Monitoring of Media Content of Local/Regional Television Broadcasters During Pre-Elections
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Monitoring of Media Content of Local/Regional Television Broadcasters during Pre-Elections Subagreement # S-12-155 Report for: July 2 - November 11, 2012 Project Period: 11 June 2012 - 10 December 2012 Total Budget: 31 000$ Monitoring of Media Content of Local/Regional Television Broadcasters Results Summary/Impact Statement Main findings of monitoring: • Very few of the monitored subjects were dedicated airtime on regional TV channels; • Out of the monitored subjects the activities carried out by five political unions including United National Movement (UNM), Georgian Dream coalition, New Rights, Christian- Democratic Movement and Free Georgia were dedicated airtime; • Following the official announcement of the election campaign the amount of reporting on the UNM and the GD activities considerably went up; • In the aftermath of elections political parties were virtually provided with no TV coverage, apart from UNM and the Georgian Dream coalition; The amount of airtime devoted to the aforementioned two monitored subjects gradually decreased; • Most of the TV stories implied superficial information about the activities of the monitored subjects and failed to demonstrate dissenting or criticizing opinions over the issue; • In the aftermath of elections the extent of subjective coverage of events went down; • Following the elections some of the TV Companies mostly reported on social, cultural and economic issues ongoing in the region rather than political developments; • Prior to the elections the greater majority of regional TV channels dedicated a fair amount of airtime to reporting on the activities carried out by the local self-government. Reporting was almost always positive in tone. During the pre-election period reporting on the activities carried out by the local self-government considerably went up but this time reporting was not solely positive in tone; • The programs initiated by the authorities were covered in a superficial manner, without providing any additional arguments; • In the greater majority of TV Companies reporting was positive in tone. In this regard the period of September 17-23 was the exception which excelled with strictly negative tone in relation to government and authorities since within this period all of the TV Companies more or less covered the main topic of the week – the release of prisoner abuse video and protest rallies organized against violence. Internews Georgia 2 Monitoring of Media Content of Local/Regional Television Broadcasters Background The report represents the results of the survey carried out within the period of July 2 - November11, 2012 by the Internews Georgia monitoring team. Media monitoring helps raise standard of professionalism and is conducive to the development of independent unbiased journalism. The goal of our survey is to reveal, through monitoring main news programs aired on Georgian regional TV broadcasters, the proceeding and trends of media coverage of pre-election campaign. Activities The survey was carried out on 20 regional broadcasters operating nationwide, including: Channel 25 (Batumi), Rioni (Kutaisi), Kvemo Kartli TV and Radio Company (Rustavi), Odishi (Zugdidi), Tanamgzavri (Telavi), 9th Channel (Alkhaltsikhe), Trialeti (Gori), Guria (Ozurgeti), Imervizia (Chiatura), Argo (Zestaponi), Gurjaani (Gurjaani), Borjomi (Borjomi), Marneuli TV (Marneuli), LTV (Lagodekhi), 12th Channel (Bolnisi), Mega TV (Khoni), Zari (Samtredia), 9th Wave (Poti), Kronika (Dusheti), Egrisi (Senaki). During the project no news programs were produced by Dusheti-based TV Company Kronika and Senaki-based TV Company Egrisi. Methodology Monitoring was conducted on the regional broadcasters’ main evening news programs during so- called prime time when the number of viewers is at its peak. The technique applied in the project is based on quantitative and qualitative research. Quantitative monitoring determines quantitative indicators that can be counted and analyzed. While qualitative monitoring is applied to evaluate the efficiency of media outlets’ activities in relation to the indicators such as ethical or professional standards whose quantitative measurement is complex. In particular, the distortion of news, unbalanced coverage, bias or anything else that might affect quality news was focused on. Quantitative data includes the running time (seconds) of the stories produced about our preselected subjects or making mention of them. In the given charts the time dedicated to the subjects is shown in seconds. In case the chart is missing any political party, which is the subject of monitoring, it means no channel dedicated any time to it within the monitoring period. Internews Georgia 3 Monitoring of Media Content of Local/Regional Television Broadcasters Direct and indirect coverage shows whether the subject is speaking on one’s own or is being spoken about either by a journalist or other respondents. In the given charts direct and indirect coverage is shown in percentage. 100 percent indicates the time dedicated to each subject on a particular channel. The tone of coverage is attributed to a subject when being indirectly spoken about or when speaking directly about oneself, other subjects or some general issues. Charts illustrate three categories of tones: positive, neutral and negative. When conducting monitoring on news programs it was interesting to find out which events, either central or regional, were covered by the TV Companies. Based on qualitative data the efficiency of media activities in terms of adherence to ethical or professional standards, will be evaluated. The qualitative part embraces components such as balance or whether diverse opinions over the covered issue are represented in the stories; accuracy or whether mistakes are in place in the names or numbers; the vocabulary used and all those important aspects that are not subject to quantitative measurement. The cases of manipulation through shots and music used in the news programs were also brought into focus. The monitoring subjects include: Parliament (speaker, vice speaker, MPs, committees); President (administration, advisors, press speaker); government (prime minister, ministers, deputy ministers, governors); authorities (when mentioned with no specification); local self-governments (mayors, chairs of Sakrebulo and Gamgeoba); Adjara government, Adjara Parliament, Central Election Commission; election observers; State Audit Agency (in relation to elections); commission in charge of verifying voters' list; United National Movement; Georgian Dream – Democratic Georgia; coalition Georgian Dream; Free Democrats; National Forum; Georgian Republican Party; Georgian Conservative party; People’s Party; Georgia’s Way; Free Georgia; New Rights; Democratic Movement for United Georgia; National Democratic Party; Labor party; Industry Will Save Georgia; Georgian Democratic Party; Georgian Troupe; Christian-Democratic Movement; European Democrats; Voters’ League; People’s Assembly; opposition (when mentioned with no specification). Internews Georgia 4 Monitoring of Media Content of Local/Regional Television Broadcasters Along with the appearance of elections-related subjects the number of monitored subjects went up. In particular the following new monitored subjects were added: For Renewed Georgia, Future Georgia, Georgian Green Party, Georgian Traditionalists Union, Whites, Social-Democratic Party, Monarchist Party, Freedom - The Way of Zviad Gamsakhurdia. News programs monitoring resulsts per channel: Channel 25 (Batumi) – The TV Company dedicated the total of 16 hours and 4 minutes to reporting on the monitored subjects. Out of the given figure 2 hours and 54 minutes falls on reporting on local self-government, 2 hours and 39 on the Georgian Dream coalition, 1 hour and 48 minutes to Adjara government. Almost equal share of airtime was received by UNM (1 hour and 24 minutes dedicated in total) and government (1 hour and 22 minutes dedicated in total). Time for Subjects ‐ Total 16 hr. 04 min. TV "Channel 25" Local self‐governance 2:54:49 Georgian Dream Coalition 2:39:04 Adjara Government 1:48:32 United National Movement 1:24:23 Government 1:22:42 Central Election Commission 1:13:02 Authorities (unspecified) 1:02:08 Christian‐Democratic Movement 0:47:44 Adjara Parliament 0:30:55 President 0:25:48 Free Georgia 0:22:24 New Rights 0:21:27 Labour Party 0:18:44 Opposition 0:10:41 Movement for Fair Georgia 0:10:33 Parliament 0:10:11 Rerpublican Party 0:09:25 Election Observers 0:07:24 Commission for Ensuring Vopters' List Accuracy 0:02:59 Georgian Dream ‐ Democratic Georgia 0:01:15 Reporting on the monitored subjects was mostly neutral in tone. 33 and 29 % positive tone was attached to reporting on New Rights (21 min dedicated in total) and Christian-Democratic Movement (47 min dedicated in total). Reporting was negative in tone in regard to the authorities - 81 percent (1 hour of dedicated time), government – 46 percent (1 hour and 22 minutes dedicated in total), UNM – 42 percent (1 hour and 24 minutes dedicated in total). Internews Georgia 5 Monitoring of Media Content of Local/Regional Television Broadcasters Tone towards Subjects (%) TV "Channel 25" Positive Neutral Negative Local self‐governance 19 56 25 Georgian Dream Coalition 21 73 6 Adjara Government 24 67 9 United National Movement 15 43 42 Government 14 40 46 Central Election Commission 7 60 33 Authorities (unspecified) 9 10 81 Christian‐Democratic Movement 29 67 4 Adjara Parliament 9 75 16 President 14 50 36 Free Georgia 24 73 3 New Rights 33 66 1 Labour Party