Wesleyan Theological Journal Publication of the Wesleyan Theological Society WESLEY’S THEOLOGY AS METHODIST PRACTICE: POSTMODERN RETRIEVAL of the WESLEYAN TRADITION
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Wesleyan Theological Journal Publication of the Wesleyan Theological Society WESLEY’S THEOLOGY AS METHODIST PRACTICE: POSTMODERN RETRIEVAL OF THE WESLEYAN TRADITION .. 7 John W. Wright READING THEORY AND BIBLICAL INTERPRETATION .............. 32 Thomas E. Phillips THE RELEVANCE OF WESLEYAN EVANGELISM IN A POSTMODERN CULTURE John Tyson ............................................................................... 49 JOHN WESLEY’S CRITICAL APPROPRIATION OF TRADITION IN HIS PRACTICAL THEOLOGY ................................ 69 Kenneth J. Collins THE PRACTICAL WAY OF HOLINESS: ISAIAH OF SCETIS AND JOHN WESLEY ...................................... 91 John Chryssavgis THE ENTHUSIASM OF THE REV. JOHN WESLEY ......................... 114 Mathias J. Kürschner THE RADICAL UNITED BRETHREN SECESSION OF 1889: GERMAN-AMERICAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE SEARCH FOR AMERICAN EVANGELICALISM .................... 138 J. Steven O’Malley AMERICAN METHODIST SOCIAL GOSPEL: THE PUBLIC/PRIVATE SPLIT REVISITED .................................... 159 Christopher H. Evans CHRISTIAN PERFECTION AMONG NINETEENTH-CENTURY AFRICAN-AMERICAN PREACHING WOMEN ............................... 179 Keith A. Chism FREE METHODIST MISSION IN SOUTH AFRICA, 1891-1960: SOCIAL CONFORMITY OR PROPHETIC CHALLENGE? ............. 194 Sarah Elizabeth Johnson IN HONOR OF DELBERT AND SUSAN (SCHULTZ) ROSE .......... 231 BOOK AWARD: DOUGLAS STRONG, PERFECTIONIST POLITICS ........................................................... 235 BOOK REVIEWS ............................................................................. 237 ADVERTISING ................................................................................. 257 Volume 35, Number 2 Fall, 2000 The Journal of the WESLEYAN THEOLOGICAL SOCIETY A Fellowship of Wesleyan-Holiness Scholars Editor and Chair of the Editorial Committee: Barry L. Callen, 1993 to present All communications concerning editorial matters should be addressed to the Editor, Barry L. Callen, c/o Anderson Univer - sity, 1100 East 5th Street, Anderson, Indiana 46012. Commu - nication about book reviews is to be directed to the Book Review Editor, David Bundy, c/o Christian Theological Semi - nary, 1000 West 42nd Street, P.O. Box 8867, Indianapolis, Indiana 46208. Membership dues and other financial matters should be addressed to the Secretary-Treasurer, William Kostlevy, c/o Asbury Theological Seminary, Wilmore, Ken - tucky 40390. Rate and application form are found at the end of this issue. E-mail addresses for all officers of the Society are also found at the end of this issue. Publication Address: Wesleyan Theological Society, P. O. Box 144, Wilmore, Kentucky 40390. WESLEYAN THEOLOGICAL SOCIETY (Organized 1965) The Society’s mission is to encourage the exchange of ideas among Wesleyan-Holiness theologians; to develop a source of papers for CHP (Christian Holiness Partnership) seminars; to stimulate scholarship among younger theologians and pastors; and to publish a scholarly journal. WESLEYAN THEOLOGICAL JOURNAL ############# Published by the Wesleyan Theological Society P. O. Box 144 Wilmore, Kentucky 40390 © Copyright 2000 by the Wesleyan Theological Society ISSN-0092-4245 This periodical is indexed in the ATLA Religion Database, published by the American Theological Library Association, 250 S. Wacker Dr., 16th Flr., Chicago, IL 60606, E-mail: [email protected], WWW: http://www.atla.com/. Available on-line through BRS (Bibliographic Retrieval Series), Latham, New York, and DIALOG, Palo Alto, California. Available in Microform from University Microfilms International, 300 North Zeek Road, Dept. I.R., Ann Arbor, Michigan 48106. Other than the most recent issues, the journal is available electronically at this online address: http://wesley.nnc.edu WTS on the Web: www.holiness.org/WTS.htm Views expressed by writers are not necessarily those of the Wesleyan Theological Society, the Editor, or the Editorial Committee. Printed by Old Paths Tract Society Shoals, Indiana 47581 CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS NUMBER ARTICLE WRITERS: Keith A. Chism Defiance College, Defiance, Ohio Kenneth J. Collins Asbury Theological Seminary, Wilmore, Kentucky John Chryssavgis Holy Cross Greek Orthodox School of Theology, Brookline, Massachusetts Christopher H. Evans Colgate Rochester Divinity School, Rochester, New York Sarah Elizabeth Johnson Seattle Pacific University, Seattle, Washington Mathias J. K ürschner University of T übingen, Germany J. Steven O’Malley Asbury Theological Seminary, Wilmore, Kentucky Thomas E. Phillips Eastern Nazarene College, Quincy, Massachusetts John Tyson Methodist College, Fayetteville, North Carolina John W. Wright Point Loma Nazarene University, San Diego, California BOOK REVIEWERS AND TRIBUTE WRITER: David Bundy, Barry L. Callen, Henry H. Knight, William C. Kostlevy, Randy L. Maddox, R. David Rightmire, Henry W. Spaulding — 3— EDITOR’S NOTES This Fall 2000 issue carries a wide range of materials. The first three articles by John W. Wright, Thomas E. Phillips, and John Tyson explore aspects of Christian faith in dialogue with postmodernism. The next two, by Kenneth Collins and John Chryssavgis, address John Wesley’s appropriation of tradition, especially the Eastern tradition of Christian faith and practice. The remaining five articles range among subjects from the United Brethren, United Methodist, and Free Methodist contexts and include consideration of African-American preaching women in the nineteenth-century Holiness movement. In the pivotal 2000 year, an intellectual biography of Clark H. Pinnock, Journey Toward Renewal , was written by Barry L. Callen and published by Evangel Publishing House in cooperation with the Wesleyan Theological Society. Included here is a book review and ad on this project. The year 2000 also saw the Society select its first volume to be honored with the Society’s Smith-Wynkoop Book Award . See the ad by Syracuse University Press highlighting the significant book Perfectionist Politics by Douglas Strong. Further, in 2000 the Society choose to honor Delbert R. and Susan A. (Schultz) Rose with the Society’s Lifetime Achievement Award . The tribute to them, delivered by William Kostlevy at the annual meeting of the Society in March, 2000, is included in this issue. Special thanks goes to David Bundy who oversees the development of book reviews. He ensures consideration of key publications that address many aspects of the history, theology, and practice of the Wes - leyan/Holiness tradition—including a global emphasis on this tradition, represented in this issue by a significant study of the Korean Holiness Church and the English origins of the Salvation Army. I commend the following material for your careful consideration. Contained in this Wesleyan/Holiness tradition are memories, traditions, and prophetic biblical and theological insights that are well-suited for nurturing the church’s life in a new century and millennium. Barry L. Callen, Editor October 2000 — 5— WESLEY’S THEOLOGY AS METHODIST PRACTICE: TOWARD THE POST-MODERN RETRIEVAL OF THE WESLEYAN TRADITION by John W. Wright Recent readings of John Wesley as a theologian have accurately characterized him as a “practical theologian.” 1 For Wesley, theology was not an endeavor to articulate clear and distinct doctrinal propositions nor principles to which one could intellectually assent and thus be identified as “Wesleyan.” Theology, for Wesley, was practical, advocating certain linguistic patterns necessary to sustain practices that formed holy believ - ers in order to keep the church faithful to God. As noted by Randy Mad - dox, not only is this seen particularly in the content of Wesley’s theology, but it is also apparent in the types of documents that Wesley produced. He published sermons, liturgies and prayers, hymns, conference notes, occa - sional essays, medical handbooks, among others. 2 Wesley stands in a the - ological tradition that reaches back into early Christianity when bishops articulated the theology of the church as a crucial aspect of the day-by- day ecclesial care of their congregations. While Wesley’s understanding of theology relates to the theological task as often pursued in early Christianity, it nonetheless stands outside 1See, for instance, Thomas Langford, Practical Divinity: Theology in the Wesleyan Tradition (Nashville: Abingdon, Press, 1983); Randy Maddox, “John Wesley—Practical Theologian?” Wesleyan Theological Journal 23 (1988), 122- 47; Randy Maddox, Responsible Grace: John Wesley’s Practical Theology (Nashville: Kingswood Books, 1994), especially 16-25. 2See Maddox, “John Wesley.” — 7— WRIGHT the mainstream of nineteenth and twentieth-century theology. Nineteenth and twentieth-century theology has largely pursued the related concerns of systematic and apologetic theology. Systematics has tended to see Christian doctrine as an abstract system of thought built on the universal foundation of Scripture or experience. 3 Theology becomes the task of developing the correct method in order to build a coherent, rational super - structure on this universal foundation. One may then discover the implica - tions and interconnections between the various realms of Christian beliefs. In its preoccupation with foundations and theological methodology, this systematic genre relates closely to modern theology’s apologetic con - cern. In modernity, however, the apologetic concern or rational defense of the Christian faith to outsiders has largely followed the route of translat - ing Christian language and concepts into language already accessible to the intellectual