DOCSLIB.ORG

Book Reviews

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Book Reviews NUMEN 53,4_f4-f6_511-526 10/30/06 10:28 AM Page 511 BOOK REVIEWS RICHARD BONNEY, Jih®d. From Quræ®n to Bin Laden. Foreword by Sheikh Dr. Zaki Badawi — London, New York et al.: Palgrave Macmillan 2004 (XXVI + 594 p.), ISBN 1–4039–3372–3. Without any doubt, jih®d is the most controversial term in modern Muslim debates regarding violence and propagation of faith in Islam. Westerners use to identify jih®d with “holy war” for the propagation of Islam while many Muslims argue against by saying it means a great effort on the path of God where military action is not a primary concern but it can also mean religious activities such as prayers and fasting. The book is a work of history which, in a solid attempt at putting all arguments forward, goes through the main lines of argumentation, from the Quræ®n up to the most recent debates in al-Qaeda circles. Though the book “makes no use of Arabic sources in Arabic, it is a work of synthesis, reliant on the detailed research of others; finally, perhaps worst of all, it unashamedly makes no excuse for using internet resources.” (XIII–XIV) Part one deals with the use of jih®d in the Quræ®n, the Sunnah, the first reports on conquests and their juridical justifications as well as on jih®d in early Sufism. It shows that the Quræ®n itself contains different mean- ings of jih®d. Therefore, different Muslim interpretations exist with regard to these texts. Consequently, the Sunnah interpretation goes along with this double understanding, of war on the one side and non military religious activity on the other. The same is true for biographies of Muhammad which sometimes underline his role as a political leader, sometimes, how- ever, see in him a spiritual rather than a political leader. And surprisingly enough, we find the same kind of ambiguity in Sufism. Part two studies Contextual Theorists and State Systems. As examples serve Ibn Taym¬yah and the defensive jih®d as a response to the Crusades and the Mongol Invasions. Then follows jih®d as State System in form of the Ottoman State, Safavid Persia and the Moghul Empire as well as Wahhabism and jih®d in the Colonial Period and Islamic Revivalism. It is © Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden (2006) NUMEN, Vol. 53 Also available online – www.brill.nl NUMEN 53,4_f4-f6_511-526 10/30/06 10:28 AM Page 512 512 Book Reviews obvious that the meaning of jih®d as military defense prevails in all these cases. Part three is dedicated to Sunni political Jih®dists of the 20th century such as Mawdudi, Hasan al-Bannaæ, Qutb, to Shiæa Depiction of jih®d and Martyrdom. Part four describes the most recent debates with regard to Palestinian jih®d from the times of the British Mandate up to present and Osama bin Laden’s global jih®d. It gives a clear description of present conflicts world-wide including Hamas and the Palestinian intif®dahs as well as bin Laden’s and his group’s interpretation of jih®d. The last two interpreta- tions are distortions in the author’s view. In conclusion, the author correctly states “that jih®d is a multi-faceted phenomenon both in theory and practice. There is no single, all-embracing concept that has been applied within the long, complex and sometimes even tortuous, course of Islamic history. Rather, there have been continual selections of texts and doctrines and the adoption of different practices, in accordance with cultural traditions and the needs and circumstances of the period. Few of the jih®ds which we have considered in their histori- cal context have conformed to a modern understanding of the theory: they were either preached and launched by individuals, not by the state, and subject to an excess of violence; or, alternatively, they were launched by states acting not in the defense of the faith but in their dynastic or national interests. Fewer still among the jih®ds of history would have passed the modern test of “just war”. The best case for jih®ds which would have passed such tests, those launched against colonial expansion by the Western powers, inevitably ended in failure because of the supe- rior military resources which the colonial power could deploy against them.” (399) The book is the best of its kind on the subject I have ever come across. It is extremely helpful in giving arguments against all kinds of historical justification of jih®d cases. On the other hand, it also argues effectively against classical stereotypes in the debate by stating that “there is no legitimate offensive jih®d; nor should Islam be regarded as a ‘religion of the sword’.” (400) It shows the “need for mainstream Islam to embrace positively the existence of pluralist societies in the contemporary world” (407) in defending jih®d as a struggle “for justice and the betterment of.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Unveiling the Truth-Proof-With Annex.Indd
    AT HOME IN EUROPE Unveiling the Truth Why 32 Muslim Women Wear the Full-face Veil in France Unveiling the Truth Why 32 Muslim Women Wear the Full-face Veil in France At Home in Europe Project Copyright © 2011 Open Society Foundations. All rights reserved, including the right to reproduce this report or portions thereof in any form. Open Society Foundations 400 West 59th Street New York, NY 10019 USA www.soros.org Október 6 Street 12 H–1051 Budapest, Hungary 100 Cambridge Grove W6 0LE London, United Kingdom At Home in Europe Project Open Society Foundations Website www.soros.org/initiatives/home Cover design by Dennis Ahlgrim l Ahlgrim Design Group Cover photograph by Naima Bouteldja Layout by Judit Kovács l Createch Ltd. l Hungary Contents Foreword 5 Acknowledgements 7 Definitions 9 1. Key Findings 11 2. Introduction 19 3. Methodology 23 4. French Political Content and History of Legislation on the Full-face Veil 27 5. Wearing the Full-face Veil 35 6. Influences and/or Coercion 47 7. How the Women Respond to Insults and Abuse 65 8. The Question of Identity 71 9. Wearing the Full-face Veil Once the Law Is Implemented 73 10. Conclusion 75 Annex 77 3 Foreword Unveiling the Truth: Why 32 Women Wear the Full-face Veil in France examines an issue causing considerable debate and controversy throughout Europe: the relationship between religion and European identity or, more succinctly, Islam’s compatibility with European values. The report offers the views of 32 women across France who wear the full-face veil, their reasons for doing so, and their experiences in public before and after the debate over banning the veil.
    [Show full text]
  • The Road Ahead
    The Road Ahead A Christian–Muslim Dialogue A record of the seminar ‘Building Bridges’ held at Lambeth Palace, 17–18 January 2002 Edited by Michael Ipgrave Church House Publishing Church House, Great Smith Street, London SW1P 3NZ ISBN 0 7151 5002 2 GS Misc 672 Published 2002 by Church House Publishing Compilation Copyright © The Archbishops’ Council 2002 All papers and responses are Copyright © individual authors 2002 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or stored or transmitted by any means or in any form, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission which should be sought from the Copyright and Contracts Administrator, The Archbishops’ Council, Church House, Great Smith Street, London SW1P 3NZ. (Tel: 020 7898 1557; Fax: 020 7898 1449; [email protected]). Cover design by Church House Publishing Typeset in Stone Serif 10pt Printed by The Cromwell Press, Trowbridge, Wiltshire Contents Participants in the Christian–Muslim seminar at Lambeth Palace 17–18 January 2002 v Introducing the seminar vii The Most Revd and Rt Hon. Dr George Carey, Archbishop of Canterbury ix His Royal Highness Prince El Hassan bin Talal of Jordan xi The Rt Hon. Tony Blair, The Prime Minister xiv Editorial preface Michael Ipgrave xvii Acknowledgements xviii Building bridges between Christians and Muslims 1 Chapter 1 Christians and Muslims face to face 4 Chapter 2 Learning from history 25 Chapter 3 Communities of faith 48 Chapter 4 Faith and
    [Show full text]
  • Islamic Statements Against the Terrorism of 9/11
    Islamic Statements Against the Terrorism of 9/11 Mustafa Mashhur, General Guide, Muslim Brotherhood, Egypt; Qazi Hussain Ahmed, Ameer, Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan, Pakistan; Muti Rahman Nizami, Ameer, Jamaat- e-Islami Bangladesh, Bangladesh; Shaykh Ahmad Yassin, Founder, Islamic Resistance Movement (Hamas), Palestine; Rashid Ghannoushi, President, Nahda Renaissance Movement, Tunisia; Fazil Nour, President, PAS - Parti Islam SeMalaysia, Malaysia; and 40 other Muslim scholars and politicians: “The undersigned, leaders of Islamic movements, are horrified by the events of Tuesday 11 September 2001 in the United States which resulted in massive killing, destruction and attack on innocent lives. We express our deepest sympathies and sorrow. We condemn, in the strongest terms, the incidents, which are against all human and Islamic norms. This is grounded in the Noble Laws of Islam which forbid all forms of attacks on innocents. God Almighty says in the Holy Qur'an: 'No bearer of burdens can bear the burden of another' (Surah al-Isra 17:15).” MSANews, September 14, 2001, http://msanews.mynet.net/MSANEWS/200109/20010917.15.html; Arabic original in al-Quds al-Arabi (London), September 14, 2001, p. 2, http://www.alquds.co.uk/Alquds/2001/09Sep/14%20Sep%20Fri/Quds02.pdf Shaykh Yusuf Qaradawi, Qatar; Tariq Bishri, Egypt; Muhammad S. Awwa, Egypt; Fahmi Huwaydi, Egypt; Haytham Khayyat, Syria; Shaykh Taha Jabir al-Alwani, U.S.: “All Muslims ought to be united against all those who terrorize the innocents, and those who permit the killing of non-combatants without a justifiable reason. Islam has declared the spilling of blood and the destruction of property as absolute prohibitions until the Day of Judgment.
    [Show full text]
  • Older People Strategy
    86 The search for common ground Muslims, non-Muslims and the UK media A report commissioned by the Mayor of London 87 88 The search for common ground Muslims, non-Muslims and the UK media 89 Copyright Greater London Authority November 2007 Published by Greater London Authority City Hall The Queen’s Walk More London London SE1 2AA Enquiries 020 7983 4100 Minicom 020 7983 4458 www.london.gov.uk ISBN: 978 1 84781 054 0 The views expressed in this report are not necessarily those of the Mayor of London or the Greater London Authority. While every effort is made to ensure that the information contained in this report is correct, no responsibility for errors or omissions can be accepted. Whilst the Greater London Authority has taken all reasonable steps to avoid the infringement of third party copyright and to seek necessary consent where applicable, the Greater London Authority would like to apologise in advance for any unintentional and/or accidental infringements that may occur. Affected parties are requested to contact the Greater London Authority as soon as possible upon suspicion of infringement in order that remedial steps can be put in place. The search for common ground Muslims, non-Muslims and the UK media v 90 Contents List of tables and boxes vii Acknowledgements ix Foreword by Ken Livingstone, the Mayor of London xi Executive summary xiii Introduction 1 Common ground? – issues, concerns and opinions 1 Studies and stories 2 A normal week? – threats and crises in Britain and the world 17 3 ‘Britishness is being destroyed’ – worries
    [Show full text]
  • Muslim Education and Interfaith Understanding: the Case of the Muslim College in the United Kingdom
    Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 115 3rd International Conferences on Education in Muslim Society (ICEMS 2017) Muslim Education and Interfaith Understanding: The Case of the Muslim College in the United Kingdom Suwitoa, Yusuf Rahmana, Izza Rohmanb a Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University Jakarta, Jl. Ir. H. Djuanda 95, Ciputat, Indonesia bUniversitas Muhammadiyah Prof. Dr. Hamka, Jl. Limau 2, Kebayoran Baru, Jakarta Selatan, Indonesia Corresponding e-mail: [email protected] Abstract In a multicultural society, Islamic education that is conscious of the need for creating social harmony across faiths and denominations has more to offer than confessional education in Islamic seminaries and secular universities’ critically approached by Islamic studies. Muslim higher educations in the United Kingdom have clearly reflected their awareness of the importance of interfaith and intrafaith understanding in many aspects, and thereby increase their capability to enhance the career prospects of their students while giving them a sense of piety and criticality at the same time. This research challenges some assumptions that Muslim education in a secular country is more driven by Muslims’ responses to the secular, modern world; and that Muslim education in a non-Muslim majority country is shaped more by majority-minority dynamics; and that Muslim education in the West is oriented more toward missionary objectives. On the other hand, this research strengthens the notion that Muslim education in the modern world is guided more by the need to establish relevance in education. This study, which combines both library and field research methods, finds that higher education institutions run by Muslims in the United Kingdom have consciously offered their students with curriculum, resources, and educational environment that are friendly to diversity of faiths and diversity within Islam in an attempt to make their skills and knowledge relevant to multicultural British society.
    [Show full text]
  • Association of Muslim Social Scientists (UK) Buy the Book Or Download the Book: Index.Html Isbn 0-86355-569-1 Price: £5.00
    ASSOCIATIONASSOCIATION OF OF MUSLIM MUSLIM SOCIALSOCIAL SCIENTISTS SCIENTISTS (UK) (UK) NEWSLETTER issue no.7 • 2006 Islam in Higher Education Conference Highlights Issue of Teaching Islam in Higher Education Long Before Government Orders a Report on the Subject Established orientalist notions of what consti- Significantly, this jointly organised tutes Islamic scholarship have largely remained Conference by AMSS and its part- ners was held more than a year unchallenged. The emergence of neo-orientalism before the government and MP Bill and phenomenological approaches are two ways Rammell’s, Minister of Education, call for a review of the teaching of in which exciting ideas are being adapted, and university Islamic courses. The government has commissioned a in some cases, challenged. Abdul-Rehman Malik report on this issue to ensure that religious oriented courses are not organised by amss (uk), the centre restricted to narrow interpreta- for the study of islam and chris- tions. Although the conference tian-muslim relations (birming- sought to highlight and examine ham university) and the higher education academy subject centre the complexities of the teaching of for philosophical and religious Islam and other related issues, invi- studies, 29-30 january 2005, at the tations to the civil service, govern- university of birmingham. ment departments and key person- nel to attend the conference met Since 11 September 2001 there has with no response. Subsequent trag- been a remarkable growth in the ic events triggered interest in the study of Islam in Higher Education. area! It is only hoped that the Whereas a decade earlier, many uni- inquiry does not start from zero versities were eager to close down but builds upon the outcome of or at best amalgamate Islamic this Conference.
    [Show full text]
  • Developing a Modern Zakat Management Model Digital Technology 4.0 Version
    DOI: 10.51377/azjaf.vol2no1.47 DEVELOPING A MODERN ZAKAT MANAGEMENT MODEL DIGITAL TECHNOLOGY 4.0 VERSION PATRIA YUNITA Faculty of Economics and Business, University of Indonesia, UI Depok Campus Jawa Barat, 16424, Indonesia. E-mail: [email protected] A PEER-REVIEWED ARTICLE (RECEIVED – 14 JUN 2020: REVISED – 26 AUGUST 2020: ACCEPTED – 1 OCTOBER 2020) ABSTRACT This study aims to develop a modern zakat management model by analyzing the zakat payment method using marketable securities and their impact on zakat fund fluctuations managed by a modern amil zakat institution in Indonesia. Zakat institutions have never implemented the zakat payment transactions like this in other Islamic countries such as Malaysia, Pakistan, and Middle Eastern countries. The study‘s focus is on The National Zakat Board of Indonesia as a modern amil zakat institution that has made this transaction to accommodate muzakki investor‘s goodwill to pay zakat obligation in the form of shares that are still traded. According to fiqh, the payment of zakat using marketable securities in the form of traded shares is still in debate. According to fiqh scholars, Imam Hanafi does not allow the zakat fund investment. While Imam Maliki, Imam Syafie, and Imam Hambali, including Yusuf Al-Qardhawi, allow some arguments. From a financial analysis point of views, to reduce the risk of decreasing zakat funds due to stock price volatility, a linkage between zakat funds in the form of shares traded with general Islamic insurance is needed, which in this case, the researcher refer to as zakat linked takaful under wakalah-waqf contract. This research used literature and empirical study to compare zakat management practices in various Muslim countries, to develop a modern zakat management model collaborated with digital Islamic financial institutions in the banking and non-banking sectors.
    [Show full text]
  • The Myth of the 'Islamic' Headscarf
    The Myth of the ‘Islamic’ headscarf Copyright © Omar Hussein Ibrahim and FELD Productions 2008, 2010 and 2019 ISBN: 978-0-244-51768-7 Dedicated to the memory of Sir Zaki Badawi, former senior imam at the Central London Mosque, Regent's Park and dean of the Muslim College. Preface A book containing the fullest coverage as to why Islam does not oblige Muslim women to cover their hair. Compiled by Omar Hussein Ibrahim, based in London, using the best academic material and press commentary available today. Contents Page Chapter 1 Treat your women well and be kind to them: Prophet Mohammad .................................................. 1 Muslim women advised to abandon hijab to avoid attack ................................................................. 2 Will dropping the hijab make women safer? ..................................................................................... 3 The headscarf martyr ....................................................................................................................... 4 A target for hate ............................................................................................................................... 6 The Freedom to Go Topless, by Amir Taheri ......................................................................................... 8 This is not Islam, by Amir Taheri .......................................................................................................... 10 Will Chirac fight fascism? by Amir Taheri ............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • A Critical Analysis of Muhammad Abduh's Notion of Revelation Throu
    religions Article Revelation in the Muslim, Christian, and Jewish Traditions: A Critical Analysis of Muhammad Abduh’s Notion of Revelation through the Lens of Joseph Ratzinger and Benedict De Spinoza Mohammad Syifa Amin Widigdo 1,* and Abd Razak Bin Zakaria 2 1 Program Studi Ekonomi Syariah, Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta, Yogyakarta 55000, Indonesia 2 Department of Educational Foundations and Humanitie, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur 50630, Malaysia; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: This research investigated one of the foundational notions of religion, i.e., revelation, as presented by Muhammad Abduh (d. 1905) in Risalat¯ al-Tawh. ¯ıd and Risalat¯ al-Warid¯ at¯ , through a comparison with the understanding of revelation in the Catholic tradition, as elucidated by Pope Ratzinger (b. 1927), and in Judaism, as presented by the Jewish scholar B. D. Spinoza (d. 1677). This research closely considered Abduh’s works to reveal whether the notion of revelation in the Islamic tradition is different from or analogous to its counterparts in Catholicism and Judaism. Although these authors’ religious backgrounds are diverse, their understandings of revelation are analogous in the sense that revelation is understood as beyond the linguistic realm. However, they each have different religious and intellectual stances regarding the valid interpretation and knowledge of Citation: Widigdo, Mohammad revelation; where Ratzinger relies on the Church’s authority, Spinoza believes in the efficacy of holy Syifa Amin, and Abd Razak Bin scripture, and Abduh has more confidence in the use of reason in understanding revelation. By Zakaria. 2021. Revelation in the delineating the commonalities and differences of the ideas of these three scholars from different Muslim, Christian, and Jewish religious backgrounds, a more open and fruitful interreligious conversation can be further cultivated.
    [Show full text]
  • Islam and Muslims in Southeast Asia, a Bibliography of English-Language
    ISlAM AND MUSLIMS IN SOUTHEAST ASIA A BIBLIOGRAPHY OF ENGLISH-LANGUAGE PUBLICATIONS 1945-1993 Compiled by Patricia Horvatich Southeast Asia Paper No. 38 Center for Southeast Asian Studies &'hool of Hawaiian, Asian and Pacific Studies University of Hawai'i at Manoa October 1993 PREFACE This bibliography on Islam and Muslims in Southeast Asia has long been in the making. I began compiling references on this subject six years ago when preparing for my comprehensive examinations as a graduate student of anthropology at Stanford University. Work on this bibliography continued as I conducted research on Islam among the Sama people of the Philippines. After completing my dissertation, I was hired by the Center for Southeast Asian Studies at the University of Hawai'i to teach courses on Islam in Southeast Asia. My research on Islam thus progressed as I prepared lectures and searched for relevant student readings. When Florence Lamoureux, the program coordinator of the Center for Southeast Asian Studies, suggested that I publish this bibliography in the Center's series, I made a final attempt to ensure that this work was as complete as possible. I began a systematic search for materials available at the Hamilton Library's Asian Collection at the University of Hawai'i. This search involved use of modern technology in the form of the UHCARL system and CD Rom and also the more familiar, if laborious, method of combing through journals, edited volumes, and bibliographies for pertinent references. As a result of these endeavors, this bibliography assumes its present and, for now, final form. In preparing this bibliography for publication, my priority has been to keep its scope as broad and interdisciplinary as possible by including topics that pertain to history, anthropology, sociology, art, music, literature; education, economics, politics, and law.
    [Show full text]
  • Intellectuals in the Modern Islamic World
    INTELLECTUALS IN THE MODERN ISLAMIC WORLD This book reconsiders the typology and history of intellectuals in the Islamic world in the modern and contemporary periods from the late nineteenth century to the present day. Intellectuals in the Modern Islamic World distinguishes itself from other major studies on modern thought in Islam by examining this topic beyond the context of the Arabic world. The first section of this book concentrates on a journal, al-Manar, published between 1898 and 1935, and read by a wide range of audiences throughout the Islamic world, which inspired the imagination and arguments of local intellectuals in the first half of the twentieth century. The second part concentrates on the formation, transmission, and transformation of learning and authority, from the Middle East to Central and South Asia, through the twentieth century. Providing a rich variety of case studies, by international authors of the most varied disciplinary scope, Intellectuals in the Modern Islamic World meets the highest academic requirements in a spirit of comparative vision and openness to the dynamism of contemporary societies of the Islamic world. As such, this book is essential reading for those with research interests in Islam and intellectual thought. Stéphane A. Dudoignon is a research fellow at the National Center for Scientific Research (Paris). Komatsu Hisao is a professor at the Graduate School of Humanities and Sociology, The University of Tokyo. Kosugi Yasushi is a professor at the Graduate School of Asian and African Area Studies, Kyoto University. NEW HORIZONS IN ISLAMIC STUDIES Series editor: Professor Sato Tsugitaka The series New Horizons in Islamic Studies presents the fruitful results of Islamic Area Studies Project conducted in Japan during the years 1997–2001.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of the Church in Developing the Law: an Islamic Response
    223 RELIGION, THE LAW, AND MEDICAL ETHICS J Med Ethics: first published as 10.1136/jme.28.4.223 on 1 August 2002. Downloaded from The role of the church in developing the law: an Islamic response Z Badawi ............................................................................................................................. J Med Ethics 2002;28:223 the country and they are both now working at Leiden Univer- The concept of Hisba in Muslim law has been used by sity. A plethora of similar interventions forced the government members of certain Islamic groups to impose, through the to restrict the right to intervene to those immediately affected. courts, limitations on freedom of expression. In so doing This proved to be ineffective since anyone can claim that the they sought to circumvent the right of parliament to violation of Islam—as he or she understands—is of immediate legislate on matters of personal freedom. This device is concern to them, so the authorities ordered that no such now restricted by the Egyptian authorities. intervention was to be entertained without the approval of the public prosecutor. Happily, the Islamic legal system is not based on precedents and so the Court of Appeal’s decision in the case of Professor Abu Zeid will not bind the courts, he separation of church and state is the hallmark of the because cases can be argued from principal sources. modern secular system of government. Nevertheless the Nevertheless, a case can be made on the basis of the previous Tlaw has to take into consideration prevailing opinion judgment and a defence lawyer would have to show that it among the population.
    [Show full text]