Bulgaria: Phase 2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DIRECTORATE FOR FINANCIAL, FISCAL AND ENTERPRISE AFFAIRS BULGARIA: PHASE 2 REPORT ON THE APPLICATION OF THE CONVENTION ON COMBATING BRIBERY OF FOREIGN PUBLIC OFFICIALS IN INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS TRANSACTIONS AND THE 1997 RECOMMENDATION ON COMBATING BRIBERY IN INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS TRANSACTIONS This report was approved and adopted by the Working Group on Bribery in International Business Transactions (CIME) on 6 June 2003. TABLE OF CONTENTS A. INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................................ 4 a) Nature of the on-site visit............................................................................................................ 4 b) Methodology and structure of the report..................................................................................... 5 c) Institutional, political and economic framework ........................................................................ 5 d) Measures to fight against corruption........................................................................................... 7 B. DOES BULGARIA HAVE EFFECTIVE MEASURES FOR PREVENTING AND DETECTING THE BRIBERY OF FOREIGN PUBLIC OFFICIALS? ............................................................................ 8 a) Awareness................................................................................................................................... 8 i) Public awareness......................................................................................................................... 8 ii) Government Awareness............................................................................................................10 b) Statistics and information about corruption.............................................................................. 11 c) Reporting .................................................................................................................................. 12 i) Reporting by members of the public......................................................................................... 13 Whistleblower and witness protection ............................................................................................... 13 Criminal defamation laws .................................................................................................................. 14 Access to Information ........................................................................................................................ 14 Hotlines and anonymous tip-offs ....................................................................................................... 15 ii) Reporting by public authorities.................................................................................................15 Tax authorities and the reporting of foreign bribery.......................................................................... 15 Reporting of money-laundering......................................................................................................... 17 iii) Disclosure by accountants and auditors.................................................................................... 19 d) Privatisation, public procurement and the arms trade............................................................... 21 (i) Privatisation................................................................................................................................... 21 (ii) Public Procurement ...................................................................................................................... 22 (iii) The Arms Trade .......................................................................................................................... 23 e) Sanctions for the offence of bribing a foreign public official................................................... 24 (i) Availability of Fines ................................................................................................................. 24 (ii) Availability of Confiscation.................................................................................................. 24 C. DOES BULGARIA HAVE ADEQUATE MECHANISMS FOR THE EFFECTIVE PROSECUTION OF FOREIGN BRIBERY OFFENCES?...................................................................... 26 a). The issue of the absence of liability of legal persons ............................................................... 26 b) The foreign bribery offence ...................................................................................................... 27 The elements of the offence............................................................................................................... 28 c) The money laundering offence ................................................................................................. 30 d) Working of the main enforcement agencies ............................................................................. 31 (i) Authorities responsible for investigation and prosecution........................................................ 31 (ii) Special Investigative Techniques.......................................................................................... 32 Generally............................................................................................................................................ 32 Access to bank information and lifting of bank secrecy.................................................................... 33 (iii) Co-ordination, co-operation and sharing of information .......................................................... 34 iv) Working of the judiciary........................................................................................................... 35 Generally............................................................................................................................................ 35 2 Judicial immunity from prosecution .................................................................................................. 35 Amendments to the Law on the Judiciary..........................................................................................37 v) Practice of referring cases back to pre-trial authorities............................................................. 38 vi) Overall monitoring of the enforcement effort........................................................................... 38 e) Mutual legal assistance ............................................................................................................. 39 D. RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................................................................................... 41 a) Recommendations..................................................................................................................... 41 b) Follow-up issues ....................................................................................................................... 43 3 A. INTRODUCTION a) Nature of the on-site visit Bulgaria ratified the Convention on Combating Bribery of Foreign Public Officials in International Business Transactions on 22 December 1998. It is a member of the OECD Working Group on Bribery in International Business Transactions, but is not a member of the OECD. In July 1999 the Working Group reviewed Bulgaria in Phase 1 of the follow-up process. A team from the Working Group visited Bulgaria in November 2002 to carry out the on-site visit under Phase 2. The team from the OECD Working Group was composed of lead examiners from Norway and Poland as well as representatives of the OECD Secretariat1. The meetings took place over the course of four days, mostly at the offices of the Ministry of Justice in Sofia, and brought together officials from the following Bulgarian government departments and agencies: the Ministry of Justice (Inspectorate, Directorate of International Legal Co-operation and International Legal Assistance, and Centre for Training of Magistrates), the Ministry of Finance (Bureau for Financial Intelligence, Public Internal Financial Control Agency, General Tax Directorate, and Customs Agency), the National Audit Office, the Ministry of Interior (National Service on Combating Organised Crime, Directorate of Inspection, National Police Service, National Border Police Service, International Co-operation Directorate, and Co-ordination and Analysis Directorate), the Ministry of Economy (Trade Promotion Agency, Internationally Controlled Trade Directorate, Directorate of Multilateral Trade Policy and Regional Co-operation), the National Investigation Service, the Privatisation Agency, the Public Procurement Directorate, judges, public prosecutors, and the Commission for Co-ordination of Activities in the Fight Against Corruption. The OECD team visited the offices of the Delegation of the European Commission to Bulgaria. The OECD team also met with representatives of the Institute of Certified Public Accountants in Bulgaria, the Centre for the Study of Democracy, the Open Society Institute, Transparency International Bulgaria and the law firm of Maximova & Ventcharska, and with a journalist from the national daily press. Part of the examining team met with representatives of the Bulgarian Business Leaders’ Forum and the Confederation of Independent Trade Unions in Bulgaria, and also with a Member of the Bulgarian Parliament. Pursuant to the procedure agreed to by the Working Group for the Phase 2 self and mutual evaluation of the implementation