Planning Committee
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TO:- Planning Committee Councillor Brian Cox , Councillor Matt Ewart , Councillor Jeff Ashley , Councillor Meg Barrow , Councillor Len Bates , Councillor Joyce Bolton , Councillor Barry Bond , Councillor Mary Bond , Councillor Anthony Bourke , Councillor Nigel Caine , Councillor Val Chapman , Councillor David Clifft J.P , Councillor Bob Cope , Councillor Brian Edwards MBE , Councillor Lisa Emery , Councillor Paul Fieldhouse , Councillor Isabel Ford , Councillor Rita Heseltine , Councillor Lin Hingley , Councillor Alan Hinton , Councillor Steve Hollis , Councillor Diane Holmes , Councillor Keith James , Councillor Janet Johnson , Councillor Michael Lawrence , Councillor Roger Lees J.P. , Councillor Peter Lever , Councillor Henryk Lobuczek , Councillor Dave Lockley , Councillor Robert Marshall , Councillor Terry Mason , Councillor Robert McCardle , Councillor John Michell , Councillor Roy Moreton , Councillor Kath Perry , Councillor Ray Perry , Councillor Christine Raven , Councillor John Raven , Councillor Robert Reade , Councillor Wendy Sutton , Councillor Ken Upton , Councillor Bernard Williams , Councillor David Williams , Councillor Henry Williams , Councillor Kath Williams , Councillor Reg Williams , Councillor Roy Wright Notice is hereby given that a meeting of the Planning Committee will be held as detailed below for the purpose of transacting the business set out below. Date: Tuesday, 18 April 2017 Time: 18:30 Venue: Council Chamber Council Offices, Wolverhampton Road, Codsall, South Staffordshire, WV8 1PX D. Heywood Chief Executive A G E N D A Part I – Public Session 1 Minutes 3 - 6 To confirm the Minutes of the meeting of the Planning Committee held on 21 March 2017 2 Apologies To receive any apologies for non-attendance. 3 Declarations of Interest To receive any declarations of interest. 4 Determination of Planning Applications - April 2017 7 - 108 Report of Director of Planning and Strategic Services Page 1 of 108 RECORDING Please note that this meeting will be recorded. PUBLIC SPEAKING Please note: Any members of the public wishing to speak must confirm their intention to speak in writing or e-mail to Development Management no later than 1 working day before the Committee i.e. before 12.00 p.m. on the preceding Monday. E-mails to [email protected] Please see Speaking at Planning Committee leaflet on the website for full details. Failure to notify the Council of your intention to speak may mean you will not be allowed to speak at Committee. Page 2 of 108 24 March 2017 Minutes of the meeting of the Planning Committee South Staffordshire Council held in the Council Chamber Council Offices, Wolverhampton Road, Codsall, South Staffordshire, WV8 1PX on Tuesday, 21 March 2017 at 18:30 Present:- Councillor Jeff Ashley (Member), Councillor Meg Barrow (Member), Councillor Len Bates (Member), Councillor Joyce Bolton (Member), Councillor Barry Bond (Member), Councillor Mary Bond (Member), Councillor Anthony Bourke (Member), Councillor Nigel Caine (Member), Councillor Val Chapman (Member), Councillor David Clifft (Member), Councillor Bob Cope (Member), Councillor Brian Cox (Chairman), Councillor Brian Edwards (Member), Councillor Matt Ewart (Vice Chairman), Councillor Paul Fieldhouse (Member), Councillor Isabel Ford (Member), Councillor Rita Heseltine (Member), Councillor Lin Hingley (Member), Councillor Alan Hinton (Member), Councillor Steve Hollis (Member), Councillor Diane Holmes (Member), Councillor Keith James (Member), Councillor Janet Johnson (Member), Councillor Michael Lawrence (Member), Councillor Roger Lees (Member), Councillor Peter Lever (Member), Councillor Henryk Lobuczek (Member), Councillor Dave Lockley (Member), Councillor Robert Marshall (Member), Councillor Terry Mason (Member), Councillor Robert McCardle (Member), Councillor John Michell (Member), Councillor Roy Moreton (Member), Councillor Kath Perry (Member), Councillor Ray Perry (Member), Councillor Christine Raven (Member), Councillor John Raven (Member), Councillor Robert Reade (Member), Councillor Wendy Sutton (Member), Councillor Ken Upton (Member), Councillor Bernard Williams (Member), Councillor David Williams (Member), Councillor Henry Williams (Member), Councillor Kath Williams (Member), Councillor Reg Williams (Member), Councillor Roy Wright (Member) OFFICERS IN ATTENDANCE David Pattison, Andeep Gill, Lucy Duffy, Andrew Johnson and Phil Spruce ( County Highways) 52 MINUTES RESOLVED: that the minutes of the meeting of the Planning Committee held on the 28 February 2017 be approved and signed by the Chairman 53 APOLOGIES There no apologies for non attendance 54 DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST Councillor D Clifft declared a non pecuniary interest in planning application 16/00487/OUT as his son worked for the applicant and left the room for consideration of this item Councillors N Caine and V Chapman declared a non pecuniary interest in planning application 16/01069/COU as members of Codsall Parish Council and they left the room for consideration of this item Councillors R Marshall and J Michell declared a non pecuniary interest in planning application 16/01069/COU as members of Codsall Parish Council Page 3 of 108 24 March 2017 and they left the room for consideration of this item after they had spoken as ward members Councillor M Ewart declared a non pecuniary interest in planning application 16/01069/COU as his wife was a member of Codsall Parish Council and he left the room for consideration of this item after he had spoken 55 DETERMINATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS The Committee received and took into account the report of the Director of Planning and Strategic Services, together with the information and details received after the agenda was prepared (copy attached to the minutes) and took into account the representations of the speakers at Committee 16/00793/FUL – YEW TREE COMPANY, YEW TREE FARM, POTTAL POOL ROAD, PENKRIDGE, ST19 5RN – APPLICANT- MR ROGER TAYLOR – PARISH – ACTON TRUSSELL, BEDNALL AND TEDDESLEY HAY (DEFERRED) RESOLVED: that the application be approved as recommended 16/01069/COU – LAND ON THE WEST SIDE OF OAKEN LAKES, CODSALL – APPLICANT – MRS MAXINE BAKER – PARISH – CODSALL Dr M Ewart spoke against the application. Mr Brian Holland spoke on behalf of Codsall Parish Council, for the application. Councillors R Marshall and J Michell spoke for the application. Councillor Fieldhouse motioned for approval but with the removal of the condition 3. This motion was not carried. Councillor B Edwards motioned that the application be considered in line with officers recommendations, this was seconded by Councillor R Wright. RESOLVED: that the application be approved as recommended 16/01118/FUL – FORRESTERS LODGE STABLES, BRIDGENORTH ROAD, STOURTON, DY7 5BQ – APPLICANT- MISS ELIZABETH FORRESTER – PARISH – KINVER Councillor Cox motioned for the deferral of the application RESOLVED: that determination of the application be deferred pending the enforcement investigation 16/01130/FUL – PARK STABLES, MICKLEWOOD LANE, PENKRIDGE ST19 5SD – APPLICANT – MRS P PITT – PARISH – PENKRIDGE RESOLVED: that the application be approved as recommended 17/00055/FUL – HELBSY HOUSE, IVESTSEY BANK ROAD, BISHOPS WOOD, ST19 9AE – APPLICANT MR M WRIGHT – PARISH – WHEATON Page 4 of 108 24 March 2017 ASTON, BISHOPSWOOD AND LAPLEY RESOLVED: that the application be refused as recommended 17/00092/FUL – HIGHDOWN NURSERY, SUGARLOAF LANE, IVERLEY, STOURBRIDGE, DY10 3AP – APPLICANT – AMP ENERGY SERVICES LTD - PARISH – KINVER Mr J Burke spoke for the application RESOLVED: that the application be approved as recommended 17/00112/VAR – ELECTRICITY SUB STATION, SWINDON ROAD, HINKSFORD – APPLICANT – PRIME ENERGY DEVELOPMENT LTD – PARISH –SWINDON RESOLVED: that the application be approved as recommended 56 DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT QUARTER 3 REPORT - PLANNING COMMITTEE ACTION PLAN 2016/2017 RESOLVED : that the Committee note the performance in Quarter 3 of the Action Plan 2016-17 (copy attached to the minutes) 57 REPORT FOR URGENT ACTION 16/00487/OUT - Hobnock Road, Essington This urgent action report is brought to the Committee of 21st March 2017 as important business with the approval of the Chairman of Planning Committee, in accordance with the Council’s Constitution Part 4 Section 1 Rule 24 (c), in order to avoid the application being refused automatically which without Committee approval would need to happen RESOLVED: that 1.Proposed recommendation (extension of time): If the Section 106 Agreement is not completed by 16/05/17, then refuse the application on grounds of affordable housing, open space and education contribution 2.Delegate APPROVAL to the Team Leader of Major Applications and Appeals to issue the decision on completion of a satisfactory Section 106 agreement. Should this not be completed by 16th May 2017, the application will be refused The Meeting ended at: 19:50 CHAIRMAN Page 5 of 108 Page 6 of 108 SOUTH STAFFORDSHIRE COUNCIL PLANNING COMMITTEE – 18 APRIL 2017 DETERMINATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS REPORT OF DIRECTOR OF PLANNING AND STRATEGIC SERVICES PART A – SUMMARY REPORT 1. SUMMARY OF PROPOSALS To determine the planning applications as set out in the attached Appendix. 2. RECOMMENDATIONS 2.1 That the planning applications be determined. 3. SUMMARY IMPACT ASSESSMENT Do these proposals contribute to specific Council Plan objectives? The reasons for the recommendation for each application Yes POLICY/COMMUNITY addresses issued pertaining to the Council’s Plan. IMPACT Has an Equality Impact Assessment (EqIA) been completed? Determination