Chapman Law Review Volume 22 Board of Editors 2018–2019 Executive Board Editor-in-Chief AMY N. HUDACK Managing Editor HOPE C. BLAIN Senior Articles Editors Production Editor CARLOS BACIO DANTE P. LOGIE JAMIE L. RICE JAMIE L. TRAXLER Senior Notes & Comments Editor MEGAN A. LEE Senior Symposium Editor KYLEY S. CHELWICK Senior Submissions & Online Editor NICHOLE N. MOVASSAGHI ±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±±± Articles Editors RAYMOND AUBELE MARLENA R. MLYNARSKA GEORGE E. BRIETIGAM BRANDON R. SALVATIERRA DRAKE A. MIRSCH HANNAH B. STETSON KATHERINE A. BURGESS SYDNEY L. WEST __________________________________________________________________ Staff Editors MICHAEL D. BENVENUTI JILLIAN C. FRIESS ALEXIS SAKARIS REBEKAH E. COOPER KIMIA HASHEMIAN KAYLEE A. SAUNDERS CAROLINE J. CORDOVA W. WALKER MACON ALEX J. VALLE MYAGMARSUREN DAVAASUREN MICHAEL A. MEISSNER PAIGE V. WILLIAMS ALEXIS M. FASIG AMANDA B. PETERSON BROOKE E. YEGAN BETHANY J. RING Faculty Advisor CELESTINE RICHARDS MCCONVILLE, Professor of Law CHAPMAN UNIVERSITY GUY AMBRAMO ADMINISTRATION RICHARD AFABLE MARILYN ALEXANDER DANIELE C. STRUPPA LISA ARGYROS ’07 President DONNA FORD ATTALLAH ’61 RAJ S. BHATHAL GLENN M. PFEIFFER KEN BUNT ’93 Provost and Executive Vice JAMES P. BURRA President for Academic Affairs MICHAEL J. CARVER PHILLIP H. CASE HAROLD W. HEWITT,JR. AKIN CEYLAN ’90 Executive Vice President and Chief IRVING M. CHASE Operating Officer HAZEM H. CHEHABI JEROME W. CWIERTNIA SHERYL A. BOURGEOIS ZEINAB H. DABBAH (JD ’12) Executive Vice President of DALE E. FOWLER ’58 University Advancement EMILY HADDAD STAN HARRELSON HELEN NORRIS GAVIN S. HERBERT,JR. Vice President and Chief LARRY HIGBY Information Officer MARK HILBERT WILLIAM K. HOOD BRIAN K. POWELL ANDY HOROWITZ Vice President and Chief Human MARK CHAPIN JOHNSON ’05 Resources Officer JENNIFER L. KELLER THOMAS E. MALLOY THOMAS C. PIECHOTA SEBASTIAN PAUL MUSCO Vice President for Research RICHARD MUTH (MBA ’81) JAMES J. PETERSON JAMIE CEMAN HARRY S. RINKER Vice President of Strategic JAMES B. ROSZAK Marketing and Communications THE HONORABLE LORETTA SANCHEZ ’82 JERRY PRICE MOHINDAR S. SANDHU Vice President for Student Affairs RONALD M. SIMON and Dean of Students RONALD E. SODERLING THE HONORABLE GADDI H. BOARD OF TRUSTEES VASQUEZ ’09 KAREN R. WILKINSON ’69 WYLIE A. AITKEN, Chair DAVID W. WILSON PARKER KENNEDY, Vice Chair JOANN LEATHERBY, Vice Chair JAMES MAZZO, Vice Chair SCOTT CHAPMAN, Secretary ZELMA M. ALLRED, Assistant Secretary THE HONORABLE ANDREW J. EMERITUS CHAIRS GUILFORD THE HONORABLE GEORGE L. THE HONORABLE W. MICHAEL ARGYROS ’59 HAYES DOY B. HENLEY DOY B. HENLEY DONALD E. SODARO JANET E. HUMPHREY THE HONORABLE PHILIP K. MAUTINO EMERITUS TRUSTEES THE HONORABLE LAYNE H. RICHARD BERTEA MELZER LYNN HIRSCH BOOTH ROBERT E. MURDOCK ARLENE R. CRAIG DAVID MURPHY J. BEN CROWELL THOMAS D. PHELPS ROBERT A. ELLIOTT STEVEN P. RUDEN (JD ’05) DAVID C. HENLEY ROGER C. HOBBS SCHOOL OF LAW CECILIA PRESLEY ADMINISTRATION BARRY RODGERS RICHARD R. SCHMID R. DAVID THRESHIE MATTHEW J. PARLOW Dean, Donald P. Kennedy Chair in Law, and Professor of Law EX-OFFICIO TRUSTEES CONNIE BENSON ’93 MARISA S. CIANCIARULO REVEREND LA TAUNYA BYNUM ’76 Associate Dean for Academic PAUL A. COOK Affairs, Doy and Dee Henley Chair REVEREND DON DEWEY in Law, and Professor of Law NANCY FLEEMAN ’86 REVEREND DAYNA KINKADE JAYNE TAYLOR KACER ANNE MANASSERO Associate Dean for Student Affairs DANIELE C. STRUPPA REVEREND FELIX VILLANUEVA DONALD J. KOCHAN Parker S. Kennedy Professor in BOARD OF ADVISORS Law and Associate Dean for Research & Faculty Development PARKER S. KENNEDY, Chair YLIE ITKEN W A. A AMY ROGAN-MEHTA ROBERT ALVARADO,JR. Associate Dean for Administration KAY ANDERLE HILLIP ASE P H. C JUSTIN CRUZ ROBERT E. CURRIE Assistant Dean of Admissions and ZEINAB H. DABBAH (JD ’12) Diversity Initiatives JOHN R. EVANS WOLFGANG FRISCH ’97 (JD ’00) SUSIE PARK THE HONORABLE RICHARD D. Assistant Dean for Career Services FYBEL LINDA KAWAGUCHI DR.THOMAS CAMPBELL Hugh and Hazel Darling Professor of Law, Former Dean Foundation Library Director and (2011-2016), and Doy and Dee Professor of Law Henley Distinguished Professor of Jurisprudence DR.RONALD L. STEINER Director of Law Graduate LAN CAO Programs and Professor Professor of Law and Betty Hutton Williams Professor of International GEORGE WILLIS Economic Law Director of the Tax Law Clinic, Associate Clinical Professor and JENNY CAREY Administrator of the Graduate Tax Professor of Legal Research and Programs Writing MARYAM ISLES ANTHONY T. CASO Registrar Professor of Law, Clinical Faculty KELLY FARANO MARISA S. CIANCIARULO Director of Administrative Associate Dean for Academic Operations Affairs, Doy and Dee Henley Chair in Law, and Professor of Law LAW SCHOOL FACULTY BOBBY DEXTER DEEPA BADRINARAYANA Professor of Law Professor of Law FRANK J. DOTI RITA BARNETT-ROSE Professor of Law and William P. Professor of Legal Research and Foley II Chair in Corporate Law Writing and Taxation MICHAEL BAZYLER DR.JOHN EASTMAN Professor of Law and 1939 Society Henry Salvatori Professor of Law Law Scholar in Holocaust and and Community Service, Former Human Rights Studies Dean (2007-2010), and Director of the Center for Constitutional THOMAS W. BELL Jurisprudence Professor of Law KURT EGGERT DENIS BINDER Professor of Law and Director of Professor of Law the Alona Cortese Elder Law Center DANIEL BOGART Professor of Law and Bolinger JUDD FUNK Chair in Real Estate, Land Use, Professor of the Practice of and Environmental Law Entertainment Law DR.JOHN A. HALL LISA LITWILLER Professor of Law and Director of Professor of Law International Law Emphasis Program KATHERINE MACFARLANE Visiting Professor of Law KATHY HELLER Associate Professor of the Practice MARIO MAINERO of Law and Executive Director of Gray Family Professor of Law, the Entertainment Law Emphasis Professor of Academic Program Achievement, and Executive Director of Bar Preparation and ERNESTO HERNANDEZ Academic Achievement Professor of Law CELESTINE RICHARDS MCCONVILLE HUGH HEWITT Professor of Law Professor of Law HENRY NOYES SCOTT W. HOWE Professor of Law Frank L. Williams Professor of Criminal Law and Former Interim MATTHEW J. PARLOW Dean (2010-2011, 2016) Dean, Donald P. Kennedy Chair in Law, and Professor of Law LINDA KAWAGUCHI Hugh and Hazel Darling ABIGAIL PATTHOFF Foundation Library Director and Professor of Legal Research and Professor of Law Writing JANINE KIM DR.RICHARD REDDING Professor of Law Professor of Law and Ronald D. Rotunda Distinguished Professor DONALD J. KOCHAN of Jurisprudence Parker S. Kennedy Professor in Law and Associate Dean for JILL REZA Research & Faculty Development Visiting Assistant Professor of Academic Success MICHAEL LANG Professor of Law SUSANNA K. RIPKEN Professor of Law CAROLYN LARMORE Professor of the Practice of Law, LAWRENCE ROSENTHAL and Director of the Externship Professor of Law Program KYNDRA ROTUNDA STEPHANIE LASCELLES Professor of Law and Executive Associate Professor of Legal Director of the Military and Research and Writing Veterans Law Institute RONALD D. ROTUNDA (1945-2018) GEORGE WILLIS Doy and Dee Henley Chair and Director of the Tax Law Clinic, Distinguished Professor of Clinical Faculty, Administrator of Jurisprudence the Graduate Tax Programs, and Professor Law MARY LEE RYAN Professor of the Practice of DR.BART J. WILSON Entertainment Law Donald P. Kennedy Chair in Economics and Law and Professor NANCY SCHULTZ of Law Kennedy Professor of Dispute Resolution and Director of Competitions and Alternative Dispute Resolution Program WENDY M. SEIDEN Professor of Law, Clinical Faculty, and Co-Director of the Bette and Wylie Aitken Family Protection Clinic SANDRA W. SKAHEN Professor of Law, Clinical Faculty DR.VERNON L. SMITH George L. Argyros Endowed Chair in Finance and Economics and Professor of Economics and Law KENNETH STAHL Professor of Law and Director of the Environmental, Land Use, and Real Estate Law Program DR.WILLIAM STALLWORTH Professor of Law Emeritus DR.RONALD L. STEINER Director of Law Graduate Programs and Professor of Law DR.PARHAM H. WILLIAMS,JR. Professor Emeritus and Former Dean (1997-2007) Chapman Law Review Volume 22 Spring 2019 Number 2 © 2019 by Chapman Law Review SYMPOSIUM: HONORING THE SCHOLARSHIP OF RONALD D. ROTUNDA Constitutional Democracy and the Third Branch Diarmuid F. O’Scannlain ............................................... 185 Ronald Rotunda: Scholar, Teacher, Professor, Public Intellectual. An Appreciation. Hugh Hewitt .................................................................... 197 The Admirable Republican Constitutional Heroism of Ronald Rotunda Stephen B. Presser ........................................................... 217 Ronald D. Rotunda: An Advocate for Standards of Professional Conduct in the Legal Profession: The Relentless Pursuit of the Professional Responsibility of Lawyers Holding America’s Lawyers Accountable John S. Dzienkowski ....................................................... 233 A Tribute to Professor Ronald Rotunda Denis Binder .................................................................... 249 Remembering Professor Ronald Rotunda Josh Blackman ................................................................ 257 Ronald D. Rotunda (1945-2018): A Giant in the Law Whose Likes We Will Not See Again Richard E. Redding ........................................................ 261 ABA Model Rule 8.4(g): An Exercise in Coercing Virtue? Jack Park ......................................................................... 267