DOCSLIB.ORG

Alternative Approaches to Abortion Law Ministerial Briefing Paper

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Alternative Approaches to Abortion Law Ministerial Briefing Paper October 2018 Wellington, New Zealand Alternative approaches to abortion law Ministerial briefing paper ALTERNATIVE APPROACHES TO ABORTION LAW MINISTERIAL BRIEFING PAPER ADDENDUM The Commission notes that the Termination of Pregnancy Bill 2018 (Qld) was passed by the Queensland Parliament on 17 October 2018, shortly after this ministerial briefing paper was finalised for printing. The Law Commission | Te Aka Matua o te Ture is an independent, publicly funded, central advisory body established by statute to undertake the systematic review, reform and development of the law of New Zealand. Its purpose is to help achieve law that is just, principled, and accessible, and that reflects the heritage and aspirations of the people of New Zealand. The Commissioners are: The Hon Sir Douglas White — President Donna Buckingham Belinda Clark QSO Helen McQueen The office of the Law Commission is at: Level 9, Solnet House, 70 The Terrace, Wellington 6011 Postal address: PO Box 2590, Wellington 6140, New Zealand Document Exchange Number: SP 23534 Telephone: 04 473 3453 Email: [email protected] Internet: www.lawcom.govt.nz A catalogue record for this title is available from the National Library of New Zealand. Kei te pātengi raraunga o Te Puna Mātauranga o Aotearoa te whakarārangi o tēnei pukapuka. ISBN: 978-1-877569-87-6 (Online) This title may be cited as NZLC MB4. This title is available on the internet at the Law Commission's website www.lawcom.govt.nz Copyright © 2018 New Zealand Law Commission. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence. In essence, you are free to copy, distribute and adapt the work, as long as you attribute the work to the Law Commission and abide by other licence terms. To view a copy of this licence, visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Foreword This ministerial briefing paper has been prepared as a matter of priority under section 7(3) of the Law Commission Act 1985, at the request of Hon Andrew Little, the Minister of Justice. It provides advice on what alternative approaches could be taken in New Zealand’s legal framework if the Government decides to propose a policy shift to treat abortion as a health issue. The Commission has not conducted a full review of all aspects of abortion law and does not express a view on the appropriate policy approach. The Commission received input from the health sector and submissions from members of the public in developing its advice. I would like to express our gratitude to all who shared their expertise and views. I would also like to acknowledge in particular the advice and assistance provided by the Ministry of Health in facilitating the Commission’s consultation with health sector representatives. This briefing paper has been prepared by Belinda Clark and a team of the Commission’s legal and policy advisors. I thank them for their hard work. The Hon Sir Douglas White President 1 CONTENTS LAW COMMISSION Contents Abbreviations and terms ................................................................................................................ 5 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 7 The Minister of Justice’s request for advice .............................................................................................. 7 The Commission’s approach .............................................................................................................................8 Input from health professionals and the public ..........................................................................................8 Executive summary ....................................................................................................................... 11 1. Abortion law in New Zealand .............................................................................................. 15 Overview ......................................................................................................................................................... 15 Performing an abortion is a crime except in certain circumstances............................................ 16 It is an offence for a woman to procure her own miscarriage ...................................................... 18 It is an offence to perform an abortion without certification or outside a licensed institution ......................................................................................................................................................... 19 Abortion services are regulated under the Contraception, Sterilisation, and Abortion Act .................................................................................................................................................................... 20 2. Abortion in practice ............................................................................................................. 31 Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 31 Key statistics .................................................................................................................................................. 31 Standards of care for women requesting abortion ......................................................................... 35 The abortion process ................................................................................................................................. 36 Culturally appropriate services ............................................................................................................... 44 Cost of abortion services .......................................................................................................................... 45 Methods of abortion ................................................................................................................................... 46 3. Wider legal context.............................................................................................................. 51 Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 51 Human rights laws ........................................................................................................................................ 51 The Treaty of Waitangi and tikanga Māori ......................................................................................... 60 General health regulation .......................................................................................................................... 64 2 ALTERNATIVE APPROACHES TO ABORTION LAW: MINISTERIAL BRIEFING PAPER LAW COMMISSION PART ONE: ALTERNATIVE LEGAL MODELS FOR TREATING ABORTION AS A HEALTH ISSUE 4. Three models for when abortion would be lawful .............................................................. 75 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................................... 75 Model A .............................................................................................................................................................. 77 Model B ............................................................................................................................................................... 81 Model C .............................................................................................................................................................. 87 5. Law changes required for all three models ......................................................................... 93 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................................... 93 The grounds for abortion in the Crimes Act 1961 would be repealed .......................................... 93 The requirement for authorisation by two certifying consultants would be repealed ........... 95 PART TWO: OTHER ASPECTS OF ABORTION LAW 6. Criminal aspects of abortion law.......................................................................................... 99 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................................... 99 Abortion laws and professional standards can be enforced in a variety of ways ................. 100 General laws protect against unsafe medical practice .................................................................... 104 Reforming the criminal offences for abortion ..................................................................................... 108 Repealing the regulatory offences for breaching the current licensing and certification requirements ....................................................................................................................................................114 Ensuring compliance with the statutory test for abortion if Model B or C is adopted .......... 115 Ensuring abortions are only performed by qualified people ........................................................... 118 7. Access to abortion services ................................................................................................. 121 Introduction .....................................................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Rt I Are Sex Selective Abortions Wrong? J.M.Johnston Masters Student, Bioethics Centre, University of Otago
    rt I Are Sex Selective Abortions Wrong? J.M.Johnston Masters Student, Bioethics Centre, University of Otago, 'THIRD WORLD GIRL ABORTIONS HERE-DOCTORS'. 8 weeks by chorionic villus sampling - a test checking chromosomal abnormalities that, like amniocentesis, is also 'WARNING OVER FOETAL SEX TESTS'. able to accurately identify the sex of the fetus (Morgan, 'FAMILY PLANNING WARNS OF SEX TEST'. 1988, p355). There seem to be two main reasons why a 'EXPERT URGES FEWER FOETUS SEX TESTS'. woman or a couple would want to use prenatal diagnosis and abortion to select the sex of their child. The first, and less controversial, reason may be to avoid the birth So read the headlines of The Dominion and The New of a child with sex linked diseases such as haemophilia or Zealand Herald in early April 2000. Identification of the sex Duchenne muscular dystrophy (Morgan, 1988, p356). The of a fetus is possible as early as six weeks into a second reason for sex selective abortion is to eliminate a pregnancy and based on anecdotal evidence from the Family fetus of the 'wrong' sex - for instance the abortion of a Planning Association, the New Zealand Medical Association male fetus by a woman who wants to have a daughter. It is believes that '[a] third world practice of couples aborting with this second use ofsex identification and abortion that I baby girls has spread to New Zealand' (The Dominion, 6 am concerned, although I do note that abortions performed April 2000, p.1). New Zealand Medical Association for the first mentioned 'therapeutic' reason are not without Chairwoman Pippa MacKay has said that although it is their critics ( see for instance Harris, 1985).
    [Show full text]
  • Fighting to Choose: the Abortion Rights Struggle in New Zealand. by Alison Mcculloch
    REVIEWS (BOOKS) 165 Fighting to Choose: The Abortion Rights Struggle in New Zealand. By Alison McCulloch. Victoria University Press, Wellington, 2013. 339pp. NZ price: $50.00. ISBN: 9780864738868. This is a partisan and passionate account of abortion politics in New Zealand, but it is also a scholarly, extensively footnoted, well-researched and fascinating history of pro- choice struggles, anti-abortion politics and the ongoing anomalies in this country’s abortion laws and regulatory processes. Acknowledgements start with McCulloch’s account of her need to present herself as ‘mentally unstable’ in order to secure her access to an abortion in her twenties and her anger at having to run the gauntlet of anti- abortion protesters as she entered Wellington’s Parkview Clinic for the procedure. Her research on the project was initiated in 2007 with a grant from the Women’s National Abortion Action Campaign (WONAAC). The book is illustrated by a range of photos assembled from the archives of the Alexander Turnbull Library and various activist organizations. McCulloch’s pro-choice position is articulated in the opening pages of the introduction. The first question that the book addresses is why the women’s movement in New Zealand failed to achieve control by women over their fertility – in particular, the right to abortion. Conservative thinking and the power of the Catholic Church, combined with what McCulloch identifies as the problematic reformist strategies of the Abortion Law Reform Association (ALRANZ), are identified as the reasons for New Zealand’s relatively restrictive abortion legislation, which nevertheless provides the framework within which 15,000 abortions are approved each year.
    [Show full text]
  • Abortion MARCH 2016
    MORAL, SOCIAL and ETHICAL issues for today’s SALVATION ARMY Published by the Moral and Social Issues (Ethics) Council New Zealand, Fiji and Tonga Territory Issued by authority of the Territorial Commander Abortion MARCH 2016 Is abortion an issue in New Zealand society today? Your response matters Abortion is on the decline overall in New Zealand. We have The Salvation Army believes life is a gift from God and that we achieved a 20-year low in the number of pregnancies terminated are answerable to God for the taking of life. We, like many other by choice. Nevertheless, more than13,000 abortions were Christian churches, accept the moment of fertilisation as the performed in this country in 2014. And more than a third of those start of human life and, in most instances would not accept were repeat occurrences where at least one abortion had been abortion as a justifiable choice. performed previously and, in some cases, as many as eight. There are exceptions where The Salvation Army accepts (as Abortion appears to be readily obtained in New Zealand. Despite noted in our International Positional Statement2), that a legislation requiring various checks and balances on decisions termination is appropriate. These are when: that an abortion is permitted, 98–99% of all abortions are • carrying the pregnancy further seriously threatens the life of granted on the basis of the mother’s medical health. Some the mother; or would say this is virtually ‘abortion on demand’. • reliable diagnostic procedures have identified a foetal Abortion is a polarising issue. Political debate on abnormality considered incompatible with survival for more decriminalisation has surfaced repeatedly in New Zealand over than a very brief post-natal period.
    [Show full text]
  • Housewives' Depression
    Housewives' Depression THE DEBATE OVER ABORTION AND BIRTH CONTROL IN THE 1930s* NEW ZEALAND has received acclaim for its ready recognition of women's rights. Women had, in the public sphere, less difficulty in breaking down the barriers to their participation than their sisters in England or America.' But, in the central areas of private morality, birth control and abortion, New Zealand women have not been granted such ready recog- nition of their autonomy. The first birth control clinic was established in New Zealand in 1953, 37 years after Margaret Sanger's first attempt to open a clinic in New York City, and 32 years after the opening of Marie Stopes's Marlborough Road clinic.2 While in England and America the government eventually took some responsibility for ensuring access to legal abortion, in New Zealand abortion remains limited to certain health grounds.3 Control of fertility raises questions of social, religious, and psycho- logical importance. Women's demands for birth control challenge the 'basic moral assumptions of a male dominated society' and threaten to overturn accepted social roles.4 This was particularly true in New Zealand. The nineteenth-century ideal of woman as the 'colonial help- * I am indebted to Erik Olssen who directed the original research for this paper. Thanks also to Lynne Milne for her comments, and Andree Levesque for her encouragement. 1 Raewyn Dalziel has persuasively argued that the vote was granted precisely because it did not threaten a change in women's prescribed sphere. R. Dalziel, 'The Colonial Helpmeet: Women's Role and the Vote in Nineteenth-Century New Zealand', New Zealand Journal of History, II (1977), 112-23.
    [Show full text]
  • Access to Abortion Reports
    ACCESS TO ABORTION: An Annotated Bibliography of Reports and Scholarship Second edition (as of April 1, 2020) prepared by The International Reproductive and Sexual Health Law Program Faculty of Law, University of Toronto, Canada, 2020 http://www.law.utoronto.ca/documents/reprohealth/abortionbib.pdf Online Publication History: This edition: Access to Abortion: An Annotated Bibliography of Reports and Scholarship. “Second edition,” current to April 1 2020, published online August 31, 2020 at: http://www.law.utoronto.ca/documents/reprohealth/abortionbib.pdf Original edition: “Access to Abortion Reports: An Annotated Bibliography” (published online January 2008, slightly updated January 2009) has been moved to: http://www.law.utoronto.ca/documents/reprohealth/abortionbib2009.pdf Publisher: The International Reproductive and Sexual Health Law Program Faculty of Law, University of Toronto, 78 Queen’s Park Crescent, Toronto Canada M5S 2A5 Website Reprohealthlaw Blog Contact: reprohealth.law{at}utoronto.ca Acknowledgements: We are most grateful to Professor Joanna Erdman for founding this bibliography in 2008-9. We are also indebted to Katelyn Sheehan (LL.M.) and Sierra Farr (J.D. candidate) for expertly collecting and analyzing new resources up to April 1, 2020, and to Sierra Farr for updating the introduction to this second edition. Updates: Kindly send suggestions for the next edition of this bibliography to: Professor Joanna Erdman, MacBain Chair in Health Law and Policy, Health Law Institute, Schulich School of Law, Dalhousie University, Email: joanna.erdman{at}dal.ca ACCESS TO ABORTION: An Annotated Bibliography of Reports and Scholarship, 2020 AN INTRODUCTION TO THE ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY: Widespread evidence indicates that abortion services remain inaccessible and inequitably available for many people despite legal entitlement.1 This is true in jurisdictions that permit abortion for specific indications (e.g.
    [Show full text]
  • Submission of the Equal Employment Opportunities Commissioner on Abortion Law Reform
    Submission of the Equal Employment Opportunities Commissioner on Abortion Law Reform 1 June 2018 Contact Person: Jackie Blue Equal Opportunities Commissioner New Zealand human Rights Commission [email protected] 1 Submission of the Equal Employment Opportunities Commissioner on Abortion Law Reform Contents Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 3 I. Current Law ..................................................................................................................................... 4 What makes abortion a crime? ........................................................................................................... 4 Regulation of abortions ...................................................................................................................... 5 II. Human Rights Law and Abortion .................................................................................................... 6 New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 ................................................................................................... 6 International Human Rights Framework ............................................................................................ 6 CEDAW Committee Comments to New Zealand .............................................................................. 10 III. Specific Issues ..........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Abortion and the Law in New
    NSW PARLIAMENTARY LIBRARY RESEARCH SERVICE Abortion and the law in New South Wales by Talina Drabsch Briefing Paper No 9/05 ISSN 1325-4456 ISBN 0 7313 1784 X August 2005 © 2005 Except to the extent of the uses permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part of this document may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means including information storage and retrieval systems, without the prior written consent from the Librarian, New South Wales Parliamentary Library, other than by Members of the New South Wales Parliament in the course of their official duties. Abortion and the law in New South Wales by Talina Drabsch NSW PARLIAMENTARY LIBRARY RESEARCH SERVICE David Clune (MA, PhD, Dip Lib), Manager..............................................(02) 9230 2484 Gareth Griffith (BSc (Econ) (Hons), LLB (Hons), PhD), Senior Research Officer, Politics and Government / Law .........................(02) 9230 2356 Talina Drabsch (BA, LLB (Hons)), Research Officer, Law ......................(02) 9230 2768 Lenny Roth (BCom, LLB), Research Officer, Law ...................................(02) 9230 3085 Stewart Smith (BSc (Hons), MELGL), Research Officer, Environment ...(02) 9230 2798 John Wilkinson (MA, PhD), Research Officer, Economics.......................(02) 9230 2006 Should Members or their staff require further information about this publication please contact the author. Information about Research Publications can be found on the Internet at: www.parliament.nsw.gov.au/WEB_FEED/PHWebContent.nsf/PHPages/LibraryPublications Advice on
    [Show full text]
  • Registering Foetuses on the National Identity System Implications for Reproductive Rights
    Registering foetuses on the National Identity System Implications for reproductive rights We recommend: That the Ministry of Health Does not enable the registration of foetuses/unborn babies 1on the new health identity system as is currently proposed Ensures that all information systems solutions, policies and programmes 2relating to sexual and reproductive health services recognise and preserve the distinction between foetuses and born children Undertakes Gender Impact Assessment and reproductive rights analysis 3in the development of policy and infrastructure in all areas of women’s health Uses neutral language in technical Ministry of Health documentation 4related to sexual and reproductive health by referring to “foetus” rather than either “unborn baby” or “baby” when describing the foetus in utero. 1 Women’s Health Action December 2011 Issues Paper WOMEN’S HEALTH Action Introduction HE Health IT Board is currently progressing with the Health Identity TProgramme which will deliver a single integrated system to lay the foundation for a secure and transferable electronic shared care record. It will replace the existing technology platform supporting the National Health Index. The National Health Index number (NHI number) is a unique identifier that is assigned to every person who uses health and disability support services in New Zealand from birth or from first access. A person’s NHI number is stored on the National Health Index (NHI) along with that person’s demographic details. NHI numbers are used to help with the planning, co-ordination and provision of health and disability support services across New Zealand. As part of the upgrade of the NHI there has been a proposal from foetal medicine specialists to formalise a process for assigning NHI numbers to foetuses whose mothers are under specialist foetal medicine care.
    [Show full text]
  • Status of Women
    PACIFIC WOMEN’S WATCH (NEW ZEALAND) NON-GOVERNMENTAL ORGANISATION ALTERNATIVE REPORT STATUS OF WOMEN Comments to the UN CEDAW Monitoring Committee on New Zealand’s progress in implementing the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) September 2017 CONTENTS Page Executive Summary and Recommendations 2 Introduction 7 Prologue to the Report 7 ARTICLES 1 Definition of Discrimination against Women 8 2 Anti-discrimination Measures 9 3 Development and Advancement of Women 9 4 Acceleration of Equality between Men and Women 9 5 Sex Roles and Stereotyping 10 6 Suppression of Exploitation of Women 10 7 Political and Public Life 10 11 Employment 11 12 Health 11 13 Economic and Social Life 12 15 Law 13 16 Marriage and Family Life 15 APPENDIX 1: Māori Women’s Welfare League (MWWL) APPENDIX 2: Shakti Community Council Inc APPENDIX 3: Women with disabilities APPENDIX 4: Women’s Health Action Trust APPENDIX 5: Transwomen statement APPENDIX 6: Women and Law APPENDIX 7: Employment and participation 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY and RECOMMENDATIONS Pacific Women’s Watch (New Zealand) (PWW(NZ)) NGO Alternative Report for the Eighth CEDAW review reports some gains for New Zealand women towards achieving equality since seventh review. Further action is still required to overcome continuing discrimination. Issues and challenges have been identified and highlighted at seminars, workshops and discussion meetings over the past four years, particularly focused on women in the greater Auckland region reflecting a large ethnically diverse population and the greatest proportion of Māori, Pacific, Asian and migrant women and girls. Technology enabled women throughout New Zealand to contribute via an online survey.
    [Show full text]
  • New Zealand Population Review
    NEW ZEALAND POPULATION REVIEW Volume 42 2016 Editors W. Friesen T. Kukutai A. Day Population Association of New Zealand TP02849 NZ Population Review Cover.indd 1 11/02/14 11:57 AM Editors Wardlow Friesen Tahu Kukutai Alison Day Contact Address: Wardlow Friesen School of Environment The University of Auckland Private Bag 92019 Auckland Email: [email protected] © 2016 Population Association of New Zealand ISSN 0111-199X (Print) ISSN 1179-8149 (Online) Population Association of New Zealand Te Roopu Waihanga Iwi o Aotearoa A forum for the discussion, study and promotion of population issues in New Zealand. Membership Provides - access to a network of individuals and organisations interested and active in population matters - opportunity to contribute and participate in the Association’s activities, including a biennial conference - access to information through the Association’s publications, including the New Zealand Population Review New members are welcome For further details go to our website: www.population.org.nz NEW ZEALAND POPULATION REVIEW Vol 42 2016 Editors’ Note 1 An Immigrant at Heart: Andrew Trlin 3 PHILIP S. MORRISON Ethnic Mobility in the New Zealand Census, 1981-2013: 27 A Preliminary Look ROBERT DIDHAM Population Replacement, Nation-Building, Population 43 Policy IAN POOL Policy Responses to Depopulation 65 RACHAEL McMILLAN Population Change and Migration in Kiribati and Tuvalu, 103 2015-2050: Hypothetical Scenarios in a Climate of Change RICHARD BEDFORD, CHARLOTTE BEDFORD, JOHN CORCORAN, ROBERT DIDHAM First Time Mothers of Advanced Age in New Zealand 135 BRYNDL HOHMANN-MARRIOTT A memory: John Caldwell 149 IAN POOL Book Review 153 Colonisation and Development in New Zealand between 1769 and 1900: The Seeds of Rangiatea LEN SMITH New Zealand Population Review, 42:1–2.
    [Show full text]
  • Plaintiff S99/2016 V Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and Another
    243 FCR] PLAINTIFF S99/2016 v MNR FOR IMMIGRATION 17 FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA Plaintiff S99/2016 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and Another [2016] FCA 483 Bromberg J 28, 29 April, 6 May 2016 Private International Law — Choice of law — Torts — Proper law — Where putative duty of care required Minister of the Commonwealth to procure a safe and lawful abortion for a person assessed as a refugee offshore — Abortion made available in Papua New Guinea — Where apprehended breach of duty an omission to procure an abortion that is safe and lawful — Whether proper law of apprehended negligence the law of Australia or the law of Papua New Guinea. Torts — Negligence — Duty of care — Unauthorised maritime arrival claimed refugee status having been transferred to Republic of Nauru — Found to be refugee and temporarily settled — Where rape occurred causing pregnancy and physical and psychological harm — Where dependence upon Commonwealth of Australia for financial and medical needs — Where abortion only able to be procured with the assistance of the Commonwealth — Whether duty of care to exercise reasonable care to procure a safe and lawful abortion — Consideration of whether Commonwealth voluntarily assumed responsibility for refugee — Consideration of statutory scheme giving rise to relationship between refugee and Commonwealth and refugee’s continued presence on Nauru — Whether higher standard for the imposition of a duty of care on public authorities applicable to foreign public authorities — Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 198AA,
    [Show full text]
  • Working for Life, Faith and Family December 2013 FREE
    Family LIFE Working for Life, Faith and Family December 2013 FREE “But he that shall scandalize one of these little ones that believe in me, it were better for him that a millstone should be hanged about his neck, and that he should be drowned in the depth of the sea.” Matthew 18:6 Contents Family LIFE From the Editor 3 Working for Life, Faith and Family New John Paul II Centre for Life opens 4 Publisher: in Dunedin Family Life International NZ National Director: Rise Up Together in the Service of Life 8 Dame Colleen Bayer, DSG Editor: Ten important facts about the NZ 12 Michelle Kaufman Family Planning Association Auckland Family Life International NZ What you need to know about Family 16 John Paul II Centre for Life Planning’s conference 2013 569 / 569A Richardson Road P O Box 27967 A Spotlight on sexuality education 18 Mt Roskill, Auckland 1440 (note content intended for adults only) Office: 09 629 4361 Wisdom from the Truth and Meaning 22 Project Rachel: 0800 111 811 of Human Sexuality Natural Fertility Regulation: 0800 367 5433 How do we reclaim a marriage culture? 24 Email: [email protected] The stark reality of abortion in New 26 Wellington Zealand Family Life International NZ John Paul II Centre for Life I once was lost but now I am pro-life 30 Mrs Clare McClean (co-ordinator) (office is at rear of Cross & Co) 40 Days for Life 31 6 Parumoana Street, Porirua Baby central at the Auckland John Paul 34 Office: 04 237 8343 II Centre for Life Mobile: 027 511 2205 Email: [email protected] NZ advocacy group Saving Downs joins 36 Dunedin
    [Show full text]