Cultivating the Commons an Assessment of the Potential for Urban Agriculture on Oakland's Public Land
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Portland State University PDXScholar Urban Studies and Planning Faculty Nohad A. Toulan School of Urban Studies and Publications and Presentations Planning 12-2010 Cultivating the Commons An Assessment of the Potential for Urban Agriculture on Oakland’s Public Land Nathan McClintock Portland State University, [email protected] Jenny Cooper University of California - Berkeley Follow this and additional works at: https://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/usp_fac Part of the Social Policy Commons, Urban Studies Commons, and the Urban Studies and Planning Commons Let us know how access to this document benefits ou.y Citation Details McClintock, N., and Cooper, J. (2010). Cultivating the Commons An Assessment of the Potential for Urban Agriculture on Oakland’s Public Land. Available at www.urbanfood.org. This Working Paper is brought to you for free and open access. It has been accepted for inclusion in Urban Studies and Planning Faculty Publications and Presentations by an authorized administrator of PDXScholar. Please contact us if we can make this document more accessible: [email protected]. Cultivating the Commons An Assessment of the Potential for Urban Agriculture on Oakland’s Public Land by Nathan McClintock & Jenny Cooper Department of Geography University of California, Berkeley REVISED EDITION – December 2010 ! i Cultivating the Commons An Assessment of the Potential for Urban Agriculture on Oakland’s Public Land Nathan McClintock & Jenny Cooper Department of Geography, University of California, Berkeley October 2009, revised December 2010 In collaboration with: City Slicker Farms HOPE Collaborative Institute for Food & Development Policy (Food First) This project was funded in part by the HOPE Collaborative. City Slicker Farms was the fiscal sponsor. Food First published print copies of the report. Fellowship funding from the Robert & Patricia Switzer Foundation, UC Berkeley’s Institute for the Study of Social Change, and Community Forestry & Environmental Research Partnerships also made this project possible. The ideas expressed in this report do not necessarily reflect those of the funding organizations. All text and maps © N. McClintock / J. Cooper. All photos © N. McClintock. All aerial imagery © 2009 TerraMetrics/Google Earth and National Agricultural Imagery Program. Please do not reproduce any element of this report without proper citation. For more information about this project, contact: Nathan McClintock University of California, Berkeley Department of Geography 507 McCone Hall, #4740 Berkeley, CA 94720 Email: [email protected] Website: www.urbanfood.org i Cultivating the Commons: An Assessment of the Potential for Urban Agriculture on Oakland’s Public Land ! Acknowledgements We are deeply indebted to everyone who contributed his or her time to this project: Community Advisory Committee: Brahm Ahmadi, People’s Grocery Thanks, also, to members of the HOPE Collaborative’s Food Leon Davis, Saint Vincent de Paul of Alameda Co. Systems Action Team (and the Production Group, in Alisa Dodge, HOPE Collaborative particular) and Built Environment Action Team for sharing Barbara Finnin, City Slicker Farms their visions of a sustainable food system for Oakland and for Alethea Harper, Oakland Food Policy Council their input into the final draft. Thanks to Alisa Dodge for her Jason Harvey, Oakland Food Connection editorial help. The preliminary analysis of private land would Hank Herrera, HOPE Collaborative have been impossible without Snehee Khandeshi’s hard work. Navina Khanna, HOPE Collaborative Grey Kolevzon, Cycles of Change / Urban Youth Harvest In fond memory of Douglas Allen, whose GIS wizardry was Max Kurtz-Cadji, People’s Grocery invaluable at the early stages of this project. He tragically Aaron Lehmer, Bay Localize passed away before seeing this project come to fruition. Kira Pascoe, Alameda County UC Cooperative Extension David Ralston, City of Oakland (Redevelopment) Loren Rodgers, North Oakland resident About the Authors Paula Simon, West Oakland resident Heather Wooten, Public Health Law & Policy Nathan McClintock is a PhD candidate in geography at UC Berkeley. He also serves on the Oakland Food Policy Dissertation Chair: Council and was a member of the HOPE Collaborative’s Food System Action Team. He holds a MS degree in crop Nathan Sayre, UC Berkeley Dept. of Geography science/sustainable agriculture from North Carolina State University and has worked extensively in sustainable Technical Advisors: agriculture research, extension, and education in the US and internationally. Douglas Allen, UC Berkeley Dept. of Geography Darin Jensen, UC Berkeley Dept. of Geography Jenny Cooper received her BA in geography from UC Mike Jones, UC Berkeley Dept. of Geography Berkeley in 2008. She is works for the Environmental Defense Kevin Koy, UC Berkeley Geospatial Innovation Facility Fund in Washington, DC, on international climate change policy. ii Cultivating the Commons: An Assessment of the Potential for Urban Agriculture on Oakland’s Public Land ! Contents 4. Site Profiles..............................................................................................19 Executive Summary .................................................................................... 1 W.D. Wood Park 1. Introduction................................................................................................ 3 “Jungle Hill” King’s Estates Open Space Food Justice in the Flatlands 3rd Street Farming the Food Deserts: Urban Agriculture Takes Root MLK Shoreline Park Box 1: Urban Agriculture’s Multi-Functionality Clinton Square Box 2: Urban Agriculture Programs in Oakland Cesar Chavez Park Map 1: Urban Gardens in Oakland Harbor Bay Pkwy. / “North Field” Why a Land Inventory? Oakport St. Cultivating the Commons Box 3: Urban Farms on Public Land 5. Conclusions & Recommendations .............................................25 2. Methods...................................................................................................... 11 Box 6: Potential Productivity Map 2: Land Owned by Public Agencies Appendices......................................................................................................31 Box 4: Public Land Assessed in this Inventory A. Land Locator ........................................................................................31 3. Results......................................................................................................... 13 Box 5: How to Use the Land Locator with Existing Online Databases Box 5: Sites by City Council District Map A: North Oakland / CCD 1 Map 3: Size and Distribution of Sites Map B: West Oakland / CCD 3 Map 4: Ground Cover Map C: Central East Oakland / CCDs 2 & 5 Map 5: Potential Agroforestry Map D: East Oakland / CCDs 6 & 7 Map 6: Slope Map E: Oakland Hills (South) / CCDs 6 & 7 Map 7: Permitted Agricultural Use Map F: Oakland Hills (Central) / CCDs 4 & 6 Map G: Oakland Hills (North) / CCD 1 B. GIS Methodology ................................................................................51 C. Calculating Oakland’s Fruit & Vegetable Needs ..........................54 D. Permitted Agricultural Use Zoning .................................................55 E. Municipal Code Related to Animal Raising ...................................57 F. Blueprint for Management Plan for Urban Agricultural Use .....59 G. Privately Owned Vacant Land ...........................................................65 References .......................................................................................................66 iii Cultivating the Commons: An Assessment of the Potential for Urban Agriculture on Oakland’s Public Land iv Cultivating the Commons: An Assessment of the Potential for Urban Agriculture on Oakland’s Public Land Executive Summary Using aerial photos, GIS, and site visits, we identified approximately 1,200 acres of undeveloped open space at 495 This is an inventory of open space with potential for agricultural sites (consisting of 756 individual publicly-owned tax parcels). production on land both owned by public agencies and within the About a third of this land is located on slopes less than 10 city limits of Oakland, California. The inventory was conducted percent, a third between 10 and 30 percent, and a third greater between the summer of 2008 and spring of 2009 and is part of an than 30 percent; overall, at least 828 acres could be cultivated. ongoing movement to develop a more resilient, sustainable, and The majority of these parcels are located within ! mile of public just food system in Oakland. This project aims to locate transportation. A third of the parcels are within a quarter mile of Oakland’s “commons”—land that is owned by public agencies a school, and 7.5 percent have an EBMUD meter. In addition to and therefore a public resource—and assess the potential for the parcels in this inventory, we identified 2,706 acres of publicly- urban agriculture (UA) on this land. We hope that this owned land with the potential for agroforestry. assessment can be used 1) to inform policy decisions that concern Oakland’s food, health, and environmental quality, and Based on a conservative estimate, the parcels identified in this 2) by non-profit organizations and city officials as a tool with land inventory could produce up to 5 percent of the City’s vegetable which to identify potential sites for UA programs. needs or 6 percent of its fruit needs. However, the potential impact of the expansion of UA programs in Oakland extends beyond the While Oakland