Road Safety Audit of an Existing Road, from Ashram Chowk to CRRI
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
International Journal of Latest Engineering Research and Applications (IJLERA) ISSN: 2455-7137 Volume – 02, Issue – 08, August – 2017, PP – 134-142 Road Safety Audit of an Existing Road, From Ashram Chowk to CRRI N. Naveen1,2, Dr. S. Velmurugan3 1(Assistant Professor, K G Reddy College of Engineering and Technology, Hyderabad, India) 2(Research scholar, VELS University, Chennai, India) 3(Sr. Prin. Scientist, Traffic & Safety Division, CRRI, New Delhi, India) Abstract: “Pedestrian” includes people who walk, sit, stand in public spaces, or use a mobility aid like walking stick, crutches or wheelchair, be they children, teenagers, adults, elderly persons, persons with disabilities, workers, residents, shoppers or people-watchers (IRC: 103-2012). Road Safety audit is the formal procedure for assessing accident potential and safety performance in the provision of new road schemes, the improvement and rehabilitation of existing road and maintenance of roads. The road selected for this study is existing road from Ashram Chowk to CRRI, which is at Delhi to Mathura road. The main tool is Road Safety Audit. This paper explores the defects in the design and other safety features. Thisaudit is a part of CRRI Road Safety Audit Training Program. In conclusion, we argue that significant measures should be taken on Road Safety aspects to mitigate the accidents and ensure the safety to pedestrians and vehicular traffic. This paper mainly highlights the safety in terms of pedestrians and traffic sign post alignment. Keywords: Accidents, CRRI, Pedestrians, Road Safety Audit, Safety, Sign boards, Vehicular Traffic. I. INTRODUCTION Road safety audit assess the operation of a road, focusing on road safety as it affects the users of the road. These users include pedestrians, cyclists, motorcyclists, truck/ bus drivers, on road public transport users, etc. Road traffic injuries are the No.1 cause of death among those aged 15–29. Road users are not perfect.The main cause for the accidents is road users, Confusion in drivers, fatigue, stress, negligence may lead to the accidents. RSA is a formal process and not an informal check Carried out by persons who are independent of the design and the construction Carried out by persons with appropriate expertise, experience and training Restricted to road safety issues The outcome of a road safety audit is the identification of any road safety deficiencies and formulation of recommendations aimed at removing or reducing those deficiencies. TABLE1 Percentage wise contribution of various elements in road accidents ELEMENT PERCENTAGE Road User 65.0 Road and Surroundings 2.5 Vehicle 2.5 Road User, Road Surroundings 24.0 Road User and Vehicle 4.5 Road User, Road & Surroundings 1.5 and Vehicle Following considerations should be taken Level of safety considering the function of the road Readability of road Delineation Roadside hazards www.ijlera.com 2017 IJLERA – All Right Reserved 134 | Page International Journal of Latest Engineering Research and Applications (IJLERA) ISSN: 2455-7137 Volume – 02, Issue – 08, August – 2017, PP – 134-142 Aspects to be checked are Safety and Operational Implications of alignment and junctions, Any deviation from standards, Facilities for pedestrians, Cyclists and intermediate transport, Road safety implication on maintenance, Non-Motorized Road Users, Day and Night Trials checks, Drainage, Climate conditions, Landscaping, Services, Access, Skid resistance, Fences , Adjacent development, Bridge parapets, Local Alignment, Visibility, New / existing road surface, Safety Aids on steep hills, Road signs markings, T, X, Y- junctions, Traffic signals, Adjacent land, Pedestrians, Cyclists, Non-motorized vehicles, Signs and Lighting , Lighting, Signs, Variable message signs . II. SITE SELECTED The road selected for this study is existing road from Ashram Chowk to CRRI, which is at Delhi to Mathura road. Fig 1 The above image showsAshram Chowk to CRRI Road map. Ashram chowk is a crossways located on the southeastern corner of the Delhi ring road. It is at the intersection of the ring road and Mathura road from the ITO crossing, the Supreme court, Pragati Maidan, Purana Quila, Nizamuddin Dargah and Haryana border at Faridabad. The distance between these two points is 4 kilometers. It is a busy area with heavy traffic, even pedestrian traffic is also heavy at this section. “Pedestrian” includes people who walk, sit, stand in public spaces, or use a mobility aid like walking stick, crutches or wheelchair, be they children, teenagers, adults, elderly persons, persons with disabilities, workers, residents, shoppers or people-watchers (IRC: 103-2012). The key principles of the Safe System approach should be, i. Recognition of human error in the transport system ii. Recognition of human physical vulnerability and limits iii. Promotion of system accountability iv. Promotion of ethical values in road safety v. Promotion of societal values www.ijlera.com 2017 IJLERA – All Right Reserved 135 | Page International Journal of Latest Engineering Research and Applications (IJLERA) ISSN: 2455-7137 Volume – 02, Issue – 08, August – 2017, PP – 134-142 III. INVESTIGATIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Fig 2 Team members of Existing Road Safety Audit with the team head Dr. S Velmurugansir. This audit is a part of CRRI Road Safety Audit Training Program in July,2017. Some of the checklist included in this audit are like i. Is the provision for road signs adequate and in accordance with standards? ii. Are there any situations where traffic signs themselves are obstructing essential line of sight for drivers and pedestrians? iii. General adequacy and visibility of road markings, during day/night time and in wet/ dry weather conditions iv. Are the proposed lighting scheme and illumination levels of an appropriate standard, consistent with the needs of the location, pedestrian and other factors? v. Are there any poles, columns along the road and comment on whether some or any of them can be removed, relocated to less hazardous positions etc. Fig 3The End treatment of Metal Beam Crash Barrier is missing 3.1. Observation The End treatment of Metal Beam Crash Barrier is missing. Reason for Concern: Vehicles plying on the road may hit the protruded MBCB which may result to fatal accident. Recommendation: It shall be provided with suitable end treatment with the inclined metal beam mounted to the end post and fixed into the median. www.ijlera.com 2017 IJLERA – All Right Reserved 136 | Page International Journal of Latest Engineering Research and Applications (IJLERA) ISSN: 2455-7137 Volume – 02, Issue – 08, August – 2017, PP – 134-142 Priority: Highly Essential. Fig4The sign Boards placed over the footpath and over-head Gantry are place properly 3.2. Observation The sign Boards placed over the footpath and over-head Gantry are place properly. Priority: Followed the safety norm completely Fig5 The slope of ground of the Petrol Pump is towards the carriageway 3.3. Observation The slope of ground of the Petrol Pump is towards the carriageway Reason for Concern: The slope of the ground of petrol pump may discharge the rain water directly to the main carriageway, resulting in the water-logged situation on the MCW. Recommendation: Proper drainage shall be provided to check the water directly discharging to the carriageway. Priority: Highly Essential www.ijlera.com 2017 IJLERA – All Right Reserved 137 | Page International Journal of Latest Engineering Research and Applications (IJLERA) ISSN: 2455-7137 Volume – 02, Issue – 08, August – 2017, PP – 134-142 Fig6 kerb placed is at a great height 3.4. Observation Water Logging at the Bus-stop The floor of the Bus-stop is raised abnormally. The sign board placed near by the bus stop is obstruction to the pedestrians. Reason for Concern: This situation obstructs the pedestrians and the public transport users to enter the bus stop Recommendation: The height of the footpath shall be reduced as per the relevant IRC norms, water logging should be avoided. Priority: Highly Essential Fig7 Ganty Post lying on the foot path creating hindrance to the pedestrians. 3.5. Observation Ganty Post lying on the foot path creating hindrance to the pedestrians & Unnecessary construction on the footpath Reason for Concern: This is creating hindrance to the pedestrians & Causes obstruction on the footpath to the pedestrians during nights Recommendation: It shall be removed immediately & Extra projections should be removed Priority: Highly Essential www.ijlera.com 2017 IJLERA – All Right Reserved 138 | Page International Journal of Latest Engineering Research and Applications (IJLERA) ISSN: 2455-7137 Volume – 02, Issue – 08, August – 2017, PP – 134-142 Fig8 Trees planted in the median 3.6. Observation Trees planted in the median. Reason for Concern: The branches protruding creates hindrance to the road users obstructs the visibility. Recommendation: The Branches shall be trimmed periodically. And the tree plantation shall not be done in the medians. Priority: Desirable Fig9 Electric Pole tilted on the footpath 3.7. Observation Electric Pole tilted on the footpath. Reason for Concern: It is causing hindrance to the pedestrians, it may be fatal in the rainy reason. Recommendation: The pole must be removed/replaced. Priority: Desirable www.ijlera.com 2017 IJLERA – All Right Reserved 139 | Page International Journal of Latest Engineering Research and Applications (IJLERA) ISSN: 2455-7137 Volume – 02, Issue – 08, August – 2017, PP – 134-142 Fig10 Drainage slab are weak and they are destroyed 3.8. Observation