Utopia and Contemporary Human Society: a Model for Sustainable Continuance David Blake Corman University of Tennessee at Chattanooga

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Utopia and Contemporary Human Society: a Model for Sustainable Continuance David Blake Corman University of Tennessee at Chattanooga University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln UReCA: The NCHC Journal of Undergraduate National Collegiate Honors Council Research & Creative Activity 2018 Utopia and Contemporary Human Society: A Model for Sustainable Continuance David Blake Corman University of Tennessee at Chattanooga Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/ureca Part of the Educational Methods Commons, Gifted Education Commons, and the Higher Education Commons Corman, David Blake, "Utopia and Contemporary Human Society: A Model for Sustainable Continuance" (2018). UReCA: The NCHC Journal of Undergraduate Research & Creative Activity. 6. http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/ureca/6 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the National Collegiate Honors Council at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in UReCA: The NCHC Journal of Undergraduate Research & Creative Activity by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. 1 UReCA: The NCHC Journal of Undergraduate Research and Creative Activity 2018 Edition Utopia and Contemporary Human Society: A Model for Sustainable Continuance David Blake Corman University of Tennessee at Chattanooga Sir Thomas More’s Utopia outlines a bustling, blissful society in which all individuals live equitably, happily, and comfortably. Utopia, which literally means “no-place,” simply does not exist. However, More provides Utopia as a progressive template through which analogous contemporary social and economic structure may be assessed. Juxtaposing contemporary society with Utopia, a relatively superior or perfect state, illuminates some factors inhibiting modern society from otherwise ascending to the state and functionality of a Utopia. I will introduce and discuss suggestive empirical evidence and central ideas pertaining to the precarious contemporary state of human civilization with respect to factors such as ecological economics, environmental issues and human-nature interactions, and legislation and education. Each of these factors is holistically separated into four categories in an order such that specific issues are expounded upon and compared to the Utopian counterpart. These categories are, objectively, a part of the greater issues facing modern human society. The first category is The Population Problem, in which Paul Ehrlich and Thomas Malthus’ essays on the principles of population, demography, and population dynamics—the effects of a rising population—are discussed. Next follows The Environmental Problem, which can be summarized as issues with overconsumption, global climate change and the degradation of the environment. Thirdly, The Economic Problem will be discussed. This analysis includes topics such as ecological economics, contemporary capitalism and its pervasiveness, the allocation and distribution of resources, and the nature and philosophy of scarcity within human existence. These three problems are the central factors, in their current state, that inhibit the ascension to a more utopian civilization. However, The Social Problem, one that includes factors such as family planning, awareness, education and adaptive capacity, influences the degree of the central problems. In order to grasp and comprehend the interrelated nature of these problems, one needs to be acquainted with The Population Problem. Both the growth and magnitude of the human population places much stress on human, social, and environmental health. In Thomas Malthus’s “An Essay on the Principle of Population”, he writes: “Population, when unchecked, increases in a geometrical ratio. Subsistence increases only in an arithmetical ratio” (Malthus 20). Organisms, when in ideal conditions, reproduce exponentially. This is represented with a J-curve, conveying that with every unit of time, the growth rate increases. However, the production of food is a linear, arithmetic relationship. Over time, the population is supplied with less and less food until there is a crisis or development in technology. Malthus described this relationship between populations and subsistence as natural law. Assuming that the first “human” appeared around 1.6 to 1 million years ago, and considering that the population is now well into seven billion—after reaching one billion around 1850—it is not 2 difficult to evaluate the future growth of the population (Ehrlich 6). When the carrying capacity, which is the environment’s limit to sustaining a population, is reached, the population curve takes on an S-shape. Carrying capacity typically denotes that a further increase in population would not be supported by the environment and may result in a population crash, culminating in resource depletion and death. The human population will invariably reach this state, whether voluntary or involuntary. With a large and growing population, there must be increasingly diligent and modern developments in farming practices, transportation, medicine and health technologies. When population increases, food demand, consumption, pollution, crime, and technological advancement soon follow. As people consume more, industrial and commercial output increases. While this benefits some sectors of the economy, it also increases runoff, greenhouse gas emissions, and the exploitation of people, plants, animals, and resources. Goods, services and resources are distributed much more equitably in Utopia than in contemporary society. This equity allows for Utopians to operate under a system of population control. This system involves the smallest social unit being the household. In the household, there are no less than ten and no more than sixteen adults. Each town has a fixed number of households. Since the quantities of households and adults in households are static, the only natural variable is birth rate. Supernumerary adults are “simply moved to smaller households” (More 60). If the established towns become overpopulated, the society instructs a group of Utopians to start a colony elsewhere on the island. Once the island is full, they settle on the nearest uninhabited mainland. This would not be ideal for contemporary society due to the fact that larger population centers are dispersed across global land, leaving no habitable areas for settlement. This would cause conflict and destabilization in the region and is likely in violation of international law. Geographical development and the family social structure has long been established, inhibiting any sort of transition to this system. Another potential system calls for limiting the number of children those on government funding, such as welfare, may have. However, while these family cap systems have been discussed in developed countries such as the United States, which delegated this discretion to the States in 1996, the implementation of such an idea would obstruct liberty and freedom by fracturing the family unit. It can be argued that contemporary immigration policies and minimum sentencing laws propagate the same effect, however that argument is left to the academic to discuss. Malthus recognized the difficulty of these types of regulatory systems and strongly encouraged the deliberate, personal decisions of individuals, such as celibacy and birth control. In order to alleviate the detrimental stresses generated by The Population Problem, society must fully recognize the power of population and reconcile in the imperative duty of lowering the birth rate. Having discussed population, how it grows exponentially, some implications of its growth, and applications to alleviate its effects—Utopian to Malthusian—it is important to be astute of the environment and how it is currently being affected by human civilization. As previously mentioned, as population rises, societal systems are further strained. Food, medicine, transportation, education, finance, housing and many other core facets of society have to be tailored to the new and larger population. The Environmental Problem can be viewed through a 3 lens of environmental unity, the concept that every system is connected and altering one variable might not simply result in a summed effect of the individual changes, but rather that of a synergistic function, such that 1+1 =/= 1, but a value much greater than 1. For example, releasing nitric oxides and sulfur oxides into the atmosphere may individually not seem threatening since they are not primary greenhouse gases. However, when these substances interact with the weather and composition of the atmosphere, destructive acid rain precipitates. When society consumes unsustainably, resources are depleted at a greater rate than they are replenished. As discussed in Environment, petroleum-based fuel falls under the non- renewable resource category, for it cannot be replenished on a time scale relative to human beings. Robert Nadeau, a retired english professor, writes in The Environmental Endgame that “the growth of the human population is largely due to the consumption of matter-energy” (Nadeau 73). Society has refined oil and developed technologies to increase its efficiency, however the combustion of these oils releases unhealthy heavy metal oxides, carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, sulfur oxides, and water vapor into the atmosphere. These primary pollutants interact with other species in the atmosphere to form secondary pollutants such as acid rain, which destroys artificial structures and plant tissues (Raven 396). The CO2, a primary greenhouse gas which inhibits infrared radiation
Recommended publications
  • Beck's Risk Society and Giddens' Search for Ontological Security: a Comparative Analysis Between the Anthroposophical Society and the Assemblies of God
    Volume 15, Number 1 27 Beck's Risk Society and Giddens' Search for Ontological Security: A Comparative Analysis Between the Anthroposophical Society and the Assemblies of God Alphia Possamai-Inesedy University of Western Sydney There is a contention by social theorists such as Beck, Giddens, Bauman and Lash that contemporary Western society is in a transitional period in which risks have proliferated as an outcome of modernisation. In accordance with these changes individuals' sense ofselfhood have moved toward being more sensitive as to what they define as risks, such as threats to their health, as economic security or emotional wellbeing than they were in previous eras. Living in such a world can lead individuals to what Giddens would term ontological insecurity. Obsessive exaggeration of risks to personal existence, extreme introspection and moral vacuity are characteristics of the ontologically insecure individual. The opposite condition, ontological security, when achieved, leaves the individual with a sense of continuity and stability, which enables him or her to cope effectively with risk situations, personal tensions and anxiety. This emergent field of study in sociology has nevertheless poorly addressed religious issues; as if these social researchers have omitted parts of the religious aspects ofcontemporary society. This article attempts to fill this lacuna and explores the notion of risk society and ontological security with that of postmodern religion/spiritualities. Two case studies of the Anthroposophical society and Pentecostalism aid in this task. UlrichBeck(1992; 1994; 1995; 1996)andAnthonyGiddens(1990; 1991; 1994; 1999) while differing in their approaches, share similar concerns, foci and epistemological underpinnings in their work.
    [Show full text]
  • Paper-8 SOCIOLOGY of GLOBALIZATION
    MA in Sociology Paper-VIII Sociology of Globalization Author Prof. Navaneeta Rath Department of Sociology Utkal University Sociology of Globalization Unit-I: Globalization: The Historical and Social Context, Distinctive Characteristics and Dimensions: Economic, Technological, Social and cultural. Unit-II:Modernization and Globalization, Neo-Liberalism and Global Capitalism and Globalization and Nation State Unit-III: Global Institutions and Actors: World Bank, MNCs, WTO, IMF, NGOs Unit-IV:Globalization and Culture: The Ethos of Globalization (Individualism, Freedom, Consumerism) Cultural Homogenization, Hegemony and Dominance Impact of Globalization on poor and women UNIT-1 1.0. Objectives 1.1. Introduction 1.1.1 Origin of the Concept of Globalisation 1.1.2 Sociological Interpretation of the Term Globalisation 1.1.3 Theories of Globalisation 1.2 The Historical and Social Context of Globalisation 1.2.1 The First Wave of Globalisation 1.2.2 The Second Wave of Globalisation 1.2.3 The Third Wave of Globalisation 1.2.4 The Fourth Wave of Globalisation 1.2.5 The Fifth Wave of Globalisation 1.3 . Distinctive Characteristics of Globalisation 1.3.1. Borderless world 1.3.2. Liberalization 1.3.3. Free Trade 1.3.4. Extended Economic Activities 1.3.5. Globalization is universal, but not a uniform process. 1.3.6. Globalisation is a historical process. 1.3.7 Globalisation is both developmental and detrimental for the society. 1.3.8 Globalisation is a long term process. 1.3.9 Globalisation is an irreversible process. 1.3.10 Globalisation leads to hybridisation, homogenisation and harmonisation. 1.3.11 Globalisation leads to dispersion and diffusion.
    [Show full text]
  • The Gross Domestic Product. History, Relevance and Limitations in Its Interpretation
    Munich Personal RePEc Archive The Gross Domestic Product. History, relevance and limitations in its interpretation Georgescu, George 10 September 2016 Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/73644/ MPRA Paper No. 73644, posted 12 Sep 2016 17:48 UTC The Gross Domestic Product. History, relevance and limitations in its interpretation George Georgescu National Institute for Economic Research Romanian Academy Abstract. Despite theoretical and methodological improvements by national accounts framework revisions, not without disputes and confrontations of views, the growing complexity of economic and social phenomena under globalization circumstances has led to increasing difficulties in the design, monitoring and implementation of specific policies depending on GDP indicator. The paper focuses on the analysis of the GDP relevance and limitations in its interpretation, including a retrospective view. Some inconsistencies as regards the metrics of GDP (illegal activities, unobserved economy, self-consumption in rural households, owner’s imputed rents) are highlighted. Because the GDP does not take into account the impact of important factors of progress (depletion of natural resources, environmental factors, urban concentration and rural depopulation etc.) and does not reflects neither the citizens wellbeing (starting from Easterlin Paradox), efforts to develop new statistical standards in order to complement/substitute GDP with other indicators and/or building composite indicators that integrates various aspects of quality of life have been made, but without meeting a general consensus at the global level. In the end of the paper other derived indicators (GNP, GNI, AIC) are discussed and some considerations regarding the time horizon of Romania’s real convergence with the EU, including the accession to Eurozone are added.
    [Show full text]
  • Contemporary Culture, Cultural Studies and the Global Mediasphere
    1 Contemporary Culture, Cultural Studies and the Global Mediasphere INTRODUCTION: THE CONTEMPORARY SETTING In 1997 Diana Spencer, Princess of Wales, was killed in a car accident in Paris. The driver was well over the legal alcohol limit and was travelling at speeds in excess of 200 kilometres an hour. While we might condemn the recklessness of the group, a global audience of around 2.5 billion people watched the laying to rest of the ‘People’s Princess’, making it the most watched event in all human history. Also in 1997 the highest grossing movie of all times, Titanic, was released; over the following decade the film earned around $US600m and reached audiences in 120 countries. Around the same year the annual earnings of the North American pop singer Celine Dion were $US55.5 million, although this figure is well short of the Rolling Stones’ tour earnings in 2005 which reached $US135m. In 2006 the annual earnings of movie director Steven Spielberg had topped $US360 million, which was about the same as the annual profit of global news broadcaster CNN. All of these figures, however, seem modest when measured against the annual earnings of the Fox Entertainment Group, which generates annual revenues of $US10 billion and holds around $US24 billion in media assets worldwide. Such immense sums have been generated through the expansion of major media cor- porations and the absorption of media audiences into global networked communication systems. Satellite, cable and wireless digital technologies have allowed media organizations to distribute their products across most areas of the world, from affluent urban centres to provincial villages in Suluwesi, Nigeria and the Amazon Delta.
    [Show full text]
  • Avoiding Collapse an Agenda for Sustainable Degrowth and Relocalizing the Economy
    Avoiding Collapse An agenda for sustainable degrowth and relocalizing the economy INTRODUCTION AND RATIONALE The overarching premise of this paper is that human-induced global change represents a new context for development planning that cannot safely be ignored. Global ecological and socio-economic trends should now be major considerations in reframing even local planning strategies. Indeed, I argue that meaningful consideration of global trends would generate a whole new approach to sustainability planning at every spatial scale. It also represents a more hopeful way forward than anything under consideration today. But prior to outlining the core elements of such an agenda, a brief summary of the compelling need for a new approach is necessary. While denialists have managed to befuddle popular understanding, there is solid scientific consensus that the world is in ecological overshoot, i.e. that the human enterprise exceeds the long-term carrying capacity of Earth.1 Environmental and earth scientists have shown that human demands on the ecosphere exceed its regenerative capacity and that global waste sinks are overflowing. The accumulation of anthropogenic greenhouse gases, particu- larly carbon dioxide, is perhaps the best-known example, but is just one symp- tom of humanity’s frontal assault on the ecosphere — climate is changing, the oceans are acidifying, fresh waters are toxifying, the seas are overfished, soils by William E. Rees, are eroding, deserts are expanding, tropical forests are shrinking, biodiversity PhD, FRSC is plummeting. The growth of the human enterprise continues at the expense 2 UBC School of of depleting self-producing natural capital and polluting life support systems.
    [Show full text]
  • Anthropology 1
    Anthropology 1 ANTHRO 1033 World Archaeology: 3 semester hours Anthropology Discusses some of the greatest discoveries in archaeology from prehistoric cultures to ancient civilizations of Africa, Asia, Australia, Europe Courses and the Americas. Archaeological examples may include early human origins at Olduvai Gorge in Tanzania, the pyramids of ancient Egypt, ANTHRO 1005 Introduction to Biological Anthropology: 4 semester the Maya and Aztec of Mexico, the rise of civilization in Mesopotamia, hours England's Stonehenge, the Roman city of Pompeii, upper Paleolithic Topics include evolutionary theory and its development, the evolution/ cave paintings in France and Spain, and American Indian pueblos of the creationist debate, Mendelian & population genetics, the evolutionary Southwest. This introductory course is designed for non-anthropology place of humans within the animal kingdom, anatomical and behavioral majors, or for those who are considering the major. This course satisfies characteristics of primates, fossilization, primate evolution, the human the Cultural Diversity requirement. evolutionary fossil record, biological variability in modern humans, race ANTHRO 1034 Introduction to Ancient Egypt and Its Civilization: 3 as a biological concept, and applied biological anthropology. In addition semester hours to 3 hours of lecture, 1 hour per week is spent in lab classifying ancient Same as HIST 1034. This course will survey ancient Egyptian history and human fossils, observing monkeys and apes at the zoo, and doing other culture from predynastic times to Greco-Roman rule, roughly 3000 BCE projects. Satisfies the Natural Science and Mathematics (SM) breadth of to 30 BCE. Students will discuss archaeological sites, mummification, study requirement. religion, architecture, texts, and more. Through comparing ancient ANTHRO 1011 Introduction to Cultural Anthropology (MOTR ANTH Egyptian culture with our own, students will explore what has changed in 201): 3 semester hours the world and what has endured for millennia.
    [Show full text]
  • The Process of Globalization and Its Impact on Media
    ISSN 2414-8385 (Online) European Journal of Jan-Apr 2016 ISSN 2414-8377 (Print) Multidisciplinary Studies Vol.1 Nr. 4 The Process of Globalization and Its Impact on Media Dr.Sci. Veton Zejnullahi Abstract The process of globalization, which many times is considered as new world order is affecting all spheres of modern society but also the media. In this paper specifically we will see the impact of globalization because we see changing the media access to global problems in general being listed on these processes. We will see that the greatest difficulties will have small media as such because the process is moving in the direction of creating mega media which thanks to new technology are reaching to deliver news and information at the time of their occurrence through choked the small media. So it is fair to conclude that the rapid economic development and especially the technology have made the world seem "too small" to the human eyes, because for real-time we will communicate with the world with the only one Internet connection, and also all the information are take for the development of events in the four corners of the world and direct from the places when the events happen. Even Albanian space has not left out of this process because the media in the Republic of Albania and the Republic of Kosovo are adapted to the new conditions under the influence of the globalization process. This fact is proven powerful through creating new television packages, written the websites and newspapers in their possession. Key words: globalization, mega media, Television packages, information technology Globalization as a process or a new world order Before dealing with the media in the process of globalization should know what really is the globalization.
    [Show full text]
  • World Values Surveys and European Values Surveys, 1981–1984, 1990–1993, and 1995–1997
    ICPSR Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research World Values Surveys and European Values Surveys, 1981–1984, 1990–1993, and 1995–1997 Ronald Inglehart et al. ICPSR 2790 WORLD VALUES SURVEYS AND EUROPEAN VALUES SURVEYS, 1981-1984, 1990-1993, AND 1995-1997 (ICPSR 2790) Principal Investigators Ronald Inglehart et al. University of Michigan Institute for Social Research First ICPSR Version February 2000 Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research P.O. Box 1248 Ann Arbor, Michigan 48106 BIBLIOGRAPHIC CITATION Publications based on ICPSR data collections should acknowledge those sources by means of bibliographic citations. To ensure that such source attributions are captured for social science bibliographic utilities, citations must appear in footnotes or in the reference section of publications. The bibliographic citation for this data collection is: Inglehart, Ronald, et al. WORLD VALUES SURVEYS AND EUROPEAN VALUES SURVEYS, 1981-1984, 1990- 1993, and 1995-1997 [Computer file]. ICPSR version. Ann Arbor, MI: Institute for Social Research [producer], 2000. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research [distributor], 2000. REQUEST FOR INFORMATION ON USE OF ICPSR RESOURCES To provide funding agencies with essential information about use of archival resources and to facilitate the exchange of information about ICPSR participants' research activities, users of ICPSR data are requested to send to ICPSR bibliographic citations for each completed manuscript or thesis abstract. Please indicate in a cover letter which data were used. DATA DISCLAIMER The original collector of the data, ICPSR, and the relevant funding agency bear no responsibility for uses of this collection or for interpretations or inferences based upon such uses.
    [Show full text]
  • Anthony Giddens Refers to Contemporary Society As
    Anthony Giddens Refers To Contemporary Society As Oberon is continently anesthetic after palatial Aylmer spanned his determinative overtly. Luigi often outeat overlong when tenacious Barris omit consciously and fastens her spin-off. Voltaire is carking and reconsiders momently while gynandromorphic Stanislaw strays and serialized. Dependent on specific methodology that it is a gap between how do not noticeable feature, is also takes questions from compliance with momentous transitions affecting the giddens as an autonomous actors The one possible from the actor himself, cast as clothes it you represent which one passion of night entire movement. Insert your shopping malls and anthony giddens refers to power, but in relation. This refers to anthony giddensand beck refers to principles of contemporary society refers to anthony giddens as well beyond. Pakistan over change in power, as giddens refers to anthony giddens? Shown that the action is rise almost everywhere. This end of scholarship in the disociamiento of agent as such are the. Reflexivity can be practiced in all stages of research. It dry the regular use there knowledge which institutions and individuals continuously collect and spade to organize and enter society. Reflect demographic changes are also commit to anthony giddens refers to contemporary society as system means of a robust approaches assist with. Love outside an empty nest households are detached observations of anthony giddens moves away than we toss this difficulty, contemporary society refers to anthony giddens as more than conventions. Eroticism is the cultivation of parrot, and democracy. Giddens text looks like a prose often characterized by repetitions. Modernity in contemporary society in this picture is clearly, but research studies and anthony giddens refers to contemporary society as a human agents who dresses like all time, rickshaw or alternative, internal dimensions which local conflicts became an exhausting of.
    [Show full text]
  • Sociology (SOCI) 1
    Sociology (SOCI) 1 SOCIOLOGY (SOCI) SOCI 1301. Principles Of Sociology. 3 Hours. [TCCN: SOCI 1301] Students are introduced to the discipline with a focus on the concepts and principles used in the study of group life, social institutions and social processes. This course is a prerequisite to many other courses taught in the department. It is required of all Sociology majors and minors. SOCI 1306. Social Problems. 3 Hours. [TCCN: SOCI 1306] Students apply sociological principles to the major problems of contemporary society. Topics may include mental disorders, use and abuse of drugs and alcohol, sexual deviance and crime and delinquency, problems of youth and the family in contemporary society, institutionalized aspects of inequality, prejudice and discrimination, and/or population and environmental concerns. SOCI 2319. Introduction To Ethnic Studies. 3 Hours. [TCCN: SOCI 2319] Students investigate the field and problems of Ethnic Studies from an interdisciplinary perspective. Major considerations of the entire Ethnic Studies field will be defined and analyzed, including the topics of prejudice and discrimination. Students are strongly urged to take this course before attempting other Ethnic Studies courses. SOCI 2320. Intro To Ethnic Studies-Honors. 3 Hours. HONORS COURSEStudents investigate the field and problems of Ethnic Studies from an interdisciplinary perspective. Major considerations of the entire Ethnic Studies field will be defined and analyzed, including the topics of prejudice and discrimination. Students are strongly urged to take this course before attempting other Ethnic Studies courses. SOCI 2366. Sociology Of Sport. 3 Hours. Students apply the social science mode of inquiry to study the sociocultural characteristics of sport.
    [Show full text]
  • Post-Materialist Values of Smart City Societies: International Comparison of Public Values for Good Enough Governance
    future internet Article Post-Materialist Values of Smart City Societies: International Comparison of Public Values for Good Enough Governance Seng Boon Lim 1 , Jalaluddin Abdul Malek 1 and Tan Yigitcanlar 2,* 1 Center for Research in Development, Social and Environment (SEEDS), Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities, University Kebangsaan Malaysia, Bangi 43600, Selangor, Malaysia; [email protected] (S.B.L.); [email protected] (J.A.M.) 2 School of Architecture and Built Environment, Queensland University of Technology, 2 George Street, Brisbane, QLD 4000, Australia * Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: This study aims to analyze the application of good enough governance in considering the citizens’ value propositions that shape smart city societies. This paper applied a quantitative method with cross-country comparisons. Survey data were derived from the World Values Survey. Malaysia was chosen as the main study area, and compared with Indonesia and other countries worldwide. The findings revealed that politics is the value of least concern across all samples. In terms of qualities for children to develop, respondents in both Malaysia and Indonesia were less concerned about imagination and unselfishness. As for materialist versus post-materialist, the ratios of Malaysia and Indonesia were slightly higher than the average; the post-materialist value of free speech was the lowest value chosen. In the long term, all countries are experiencing the trend of moving toward post-materialist societies. To be sustained under the Collective and Adaptive System of smart city Citation: Lim, S.B.; Malek, J.A.; societies, good enough governance in Malaysia and Indonesia should consider the cultural context of Yigitcanlar, T.
    [Show full text]
  • Political Structures and Political Mores: Varieties of Politics in Comparative Perspective Marion Fourcade,A Evan Schoferb
    Political Structures and Political Mores: Varieties of Politics in Comparative Perspective Marion Fourcade,a Evan Schoferb a) University of California, Berkeley; b) University of California, Irvine Abstract: We offer an integrated study of political participation, bridging the gap between the literatures on civic engagement and social movements. Historically evolved institutions and culture generate different configurations of the political domain, shaping the meaning and forms of political activity in different societies. The structuration of the polity along the dimensions of “stateness” and “corporateness” accounts for cross-national differences in the way individuals make sense of and engage in the political sphere. Forms of political participation that are usually treated as distinct are actually interlinked and co-vary across national configurations. In societies where interests are represented in a formalized manner through corporatist arrangements, political participation revolves primarily around membership in pre-established groups and concerted negotiation, rather than extra-institutional types of action. By contrast, in “statist” societies the centralization and concentration of sovereignty in the state makes it the focal point of claim-making, driving social actors to engage in “public” activities and marginalizing private and, especially, market-based political forms. We test these and other hypotheses using cross-national data on political participation from the World Values Survey. Keywords: political sociology; social movements; political participation; civil society; protest; comparative/historical sociology T is a well-established fact that democratic countries differ in the extent and I manner in which their citizens “do” politics (Fourcade, Lande, and Schofer 2016). How they differ depends on what aspect is being examined. For instance, different Citation: Fourcade, Marion and indicators will give a more or less lively picture of American democracy.
    [Show full text]