HEP Analysis
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
HEP Analysis John Morris Monte Carlo What is MC? Why use MC? MC Generation Detector Sim Reconstruction Reconstruction Event Properties HEP Analysis MC Corrections MC Corrections Re-Weighting Tag & Probe John Morris Smearing Summary Queen Mary University of London Measurements 2012 Cross section Luminosity Selection Backgrounds Efficiency Results Uncertainties Statistical Luminosity Experimental Modelling Searches Searches Higgs BSM Conclusion 1 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris HEP Analysis Monte Carlo What is MC? Why use MC? MC Generation Outline Detector Sim Reconstruction • Monte Carlo (MC) Reconstruction • What is MC and why do we use it? Event Properties MC Corrections • MC event generation MC Corrections • MC detector simulation Re-Weighting Tag & Probe • What happens when MC does not agree with data? Smearing Summary • Event re-weighting Measurements • 4-vector smearing Cross section Luminosity • Cross Section measurement Selection Backgrounds Efficiency • Systematic uncertainties Results Uncertainties Statistical • These notes will focus on the ATLAS experiment, but also apply Luminosity Experimental to other experiments Modelling • Searches Borrowing slides, plots and ideas from E. Rizvi, T. Sjostrand Searches and ATLAS public results Higgs BSM Conclusion 2 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris HEP Analysis Monte Carlo What is MC? This is not an in-depth MC course Why use MC? MC Generation Detector Sim • The subject of MC is vast Reconstruction Reconstruction • There are many different models, generators and techniques Event Properties • Could spend hours, weeks, months on each MC Corrections MC Corrections • These slides are just a brief outline Re-Weighting Tag & Probe • Focus on the generalities Smearing Summary • Explain the steps involved Measurements • Not going to get bogged down in details Cross section Luminosity Selection Aim of this course Backgrounds Efficiency • Aim is to provide a working knowledge of MC basics Results • Steps involved in generation Uncertainties Statistical • Introduction to various systematics Luminosity Experimental • Techniques for correcting MC to describe data Modelling Searches • Overview of a measurement Searches Higgs • Systematics BSM Conclusion 3 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris Monte Carlo (MC) - What is MC? Monte Carlo What is MC? Why use MC? MC Generation Detector Sim • MC is a simulation of collisions between particles Reconstruction • Reconstruction For these notes, pp collisions in ATLAS at the LHC Event Properties • MC is used in all particle physics experiments MC Corrections MC Corrections • MC generation is broadly split into 2 parts: Re-Weighting 1 Generation of the physics process Tag & Probe Smearing • Matrix element calculation Summary • ...(lots of steps)... Measurements • 4-vectors of final state hadrons Cross section Luminosity 2 Simulation of the detector Selection Backgrounds • Trigger, tracking and calorimeter simulation Efficiency • ...(lots of steps)... Results • Analysis objects like electrons and jets Uncertainties Statistical • End result: Luminosity Experimental • MC Samples in the same format as the actual data Modelling • With additional information from Step 1, the truth record Searches Searches Higgs BSM Conclusion 4 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris Monte Carlo (MC) - What is MC? Monte Carlo What is MC? Why use MC? MC Generation Detector Sim Reconstruction Reconstruction Event Properties MC Corrections MC Corrections Re-Weighting Tag & Probe Smearing Summary Measurements Cross section Luminosity Selection Backgrounds Efficiency Results Uncertainties Statistical Luminosity Experimental Modelling Searches • MC simulates what happens at the LHC and ATLAS Searches Higgs • Many different programmes can be used at each stage BSM Conclusion 5 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris Monte Carlo (MC) - Why use MC? Monte Carlo What is MC? Why use generators? Why use MC? MC Generation Detector Sim • Allows studies of complex multi-particle physics Reconstruction Reconstruction • Allows studies of theoretical models Event Properties • ) What does a SUSY signal look like? MC Corrections MC Corrections Can be used to Re-Weighting Tag & Probe Smearing • Predict cross sections and topologies of various processes Summary • ) Feasibility study - Can we find the theoretical particle X? Measurements Cross section • Simulate background processes to the signal of interest Luminosity Selection • ) Can devise analysis strategies Backgrounds Efficiency • Study detector response Results Uncertainties • ) Optimise trigger & detector selection cuts Statistical Luminosity • Study detector imperfections Experimental Modelling • ) Can evaluate acceptance corrections Searches • See next week for a discussion of acceptance Searches Higgs • Remove the effect of the apparatus from the measurement BSM • ) Unfold the data. Correcting the data for detector effects Conclusion 6 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris MC Generation Monte Carlo What is MC? Why use MC? MC Generation Detector Sim Use random numbers for integration Reconstruction Reconstruction • Code uses random number generator to integrate Event Properties x2 MC Corrections Z MC Corrections f (x) :dx = (x2 − x1) hf (x)i Re-Weighting x1 Tag & Probe Smearing N Summary 1 X hf (x)i = f (x ) Measurements N i Cross section i=1 Luminosity Selection Backgrounds Efficiency • Cross section randomly sampled over phase space Results • Want to generate events that simulate nature Uncertainties Statistical • Get average and fluctuations right Luminosity Experimental • Need to make random choices, as in nature Modelling • An event with n particles involves O (10n) random choices Searches • LHC events involve 1000's of random choices Searches Higgs BSM Conclusion 7 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris Monte Carlo Generation Monte Carlo What is MC? Why use MC? MC Generation Detector Sim Reconstruction Reconstruction Event Properties MC Corrections MC Corrections Re-Weighting Tag & Probe Smearing Summary Measurements Cross section Luminosity Selection Backgrounds Efficiency Results Uncertainties Statistical Luminosity Experimental Modelling Searches Searches Higgs BSM Conclusion 8 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris Monte Carlo Generation Monte Carlo What is MC? Why use MC? MC Generation Detector Sim Reconstruction Reconstruction Event Properties MC Corrections MC Corrections Re-Weighting Tag & Probe Smearing Summary Measurements Cross section Luminosity Selection Backgrounds Efficiency Results Uncertainties Statistical Luminosity Experimental Modelling Searches Searches Higgs BSM Conclusion 9 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris Monte Carlo Generation Monte Carlo What is MC? Why use MC? MC Generation Detector Sim Reconstruction Identifying theoretical modelling uncertainties Reconstruction Event Properties MC Corrections • Let's look at some of these steps in more detail MC Corrections Re-Weighting • There are several ways to perform each step Tag & Probe Smearing • This choice leads to theoretical modelling uncertainties Summary • These uncertainties enter into most LHC results Measurements Cross section • Want to understand where they come from Luminosity Selection • Theoretical modelling uncertainties include: Backgrounds Efficiency • Generator uncertainties Results • PDF uncertainties Uncertainties Statistical • Parton shower uncertainties Luminosity • Hadronisation uncertainties Experimental Modelling Searches Searches Higgs BSM Conclusion 10 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris Matrix element calculation Monte Carlo What is MC? Why use MC? Normally calculated at LO or NLO MC Generation Detector Sim Reconstruction Reconstruction Event Properties MC Corrections MC Corrections Re-Weighting Tag & Probe Smearing Summary Measurements Cross section • Higher order corrections are important: Luminosity Selection • Normalisation and shape of kinematic distributions Backgrounds Efficiency • Multiplicity of objects like jets Results Uncertainties • Higher order corrections are hard to calculate and CPU intensive Statistical Luminosity • Several programs that will do the calculation Experimental Modelling • Different calculation techniques Searches • Different assumptions Searches • Different results Higgs BSM • ) Theoretical modelling uncertainty Conclusion 11 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris PDF Monte Carlo What is MC? The ProtonPartonDensityFunction (PDF) Why use MC? MC Generation Detector Sim • Proton is not a point-like particle, it's full of partons Reconstruction Reconstruction • Need to calculate: Event Properties • Probability of propagator interacting with quarks/gluon MC Corrections 2 MC Corrections • Needed as a function of Q and x Re-Weighting Tag & Probe Smearing HERA I+II inclusive, jets, charm PDF Fit • Various groups provide PDFs Summary 1 xf Q2 = 10 GeV2 Measurements • Parametrised differently Cross section HERAPDF1.7 (prel.) 0.8 Luminosity exp. uncert. • LHC uses: Selection model uncert. Backgrounds parametrization uncert. • xuv CTEQ Efficiency 0.6 Results HERAPDF1.6 (prel.) • MSTW Uncertainties • NNPDF Statistical 0.4 × Luminosity xg ( 0.05) xdv • Get a different result using Experimental Modelling different PDFs Searches 0.2 • ) Theoretical modelling Searches xS (× 0.05) Higgs uncertainty BSM HERAPDF Structure Function Working Group June 2011 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 1 Conclusion x 12 / 105 HEP Analysis John Morris Parton Showering Monte Carlo What is MC? Why use MC? MC Generation Detector Sim Reconstruction Reconstruction Event Properties MC Corrections MC Corrections Re-Weighting Tag & Probe Smearing Summary Measurements Cross section Luminosity Selection Backgrounds • Efficiency Need to go from 2!2 scattering