that included local SAGE said, “The more rapidly interventions are put public health, virology, primary care, and local in place, and the more stringent they are, the faster authority leaders, backed by volunteers if necessary. the reduction in incidence and prevalence, and the The government must cover salaries in full of people greater the reduction in covid-related deaths (high asked to isolate, he said, and compliance with on 23 September 2021 by guest. Protected copyright. confidence). Both local and national measures are isolation should be monitored through calls, home needed; measures should not be applied in too visits, or an app, as in South Korea. specific a geographical area.” 1 Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies. SAGE 58 minutes: Coronavirus David Nabarro, World Health Organization special (COVID-19) response, 21 September 2020. 12 Oct 2020. envoy for covid-19, has separately appealed to https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/fifty-eighth-sage-meeting- on-covid-19-21-september-2020. government leaders: “Stop using lockdowns as a 2 Iacobucci G. Sixty seconds on . circuit break. BMJ 2020;370:m3686. primary means of controlling the virus. Develop better doi: 10.1136/bmj.m3686 pmid: 32958462 systems for doing it.” Speaking in an interview with 3 Iacobucci G. Covid-19: Three tier alert system takes effect across England. Spectator magazine he said, “The only way that BMJ 2020;371:m3961. lockdowns are justified is to buy you time to 4 Costello A. Twitter 11 Oct 2020. https://twitter.com/globalhlthtwit/sta- reorganise, regroup, rebalance your resources and tus/1315336234382827522. protect your healthcare workers.”4 5 Turner-Cohen A. Coronavirus: WHO backflips on virus stance by condemning lockdowns. 12 Oct 2020. https://www.news.com.au/world/coronavirus/glob- On 11 October Anthony Costello, professor of global al/coronavirus-who-backflips-on-virus-stance-by-condemning-lock- health and sustainable development at University downs/news-story/f2188f2aebff1b7b291b297731c3da74. College London and a member of the Independent SAGE group, wrote a long thread on Twitter arguing This article is made freely available for use in accordance with BMJ's website against local lockdowns and calling for a national terms and conditions for the duration of the covid-19 pandemic or until otherwise determined by BMJ. You may use, download and print the article for any lawful, circuit breaker together with immediate reform of the non-commercial purpose (including text and data mining) provided that all 5 test and trace system. copyright notices and trade marks are retained. “We’re in a mess. Cases, hospitalisations and deaths are rising,” wrote Costello, a former WHO director. the bmj | BMJ 2020;371:m3959 | doi: 10.1136/bmj.m3959 1.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 1 Andrew Marr Show, Jeremy Hunt, Mp
    1 ANDREW MARR SHOW, JEREMY HUNT, MP ANDREW MARR SHOW, 30TH JUNE, 2019 JEREMY HUNT, MP Foreign Secretary AM: Now the truth of the matter is, you know, you’re making a bit of progress but you’re still far, far behind Boris Johnson, and that’s partly down to your own use of language. Do you regret calling him a coward? JH: Well what I said is, “don’t be a coward,” because I think it’s a great shame. This is actually the last of your shows before many Conservative Party members will vote, because they’ll be getting their ballot papers in the next few days and he hasn’t been on here, he hasn’t been prepared to do head to head debates with me before people vote and I think people want a contest; I think that’s respectful to members and I think it will be much better for whoever’s Prime Minister to have that had contest first. So I think what we need is a bit of mojo from Bo-Jo. AM: Now you have also said he must be straight with people. Being straight is our motto here today. JH: I’m always straight on your show, Andrew. AM: Of course you are. In that spirit I want to ask about the Hunt spending splurge, because it seems like an awful lot of money. Corporation Tax, your proposals on Corporation Tax would cost about £13 billion, where would that come from? JH: Well we have about £26 billion of headroom at the moment, and this is a very – AM: I thought you’d say that.
    [Show full text]
  • Open PDF 273KB
    Foreign Affairs Committee Oral evidence: Global health security, HC 200 Tuesday 22 June 2021 Ordered by the House of Commons to be published on 22 June 2021. Watch the meeting Members present: Tom Tugendhat (Chair); Stewart Malcolm McDonald; Andrew Rosindell; Henry Smith; Royston Smith; Graham Stringer; Claudia Webbe. Questions 96-152 Witnesses I: Rt Hon. Jeremy Hunt MP, former Foreign Secretary and former Health Secretary. II: Niall Ferguson, historian and commentator. Examination of witness Witness: Rt Hon. Jeremy Hunt MP. Q96 Chair: Welcome to this afternoon’s session of the Foreign Affairs Committee. In a repeat of a few years ago, we have Jeremy Hunt, no longer the Foreign Secretary, before the Committee—I will call you Jeremy if that’s all right, because it would be weird not to. You are unusual in having held two of the great offices that specifically affect global health diplomacy: you were Health Secretary for nearly seven years and Foreign Secretary for nearly two years. Does the UK co- ordinate health and foreign policy well? Jeremy Hunt: I think we do it better than most other countries, but clearly not well enough. The big lesson of the last year is that we are going to have to raise our game massively. When I was Health Secretary, pandemic planning was left entirely to me and very rarely raised at Cabinet level or with the Cabinet Office. We did extensive preparations and planning, but we now know that we over-prepared for flu pandemics and under-prepared for SARS-like pandemics. We clearly did not get it all right.
    [Show full text]
  • House of Commons Thursday 12 July 2012 Votes and Proceedings
    No. 31 251 House of Commons Thursday 12 July 2012 Votes and Proceedings The House met at 10.30 am. PRAYERS. 1 Questions to the Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change 2 Urgent Question: Olympics security (Secretary Theresa May) 3 Statements: (1) Balance of competences (Secretary William Hague) (2) Business (Leader of the House) 4 Court of Justice of the European Union Resolved, That this House takes note of the draft Regulation 2011/0901A(COD) of the European Parliament and of the Council (amending the Protocol on the Statute of the Court of Justice of the European Union and Annex 1 thereto) and draft Regulation 2011/0902(COD) (relating to temporary Judges of the European Union Civil Service Tribunal) and, in accordance with section 10 of the European Union Act 2011, approves Her Majesty’s Government’s intention to support the adoption of draft Regulations 2011/0901A(COD) and 2011/0902(COD) of the European Parliament and of the Council.—(Mr David Lidington.) 5 Preparation of the 2013 European Union Budget Motion made and Question proposed, That this House takes note of an unnumbered Explanatory Memorandum dated 5 June 2012 from HM Treasury on the Statement of Estimates of the Commission for 2013 (Preparation of the 2013 Draft Budget); recalls the agreement at the October 2010 European Council and the Prime Minister’s letter of 18 December 2010 to European Commission President Manuel Barroso, which both note that it is essential that the European Union budget and the forthcoming Multi-Annual Financial Framework reflect the consolidation
    [Show full text]
  • Conservative Leadership Poll II
    State of Play Analysis Methodology v Two surveys each of n=2,400 eligible voters. v Max margin of error of +/-2.0 percent at a 95 percent confidence interval. v Respondents were residents of the 48 most marginal Conservative held seats in the UK. v 50 respondents were surveyed from each seat. v Minimum quotas set by age, gender, tenure, region, education, occupation, ethnicity and past vote. v Mixed modal online and CATI poll from 10th – 24th April conducted by IQR and Research Interactive. v Online poll from 1st – 9th May 2019 conducted by Research Interactive. © 2019 C|T Group 2 Analysis Groups v ALL VOTERS are all respondents in the survey and representative of the country as a whole. v SOFT VOTERS are undecided who they will vote for, or are likely to change their mind about their current voting intention. v CONSERVATIVE DEFECTORS voted Conservative in the 2017 General Election but would not vote Conservative if an election was held today. v LEAVE VOTERS are those who voted to Leave at the 2016 EU Referendum. v REMAIN VOTERS are those who voted to Remain at the 2016 EU Referendum. v CONSERVATIVE VOTERS are those who would vote Conservative if a General Election was held today. © 2019 C|T Group 3 Political Context National Issue Agenda (>4%) 49% TOTAL BREXIT 46% 65% 21% Brexit - not specified whether for or against 18% 23% 19% Brexit - pro 15% 43% 10% Brexit - against / 2nd referendum 3% 8% NHS 8% 3% 12% 8% Party or policy 6%8% 5% Political instability / current mess 4%6% 2% Other 2%2% 4% Nothing 4% 10% 3% Don't know 5% 9% Total Soft Voters Conservative Defectors Proportion from T1 © 2019 C|T Group Q) If a General Election was held today, what is the most important issue to you that would influence if and how you vote? That issue could be about the 5 parties, the candidates, or international, national or local issues.
    [Show full text]
  • 20210415 the Future of Liberal Democracies
    Transcript The Future of Liberal Democracies: In Conversation with Margot Wallström Margot Wallström Minister for Foreign Affairs (2014-19), Sweden The Rt Hon Jeremy Hunt Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs (2018-19), UK Chair: Dr Robin Niblett CMG Director and Chief Executive, Chatham House Event date: 15 April 2021 The views expressed in this document are the sole responsibility of the speaker(s) and participants, and do not necessarily reflect the view of Chatham House, its staff, associates or Council. Chatham House is independent and owes no allegiance to any government or to any political body. It does not take institutional positions on policy issues. This document is issued on the understanding that if any extract is used, the author(s)/speaker(s) and Chatham House should be credited, preferably with the date of the publication or details of the event. Where this document refers to or reports statements made by speakers at an event, every effort has been made to provide a fair representation of their views and opinions. The published text of speeches and presentations may differ from delivery. © The Royal Institute of International Affairs, 2021. 10 St James’s Square, London SW1Y 4LE T +44 (0)20 7957 5700 F +44 (0)20 7957 5710 www.chathamhouse.org Patron: Her Majesty The Queen Chair: Jim O’Neill Director: Dr Robin Niblett Charity Registration Number: 208223 2 The Future of Liberal Democracies: In Conversation with Margot Wallström Dr Robin Niblett CMG Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to this next in our Chatham House series on The Future of Liberal Democracies.
    [Show full text]
  • BIA Briefing on the Conservative Party Leadership Candidates
    BIA briefing on the Conservative Party leadership candidates June 2019 Contents The candidates...................................................................................................................................................... 2 The election process ............................................................................................................................................. 3 Biographies ........................................................................................................................................................... 4 Michael Gove ............................................................................................................................................ 4 Matt Hancock ........................................................................................................................................... 4 Mark Harper ............................................................................................................................................. 5 Jeremy Hunt ............................................................................................................................................ 6 Sajid Javid ................................................................................................................................................ 6 Boris Johnson .......................................................................................................................................... 7 Andrea Leadsom .....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • A Guide to the Government for BIA Members
    A guide to the Government for BIA members Correct as of 29 November 2018 This is a briefing for BIA members on the Government and key ministerial appointments for our sector. It has been updated to reflect the changes in the Cabinet following the resignations in the aftermath of the government’s proposed Brexit deal. The Conservative government does not have a parliamentary majority of MPs but has a confidence and supply deal with the Northern Irish Democratic Unionist Party (DUP). The DUP will support the government in key votes, such as on the Queen's Speech and Budgets. This gives the government a working majority of 13. Contents: Ministerial and policy maker positions in the new Government relevant to the life sciences sector .......................................................................................... 2 Ministerial brief for the Life Sciences.............................................................................................................................................................................................. 6 Theresa May’s team in Number 10 ................................................................................................................................................................................................. 7 Ministerial and policy maker positions in the new Government relevant to the life sciences sector* *Please note that this guide only covers ministers and responsibilities pertinent to the life sciences and will be updated as further roles and responsibilities are announced.
    [Show full text]
  • 6 Things We Learned from the Tory Leadership Debate
    6 things we learned from the Tory Leadership Debate By Bethan Tolley, Communications Officer at the Centre for Brexit Studies Five men, one job. Last night BBC One played host to their very first Tory Leadership Debate. ‘Our Next Prime Minister’ saw all five remaining contenders – Boris Johnson, Jeremy Hunt, Michael Gove, Sajid Javid and Rory Stewart – battle it out on live TV with a series of questions on various topics from the great British public. Here’s the six things we learned from the debate… Where do they really stand on Brexit? Of course, a huge amount of the debate was all about Brexit and if we really will be leaving on the 31st October. Boris Johnson stated on several occasions that the UK will absolutely leave the EU by the 31st October, because otherwise the Conservative party face a “catastrophic loss of confidence in politics.” On the other hand, Jeremy Hunt stated that he would have the UK leave the EU on that date if there was no option of another deal, however, if there was a prospect that we were nearly there, then I would take a bit longer.”. Michael Gove stated that as he started this (leave campaign) “I will finish it – I will make sure that we leave the European Union in good order”. However, he also agreed with Jeremy Hunt that he would extend if he needed to – but only by a couple of days. Sajid Javid stated that it is fundamental that we leave the EU by the 31st October: “We’ve got to learn from our mistakes.
    [Show full text]
  • Cabinet Committee Membership Lists
    Cabinet December Committee Membership 2014 Lists 1 Contents Coalition Committee ................................................................................................... 3 Devolution Committee ................................................................................................ 4 Economic Affairs Committee ...................................................................................... 5 Economic Affairs (Infrastructure) sub-Committee ................................................... 6 Economic Affairs (Reducing Regulation) sub-Committee ....................................... 7 European Affairs Committee ...................................................................................... 8 European Affairs sub-Committee ............................................................................ 9 Flooding Committee ................................................................................................. 10 Growth and Enterprise Committee ........................................................................... 11 Home Affairs Committee .......................................................................................... 12 Home Affairs (Armed Forces Covenant) sub-Committee ...................................... 14 Home Affairs (Greening Government Commitments) sub-Committee .................. 15 Local Growth Committee .......................................................................................... 16 Local Growth sub-Committee ..............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • In a Letter on Tuesday 21 July
    The Muslim Council of Britain PO Box 57330 London E1 2WJ Rt Hon Dominic Raab MP Secretary of State for Foreign & Commonwealth Affairs Foreign & Commonwealth Office King Charles Street London SW1A 2AH By email to: [email protected] 21 July 2020 Dear Foreign Secretary, I am writing on behalf of the Muslim Council of Britain, the UK’s largest representative body of Muslim organisations. In December 2018, I wrote to your predecessor, Jeremy Hunt, raising my grave concerns of the treatment of the Uighur Muslims, and the lack of response to our concerns from of His Excellency Ambassador Lui Xiaoming. Nineteen months later, it fills me with great sadness to be writing to you raising the same grave concerns, and without a response from the Chinese Ambassador. The situation in Xinjiang has not improved, and as you are well aware, the persecution of Muslims continues with the forced sterilisation of women and the detention without trial in concentration camps of over a million people. The actions of the Chinese Government against the Uighur Muslims has all the hallmarks of a genocidal atrocity, and I fear unless strong, substantive action is taken against the Chinese Government, we will be witnessing the total ethnic cleansing of the Uighur Muslims. This is deeply distressing to many Muslims across Britain, and indeed across the world. You and the Prime Minister have recently criticised the Chinese Government over its flagrant human rights abuses against the Uighur Muslims which has been very welcome, but I fear that without a tangible action plan to address the atrocities carried out by the Chinese Government, these abuses will not stop and more lives will be lost.
    [Show full text]
  • Liaison Committee Oral Evidence from the Prime Minister, HC 1144
    Liaison Committee Oral evidence from the Prime Minister, HC 1144 Wednesday 13 January 2021 Ordered by the House of Commons to be published on 13 January 2021. Watch the meeting Members present: Sir Bernard Jenkin (Chair); Hilary Benn; Mr Clive Betts; Sir William Cash; Yvette Cooper; Philip Dunne; Robert Halfon; Meg Hillier; Simon Hoare; Jeremy Hunt; Darren Jones; Catherine McKinnell; Caroline Nokes; Stephen Timms; Tom Tugendhat; Pete Wishart. Questions 1-103 Witness I: Rt Hon Boris Johnson MP, Prime Minister. Examination of witness Witness: Boris Johnson MP. Q1 Chair: I welcome everyone to this session of the Liaison Committee and thank the Prime Minister for joining us today. Prime Minister, we are doing our best to set a good example of compliance with the covid rules. Apart from you and me, everyone else is working from their own premises. This session is the December session that was held over until now, for your convenience, Prime Minister. I hope you can confirm that there will still be three 2021 sessions? The Prime Minister: I can indeed confirm that, Sir Bernard, and I look forward very much to further such sessions this year. Chair: The second part of today’s session will concentrate on the UK post Brexit, but we start with the Government’s response to covid. Jeremy Hunt. Q2 Jeremy Hunt: Prime Minister, thank you for joining us at such a very busy time. It is obviously horrific right now on the NHS frontline. I wondered if we could just start by you updating us on what the situation is now in our hospitals.
    [Show full text]
  • House of Commons Thursday 30 June 2011 Votes and Proceedings
    No. 179 1177 House of Commons Thursday 30 June 2011 Votes and Proceedings The House met at 10.30 am. PRAYERS. 1 Questions to (1) the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (2) the honourable Member representing the Church Commissioners 2 Ninetieth Birthday of His Royal Highness the Duke of Edinburgh The Speaker reported to the House, That the Members appointed on 8 June to wait upon His Royal Highness the Duke of Edinburgh with the Message of warmest good wishes upon the occasion of his ninetieth birthday had waited upon His Royal Highness; and That they had been graciously received by His Royal Highness, who had responded in these terms: My Lords and Members of the House of Commons I received your kind message of congratulations on my ninetieth birthday with the greatest pleasure. I have derived much satisfaction from the many years that I have been able to help and support The Queen. Few others, if any, have had the satisfaction of witnessing the affection and respect that so many people round the world have shown for The Queen since the beginning of her reign. I acknowledge that the position I have held has made it possible for me to support and encourage a great many valuable and worthwhile organisations in this country and further afield. It has been a particular pleasure to be associated with so many organisations that have encouraged the development of the younger generation in this country and in the wider world. 3 Speaker's Statement: Appointment of the Clerk of the House 4 Urgent Question: News Corporation’s
    [Show full text]