New Zealand's High Speed Research Network

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

New Zealand's High Speed Research Network Report prepared for the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment New Zealand’s high speed research network: at a critical juncture David Moore, Linda Tran, Michael Uddstrom (NIWA) and Dean Yarrall 05 December 2018 About Sapere Research Group Limited Sapere Research Group is one of the largest expert consulting firms in Australasia and a leader in provision of independent economic, forensic accounting and public policy services. Sapere provides independent expert testimony, strategic advisory services, data analytics and other advice to Australasia’s private sector corporate clients, major law firms, government agencies, and regulatory bodies. Wellington Auckland Level 9, 1 Willeston St Level 8, 203 Queen St PO Box 587 PO Box 2475 Wellington 6140 Auckland 1140 Ph: +64 4 915 7590 Ph: +64 9 909 5810 Fax: +64 4 915 7596 Fax: +64 9 909 5828 Sydney Canberra Melbourne Suite 18.02, Level 18, 135 GPO Box 252 Level 8, 90 Collins Street King St Canberra City ACT 2601 Melbourne VIC 3000 Sydney NSW 2000 Ph: +61 2 6267 2700 GPO Box 3179 GPO Box 220 Fax: +61 2 6267 2710 Melbourne VIC 3001 Sydney NSW 2001 Ph: +61 3 9005 1454 Ph: +61 2 9234 0200 Fax: +61 2 9234 0201 Fax: +61 2 9234 0201 For information on this report please contact: Name: David Moore Telephone: +64 4 915 5355 Mobile: +64 21 518 002 Email: [email protected] Page i Contents Executive summary ..................................................................................................... vii 1. Introduction ...................................................................................................... 1 2. NRENs are essential to research data exchange .............................................. 2 2.1 A long history of NRENs ....................................................................................... 2 2.1.1 Established prior to adoption of TCP/IP ............................................. 2 2.2 An NREN to reduce coordination and transaction costs ................................. 3 2.3 NREN services support data-intensive research and international collaboration ............................................................................................................. 6 2.4 A deliberately informal club ................................................................................... 7 3. REANNZ and e-Research in NZ ..................................................................... 8 3.1 An NREN to align with goals for science in New Zealand .............................. 8 3.2 Levels of service are generous................................................................................ 9 3.2.1 Added services such as Tuakiri essential ............................................... 9 3.2.2 Eduroam needs one node for NZ but that need not be REANNZ ................................................................................................. 10 3.3 Infrastructure is a mix of leased or bought ........................................................ 10 3.3.1 Infrastructure built around a ‘backbone’ ............................................. 10 3.3.2 A cornerstone investor in Hawaiki Cable ............................................ 11 3.3.3 Capacity within New Zealand is provided by Vocus ......................... 12 3.4 Unanimous support for an NREN ..................................................................... 12 3.4.1 International collaboration benefits seem real .................................... 13 4. REANNZ is in a precarious financial position .............................................. 15 4.1 Costs have risen and are forecast to continue to rise ....................................... 15 4.2 Revenue from the Crown and members is falling ............................................ 16 4.2.1 The possibility of a significant future liability ..................................... 17 4.3 Member engagement is low .................................................................................. 17 4.3.1 Transparency of costs and cost decisions lacking .............................. 18 4.3.2 Members question focus ........................................................................ 18 4.3.3 Governance arrangements lead some to feel like captive customers rather than members ........................................................... 18 4.3.4 Concerns of universities are ignored by REANNZ .......................... 18 4.3.5 Bundling of products causes friction ................................................... 19 4.4 Market evolution means the competition is cheaper and faster than 13 years ago ............................................................................................................. 19 5. Why we have not realised specialised connectivity benefits in New Zealand ............................................................................................................ 21 5.1 REANNZ supported through the Strategic Science Investment Fund ........ 21 5.2 REANNZ needs to be used more ...................................................................... 22 5.3 Market-specific problems are timing and maturation based ........................... 23 5.4 Internal network connectivity is the main barrier to research use ................. 23 Page iii 5.5 Asymmetry of use by members results in different value perceptions.......... 23 6. How does New Zealand compare to international NRENs? ......................... 25 6.1 What makes a successful NREN? ....................................................................... 25 6.1.1 DFN in Germany is self-funded due to economies of scale ............ 26 6.1.2 Internet2 in the US strongly supported by the government ............ 27 6.1.3 CANARIE in Canada is completely government-funded ................ 28 6.1.4 JANET in the United Kingdom has both funding and engagement ............................................................................................... 28 6.1.5 NORDUnet in Nordic countries aggregate at many levels .............. 29 6.1.6 AARNet in Australia and below-market fibre .................................... 29 6.2 A number of implications for REANNZ .......................................................... 30 6.2.1 Poor representation of members and users ........................................ 31 6.2.2 The cost of international connectivity ................................................. 32 6.2.3 A limited user base .................................................................................. 33 7. An options assessment framework .................................................................. 35 7.1 Assessment criteria must be strategic ................................................................. 35 7.1.1 Supports NZ’s data science initiatives ................................................. 35 7.1.2 A durable solution ................................................................................... 36 7.1.3 An affordable service to members ....................................................... 36 7.1.4 Enhanced member engagement ............................................................ 36 7.1.5 The Crown is not worse off .................................................................. 36 7.2 The status quo is not an option ........................................................................... 37 7.3 Options range from ‘do minimum’ to ‘devolution’ .......................................... 37 7.4 Our assessment....................................................................................................... 39 7.4.1 Reinforce research collaboration in every way possible .................... 52 7.4.2 Transparency means integrity of decision making ............................. 52 7.4.3 Cost cutting is essential and synergies are worth exploring.............. 52 7.4.4 Don’t try to change university incentives through REANNZ ........ 53 7.4.5 Option short list ...................................................................................... 53 Appendices Appendix 1 Researcher interviews and survey ............................................................................... 54 NZ researchers identify value but this value cannot be measured 54 Collaboration is key to value 54 Research is considered to be data intensive 55 Data intensity is expected to increase 55 Data intensive research needs specific network characteristics 56 REANNZ network characteristics and services are important 57 Others services of lesser value 59 Value not always apparent, and may be expressed through complementary investments 61 The major barrier to use; internal network connectivity 61 Appendix 2 Feedback from CIOs of member institutions ........................................................... 64 Underlying value differs between universities and Crown Research Institutes 64 Within-group differences drive perceptions of value for universities 65 Page iv More data-intensive universities and CRIs perceive greater value from REANNZ 65 Options workshop confirmed the problem definition 66 Commercial providers are unable to meet these users’ needs 66 Cost factors less important to these universities 67 Massey perceive value from cost-savings rather than research enablement 67 Costs and research needs drove former university members from REANNZ 68 Crown Research Institutes are heavily reliant on the network 69 A decentralised IT model provided by REANNZ membership allows CRIs to function 69 A cost effective solution, with ‘club’ member privileges 70 Other parties show the value proposition can teeter either way 71 TEC
Recommended publications
  • QUILT CIRCLE2020 a Letter from the President
    THE QUILT CIRCLE2020 A Letter From the President This 2020 Quilt Circle edition commemorates the 20th Anniversary of The Quilt. The fabric of our research and education (R&E) networking community has never been stronger. While our Quilt community has evolved in new and exciting ways in the past two decades, we have also been faced with a number of challenges which we take head-on and always with the spirit of collaboration. As we address the unprecedented challenges presented by the current global public health crisis due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the work of our members is more important than ever to the missions of their member communities. U.S. higher education institutions rely on R&E networks to give them a competitive edge in the most impactful scientific research initiatives which is essential in this crisis. We connect the educational institutions that support university medical centers and their associated hospitals. R&E networks also connect tens of thousands of other community anchor institutions, including K-12 schools, public libraries, local/state government, research sites, cultural institutions, public safety, and tribal lands. Being responsive and providing vital networking infrastructure and resources right now to address immediate needs is who we are and what we do. R&E networks are part of our nation’s critical infrastructure. This year’s edition of The Quilt Circle showcases several examples of the key role of R&E network members in both providing and facilitating the use-network infrastructure to further scientific discovery and collaborations at higher education institutions of all sizes.
    [Show full text]
  • Innovation Ecosystem
    Central Alberta Alberta Real Estate Regional Innovation Wood Buffalo Alberta Biodiversity Regional (CATAPULT) Alberta Industrial Foundation Network for Southern Regional Innovation Monitoring Miistakis Institute Municipality of Heartland Association Tri-region (Spruce Alberta Network Canadian Association Canadian Institute Wood Buffalo Edmonton Grove, Stony Plain, Grande Prairie Edmonton Regional of Petroleum Producers Renewable Fuels County of (TEC Edmonton, Startup Innovation Network Resource BC Bioenergy Alberta Land Parkland County) (Spark!) East Central Alberta Grande Prairie Association Wetaskiwin Municipal District Edmonton, NABI, NAIT) East MEGlobal Industries Suppliers Association Land Trust Stewardship Regional Innovation Regional Innovation Petroleum Services Association Alberta Centre Pembina Institute of Greenview Central Central Alberta Alliance Calgary Network Network Petroleum Association of Bioenergy Regional Innovation Concordia Technology Alliance Canadian Lumber St. Paul Town of Sundre University Athabasca NOVA Chemicals Canada BioAlberta Producers Waterton Biosphere Athabasca County Southern Alberta Network Canada Standards Association Alberta Land Medicine Hat University Reserve Association City of Red Deer (TecConnect) Southeast Alberta Transalta Institute (APEX) Canadian (WBRA) City of Edmonton Calgary Regional Regional Innovation MacEwan Enerplus BioTalent University University of Sundre Clean Power Innovation Network University Canada ENVIRONMENTAL Sturgeon County Red Deer County of Alberta Lethbridge Petroleum
    [Show full text]
  • Aarnet Australia's Academic and Research Network
    aarnet Australia's Academic and Research Network IPv6 network day 1. Agenda The previous two days training have investigated the IPv6 protocol and its configuration on Cisco Systems© IOS. Today this knowledge is put to use to construct a test network. 2. Test network 2.1 Topology The test network is a sample university network. ISP Border Firewall Core Switch Figure 1. Sample university network. To save time we will not configure a firewall, but will configure the network as if an OSPFv3-speaking firewall is in place. 2.2 Addressing Each sample university is allocated an address range. From that you must develop an addressing plan which includes: 2.2.1 Host subnet addresses These will be EUI-64 subnets. In a real network these addresses would be allocated in blocks which can be aggregated at each site edge. Our sample network is too small for this. 2.2.2 Link addresses for router-router links These will be /64 subnets. ::1 is used for the upstream, ::2 for the downstream. Router addresses are often replicated throughout router Ð 1 Ð configurations, so using a /64 is more maintainable than the dynamic interface addresses of EUI-64. 2.2.3 Control and administrative addresses for routers Most networking equipment assigns the router an interface in the control plane. Cisco IOS typically uses ªLoopback0º. This is a /128 address. Some routers treat higher addresses as administrative domain addresses by default, so reserve the highest /64 for loopback addresses. The DNS entry for control plane addresses usually contains the name of the router.
    [Show full text]
  • AUSTRALIAN NATIONAL PEERING POLICY Guidelines for Potential National Peering Partners
    AUSTRALIAN NATIONAL PEERING POLICY Guidelines for potential national peering partners LAST UPDATED SEPTEMBER 2021 aarnet.edu.au CONTENTS 1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................................ 3 2. Interconnection Requirements ....................................................................................................... 4 Bilateral Peering. ...................................................................................................................................................4 Geographic Scope. ..............................................................................................................................................4 Traffic Exchange Ratio. ........................................................................................................................................4 Traffic Exchange Volume. ...................................................................................................................................4 Backbone Capacity. .............................................................................................................................................4 Dedicated peering. ...............................................................................................................................................4 Access to the AARNet Mirror. ............................................................................................................................4
    [Show full text]
  • Remote Research Basics Quick Reference Guide Remote Research Basics Quick Reference Guide
    Remote Research Basics Quick Reference Guide Remote Research Basics Quick Reference Guide An introduction to networks and data movement for researchers with little to no technical knowledge. This guide includes simple tests and tools that you can use when working from home. All content is publicly available under the Creative Commons Attribution License https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ About AARNet AARNet is a not-for-profit organisation owned by Australian universities and research institutions. We provide high speed network for universities to connect researchers. We also provide cloud storage, known as CloudStor, and other network services. More information: www.aarnet.edu.au Networks and connections NBN vs ADSL The main difference for the consumer between the NBN and ADSL is speed. There are various options for speed, depending on requirements. This video helps explain: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=31&v=L3QJLEbUj94 Learn more about what is available via the NBN: https://www.nbnco.com.au/learn/speed https://www.nbnco.com.au/learn/speed/understanding-speed-and-data NREN The Australian National Research Network (NREN) operated by AARNet provides advanced research network infrastructure. It is fast, with connections from 10 Gbps to 40 and 100 Gbps. Learn more: https://www.aarnet.edu.au/network-and-services/advanced-network-services Don’t forget eduroam! eduroam is a secure global roaming wireless network for the research and education sector. In Australia eduroam is operated by AARNet. Lean more: https://www.eduroam.edu.au/ aarnet.edu.au 1 Remote Research Basics Quick Reference Guide How fast is fast? Speed test You can test the speed of your connection by using an app or a website.
    [Show full text]
  • Connecting People and Technology Positioning Alberta at the Forefront CONTENTS of Technological CONVERSATION with the PRESIDENT & CEO 4 Innovation
    connecting people and technology Positioning Alberta at the forefront CONTENTS of technological CONVERSATION WITH THE PRESIDENT & CEO 4 innovation. CONNECT 6 ENABLE 8 SHARE 10 ADVOCATE 12 SECURE 14 THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS 16 CYBERA MEMBER ORGANIZATIONS 17 A YEAR IN FLUX 21 FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 22 My first year as President and CEO of Cybera has certainly been disruptive, providing CONVERSATION both challenging and exciting opportunities! By now, everyone in Alberta is feeling the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. Combined with existing budget restrictions, WITH THE this has been one of the most difficult times ever faced by the province’s public and education sectors. I’m pleased to see the spirit of collaboration and community rise to the fore, as Alberta’s schools, post-secondary institutions, libraries, government PRESIDENT & CEO agencies, and start-ups have come together to support each other through this period. As this annual review will show, Cybera has been playing its part to facilitate these collaborations, both through offering shared services that increase efficiencies and lower costs, and through bringing groups together to exchange ideas. We now serve a wider community than ever before, having surpassed the 100-member mark this past year. Today, nearly 850,000 Albertans utilize the services Cybera provides, which created over $11 million in net savings for the public and education sectors this past year. Mindful of the important role we play in maintaining — and improving access to — digital infrastructure for such a large group, we took some time this past year to review our mission and strategy. We wanted to ensure our mandate and actions match the changing needs and priorities of our member community.
    [Show full text]
  • The People Who Invented the Internet Source: Wikipedia's History of the Internet
    The People Who Invented the Internet Source: Wikipedia's History of the Internet PDF generated using the open source mwlib toolkit. See http://code.pediapress.com/ for more information. PDF generated at: Sat, 22 Sep 2012 02:49:54 UTC Contents Articles History of the Internet 1 Barry Appelman 26 Paul Baran 28 Vint Cerf 33 Danny Cohen (engineer) 41 David D. Clark 44 Steve Crocker 45 Donald Davies 47 Douglas Engelbart 49 Charles M. Herzfeld 56 Internet Engineering Task Force 58 Bob Kahn 61 Peter T. Kirstein 65 Leonard Kleinrock 66 John Klensin 70 J. C. R. Licklider 71 Jon Postel 77 Louis Pouzin 80 Lawrence Roberts (scientist) 81 John Romkey 84 Ivan Sutherland 85 Robert Taylor (computer scientist) 89 Ray Tomlinson 92 Oleg Vishnepolsky 94 Phil Zimmermann 96 References Article Sources and Contributors 99 Image Sources, Licenses and Contributors 102 Article Licenses License 103 History of the Internet 1 History of the Internet The history of the Internet began with the development of electronic computers in the 1950s. This began with point-to-point communication between mainframe computers and terminals, expanded to point-to-point connections between computers and then early research into packet switching. Packet switched networks such as ARPANET, Mark I at NPL in the UK, CYCLADES, Merit Network, Tymnet, and Telenet, were developed in the late 1960s and early 1970s using a variety of protocols. The ARPANET in particular led to the development of protocols for internetworking, where multiple separate networks could be joined together into a network of networks. In 1982 the Internet Protocol Suite (TCP/IP) was standardized and the concept of a world-wide network of fully interconnected TCP/IP networks called the Internet was introduced.
    [Show full text]
  • DATA / FASTER Head Office Aarnet Pty Ltd Level 2, Building 1 3 Richardson Place North Ryde NSW 2113
    ANNUAL REPORT 2016 DATA / FASTER Head Office AARNet Pty Ltd Level 2, Building 1 3 Richardson Place North Ryde NSW 2113 GPO Box 1559 Canberra ACT 2601 ABN 54 084 540 518 T: +61 2 6222 3530 F: +61 2 6222 3535 [email protected] aarnet.edu.au © AARNet 2017 2 AARNET ANNUAL REPORT 2016 CONTENTS CONTENTS ABOUT US 4 32 SPOTLIGHT Who we are 4 32 Australian regional data hub for Copernicus data Network maps 6 34 A dedicated radio astronomy research network Message from the Chairman 10 36 Future network technologies Message from the CEO 12 40 Global access to world’s largest life sciences data collections Highlights by numbers 14 42 Big data analytics for the Koala Genome project needs a big network 44 eduroam in schools takes off THE YEAR IN REVIEW 16 46 Smart data access for next-gen climate modelling research Delivering Australia’s research and education network 16 FINANCIALS AND REPORTING Growing the research and education community 19 49 Building services capability 22 Our team 26 Corporate governance 30 2 AARNET ANNUAL REPORT 2016 AARNET ANNUAL REPORT 2016 3 We pride ourselves on being future focused and providing what commercial operators are unequipped or unable to provide: an ultra high speed network that pushes the boundaries of networking technology whilst delivering cost- WHO WE ARE effective and sustainable infrastructure for AARNet is a national resource, a national research Australia. The research and education community and education network, run by AARNet Pty Ltd, a relies on AARNet for outstanding service availability not-for-profit company owned by 38 Australian universities and CSIRO.
    [Show full text]
  • Cybera White Paper: Impact of COVID-19 on Rural Internet in Alberta, and Necessary Next Steps
    Cybera White Paper: Impact of COVID-19 On Rural Internet In Alberta, And Necessary Next Steps Cybera Inc. Calgary Office: Suite 200, 3512 - 33 St NW, Calgary, AB T2L 2A6 T: 403-210-5333 Edmonton Office: Suite 1101, 10065 Jasper Avenue NW, Edmonton, AB T5J 3B1 cybera.ca | [email protected] | @cybera ​ ​ ​ ​ Abstract In response to the growing COVID-19 pandemic, on March 16, 2020, the Government of Alberta ordered the immediate cancellation of on-site classes at schools and universities in the province. Today, 741,802 K-12 students and 194,010 post-secondary students in Alberta are learning from home, and will likely continue to do so until at least the end of current school semesters.1 2 A significant portion of the internet bandwidth used by these students (and their instructors) has now migrated from SuperNet and CyberaNet (which supply much of the internet connections to Alberta’s educational institutions), to private internet plans on residential networks. Overall, global internet traffic increased 56% in March, and has remained at above-average levels since.3 In this white paper, we will outline the scope of the problem in Alberta based on data from Cybera’s member base and the Research and Education Network usage statistics, as well as outreach conducted by Cybera with our K-12 and post-secondary community members, and Alberta’s rural internet service providers. This white paper will demonstrate that a significant portion of the province’s population are vulnerable to unaffordable overage charges and intermittent disconnections of service. We believe all levels of government must act now to mitigate the financial and social harms to Albertans.
    [Show full text]
  • Ipv6 Tunneling Ipv6 Host Ipv4/V6
    Business Service Management for Performance I’m Running IPv6: How Do I Access??? Share Session 12150 Laura Knapp WW Business Consultant [email protected] 01/15/2013 © Applied Expert Systems, Inc. 2013 1 Business Service Management for Performance What is IPv6 Updated version of the Internet Protocol (IPv4) Defined in RFC 1752 New features Larger address space Encapsulation Class of service for audio, video, etc. Multicast support Authentication Encryption Automatic configuration/reconfiguration Support for non-IP protocols 01/15/2013 © Applied Expert Systems, Inc. 2013 2 Business Service Management for Performance IPv6 Technology Scope IP Service IPv4 Solution IPv6 Solution 32-bit, Network Addressing Range 128-bit, Multiple Address Translation Scopes Serverless, Auto configuration DHCP Reconfiguration, DHCP Security IPSec IPSec Mandated, works End-to-End Mobile IP with Direct Mobility Mobile IP Routing Differentiated Service, Differentiated Service, Quality-of-Service Integrated Service Integrated Service IP Multicast IGMP/PIM/Multicast MLD/PIM/Multicast BGP BGP,Scope Identifier 01/15/2013 © Applied Expert Systems, Inc. 2013 3 Business Service Management for Performance IPv6 Transition Paths – ISP Focus 01/15/2013 © Applied Expert Systems, Inc. 2013 4 Business Service Management for Performance IPv6 in the Enterprise 01/15/2013 © Applied Expert Systems, Inc. 2013 5 Business Service Management for Performance Types of IPv6 Node Types IPv4 only node – a node running only IPv4 IPv6/IPv4 node – a node running dual stack IPv6 only node – a node running only IPv6 IPv6 node – node running IPv6 and it may also run IPv4 IPv4 node – node running IPv4 and it may also run IPv6 01/15/2013 © Applied Expert Systems, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • Australia's National Research and Education Network
    Published on Telsoc (https://telsoc.org) Home > Australia's national research and education network Australia's national research and education network Liz Fell [1] Freelance communications journalist TJA - Vol 62, No 5 - November 2012 [2] [3] 36 [4] Abstract Chris Hancock was appointed in 2004 as chief executive officer of AARNet, Australia?s Academic Research Network that brought the first Internet connection to the nation in 1989. The not-for-profit AARNet Pty Ltd now manages the Australian Research and Education Network (AREN) providing high capacity infrastructure and services to research, education, training, cultural and scientific institutions. Hancock's previous experience spans senior management positions in the telecommunications sector including as managing director, Optus Wholesale and Optus Data & Business Services (1998-2004); and executive positions at Vodafone Australia, Seven Network and Sarah Lee Corporation. He holds a Bachelor of Arts (Social Science) degree from Charles Sturt University and a Master of Business Administration (Executive) from the Australian Graduate School of Management. His board positions include as a director of the Institute for a Broadband-Enabled Society (IBES), the Smart Services Cooperative Research Centre, and AARNet Pty Ltd. Freelance communications journalist, Liz Fell, spoke with Hancock for the TJA in mid-October at AARNet headquarters in Binary House, North Ryde, Sydney. 1 Introduction Chris Hancock was appointed in 2004 as chief executive officer of AARNet, Australia's Academic Research Network that brought the first Internet connection to the nation in 1989. The not-for- profit AARNet Pty Ltd now manages the Australian Research and Education Network (AREN) providing high capacity infrastructure and services to research, education, training, cultural and scientific institutions.
    [Show full text]
  • 2011-2012 Stakeholder Recap Contents
    2011-2012 Stakeholder Recap Contents Message from the Executive 2 Mission and Vision 7 Year in Review 8 Usage and Storage Graphs 12 Researcher Profiles 16 Staff and Committees 23 Financials 25 Partners 26 Contact Us 27 2 Message from the Executive A Year in Review: Building On Strengths And Supporting New Research Projects With winter at our doorstep and a new year on the horizon, we felt it was an appropriate time to reflect on some of the milestones from 2012 and to acknowledge the individuals, teams, and research community involved in contributing to the success of the organization. We have noted in past Annual Reports how High Performance Computing (HPC) has become more prevalent within various public and private sectors. We’ve seen this driven in part by the fact that data is now constantly being collected by everything from orbiting satellites in space to environmental monitoring devices in the field to smartphones in the palms of our hand. Within the academic world, the possibilities for data collection across nearly every spectrum of research has uncovered new needs, increased demands, and exciting opportunities for HPC in a range of traditional and non- traditional discipline areas. At WestGrid, we see evidence of this growth through each increase in the number of proposals submitted to Compute Canada - Calcul Canada’s annual Resource Allocation call. Looking towards 2013, we will continue to engage new users across all disciplines and work with Compute Canada and the other regional HPC divisions to ensure the national HPC platform meets the evolving needs of our user community.
    [Show full text]