• Abstract and Figures
• Public Full-text

Variable Modified Newtonian Mechanics II: Baryonic Tully Fisher Relation C. C. Wong Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, University of Hong Kong. H.K. (Dated: February 11, 2021) Recently we find a single-metric solution for a point mass residing in an expanding universe [1], which apart from the Newtonian acceleration, gives rise to an additional MOND-like acceleration in which the MOND acceleration a0 is replaced by the cosmological acceleration. We study a Milky Way size protogalactic cloud in this acceleration, in which the growth of angular momentum can lead to an end of the overdensity growth. Within realistic redshifts, the overdensity stops growing at a value where the MOND-like acceleration dominates over Newton and the outer mass shell rotational velocity obeys the Baryonic Tully Fisher Relation (BTFR) with a smaller MOND acceleration. As the outer mass shell shrinks to a few scale length distances, the rotational velocity BTFR persists due to the conservation of angular momentum and the MOND acceleration grows to the phenomenological MOND acceleration value a0 at late time. PACS numbers: ?? INTRODUCTION A common response to the non-Newtonian rotational curve of a galaxy is that its ”Newtonian” dynamics requires cold dark matter (DM) particles. However, the small observed scatter of empirical Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation (BTFR) of gas rich galaxies, see McGaugh [2]-Lelli [3], Milgrom [4] and Sanders [5], continues to motivate the hunt for a non-Newtonian connection between the rotational speeds and the baryon mass. On the modified DM theory front, Khoury [6] proposes a DM Bose-Einstein Condensate (BEC) phase where DM can interact more strongly with baryons. Modified gravity theories in general attempt to come up with a dominant non-Newtonian acceleration, where mass discrepancy requires, without DM. If successful it could mitigate some CDM modelling problems including the ”Angular Momentum Catastrophe” in galaxy formation [7], Coplanar dwarf galaxies around Centaurus A [8], the failing of the ”Dual dwarf galaxy theorem” and the lack of dynamical friction in galaxy formation [9], the low hydrogen temperature from the EDGES experiments [10]-[11] and most importantly the increasingly difficult search for dark particles at large quantities. An example of modifying gravity is Conformal Gravity [12]-[13], which by starting with a conformally invariant gravity action, produces an additional tunable ”constant” acceleration. Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) by Milgrom [14] modifies the gravitational acceleration when the Newtonian acceleration is below some phenomenological scale a0, reproduces the BTFR, see also Famaey-McGaugh[15]-[16], and the Faber Jackson relation (FJR), Milgrom[17]. Comparing the MOND and DM predictions with galactic rotational curve observations [18] reinforces the view that MOND should emerge from any viable modified gravity theory. The recent FJR observations for spherical galaxies over 7 order of magnitudes in mass scale, Durazo et. al. [19], further strengthen the relevance of MOND at galactic scales. As it stands, MOND remains a phenomenological theory as the search for a relativistic origin continues [16],[20]. It is worth noting that a class of TeVes theory proposed by Skordis [21] is shown to provide an acceptable speed of gravity. The lack of a relativistic theory limits the use of MOND to that of a peculiar acceleration of the overdensity in cosmological situations. The high gravitational acceleration in the pre-recombination epoch however limits the use of MOND to explain the high acoustic peaks [16]. The matter power spectrum further requires a strong non-baryonic potential to dampen baryonic acoustic oscillations arXiv:1802.01493v7 [astro-ph.GA] 10 Feb 2021 after recombination, Dodelson [22] Spergel [23]. In large scale structure formation simulation, Nusser [24] shows that MOND with a significantly smaller a0 can reproduce a large scale structure similar to the CDM results. In a MOND acceleration treatment of high temperature X-ray region of galaxy cluster [25]-[26], it is found that either more invisible mass is required or an increase of the MOND acceleration a0 by a factor of 4 will be necessary to produce the observed temperature. Modelling galaxy cluster formation with MOND using simulation remains problematic especially in accounting for the temperature profile in the central region, Nusser [27]. Other Modified gravity theories are used to match the DM function in cluster A1689 [28]. These include EMOND, a Generalised versions of MOND [29], GMOND [30], Emergent Gravity [31] and MOG [32]. At large distances, both EMOND and Emergent Gravity have a MOND like acceleration which can accommodate a larger a0 [28]. In EMOND, a0 increases at large Newtonian acceleration but this model becomes problematic at stellar scales. In summary, a viable MOND-like theory seems to require the MOND acceleration a0 to vary in strength according to the environment where mass discrepancies appear upto 1 Gpc [33]. Given the many successes of General Relavity, the question is whether such acceleration can be found. 2 Emerging studies of Early type galaxy (ETG) rotational curves open up a new perspective on gravitational acceleration of large structures during cosmic evolution. Recently, Genzel et.al. [34] and Lang [35] show that early type galaxies have Newtonian rotational curves outside its scale length r0, which in fact fall off faster than the (Newtonian) exponential disk from 2r 5r , where 5r is the galactic disk size. By modelling DM density profile 0 ∼ 0 0 based on the NSW model, the authors of [35] obtain the following equation for the rotational speed vrot, speed due to disk mass vdisk and speed due to dark matter vDM 2 2 2 2 r vrot(r)= vdisk(r)+ vDM (r) 2σ ( ), (1) − r0 2 2 where the (1-dimensional) σ is the velocity dispersion usually taken to be vrot = 3σ and the last term in the Eq. (1) represents pressure support inside the disk. Using simulations, the authors in [35] reproduce the observations by using maximal baryonic density (no DM allowed) inside the disk and including pressure support term. This work suggests that ” at z 2 there is no need for dark matter inside the galactic disk upto 5r0 ”. Work by Simons et.al. [36] demonstrates that∼ from z 2 to z 0.2, galactic rotational speed starts growing at a rate correlating with galactic mass growth and a rapid∼ decrease∼ of velocity dispersion σ. This is independently confirmed by Kassin et. al. [37]. Pure disk galaxies [38] observations also show that from z 1, a central exponential disk profile is maintained without major mergers. Their central surface brightness remain ∼unchanged over 1 >z> 0.4, but over 0.4 >z> 0.02 the stellar disk mass increases upto 40% while the central brightness and scale length remain unchanged. This indicates that after z < 0.4 a significant amount of gas from large radii has moved onto the central disk. However, this gas cannot get through into the stellar disk and is kept in the region r0 2r0. Continuous cold gas accretion is known to be a crucial ingredient in the evolution of spiral galaxies, see for∼ example [38]-[40]. The gas accretion time is almost an order of magnitude larger than the free fall time under a Newtonian acceleration, it is generally believed that this gas comes from cold streaming of the cosmic filaments. However, if the gas accretion comes from the same protogalactic cloud, one would expect that the dynamics of the accretion gas would be very different to that of Newtonian collapse. The collapse of HI gas from large radii onto a stellar disk is also observed in the DiskMass Survey [41]-[43]. At early time the mass profile of HI gas is low inside 5r0, but increases to a peak outside 5r0 and then becomes flattened. The rotational curve also flattens outside 5r0 where the HI mass profile is flat. At late times, the HI mass profile is seen to have moved inside the 5r0 distances and peaks strongly around 2r0. Even more specifically, [44] finds that for ETG at small radii outside r0, the amount of DM required is small ( 10%). However, for large radii outside 5r0, the rotational curves follows a BTFR with very tight scatter [45].∼ This BTFR matchs the late time BTFR of spiral galaxies at 60 70% of maximal mass to light ratio. − In MOND term, this is equivalent to requiring a smaller MOND accleration a0 at higher reshift and at larger distances. The above observations show that for Early type spiral galaxies, a nearly Newtonian central stellar disk develops first while its outer MOND-like rotating gas at radii larger than 5r0 moves very slowly towards the stellar disk. In studies involving galaxies, the background metric is generally assumed to be the Einstein-Straus (Swiss-cheese) model [46] or the McVittie metric [47], in which a central mass region is described by the Schwarzschild metric, while outside of a junction the relevant metric is that of the Friedmann Robertson Walker (FRW) metric. Neither of these solutions is without criticism. It is known that a Einstein-Straus (Swiss cheese) solution does not exist in cylindrical coordinates, and the McVittie metric has a pressure singularity at small distances. A review of the difficulties in both approaches can be found in [48]. In strong lensing applications for galaxies, the debates between these two metrics remain ongoing [49]-[53]. However, these solutions are not necessarily the only choices. In a previous work [1], we find a single ”inhomogeneous” metric from solving Einstein equations for a point mass residing in an expanding FRW background, in which a MOND-like potential (acceleration) at slow speeds arises. This potential has no tunable parameter and depends strictly on the central baryonic density and the cosmological background density. In [1] we find that combining Newtonian and non-Newtonian acceleration (which we name ”VMOND” acceleration) amounts to the MOND scheme that interpolates between Newtonian and non-Newtonian acceleration.

Load more

  17

Copy Link