Systems Approach to the Concept of Environment1' 2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Copyright © 1978 Ohio Acad. Sci. 0030-0950/78/0004-0206S2.00/0 SYSTEMS APPROACH TO THE CONCEPT OF ENVIRONMENT1' 2 BERNARD C. PATTEN, Department of Zoology and Institute of Ecology, University of Georgia, Athens, GA 30602 Abstract. A systems theory of environment formulates causal interactions between things, including organisms, and their environments in terms of four system theoretical abstract objects. Creaons receive stimuli and implicitly create input environments. Genons react to received causes and generate potential output environments as effects. A holon represents the combined input-output model of an entity consisting of a creaon and a genon. An environ is a creaon and its corresponding input environment, or a genon and its related output environment. The theory is presented in terms of three propositions that: (1) recognize two distinct environments (input and output) asso- ciated with things, (2) establish things and their environments as units (environs) to be taken together, and (3) partition systems into input and output environs associated with intrasystem creaons and genons, respectively. OHIO J. SCI. 78(4): 206, 1978 Ecology is the biological science of en- organism, loose usage frequently extends vironment. It considers environment as the concept from individuals to groups a derivative of physiology in the sense {our environment), or suggests something that environment contains resources to absolute (the environment). The dic- be mobilized by organisms, and condi- tionary defines environment variously as: tions of life under which this mobilization "the surrounding conditions, influences or must occur. The resource in least sup- forces that influence or modify; the whole ply at any given time is rate limiting (law complex of climatic, edaphic and biotic of the minimum), as is the factor, such as factors that act upon an organism or an temperature, in greatest extreme (law of ecological community and ultimately de- tolerance). Thus, the organism is seen termine its form and survival; the aggre- by ecology to inhabit a physiological life gate of social and cultural conditions that space bounded by conservative and non- influence the life of an individual or com- conservative elements of its environment munity," (Merriam-Webster 1971). The —resources and factors, respectively. significant features of environment in The nature and composition of this life ordinary usage are that some defined sub- space varies according to the character ject (individual or group) is immersed in of the larger system of which the organ- or surrounded by it, and influenced by ism is seen as a part. Population aspects it through a causal relationship. This of environment encompass the intra- causality, as developed below, is the specific reproductive, genetic, demo- basis for the present attempt to express graphic and social worlds of the organ- environment in terms of system theory, ism. A community aspect refers to in- which is the purpose of this paper. terspecific biotic associations. The eco- system aspect takes into account all fea- SYSTEMS DEFINITIONS tures of the organism's biotic and abiotic Systems ecology is a branch of ecology interactions. that applies systems thinking and meth- ods to ecological problems. Several def- Although the strict ecological idea of initions of basic system concepts are use- environment is based on the individual ful in prospect of a systems approach to defining environment. A system is a 1Manuscript received January 19, 1977 and in revised form June 15, 1978 (#77-6). partially interconnected (interacting or 2University of Georgia Contributions in Sys- causally joined) set of components. In- tems Ecology, No. 41. teractions may be mediated by energy- 206 Ohio J. Sci. EIA-SYSTEMS APPROACH 207 matter through transactions, or by infor- an organism. Non-environment consists mation through communications. Trans- of all phenomena (indirect, historical and actions and communications correspond, organism-caused) which never enter into respectively, to transfers of conservative a direct environmental relation with the resources and nonconservative factors in organism. the physiological account of environment Mason and Langenheim (1957) as- described above. serted, "the environment of any organ- In a hierarchical model of nature, any ism is the class ... of those phenomena given system can usefully be abstracted that enter a reaction system of the organ- as three discrete levels separated out of a ism or otherwise directly impinge upon it hierarchical continuum: system, subsys- to affect its mode of life at any time tem and supersystem. Subsystems are throughout its life cycle as ordered by the components of the systems. Supersys- demands of the ontogeny of the organism tems are composed of systems. Koestler's or as ordered by any other condition . (1967) term "holon" for a hierarchical that alters its environmental demands." system can be used to refer to any of Only direct factors were considered part these three levels of organization, accord- of environment. "[Indirect and histori- ing to the frame of reference. cal] factors both function to condition a A system is closed if it does not interact phenomenon ... to which an organism with another system, and open if it re- then reacts. Important as this is to the ceives causes from or generates effects to ecosystem the only [organism] reaction another system. A system boundary ... is to an already conditioned phe- provides the interface with other systems nomenon. The state of the phenomenon and is defined by specifying its component prior to its conditioning is outside the set. Input is any movement of energy- scope of operational . and . po- matter or information from supersystem tential environment. This may seem to system, and output is any similar to rest upon trivial distinctions, but we movement across the system boundary in are convinced that this is the precise the opposite direction. boundary between clarity and confusion in the problems of the environment." ECOLOGICAL CONCEPTS OF Thus, chains and networks of historical ENVIRONMENT causation, which condition direct factors, Environment as a concept has not been are excluded from Mason and Langen- treated very seriously in ecological litera- heim's (1957) concept of environment: ture and only a few explicit works are "... we must reject the implication that available. Mason and Langenheim (1957) . [causal] chains constitute a unitary defined environmental phenomena as those event playing a significant role in the en- that have or may have an operational re- vironmental relation even though the lation with any organism. The environ- steps are very important to the ecosys- mental relation of an organism is the sum tem. There is also a philosophical of empirical relations between the en- reason for removing indirect factors from vironmental phenomena and any indi- the concept of environment. To intro- vidual organism. The operational en- duce indirect factors into causal relations vironment of an organism consists of those within the environment is to introduce an instantaneous environmental phenomena infinite regress into the system of expla- that actually enter a relation with an or- nation. Every cause has in turn itself ganism; the concept applies to specific in- a cause which becomes an indirect cause dividual organisms. Space and time of the most recent effect. The regress is frames of the operational environment toward the limbo of ultimate cause along are determined by the organism. The an infinitely reticulating path; for this life span of the organism corresponds to we have neither finite description nor the existence time of its operational en- finite explanation. To include such vironment. Potential environment con- relations in environment is to confuse en- sists of the set of environmental phenom- vironment with its history." ena that may enter into an environmental A systems ecology concept of environ- relation at some point in the ontogeny of ment must take issue with the Mason and 208 BERNARD C. PATTEN Vol. 78 Langenehim theory. The whole thrust causes as well, so long as their eventual of a systems understanding of nature is influences can be propagated to a sub- to reconstruct the main patterns of causa- ject, such as an organism, during its tion in models. Within the confines of a existence interval. Systems ecology mod- finite model forming a whole from inter- els that represent complex intrasystem connected parts, an expanded concept of webs of direct and indirect causation environment of the parts is possible, make it possible to implement such an which includes both direct and indirect expanded concept of environment. A factors. The intrasystem causal net- formal approach to such implementation work is never an unknown infinite regress, is described below. but is explicit to the model boundary which constitutes the limit of finite de- HOLONS scription and explanation which were General systems theory defines a sys- lacking in Mason and Langenheim's time. tem to be a partially interconnected set of While the conditioning of direct causes by objects, then proceeds to describe the ob- indirect effects may be temporally ante- jects and various aspects of their inter- cedent, ecosystems and their models are active coupling. Formal details differ persistent or recurrent organizations so with the specific theory, but most general that historical patterns of causation are systems objects have in common that in relevant, with perhaps small corrections some sense they perform