DOCSLIB.ORG

IN the MATTER of the Exclusive Economic Zone and Continental Shelf (Environmental Effects) Act 2012

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
IN the MATTER of the Exclusive Economic Zone and Continental Shelf (Environmental Effects) Act 2012 BEFORE THE EPA CHATHAM ROCK PHOSPHATE MARINE CONSENT APPLICATION IN THE MATTER of the Exclusive Economic Zone and Continental Shelf (Environmental Effects) Act 2012 AND IN THE MATTER of a decision-making committee appointed to consider a marine consent application made by Chatham Rock Phosphate Limited to undertake rock phosphate extraction on the Chatham Rise __________________________________________________________ STATEMENT OF EVIDENCE OF MARTIN WILLIAM CAWTHORN FOR CHATHAM ROCK PHOSPHATE LIMITED Dated: 25 August 2014 __________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________ Barristers & Solicitors J G A Winchester / H P Harwood Telephone: +64-4-499 4599 Facsimile: +64-4-472 6986 Email: [email protected] DX SX11174 P O Box 2402 Wellington CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................... 4 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................ 5 Qualifications and experience ........................................................................... 5 Code of conduct .................................................................................................. 7 Role in marine consent application ................................................................... 7 Scope of Evidence............................................................................................... 7 PREVALENCE AND DISTRIBUTION OF MARINE ANIMALS ON THE CHATHAM RISE .............................................................................................. 7 Marine mammal habitat utilisation of the crest of the Chatham Rise ........... 9 CONSERVATION SIGNIFICANCE OF MARINE MAMMALS ON THE CHATHAM RISE ............................................................................................. 10 LIKELY IMPACTS OF THE PROPOSED MINING ACTIVITY ON MARINE MAMMALS BASED ON THEIR ABUNDANCE AND HABITAT USAGE ............................................................................................................. 11 Ship strikes .......................................................................................................... 11 Entanglement ....................................................................................................... 12 Noise ..................................................................................................................... 13 Behavioural response ......................................................................................... 15 Human induced changes to marine environment ........................................... 15 Pollution ............................................................................................................... 16 Mitigation effectiveness ...................................................................................... 16 RESPONSE TO SUBMISSIONS ............................................................................... 17 The Crown ............................................................................................................ 17 Ngai Tahu ............................................................................................................. 19 Greenpeace and Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated ................. 19 ECO ..................................................................................................................... 20 KASM .................................................................................................................... 20 CONCLUSION ........................................................................................................... 21 Page 2 24843608 REFERENCES (CITED IN THIS EVIDENCE) ........................................................... 22 APPENDICES ............................................................................................................ 24 Table 1. Threat Rankings for marine mammal species found across the Chatham Rise (after Baker 2010) ....................................................... 24 Table 2. Vocalisation ranges of whales and dolphins within and near CRP's proposed marine consent area (based on Torres et al. 2013a) ................................................................................................ 24 32. Species Accounts ......................................................................................... 25 Page 3 24843608 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1. This evidence describes the distribution patterns of marine mammals over the Chatham Rise. 2. Two data sets of incidental sightings of cetacean species were used to describe their distribution: (a) the Cawthorn dataset of incidental sightings from ships in transit to or from New Zealand ports; and (b) the Department of Conservation (DOC) cetacean sightings data. 3. The data sets provide 137 records of 12 different cetacean species and one species group, the beaked whales, sighted within the study area which consists of an approximately 100 km buffer area of the Chatham Rock Phosphate Ltd (CRP) mining permit area. 4. Most of the sightings of cetaceans within the study area are of sperm whales and pilot whales, which feed along the flanks of the Chatham Rise where they forage along the steep slopes for preferred food species. Various species of dolphins, beaked whales, killer whales, and baleen whales including southern right whales either use the Chatham Rise or transit it during their northward and southward migrations. The southern margin and south eastern end of the Chatham Rise are foraging grounds for southern right whales and beaked whales respectively. 5. The presence of CRP’s mining vessel, as well as fishing vessels, is unlikely to substantially increase the risk of ship strikes on whales or any form of entanglement. 6. Noise displacement, should it occur, should be of short duration, over a small area during the 4-5 day mining period. 7. As rorquals (blue, fin, sei and minke whales) and humpbacks will be in transit when in the vicinity of the Chatham Rise and dolphins feed in the upper part of the water column they are unlikely to be affected by any Page 4 24843608 suspended sediment from the mining operation in the top centre of the Chatham Rise. 8. Mitigation methods should ensure that no mining begins when any whales are within a buffer area around the vessel, and thus the equipment on the seabed. INTRODUCTION Qualifications and experience 9. My full name is Martin William Cawthorn. I am the Managing Director of Cawthorn and Associates. 10. I hold a Bachelor of Science degree with Honours majoring in Zoology. 11. I have had 45 years of specialist marine mammal research experience (whales and seals). During that time I have held the following positions: (a) 1962-66: Technical Officer (Marine Mammals), NZ Marine Department Research Division; (b) 1966-71: Scientist, Whaling Section, Fisheries Research Board of Canada, Arctic Biological Station, Ste Anne de Bellevue, Quebec, Canada; (c) 1976-87: Scientist (Marine Mammals/Deepwater Fisheries), MAF Fisheries Research Division; (d) 1987-92: Senior Scientist (Marine Mammals), Department of Conservation; and (e) 1992: established Cawthorn & Associates, consultants specialising in interactions between marine mammals, static and active fisheries, and marine industrial installations and activities. (f) Adjunct Lecturer, Institute of Veterinary and Biological Studies, Massey University. Page 5 24843608 12. My experience has included work in New Zealand, South West Pacific and Polynesia, Eastern Tropical Pacific, Central and South America, South Atlantic, Southern Indian Ocean, Southern Ocean/Antarctic, Western North Atlantic, Canadian Arctic, and the Norwegian Sea. 13. My specific experience within the New Zealand exclusive economic zone (EEZ) has included establishment and maintenance of a major incidental whale sightings system throughout the Tasman Sea and south west Pacific Ocean from the northern extremity of the New Zealand EEZ to the southern limit. 14. I was resident government biologist at Tory Channel Whaling Station from the latter days of humpback whaling through the entire period of sperm whaling until closure after the 1964-5 season. I organised and conducted aerial and shipboard surveys of sperm whales, including whale marking surveys, around the entire New Zealand coast. I conducted studies of seasonal distribution and movements of all whale species; studies of marine mammal ageing and reproduction; and feeding and dietary studies of sperm whales from the Cook Strait region. I also conducted shipboard and aerial surveys of all cetacean species off the East Coast, surveys across the Chatham Rise to Chatham Island and local waters. 15. I participated in a three year survey of Hector’s dolphins in Clifford and Cloudy Bay, and most recently organised and conducted a 12 month aerial survey of all marine mammals in nearshore waters of the south Taranaki Bight. 16. I have provided consultancy services to Australian, Canadian, Japanese, New Zealand, Norwegian and Tongan government agencies, and most recently to the United Kingdom Government Department of Environment Fisheries and Rural Affairs (2002-3) and the Australian Fisheries Management Authority (2008). I have also provided consultancy services to private aquaculture enterprises and participated in resource consent hearings regarding the potential effects on marine mammals of marine farming, marine electricity generation, and iron sand extraction.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Your Southern Supply Base
    Dunedin Your Southern Supply Base Dunedin is the leading site for a supply base, logistics provider and support centre for the offshore and onshore oil industry in the Great South Basin and East Coast of the South Island of New Zealand. Dunedin – Supply Base The Dunedin supply base is situated at the head of the deep and sheltered Otago Harbour. At present, laydown areas, wharf space and bunkering facilities already exist. Provedoring, marine repair and servicing facilities are also currently available. Looking to the future, the Dunedin City Council and Port Otago own a significant amount of land in this area and have identified it for redevelopment with provisions already in place to allow for this. Planning is underway for the construction of an International Logistics Hub and Offshore Supply Base to support the oil industry in the southern part of New Zealand. This would allow for easy development into a major industrial cluster and logistics centre. 1 CBD Supply base area Engineering cluster Wharf area Key Features: A land area of more than 200,000m2 25 km from Dunedin International Airport It is fully serviced for all utilities 10 km from the associated deep water Port Chalmers Container Terminal 24 hours a day, seven days a week operation is a permitted activity Within the proposed area there is provision for a tank farm Commercial shipping of up to 8.0 metres draft and 32.2 Commercial terminal and Stevedore services metres beam catered for at the Dunedin wharf system Provision for bulk cargo, warehousing and storage facilities
    [Show full text]
  • The New Zealand Cetacea
    r- tl^Ðn**t t Fisheries Research Bulletin No. r (New Series) The New Zealand Cetacea By D. E. Gaskin FISHERTES RESEÄRCH DIVISION, NEW ZEALAND MÁ.RTNB DEPÁ.RTMENT _l THE NE'üØ ZEALAND CETACEA , ,,i! ''it{ Pholograph fui D. E. Gaskin. Frontispiece : A blue whale (Balaenoþtera tnusculus) being flensed on the deck of the FF Southern Venlurt:r in the Weddell Sea in February t962. Fisheries Research Bulletin No. r (New Series) The New Zealand Cetacea By D. E" Gaskin* Fisheries Research Division, Marine Department, Wellington, New Zealand * Present address: Depattment of Zooloe¡ Massey lJnivetsity, Palmetston Noth FISHERIES RESE..q.RCH DIVISION, NE\Ø ZEAIAND MÁ.RINE DEP,{.RTMENT Edited byJ W McArthur Published by the New Zealand Marine Department, 1968 I{. [,. OWDN, GOVI':RNMENT PRINTDR. WELLINGTON. NEW ZEALAND-19ti3 FORE\TORD OvBn the past decade there has been a continued interest in the Iarge and small whales of New Zealand. This activity in the Marine Department and elsewhere followed earlier intensive work on the humpback whale in Victoria University of Wellington. As the humpback industry declined attention turned to the sperm whale. Substantial field studies of this species in local waters were made by the Marine Department. At the same time there has been a steady increase in the data available on strandings of the smaller whales. The circumstances make it appropriate to provide a handbook of the whale species fo-und in New Zealand waters. This bulletin is presented as a review of the available taxonomic and ecological data and not as a systematic revision of the group.
    [Show full text]
  • Review of Underwater and In-Air Sounds Emitted by Australian and Antarctic Marine Mammals
    Acoust Aust (2017) 45:179–241 DOI 10.1007/s40857-017-0101-z ORIGINAL PAPER Review of Underwater and In-Air Sounds Emitted by Australian and Antarctic Marine Mammals Christine Erbe1 · Rebecca Dunlop2 · K. Curt S. Jenner3 · Micheline-N. M. Jenner3 · Robert D. McCauley1 · Iain Parnum1 · Miles Parsons1 · Tracey Rogers4 · Chandra Salgado-Kent1 Received: 8 May 2017 / Accepted: 1 July 2017 / Published online: 19 September 2017 © The Author(s) 2017. This article is an open access publication Abstract The study of marine soundscapes is a growing field of research. Recording hardware is becoming more accessible; there are a number of off-the-shelf autonomous recorders that can be deployed for months at a time; software analysis tools exist as shareware; raw or preprocessed recordings are freely and publicly available. However, what is missing are catalogues of commonly recorded sounds. Sounds related to geophysical events (e.g. earthquakes) and weather (e.g. wind and precipitation), to human activities (e.g. ships) and to marine animals (e.g. crustaceans, fish and marine mammals) commonly occur. Marine mammals are distributed throughout Australia’s oceans and significantly contribute to the underwater soundscape. However, due to a lack of concurrent visual and passive acoustic observations, it is often not known which species produces which sounds. To aid in the analysis of Australian and Antarctic marine soundscape recordings, a literature review of the sounds made by marine mammals was undertaken. Frequency, duration and source level measurements are summarised and tabulated. In addition to the literature review, new marine mammal data are presented and include recordings from Australia of Omura’s whales (Balaenoptera omurai), dwarf sperm whales (Kogia sima), common dolphins (Delphinus delphis), short-finned pilot whales (Globicephala macrorhynchus), long-finned pilot whales (G.
    [Show full text]
  • La Crème De La Crème
    W E L C O M E T O T H E H O C K E N Friends of the Hocken Collections B U L L E T I N NU M B E R 26 : November 1998 La Crème de la Crème THE MOVE of the Hocken Library, reconsolidated with Hocken Archives, into the old Otago Co-operative Dairy Company building on Anzac Avenue, is an opportune time to examine some of the material on the dairy industry held within the Hocken collections. While the NZ dairy industry is now more often associated with Taranaki and the Wai- kato, Otago has a special place in the history of that industry. The first co-operative dairy factory in New Zealand was located on the Otago Peninsula, and the country’s first refrigerated butter export sailed on the s.s.Dunedin from Port Chalmers in 1882. Both were seminal events for the industry that was to become one of New Zealand’s most important export earners. The first moves away from simple domestic production of butter and cheese towards a more commercial operation in New Zealand were probably made either on Banks Peninsula or in Taranaki in the 1850s. In 1855, some five tons of butter and 34 tons of cheese were exported from Banks Peninsula to the rest of New Zealand and Australia, while at some time during the decade a ‘factory’ was established in Taranaki to collect milk from several suppliers to produce cheese for local sale. However, the birth of the co-operative system which came to typify the New Zealand dairy industry took place in Otago.
    [Show full text]
  • Minutes of Otago Peninsula Community Board
    Otago Peninsula Community Board MINUTES Minutes of an ordinary meeting of the Otago Peninsula Community Board held in the Portobello Bowling Club, Sherwood Street, Portobello on Thursday 24 June 2021, commencing at 10:00 am. PRESENT Chairperson Paul Pope Members Lox Kellas Graham McArthur Cheryl Neill Edna Stevenson Cr Andrew Whiley IN ATTENDANCE Chris Henderson, Group Manager Waste and Environmental Services Governance Support Officer Lauren McDonald 1 OPENING Graham McArthur opened the meeting with a reflection on democracy. 2 PUBLIC FORUM 2.1 Public Forum - Fulton Hogan Paul Jamieson, Fulton Hogan Road Maintenance Manager provided an update on the peninsula connection project works and responded to questions from Board Members. 2.2 Public Forum – Pump Track Portobello Domain. Supporting information was provided to members from Portobello Community Inc, which outlined the community fund raising and budget to date, the proposed pump track design and build costs, and the DCC approval for the proposed track at the Portobello Domain. Members were advised that fundraising drives and grant applications were underway by Portobello Community Inc and that the anticipated start date for the build was Summer of 2022. Three Portobello School pupils spoke in support of the pump track and advised that they saw it as a community asset, providing a meeting place, of benefit to local businesses and encouraging visitors of all ages to Portobello to enjoy the outdoor facilities. Paul Pope advised that the Community Board would provide a letter of support to Portobello Community Inc, to support the ongoing funding raising efforts. Otago Peninsula Community Board Minutes 24 June 2021 Page 1 of 6 3 APOLOGIES Moved (Paul Pope/Lox Kellas): That the Board: Accepts the apology of Hoani Langsbury.
    [Show full text]
  • Sightings of Southern Right Whales Around 'Mainland' New Zealand
    Sightings of southern right whales around ‘mainland’ New Zealand SCIENCE FOR CONSERVATION 225 Nathalie J. Patenaude Published by Department of Conservation PO Box 10-420 Wellington, New Zealand Science for Conservation is a scientific monograph series presenting research funded by New Zealand Department of Conservation (DOC). Manuscripts are internally and externally peer-reviewed; resulting publications are considered part of the formal international scientific literature. Titles are listed in the DOC Science Publishing catalogue on the departmental website http:// www.doc.govt.nz and printed copies can be purchased from [email protected] © Copyright July 2003, New Zealand Department of Conservation ISSN 1173–2946 ISBN 0–478–22454–0 In the interest of forest conservation, DOC Science Publishing supports paperless electronic publishing. When printing, recycled paper is used wherever possible. This report was prepared for publication by DOC Science Publishing, Science & Research Unit; editing by Jaap Jasperse and layout by Ruth Munro. Publication was approved by the Manager, Science & Research Unit, Science Technology and Information Services, Department of Conservation, Wellington. CONTENTS Abstract 5 1. Introduction 6 1.1 Southern right whales in New Zealand waters 7 2. Purpose of research 8 3. Methods 9 3.1 Collation of sightings and photographs 9 3.2 Photo-identification and matching 10 4. Results 11 4.1 Sighting database 11 4.2 Trends in abundance 11 4.3 Distribution 14 4.4 Seasonality 15 4.5 Residence time 15 4.6 Behaviour 18 4.7 Photo-identification 19 5. Discussion 19 5.1 Limitations and biases 19 5.2 Evidence of a significant recovery of southern right whales around mainland New Zealand 20 5.3 Identifying important NZ coastal habitat for right whales 20 5.4 Determining residence time and behaviour of right whales 21 5.5 Determining by photo-identification matching if the right whales around mainland NZ represent a separate stock 21 5.6 Management recommendations 23 6.
    [Show full text]
  • The Natural Hazards of South Dunedin
    The Natural Hazards of South Dunedin July 2016 Otago Regional Council Private Bag 1954, Dunedin 9054 70 Stafford Street, Dunedin 9016 Phone 03 474 0827 Fax 03 479 0015 Freephone 0800 474 082 www.orc.govt.nz © Copyright for this publication is held by the Otago Regional Council. This publication may be reproduced in whole or in part, provided the source is fully and clearly acknowledged. ISBN: 978-0-908324-35-4 Report writers: Michael Goldsmith, ORC Natural Hazards Manager Sharon Hornblow, ORC Natural Hazards Analyst Reviewed by: Gavin Palmer, ORC Director Engineering, Hazards and Science External review by: David Barrell, Simon Cox, GNS Science, Dunedin Published July 2016 The natural hazards of South Dunedin iii Contents 1. Summary .............................................................................................................................. 1 2. Environmental setting .......................................................................................................... 3 2.1. Geographical setting ............................................................................................................ 3 2.2. Geological and marine processes........................................................................................ 6 2.3. European land-filling ............................................................................................................ 9 2.4. Meteorological setting ........................................................................................................11 2.5. Hydrological
    [Show full text]
  • Valuing the Otago Peninsula: the Economic Benefits of Conservation by Clem Tisdell, November 2007
    ISSN 1327-8231 ECONOMICS, ECOLOGY AND THE ENVIRONMENT Working Paper No. 149 Wildlife Conservation and the Value of New Zealand’s Otago Peninsula: Economic Impacts and Other Considerations by Clem Tisdell June 2008 THE UNIVERSITY OF QUEENSLAND ISSN 1327-8231 WORKING PAPERS ON ECONOMICS, ECOLOGY AND THE ENVIRONMENT Working Paper No. 149 Wildlife Conservation and the Value of New Zealand’s Otago Peninsula: Economic Impacts and Other Considerations* by Clem Tisdell† June 2008 © All rights reserved * This is a revised and extended version of Working Paper No. 145 in this series. It is a draft contribution to the edited book entitled Wildlife: Destruction, Conservation and Biodiversity to be published by Nova Science Publishers, New York. † School of Economics, The University of Queensland, Brisbane QLD 4072, Australia Email: [email protected] WORKING PAPERS IN THE SERIES, Economics, Ecology and the Environment are published by the School of Economics, University of Queensland, 4072, Australia, as follow up to the Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research Project 40 of which Professor Clem Tisdell was the Project Leader. Views expressed in these working papers are those of their authors and not necessarily of any of the organisations associated with the Project. They should not be reproduced in whole or in part without the written permission of the Project Leader. It is planned to publish contributions to this series over the next few years. Research for ACIAR project 40, Economic Impact and Rural Adjustments to Nature Conservation (Biodiversity) Programmes: A Case Study of Xishuangbanna Dai Autonomous Prefecture, Yunnan, China was sponsored by the Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research (ACIAR), GPO Box 1571, Canberra, ACT, 2601, Australia.
    [Show full text]
  • Otago Peninsula Plants
    Otago Peninsula Plants An annotated list of vascular plants growing in wild places Peter Johnson 2004 Published by Save The Otago Peninsula (STOP) Inc. P.O. Box 23 Portobello Dunedin, New Zealand ISBN 0-476-00473-X Contents Introduction...........................................................................................3 Maps......................................................................................................4 Study area and methods ........................................................................6 Plant identification................................................................................6 The Otago Peninsula environment........................................................7 Vegetation and habitats.........................................................................8 Analysis of the flora............................................................................10 Plant species not recently recorded.....................................................12 Abundance and rarity of the current flora...........................................13 Nationally threatened and uncommon plants......................................15 Weeds..................................................................................................17 List of plants .......................................................................................20 Ferns and fern allies ........................................................................21 Gymnosperms ..................................................................................27
    [Show full text]
  • New Zealand Hosts SMM Biennial
    New Zealand Hosts SMM Biennial Scenic vistas, wave-swept sandy beaches and coastal flax flowers are commonly seen along New Zealand’s eastern South Island coastline, such as this view of Sand Fly Bay on the Otago Peninsula. All photos in this article by Diane Alps. by Diane Alps Every two years, the Society for Marine Mammalogy hosts the world’s largest international conference focused on marine mammals. With over 2,000 marine mammal researchers participating in these week-long meetings, “The Biennial” is the leading venue for dissemination of the “latest and greatest” in marine mammal science. The Society for Marine Mammalogy (SMM) is a professional society whose mission is to promote the global advancement of marine mammal science and contribute to its relevance and impact in education, science, conservation and management. Founded in 1981, the Society was developed based on a need for an entity to organize and run the already successful, Biennial Conference on the Biology of Marine Mammals. The Biennial Conferences, indeed, predate the beginning of the Society (a detailed history can be found on the Society’s website). The first Biennial was held in 1975, with 300 attendees. Today, attendance at the Biennials often exceeds 2,000 marine mammal experts. These conferences play an important role in the world of marine mammal science, bringing researchers and students together to share findings, Spyhopper strategies and methods toward the advancement of the sciences. The Society’s scientific journal, Marine Mammal Science, is the leading journal for original research on (you guessed it!) marine mammal science, including form and function, evolution, ACS Newsletter systematics, physiology, biochemistry, behavior, population biology, life history, genetics, ecology June 2014 and conservation.
    [Show full text]
  • Environmental Evaluation International Ocean Discovery
    Environmental Evaluation International Ocean Discovery Program Expedition 369 from the R/V JOIDES Resolution off Western Australia, September–November 2017 Prepared for JOIDES Resolution Science Operator, Texas A&M University College Station, TX 77845 and National Science Foundation Division of Ocean Sciences 4201 Wilson Blvd., Suite 725 Arlington, VA 22230 by LGL Limited, environmental research associates 22 Fisher St., POB 280 King City, Ont. L7B 1A6 30 January 2017 LGL Report FA0105 Seismic Activities during IODP-JRSO Expedition 369, 2017 Page ii Table of Contents TABLE OF CONTENTS Page LIST OF ACRONYMS ..................................................................................................................................... iv 1. INTRODUCTION ...........................................................................................................................................1 2. VSP DETAILS AND MITIGATION MEASURES ..............................................................................................3 2.1 Airgun Size and Configuration ......................................................................................................3 2.2 Airgun Source Levels ....................................................................................................................3 2.3 Exclusion Zones for Marine Mammals, Sea Turtles, and Endangered Species ............................4 2.4 Protected Species Observers ..........................................................................................................8
    [Show full text]
  • Revisiting the Foraging Ecology and Extinction History of Two Endemic Vertebrates from Tenerife, Canary Islands
    quaternary Article Revisiting the Foraging Ecology and Extinction History of Two Endemic Vertebrates from Tenerife, Canary Islands Brooke Erin Crowley 1,* , Yurena Yanes 2, Stella Grace Mosher 3 and Juan Carlos Rando 4 1 University of Cincinnati, Departments of Geology and Anthropology, Cincinnati, OH 45221, USA 2 University of Cincinnati, Department of Geology, Cincinnati, Ohio 45221, USA; [email protected] 3 Salt Lake Community College, Division of Natural Sciences, Salt Lake City, UT 84123, USA; [email protected] 4 Universidad de La Laguna, Departamento de Biología Animal, Edafología y Geología, 38200 Santa Cruz de Tenerife, Spain; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected]; Tel.: +1-513-221-1039 Received: 11 January 2019; Accepted: 18 February 2019; Published: 21 February 2019 Abstract: We used carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) isotopes to examine the foraging ecology of Tenerife giant rats (Canariomys bravoi) and lizards (Gallotia goliath) in northwestern Tenerife, which until recently, were the island’s largest terrestrial vertebrates. We combined new isotope data for 28 C. bravoi and 14 G. goliath with published regional data for both species and then compared these with data for co-occurring extant taxa and modern C3 plants. Isotope data suggest both extinct species relied primarily on C3 resources and were trophic omnivores. However, the two species appear to have partitioned their resources when living in sympatry. Isotopic overlap between C. bravoi and Rattus spp., and between G. goliath, extant Gallotia galloti, and introduced rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus) suggests reliance on similar foods. We radiocarbon dated four C. bravoi and two G. goliath with the most extreme isotope values.
    [Show full text]