Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation 2016

Local Analysis – West

1

Introduction

The latest Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) 2016 was launched by the on 31st August 2016. Previous SIMDs were published in 2004, 2006, 2009 and 2012. The data zone boundaries for this publication were redrawn following the 2011 census; reflecting population shifts since 2001. These differ from the 2001 data zones which were used for previous SIMD editions. Therefore, direct comparisons of indicators between 2016 and previous years are not possible.

SIMD 2016 – Context

The SIMD 2016 provides an analysis of deprivation across based on 6,976 data zone areas across Scotland. This is an increase of 471 data zones from the last SIMD publication in 2012.

The SIMD identifies small area concentrations of multiple deprivation across all of Scotland in a consistent way. This is achieved by dividing Scotland into 6,976 small areas called data zones, each with roughly the same population size and characteristics. The index then ranks these data zones from most to least deprived based on 7 aspects of deprivation – Income, Employment, Health, Education, Access to services, Crime and Housing.

The average number of people living in each data zone is around 700. The SIMD shows where Scotland’s most deprived areas are, so organisations know where their work can have the biggest impact.

CAVEATS:

 It is a relative measure of deprivation across small areas in Scotland  It looks at multiple deprivation. ‘Deprived’ does not just mean ‘poor’ or ‘low income’  It can also mean people have fewer resources and opportunities, for example in health and education.

What the SIMD can be used for What the SIMD cannot be used for:  Comparing overall deprivation of  Saying how much more deprived one area is from another small areas – the difference between two ranks can be tiny or large   Comparing the seven domains of  Comparing ranks over time – changes are relative and deprivation may not reflect actual changes in the neighbourhood (note  this when looking at local share of most deprived data  Comparing the proportion of small zones) areas in a council that are very deprived  Comparing with other UK countries – each country  measures deprivation slightly differently  Finding areas where many people experience multiple deprivation  Identifying all people who are deprived in Scotland – not  everyone who is deprived lives in a deprived area  Finding areas of greater need for support and intervention  Finding affluent areas – lack of deprivation is not the same as being rich

2

West Dunbartonshire

The following table demonstrates the change in the number of data zones at national and local level from the 2012 SIMD to the 2016 SIMD.

Area 2001 data zones 2011 data zones Difference 118 121 + 3 Scotland 6,505 6,976 + 471

Local Share: 48 West Dunbartonshire data zones - which equates to 40% of all data zones in our area - are within the 20% most deprived.

Our National Share is 3.4% of all data zones in Scotland.

This is not directly comparable with the local share of the 20% most deprived in SIMD 2012.

The following chart shows the share across the deciles for West Dunbartonshire data zones.

Nationally the focus is on the analysis of the 20% most deprived so the following profile is consistent with that.

3

The map below displays in red the data zones within West Dunbartonshire that are ranked within the 20% most deprived in Scotland.

As can be seen from this map, these data zones tend to be clustered within specific small areas.

The following table demonstrates those data zones that are ranked within the 20% most deprived in Scotland. It also shows where these data zones rank under the individual domains. They have been aligned to Community Council area within West Dunbartonshire, which are broadly reflective of the Intermediate Zones used for aggregating data.

Data zones that are not ranked within the 20% most deprived overall have been excluded. The following Community Council areas have no data zones within the 20% most deprived.  East and Central  Kilmaronock  Milton and Bowling   Silverton and Overtoun

See appendix one for a heat map of all West Dunbartonshire data zones.

4

WD CC areas containing data zones ranked within the 20% most Deprived in Scotland.

Community

Overall SIMD Rank Employment Income Education Health Access Crime Housing Council Area Data Zone

S01013228 1067 1206 996 1040 1135 6915 300 1350 Alexandria S01013231 1236 1042 1193 2211 769 4594 1412 2386 S01013227 807 619 772 1723 784 4021 731 3213 S01013238 573 511 876 550 592 2262 1243 1286 Balloch and S01013240 448 530 448 649 304 2391 2883 1633 Haldane S01013239 423 445 288 1048 646 1390 1825 4136 S01013219 1022 1301 763 1130 1670 1556 3155 531

Alexandria S01013216 1068 1536 633 1436 1615 1492 2657 1276 and S01013225 758 1165 624 566 857 1993 2351 1501 Dalmonach S01013218 767 1166 730 426 1102 1512 2121 1511 S01013220 862 873 833 818 1636 3360 456 1600 S01013128 1019 949 1104 1890 1216 2599 538 464 S01013127 452 868 526 380 549 992 548 1105 S01013126 443 779 463 523 478 911 1099 1180 East S01013122 306 174 442 529 791 4598 129 1537 S01013123 1371 1238 1299 1596 2435 2439 706 2023 S01013167 92 50 161 161 207 5169 311 701 S01013132 912 698 962 1269 812 4081 3702 712 S01013170 663 706 511 689 1223 2592 2449 1132 and S01013166 104 75 63 754 139 5708 247 1399 Mountblow S01013169 836 689 911 857 1016 3013 2146 1772

S01013168 1348 1150 1143 2452 1287 3415 1610 2244 S01013133 969 692 844 1975 934 4831 1658 2321 and S01013162 1198 1147 1119 2496 1104 1403 2276 1296 S01013155 831 1219 737 954 1025 949 2366 765 S01013156 597 925 430 1099 506 1494 2602 927 Clydebank S01013153 743 1103 683 552 1418 1047 1554 1227 S01013157 732 759 679 999 886 1551 3040 1734 S01013154 1381 1513 1305 2056 1490 1333 1548 2041 S01013135 83 100 71 348 140 2403 674 675 S01013139 409 364 339 608 844 4178 664 1156 Linnvale and S01013138 138 202 155 305 115 3311 170 1582 S01013140 618 580 565 1521 488 4629 608 1620 S01013129 1130 1318 1237 3249 819 1538 135 2034 Parkhall, North S01013130 299 500 105 638 723 4401 439 863 Kilbowie and S01013141 1304 1198 1004 2087 1283 4467 1395 1771 Central S01013142 839 540 880 1286 895 4247 2177 1952 Dumbarton S01013186 1099 1183 758 1632 1390 2622 2355 1657 North S01013184 603 620 628 1080 805 1743 728 1797

S01013203 559 301 873 1839 940 1042 411 1195 S01013206 1203 882 1381 1572 1672 2776 1103 1253 Dumbarton S01013202 869 628 1343 1279 1181 2619 256 1508 West S01013205 219 291 343 84 545 1277 812 1527 S01013201 127 270 201 109 67 2319 377 1649 S01013200 1213 947 943 2625 1561 4567 620 1966 Dumbarton S01013222 593 523 513 2305 264 4924 872 1984 Renton S01013207 1353 1308 1167 2311 981 2851 2357 2586 S01013208 749 648 864 1144 681 4732 361 2990

Colour % Deprived 5%

10%

15%

20%

Out with 20%

5

SIMD Domains

The Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) combines seven different domains (aspects) of deprivation:

 Income  Employment  Health  Education, Skills and Training  Geographic Access to Services  Crime  Housing

These domains make up a percentage of the overall SIMD as demonstrated in the chart below:

Percentage of overall SIMD: Domains

2% Income 5% 9% Employment 28% Health 14% Education, Skills and Training

Geographical Access to Services 14% 28% Crime

Housing

The following table shows how many of our 121 data zones are within the 20% most deprived in relation to each of the SIMD domains. It also show the most deprived data zone for each of the domains and the Community Council Area that data zone is located. No. of DZ in lowest most deprived Community Council Area covering Domain quintile % data zone most deprived data zone Income 49 40% S01013166 Dalmuir & Mountblow Employment 50 41% S01013167 Dalmuir & Mountblow Health 46 38% S01013201 Dumbarton West Education, Skills 30 25% S01013205 Dumbarton West and Training Geographical Access to 24 20% S01013214 Bonhill & Dalmonach Services Crime 36 30% S01013195 Dumbarton East and Central Housing 23 19% S01013128 Clydebank East

6

Further Information

Information about the SIMD including reports, guidance and mapping is available at:

1. National analysis of SIMD http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Topics/Statistics/SIMD/ 2. National mapping of SIMD http://simd.scot

Contact: Amanda Coulthard [email protected]

7

SIMD 2016 West Dunbartonshire Heat Map Appendix 1

SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 Working Overall Employm Income Educatio Health Access Crime Housing Populatio _Age_Po ComCouncil DZ Rank ent Rank Rank n Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank n pulation Linnvale and Drumry S01013135 83 100 71 348 140 2,403 674 675 751 502 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013167 92 50 161 161 207 5,169 311 701 607 432 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013166 104 75 63 754 139 5,708 247 1,399 630 443 Dumbarton West S01013201 127 270 201 109 67 2,319 377 1,649 752 496 Linnvale and Drumry S01013138 138 202 155 305 115 3,311 170 1,582 690 446 Dumbarton West S01013205 219 291 343 84 545 1,277 812 1,527 567 344 Parkhall, North Kilbowie and Central S01013130 299 500 105 638 723 4,401 439 863 533 372 Clydebank East S01013122 306 174 442 529 791 4,598 129 1,537 491 334 Linnvale and Drumry S01013139 409 364 339 608 844 4,178 664 1,156 882 551 Balloch and Haldane S01013239 423 445 288 1,048 646 1,390 1,825 4,136 824 526 Clydebank East S01013126 443 779 463 523 478 911 1,099 1,180 727 506 Balloch and Haldane S01013240 448 530 448 649 304 2,391 2,883 1,633 586 369 Clydebank East S01013127 452 868 526 380 549 992 548 1,105 900 548 Dumbarton West S01013203 559 301 873 1,839 940 1,042 411 1,195 693 454 Balloch and Haldane S01013238 573 511 876 550 592 2,262 1,243 1,286 876 579 Renton S01013222 593 523 513 2,305 264 4,924 872 1,984 588 349 Faifley S01013156 597 925 430 1,099 506 1,494 2,602 927 813 549 Dumbarton North S01013184 603 620 628 1,080 805 1,743 728 1,797 507 347 Linnvale and Drumry S01013140 618 580 565 1,521 488 4,629 608 1,620 801 499 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013170 663 706 511 689 1,223 2,592 2,449 1,132 502 327 Faifley S01013157 732 759 679 999 886 1,551 3,040 1,734 950 605 Faifley S01013153 743 1,103 683 552 1,418 1,047 1,554 1,227 902 562 Renton S01013208 749 648 864 1,144 681 4,732 361 2,990 901 607 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013225 758 1,165 624 566 857 1,993 2,351 1,501 776 490 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013218 767 1,166 730 426 1,102 1,512 2,121 1,511 598 384 Alexandria S01013227 807 619 772 1,723 784 4,021 731 3,213 731 442 Faifley S01013155 831 1,219 737 954 1,025 949 2,366 765 878 588 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013169 836 689 911 857 1,016 3,013 2,146 1,772 844 498 Parkhall, North Kilbowie and Central S01013142 839 540 880 1,286 895 4,247 2,177 1,952 853 495 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013220 862 873 833 818 1,636 3,360 456 1,600 696 406 Dumbarton West S01013202 869 628 1,343 1,279 1,181 2,619 256 1,508 534 338 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013132 912 698 962 1,269 812 4,081 3,702 712 574 381 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013133 969 692 844 1,975 934 4,831 1,658 2,321 942 551 Clydebank East S01013128 1019 949 1,104 1,890 1,216 2,599 538 464 606 462 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013219 1022 1,301 763 1,130 1,670 1,556 3,155 531 473 303 Alexandria S01013228 1067 1,206 996 1,040 1,135 6,915 300 1,350 699 486 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013216 1068 1,536 633 1,436 1,615 1,492 2,657 1,276 540 351 Dumbarton North S01013186 1099 1,183 758 1,632 1,390 2,622 2,355 1,657 680 460 Linnvale and Drumry S01013129 1130 1,318 1,237 3,249 819 1,538 135 2,034 1114 692 Duntocher and Hardgate S01013162 1198 1,147 1,119 2,496 1,104 1,403 2,276 1,296 789 437 Dumbarton West S01013206 1203 882 1,381 1,572 1,672 2,776 1,103 1,253 590 392 Dumbarton West S01013200 1213 947 943 2,625 1,561 4,567 620 1,966 720 417 Alexandria S01013231 1236 1,042 1,193 2,211 769 4,594 1,412 2,386 695 451 Parkhall, North Kilbowie and Central S01013141 1304 1,198 1,004 2,087 1,283 4,467 1,395 1,771 802 493 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013168 1348 1,150 1,143 2,452 1,287 3,415 1,610 2,244 900 520 Renton S01013207 1353 1,308 1,167 2,311 981 2,851 2,357 2,586 940 581 Clydebank East S01013123 1371 1,238 1,299 1,596 2,435 2,439 706 2,023 737 513 Faifley S01013154 1381 1,513 1,305 2,056 1,490 1,333 1,548 2,041 901 602 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013221 1467 1,505 1,586 1,851 1,450 1,527 1,793 2,226 868 536 Linnvale and Drumry S01013136 1504 1,658 1,818 1,584 1,623 1,480 1,063 1,567 905 553 Dumbarton North S01013187 1549 1,329 1,690 2,138 1,783 2,175 1,264 2,319 819 539 Renton S01013223 1572 1,678 1,314 3,226 884 6,250 459 2,802 1142 687 Alexandria S01013232 1587 1,114 1,645 2,279 1,015 5,695 3,356 3,279 651 417 Duntocher and Hardgate S01013161 1697 1,818 1,537 1,661 2,545 1,798 2,348 1,667 1034 648 Renton S01013209 1735 1,686 1,538 2,883 1,049 5,567 1,227 2,630 787 487 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013131 1749 1,967 1,268 1,768 3,308 2,559 1,670 1,313 648 448 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013224 1756 1,638 2,154 2,384 1,141 3,004 1,426 1,720 766 541 Alexandria S01013229 1761 1,405 1,798 2,131 1,276 4,843 3,610 2,084 757 492 Dumbarton North S01013185 1816 1,357 2,053 2,379 2,494 2,073 2,067 1,697 760 467 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013164 1836 1,346 1,802 3,364 2,468 2,443 1,192 3,106 1022 649 Dumbarton East and Central S01013195 1978 2,134 2,144 3,275 1,513 6,590 89 1,351 1016 720 Parkhall, North Kilbowie and Central S01013144 1992 1,617 2,068 2,614 2,107 2,160 4,550 2,344 870 525 Parkhall, North Kilbowie and Central S01013145 2014 2,317 1,826 1,634 1,680 3,494 4,219 2,467 698 446 Clydebank East S01013124 2070 2,044 1,982 2,987 1,705 2,946 1,937 3,243 695 454 Parkhall, North Kilbowie and Central S01013143 2084 1,842 1,933 2,557 2,268 2,914 3,944 1,800 803 515 Linnvale and Drumry S01013137 2119 2,264 1,988 2,417 2,751 969 5,652 2,455 732 460 SIMD 2016 West Dunbartonshire Heat Map Appendix 1

SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 SIMD16 Working Overall Employm Income Educatio Health Access Crime Housing Populatio _Age_Po ComCouncil DZ Rank ent Rank Rank n Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank n pulation Silverton and Overtoun S01013190 2189 2,106 2,069 3,300 1,534 3,021 3,568 3,112 748 467 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013217 2201 2,351 2,319 2,549 2,472 1,567 2,425 2,174 663 434 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013215 2320 2,636 3,197 1,603 2,798 1,056 3,164 1,178 821 568 Alexandria S01013230 2371 2,476 2,293 2,113 1,763 4,690 2,976 3,968 647 373 Linnvale and Drumry S01013134 2420 2,584 1,912 3,320 2,316 3,947 1,800 3,271 844 547 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013172 2421 2,299 2,097 2,900 2,439 3,205 4,151 2,692 742 459 Dumbarton West S01013199 2460 2,510 2,423 5,601 948 3,651 1,842 4,870 937 583 Dumbarton North S01013198 2465 2,114 3,097 3,083 1,443 3,694 2,977 2,241 1173 755 Duntocher and Hardgate S01013150 2550 1,858 2,400 3,706 2,734 3,999 3,180 3,299 825 462 Silverton and Overtoun S01013182 2557 2,452 2,593 3,071 1,709 4,336 3,025 1,989 699 436 Balloch and Haldane S01013237 2596 2,703 2,620 3,486 2,194 2,538 1,359 4,458 788 536 Parkhall, North Kilbowie and Central S01013146 2620 2,883 2,018 3,090 1,880 3,378 6,935 3,376 477 286 Faifley S01013152 2655 3,049 2,569 2,862 2,810 1,284 3,592 3,376 904 561 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013211 2738 2,462 2,739 3,167 2,091 3,428 4,380 2,928 879 627 Clydebank East S01013125 2857 3,157 2,490 3,601 2,094 3,713 2,344 2,473 806 485 Parkhall, North Kilbowie and Central S01013149 2882 3,221 2,877 2,271 3,267 1,962 4,334 1,483 860 562 Parkhall, North Kilbowie and Central S01013165 2953 2,924 2,718 3,413 2,168 4,402 2,418 3,522 893 526 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013226 3047 2,892 3,189 3,003 2,771 2,425 3,491 3,870 486 326 Alexandria S01013233 3048 2,894 2,947 3,681 2,385 4,805 1,304 4,119 533 328 Milton and Bowling S01013179 3078 3,632 3,881 3,099 2,781 728 3,090 2,969 757 500 Old Kilpatrick S01013176 3106 2,786 2,878 3,377 2,644 4,752 3,816 1,640 766 464 Dumbarton North S01013188 3128 3,142 3,127 3,818 3,292 1,842 2,354 2,755 841 546 Balloch and Haldane S01013235 3237 3,170 3,302 3,519 2,750 4,620 1,141 2,816 743 491 Linnvale and Drumry S01013147 3274 3,232 2,614 4,795 3,053 4,087 1,792 3,007 710 446 Dumbarton East and Central S01013194 3708 2,825 3,343 4,584 2,929 6,042 5,826 1,353 550 380 Silverton and Overtoun S01013183 3793 3,303 4,313 4,834 3,912 850 5,308 6,167 811 542 Dumbarton West S01013204 3822 4,134 4,154 4,029 3,883 704 6,238 3,382 770 511 Dumbarton East and Central S01013192 3829 3,035 3,557 4,828 2,876 4,587 4,590 3,281 957 602 Milton and Bowling S01013178 3961 4,084 3,644 3,805 4,176 1,969 4,073 2,765 724 463 Parkhall, North Kilbowie and Central S01013148 4002 3,193 3,777 4,755 3,731 3,294 4,236 3,256 766 469 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013171 4023 3,932 4,206 5,205 4,268 1,110 2,661 3,991 649 434 Old Kilpatrick S01013173 4130 3,775 3,701 3,938 3,999 2,778 5,489 3,449 780 529 Duntocher and Hardgate S01013151 4264 3,710 4,291 4,536 3,905 3,772 1,664 4,618 547 342 Dumbarton East and Central S01013181 4309 3,711 4,569 4,221 2,993 2,972 5,918 3,369 731 483 Duntocher and Hardgate S01013163 4437 5,099 4,735 4,128 5,292 756 3,447 2,724 670 442 Silverton and Overtoun S01013197 4520 3,823 4,293 5,336 2,711 4,358 5,146 4,765 559 315 Old Kilpatrick S01013175 4523 4,195 3,913 5,218 4,658 1,730 6,287 4,766 807 529 Balloch and Haldane S01013236 4534 3,675 4,312 4,873 4,615 2,340 5,639 5,103 848 479 Old Kilpatrick S01013177 4541 4,472 4,415 3,762 3,758 3,946 3,668 1,808 618 404 Duntocher and Hardgate S01013159 4575 4,926 4,533 4,337 4,251 1,263 5,808 3,289 679 417 Kilmaronock S01013242 4649 4,391 5,269 5,987 5,359 660 3,245 5,567 625 369 Duntocher and Hardgate S01013158 4862 5,432 4,805 5,141 4,243 1,202 3,839 6,494 608 360 Dumbarton East and Central S01013193 4868 4,315 4,879 4,553 3,942 4,199 3,775 2,262 753 514 Silverton and Overtoun S01013196 5116 4,306 4,828 4,934 4,157 5,790 3,603 2,428 604 444 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013214 5143 5,852 6,227 4,505 4,439 619 6,375 5,405 441 329 Dumbarton East and Central S01013180 5155 4,811 6,405 4,989 4,618 1,733 2,074 4,969 410 303 Renton S01013210 5339 3,771 5,171 5,148 4,269 6,346 5,535 6,186 571 354 Duntocher and Hardgate S01013160 5387 4,750 6,145 5,248 6,211 965 6,161 5,963 712 439 Kilmaronock S01013241 5393 5,784 5,808 5,744 5,243 891 3,912 6,623 791 480 Silverton and Overtoun S01013189 5501 4,987 4,906 5,625 4,163 3,710 6,302 4,877 619 408 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013213 5766 6,238 6,249 5,455 6,535 780 5,066 5,976 542 392 Dalmuir and Mountblow S01013174 5833 5,686 5,570 5,599 5,607 1,772 6,851 6,246 795 563 Bonhill and Dalmonach S01013212 6013 5,925 6,766 5,657 5,774 1,200 5,888 6,633 572 444 Balloch and Haldane S01013234 6072 5,719 6,183 6,082 6,508 2,775 1,886 6,372 382 268 Dumbarton East and Central S01013191 6317 6,117 6,472 5,527 6,176 1,914 6,000 6,023 1239 804