DOCSLIB.ORG

Dsl-252 Checklist Environmental Assessment

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Dsl-252 Checklist Environmental Assessment DSL-252 CHECKLIST ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT Project Name: Installation of an overhead power Proposed Implementation Date: Summer 2021 transmission line. Proponent: Big Flat Electric Cooperative, PO Box 229, Malta, MT 59538 Type and Purpose of Action: The applicant proposes to install an overhead power line with a capacity of 115kV within a right-of-way 80’ wide (40’ on either side of a centerline) across School Trust land in Phillips County. This line will be used to transmit power to TransCanada’s Keystone XL Pumpstation. The line will allow for improved electric power distribution in this rural area and the surrounding communities. Location: W2W2 Section 16, Township 30N, Range County: Phillips 33E I. PROJECT DEVELOPMENT 1. PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT, AGENCIES, Big Flat Electric contacted the Glasgow GROUPS OR INDIVIDUALS CONTACTED: Unit regarding the project and Provide a brief chronology of the submitted the right-of-way application. scoping and ongoing involvement for this project. 2. OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES WITH No other governmental agencies have JURISDICTION, LIST OF PERMITS jurisdiction over this project as it NEEDED: pertains to School Trust lands. Montana DNRC, Real Estate Management Bureau has jurisdiction over the project. 3. ALTERNATIVES CONSIDERED: Action Alternative: Grant permission to the proponent to install the overhead power line on School Trust land. No Action Alternative: Deny permission to the proponent to install the overhead power line on School Trust land. II. IMPACTS ON THE PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT RESOURCE POTENTIAL IMPACTS II. IMPACTS ON THE PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT 4. GEOLOGY AND SOIL QUALITY, The area of impact consists of Scobey- STABILITY AND MOISTURE: Are Kevin clay loams and gravelly loams fragile, compatible or unstable with 2 to 8% slopes. This soil is not soils present? Are there unusual fragile or unstable, and no unusual geologic features? Are there geologic features are present. special reclamation considerations? Action Alternative: There will be some soil disturbance due to the installation of the poles. Any disturbance will be temporary and recover quickly with typical vegetation regrowth. No Action Alternative: Under this alternative there will be no changes to soils on the School Trust land. 5. WATER QUALITY, QUANTITY AND There are no important water resources DISTRIBUTION: Are important present within the area of impact. surface or groundwater resources There is no potential for impact on present? Is there potential for drinking water in the area. violation of ambient water quality standards, drinking water maximum Action Alternative: The proposed contaminant levels, or degradation transmission line installation would of water quality? not negatively impact the quality, quantity and distribution of water. No Action Alternative: Under this alternative, there will be no impacts to water quality, quantity and distribution. 6. AIR QUALITY: Will pollutants or This project is not influenced by any particulate be produced? Is the air quality regulations or zones. A project influenced by air quality short-term increase in vehicle traffic regulations or zones (Class I will result in a slight increase in airshed)? dust. No pollutants will be produced. Action Alternative: This type of project on the School Trust land will have minimal impact to the air quality. Some dust may occur due to vehicle use. II. IMPACTS ON THE PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT No Action Alternative: Under this alternative there will be no impacts to air quality. 7. VEGETATION COVER, QUANTITY AND The area of impact is native rangeland QUALITY: Will vegetative that sees seasonal livestock grazing. communities be permanently altered? No rare plants or cover types are Are any rare plants or cover types present. present? Action Alternative: The installation of this overhead line will have minimal impact to the surface vegetation. There is increased potential for spread of invasive plant species with soil disturbance. No Action Alternative: Under this alternative there will be no impacts to the plant communities on the School Trust land. 8. TERRESTRIAL, AVIAN AND AQUATIC The area of impact may see occasional LIFE AND HABITATS: Is there use by antelope, deer and substantial use of the area by upland/grassland birds. important wildlife, birds or fish? Action Alternative: There are no impacts to wildlife habitat expected due to installation of the transmission line. No Action Alternative: Under this alternative there will be no impacts to the possible use of the School Trust land as wildlife habitat. 9. UNIQUE, ENDANGERED, FRAGILE OR The area of impact is native rangeland LIMITED ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES: that provides quality habitat for Are any federally listed threatened wildlife species. No wetlands are or endangered species or identified within the area of impact. This habitat present? Any wetlands? project is within General Greater Sensitive Species or Species of Sage-Grouse habitat as outlined by the special concern? Montana Sage Grouse Oversight Team (MSGOT). The proponent submitted the project to MSGOT for review prior to submitting the application, and received approval, along with guidelines to follow, back from MSGOT. The following species of concern are II. IMPACTS ON THE PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT listed as being at least seasonally present within the area of impact: Greater Sage-Grouse, Baird’s Sparrrow and Long-Billed Curlew. Action Alternative: By following the recommendations made by MSGOT, impacts to sage-grouse will be mitigated during and after the installation process. No Action Alternative: Under this alternative there will be no impacts to the environmental resources. 10. HISTORICAL AND ARCHAEOLOGICAL The area of impact contains no SITES: Are any historical, historical, archaeological or archaeological or paleontological paleontological resources. A Class- resources present? III cultural resource inventory was performed along the proposed route by Act, Garcia and Associates. Based on this inventory, all ground disturbance activities associated with installation of the line will avoid resources by at least 50 feet. Action Alternative: The proposed line will have no impact on historical, archaeological or paleontological resources. No Action Alternative: There will be no impact to historical or archaeological sites under this alternative. 11. AESTHETICS: Is the project on a The area of impact is near a county prominent topographic feature? road and visible to the public. Will it be visible from populated or scenic areas? Will there be Action Alternative: The line will be excessive noise or light? readily visible from the nearby county road. No excessive noise or light would be produced. No Action Alternative: Under this alternative there will be no impacts to aesthetics associated with the II. IMPACTS ON THE PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT School Trust land. 12. DEMANDS ON ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES Environmental resources in the area OF LAND, WATER, AIR OR ENERGY: are not specifically limited and are Will the project use resources that not affected by the proposed project. are limited in the area? Are there No nearby activities will affect the other activities nearby that will project. affect the project? Action Alternative: The proposed project will place no additional demands on any environmental resources in the area. No Action Alternative: Under this alternative there will be no demands placed on environmental resources of land, water, air or energy. 13. OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENTS This site is managed for livestock PERTINENT TO THE AREA: Are there grazing under a School Trust lands other studies, plans or projects on lease. There are no other pertinent this tract? studies, plans or projects within the area of impact. Action Alternative: Installation of this line is crucial to the installation of TransCanada’s Keystone XL pump station. No Action Alternative: Under this alternative there will be no impacts to the plans or studies that Montana Department of Natural Resources and Conservation has on the School Trust land. III. IMPACTS ON THE HUMAN POPULATION RESOURCE POTENTIAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES 14. HUMAN HEALTH AND SAFETY: Will The operation and movement of heavy this project add to health and equipment and vehicles has inherent safety risks in the area? risks that are not impacted by access across the School Trust land. Action Alternative: The installation of the line would require the use of heavy equipment. No Action Alternative: Under this alternative there will be no impacts to human health or safety. 15. INDUSTRIAL, COMMERCIAL AND The area of impact is native rangeland AGRICULTURAL ACTIVITIES AND that is leased by a neighboring PRODUCTION: Will the project add rancher for seasonal livestock use. to or alter these activities? Action Alternative: Installation of the line will have no impact on livestock grazing on this tract. No Action Alternative: Under this alternative there will be no impacts to agricultural activities on the School Trust land. 16. QUANTITY AND DISTRIBUTION OF Action Alternative: The project will EMPLOYMENT: Will the project not create nor impact any jobs in the create, move or eliminate jobs? If area. so, estimated number. No Action Alternative: There will be no impacts to quantity and distribution of employment under this alternative. 17. LOCAL AND STATE TAX BASE AND TAX Action Alternative: The project will REVENUES: Will the project create have no impacts on the local and state or eliminate tax revenue? tax base and tax revenues. No Action Alternative: There will be no impacts to the local and
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Safety from Electricity Overhead Power Lines
    SAFETY FROM ELECTRICITY OVERHEAD POWER LINES STEVE GARNETT SAFETY MANAGER NORTHERN POWERGRID Call the national telephone number ‘105’ to automatically connect to your Electricity Distribution Network Operator 2 OVERHEAD POWER LINE INCIDENT STATISTICS Contact with overhead power lines is extremely dangerous And it occurs too often Some are very lucky and escape without injuries But when luck has run out, the consequences are frightening… 5 YEAR PERIOD 2012 – 2016 • Over 3000 Haulage and Transport vehicles reported coming into contact with overhead power lines in the UK • 59 people received injuries IN THE LAST 2 YEARS • 8 people were killed • Death is not always instant 3 OVERHEAD POWER LINE EXAMPLES Typical voltages range from 230 Volts up to 400000 Volts Lines can be bare wire, fully insulated or partially insulated 11000 volts 11000 33000 volts volts 230 volts 275000 volts 4 NOT OVERHEAD POWER LINES ? Overhead power lines can sometimes be very difficult to distinguish from telephone lines BT ? 5 EFFECT OF ELECTRIC SHOCK Electric shock is the effect of current flowing through the body It causes muscle contractions, tissue damage and internal burning It can cause cardiac arrest and respiratory failure JUMP Electricity can jump or ‘flashover’ – you don’t need to touch electrical conductors to draw a current Rubber boots will not protect you 6 ENERGY CREATED BY CONTACT WITH ELECTRICITY NETWORKS The energy created by a network contact is equivalent to at least 30,000 single bar electric fires. To put that in context… The Japanese
    [Show full text]
  • Margonin Wind Farm Non-Technical Summary [EBRD
    1 Non-Technical Executive Summary MARGONIN WIND FARM PROJECT, POLAND 2 Introduction EDP Renovaveis, the worlds fourth largest wind power operator is developing a major wind farm in the central part of Poland - Wielkopolskie Voivodship associated with the construction and development of wind farm projects in the Margonin area by EDP Renovaveis. The aim of this non-technical summary is to ensure that a cumulative assessment of the planned wind farm developments in the region can be presented to enable meaningful public and stakeholders engagement process. Attached to this documents are non-technical resumes which are integral part of the Environmental Impact Assessment Reports which are presented separately. In line with the Polish environmental regulations the need of preparation of an Environmental Impact Assessment is required for this project. General project presentation EDP Renovaveis is a leading international wind power developer, with a number of active wind farms located in the USA, Brazil, Spain, France, Belgium and Portugal. Installed capacity of EDP wind energy increased four-fold between 2005 and 2007, and now the company is among the world top three firms in the world in terms of growth in this sector. As a leading wind developer, the company is committed to guide the business activity in accordance with the sustainable development principles of the EDP Group, including among others: • Efficient use of resources, including the development of cleaner and more efficient energy technology and development of energy generation means based on renewable sources; • Environmental protection with minimization of the environmental impact of all business activities and participation in initiatives that contribute to the conservation of the environment; • Support social development.
    [Show full text]
  • High-Power Energy Scavenging for Portable Devices
    Wright State University CORE Scholar Browse all Theses and Dissertations Theses and Dissertations 2010 High-Power Energy Scavenging for Portable Devices Simon J. Tritschler Wright State University Follow this and additional works at: https://corescholar.libraries.wright.edu/etd_all Part of the Engineering Commons Repository Citation Tritschler, Simon J., "High-Power Energy Scavenging for Portable Devices" (2010). Browse all Theses and Dissertations. 997. https://corescholar.libraries.wright.edu/etd_all/997 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses and Dissertations at CORE Scholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in Browse all Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of CORE Scholar. For more information, please contact [email protected]. HIGH-POWER ENERGY SCAVENGING FOR PORTABLE DEVICES A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy By SIMON JOSEF TRITSCHLER B.S.E.E., Wright State University, 2001 M.S.Egr., Wright State University, 2003 2010 Wright State University WRIGHT STATE UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES 27 May 2010 I HEREBY RECOMMEND THAT THE DISSERTATION PREPARED UNDER MY SUPERVISION BY Simon Josef Tritschler ENTITLED High-Power Energy Scavenging for Portable Devices BE ACCEPTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF Doctor of Philosophy. ___________________________________ Marian K. Kazimierczuk, Ph.D. Dissertation Director ___________________________________ Ramana V. Grandhi, Ph.D. Director, Ph.D. in Engineering Program Committee on Final Examination ___________________________________ Jack A. Bantle, Ph.D. Vice President for Research and Graduate Studies ___________________________________ and Interim Dean of Graduate Studies Marian K. Kazimierczuk, Ph.D. ___________________________________ Fred D.
    [Show full text]
  • Kyoto Energypark
    Environmental Assessment Nov 2008 Kyoto energypark 21. Summary and Justification Page | 403 Summary and Justification Section 21 - Page | 404 Environmental Assessment Nov 2008 21.0 SUMMARY & JUSTIFICATION 21.1 Key Strategic Planning Issues • The Kyoto Energy Park project is a major initiative in providing large-scale renewable power and distribution for the Upper Hunter region. • The Kyoto Energy Park will be a carbon negative project with overall energy payback period of 6 months for wind turbines and approximately 13 months for the Mt Moobi Solar PV farm. This will represent a positive step in the promotion of the use of renewable energy sources. It will help to reverse potentially catastrophic climate change. • Ongoing employment for up to 15 operation and maintenance professionals. • Regional multiplier effects of between 914 and 1595 job years. • Development of a new skills sectors in the renewable energy industry within the Hunter region. • The project combines three proven, commercialised renewable technologies (solar, wind and hydro) Solar PV offers the fastest deployment of any renewable energy technologies today • Renewable technologies integrated in a complementary way to shave expensive peak demand • Flexibility to easily move the peak supply as the peak demand period moves according to seasons • Reduced peak demand resulting in infrastructure and generation savings • Creation of jobs across various fields (e.g. research, installation, project management) during development and construction • Significant ongoing green collar
    [Show full text]
  • 2014 Electric Reliability Plan (For Information & Discussion Only)
    LOS ALAMOS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC UTILITIES 2014 ELECTRIC RELIABILITY PLAN (FOR INFORMATION & DISCUSSION ONLY) Rafael De La Torre, PE Deputy Utility Manager, Electric Distribution November 19, 2014 1 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS .................................................................................................................................... 1 Executive Summary .................................................................................................... 5 I. System Overview: ................................................................................................. 7 Los Alamos Power Pool ........................................................................................... 7 Los Alamos Transmission System ........................................................................... 7 LACU Distribution System ....................................................................................... 8 II. Description of Relevant Systems and Impact on Reliability ............................. 10 The Regional Transmission Grid: ........................................................................... 10 The Local Transmission Grid: ................................................................................ 13 The Local Distribution Grid: ................................................................................... 14 Analysis of Performance Measures ....................................................................... 17 SAIDI Comparison with Nearby Utilities ................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Case 2:14-Cv-01781-SSV-KWR Document 26 Filed 03/12/15 Page 1 of 10
    Case 2:14-cv-01781-SSV-KWR Document 26 Filed 03/12/15 Page 1 of 10 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA WALTON CONSTRUCTION – A CORE CIVIL ACTION COMPANY, LLC, VERSUS NO: 14-1781 FIRST FINANCIAL INSURANCE COMPANY SECTION: R(2) ORDER AND REASONS This insurance coverage dispute concerns a commercial general liability policy issued by defendant First Financial Insurance Company. Plaintiff Walton Construction seeks a declaration that the policy affords it "additional insured" coverage in an underlying state court tort suit. First Financial seeks a declaration that it has no duty to defend or indemnify Walton. The parties have filed cross motions for summary judgment.1 For the following reasons, the Court denies Walton's motion and grants First Financial's motion. I. BACKGROUND This insurance coverage dispute arises out of a personal injury lawsuit brought by John Maestri against Entergy Louisiana, LLC, in Louisiana state court. Only a few facts are necessary to understand the underlying suit. Entergy is a power company. Maestri worked in construction for A-1 Glass Service, Inc., a 1 R. Doc. 9 (First Financial); R. Doc. 14 (Walton). Case 2:14-cv-01781-SSV-KWR Document 26 Filed 03/12/15 Page 2 of 10 commercial glazier. A-1 worked as a subcontractor to Walton on a construction project for the Jefferson Parish School Board. In March 2012, while Maestri was installing glass as part of that project, an Entergy high-voltage power line electrocuted him, burning his arms, chest, and hands. Maestri sued Entergy for his injuries. After Maestri sued Entergy, Entergy filed a third-party complaint against A-1 and Walton, alleging that the companies had violated the Louisiana Overhead Power Line Safety Act, La.
    [Show full text]
  • Nov HSA 2000
    CONTENTS: Winter Alert - “Someone’s Waiting for You at Home”................................................................................3 MSHA Creates a Coal Waste Dams and Impoundments Webpage Site........................................................4 “Battery Station Ventilation”......................................................................................................................5 “Pre-packaged Belt Move”.........................................................................................................................6 “Dump Shorty”..........................................................................................................................................7 “Railcar/Roller/Risk/Reduction/Remedy”.................................................................................................9 High Voltage Electrical Hazards - (Surface).............................................................................................10 Part 46 Training CD-ROM, Developed Cooperatively Between State and Industry......................................14 A Miner’s Story.........................................................................................................................................15 “Canaries”................................................................................................................................................18 Poem “Waiting”................................................................................................................................................19
    [Show full text]
  • Real-Time Health Monitoring of Power Networks Based on High
    REAL-TIME HEALTH MONITORING OF POWER NETWORKS BASED ON HIGH FREQUENCY BEHAVIOR A Dissertation Presented to The Graduate Faculty of The University of Akron In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy Amir mehdi Pasdar December, 2014 REAL-TIME HEALTH MONITORING OF POWER NETWORKS BASED ON HIGH FREQUENCY BEHAVIOR Amir mehdi Pasdar Dissertation Approved: Accepted: _______________________________ _______________________________ Advisor Department Chair Dr. Yilmaz Sozer Dr. Abbas Omar _______________________________ _______________________________ Committee Member Dean of the College Dr. Malik Elbuluk Dr. George K. Haritos _______________________________ _______________________________ Committee Member Dean of the Graduate School Dr. Tom Hartley Dr. George R. Newkome _______________________________ _______________________________ Committee Member Date Dr. Nathan Ida _______________________________ Committee Member Dr. Ping Yi _______________________________ Committee Member Dr. Alper Buldum ii ABSTRACT Sustainable and reliable electric power delivery to the users is critical for the well being of the society. Electric power delivery can be interrupted due to faults in the transmission lines, which can be defined as the flow of a current through an improper path of the power grid. Faults in the power line could cause power interruption, equipment damage, personal injury or death. Knowledge about the health condition of the power network helps to predict the possibility of the future fault occurrences due to the aging or failure of the insulators, conductors or towers. There has been significant research conducted in the past to monitor the health condition of the power grid, which has resulted in many types of sensors being commercially available. The time domain refletometer (TDR) type sensors have been developed for detecting a fault in an off-line long range power line.
    [Show full text]
  • Working Safely Around Electricity
    Working Safely Around Electricity About WorkSafeBC WorkSafeBC (the Workers’ Compensation Board) is an independent provincial statutory agency governed by a Board of Directors. It is funded by insurance premiums paid by registered employers and by investment returns. In administering the Workers Compensation Act, WorkSafeBC remains separate and distinct from government; however, it is accountable to the public through government in its role of protecting and maintaining the overall well-being of the workers’ compensation system. WorkSafeBC was born out of a compromise between B.C.’s workers and employers in 1917 where workers gave up the right to sue their employers or fellow workers for injuries on the job in return for a no-fault insurance program fully paid for by employers. WorkSafeBC is committed to a safe and healthy workplace, and to providing return-to-work rehabilitation and legislated compensation benefits to workers injured as a result of their employment. WorkSafeBC Prevention Information Line The WorkSafeBC Prevention Information Line can answer your questions about workplace health and safety, worker and employer responsibilities, and reporting a workplace accident or incident. The Prevention Information Line accepts anonymous calls. Phone 604.276.3100 in the Lower Mainland, or call 1.888.621.7233 (621.SAFE) toll-free in British Columbia. To report after-hours and weekend accidents and emergencies, call 604.273.7711 in the Lower Mainland, or call 1.866.922.4357 (WCB.HELP) toll-free in British Columbia. BC Hydro Public Safety Information www.bchydro.com/safety For information on overhead power line voltage or to complete WorkSafeBC form 30M33, call the BC Hydro Electric Service Coordination Centre at 1.877.520.1355.
    [Show full text]
  • Living and Working Safely Around High-Voltage Power Lines 1
    LIVING and WORKING SAFELY AROUND HIGH-VOLTAGE POWER LINES 1 igh-voltage power lines can be just as safe as H the electrical wiring in our homes — or just as danger- ous. The key is learning to act rural cooperatives take delivery of the power at these points and deliver it to the ultimate customers. safely around them. BPA’s lines cross all types of property: residential, This booklet is a basic safety guide for those who agricultural, industrial, commercial and recreational. live and work around power lines. It deals primarily with nuisance shocks caused by induced voltages If you have questions about and with possible electric shock hazards from safe practices near contact with high-voltage lines. power lines, call BPA. In preparing this booklet, the Bonneville Power Administration has drawn on more than 70 years Due to safety considerations many of the practices of experience with high-voltage power lines. BPA suggested in this booklet are restrictive. This is operates one of the world’s largest networks of because they attempt to cover all possible situa- long-distance, high-voltage lines, ranging from tions, and the worst conditions are assumed. 69,000 volts to 500,000 volts. This system has In certain circumstances, the restrictions can more than 200 substations and more than be re-evaluated. To determine what practices 15,000 miles of power lines. are applicable to your case, contact BPA at 1-800-836-6619 or find the contact information BPA’s lines make up the main electrical grid for for the local BPA office at www.transmission.bpa.
    [Show full text]
  • Testimony of Citizens Against Overhead Power Line Construction
    Testimony of Citizens Against Overhead Power Line Construction Prepared for the Connecticut Siting Council Docket 370 October 30, 2009 Citizens Against Overhead Power Line Construction Table of Contents Page 2 Citizens Against Overhead Power Line Construction The Connecticut Light & Power Company application for Certificates CT DOCKET No. 370 of Environmental Compatibilitiy and Public Need for the Connecticut Valley Electric Transmission Reliability Projects which consits of (1) The Connecticut portion of the Greater Springfield Reliability Project that traverses the municiplaities of Bloomfield, East Granby, and Suffield, or potentially including an alternate portion that traverses the municipalities of Suffield and Enfield, terminating at the North October 30, 2009 Bloommfield Substation; and (2) the Manchester Substation to Meekville Junction Circuit Separation project in Manchester, Connecticut. Citizens Against Overhead Power Line Construction Pre-filed Testimony Testimony of Richard Legere, ARM Executive Director, CAOPLC 1 Preface 2 3 I am addressing my comments to the CSC first as the Executive Director of Citizens Against Overhead 4 Power Line Construction (CAOPLC). CAOPLC is an organization comprised of approximately 100 families 5 and property owners in East Granby and Suffield who are affected by Docket 370, including property 6 owners who allow the Metacomet Trail to be on their land. 7 8 Second, I am addressing some specific comments as an individual property with concerns about the 9 siting of the power towers on my land. In that regard I would like to make a few specific suggestions to 10 the CSC about how the towers can be sited, if the CSC approves overhead towers over undergrounding 11 of the power lines through the Metacomet/Newgate area.
    [Show full text]
  • H:\IBLA Convert\Converted\180IBLA\WPD\L291-307.Wpd
    MACK ENERGY CORPORATION 180 IBLA 291 Decided January 12, 2011 United States Department of the Interior Office of Hearings and Appeals Interior Board of Land Appeals 801 N. Quincy St., Suite 300 Arlington, VA 22203 MACK ENERGY CORPORATION IBLA 2010-155 Decided January 12, 2011 Appeal from a decision of the Roswell (New Mexico) Field Office, Bureau of Land Management, offering right-of-way grants for a buried power line. NMNM 124105. Set aside and remanded. 1. Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976: Rights- of-Way--Rights-of-Way: Applications--Rights-of-Way: Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976 Under section 501 of the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976, 43 U.S.C. § 1761 (2006), a decision to reject or issue a right-of-way is discretionary and will be affirmed where the record shows the decision to be based on a reasoned analysis of the facts involved, made with due regard for the public interest, and where appellant fails to show error in the decision. To successfully challenge a discretionary decision, the burden is upon an appellant to demonstrate by a preponderance of the evidence that BLM committed a material error in its factual analysis or that the decision generally is not supported by a record showing that BLM gave due consideration to all relevant factors and acted on the basis of a rational connection between the facts found and the choice made. The Board will set aside a BLM decision requiring an appellant to bury a power line, rather than approving appellant’s application to construct an overhead line, when the appellant demonstrates that there is no rational connection between the facts cited by BLM and the decision made.
    [Show full text]