Arxiv:1903.09087V3 [Physics.Optics] 3 Apr 2019 C
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Electromagnetic Chirality 1, 2 Christophe Caloz ¤ and Ari Sihvola 1Polytechnique Montréal, Montréal, QC H3T-1J4, Canada 2Aalto University, Espoo, FI-00076, Finland This paper presents a first-principle and global perspective of electromagnetic chirality. It follows for this purpose a bottom-up construction, from the description of chiral particles or metaparticles (microscopic scale), through the electromagnetic theory of chiral media (macroscopic scale), to the establishment ad- vanced properties and design principles of chiral materials and metamaterials. It preliminarily highlights the three fundamental concepts related to chirality – mirror asymmetry, polarization rotation and magne- todielectric coupling – and points out the nontrivial interdependencies existing between them. The first part (chiral particles) presents metamaterial as the most promising technology for chirality, compares two rep- resentative particles involving magnetoelectric coupling, namely the planar Omega particle and the twisted Omega or helix particle, and shows that only the latter is chiral, and finally links the response of microscopic particles to that of the medium formed by arranging them according to a subwavelength lattice structure. The second part (electromagnetic theory) infers from the previous microscopic study the chiral constitutive relations as a subset of the most general bianisotropic relations, derives parity conditions for the chiral pa- rameters, computes the chiral eigenstates as circularly polarized waves, and finally shows that the circular birefringence of these states leads to polarization rotation. The third part (properties and design) introduces an explicit formulation of chirality based on spatial frequency dispersion or nonlocality, analyzes the tempo- ral frequency dispersion or nonlocality of chiral media, and finally provides guidelines to design a practical chiral metamaterial. CONTENTS C. Opposite Propagation Direction 14 D. Modal Isotropy and Eigenstate Perpective 15 I. Introduction 2 X. Polarization Rotation or Gyrotropy 15 II. Preliminary Comment: the Chiral Trinity 3 XI. Spatial Dispersion (or Spatial Nonlocality) 16 III. Global Assumptions 3 A. Definition and Identification 16 B. Spatial-Spectral Constitutive Relations 17 IV. Metamaterial Implementation 4 C. Application to the Omega Particles 18 A. Motivation and Definition 4 B. Dimensional Constraints 4 XII. Temporal Dispersion (or Temporal Nonlocality) 19 C. Metaparticle Selection 5 A. Lorentz Response 19 D. Metaparticle Polarizabilities 5 B. Metamaterial Resonance and Plasma Frequencies 19 V. Two Metaparticle Study Cases 6 C. Parametric Study 20 A. Mirror-Symmetry Test 6 B. Volume Necessary (but Insufficient) XIII. Design Guidelines 20 Condition 6 XIV. Conclusions 21 C. Planar Omega Particle (Achiral) 7 D. Twisted Omega or Helix Particle (Chiral) 8 Acknowledgment 23 VI. Microscopic-to-Macroscopic Scales Conversion 10 References 23 VII. Constitutive Relations 10 Appendices 25 A. General Bianisotropic Relations 10 B. Biisotropic Chiral Media 11 A. Units of the Polarizabilities and of the Constitutive arXiv:1903.09087v3 [physics.optics] 3 Apr 2019 C. Generalized Biisotropic Media 12 Parameters 25 D. Loss 13 B. Signs of the Imaginary Parts of the Chiral VIII. Parity Conditions 13 Constitutive Parameters in the Lossy Case 25 IX. Chiral Eigenstates 14 C. Derivation of the Chiral Eigenstates 25 A. Modal Solutions 14 B. Circular Polarization 14 D. Bianisotropic Spatial Nonlocality 26 E. Parameter Extraction Formulas 27 ¤ [email protected] 2 I. INTRODUCTION The term chirality comes from the Greek word χε´ιρ, which means hand. It is the geometric property according to which an object is mirror asymmetric or, equivalently, dif- ferent from its image in a mirror, irrespectively to orienta- tion. The etymology and definition of chirality may be un- derstood by considering Fig. 1. The (mirror-plane) image of the right (resp. left) hand is not superimposable with the right (resp. left) hand itself, but rather with the left (resp. right) hand. So, the human hands are chiral [sic], (a) (b) with right or left handedness, and the right and left hands are called the enantiomers (from the Greek, εναντι´ : oppo- FIG. 2. Chirality in a generic amino acid (–NH2: amine, –COOH: site, &ερ´ o&: other) of each other. The fact that hands are cer- caboxyl, –R: rest of the molecule). (a) Left-handed (LH) enan- tiomer: with thumb along the C H axis, it takes the left hand tainly the most common chiral things that we deal with on ! for the fingers to point from COOH to NH through R. (b) Right- a daily basis justifies the etymology. However, many other 2 handed (RH) enantiomer: with thumb along the C H axis, it takes things are chiral, such as amino-acids – see Fig. 2 – and ! the right hand for the fingers to point from COOH to NH2 through tris(bipyridine)ruthenium(II) chloride (red crystalline salt) R. (Picture: Wikimedia Commons) in chemistry, DNA and sugars in biochemistry, sea snails and ammonite fossils in biology, screws and helical anten- nas in engineering, and fusilli pasta and twisted pastry in shortly later [2], and it was explained by Fresnel in terms of food! circular birefringence in 1821-22 [3]. It was further stud- ied by Pasteur in salts of solutions of racemic mixtures of tartrates near the middle of the XIXth century [4]. In 1898, Bose reported the first microwave observation of chiral po- RH-i larization rotation, in twisted jute (fiber produced by some LH-i plants) structures [5], and, about twenty years later, Lind- man introduced wire spirals as more practical artificial chi- ral particles [6]. In the course of the XXth century, it has been established that optical activity results from coupling between the electric and magnetic responses, or magneto- electric coupling, of chiral particles, and different related RH-o form of electromagnetic constitutive relations have been LH-o proposed [7–11]. Towards the end of the century appeared the first textbooks on chiral and biisotropic media [12, 13]. Until the turn of the current century, chiral media had been mostly restricted to theoretical electromagnetic stud- ies [12–14]. The advent of modern metamaterials (e.g. [15]) and, even more, metasurfaces (e.g. [16]) has dramatically changed the situation, and chiral media, along with their FIG. 1. Human hands and their reflection in a mirror. RH-o and bianisotropic extension [14], have now become a practical LH-o are the original right hand (RH) and left hand (LH), while RH- reality that is poised to revolutionize microwave, terahertz i and LH-i are their images in the mirror, with the correspondence and photonics technologies. RH-o LH-i and LH-o RH-i. The non-superimposability may be Chirality involves a number of concepts that are some- $ $ specifically understood as follows. RH-i is finger-to-finger aligned times misunderstood and confused. These concepts in- with RH-o, but it shows its palm whereas RH-o shows its back. clude Pasteur and Tellegen biisotropy [13], biisotropy Flipping RH-i brings about back-to-back translational symmetry, and bianisotropy [14], circular birefringence and circular but loses finger-to-finger symmetry. So, RH-i and RH-o are fun- dichroism [17], reciprocal and nonreciprocal polarization damentally different, irrespectively to their orientation in space. rotation [18], temporal and spatial electromagnetic sym- The same naturally applies to the pair (LH-o,LH-i). (Photograph: Raphaël Caloz) metry [19], and temporal and spatial dispersion or nonlo- cality [19, 20]. This paper presents a global, intuitive and yet rigorous, first-principle perspective of chiral media and A medium made of chiral molecules or particles is called metamaterials that is intended to dissipate misunderstand- a chiral medium. Such a medium has the remarkable prop- ings and confusions, and hence help further research in the erty of rotating the polarization of electromagnetic waves field. propagating through it. This phenomenon of polarization The rest of the paper is organized as follows. After making rotation, also called optical activity, was first observed more a global comment on the three fundamental aspects of chi- than 200 years ago with light passing through ‘translucent’ rality – mirror asymmetry, polarization rotation and mag- substances by Arago in 1811 [1] and through quartz by Biot netodielectric coupling – and their interrelations in Sec. II, 3 and setting global assumptions in Sec. III, the document fol- lows a bottom-up development in three main parts. The first part, composed of Secs. IV to VI, deals with the micro- Mirror scopic, particle aspect of chirality; specifically, it presents Asymmetry metamaterial technology as the most promising approach to electromagnetic chirality (Sec. IV), analyses two repre- sentative metaparticles involving magnetoelectric coupling – the achiral planar Omega particle and the volume-twisted ➊ Omega or helix particle (Sec. V) – and links the micro- ➁ ➂ scopic metaparticle response to the macroscopic response of the corresponding metamaterial (Sec. VI). The second part, composed of Secs. VII to IX, covers the electromag- CHIRALITY netic theory of chiral media; specifically, it infers from the ➃ ➄ previous microscopic study the chiral constitutive relations as a subset of the bianisotropic relations (Sec. VII), derives parity conditions for the chiral parameters (Sec. VIII), com- Polarization ➅ Magneto- putes the chiral eigenstates as circularly-polarized waves Rotation ➆ Electric (Sec. IX), and finally shows that the circular birefringence