Example Level 1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
(v. 2.0) OHIO DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION OFFICE OF ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES 1980 WEST BROAD STREET COLUMBUS, OHIO 43223 (614) 466-7100 Project C-R-S / Name: GAL-TR 752-0.29 Project Identification Number (PID): 93152 Report Type: Level One ESR (MOA) Report Author(s): Curt Hatton Ohio Department of Affiliation: Transportation, District 9 Phone: 740-774-8979 Email: [email protected] 7/20/2012 (OES Revised Date of Submission: 8-24-12) LEVEL 1 ECOLOGICAL SURVEY GENERAL PROJECT INFORMATION ODOT District: 9 County(ies): Gallia Township(s): Walnut Latitude: 38.7558 Study Area Area of Construction 0.5 ac 0.1 ac Longitude: -82.4584 Size (ac): Limits (ac): Date of Survey Work (mm/dd/yyyy): 5/15/2012, 6/8/2012 and 7/3/2012 HUC 14: 05090101090030 Project Description (include a detailed description of the construction activities): It is proposed to replace a bridge over Symmes Creek on TR 752 in Gallia County, Ohio. The bridge, located at GAL-TR 752-0.29, is a steel pony truss simple span with a corrugated steel plate deck. The current bridge will be replaced with a similar type of bridge. The project is design build. The existing structure (SFN 2743531) over Symmes Creek has a sufficiency rating of 21.7 SD and the general appraisal rating is 4. No new right-of-way will be needed for the project. No homes or businesses will be removed by the project. The project is located in a rural area in Walnut Township of Gallia County. Symmes Creek is a perennial stream that is in the Ohio River drainage basin. Within the project area the Symmes Creek has a drainage area of 194 mi². Some small trees and bushes will be removed as part of the project; however, none of the trees have the habitat for the federally endangered Indiana Bat. The funding for the project is 80% Federal and 20% Local with a total cost of $948,200. The environmental commitment date is 5/15/2015. The project is currently expected to be awarded 11/3/2016. VEGETATIVE COMMUNITIES AND LAND COVER WITHIN CONSTRUCTION LIMITS (areas impacted by the project) Vegetative Communities and Land Cover found Unique, Rare, or Degree of Man Induced Ecological Disturbance Impacted Acres within the Construction Limits: High Quality? Intermediate Disturbance (dominated by plants Scrub/Shrub - SS - (true shrubs, and young trees that typify a stable phase of a native community NO 0.01 in an early successional stage) that persists under some disturbance) Developed Open Space - DS - (mown right-of- way, large-lot single-family housing units, parks, High Disturbance (dominated by widespread taxa golf courses, and vegetation planted in NO 0.09 not typical of a particular community) developed settings for recreation, erosion control, or aesthetic purposes) STREAMS Present? YES Impacts? YES ) 2 Stream ID Photo # Receiving Waters Drainage Area (mi Stream Type Hydrology USACE Flow Characteristics* OEPA Use Designation** Scenic River Length within Area the Project (ft.) QHEI/HHEI SCORE (ft.) Impacts Symmes Creek 1-10 Ohio River 194 Perennial RPW WWH No 50 ft. N/A 30 ft. mi² *Subject to verification by the USACE (TNW=Traditional Navigable Water, RPW=Relatively Permanent Water Perennial or Seasonal, NRPW=Non-RPW) **May be provisional based on habitat assessment forms No QHEI assessment was performed as Symmes Creek has been designated WWH by Ohio EPA (OAC-3745-1-16). Additional Information: How the stream(s) connect to Traditional Navigable Water (TNW): Symmes Creek → Ohio River WETLANDS Present? NO Impacts? NO DITCHES Present? NO Impacts? NO PONDS, LAKES, RESERVOIRS Present? NO Impacts? NO MUSSEL BEDS Present? YES Impacts? YES Species Name: Threeridge (Amblema plicata) Listing Status: Not listed Approximately 25 live individuals encountered. Species Name: Plain pocketbook (Lampsilis cardium) Listing Status: Not listed Approximately 15 live individuals encountered. Species Name: Fat mucket (Lampsilis radiata luteola) Listing Status: Not listed Approximately 15 live individuals encountered. Species Name: Pistolgrip (Tritogonia verrucosa) Listing Status: Not listed Approximately 50 live individuals encountered. Species Name: White heelsplitter (Lasmigona complanata) Listing Status: Not listed Approximately 5 live individuals encountered. Species Name: Wabash pigtoe (Fusconaia flava) Listing Status: Not listed Approximately 10 live individuals encountered. Species Name: Fragile papershell (Leptodea fragilis) Listing Status: Not listed Approximately 15 live individuals encountered. Species Name: Pink Heelsplitter (Potamilus alatus) Listing Status: Not listed Approximately 10 live individuals encountered. Species Name: Black sandshell (Ligumia recta) Listing Status: State Threatened 2 live individuals encountered (1 female and 1 male) encountered. The mussels were found in sandy substrates in approximately 3 inches of water. One individual was found approximately 150 feet downstream of the bridge, and one was observed approximately 20 feet upstream of the bridge. Both individuals were immediately returned to the stream at the location they were found. Additional Information: ODOT-OES biologists (Megan Michael, Matt Raymond, and Matt Perlik) conducted a qualitative presence/absence survey for mussels within Symmes Creek at the Gallia County, TR 752 bridge on 08/15/12. An area that extended 400 feet downstream to 100 feet upstream of the existing bridge was surveyed for mussels. Water clarity at the time of survey was egood, and water depths ranged from 1 inch to 3 feet within the wetted channel. Substrates within the channel were primarily gravel and cobble and sand. Much of the substrates were covered with large mats of attached algae. The entire area was found to have a dense mussel community, with some locations containing up to 20 mussels per m2. These mussels were found in riffle, pool, and run habitats in areas with and without large amount of attached algae. The mussel community was dominated by pistol grip mussels, followed by fat mucket and threeridge. Many young and juvenile mussels were observed within the stream, indicating a healthy reproducing population was present. The survey identified nine species of mussels within the proximity of the bridge. All mussels encountered during the survey were immediately returned to the stream substrates they were lifted from. No mussels were vouchered or removed from the survey area. The results of the survey are similar to those observed by Dr. Michael Hoggarth during an August 2004 survey, with the exception of two species. During Dr. Hoggarth’s survey, one subfossil of Quadrula quadrula was observed. The survey conducted 8/15/12 did not find any living or dead Q. quadrula. In fact, very few shells or fragments of deceased unionids were observed near the bridge during the survey. The 8/15/12 ODOT survey did, however, find two live individuals of the State Threatened black sandshell (Ligumia recta). This species was not identified by Dr. Hoggarth at the site in 2004. As proposed, this project will require in stream work to replace the existing bridge structure. Mussels located within construction limits of the project will likely be directly impacted, and those located within a close proximity downstream of the project area (400 feet) may be impacted as a result of increased sediment loads. FEDERALLY LISTED SPECIES Species Name: Indiana Bat (Myotis sodalis) Listing Status: Endangered Total amount of impact to forested areas as a result of the project (ac): <0.1 (mostly scrub shrub) The Indiana bat life cycle requires suitable summer roosting and brood rearing habitat (which includes living or standing dead trees or snags with exfoliating, peeling or loose bark, split trunks and/or branches, or cavities) and suitable hibernacula during the winter months (typically caves, or abandoned mines that provide cool, humid, stable conditions for hibernation). The project area is located within the southern management unit as defined by the Programmatic Biological Opinion (PBO) on the Ohio Department of Transportation's Statewide Transportation Program for the Federally-listed endangered Indiana bat (Myotis sodalis), dated January 26, 2007. A survey of the project study area did not identify any portals, openings, cracks, or crevices in rock outcrops that may be an entrance to a cave or mine that would be considered suitable winter hibernacula habitat for the bat. Additionally, no trees possessing potentially suitable roosting habitat for the Indiana bat will be removed for the project, and the project is located more than 10 miles from the nearest suspect hibernaculum or capture record. Since no suitable habitat for the species will be impacted by the proposed project, the project should have no effect on the species. Species Name: Fanshell Mussel (Cyprogenia stegaria) Listing Status: Endangered This mussel is found in medium to large rivers. It buries itself in sand or gravel in deep water of moderate current, with only the edge of its shell and its feeding siphons exposed. Within Gallia County this species is known from the Ohio River, and no records of this species have been identified in Symmes Creek. At this location, base flows for Symmes Creek are somewhat low for what is typically considered preferred habitat for this species (a larger river species), and the project area possesses habitat that would be considered marginally suitable for the species. The presence/absence mussel survey conducted at this location (see mussel discussion) did not identify any living or deceased individuals of this species within the project area. As a result, the project should have no effect on the species. Species Name: Pink Mucket Pearly Mussel (Lampsilis orbiculata) Listing Status: Endangered This mussel is found in mud and sand and in shallow riffles and shoals swept free of silt in major rivers and tributaries. This mussel buries itself in sand or gravel, with only the edge of its shell and its feeding siphons exposed. Within Gallia County this species is known from the Ohio River, and no records of this species have been identified in Symmes Creek.