Marcellus Shale Safe Drilling Initiative Study
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MARCELLUS SHALE SAFE DRILLING INITIATIVE STUDY PART III FINAL REPORT FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS December 19, 2014 Prepared By: Maryland Department of the Environment Maryland Department of Natural Resources Prepared For: Martin O’Malley, Governor State of Maryland Thomas V. Mike Miller, Jr., Senate President Maryland General Assembly Michael E. Busch, House Speaker Maryland General Assembly Prepared pursuant to Executive Order 01.01.2011.11 Table of Contents Table of Contents ........................................................................................................................................... i Tables ............................................................................................................................................................ ii Figures .......................................................................................................................................................... iii Executive Summary ................................................................................................................................... 1 Section I: The Initiative ............................................................................................................................. 3 Section II: Marcellus Shale Gas Development .......................................................................................... 5 A. Shale Gas in Maryland................................................................................................................... 5 B. Unconventional Gas Development and Production ..................................................................... 7 C. Laws and Regulations Affecting Shale Gas Development ............................................................. 8 Section III: Work under the Initiative ...................................................................................................... 10 A. Presentations and Briefings ........................................................................................................ 10 B. Studies by Contractors ................................................................................................................ 11 C. Studies by MDE and DNR ............................................................................................................ 12 D. The Reports ................................................................................................................................. 13 Section IV: Principal Issues: Discussion and Findings.............................................................................. 17 A. Air Pollution ................................................................................................................................ 17 B. Methane Migration ..................................................................................................................... 25 C. Noise ........................................................................................................................................... 27 D. Soil Contamination, Groundwater Contamination and Surface Water Contamination ............. 30 E. NORM and TENORM ................................................................................................................... 34 F. Use and Disclosure of Chemicals ................................................................................................ 37 G. Use of Fresh Water ..................................................................................................................... 47 H. Greenhouse Gas Emissions ......................................................................................................... 49 I. Impacts on Habitat and Natural Resources ................................................................................ 52 J. Impacts of Traffic ........................................................................................................................ 55 K. Community Impacts .................................................................................................................... 59 L. Industrialization of Landscape .................................................................................................... 62 M. Influx of Workers......................................................................................................................... 67 N. Availability of Housing................................................................................................................. 68 O. Economic Impact: Gas Production .............................................................................................. 69 i P. Economic Impact: Property Values ............................................................................................. 74 Q. Economic impact: Tourism .......................................................................................................... 75 R. Emergency Response Capacity ................................................................................................... 77 S. Health Infrastructure Capacity .................................................................................................... 79 T. Health Surveillance ..................................................................................................................... 82 U. Waste and Wastewater Disposal ................................................................................................ 83 Section V: Information Gaps ................................................................................................................... 86 Section VI: Conclusions and Recommendations ..................................................................................... 88 References .............................................................................................................................................. 91 Appendix A: Members of the Advisory Commission .............................................................................. 97 Appendix B: Comments and Concerns .................................................................................................... 98 Appendix C: Best Practices .................................................................................................................... 100 Tables Table 1. Sampling efforts. ........................................................................................................................... 19 Table 2. Hazard quotients calculated by McKenzie et al. ........................................................................... 21 Table 3. Typical Sound Reductions. ............................................................................................................ 28 Table 4. Maryland Maximum Allowable Noise Levels ................................................................................ 28 Table 5. Noise levels at distances ............................................................................................................... 29 Table 6. Setbacks ......................................................................................................................................... 29 Table 7. Chemicals commonly used in hydraulic fracturing ....................................................................... 44 Table 8. EPA noise levels for heavy trucks .................................................................................................. 56 Table 9. Maryland maximum sound levels for heavy trucks ...................................................................... 57 Table 10. Land Use in Allegany and Garrett Counties................................................................................. 65 Table 11. Well and Well Pad Development Activity for Scenarios 1 and 2................................................. 65 Table 12. Economic and Fiscal Impacts for Allegany County – Scenario 1, 25% extraction ....................... 69 Table 13. Economic and Fiscal Impacts for Allegany County – Scenario 2, 75% Extraction ....................... 70 Table 14. Economic and Fiscal Impacts for Garrett County – Scenario 1, 25% Extraction ......................... 70 Table 15. Economic and Fiscal Impacts for Garrett County – Scenario 2, 75% Extraction ......................... 70 Table 16. Estimated Royalty Payments Made by Firms Extracting Gas in Allegany County ....................... 71 Table 17. Estimated Royalty Payments Made by Firms Extracting Gas in Garrett County ......................... 71 Table 18. Annual occupational fatality rate ................................................................................................ 80 Table 19. Annual nonfatal injuries rate....................................................................................................... 80 Table 20. Numbers of jobs in peak year ..................................................................................................... 80 Table 21. Number of fatalities in peak year ................................................................................................ 81 Table 22. Number of nonfatal injuries in peak year ................................................................................... 81 ii Figures Figure 1. Locations of the Marcellus Shale and Utica Shale ......................................................................... 5 Figure 2. Additional oil and gas basins in the Eastern United States ...........................................................