Gender and Ethnicity in the Global South: an Analysis of the Struggles of Women Tribal Leader in a Graded Indian Society

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Gender and Ethnicity in the Global South: an Analysis of the Struggles of Women Tribal Leader in a Graded Indian Society Gender and Ethnicity in the Global South: An analysis of the struggles of women tribal leader in a graded Indian society Mochish KS Doctoral Candidate School of Media and Cultural Studies Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Mumbai Unique apparatus of exploitations and the societal contradictions rather than diversity and peaceful coexistence are making India distinctive from the rest of the world in the 21st century. The society is distinctly stratified along the lines of caste, gender, class, ethnicity, language etc. to name a few. Specifically, the discrimination on the basis of ethnicity, caste and gender has been marked and inexorable. According to Dr. B.R Ambedkar “Caste system is social division of people of the same race” (Ambedkar, 1936). The caste system which has its origins in the Hindu mythology is a system where castes are hierarchically organized on the basis of rules of ritual purity and pollution. This system has had a serious impact on the socio-economic lives of the people as it regulates one’s access to better life and equal social status. This system of social division is also highly patriarchal in nature and has functioned as an oppressive tool for centuries in the Indian society. So, the discrimination along the lines of gender and ethnicity has deep rooted connections with the existing social hierarchy which makes the degree of oppression even more ruthless. This paper will examine the public response towards the struggles of C.K. Janu who led the historic struggles for land for the tribals of Kerala and commands a high regard among them. Tribals are untouchable groups according to the laws of the dominant Hindu religion in the country. Ms. C K Janu is an illiterate, born in a very poor tribal family of Wayanad, Kerala, the southern state in the Indian Union. She emerged as a strong leader of a mass movement against all odds of gender and caste hierarchy prevalent in the Kerala society. The analysis will be based on the Malayalam1 newspaper reports, articles and editorials on the Muthanga land struggles of 2003. The print in Kerala has a rich heritage of plurality and vibrancy that allowed them to occupy a significant position the in the media history of the country. The print history demonstrates that the media in Kerala has championed in achieving an inclusive readership in the early periods among various social groups unlike in other Indian states. 1 Native language of Kerala state This paper will explore the reportage of the popular Malayalam newspapers towards the struggles of C.K. Janu, for which I am looking at four major newspapers in Malayalam. These are Deepika (1887), Malayala Manorama (1888), Mathrubhumi (1923), and Kerala Kaumudi (1911). Their wide circulation and consumption among the public shows the significance of these dailies in the public sphere of Kerala society. The initial analysis of the media archives shows that, on the whole, the strength of newspapers has historically contributed to the vitality of Kerala’s political society. Yet, on key agendas, such as gender and caste a section of newspapers played a complex, and sometimes regressive, role. With respect to these critical agendas, newspaper reporting reflected the sharp contestations that marked the political arena. As a result, progressive movements in Kerala, most notably the tribal movement, had to fight not just the lobbies of the landlords, elite and the state, but also the powerful media groups aligned with them. CK Janu’s rightful fight for her as well as the land of her people can be considered a courageous act that entailed transgressing the social boundaries that were assigned to her. She challenged the oppressive social structures at more than one levels. For a tribal woman to come out and assume the leadership of a land struggle, and doing so in the public domain when women were strictly relegated to the private domain, is not something, which can be termed as routine or common place. This act entailed challenging and opposing the oppressive structures working to maintain caste, class and gender discrimination. Keywords: Ethnicity, Gender, Media, Graded Society .
Recommended publications
  • Minority Media and Community Agenda Setting a Study on Muslim Press in Kerala
    Minority Media and Community Agenda Setting A Study On Muslim Press In Kerala Muhammadali Nelliyullathil, Ph.D. Dean, Faculty of Journalism and Head, Dept. of Mass Communication University of Calicut, Kerala India Abstract Unlike their counterparts elsewhere in the country, Muslim newspapers in Kerala are highly professional in staffing, payment, and news management and production technology and they enjoy 35 percent of the newspaper readership in Kerala. They are published in Malayalam when Indian Muslim Press outside Kerala concentrates on Urdu journalism. And, most of these newspapers have a promising newsroom diversity employing Muslim and non-Muslim women, Dalits and professionals from minority and majority religions. However, how effective are these newspapers in forming public opinion among community members and setting agendas for community issues in public sphere? The study, which is centered on this fundamental question and based on the conceptual framework of agenda setting theory and functional perspective of minority media, examines the role of Muslim newspapers in Kerala in forming a politically vibrant, progress oriented, Muslim community in Kerala, bringing a collective Muslim public opinion into being, Influencing non-Muslim media programming on Muslim issues and influencing the policy agenda of the Government on Muslim issues. The results provide empirical evidences to support the fact that news selection and presentation preferences and strategies of Muslim newspapers in Kerala are in line with Muslim communities’ news consumption pattern and related dynamics. Similarly, Muslim public’s perception of community issues are formed in accordance with the news framing and priming by Muslim newspapers in Kerala. The findings trigger more justifications for micro level analysis of the functioning of the Muslim press in Kerala to explore the community variable in agenda setting schema and the significance of minority press in democratic political context.
    [Show full text]
  • Journalism Class - Xi
    HIGHER SECONDARY COURSE JOURNALISM CLASS - XI Government of Kerala DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION State Council of Educational Research and Training (SCERT) Kerala 2016 THE NATIONAL ANTHEM Jana-gana-mana adhinayaka, jaya he Bharatha-bhagya-vidhata. Punjab-Sindh-Gujarat-Maratha Dravida-Utkala-Banga Vindhya-Himachala-Yamuna-Ganga Uchchala-Jaladhi-taranga Tava subha name jage, Tava subha asisa mage, Gahe tava jaya gatha. Jana-gana-mangala-dayaka jaya he Bharatha-bhagya-vidhata. Jaya he, jaya he, jaya he, Jaya jaya jaya, jaya he! PLEDGE India is my country. All Indians are my brothers and sisters. I love my country, and I am proud of its rich and varied heritage. I shall always strive to be worthy of it. I shall give my parents, teachers and all elders respect, and treat everyone with courtesy. To my country and my people, I pledge my devotion. In their well-being and prosperity alone lies my happiness. Prepared by State Council of Educational Research and Training (SCERT) Poojappura, Thiruvananthapuram 695012, Kerala Website : www.scertkerala.gov.in e-mail : [email protected] Phone : 0471 - 2341883, Fax : 0471 - 2341869 Typesetting and Layout : SCERT © Department of Education, Government of Kerala To be printed in quality paper - 80gsm map litho (snow-white) Foreword Dear learners, It is with immense pleasure and pride that State Council of Educational Research and Training (SCERT), Kerala brings forth its first textbook in Journalism for higher secondary students. We have been trying to set up a well structured syllabus and textbook for Journalism since the introduction of the course at the higher secondary level. Though we could frame a syllabus, we could not develop a textbook for Journalism all these years.
    [Show full text]
  • MCJ Programme
    SACRED HEART COLLEGE (AUTONOMOUS), THEVARA KOCHI, KERALA, 682013 CURRICULUM AND SYLLABI CHOICE BASED CREDIT AND SEMESTER SYSTEM (CBCSS) MASTER OF COMMUNICATION AND JOURNALISM (M.C.J) INTRODUCED FROM 2020 ADMISSION ONWARDS BOARD OF STUDIES IN COMMUNICATION AND JOURNALISM (PG) 2020 CONTENTS Sl. No. Content Page No. 1. Introduction 3 2. Regulations 6 3 POs and PSOs 18 3. Consolidated Scheme 19 4. Syllabus 20 2 INTRODUCTION Sacred Heart School of Communication (SHSC) was established as the Department of Communication of Sacred Heart College, Kochi in 2012 with a vision to make use of the reach of communication media in society and utilize their powers for common good. We give emphasis to develop a balanced sensibility and creative initiative among the Under Graduate and Post Graduate level students. The Master’s Programme in Communication and Journalism is intended to prepare students for professional practice through a curriculum that focuses on a balanced development of technical skills and theoretical understanding. The Programme is designed so as to accommodate the rapid changes in technology while maintaining a firm grounding in basic media principles and ethics. The scope of Journalism and Communication Studies has expanded in the recent years and it has found new dimensions with the advent of new media. The M.C.J Programme aims to impart quality education in Print/TV/Online journalism, advertising, PR and other areas of communication, thus molding professionals needed for the ever-expanding media industry. The Programme structure that blends theory and practical learning and industry interface provides ample space for specializations. Designed to meet global standards, this course fosters creative and responsible communication professionals, who will be the next generation journalists, copy writers, corporate communicators, PR professionals, visualizers and much more.
    [Show full text]
  • B.A. Malayalam & Mass Communication
    UNIVERSITY OF KERALA Career-related First Degree Programme Under CBCS System Group 2 - A Malayalam and Mass Communication 2014 admission onwards Course Structure & Syllabus Career related First Degree Programme under the Choice Based Credit and Semester (CBCS) System Programme - Group 2 - A Malayalam and Mass Communication Course Structure Semester Course Instructional Credit/ Page No. code Course title hours/weeks Course No L T P C EN 1111.1 Language Course I (English I) 5 - - 3 ML 1111.3 Lang. Course II (Adl.Lang.I) - KZy-km-lnXyw (KZy]Yw) 5-- 3 MX 1121 Foundation Course 1 k¿Km-fl-I-c-N\ 2-- 2 6 I MX 1141 Core Course 1 - tIcfkwkvImcw `mKw˛1 3-- 3 12 MX 1142 Core Course II - t\mhepw sNdp-I-Ybpw 2-- 2 14 MX 1171 Vocnl. Course I - Introduction to Mass Communication 3 - - 3 63 MX 1131 Compl. Course I - hnh¿Ø\w ˛ Bap-Jhpw Ncn-{Xhpw 5-- 4 56 BsI 25 - - 20 EN 1212.1 Lang. Course-III (English II) 5 - - 3 ML 1211.3 Lang. Course II (Addl. lang. II) - Zriy-IemkmlnXyw (Zr-iy-km-ln-Xn) 5-- 3 II MX 1241 Core Course II - ae-bmfIhnX ˛ ]q¿Δ-L´w 4-- 4 17 MX 1271 Vocnl.Course II- Malayalam Journalism 6 - - 4 64 MX 1231 Compl. Course II -hnh¿Ø-\- ]-T-\hpw kwkvIm-chpw 5-- 4 57 BsI 25 - - 18 EN 1311.1 Lang. Course V (English III) 5 - - 3 MX 1321 Foundation Course - II (Informatics)- III B[p\nI kmt¶XnI hnZybpw aebmf`mjm]T\hpw 3-- 3 8 MX 1341 Core Course IV - ]cnÿnXn: kn≤m¥hpw Bhnjv°mchpw 2-- 2 20 ML 1331 Core Course V - ZensXgpØv, s]sÆgpØv: kn≤m¥hpw Bhnjv°mchpw 3-- 3 23 Semester Course Course title Instructional Credit Page No.
    [Show full text]
  • Masculinity and the Structuring of the Public Domain in Kerala: a History of the Contemporary
    MASCULINITY AND THE STRUCTURING OF THE PUBLIC DOMAIN IN KERALA: A HISTORY OF THE CONTEMPORARY Ph. D. Thesis submitted to MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION (MAHE – Deemed University) RATHEESH RADHAKRISHNAN CENTRE FOR THE STUDY OF CULTURE AND SOCIETY (Affiliated to MAHE- Deemed University) BANGALORE- 560011 JULY 2006 To my parents KM Rajalakshmy and M Radhakrishnan For the spirit of reason and freedom I was introduced to… This work is dedicated…. The object was to learn to what extent the effort to think one’s own history can free thought from what it silently thinks, so enable it to think differently. Michel Foucault. 1985/1990. The Use of Pleasure: The History of Sexuality Vol. II, trans. Robert Hurley. New York: Vintage: 9. … in order to problematise our inherited categories and perspectives on gender meanings, might not men’s experiences of gender – in relation to themselves, their bodies, to socially constructed representations, and to others (men and women) – be a potentially subversive way to begin? […]. Of course the risks are very high, namely, of being misunderstood both by the common sense of the dominant order and by a politically correct feminism. But, then, welcome to the margins! Mary E. John. 2002. “Responses”. From the Margins (February 2002): 247. The peacock has his plumes The cock his comb The lion his mane And the man his moustache. Tell me O Evolution! Is masculinity Only clothes and ornaments That in time becomes the body? PN Gopikrishnan. 2003. “Parayu Parinaamame!” (Tell me O Evolution!). Reprinted in Madiyanmarude Manifesto (Manifesto of the Lazy, 2006). Thrissur: Current Books: 78.
    [Show full text]
  • When the King Turns Jester: a Carnivalesque Analysis of Police Outreach on Social Media in Kerala
    When the King turns Jester: A Carnivalesque Analysis of Police Outreach on Social Media in Kerala Drupa Dinnie Charles [0000-0002-6548-6887] and Joyojeet Pal [0000-0002-9076-2046] Microsoft Research Lab, Bengaluru 560001, India [email protected] Abstract. As bureaucratic organizations enter social media spaces for public out- reach, the organization of their communication assumes forms more suited to the needs, requirements and tastes of a digital society. Successfully interacting with new media users requires that the organization shed bureaucratic formality and appropriate a social media personality, with its language and viral digital arte- facts. The study examines the digital approach of the Kerala Police in its use of memes based on popular Malayalam cinema, a sub-literacy that the bureaucracy shares with the public. Using a mix of interpretive examination of memes and interviews with the police, we use a carnivalesque frame to highlight ways in which the Kerala Police subverts the negative discourses related to police identity and police-public interaction through comic memes. We propose that the choice of a means of outreach that has a greater affective impact on the middle-classes, rather than the poor, offers insight into a specific moment in state-citizen relations where a bureaucratic organization’s use of technology becomes the means of de- fining its approachability. This case also highlights the prerogative institutions have in creating solid online presences to deal with new forms of informational attacks that are enabled by viral social media. Keywords: Bureaucratic communication·Social media communication·Po- lice·Humour·Cinema·Facebook·Memes·Carnivalesque.
    [Show full text]
  • A Comparative Analysis of Kerala Floods Among English Newspapers
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH CULTURE SOCIETY ISSN: 2456-6683 Volume - 3, Issue - 4, Apr – 2019 Monthly, Peer-Reviewed, Refereed, Indexed Journal Impact Factor: 4.526 Publication Date: 30/04/2019 A comparative analysis of Kerala floods among English newspapers R. Venkatesh Aravindh Doctoral Research Scholar, Department of Journalism and Mass Communication Periyar University, Salem, TN, India - 636011 Email - [email protected] Abstract: Print media has had been a part of everyday lives of the people especially in a country like India. Print media also has been at the foreront of various issues and events. The newspapers played a vital role in bringing several issues to the forefront and serves a variety of purposes such as awareness creation, information dissemination. Kerala is a state that is often credited with high literacy levels. Kerala was ravaged by what was described as the worst floods ever in a century. The current research study explores the coverage given to Kerala floods by the English newspapers. The research study adopts quantitative research approaches in the form of content analysis to meet the objectives of the research study. Key Words: Print media, Newspapers, Coverage, Content analysis, Kerala floods. 1. INTRODUCTION: 1.1 Origin of Press in India: The printing press was introduced in India (1556 AD). Newspaper in India is also the outgrowth of the British rule. The first attempt or experiment to start a newspaper in Kolkata was made by William Bolts. James Aguste Hickey an Englishman started the first English Newspaper Bengal Gazette or Calcutta General Advertiser (1780) at Kolkata. 1.2 History of Print media in Kerala: The history of early Malayalam press and Printing started in Kerala in the 16th century.
    [Show full text]
  • Master of Arts Journalism and Mass Communication
    Master of Arts Journalism and Mass Communication PROGRAM STRUCTURE AND SYLLABUS 2019-20 ADMISSIONS ONWARDS (UNDER MAHATMA GANDHI UNIVERSITY PGCSS REGULATIONS 2019) EXPERT COMMITTEE IN JOURNALISM AND MASS COMMUNICATION (PG) MAHATMA GANDHI UNIVERSITY 2019 BOARD OF STUDIES IN JOURNALISM AND MASS COMMUNICATION (PG) PROGRAMME STRUCTURE & SYLLABUS PGCSS 2019-MAJMC Page 1 Chairperson: Prof. Madavana Balakrishna Pillai Director Institute of Communication and Journalism CPAS, Pullarikunnu Campus, Kottayam Members: 1. Dr. K.V Nagaraj Chairperson Mizoram Central University Aizawl-796 004 2. Dr. Nirmal Jacob HOD- DePaul Institute of Science and Technology (DIST) Angamaly 3. Shiby Joseph HOD- DB College Keezhoor PROGRAMME STRUCTURE & SYLLABUS PGCSS 2019-MAJMC Page 2 1. Aim of the Programme The main objective of the MAJMC programme is to prepare students for the exciting profession of Journalism, by meaningfully combining media theory and practice. The finished products are supposed to be socially responsible and responsive for the larger good of the people whom they serve, through the profession o f Journalism. 2. Eligibility for Admission: Any student with a bachelor’s degree in any subject with a minimum marks of 45 percent or as per the university regulations is eligible to apply for admission to the MAJMC programme. A relaxation of 5 percent of marks is given to SC and ST students to secure admission to the MAJMC programme. 3. Medium of Instruction and Assessment: The medium of instruction is English for the MAJMC programme except the elective course of Malayalam Journalism, the examination for which can be written in Malayalam only. 4. Faculty under which the Degree is awarded : Faculty of social science 5.
    [Show full text]
  • A Comparative Analysis of Kerala Floods Among Malayalam Newspapers
    American International Journal of Available online at http://www.iasir.net Research in Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences ISSN (Print): 2328-3734, ISSN (Online): 2328-3696, ISSN (CD-ROM): 2328-3688 AIJRHASS is a refereed, indexed, peer-reviewed, multidisciplinary and open access journal published by International Association of Scientific Innovation and Research (IASIR), USA (An Association Unifying the Sciences, Engineering, and Applied Research) A comparative analysis of Kerala floods among Malayalam newspapers R. Venkatesh Aravindh Doctoral Research Scholar, Department of Journalism and Mass Communication Periyar University, Salem, TN, India – 636011 Abstract: Print media has had been a part of everydaylives of the people especially in a country like India. Print media also has been at the foreront of various issues and events. The newspapersplayed a vital role in bringingseveral issues to the forefront and serves a variety of purposessuch as awarenesscreation, information dissemination. Kerala is a state thatisoftencreditedwith high literacylevels. Kerala wasravaged by whatwasdescribed as the worstfloodsever in a century. The currentresearchstudy explores the coveragegiven to Kerala floods by the Malayalamnewspapers. The researchstudyadopts quantitative researchapproaches in the form of content analysis to meet the objectives of the researchstudy. Keywords: Print media, Newspapers, Coverage, Content analysis, Kerala floods, I. INTRODUCTION A. Origin of the Press in India Gangadhara Bhattacharya and Harchandra Ray launched apaper from Kolkata Bengal Gazette (1816) in Bengali. It was the first Indian newspaper inIndian languages. Samachar Darpan weekly (1818) started for the first time in Bengali, whichbrought in ‘Indian Commerce’ among the other topics. At the First World War time a remarkablegrowth in the circulation of newspapers was witnessed.
    [Show full text]
  • Urbanization and Environment – Issues, Challenges and Potentials
    PROCEEDINGS OF KERALA ENVIRONMENT CONGRESS 2016 FOCAL THEME URBANIZation AND ENVIRONMENT ISSUES CHALLENGES AND POTENTIALS 28th & 29th November, 2016 at Energy Management Centre - Kerala Thiruvananthapuram Organised by CENTRE FOR ENVIRONMENT AND Development THIRUVANANTHAPURAM In Association with ENERGY Management CENTRE – Kerala Supported by Kerala State Council for Science Technology and Environment & Kerala State Biodiversity Board Proceedings of the Kerala Environment Congress - 2016 Editors Dr Vinod T R Dr T Sabu Dr Thrivikramji K P Dr Babu Ambat Published by Centre for Environment and Development Thozhuvancode, Vattiyoorkavu Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala, India-695013 Design & Pre-press Godfrey’s Graphics Sasthamangalam, Thiruvananthapuram Printed at Newmulti Offset, Thiruvananthapuram Kerala State Council for Science Technology & Environment Sasthrabhavan, Pattom P.O Thiruvananthapuram-695 004, Kerala, India Ph: +91471-2543557 (Direct), Fax: +91471-2540085 E-mail: [email protected] Official Email:[email protected] Dr. Suresh Das Executive Vice President FOREWORD Worldwide, rapid urbanization is leading to several challenges related to housing, infrastructure, encroachment of land, pollution, sewerage, waste and traffic management. In addition, the difficulties of providing sufficient jobs in urban areas has led to poverty, expanding slums and social unrest making urban governance a difficult task. This is especially true of the developing world and more so for the two rapidly developing countries, China and India. At present, more than half of the world’s population is living in small towns and cities with about half a million population. By 2050, the world population is projected to be 9.2 billion, of which 6.7 billion or 73% are estimated to live in urban areas.
    [Show full text]
  • At a Glance IPCNA at a Glance
    India Press Club of North America IPCNA At a glance IPCNA At a glance ndia Press Club of North America (IPCNA) Iis a professional media organization with a membership of those working in print, visual, online and social media platforms. It is the only organization for the Keralite media professionals in North America. Some of them own and operate their own media outlets. IPCNA was founded in New York 16 years ago by professionals who worked in various medias in India, who continued their passion for journalism in the US too. George Joseph, a veteran journal- ist, who worked in Malayala Manorama as a chief television, print and online media in Kerala on an sub editor, was the first president. He was also a ongoing basis. president of Kottayam Press Club. IPCNA’s ‘Madhyama Sree’ Award with a prize IPCNA has grown out of New York and es- money of one lakh rupees, for a senior journal- tablished across North America and established ist in Kerala for his/her contributions, is one of Chapters in addition to New York, Dallas, Texas, the most celebrated honors for media profession- Houston, Texas, Florida, Philadelphia, Detroit, als in Kerala. The winners are selected by noted Michigan, California, Canada and many more to judges, who are not connected to any media. Late come. Dr. Babu Paul always worked in the judging panel India Press Club is connected to mainstream and attended IPCNA events. India Press Club Of North America www.indiapressclubna.org The awards are presented at a grand pivotal role in launching Asianet chan- event at the IPCNA International Confer- nel in North America in 2003.
    [Show full text]
  • A Study on the Use of Social Media As a Tool of Citizen Journalism With
    Journal of Advanced Research in Journalism & Mass Communication Volume 5, Issue 4 - 2018, Pg. No. 50-53 Peer Review Journal Research Article A Study on the use of Social Media as a Tool of Citizen Journalism with Special Reference to the Updates on Kerala Flood Relief Sathya P Assistant Professor, Department of Visual Communication, Faculty of Science and Humanities, SRM Institute of Science and Technology. DOI: https://doi.org/10.24321/2395.3810.201819 Abstract Social networking is a unique platform for content sharing used by people all over the world irrespective of vast differences in language, culture and societal norms. The connectivity, flexibility and ease of access have lead to the utilization of these social networks as a tool of citizen journalism. Now-a-days, people exhibit their social responsibility by informing or reporting about the problems in the society through these social networks that reaches the masses which in turn makes press and media, government officials and authorities to look into the issue. Kerala, famously called as “The God’s own Country” is facing its worst time ever with the pouring rainfall, flooding rivers, landslides and people are losing their lives, getting displaced and are being accommodated in several camps in the state. In this situation, people in and around Kerala is using social media to organise, collect, and distribute the relief funds and materials required in different locations. It is noted that immediate requirements are informed to people through social media and it is being fulfilled at the earliest. The purpose of this study is to explore the utilization of social networks as the journalistic tool by the citizens and attempt to sooth the hardships faced by the people.
    [Show full text]