EARLY MUSIC PERFORMER JOURNAL OF THE NATIONAL EARLY MUSIC ASSOCIATION ISSUE 41 October 2017 I.S.S.N 1477-478X Published biannually by Ruxbury Publications (Hebden Bridge) on behalf of the National Early Music Association (NEMA) Subscription is arranged by becoming a member of NEMA at a cost of £15 (all categories) Contact: John Bence, Administrator (
[email protected]) • JOHANN BAPTIST VANHAL, STRING QUARTETS OP. 33, NOS. 1–3, ED. 2 DAVID C. BIRCHLER EDITORIAL Simone Laghi Andrew Woolley 27 3 • PUBLICATIONS LIST ARTICLES Compiled by James Hume • MUSEUM PIECES? SIXTEENTH- CENTURY SACRED POLYPHONY AND THE MODERN ENGLISH TRADITION OF A CAPELLA PERFORMANCE David Allinson 10 • THE ACCELERATING TACTUS Richard Bethell 20 COVER: an excerpt from John Playford’s An Introduction to the Skill of Musick REVIEWS (London, 1694) concerned with metre and tempo. • MASSES BY LUDWIG DASER AND MATTHAEUS LE MAISTRE: PARODY MASSES ON JOSQUIN’S MOTETS, ED. STEPHANIE P. SCHLAGEL Megan K. Eagen-Jones • REFLECTIONS OF AN AMERICAN HARPSICHORDIST, ED. EDITOR: Andrew Woolley MEREDITH KIRKPATRICK EDITORIAL ASSISTANTS: Stephanie Carter and James Hume John Kitchen EDITORIAL BOARD: Peter Holman (Chairman), Clifford Bartlett, Clive Brown, Nancy Hadden, David Lasocki, Richard Maunder, Christopher Page, Andrew Parrott, Richard Rastall, Michael Talbot, Bryan White 1 Editorial This EMP offers two contrasting perspectives on the interpretative choices of early music performers, a topic that has been touched on previously in these pages. In 2014, Alberto Sanna wrote about the tendency to apply a one-size-fits-all ‘Baroque’ paradigm, modelled on eighteenth-century practices, in seventeenth-century Italian sonatas.1 This is an inheritance from when ‘Baroque’, as a music-historical term, became widely adopted after 1945, but as Sanna noted, it sustains itself because of the way early music is taught and for commercial reasons, in spite of advances in understanding of seventeenth-century performance practices.