WICKLOW COUNTY COUNCIL

Transcript of the County Council Meeting Held on 2 March 2015 In the County Council Chamber, Wicklow

Text streamed live to the web on www.seewritenow.ie Telephone ……………………………. (0404) 64355 Fax ……………….…………………... (0404) 64354 Email …………………………………. [email protected] Website ……………………………….. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 1

1 Disclaimer: The following is the transcript of the realtime text transcribed during the meeting. 2 The realtime text service and subsequent transcript are for the purposes of accessibility to the 3 public meetings of the Wicklow County Council, and are not intended or portrayed as an official 4 verbatim note or minutes of the meetings. And while we take care to ensure the service is as 5 accurate as is possible, some errors may and do occur. 6 7 Wicklow County Council Meeting, 2nd of March 2015: 8 9 CATHAOIRLEACH: Fáilte anseo. I welcome you all in Irish because from the 1st to the 17th 10 of March of course is Seachtain in a Gaeilge, it's Irish week. I know we have a great 11 announcement that Colaiste Rathin have the go ahead for planning for a modern state-of-the-art 12 school, there are councillors around the chamber like Cllr Thornhill and Oliver O'Brien who 13 actively promote Irish language and culture and they are both to be commended for that. So I 14 think it's fitting with Cllr Thornhill's encouragement just to start with a few words As Gaeilge. 15 Cllr THORNHILL: I think it's great to have this opportunity and to have Cathaoirleach leabairt 16 as Gaeilge, I think important for us as public representatives to, we have a great opportunity to 17 show the people in our areas that we are interested in our native culture, and as the Cathaoirleach 18 mentioned, after 20 years Colaiste Rathin have been given the go ahead to look for planning 19 permission to build a state-of-the-art up to date secondary school and it should do great for the 20 future of Irish culture in the Wicklow area, and especially in Bray, the area which I'm in, we 21 have three national schools. 22 23 From here onwards, if we all do our little bit to promote the language it's upwards and onwards. 24 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay we're going to take votes of sympathy. We have recently the sad 25 passing of Una Timmins, Billy and Edward's sister, of course Una worked for their father, the 26 late Godfrey for a number of years, I think she worked for Billy as well, there was a huge crowd 27 at the funeral which was a testament to how well respected Una was held in both the Baltinglass 28 community and further afield in Wicklow and further. So my deepest sympathy to the Timmins 29 family on the loss of Una. 30 31 We have other votes, Cllr Snell? 32 Cllr SNELL: Thanks Cathaoirleach, I'd like to pass a vote of sympathy to the family of the late 33 Anthony Doyle. Anthony passed away last week there, he worked for Wicklow County Council, 34 he was a rent collector in here for many, many years. He also was a fieldworker in compiling

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 2

1 the election register and keeping it up to date. He will be sadly missed, not only by his family, 2 but by his many, many friends. 3 4 Anthony led an extraordinary life, he dedicated it to community, he was instrumental in the 5 setting up of the Rathnew Development Association for many, many years. But I think his real 6 passion was in -- not just in drama, he won an All-Ireland for St. Brigid's drama group in 7 Rathnew back in the 1950s, he was involved in Wicklow drama group, involved in Rathnew, the 8 village players. Myth productions here in the town, and his other great passion in life was the 9 GAA. 10 11 He was president of Rathnew GAA club at the time of his passing. He won, he was a member of 12 the last hurling championship, which was the senior championship won for Rathnew in hurling 13 in 1950. 20 years later at the end of his playing career he won a senior football championship in 14 1970. 15 16 But the true mark of the man's passion for GAA was that he refereed up to the age of 75, which 17 is a remarkable feat. His other passion was the procession, the Corpus Christi procession, 18 Anthony organised it many many years, I had the pleasure of showing him some tapes that came 19 into my possession recently of a procession in 1960, I showed him some of the footage from it, 20 himself and a priest who was 93, both of them sat down and reminisced over many, many years. 21 22 The Corpus Christi procession is a true indictment to the community and people like Anthony 23 Doyle who kept it going, last year was its 100th year in existence. I'd like to extend my 24 condolences to Anthony's family, his wife Betty, his sons, daughters, grandchildren, some of 25 who are members of this local authority and working here still. So to Anthony, he is in our 26 thoughts and prayers. Thanks Cathaoirleach. 27 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thanks councillor, other votes of sympathy Cllr Blake? 28 Cllr BLAKE: I too would like to sympathise with the Doyle family, we all knew Anthony for 29 many years. 30 31 But you said at the outset regards Una Timmins, she was well known, among the staff of the 32 County Council, from my own point of view I've known her quite a number of years, our dearest 33 sympathy to her mother Nora, to Billy, and Edward, and to all her brothers and sisters as well. 34

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 3

1 It's a big loss to her family and certainly a very unexpected death. We all knew she had her 2 difficulties with health over the last few years, but nevertheless when it does come, it came as a 3 major shock and surprise to everybody. The staff in here would have known the voice of Una 4 rather than the face of Una because she certainly, was in contact with a lot of staff and people 5 made reference to me who were at the funeral as well, the first time a lot of them had seen Una, 6 but nevertheless talk to her over the phone on numerous occasions over the years while she 7 worked for Billy and her late father as well. So deepest sympathy to the Timmins family on the 8 death of a very untimely death, at a young age of Una. 9 10 I'd also like to take the opportunity of Jim Tallon in Arklow, who was a very well known 11 election candidate, not alone here in Wicklow but all over Ireland as well. Reasonably young 12 age as well, he was buried this morning. So the family are well known throughout County 13 Wicklow in education and farming activities, our deepest sympathy. 14 Cllr McDONALD: Just like Cllr Blake I want to offer my condolences to the Tallon family, he 15 was from the Republic of Glasnos in Arklow, a colourful character, fully committed to his 16 beliefs, very generous with his time. I don't think we have heard the last of him, I think 17 everybody in the town and county have a story to tell about Jim and somebody, maybe some 18 day, will put pen to paper, but I want to extend my condolences to his family and his friends in 19 Arklow. 20 Cllr BRADY: Just a vote of sympathy to the O'Sullivan family in Bray for the death of Teddy 21 O'Sullivan, a former Lord Mayor of Bray, he was made Lord Mayor through a difficult format, it 22 was a community initiative at that stage, I think it was 1985, he became the Lord Mayor of Bray. 23 But he would have done enormous work in the Ballywaltrim area of Bray, a founder member of 24 the Ballywaltrim Community Council. Unfortunately Eddie passed away in the last week or so, 25 just condolences to all his family. 26 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you. Cllr O'Neill? 27 Cllr O'NEILL: Again I'd like to offer -- I'm not with it today, sorry about that -- my sympathies 28 to the Timmins family, especially Billy and Edward, on the death of Una. I've known Una for a 29 long time, I met her once or twice, but I know she didn't care about your religion or your politics, 30 she was a great help over the years, and I know even the day her last journey to the hospital she 31 was making inquiries about constituents and their needs or whatever, so she was a great woman. 32 And I especially extend sympathy to her brother, I know she will be sorely missed by the whole 33 of west Wicklow. 34 Cllr WALSH: I'd like to extend sympathies to the family of Ann Nolan, Ann was 48 years of

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 4

1 age, her funeral took place in Greystones this morning, I first got to know Ann through her sons 2 Keith and James, when they started to play hurling, she was a great supporter, her car was 3 always available to ferry young players to matches, she was also a member of the, long serving 4 member of the Cumman in Greystones, her son was the secretary of that Cumman. I'd like to 5 extend sympathies to her family. 6 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thanks. Cllr Vance? 7 Cllr VANCE: Thank you Chairman, I'd obviously like to be associated with the vote of 8 sympathy to the Timmins family on the death of Una on behalf of the Fianna Fail group here, 9 very, very sad occasion for the Timmins family. 10 11 I'd also like to be associated with the vote of sympathy in regard to Eddie O'Sullivan, who was a 12 great contributor in the Boghall area, the community up there in Bray, he had a huge funeral. 13 And also to Cyril Dunne on the death of his wife Sheila, who was a long time in business in 14 Bray, a very popular man. 15 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you councillor. Cllr Thornhill? 16 Cllr THORNHILL: I would like to, like the other councillors, express my sympathy to the 17 family of Eddie O'Sullivan. Eddie I would have known over the years and as a community 18 guard I really appreciated his presence on the main street, very colourful character and he had 19 been Lord Mayor of Bray at one stage and he was also involved with the BLB, and I must say 20 one individual that would really put you in good humour. 21 Cllr RUTTLE: As I said I'd like to be associated as well with the vote of sympathy for the 22 passing of Una. I first came to know her in 1980 and always found her a dedicated kind 23 individual who dealt with everybody fairly and in a kind manner, it was a great shock to the 24 family and my sympathy, all our sympathies are with the family at this time of loss. 25 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you councillor. Thank you members. Just in relation to Anthony 26 Doyle, my own father passed away suddenly 20 years ago this month at a Rathnew GAA dinner 27 dance. Anthony was the Chairman, and was given the unenviable task of heading to Kilmac to 28 inform my mother, but handled it so well, that my mother has become a Rathnew GAA closet 29 supporter, it's not something I care to admit to but... 30 Cllr SNELL: I'll bring in a jersey next week! 31 CATHAOIRLEACH: But I was very saddened to hear of Anthony's passing, I'll let in the 32 manager. 33 COUNTY MANAGER: Chairman, just to say on behalf of all of the staff of the Council and my 34 own behalf I'd like to convey my sympathies to Edward Timmins and all the family on the

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 5

1 untimely and sad passing of Una, just to convey our sympathy on that and indeed to be 2 associated with the other votes of sympathy, perhaps also to convey our sympathy to the 3 Williams family, from Redcross on the death of Robert Williams last week. The Williams 4 family had been involved in the tourist committee and other development issues throughout the 5 county. 6 CATHAOIRLEACH: We'll stand for a moment. 7 8 (Minute's silence) 9 10 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay Cllr Nolan? 11 Cllr NOLAN: Just very briefly Cathaoirleach. I'd like to send sincere congratulations to 12 Newtown United FC, they had a great victory last weekend in the Leinster Senior Cup, they beat 13 Shelbourne in Tolka Park, it was a huge historic day in the history of Newtown United and 14 Wicklow, it's had many great victories over here, this trumped them all, in May they are going to 15 play Bohemians in the next round, so fingers crossed they'll repeat that, they've had some year to 16 support them over the last 12 months this was another addition to that. 17 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thanks congratulations, it was a fantastic achievement. 18 19 Okay I have a request for suspension of standing orders, Cllr McDonald I'll let you in first. 20 Cllr McDONALD: Thank you. I just want to call for suspension of standing orders just to 21 express my concern over the spending of public money on sending the retiring CEO on a trip to 22 America. I know it's been organised, but I just think that the money could be better spent and I 23 know the protocol is that these trips are used to highlight Wicklow, to highlight the county of 24 Wicklow to bring back money, jobs, investment, but I just don't think at this stage with less than 25 a month to the CEO retiring, that this particular trip will be of any benefit to County Wicklow. I 26 have a proposal that I gave to you, I wanted to put on the table, for consideration. I know we're 27 talking about this later on in the agenda if you want to... 28 CATHAOIRLEACH: Do you want to read it out? 29 Cllr McDONALD: "As the CEO Mr Eddie Sheehy has announced his retirement, I am calling 30 on him to do the right thing and cancel his trip to America for the St. Patrick's Day festival as 31 this trip will be no benefit to County Wicklow as his retirement will be a week after he returns. 32 As a gesture of goodwill he should redirect the money to a homeless charity in Wicklow." 33 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay, it's up to the members, do I have a seconder for that? Cllr Brady. 34 It's up to the members who can set time, quarter to five for this if the members wish?

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 6

1 Cllr BRADY: Agreed. 2 Cllr VANCE: I wouldn't agree with that. I don't think it's appropriate for suspension of standing 3 orders. Standing orders are supposed to be an emergency situation, this is not an emergency 4 situation as far as I'm concerned. 5 Cllr McDONALD: With less than a month to go it is a bit of an emergency. 6 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay take a roll call on it. This is for suspension of standing orders to 7 discuss the matter, okay? 8 9 (Vote taken) 10 11 MS GALLAGHER: 13 for, 16 against and 3 not present. Falls. 12 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay, we did have discussions on this late last year, the 3rd of November 13 councillors, it was agreed by the Protocol Committee, which is made up of all the parties. So 14 that falls. Okay. Cllr Brady? 15 Cllr BRADY: Thanks Cathaoirleach, I'd also like to request a suspension of standing orders and 16 also in relation to the announcement by Eddie Sheehy, the County Manager or CEO, in his 17 announcement that he is going to retire, and also in relation to his disgraceful radio interview 18 that he gave on East Coast Radio last week, and some very, very hurtful comments and untrue 19 comments that he made during the course of that radio interview in relation to the deaths of two 20 Bray fire fighters that lost their lives here in this county under Eddie Sheehy's watch, as County 21 Manager. 22 23 I had previously asked Eddie Sheehy to apologise for those. 24 CATHAOIRLEACH: Are you requesting a suspension? 25 Cllr BRADY: I'm requested a suspension of standing orders to discuss Eddie Sheehy's 26 retirement. I see on item number 13 it's just down as, to note the retirement of Mr Eddie Sheehy 27 as chief executive, I think we need a full discussion on this issue, because I firmly believe there 28 needs to be an investigation into Eddie Sheehy's 14 years at the helm of this county. I also 29 believe he needs to apologise, and I also think he needs to retract those very, very hurtful and 30 untrue comments he made during the course of that radio interview last week, and certainly this 31 Council endorsed the verdict... 32 CATHAOIRLEACH: Look, we're not having a discussion now. 33 Cllr BRADY: Mr Sheehy seems to disregard... 34 CATHAOIRLEACH: Have I a seconder? Is that agreed?

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 7

1 Cllr VANCE: Chairman could I suggest that we take -- there's agreement that we can get 2 through the agenda fairly quickly, that's up to all the members here, we can take it in under 13. 3 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay we'll take it under 13 then. 4 Cllr BRADY: As long as we get to item 13. 5 Cllr VANCE: That's up to the members. 6 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay. We'll crack on then okay. To confirm and sign... 7 Cllr FORTUNE: Sorry chair. 8 CATHAOIRLEACH: Cllr Fortune. Apologies. 9 Cllr FORTUNE: I want to raise an item on point of order. Yesterday we got a mail at 2.29 10 basically informing us about a cost, or fine of 7,000 that was imposed on the Council. I just 11 thought it was most unusual to receive such correspondence on a Sunday afternoon, and why 12 that happened. 13 14 I can recall the background to this because I was unfortunately involved around AGM time, 15 when I was basically shafted as I said at the time and talked about various things. It would 16 appear that there is questions that need to be explained about what we got yesterday, a bit of 17 detail about it, background to it, why certain paragraphs are written the way they're written 18 because there was a question asked here in the chamber only a short couple of months ago on 19 that matter, and we were basically told there was no issue, no problem. And now it transpires 20 that there is a problem, and also it necessitated a mail coming out on Sunday the 1st of March at 21 2.29. That's quite dramatic I think in anyone's language. So I would hope that we, on a point of 22 order that we can get an explanation to that. 23 CATHAOIRLEACH: I think that's fair. I'll set aside at quarter to five and we'll get the director 24 of roads to clarify exactly what the issue is, okay. Is that agreed? Quarter to five councillor, all 25 right? 26 27 Okay we'll move on. Item 1. Confirm and sign minutes of Ordinary Meeting of the 12th of 28 January. Proposed? Cllr Casey. Seconded Cllr Nolan. Is that agreed? 29 30 Item 2, confirm and sign minutes of Ordinary Meeting of Monday 2nd of February. Proposed 31 Cllr Blake, seconded Cllr Bourke. Agreed? 32 33 Item 3 ... 34 Cllr BRADY: Sorry Cathaoirleach?

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 8

1 CATHAOIRLEACH: Sorry Cllr O'Brien. 2 Cllr O'BRIEN: Just under matters arising, since the last council meeting I received a further 3 e-mail, obviously since the way I clarified my position regarding staff was not acceptable and it 4 must have caused some offence, particularly when I mentioned pushing in filing cabinets and 5 things like that and producing nothing. I was not having a go at the ordinary staff, I was in no 6 way having a go at the ordinary staff, I am well aware as was recorded in the Bray People, the 7 few days after, that I had said that I know how hard the staff work. And that I said it was 8 administratively top heavy, just to clarify my position a bit more. I have a friend works high up 9 in the bank in America, he says I do very little, and he says the guy above me does even less, he 10 said it's the girls in the office that do all the work around here, so I'm not having any go at the 11 ordinary staff members here. What I was having a go about was, when I said they aren't 12 producing nothing, means you are producing something, two negatives make a positive. They 13 are obviously producing something. But I felt there was over -- I felt there was too much 14 administration, I don't feel that any housing officer or any waiting list would suffer if we built 15 houses. I'm worried the reflection of the Council, the administrative staff is so big, I use that as 16 criteria whether we are succeeding or failing, the bigger the admin staff the more you're failing 17 doing the ordinary work, that's my view. I know that I said it, I apologised if I did cause offence, 18 I apologise for that, but as well as that, I do feel that you are on a show like that you don't get 19 much time, I wasn't on the panel, I was out in the audience, I was not allowed to express my 20 opinion, people say things I wasn't happy, you can't come back in and say what I meant was -- 21 Mr Timmins had a go at me about administration, he said Sinn Fein is the party with more 22 administrators, of course everybody laughed, but I was pointing out when you start a project like 23 we were starting the project of this country maybe 70 years ago you need a lot of administrators, 24 but 70 years later they are still there there's something seriously wrong. 25 26 There are uses -- the point I'm making is there are useful jobs in the country and they are useless 27 jobs that's the main point I'm making, it's very sad that the higher up you go the less do you and 28 more you get paid. We need to correct that in this country that's all I'm effectively saying, I have 29 the highest respect. I don't know how they do the work, the work they have to do. They are -- 30 the work the ordinary girls in the office do, they are given that work. I couldn't do the work they 31 do. I would go mad if I was standing in an office five days, I'd be gone mad. So apologies from 32 me if there was any offence caused. Susan you were the one that sent me the e-mail, I apologise, 33 I was no way having a go at you or anybody else on the staff. 34 CATHAOIRLEACH: Councillor, I know you well enough to know you didn't intend offence.

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 9

1 We'll keep cracking on. 2 3 Disposals item 3. Consider disposal of 0.23 hectares in the townland of Crosscoole harbour, 4 proposed? Cllr Ruttle. Seconded by Cllr Nolan. Is that agreed by everyone? Okay. Agreed. 5 6 Item 4 consider the disposal of 31 Connolly Square north, Bray, 0.0012 hectares or thereabouts. 7 Proposed Cllr Vance, seconded by Cllr Matthews, is that agreed? Okay. 8 9 Item 5 receive a presentation from Mark, ready to go? Regarding flood risk assessment 10 management programme. 11 MR DEVEREAUX: Thank you members, I have two presentations, the very first is very short 12 and I have a longer presentation, you'll have to bear with me. You don't need to know all of it. 13 14 The OPW are about to start a process of consultation about what's called CFRAMS, the 15 consultation will be taking place over the next number of weeks, Wicklow County Council are 16 partners in the consultation process, we'll provide two of the venues, here in our building and in 17 Greystones. The objective of the consultation is to get people's input to the process which the 18 OPW have done so far and also to inform you of what's going to happen over the next year or so 19 about finalising this process. The process is important because it will be laying down for the 20 record areas that flood, areas that are known to flood, and they will be made available to the 21 public and it includes a lot of decisions over the next number of years and may influence 22 people's building of their own homes and indeed developing lands. 23 24 These are the locations when the consultation will take place, each consultation starts at 3pm 25 till7 pm to allow people who want to go after work to attend. There will be OPW staff and RPS 26 Consulting Engineers will have staff there as well. 27 28 But also each of the consultation processes will start with a session during which the Council 29 Members, yourselves, will be given access to the staff, the OPW staff, some of our own staff, 30 Sorcha is providing some of her staff and I will be there at some meetings, we can't be at all of 31 them, you will see some are on simultaneously, again because of the way the OPW are rolling 32 this out to the whole country over the next number of months, so there's a certain amount of 33 doubling up. But we have asked them to do try and adjust some of the times they gave us so that 34 they would be in different municipal districts at different times so district councillors will be able

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 10

1 to go to their own district for the process. 2 3 Aughrim and Greystones/Kilcoole will be on at the same time, so Arklow district members can 4 go to one and Greystones to the other. So the important thing is it's starting at 2pm in the 5 afternoons in question, there will be OPW staff as I say and RPS staff available to give, to the 6 members, these will be closed to the public, only open to the members, the staff of the Council. 7 They are all starting at 2pm, except Greystones, which for some reason is starting at half one. 8 9 At 3pm each of the sessions will be open to the general public. If you want more information or 10 more detailed information about the studies and various areas the websites are there. Indeed 11 anybody can e-mail me if you want further information about it. 12 13 This is the more detailed presentation that I'll run through, because a lot of this will be available 14 if you attend. It's more specific to the process. CFRAM study catchment flood risk assessment 15 and management carried out effectively by OPW, but in our areas we're partners and involved in 16 it. 17 18 At the moment what paperwork is available is draft flood mapping, it's not finalised. The 19 objective is to give you an overview of the studies, the current status and some background and 20 explanation of maps, but there will be much more help available when you come to the sessions, 21 I'll tell you what the next steps are and guidance as to how to make submissions. 22 23 They arise from EU floods directive and our own law was SI122 of 2010, which gives OPW the 24 obligation and powers to go ahead and do the studies and notes the local authorities as statutory 25 consultees we call them, normally we're several stages we have an opportunity to be consulted 26 and make our comments on the process, we're just about approaching the point when we'll be 27 given our statutory time or opportunity to formally comment and this is, this process is a lead up 28 to that. 29 30 There was other pilot projects, effectively this is the overall study, nationwide study is based on 31 the river basin districts which doesn't much the county boundaries, we're in both eastern region, 32 which is the pink area on the map of Ireland and part of our county that's affected by the River 33 Slaney is in south-eastern region. 34

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 11

1 The project commenced in 2011 and '12 and the objective is to have the process completed and 2 in law by 2016. The roles and responsibilities, OPW are the competent authority and through 3 the Department of Finance they have funding and they have managed the process. They do all 4 the reporting, co-ordination and consultation, they are the main body. 5 6 Other public bodies local and regional authorities are partners, partly because of the way we are 7 involved, we have plenty of opportunity to be involved, we progress, tend to progress minor 8 works in the schemes some of you may shall aware, there are some headline schemes like River 9 Dargle flood defence scheme and River Avoca, they come under this in the sense they are 10 mentioned, they were not specifically covered under the process and I'll explain that in a minute. 11 12 We also have an obligation to have appropriate planning and development for the flood risk 13 that's built into it, but mentioned in SI122 which takes on board the outcome and where 14 appropriate there will be maintenance where schemes are put in place. 15 16 RPS are the consultants employed by the OPW to support the process and provide labour and 17 technical expertise to develop the process. 18 19 The objective is to provide flood risk management plans and the first thing to say is flood risk 20 management plans are not emergency response plans, nothing to do with schemes or studies 21 going on, construction projects going on. They are solely focused on flood protection -- solely 22 not solely focused on flood protection, they are focused on flood mechanisms. They don't 23 produce detailed designs and won't produce a set of works to progress immediately. 24 25 As part of the process the OPW and RPS looked at each of the catchments and within the 26 catchments they developed areas for further assessment. The bulk of the catchment is not really 27 affected by flooding maybe on the ground but the consequences are relatively low for farmland 28 and agricultural land, I accept there is consequences for farmland and agricultural land, but in the 29 context of this study the OPW have concentrated on what they call area of further assessment, 30 our areas are highlighted in blue on the map, on the out eastern area Baltinglass is the only area 31 on the River Slaney and on the other map the areas have been selected for further assessment. 32 33 The process will concentrate on them towards the end. The current status, we are currently at the 34 second of the boxes there where the flood hazard and risk maps are being prepared, which is the

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 12

1 information being fed inwards into the process at the moment. They still haven't started working 2 on the objectives, the options development or solutions nor the draft flood risk management 3 plans have been prepared yet. When the draft flood risk management plans are developed and 4 finalised they will be given to us for formal consultation, that's one of our statutory points of 5 consultation and objective being to have the final flood risk management plan in place. Which 6 leads to the question who does the solution and when? It's not part of the process. 7 8 The project tasks carried out at the moment are data collection, flood risk review, submissions by 9 OPW to EC Commission on that, surveys, hydrological analysis, flood risk assessment, 10 environmental assessment, consultation and engagement -- that's the stage we are at, at the 11 moment, the next two stages are down the line development of flood management options and 12 preparation of flood risk management plans. 13 14 The surveys have consisted of on the ground surveys, what we refer to as surveys topographical 15 surveys, also using aerial surveys from Ordnance Survey Ireland. Then surveying of the ground 16 and flood plains, there is commissioned surveys of defence assets, that's walls or flood defences 17 constructed in past times and property surveys, mostly to assess the amount and type of 18 properties that are in the flood plain or at risk in the areas. 19 20 There's been a significant amount of hydrological analysis, analysis of what happened to date, 21 historical events, developing catchment boundaries, analysing rainfall data built up over the 22 years of collecting data, hydrometric data that's on the rivers themselves, there's certain amount 23 of stations where, monitoring stations over the years measuring rainfall, river levels, then we 24 move into gauging station rating review which is each of those stations will have its parameters 25 mapped and logged and then those parameters are used to predict flow levels, there's estimation 26 of design flood parameters that's to estimate what design -- what if a flood occurs in a particular 27 scenario, they are referred to as design floods, they are floods against which they measure the 28 designs. Then there is joint probability analysis, that mean these look at different scenarios for a 29 lot of NFA they look at high tide event versus low to medium then high rainfall event and low to 30 medium tidal event. Usually a high tide and high rainfall don't happen at the same time, there's a 31 very low probability, so very, very rare occurrence, they do a combination of two different 32 occurrences happening in a catchment, that's joint probability analysis. 33 34 Sensitivity analysis means they look and see what if we got it wrong, what if our estimates are

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 13

1 out by factors, when we make a decision based on the study they usually test sensitivity, if they 2 make a mistake what are the consequences? And make sure that their confidence in their studies 3 match the sensitivity to future events. The future changes, that's to do with global warming, 4 factored into the overall. 5 6 The RPS have carried out hydraulic analysis, this is modelling, computing modelling estimating 7 the consequences of the rainfall and tidal events etcetera, I'm not going into detail on that for 8 you. Calibration and verification of deliverables, that's where they compare what they think will 9 happen based on studies with knowledge that may be on the ground, say the likes of our district 10 engineers, ourselves, they will have compared the flow, events they modelled with what they see 11 on their hydro-graphs, on their measurements they carried out on rivers themselves. They look 12 at survey flood depth information, things like trash lines they go and survey the rivers that have 13 risen and follow the trash line and see does it match what they predicted the water would come 14 up to, that's used, all this data is known as calibration data, it's all kept centrally by OPW and 15 used for studying other catchments, for instance if they study in Arklow they might look at other 16 catchments up around the north or eastern coast, some of the rivers behave similarly to the river 17 in Arklow therefore knowledge in one catchment can inform another catchment. 18 19 The deliverables for this whole study is to try and deliver flood extend which is what areas flood, 20 the flood zone, which is the zone that is influenced, the flood depth, the velocity, the speed of the 21 water and river channel mostly and flood hazard function mapping, that's about mapping all the 22 various parameters in one place. 23 24 Those numbers are Annual Exceedence Probability, AEP, we used to talk about one in ten year 25 events, scientific formula the way they do it now is Annual Exceedence Probability, a 50% is 26 one in two year, so the event happens every two years. For instance if you look at -- 2% -- 5% to 27 2%, river Dargle generally bursts its banks and floods roads every 30 to 40 years, that's between 28 5 and 2% AEP event. 29 30 I'll talk about percentages, what I'm actually talking about is return period, how often a particular 31 event is likely to occur based on a study. 32 33 The flood mapping you will see a number of these maps for each area, that's the area for 34 Wicklow, a big blue area top right-hand corner of the map is Broadlough, we all know it floods

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 14

1 that's why we show this slide, it's instructive. The area in the middle in blue is the area around 2 the railway line, if anybody knows the area the river that comes through under the railway line 3 out towards Rathnew direction, has been known to flood gardens of houses there, that's a fact. 4 5 The different colour on the maps relates back to AEP, on the right-hand side you think see the 6 box with text, that legend shows you what the different AEPs are, the probability. This map 7 shows, makes it look like a lot of properties flood, but bear in mind the values that are mapped 8 on this are 5%, 1%, 0.1% which is one in a thousand year flood event, so some of the 9 probabilities are quite high, so areas are shown to flood but flood in quite an extreme event, 10 that's the first thing to bear in mind. 11 12 So those numbers along the bottom they are all mapped in blue on the maps and the maps we'll 13 show you over the next couple of weeks will be specific to the rivers and areas in question. 14 15 If you want to make submissions on public consultations days, the first of which is tomorrow 16 here for Wicklow, Ashford, Rathnew areas. You can come along to the public consultation days, 17 there are already people on hand with questionnaires. If you go onto the website which I gave 18 you at the beginning there is mapping available for viewing on the websites, it will be made 19 available as the consultation goes on. There is a questionnaire on the website you can download 20 and complete, or you can submit the comments via the website itself. 21 22 Further statutory instrument consultation, that's the statutory consultation that will happen in a 23 matter of weeks or months from now, there will be an online tool where you can make your 24 comments on that as well. But in order to understand the flood maps and how they will be 25 developed and what they mean I encourage you to come to the consultation days. 26 27 The next steps, the RPS in conjunction with OPW and in conjunction with ourselves will 28 develop flood risk management options, these are where mapping shows an area of flood they 29 will look at the likely types of interventions that could be carried out to stop that area flooding 30 and the cost versus benefit, such as area whether it's urban or where there is significant benefit or 31 rural area where benefit while not insignificant to landowners may not yield benefit sufficiently 32 high to warrant. There will be consultation on that as well, they will be part of future 33 consultation, the objective for the current round of consultation is to get all the information in 34 and really the question RPS want to ask is have we got it right, are we thinking these are the

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 15

1 areas that flood. 2 3 Then after the consultation on flood risk management options there will be a series of plans 4 publicised by OPW as they go ahead. 5 6 Just to go back to the list of AFAs, just to point out something I missed, if you look at the 7 mapping although Bray is mentioned as AFA, that's an error, Bray is not currently being 8 included in the AFAs in the public consultation because the River Dargle has a flood scheme 9 under construction, so the mapping study that was done on Dargle was done in 2006, 2007 so 10 there isn't actually a need to do flood assessment for that because it's done, the construction work 11 that's underway as a result of that study, so there is no formal consultation for Bray AFA in this 12 process, because it's already been done. Similarly for Arklow, the River Avoca is not being 13 studied in the town of Arklow under this process, but it is being studied under the Arklow Flood 14 Relief Scheme, which is underway and consultants have been appointed. So because Bray and 15 Arklow are at an advanced stage they are not included in the areas of further assessment. So 16 before you ask me that question, they are not included in this process because there isn't such a 17 need because it's already been done under a separate process. 18 19 The other areas listed here are (inaudible) thanks. 20 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thanks Mark. Okay Cllr Blake? 21 Cllr BLAKE: Thanks Mark for the presentation, this certainly is an issue that has been to the 22 forefront in County Wicklow for a number of years, because we have a lot of mountains in the 23 county leads to the problems that water certainly appears down to low lying areas very quickly. 24 In regards to Aughrim and Baltinglass a lot of work has been carried out and alleviates a lot of 25 the problems, but one area that has, and you alluded to it by talking about historical problems, 26 one was in Shillelagh, for a number of years we had a lot of flooding, work was carried out but 27 over the last few years flooding has again been occurring in that area and also planning 28 permission a few years ago was refused for a number of houses based on the possibility of 29 flooding in a particular area in Shillelagh, so I'm surprised to see it hasn't been included in this 30 particular assessment of all aspects, but it will be an opportunity or can I ask you will there be an 31 opportunity to add a location based on experience or the fact that it has been flagged to yourself 32 and the committee as well over the next number of weeks? 33 Cllr WHITMORE: Thanks very much for that presentation Mark, I was just wondering up to 34 now what sort of analysis has been done by the Council in order to give permissions and things

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 16

1 like that and whether, if this new study because it seems to be very in-depth if that throws up 2 discrepancies between the maps we had been using and the ones that the OPW will actually 3 identify, if there is any potential impacts on the Council? 4 Cllr SNELL: Thanks for the presentation. I think it is important that this is carried out, just 5 wondering, you stated in your presentation that basically it's to compile all the data, but we're 6 actually unsure where we're going to get the funding from to address the issues that's 7 highlighted, I suppose that's an issue for another day, but just in regards to the Wicklow 8 Town/Rathnew environs plan that the members went through here, quite extensively, we had 13 9 or 14 steering group meetings, and thankfully there was a comprehensive flood risk assessment 10 carried out for that plan. 11 12 The Ashford area as well which would lead into this, I assume that all this is compiled, will it be 13 fed into our current County Development Plan that we're going to implement which is at draft 14 stage at the moment? You did refer yourself just in regards to an issue of around Knockrobin 15 there, a lot of issues in regards to them houses flooding at the moment, and having personal 16 knowledge of the families there and of the issues, people would say that it's been exasperated 17 since we try and put in new infrastructure, such as the port access road and since that necessary 18 infrastructure went in there it now seems to have exasperated the flooding problems. I'm just 19 saying that yeah, there is issues where we have to potentially look at stopping the flood risk 20 assessment and stopping floods potentially into the coming years, but if they are of a vastly rural 21 nature, if they are of no benefit for building purposes and they have a huge history in regards to 22 flooding over 60, 80 years surely we're not going to go looking for funding to alleviate problems 23 on really land that the land owners know and is in families for generations. 24 25 If it's a case that developers have, surely there's an onus on the developers to put in their own 26 flood risk assessment and carry out their own works and it shouldn't be coming through local 27 authority funding, which I assume would come from the Department? I'd just be wary of a 28 detailed report of what lands we're talking about at the end of this, what lands we'd actually look 29 at to go seeking funding to address. 30 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay thanks councillor. Mark? 31 MR DEVEREAUX: On Shillelagh I can't answer that question, I know the OPW did an exercise 32 in going through some of the smaller areas and decided where they were going to concentrate the 33 AFAs -- I'll check on where Shillelagh lies, they were given a certain amount of information and 34 went through some process, I'm not sure but no harm coming along to the consultation for

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 17

1 Baltinglass or for the other areas we can get that fed into the system anyway, find out why 2 Shillelagh isn't on the AFA, and we can look at it separately. I don't know the answer is the 3 short answer. 4 5 There's probably not an opportunity to add that on, but we'll ask the question. 6 7 What studies have we done Cllr Whitmore? The planning process, the process of developing the 8 County Development Plan, the process that Sorcha goes through every few years has cognisance 9 of flooding we know about, it's built into the plan, one of the questions we have asked of the 10 OPW, is the difference between this process and what information it will yield and the process 11 that we have gone through ourselves where we've identified areas that are known to flood and 12 our Development Plan contains reference to areas that are known to flood. 13 14 The short answer is that this is a very broad brush exercise using the same parameters for the 15 whole country, so it produces a result which is slightly different to our own process. In that 16 we -- our consultation and our Development Plan contains information from ourselves, it also, 17 our plan allows for areas that flood because of issues which are not necessarily to do with the 18 river per se, for instance culvert blockage, that's where there's a local problem in the pipe or a 19 culvert or a bridge or something that's known to cause a problem to flood land. We would still 20 include that land as potentially flooded or flooded in our Development Plan and that informs us 21 and our decision-making process, the OPW would not necessarily include that land in the 22 CFRAMS process, because they assume every bridge and culvert operates as it's supposed to and 23 that's the same parameter for the whole country, they use that process in modelling flooding in 24 the whole country, and that really is referred to us as our problem locally to deal with, such as a 25 culvert that blocks. So there's differences between information we have in our plan and the 26 CFRAMS process when it's completed, that's because of local issues. 27 28 We are obliged to take cognisance of the CFRAMS and what results it throws out, but equally 29 we can have cognisance locally to things we know about ourselves. So they are two different 30 processes and two different sets of information. There is a lot of interaction between Sorcha and 31 her team and the OPW and we have been asking that question as well, we don't want to be left 32 with a series of maps that differ to the maps we produce, the reality is we'll be left with two 33 different sets of maps for two different purposes and inputs if you like. They won't change, we 34 won't change our attitude to areas that we think are known floods because the mechanism is

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 18

1 different to which the OPW studied, so we won't necessarily change it. We'll still leave areas 2 with the risk if we think they are, even if though don't appear on CFRAMS. 3 4 Cllr Snell, I think your question is the type of land that's protected, the exercise right here and 5 now that the OPW are doing is to measure what areas are likely to flood, map it all, and the 6 circumstances under which they are likely to flood, so the probability of a return period to -- of 7 the event to cause the flood will be mapped. What type of land is only being considered when 8 the OPW look at defending it, the plan arising out of this, so what land they will defend. They 9 will only defend generally public land or large areas of private land, so a street in a housing 10 estate or a large area where a number of properties private or otherwise require defending, they 11 won't necessarily, while they might refer to a piece of land and have a plan, they won't 12 necessarily fund the defending, that's done in a separate process, outside this process. 13 14 These studies and plans will then be taken by the people who may look for funding, if we go 15 looking for funding we'll look for funding for public lands or lands that we are in control of. 16 17 Developers and private landowners may take this information and use it themselves, the decision 18 on funding is a matter for OPW and Department of Finance, while I can't say strictly how they 19 go about it, from experience of dealing with them, private developer land or private lands 20 generally is left to the private developer to deal with and sort out and OPW when they consider 21 requests for funding from us, they consider public infrastructure first, roads, assets like that. 22 They consider employment zones and areas such as the main street of a town next, in terms of 23 priority. And privately developed land will be way down the priorities in terms of how the OPW 24 consider it. So I don't think there's any hint that this process here will lead to lands being 25 defended or worked on to benefit of anybody other than this State or people generally. Private 26 land is left to the developer to deal with. 27 28 How this might change the people's attitudes to development land is a matter for the owners of 29 the land, and market prices will change for land once this process is completed, that's entirely out 30 of our control. Does that answer the questions? 31 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you. Thank you very much Mark. It's a long process and 32 sometimes people only think about floods when it happens, so thanks again. 33 34 I'm delighted to welcome Wicklow Local Access Action Group, sorry to keep you waiting. We

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 19

1 have of course our own Miriam, David Lee, Padraig Reilly, John Ashton and I know Anthony is 2 down in the gallery as well, so we're going to receive a presentation, Miriam you are going to do 3 the presentation. 4 Cllr MURPHY: First of all I'd like to thank you all for giving us the time. I'd like to introduce 5 as the Chairman has, this is David Lee our chairperson of our local Wicklow Local Authority 6 Access Group. Padraig Reilly is our committee member and John is a committee member and 7 support worker for care as well. 8 9 So we'll move onto the first presentation. Our presentation today is to members of Wicklow 10 Local Authority Access Group, we're here to present to you the members of Wicklow County 11 Council, the overview of the work that we have done in the last few years, but more importantly 12 the work that this committee can do in the future, and that's in conjunction with the Wicklow 13 County Council and the five municipal districts and the directors of services, the engineers and 14 the access officer and all the staff also. 15 16 I'll give you a brief history of the committee and our aims. David and Padraig will highlight 17 work and achievements that the group have done, including surveys of Baltinglass and 18 Blessington which they done recently and John will conclude and give a summary and the 19 recommendations to you. 20 21 Our mission statement, and this is to support Wicklow County Council in the delivery and the 22 enhancement of its services by advising and recommending on key strategies and actions. Two 23 of the most important ones I felt were to achieve full access for all, and to assist Wicklow 24 County Council in deliver its legal responsibilities under the Disability Act 2005. 25 26 And our membership consists of members of Arklow Disability Action Group, which I am one 27 of them. Disability Action Greystones Together, a new group formed in Greystones and we 28 welcome them on board. Our support committee is Disability Federation of Ireland who did a 29 lot of work with this group and other disability groups also. Our Kare reps are here today from 30 Tinahely, Baltinglass and Blessington services, we also have members from Sunbeam House 31 Services, Wicklow Disability Action Group and also our County Council access officer, Vibece 32 and also individual membership also. 33 34 The history of WLAAG, in 1995 the Barcelona Declaration was introduced to all local

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 20

1 authorities and this was to include people with disabilities in delivery of policies and planning. 2 In 2003 the Barcelona implementation plan was delivered for the county, which was adopted by 3 Wicklow County Council in 2004. This plan contained a number of projects designed to 4 improve access to Wicklow County Council services by people with disabilities. Wicklow 5 County Council Barcelona Declaration Steering Group, which is a mouthful, consisted of a 6 cross-section of staff, as well as presentations from disability sector. This committee began the 7 process of making Wicklow local authorities and its services accessible for all. 8 9 The Barcelona -- I won't run through that, but the main five points were promotion of disability, 10 policies and measures, consultative process, inclusion and accessibility, training and analysis and 11 assessments. I know the new members probably want to read up on that. 12 13 The history of our group. The Barcelona again, that came to bring about disability awareness but 14 there was no enforcement on this programme, a little but not enough. About ten years ago 15 Wicklow County Council's Barcelona Steering Group reformed as WLAAG to bring a group of 16 people with varying disabilities along with various agencies to work with the management of 17 Wicklow County Council and all the departments of Wicklow County Council. 18 19 At this point I would like to thank Margaret Malone of Wicklow CC who was involved in this 20 group for many years. Margaret's work really helped us to come and make a committee, in a 21 huge way we are sincerely thankful. 22 23 Our aims, to advise Wicklow County Council in the enhancement and delivery of all services. 24 To advise Wicklow County Council in the access, circulation and ethos of the built environment. 25 To advise Wicklow County Council on awareness of access to information and communication 26 in technology. And to advise Wicklow County Council in the allocation of disability strategy 27 funding. 28 29 Our networking: The group has successfully lobbied on many local issues. A notable 30 achievement of the group some years ago was the employment of a full-time access officer in 31 Wicklow County Council and this proved to be vital in the future work of our committee. This 32 group has built up strong networks and connections with Wicklow County Council Director of 33 Services, staff, engineers, etcetera, and without those networks we probably wouldn't have got as 34 far as we have been. And this has given us a voice and the knowledge that our work as a group

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 21

1 is vital to Wicklow County Council. 2 3 I'll pass on to David. 4 MR LEIGH: What is disability? Anything that prevents a person doing what they want to do on 5 a daily basis and is deemed to be a disability. 83% of people will acquire a disability at some 6 time in their lives. How can we help people to improve their lives? 7 8 Remember, are you prepared to walk in my shoes? And think of how you need to live your daily 9 life and get around? 10 11 At an WLAAG meeting in the Arklow Bay Hotel on the 13th of October 2013 we decided to 12 draw up an action plan for access to all services in Wicklow. 13 14 The action plan consists of town audits to help Wicklow County Council and the Gardaí and 15 local businesses to make our local communities more accessible for everyone. 16 17 On Friday 29th of November 2013 we walked the town of Baltinglass with a service user from 18 the Kare Lalor centre in a wheelchair to identify any access difficulties, taking photos of relevant 19 issues. 20 21 With this information we arranged a meeting with the Wicklow County Council area engineer, 22 Jack Kelly, and Wicklow County Council town overseer Seamus O'Halloran in the Kare Lalor 23 centre Baltinglass on Friday the 9th of May 2014 to discuss those findings of our town audit that 24 concerned Wicklow County Council. 25 26 After this meeting, we walked the town with Jack and Seamus and pointed out to them the 27 concerns we had with footpaths, crossings, signage and disability parking. This was a very 28 positive and successful meeting and work has progressed well since with regular contact with 29 Seamus. 30 31 Arising from our town audit and complaints from families of service users attending the Kare 32 Lalor centre, parking on footpaths was identified as a major problem in Baltinglass. On the 29th 33 of October 2014 we met with local Gardaí to discuss enforcement by Gardaí of parking in the 34 town, especially parking on footpaths, hindering wheelchairs, baby buggies and people with

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 22

1 visual and/or mobility impairment. 2 3 We also decided to contact local businesses informing them of any difficulties we found 4 accessing their premises or services. We prepared a letter for each business, stressing that we 5 were bringing these access difficulties to their attention for the benefit of their business, as 6 people with disabilities could not enter their premises. We hand delivered each letter with the 7 relevant photos and explanation of who we are and informing them we were here to assist and 8 advise them with any disability questions that they may have. 9 10 These are some examples of improvements made by Wicklow County Council as a result of our 11 Baltinglass town audit. As you remember there was a pole in the middle of that, now they 12 changed it, and brought it to the corner. And there's a footpath there, it was bad, and they also 13 fixed that up as well. 14 PADRAIG: This is Blessington town, I did, when Baltinglass had their one I thought I would do 15 one about Blessington, because I think Blessington needs a lot of jobs on paths done. I went 16 through the town, I saw problems with paths, we did all of Blessington, there's one there with the 17 wheelchair ramp, that's a dangerous one. 18 MR LEIGH: We have forwarded the outcome of the Blessington town audit to County Council 19 through Vibeke Delahunt, the Wicklow County Council access officer. We hope to hold a 20 meeting with a representative from Wicklow County Council in the near future regarding 21 Blessington. 22 23 We'll continue with town audits throughout 2015. We have asked Wicklow County Council to 24 commence a review of the Wicklow local authorities disability implementation plan 2005-2015, 25 strategic plan of March 2008. We are continuing to engage with Wicklow County Council at all 26 levels of the organisation. 27 MR ASHTON: To summarise, Wicklow County Council disability implementation plan 28 2005/2015. Review of the 2007/08 access audits of towns and villages. Wicklow County 29 Council access officer. Planning. Work with Wicklow County Council engineers and 30 community and financial support. 31 32 Wicklow County Council disability implementation plan 2005-2015. The vision of Wicklow 33 County Council is one of an inclusive Wicklow society in which people with disabilities have 34 equal rights and opportunities to participate in the social, economic and cultural life of the

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 23

1 county. 2 3 Wicklow County Council recognises that the implementation of the Disability Act 2005 will not 4 only make services and facilities more accessible to people with disabilities but will ensure that 5 Wicklow as a county strives to be universally accessible to everyone. Therefore, Wicklow local 6 access action group is requested a formal review and report of the disability implementation 7 plan. 8 9 Review of 2007/08 Wicklow County Council access audits of towns and villages. The access 10 audits took place in Bray, Greystones, Arklow, Wicklow, Blessington, Kilcoole, 11 Newtownmountkennedy, Enniskerry, Rathnew, Baltinglass, Rathdrum, Ashford, Aughrim, 12 Tinahely, Carnew and Dunlavin. These took place with the participation of Wicklow Local 13 Access Action Group and other local disability groups and committees. Wicklow Local Access 14 Action Group is requesting a formal review and report of the access audits. 15 16 Wicklow County Council access officer. The Wicklow County Council access officer is 17 appointed in accordance with section 26.2 of the Disability Act 2005. Until recently this was a 18 full-time position. This is now a part-time position, currently part of the Film Commissioner's 19 brief, in addition to her other roles. The access officer is responsible for providing or arranging 20 for, and coordinating assistance and guidance to persons with disabilities accessing services 21 provided by Wicklow County Council. 22 23 The access officer also assists the various Wicklow County Council departments in meeting their 24 requirements under the Disability Act 2005 and in turn, in making Wicklow County Council and 25 its services accessible for all. WLAAG recognises the current financial restrictions but is calling 26 for the Wicklow County Council access officer to be reinstated as a full-time role. 27 28 Planning. Wicklow Local Access Action Group calls for the use of maximum, not minimum 29 building standards. Councillors need to be aware of the standards when approving planning 30 permissions. The current minimum standards Part M are not fit for purpose and are not in line 31 with universal design or best practice. 32 33 All Wicklow County Council staff need to be aware of accessibility standards in relation to all 34 Wicklow County Council services, not just the built environment. WLAAG is available to assist

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 24

1 and offer advice in any area of accessibility. 2 3 Work with the Wicklow County Council engineers and community. WLAAG will continue to 4 be available to work with Wicklow County Council directors, councillors, engineers, local 5 communities, to help people with disability to live independently. WLAAG is represented on 6 the Wicklow Housing and Disability Steering Group. 7 8 Financial support. WLAAG presented a funding proposal to the Wicklow County Council in 9 2014. Requested 5,000 per annum for the next five years. In addition, WLAAG requested that 10 Wicklow County Council formally approves a designated administrative support person with 11 Wicklow County Council who will work closely with the WLAAG and the Wicklow County 12 Council access officer. 13 14 Financial support. Five year plan. Formulate detailed five year plan, for approval by Wicklow 15 County Council. Representation on the housing and disability steering group (reference Article 16 8 of the protocol for the provision of housing support to people with disabilities March 2013). 17 Review of and advice relating to all part 8 notices of the planning regulations, in relation to 18 disability and to universal access. Support and advice to the Wicklow County Council access 19 officer. Promote awareness of the WLAAG with Wicklow County Council with a view to 20 promoting disability access to all Wicklow County Council services. Consultancy and advice to 21 Wicklow County Council on disability proofing all Wicklow County Council services and 22 projects. 23 24 Provide a public consultation and Aware/Education service with regard to the provision of 25 Wicklow County Council's services such as housing, etcetera. Provide an interface to the 26 disability sector, disability service providers and people with disabilities. Assist in the review 27 and make recommendations to support the ongoing implementation of the Wicklow local 28 authority's disability implementation plan 2005-15. Advise on disability and access issues with 29 regard to local government reform, including the cohesion policy and leader programmes. 30 Develop a web page on the Wicklow County Council website with information and links to 31 relevant organisations and agencies. Work with organisations with similar aims to the WLAAG, 32 in other areas of the country, such as the DLRCC disability consultation group. 33 34 To this end, it is the intention to look to contract a Tús, gateway, job-bridge worker to seek

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 25

1 additional funding to enable the employment of a part-time worker. In addition, WLAAG will 2 seek to fully utilise all relevant aspects of social media, will develop a separate page on the 3 Wicklow County Council website and will seek to be included in Wicklow County Council 4 literature and links. 5 6 Finally, we want to position and promote Wicklow as a leader in accessibility. Wicklow Local 7 Access Action Group is there to assist. Please work with us, we'll work with you. Thank you 8 for listening. 9 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you very much. A lot of food for thought in that presentation. 10 Certainly I found it very interesting, the Baltinglass town audit, I'm sure if you go around any 11 town or village in Wicklow, you will find something that's there in front of us and we don't 12 realise it, so I'm glad it was a positive experience that the engineer and overseer engaged with 13 you and I look forward to that being expanded out to other towns and villages in Wicklow. 14 15 There are recommendations within the report, or presentation, that I'd like the chairs of the 16 various SPCs to take on board, whether it's planning or housing, to see if we can get stuck into 17 these issues, because there's no point in just giving a presentation and everybody going out of 18 here and forgetting about it. We want to see action on the recommendations. 19 20 So I'll let in the councillors. Cllr Timmins. 21 Cllr TIMMINS: Thanks Chairman. Just first of all thanks very much for the presentation, it was 22 excellent and very informative. I'd like to agree with the Chairman, a lot of the success of this is 23 based on the support of the area engineer and overseer, I know shortly after I joined the Council 24 I met with the overseer out in Baltinglass and the area engineer and they were happy to go 25 around the town and mark out spots for disability points, for bank, post office and things like 26 that, that was just the beginning of what's been done, you guys have obviously brought it to a 27 much further stage. 28 29 I'd like to say the Development Plan is coming up for submission and consideration now, maybe 30 there's an opportunity for us as members and for the disability action group as well to make 31 submissions that would further enhance and copper-fasten the importance of disability access in 32 our County Development Plan. 33 34 Additionally in particular in Baltinglass since that got a bit of airtime here today, there is

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 26

1 currently going on display a new town centre layout for Baltinglass, that covers things like 2 parking, crossing, pedestrian crossings for instance in the middle of Baltinglass there is no 3 pedestrian crossing and we have an opportunity to put one in which will help all members of the 4 community, including those with disability issues, that's something as well, that will go on public 5 display shortly and submissions can be made on that to make sure what you want out of that. 6 7 Lastly I'll mention the budget, that we in the Council should consider in our next year's budget 8 putting money aside to improve disability access in our towns and villages. I see you've already 9 raised that issue yourselves, but I think it's something that we have to take cognisance of. 10 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you councillor. 11 Cllr McDONALD: I'd like to echo Cllr Timmins. Thank you very much for highlighting this 12 issue to us, I think it's an issue I'm as guilty as anybody, we just don't take on board as much as 13 we should, until it actually comes knocking at your own door and until you see the difficulties, 14 witness the difficulties of people with disabilities, just on that note I want to put on record and 15 publicly thank Cllr Murphy for her Trojan efforts over the years, the issue of the ramp or lack of 16 the ramp at the post office in Arklow, I think she's been fighting that for about eight years for 17 something that ultimately took a week to complete. 18 19 Like I say, it's something that we don't take enough interest in until it actually came to my own 20 family and when you witness the difficulties that people in wheelchairs and limited mobility 21 actually encounter on a daily basis, I think it's not given half as much coverage, half as much 22 support as we need to do. I think as councillors and as elected members of Wicklow County 23 Council we need to get on the back of this and give them our 100% support, and get them all the 24 help and funding, anything that's there to be drawn down. We have junior Ministers from 25 Wicklow, we have TDs in Wicklow and I think we need to be calling on them in their capacity to 26 get us the funding and everything that's available to help this particular group. Thank you very 27 much. 28 Cllr KAVANAGH: Thanks Cathaoirleach. First of all I'd like to thank the team here today for 29 their excellent presentation. It's about accessibility, but the presentation was very accessible to 30 us as well. 31 32 I want to particularly commend you for the proactive approach you have taken in getting out to 33 do the surveys yourselves and these surveys are invaluable, they might look like small things, a 34 piece of a footpath missing or broken or whatever, but these are the things that make a difference

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 27

1 to people's comfort, but also to their health and safety, if you can't get on to a footpath and have 2 to travel on the road you are putting yourself in danger. So I think you're speaking for people 3 who feel that they don't have a voice or they are not being heard, I'd like to say the presentation 4 today has been heard and I hope it will be heard and that your request for 5,000 which seems to 5 me to be very reasonable, that equates to 1,000 for each municipal district, which is nothing, if 6 we had to get a consultant in to do the work you are doing it would cost us way more than 5,000, 7 so I hope that the Council, whether it be from the general budget of the Council or municipal 8 districts, that each contract maybe a thousand euro that that funding will be looked at for you to 9 progress your work, invaluable work you are doing. Thanks again. 10 Cllr CULLEN: Thanks Chairman, compliments on the presentation, very well put together and 11 very well delivered. A few points, first of all disability parking is a major concern for people 12 involved, unfortunately some of the general public don't adhere to the disability parking and I 13 think it's maybe a role for the parking wardens of our towns that they should be very vigilant in 14 that area, apart from people parking illegally, we should certainly look at improving the amount 15 of parking spaces made available for disabled parking. 16 17 Your presentation and your report there, again I think it should be given out to community 18 groups around the county. To make them aware of the amount of work you put into this and 19 keep the communities involved and that they have a role in trying to improve each area 20 themselves. 21 22 Another point, as a Council we should taking heed of as well, the next phase of building we 23 intend to do in the county here, we should certainly consider the disability and elderly when it 24 comes to building our houses and making houses more accessible, i.e. bathrooms to be built with 25 disability in mind as well, there's areas that we certainly, as a Council, can play a very important 26 role in and these are some of them. 27 28 And finally, as Cllr Kavanagh alluded to, the amount of money that your group is looking for, in 29 my opinion is a small amount of money and I think we as a Council should be willing to promote 30 the accessibility issue where possible and I think we can play a very key role in that. Thank you. 31 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you. Cllr O'Neill? 32 Cllr O'NEILL: Again I'd like to thank the group for their presentation, a fine presentation, and 33 it's something that's dear to my heart for a long, long time. But I did walk the streets of 34 Blessington with Padraig there a while ago, I'm only too familiar with the problems that

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 28

1 wheelchair bound people have to deal with. There are problems in Blessington all right, that the 2 local engineer, although doing what he can, the town centre is under Dunnes Stores management 3 or whatever and there's no getting around that. Also the development land where the Kare 4 Centre is -- that again is under NAMA land and it's a little bit more difficult, but I know the 5 engineer, I was around with him only a week ago, he is determined to do what he can in the area. 6 7 But could I just echo the Cathaoirleach's statements there, Cllr Fox, that it's time for a little bit of 8 action. I'm familiar with this, first hand and the new green way in Blessington, it's four 9 kilometres at the moment, but again that should be wheelchair friendly, but it was put in and it 10 wasn't wheelchair friendly, I think that's discrimination against people in wheelchairs. I have 11 been assured that the next stage of it will be wheelchair friendly. So it's important that -- and I 12 know the councillors in the municipal area are aware of this, that those things have been done, as 13 the Cathaoirleach said there's not much point talking about these things. 14 15 Again local areas are obliged to employ up to 3% of people with disabilities, I know Wicklow 16 County Council isn't up to that either, so again I think it's something that we should always 17 remember. So again I'd just like to let you know that I'm with you all the way on that, and again 18 thanks very much for the presentation, it was excellent and I know Padraig in my neck of the 19 woods, he'll keep us going and keep us moving and remind us at every given chance, thanks very 20 much. 21 Cllr WALSH: Thank you Cathaoirleach. I want to thank David, Padraig, John and Miriam for 22 an excellent and informative presentation, we have an active group in Greystones which I'm 23 familiar with, I note from the presentation that we had access audits around the county in 24 2007-08 and that now there's been a request of a review of these formal audits, I wonder where 25 we're at with that request, is that going to take place any time soon? 26 CATHAOIRLEACH: We'll get an answer for that. 27 Cllr FITZGERALD: I just want to -- I'm not going back over what everyone else said, but I 28 want to thank the group for their presentation and I am aware of the contribution that Cllr 29 Murphy made to the action group. And certainly I believe it's been stated there already that her 30 fight to get wheelchair accessibility at Arklow post office for all, she finally won the battle, great 31 credit is due to her on that account and many other issues. Obviously the subject is dear to my 32 heart, I have a sister who's 19 years in the Cheshire Home in Shillelagh where she gets great 33 care, I'm aware of the accessibility problems some have been sorted out, it brought home to me 34 recently the difficulties people have in Arklow municipal district, the pedestrian crossings in the

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 29

1 main street, I met a gentleman in the wheelchair, he said it was the first time he could cross the 2 street without fear of being injured, previously he had to go up to the post office 500 metres 3 away to get across the main street safely, this was the first time he had crossed the street in 4 Arklow, in a wheelchair where he wanted to go, it meant he had to go up 400 back down and 5 then go where he wanted to go. There's a lot still needs to be done and I know that in Arklow, I 6 take on the board that all the municipal districts should where possible and it is possible, contract 7 5,000 I think is the figure there, that's certainly something that needs to be done. 8 9 Can I thank everyone for the contributions and the work that's going on to help those with 10 disabilities and hopefully we can succeed into the future. 11 Cllr FORTUNE: Again, can I thank the group for your presentation and say thanks to Cllr 12 Murphy who has been and is a tremendous advocate for the whole area of access. She's been at 13 it for a long long time. I think in listening to your presentation obviously the Barcelona 14 Declaration is implemented and everyone takes it on board it's going to sort out most of the 15 problems, I think that's the challenge. I recall walking in Greystones in the last couple of years, 16 it's improved and lots of things were done following all that, but as other councillors said there's 17 so much to be done. In looking at your presentation and listening to what you were saying, it's 18 all in the Barcelona Declaration, so that's really the challenge to make sure that the system that 19 we all work for lives up to that, and if it does we'll achieve the objectives. 20 Cllr BRADY: Again like the other members just to commend you for coming in here this 21 afternoon for the excellent presentation, certainly very, very worthwhile. Just a couple of points, 22 you said a formal review is needed, hopefully that can commence as soon as possible and I'm 23 sure the Council has a huge role to play in that and I'm just hoping that that process isn't being 24 held up by the fact that we only have a part-time access officer, because I think that is the huge 25 elephant in the room here, in terms of everything that we're speaking about. We can talk about 26 the declaration, Barcelona Declaration, but until we get a full-time access officer here in the 27 county, we're really only providing lip service to it, hopefully -- I know our hands are tied in 28 terms of that because of the recruitment embargo, so maybe if we can just get a position from the 29 top table as to where we are with that, have we made approaches to the department to get a 30 full-time position here, to get a person employed, that's not to take away from the person that is 31 doing the part-time work, I want to commend the work that is being carried out there, I'm not for 32 one second criticising, it's such an important role, I think we need a dedicated person in that 33 position. 34

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 30

1 When we talk about disabilities we all know there are many types of disability and it's not just 2 people in wheelchairs or whatever, I've spoken to a lot of people who are visually impaired as 3 well, who have massive difficulties even simple tasks such as crossing the road at a pedestrian 4 crossing, there is issues for us as a local authority in terms of putting in place the audio that 5 comes on when the green light comes up, so people with visual impairments can cross the road. 6 So there is many things that we should be doing, and when we carry out our footpath repairs 7 there should be a standard process that we're dishing curbs and putting in place -- I commend the 8 local authority particularly in Bray where huge work has been done in dishing footpaths and 9 putting in the special cobble stone for visually impaired people to let them know they are about 10 to cross the road, huge work has been done and that needs to be rolled out in all areas. 11 12 I also want to commend the Council for work that has been carried out in playgrounds more 13 recently, and the inclusion of equipment that is accessible to children with disabilities, that 14 should be standard procedure in all our playgrounds, that no-one should be discriminated against 15 with any disability. 16 17 The last point there, maybe as part of the review, I know different councillors have engaged in 18 the past in different reviews, maybe as part of that process councillors could be brought in and 19 put in a wheelchair, a blindfold put around them to try and allow them manoeuvre around our 20 towns, just to see how difficult a process it is. Maybe if that can be included in whatever review 21 is going to take place, I think it would be a very, very worthwhile exercise here and certainly 22 open an awful lot of people's eyes around the table to the challenges facing people with 23 disabilities. So again I commend you all. 24 25 Just to finish off I also would support, I know Bray tomorrow what we're dealing with 26 discretionary funding, hopefully the other members might be able to support a proposal to meet 27 some of the financial needs that are there. 28 Cllr RUTTLE: Thank you very much. I'd like to first of all thank everyone for the presentation 29 we had here today, it was very detailed and specific. However as was alluded to by my 30 colleague Cllr Timmins, it's time to think about how to move forward and what we can do to 31 help in that regard. 32 33 Certainly as Chairman of the community social committee of the Council myself I would be 34 most anxious that we'll do everything we could to organise funding of the figure of 5,000, what I

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 31

1 will propose to that committee is out of our funding, the allocation of that to help you with your 2 future work in that regard, that's specifically our remit under the Community Act. 3 4 Thank you for your presentation, for your work. I know you are very dedicated, I know Padraig 5 from west Wicklow here. And I will certainly do anything I can and in the upcoming budget as 6 well to help with your resources you need to move forward on that issue. Thank you again. 7 Cllr LAWLESS: I want to echo what most councillors have said, thank you very much for the 8 presentation, there is a huge amount of work gone into this and I welcome it. For someone who 9 actually would have family members with disabilities I'm quite aware of our community not 10 getting access to all the amenities within their towns or villages where they live. I've also had 11 Dags T group in with us as well, they have came up with an idea of the gold star initiative, trying 12 to encourage businesses to allow our communities, that everyone gets access to everything 13 within the communities. I think as a county it would be very good for us to strive forward in this 14 and try and promote that Wicklow is accessible to everybody regardless of what your disability 15 is. 16 17 So I would fully support any work that's going on in this area. I also think that 5,000 euro for the 18 next five years is a very small amount of money for the work that is needed to be done and I do 19 think this needs to be looked at in our annual budget and we should be looking at this more 20 often. 21 22 Also in regards to the audits done around the town six or seven years ago since it's done, maybe 23 it should be something that's done a little more often, even a three-year period would be a little 24 more feasible than six or seven years, as our towns and villages have grown considerably year on 25 year. So again I just want to thank you very much for the presentation, it was very welcomed. 26 Thank you. 27 Cllr SNELL: Thanks Cathaoirleach, I won't repeat what other councillors have said, I actually 28 want to thank the group for coming in and giving a very detailed presentation here and it's been 29 well covered in regards to accessibility. But if I could just speak about housing and myself and 30 Cllr Murphy have discussed it, and I know it's something that the group are going to get their 31 teeth into. While there is help through the local authority to people who own their own houses 32 and they can avail of various grants whether it be elderly persons, people with disabilities or 33 mobility grants, we have seen the finance going to that sector dwindle year on year, it's now got 34 to such a stage where it's quite difficult for people, they are only getting 66% of the overall

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 32

1 works that's been carried out, so they have to come up with a lot of finance themselves. But we 2 also have an onus as a local authority and it's something we'll deal with through the Strategic 3 Policy Committee on housing, which is our obligation to people on the housing list. I know Cllr 4 Murphy and her group are trying to get information in exactly where we stand in regards to our 5 obligations and specific numbers, because it's something going forward, we are meant to be 6 dealing with diversity here in regards to all groups, all citizens, I believe that's something that 7 we've probably failed in the Celtic Tiger years to provide for, certainly it's something that as 8 chair of the housing SPC, I feel we need to do something that's constructive, we need to actually 9 produce units that are going to help people in the situation that Cllr Murphy and her group have 10 outlined here today. Because at this moment in time there is people sitting on our housing lists, 11 part of the four and a half thousand people on the housing lists for local authority housing, who 12 can't avail of the units, the very few units, bearing in mind there is only 21 vacant units in the 13 whole of the county. Out of them 21 I imagine there is very few that are suitable for people of 14 this group who need social housing, that's something we have to take on board and something I 15 have been committing to Miriam and her group to look into, thanks Cathaoirleach. 16 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thanks councillor. 17 Cllr THORNHILL: Can I just take this opportunity to thank everyone for giving us an excellent 18 presentation and I am sure we'll all agree that it's a situation where we have loved ones or 19 whoever in these circumstances that we should be really trying to improve things. I know that in 20 Bray that we have an organisation by the name of Bray Lakers who really excelled themselves 21 and are a great example to situations where people -- they take part in Paralympics and they 22 really put themselves to the fore, and I'm sure we should always realise, remember that the 23 person that's giving out about they had no shoes to wear until they met the person with no feet. 24 So at the end of the day we should always be aware of other people, it's very important. And 25 accessibility is the key word and it should be there for everyone, compliments to everyone for an 26 excellent presentation. 27 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thanks again to all the members that gave the presentation, I know the 28 Arklow councillors alluded to the fact that Miriam fought a campaign at the post office and little 29 did the gentleman in the GPO realise who he was taking on! So well done on that. Keep up the 30 good work. Thanks a lot. 31 32 Okay we're moving on. Consider the establishment of Wicklow heritage forum and preparation 33 of the heritage plan. 34 >> Thank you Cathaoirleach, members, everybody received a briefing document on the county

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 33

1 heritage plan. I'll do a very brief presentation to give the background to that. I know some of 2 you are very familiar with it and have been directly involved and others maybe less so. The 3 proposal here today is to adopt to agree to this process and give feedback to this process of the 4 preparing the next county heritage plan and also we circulated at the municipal districts to seek a 5 representative from each of the municipal districts, so if we can have a vote on that as well. 6 7 Just an introduction to the county heritage plan, the context for it is through the National 8 Heritage Plan 2002 and that called on greater management of heritage at a local level and called 9 on setting up of local heritage fora, so that's the background, the Heritage Act sets out the scope 10 of heritage and that's everything listed here, everything from archaeology to wildlife, species, 11 habitats, heritage objects and through the county heritage plan we've also broadened that scope 12 and looked at other aspects of cultural heritage, traditions, skills and place names and that kind 13 of stuff. 14 15 As I mentioned we have two previous heritage plans, the 2004 and 2009, this will be the third for 16 the county. It's a partnership plan, it's initiated and driven by Wicklow County Council, but it's 17 very much done in partnership foremost with the Heritage Council who have an important role to 18 play, they set out a methodology for how these plans have been rolled out nationwide, and they 19 also treat each heritage plan as a strategic funded application, they have made heritage plan 20 funding available to any county with a heritage plan. But also involving Wicklow County 21 Council and the Heritage Council there are very much other statutory and non-statutory 22 organisations and individuals, you will see that in the proposed set up of the heritage forum I'll 23 go into a little more detail in a while, that's really the implementation group if you like for the 24 heritage plan. 25 26 So really going forward the next plan will seek to develop the strategic vision that was set out in 27 our previous two plans and to complement the actions that have been carried out to date. Then it 28 will look on building on those for new actions and priorities. I listed four key theme areas, these 29 are the themes under which all our actions fall under one of them, sometimes overlap and fall 30 under a couple of these, really one key one has been the compiling of information about our 31 heritage resources, I'll give one or two examples, you'll see them in the appendix of the 32 document listing the actions, really about gathering information, in particular aspects that we 33 don't know much about, whether archaeology, biodiversity, and using that information to inform 34 our policies.

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 34

1 2 Raising awareness and appreciation of heritage is always a key action as well, unless we all are 3 aware of what we have and feel proud of it and appreciate it we won't protect it as much as we 4 should. 5 6 Promoting best practice is always one of the cornerstones through the heritage plan, we ran 7 various training courses, talks, events, various publications to try and promote and generate this 8 climate of best practice, both in the local authority and our own actions and in the wider 9 community by offering advice. And then the cornerstone all about encouraging active 10 participation and partnership, that's really what the whole plan is about, bigger than the sum of 11 the parts, it is only through the involvement of various groups and organisations that we're able 12 together to carry out the multiple actions. 13 14 Rather than going through it I'm going to pick out -- all the actions are listed in the appendix, but 15 just to pick out three actions as an example, so three theme areas if you like we've done work on 16 in the last heritage plan. 17 18 Wicklow's traditional buildings, Wicklow wetlands and our online community heritage archive. 19 So on the traditional buildings, a lot of you might be familiar with that book we published before 20 last Christmas, the Traditional Farmhouses of County Wicklow, but just to give you a bit of 21 background to that, it happened as a result of various actions over the years, in 2007 we first 22 carried out our representative survey of the traditional houses of Wicklow. We surveyed 147 23 and really came up with an idea of the kind of traditional houses we have and where they are 24 located and materials, moving on from that we did an exhibition on this and various talks, 25 produced a calendar in 2009 on this theme and really incorporated some of the buildings from 26 the study that were suitable into the record of protected structures in the County Development 27 Plan giving them statutory protection, we had a traditional skills open day in Wicklow Gaol back 28 in 2010 to showcase the practitioners of traditional skills (inaudible) the publication and this year 29 to keep the theme we're hoping later in the year we'll be able, the Irish Georgian Society, have a 30 whole weekend. So just to give you an example of how actions, we try and keep the theme and 31 as we can over the years, develop it further. 32 33 Wicklow wetlands that's another one, the small document is the county Biodiversity Action Plan. 34 Again it was a separate action plan, but in our action plan to produce it was, it was in 2010, one

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 35

1 of the key things of that was identifying information about probably our most vulnerable habitat, 2 our wetlands , this came to the fore with planning and development regulations in 2011 whereby 3 you needed planning permission for the first time to drain wetlands, but you need to have a good 4 baseline of where the wetlands are in the county and what kinds we have, so we have done two 5 years of survey work to date. Phase 1 was all about desktop research, compiling all the data and 6 generating a GIS map and also database of known wetlands and phase 2 elaborated on that and 7 we did quite a bit of detailed survey work. 8 9 We ended up having our GIS map, our individual survey, all that information, going into the 10 landscape character assessments, to inform our SEA and our planning work here. It's through 11 this kind of work we generated lots of biodiversity information that goes to national parks and 12 wildlife, the little image of the larvae was a new species, it was thought to be extinct in County 13 Wicklow until we did our survey. It hadn't been recorded until we did our survey, we found it on 14 quite a few sites in the county, that's gone to inform the national biodiversity data centre. 15 16 Then to follow through with that we have had various awareness raising activities over the years 17 on this theme as well, we have had exhibitions, a photography competition and biodiversity 18 week in 2013, again it was a theme we have worked on and hope to continue working on. 19 20 Another action, the third, a different type of one through the Heritage Plan has been a 21 development of Wicklow's online community archive, we just launched that during Heritage 22 Week last year, we developed it for a year and a half before that, really it's the first in Ireland, 23 we're part of a network with the Museum of Country Life in Castlebar, we're part of the ICAN, 24 there is a number of towns in the west of Ireland that developed these online repositories for 25 heritage information, we are the first one this side of the Shannon to come on board. We have 26 developed a web based digital archive of people, places and topics of heritage interest in County 27 Wicklow, it's open access, anybody can log on, for the community at large, we have had great 28 input to it and really it acts as a resource for information about County Wicklow, but also as a 29 notice board. This came about through the action of the Heritage Plan. We tried to help people 30 network a bit better and find out more about Wicklow, we have been happy about how it 31 developed, we are hoping to develop it more, it expanded the audience for County Wicklow 32 globally and connected with the Wicklow Diaspora in overseas countries. 33 34 In the last year, from the 1st of March '14 to this year we had 26,000 visitors and up to 90

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 36

1 different countries, the top five are there. So it's very big, it's getting new and younger audiences 2 to our Facebook and things like that. 3 4 They are just, when I'm talking about actions you have an idea of what we're talking about, they 5 are three actions we have done. I suppose the key part of producing the Heritage Plan is having 6 a heritage forum, that's our steering group, our non-statutory advisory group, it oversees the 7 preparation of the Heritage Plan and oversees implementation and that typically has involved 8 four meetings per year and also as part of that, I should say when we're producing the next 9 series, even though people might be represented on the forum, there is lots of scope for 10 involvements in the working groups. 11 12 You have in the document the proposed composition of five elected representatives, one from 13 each of the districts, four representatives from State bodies, different sectoral interests in 14 Wicklow and they are listed out in the document everyone has in front of them, and from 15 Wicklow County Council staff as well, that's how we would see it rolling out. 16 17 The process itself is fairly straightforward, and set out in the document, we're on stages one and 18 two of that list there, I did present it to the Planning SPC who agreed to the process going 19 forward, it has been circulated to the municipal districts and now back to you as full Council and 20 we'll seek representative bodies from the elected members and from the wider community, after 21 that we'll advertise and set the process to prepare the Heritage Plan, we'll set up some working 22 groups, identify our issues and priorities, work on those through the forum and come up with a 23 draft plan, which again will come back to the full Council for input to it and for discussion and 24 ultimately adoption. 25 26 So that's all my presentation. 27 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you very much Deirdre. I think it has to be acknowledged the 28 fantastic work that Deirdre does, she is a one person dynamo! I don't think we have had the 29 forum up and running since March and I'd also like to add the online community heritage archive 30 that was set up last year is a fantastic website to go into and have a look, I know I promised to 31 put in a contribution which I haven't done yet. 32 33 Okay, we do want to get a member from each municipal district, I know it was on the district 34 agendas, hopefully each district has selected a member. So we'll start with Bray, I know Bray

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 37

1 proposed Cllr Matthews. We'll go through the others. Have Arklow selected? Cllr McDonald, 2 thank you. Baltinglass/Blessington? Cllr Tommy Cullen. Wicklow? Cllr Snell. Greystones? 3 Cllr Shay CULLEN: Wicklow municipal district did ask if it was possible to have a second 4 candidate? We had two interested parties in the position? 5 MS BURNS: In the interest of balance we just have one, but I'd say there will be a lot of scope 6 through the working groups for additional. Or it could be a rotating arrangement if you wanted. 7 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay, Cllr McLoughlin you were nominated from Greystones? 8 Cllr McLOUGHLIN: Gentlemen, I just want to make a -- commend you on the presentation and 9 thank you very much Deirdre for it. I for one would like to endorse what our Cathaoirleach said, 10 Deirdre's that silent person in the background that sweeps across the whole county and achieves 11 probably more than any one individual, I just think she's absolutely extraordinary. Her last plan 12 was absolutely superb. If you look at the amount of work done by this one woman army as I call 13 her, it was huge. But it's also showing there hasn't been enough funding given to heritage for the 14 last number of years, there was a huge amount in 2004 to '09 and then there was a cut-off point 15 where Deirdre was, somebody decided she would achieve stuff anyway we don't need to give her 16 money, just get on with it. She has. It's been remarkable. But I think our heritage is every bit as 17 important as tourism and every other aspect, so she needs the support and particularly the new 18 councillors on the Council, they need to know the work that that person up there does is 19 remarkable, she has done incredible work for the county and deserves thanks and support from 20 every single one of us going forward. 21 Cllr CASEY: Equally with yourself and Cllr McLoughlin, I fully agree with the sentiments of 22 the heritage officer, Deirdre works quietly in the background but in a very constructive manner. 23 She said about the plan working in partnership, that's the way she works, in partnership. 24 Especially through the community groups, she always made herself fully available to any 25 community groups in relation to heritage matters, I have to put on record my thanks to her, she's 26 been a huge support to us for five or six years where we have indeed got indirect funding 27 through the local authority here, and also my record of thanks for the local authority for help in 28 getting us that. But a special thanks to Deirdre for doing the work. Thank you. 29 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay then, the five names, Cllr McDonald, Cllr Matthews, Cllr Snell, 30 Cllr Tommy Cullen, Cllr McLoughlin, is that agreed? Okay. 31 32 Okay I'll ask Christine Flood to come up to discuss the draft Wicklow local authority corporate 33 plan 2015-19. Everybody got a copy I presume, yeah? 34 MS FLOOD: Thank you Cathaoirleach. Members will know that the corporate plan 2015-2019

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 38

1 is a high level document, it's the strategic blue print for the activities of the Council for the 2 lifetime of this current Council. It's a top level plan, part of a suite of plans which also includes 3 the annual service delivery plans and it links in with the funds management and indeed with 4 metrics and measurement. 5 6 It sets out our goals and strategies, our objectives and mission statement and what you probably 7 find of great interest is the metrics in the report. The figures in the 2015 draft plan are related to 8 2013 data. We're compiling the 2014 figures at the moment. It is likely, this plan is due for 9 review at the end of 2015, it will be reviewed to reflect any changes that might be required, as a 10 result of the preparation of the local economic community plan, again they are very closely 11 related and inter-dependant. So this corporate plan may change at the end of the year. And if 12 that's the case we'll be able to put in the 2014 figures as well. So it will give you a good idea of 13 the performance of the Council. 14 15 The national auditing oversight committee may introduce new metrics, but it's a requirement that 16 each corporate plan has these types of metrics in order to be able to measure our performance. 17 So thank you very much. Cathaoirleach. 18 CATHAOIRLEACH: Corporate Policy Group had a discussion on this this morning and went 19 through a number of issues and I think it was the view of the Corporate Policy Group that this 20 should be a working document and not something put on the shelf, because it does allow for 21 service indicators where performance can be compared to previous years. 22 Cllr WHITMORE: Thanks very much. I was wondering is there any possibility of getting some 23 targets into the metrics as well? Because it's really important that we understand where we are at 24 the moment, but also to say this is where we want to be in a year or five years time, that would 25 enable us to gauge whether or not what we are doing is working. Would that be possible? 26 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you. 27 Cllr TIMMINS: Just briefly I'd like to see the metrics expanded. I know I came up with 28 proposals here before, I'd like to bring them again maybe to Christine, just in relation to 29 expanding metrics. I know for instance just the number of vacant houses, a number of things 30 like that, split by electoral area, a lot of extra relevant figures that we can ask to be put into our 31 corporate plan. There is still a lot of work to do in relation to us designing metrics that are 32 relevant to Wicklow and our electoral areas that may not be the same as what's produced at a 33 national level, I know national oversight is only getting off the ground as regards giving 34 guidelines to Councils about different metrics that should be used, and I'd be interested in what

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 39

1 they have to say to the Councils, I think they will be starting to build up a lot of knowledge about 2 what Councils should be measuring, so any updates from them I'd be interested in them, it's a 3 great way of us monitoring how the Council is doing. Some are doing well, some could do 4 better, but it's metrics, through measurement, not just people shooting their mouth off about 5 different things. It's a true measure of what's actually happening, you can't beat statistics and 6 facts to know what's going on in this county rather than the hype. 7 8 I was disappointed that the N81 wasn't mentioned in the corporate plan and transport, public 9 transport links on the west side of the county, we're under pressure with CIE dropping one of the 10 routes that goes down the N81, I know Baltinglass, certainly it will affect all of west Wicklow 11 losing a bus route that runs to Dublin on a daily basis, one of the bus routes is proposed to be 12 withdrawn by Bus Eireann from June, that's certainly a concern. I'm not sure what the corporate 13 plan can do to help that, but I'd urge it to be considered. 14 Cllr RYAN: Thank you Christine. Thanks for providing us with the document, to me it's really 15 important that we are a bit more strategic in how we go about things as a Council, and not 16 reactive as we tend to be. So it's great to get the corporate plan on paper, I think it's a starting 17 point, I'd say we'll develop it with time, I'm just interested in the values that are there within the 18 plan, I think it would be really useful if we had a workshop on the values that we believe in and 19 that we share and that we break them down into a set of behaviours that are the way we live 20 those values, because to me having values sitting in a document or on a wall means nothing, it's 21 how we bring them alive in the day-to-day operation of the Council. I'd probably like the plan to 22 be a little more aspirational in terms of where we want to go and what we want to be, I certainly 23 want to be part of the best performing local authority in the county -- sorry in the country! So 24 from that point of view I'd love to know when they are available, I think all these corporate plans 25 have to be done now, when all the other counties have them done, I'd like to see them, to see 26 what they are saying and their aspirations and maybe we can get together as a Council later on 27 and develop ours, but I believe it has to be a collaborative approach of everybody involved, all 28 the stakeholders in this county to make the best plans, so we can focus resources and make it 29 happen. 30 Cllr CASEY: I'll be fairly brief in relation to it, this is a draft corporate plan, I'd like to inform 31 the members also by the end of the year we'll hopefully have our local economic and community 32 plan in place. Which will also give us an opportunity to amend this plan to take the 33 recommended outputs of both the economic and community sections and adopt them into that 34 plan at the time, I think that's important to say, that that facility will be available at the end of the

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 40

1 year to the members as well. 2 Cllr WALSH: I want to thank Christine for the document, two quick questions on reading 3 through it. One in the appendix section, I see finance resources to upgrade existing local 4 authority housing in housing estates. I was surprised to learn recently that those resources did 5 not include the replacement of doors and windows for the regeneration scheme, so that was a 6 surprise to me. The second query I had was on the fire services section, the number of false 7 alarms, there's a figure of 120, does that refer to actual call outs or how was that figure 8 compiled? 9 CATHAOIRLEACH: I would say that would take the director of service for that area, but we'll 10 get you answers. 11 MR MURPHY: I think for new councillors it's an interesting document, but I do think that as 12 there is new blood into the County Council I think it's the way forward, but I do think we need to 13 know what's going on across the board and to network, and as Cllr Ryan said to see what other 14 County Councils have achieved or not achieved, where are our weaknesses. It's like the Leaving 15 Cert, you have the mock exams and the real exams, I suppose that's where we are. If we need to 16 improve, we need to revise and I think for new councillors that's what we need do as well. 17 Cllr FORTUNE: Thanks Christine for the booklet, lots of stuff in it. I think where the focus 18 needs to be is on our core values and I think while there's a statement here highlighting each of 19 the core values I think it would be helpful if we are going to have a workshop or some kind of 20 follow through on this, that we actually critique each of the core values, because it's like we were 21 talking earlier with Cllr Murphy in regards to the Barcelona agreement, if we can live the core 22 values and understand, as taking up Cllr Ryan's point, if we can understand what we're trying to 23 do as an organisation what we want to achieve that's the key there, but they have to have 24 meaning, they have to have measurement and we have to understand what we mean when we 25 write down these statements, because written down here they mean nothing. 26 Cllr BLAKE: Thanks Christine for the presentation, just to ask her in relation to the overall 27 structure of local authorities looking at the corporate plan for all of the plans for the whole 28 country, is she familiar with that aspect of it, and if they are reviewing all aspects of it coming 29 back early in the year or the back end of the year, with regards all aspects of it? You said it 30 already it is a working document and when that report does come out that we can actually come 31 back and have a look at what they say and what relevance it has for our own corporate plan. 32 MS FLOOD: Thank you Cathaoirleach. Just with regard to targets and metrics. The targets and 33 metrics are based largely on our service indicators which are figures that we have to compile 34 annually and there is -- the Department of the Environment compiles those figures nationally, so

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 41

1 it is possible to go in on the Department of the Environment website and compare Wicklow 2 County Council with others. It's also possible to look at other corporate plans, there's quite a few 3 of them there online, most at the moment are in draft format, but Wicklow's corporate plan fits in 4 very well with the requirements set out by the Department in their template. 5 6 With regard to creating additional metrics and setting targets, that's possible. Maybe at the 7 Strategic Policy Committee members might consider what metrics or targets they would like to 8 set, the corporate plan had been sent in draft format to the SPCs for consideration, we didn't get a 9 huge amount of feedback, but there is an opportunity, as Cllr Casey pointed out, it will be 10 reviewed in the context of the local economic and community plan, so there is an opportunity to 11 review these, have a workshop and consider the targets and our values and all of the other issues 12 that are actually in the corporate plan. And it might be a good time to do that towards the end of 13 the year when we're looking at it in the light of the local economic and community plan. 14 15 With regard to specifics with the N81 and public transport links I'll certainly talk to my 16 colleagues in the roads, transport and roads department to see if there is additional detail in there. 17 This is a high level plan and we'll also have annual service delivery plans which will actually 18 have more detailed information and again they are likely to have more metrics in them. 19 20 Regards to the door and window replacement programme, I have to find that out. Again it's a 21 level of detail that wouldn't be expected in the corporate plan, but I can find that information out. 22 23 With regard to the fire services false alarms, 120 is the actual figures, the number of times the 24 crew have had to leave to go out to attend to false alarms, so it is the number of false alarms. 25 26 The National Oversight and Audit Committee are actually looking at all the corporate plans and 27 there will be comparisons drawn, they may actually introduce more metrics and measurements as 28 they get up and running and look at other local authority plans, but certainly there is renewed 29 focus on metrics and measurement. I think that's it. 30 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay thanks Christine. Can I have a proposer then for the plan? Cllr 31 Timmins, seconded by Cllr Casey. Is that agreed? Okay, there will be a review towards the end 32 of the year as we say, as Christine pointed out, maybe it's no harm if special policy committees 33 had discussions on it to see what we can add or improve to the document. 34

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 42

1 Item 9, proposed? Cllr Fitzgerald. 2 Cllr FITZGERALD: Just it states in that fund there that it was increased funding because of the 3 amalgamation of the Town Councils. I am well aware that Arklow Music Festival, I don't know 4 what criteria is used so they didn't get anything -- they depended on a grant from the old Arklow 5 Town Council, 7,000 people come between competitors and visitors, which runs from next 6 Sunday to the following, for a week. I'm a bit disappointed I didn't get time, I only received that 7 on Friday, to talk to Jenny because I was away on Thursday, I'm a bit confused, what more do 8 they want? It's a music festival, we have some of the greatest musicians and contributions from 9 people in the country, it's acknowledged as the second or third biggest in the country, there will 10 be no more funding, very little funding from the municipal district coming in the future, there 11 will be none because it will all gone through the County Council, but I query why, I should have 12 mentioned before I queried it here, I didn't get a chance, but I find it strange and I rang them to 13 make sure they had made the, sent in the document and they had sent it in they tell me and they 14 haven't heard anything that I have heard of. They haven't been obviously considered, but they 15 always got funding through the Town Council. That funding was the lifeline for that group, 16 totally voluntary group. And next week, it's good for Arklow and the area as well, it's a huge 17 number of people coming into the town. I'm very surprised. I won't be supporting the document 18 until I get clarification on why they didn't get anything anyway. 19 Cllr RUTTLE: Just referring here to the six festivals listed from Bray down to Dunlavin Arts 20 Festival, ranging from top of the range of 8,500 down to Dunlavin recommended at 500 and I 21 just, that was obviously a huge imbalance and gaps in between, so I would be proposing that 22 Dunlavin Arts Festival be brought up to a grant of a thousand and the monies for that be left for 23 the direct allocation through the system. Dunlavin Arts Festival is running for about 40 years, an 24 example of huge community effort and an excellent festival involving various multidisciplinary 25 arts festival, and I think we have to do it better than 500, so I formally propose that we bring it to 26 1,000 and leave it at the discretion of the director to allocate the monies to put that extra at 27 Dunlavin, it's a festival worthy of support in the most westerly town of this county of Wicklow, 28 thank you. 29 CATHAOIRLEACH: Have I a seconder for that proposal? 30 Cllr TIMMINS: Yeah. That's what I wanted, just to back Cllr Ruttle on that proposal. That's 31 the only arts festival in the west of the county. So I'll support that. 32 Cllr BOURKE: I'd like to support Cllr Fitzgerald in his request for funding for the Arklow 33 Music Festival. It's not the first time at these meetings that myself and Cllr Kelly had 34 highlighted that there was nothing in previous budgets given to the south of the county for grants

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 43

1 for music festivals or arts festivals, I think we are getting a raw deal in the south of the county on 2 this, I did bring it up before, I obviously wasn't listened to, so I'll vote along with Cllr Fitzgerald 3 in protest. 4 Cllr VANCE: Can I just say the Bray Jazz Festival is an international festival, it has always 5 been given a grant from Bray Town Council, obviously the municipal now, I can tell you now I 6 don't mind other people supporting their own particular areas, that's fine. But as far as I'm 7 concerned no money is coming off this, because this is funding that has always been provided 8 from Bray Town Council in the Bray area, this is an internationally renowned festival and it's 9 absolutely essential for this type of money, it's the least we can put in because of the money that 10 it generates and the activity it generates in the Bray area every year. 11 Cllr ANNESLEY: I would like to second Cllr Fitzgerald. It's disgraceful that Arklow music 12 festival isn't getting any money whatsoever, they have been going since 1972 and gone from 13 strength to strength, it starts at a very early stage, with a young lad getting up and saying a poem 14 and now to be able to perform on worldwide stages. We're not trying to take any money off any 15 other groups, but I think it's absolutely disgraceful that no funding whatsoever has been given to 16 Arklow and yet again Arklow has been overlooked. I just can't sit here and vote for this, so I 17 won't vote for it either Cathaoirleach. 18 Cllr MURPHY: I'd like to echo what my other colleagues from Arklow have said. I think it's 19 such a surprise, because we all have sat here, the 32 councillors, I'm sure Arklow festival will 20 tell you themselves, it's the development of young children and it is also the dedication of the 21 schools, secondary and national and adult choirs and also the small committee of the Arklow 22 music festival and this needs to be acknowledged, I won't support it either. 23 Cllr BRADY: Just for clarification I agree totally with what Cllr Vance said in relation to Bray 24 Jazz Festival, I note in the Bray municipal district we're meeting tomorrow night there's a 25 proposal to allocate them a funding of in the region of 4,000, which would appear to be on top of 26 this, can I just ask whether Bray Jazz Festival received money on an annual basis from Wicklow 27 County Council as well as Bray Town Council? Just to clarify that there is a doubling up here? 28 CATHAOIRLEACH: Yes they have. Look we're not getting through the agenda very well. Do 29 people want to extend the meeting? I propose an extra 15 minutes. Half an hour. 30 Cllr McLOUGHLIN: I think the real problem here is not the paltry 8 and a half thousand to an 31 international festival or indeed some festivals getting nothing and some getting 500 it's an 32 absolute disgrace that Wicklow County Council are only giving 16,800. If we look at what other 33 counties around the country are giving to the arts it's an embarrassment for somebody that 34 worked in the arts sector I know, God knows what we'd get if Greystones Arts Festival was

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 44

1 going, I remember before you had the breakdown of municipal districts was getting 8 and a half 2 thousand itself, we have to really look, just because it's a soft attack and heritage is soft, in 3 Wicklow we have to remember that the festivals bring as much to our economy as anything else 4 in this county, giving a whole county 16,800 is just not good enough and it cannot sustain 5 festival industry in this county. With regards to the jazz festival in Bray, of course we need to 6 continue to manage and support the jazz festival, but the amount that the other festivals in the 7 county are getting, if you look at the amount of work Wicklow Arts Festival does, it's 8 community based and completely, relies completely on funding from the likes of us and others, 9 we're not supporting them enough and I would really beseech my fellow members when it comes 10 around to the budget next year, think about what you are all saying, you want the local festival 11 supported and we can only do that if we agree as a group to give more money to festivals and to 12 Jenny so she can support them. 13 Cllr RYAN: I want to mention maybe the Bray Jazz Festival, the fact it's called Bray makes it 14 sound like it's all about Bray, it's not, it's all about Wicklow, about Ireland, so in terms of what it 15 actually provides, from that point of view it's not a parochial thing. 16 Cllr KAVANAGH: Is it possible to get information about some of the, about all of the festivals, 17 some are in areas I don't know about, some I haven't heard of and I don't know what the festival 18 is even. It would be nice to have information about where they are and where the money is 19 going. 20 Cllr WHITMORE: I agree with Cllr Kavanagh, what's missing is who applied and who didn't 21 get funding and what the rationale for funding is? So why were certain festivals picked? That's 22 important information to have. 23 Cllr WALSH: I'm just asking the question, is it possible to amend this document now as a result 24 of what we heard in relation to the Arklow Music Festival and include them in the groups for 25 funding? 26 CATHAOIRLEACH: I'll let in Michael, but Jenny Sherwin I'm sure has gone through all the 27 applications in detail. But I'll let in Michael to make a comment. 28 >> As you say we had an adjudication panel that looked at the applications and awarded money 29 as best they saw fit. The cake is small to begin with and we try to slice it up -- Jenny tried to 30 reflect what the festivals would have got under the old regime of Town Councils as best she 31 could. But it doesn't have to be done today, if the members prefer we can leave it and put it on 32 the agenda for the April meeting and I'll get more information and give it out. That may be the 33 best thing to do. 34 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay. Jenny is on leave this week as well, so maybe that might be the

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 45

1 best. We'll defer that. 2 Cllr CASEY: Can we also find out where they got funding last year, whether it was through 3 town versus County Council, should it be in the municipal budget. 4 CATHAOIRLEACH: Some have been dual funded. Okay we'll defer that. 5 Cllr BLAKE: I know where Bray, Wicklow and Dunlavin but are who are the other three? 6 >> Alchemy music festival is in Ashford Callary in Roundwood, Compass Arts is Mermaid in 7 Bray, Outpost is Bray, High Seas is Bray, Music Together is Greystones. 8 Cllr MURPHY: Can I just say also maybe for the April meeting that we could know how many 9 people, how many groups had applied in the total? 10 CATHAOIRLEACH: Yeah thank you. We'll move on. To note monthly management report of 11 Wicklow County Council. That's been circulated. 12 13 11, note the data protection procedure policy and privacy statement that was also correspondence 14 enclosed. Christine do you want to give a brief outline on that as well. 15 MS FLOOD: Thank you Cathaoirleach. Members, you have been circulated with a suite of 16 documents in connection with our privacy statement and data protection policy. You will also 17 have received a copy of the proposed new data protection procedures. There's a number of 18 reasons for the review of the data protection procedures and documents carried out. One is there 19 has been renewed media focus on data protection, there has been a rise in data protection 20 inquiries, people asking why is this on my file, who can look at it, etcetera. Also the new 21 structures in the local authority, the smaller numbers of staff in Bray and Arklow, and then the 22 larger councillors. So we thought it was opportune, particularly with a number of new members, 23 to review the policy procedures. 24 25 Now procedures are aimed at protecting members, staff and the organisation. There have been 26 prosecutions in relation to the data protection and there have been compensation awards recently, 27 which is relatively new in the whole area of data protection. There will be training organised for 28 elected members on the 9th of March and it is proposed to roll-out the new policies, procedures, 29 during the month of March and your co-operation would be much appreciated. We did circulate 30 at Corporate Policy Group a draft request, authorisation to be signed by people making 31 representations to councillors, where privacy or data protection would kick in, and that would be 32 typically in relation to housing and planning in particular. 33 34 We're in the process, that's only just a draft, there were some issues raised at the Corporate

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 46

1 Policy Group, and no doubt when training takes place on the 9th of March the training will be 2 carried out by a solicitor who is a legal expert in the whole area of data protection, I'm sure there 3 will be other issues raised at that stage and it may be a case that we might review the request 4 form and that will be accompanied by representations made by councillors. 5 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you. So we're going to have a day here, the 9th of March that all 6 questions and clarifications can be sought. I know it has particular relevance to the Planning 7 Department, but there are probably other areas as well. So I would ask the members to try and 8 attend on the 9th if possible. 10.30. We'll confirm that. 9 Cllr FORTUNE: I have a meeting, the risk assessment. 10 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay we'll try and be flexible. 11 MS FLOOD: The data protection will be over by the time the CFRAM starts. 12 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay. They won't clash. Thanks Christine. Item number 12. To appoint 13 one elected representative to Wicklow Music Education Partnership, a subcommittee of the 14 KWETB, maybe it might be preferable to have somebody, one of the members would be willing 15 to take the position? Can I have proposals? 16 Cllr LAWLESS: I've actually been invited to go on to that already, I've been approached, I don't 17 know whether that's part of being on the actual board of the KWETB, or whether they need 18 another actual representative from the Council who is not on the actual board. Maybe that 19 should be cleared. 20 MS GALLAGHER: There is a letter from the Chief Operations Officer referring to the Terms of 21 Reference of the partnership provision, three members should be nominated from Wicklow 22 County Council, at least one of whom should be an elected representative, the remaining should 23 include an arts officer and director of County Council, so additional. 24 CATHAOIRLEACH: Can I have proposals, I know Cllr Glynn in the past had a huge interest in 25 the whole music generation and put in a quite a lot of effort into it, it was very rewarding for 26 him. Can I have proposals? 27 Cllr BOURKE: Tommy Annesley I propose. 28 Cllr ANNESLEY: Yeah I have no problem, I'll let you know, I wouldn't know much about 29 music, so as long as they don't ask me to play a keyboard or anything there will be no problem! 30 CATHAOIRLEACH: You've just been looking for money for a music festival! 31 Cllr ANNESLEY: I'm good at looking for money, but that's for the people of Arklow, not for 32 myself. No bother going on that. 33 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay. Is that agreed? Who seconded that? Cllr McLoughlin. Okay 34 that's agreed. Okay quarter to 5. We'll get an answer to Cllr Fortune's suspension, maybe Sean

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 47

1 will come up here and give clarification on that? 2 DIRECTOR QUIRKE: I think this relates to an e-mail that was sent out yesterday. The time of 3 the e-mail I think is just a matter of technology, it should have gone out earlier but didn't. But I 4 think it's worthwhile just looking at the chronology of what led to this and it probably goes back 5 to 2008 when a system for procuring bitumen was introduced, a national system called LA 6 Bitumen and it was open at that time to Councils to partake in it, the fee for joining it was 7 €10,000. Just to put it in context, bitumen is supplied by three suppliers in the country, to give 8 you an example, in 2012 the difference between the suppliers was about 0.2%, so a tonne of 9 bitumen would have been 584 and from another was 583.94, so literally nothing in it. 10 11 So at that point a decision was made not to partake, it didn't seem to be value for money, we 12 were only going through, we used all three at various stages, at the point we were only using 13 two. And they submitted their rates voluntarily for the following six months and the rates were 14 the same as LA Bitumen, so it just didn't seem to make any sense, so we continued with that. 15 16 In March 2012 a circular issued from the Department of Transport regarding road works 17 expenditure and setting out procurement requirements and so on, we continued with our 18 procurement the way we were doing it, because we felt we had comparison. In November 2012 19 the Department issued guidelines on the circular, but in the interim on the 22nd of October 2012 20 we had a spot-check, what was called a spot-check by the Department of Transport and they 21 went through our expenditure on roads, they queried about 500 items, varying in value from 10 22 euro to thousands. 23 24 And in February 2013 they wrote to us and said that they had a number of items outstanding, 25 they listed out items, March 2013 we sent in a response to the items that were raised and in June 26 2013 the Department advised us that they proposed a sanction of 69,000, and they listed out the 27 items. 28 29 So we made a further submission to them on the items that they had listed based on the fact that 30 they said that, correctly in some cases that expenditure was ineligible, but in those cases we 31 would have had, we didn't get the full value of the work of the particular job from the grant, we 32 would have had our open expenditure on top of it, so we could replace the, their ineligible 33 expenditure with our expenditure and recoup the full money. 34

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 48

1 Just to give you an example, there are minor things like for instance we had a road job in 2 Rathnew where we hired a skip to take away rubbish, hiring the skip is ineligible, now the logic 3 for somebody working on the job would be sure it's part of the job, but it's not eligible so we 4 couldn't charge. So we had to charge up something else instead that's a small item, but it's just 5 the actual definition of eligible and ineligible given that there were about 500 items was quite 6 extensive. 7 8 They did also raise queries outside of the bitumen on our hiring of plant and machinery, in a lot 9 of cases these were machines we had on hire all the time, they want to see the paper for that, in 10 some cases it was just going year to year, in the end they mitigated that in fairness to them. But 11 they imposed the sanction of 27,945 in relation to our procurement of bitumen and our 12 discretionary grant was reduced by that amount in late 2013. 13 14 So it was based on -- the circular gave the Department the option of imposing a fine of between 15 5% and 15% on ineligible expenditure, in this case they imposed a sanction on us of 15% of a 16 figure of 189,000. So I think the important thing in terms of impression of all this is that neither 17 the Council nor the Department or Exchequer was in any loss, because we got the same rate from 18 suppliers, not through our own system if you want to call it that, as signing up for LA Bitumen, 19 that has an annual cost as well for maintenance, so over that period of time we would have paid 20 20,000 to LA Bitumen for the services, but we didn't. So you could say it was a saving of 21 20,000, we didn't sign up to it anyway. 22 23 So our discretionary grant was reduced by 27,935 and that was apportioned then through the 24 areas in accordance with the amount that related to particular areas. In -- we signed up in 2014 25 for LA Bitumen, so we're getting the same prices as what we're getting through the LA Bitumen 26 system, so the matter has been dealt with. That's the background to it, I don't know Cllr Fortune 27 if it relates to the issue Cllr Cullen raised in October 2014, which was a year after that, I was at 28 the meeting, so I do recall it, he raised an issue in relation to Structural Funds issued by the 29 Department of the Environment, and to be perfectly honest with you I didn't relate these because 30 these aren't Structural Funds and they weren't from the Department of Environment, they were 31 roads funds from the government and issued by Department of Transport through NRA. So if I 32 didn't pick up on it, that's my fault obviously, but I just didn't relate two items, it was the wrong 33 department and wrong name. So I didn't relate those two items. 34 Cllr FORTUNE: Well I suppose I hear what the director is saying, this goes back to 2008 in

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 49

1 roads, so it begs the question why. And there's a kind of philosophy in life that when someone 2 tells you something and you hear it you can't be untold it. How I became aware of this was 3 getting back to the famous recent AGM when I objected to the way that was constructed, 4 subsequently wrote and I would have copied the manager and Mr Murphy and several people, so 5 you're aware of what I wrote. I was unhappy with several aspects of it, I also wrote to the 6 Department which culminated in me having a meeting in the Department to air my grievance, no 7 I didn't, to be honest have great confidence in anything that would happen, but on principle I was 8 very annoyed over the way, it's a matter of public record, I'm not saying anything I hadn't said. 9 In the course of the meeting there was a comment made to us by a senior official, and the, that 10 remark was subsequently raised here in the chamber and it was just, this is my language, I think, 11 it was fobbed off basically, I hear what you are saying that you didn't relate the two points, but I 12 would say there's a question as to why, why the Department felt the need to query, why they 13 followed it through, why they threatened to suspend funding, why they did put a charge on us, is 14 there any possibility that the bitumen that we were procuring back then was the right product, the 15 right specification, is there any implication for health and safety? If you don't know the facts 16 and it's not explained it does beg those kind of questions. And I would say, I totally respect you 17 Mr Quirke, I just think -- it's a bit disingenuous to say that the question Cllr Cullen did ask that 18 day wasn't answered, it was kind of, it was like as if he asked the question, but didn't ask the 19 question in the right way, therefore the question didn't have to be answered. It's a bit like that. 20 21 So I just think it's very serious that the Department would take an action like this, and they 22 actually did say that in any future expenditure that, it's in the letter we got, may result in the 23 Council's grants being reduced or held up. That's a very serious thing. How the Department 24 would do that and why they would do that or feel the need to do it, equally it raises the question 25 from a professional perspective why the local authority would put themselves in that position, 26 why they wouldn't follow procurement procedures? That's why, not to get on too much of a 27 tangent why the country's in the state it's in, people didn't follow regulations or do things the way 28 they should be done, so it smacks -- I think my problem with the response is that, why? Why did 29 this happen, why did the Department have to do what they did, why they followed it through 30 such a long time, I just think it smacks. 31 32 As I say, I heard that in the circumstances I have just described, so therefore it wasn't something 33 light. It was something very serious and it came across as being a very, very serious issue. I 34 must say I struggle in trying to accept fully that when the question was asked in October that it

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 50

1 couldn't have been answered. 2 Cllr WINTERS: Thanks Mr Quirke for your clarification. But it's awful that we're sitting here 3 as 32 elected representatives and it's because a newspaper found out about it that we find out 4 about it. If we've done something wrong there's loads of subcommittees, there's a Corporate 5 Policy Group and lots and lots of ways without coming into this meeting and telling the 6 councillors look unfortunately we've lost 27,000 of our road grant this year because we didn't 7 follow public procurement procedures, so we can't do that amount of resurfacing because we 8 have to spend it on a fine, without us having to wait 18 months and hear it from a journalist, 9 that's what's ultimately wrong with this. Anybody can make a mistake, but every mistake that's 10 made here, unless somebody investigates it and brings it into a big issue, there's no transparency, 11 never anybody holding their hand up saying they made a mistake. 12 13 You said over the start of March 2008, a circular was issued in March 2012, so it's only over six 14 months, 27,000 in six months is a lot of money, we could have done that road resurfacing 15 somewhere else and I want to know how the Audit Committee were never informed, surely if 16 27,000 is a reasonable expenditure to advise the Audit Committee on, which is out of the norm 17 or out of the ordinary, but when the Audit Committee sit down and say to the staff did anything 18 unusual happen this year? That that's not a usual occurrence, unless you are telling us it is a 19 usual occurrence and there's lots more that we're waiting for investigative journalists to find out 20 about, I'm disgusted how we found out about it, if we make mistakes fine, but tell us about them 21 and let us move on. 22 Cllr KAVANAGH: I wasn't here at the time all this happened and I do feel questions need to be 23 asked about it, one of the questions I would have and Cllr Winters referred to it, did this 24 reduction in funding or the loss of whatever was available, did it come up in discussions with the 25 Council and did the Finance Officer discuss this with the members of the Council? You said it 26 was apportioned throughout various areas, was that something slipped through or was it 27 highlighted to this Council? Because I would be concerned having gone through the budgetary 28 process at the end of the year that these things slip under the radar and they are not brought by 29 the Finance Officer when the budget is being discussed, and again as Cllr Winters said, that the 30 auditor wouldn't have referred to it. That's where it should be brought to our attention, where 31 money is in or out, gained or lost or whatever, it needs to be brought to our attention. Thank 32 you. 33 Cllr MITCHELL: I think the deficiencies which occurred were minor, it seemed we saved 34 20,000 on not subscribing to this website and the fine cost 27,000 and there was a second issue

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 51

1 of a mis-allocation of expenses from one heading to another, I don't think there's any question of 2 significant irregularity. But I do think that where there are issues like this it should in some way 3 be mentioned to the Audit Committee. I don't think it was, so that there is somebody who was 4 aware at least of these relatively minor book-keeping issues and small fine issues in what's a 5 very large amount of expenditure here, we're always going to get such things, but I think 6 certainly in private business there are audit letters from the auditors, which detail to the 7 management and the directors of companies, what the auditors see asphalts in book-keeping or 8 activities which are minor and don't need any action usually, but are at least listed and up for 9 consideration. I think it would be better if somehow that happened here. Thank you. 10 Cllr VANCE: Just for clarification, do I have it right by saying the Department wanted us to join 11 a scheme at 10,000 each year, we didn't do it for two years and the bitumen was at the same 12 price. So it beggar's belief with me that the Department were actually, would have been ordering 13 the Council to pay 10,000 a year more for bitumen. It just doesn't go with what I'm thinking, 14 you join a scheme for 10,000 I would imagine that the bitumen should have been cheaper than 15 you get on the open market. I just want clarification of that, is that exactly the case? That in fact 16 by us not joining for two years we actually saved 20,000 because the bitumen was exactly the 17 same price, that's one thing. 18 19 Could I ask that when we did join in 2014 we had to pay 10,000 as well again, would that be 20 correct and is the bitumen still at the same price? I would have imagined that you're getting into 21 a buying scheme that you're going to pay 10,000 up front that you would get it a lot cheaper, 22 where there's a massive amount being bought, so it just doesn't make sense to me that we save 23 20,000, and because we didn't go down this route that the Department are actually punishing the 24 Council by putting a fine on them of 27,000, it doesn't make sense. Could I just ask for 25 clarification that's how I understand it. 26 Cllr CASEY: I'll be fairly brief. I spoke this morning at the Corporate Policy meeting, I said I 27 was very disappointed how we find out about this, not necessarily the figure of 27,000 it's the 28 process of how we were informed about it, through the press, was disappointing. I just want to 29 put it on record that the Audit Committee were not aware of this either, it was never brought to 30 the attention of the Audit Committee and the Audit Committee is always trying to ensure that we 31 claim down off the Department, that we don't leave any funding behind us there, we have always 32 been focused on making sure each department is claiming off the Department on time and we're 33 drawing down the appropriate funds. I just feel this is disappointing how the process that was 34 involved that we had to find it out from a local paper today, rather than being informed about it

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 52

1 at the time and as Cllr Winters said there is several procedures we could have gone through, we 2 could have brought it to Audit Committee, to CPG, there were various ways to head it off, it's 3 not the 27,000, it's the process that's involved or lack of information that I'm disappointed in. 4 Cllr RYAN: I too am very uncomfortable with this, it begs the question as to whether or not 5 there is other fines that the Council has been given that we don't know about, that's number one. 6 I'd like to know that the process is now changed so that the Audit Committee will actually be 7 notified of any fines that go forward into the future because we can't change this now. But at 8 least from here on in that we try to bring a bit more transparency to the process. I'd also like to 9 know whether or not spot-checks were done on all Councils in Ireland and whether or not other 10 Councils had similar issues raised with them? I think that's information we don't have right now, 11 I think it's information that the Department of Environment should actually proffer and it's only 12 right -- I'm still confused as to how this information came out, whether it was in a meeting with 13 Cllr Fortune that an official happened to say it and it was seen as Structural Funds and it came 14 up, because I remember that meeting here in Wicklow County Council where Cllr Cullen was 15 saying about Structural Funds; I hadn't a clue what he was on about, I don't think many other 16 people had an idea either. I think if councillors have information they should be clear about it 17 and say it and not try and allude to certain things, just if you have something come forward and 18 say it and let us all try and make sure we're running a Council that's open and honest. So I would 19 be interested in that, if there is other Councils around Ireland also done spot-checks. Like Cllr 20 Vance, it seems bizarre you have to pay 10,000 to join a website that gives no efficiency, I'd love 21 someone to explain that and what the Department are at because those procurement rules seem 22 crazy. 23 Cllr BOURKE: Further to my colleague Cllr Ryan's suggestions, I'd like to ask is there -- is it 24 possible that there is a cartel in operation, if so would you not be suspicious that if there was a 25 cartel that we should have it investigated by the Competition Authority so we're getting proper 26 value for money. 27 CATHAOIRLEACH: As the director said there are only three in the country. 28 Cllr BOURKE: There's only three meat factories too. 29 Cllr RUTTLE: Like Cllr Vance there, I'd like to know about this, this 10,000 seems like a rip off 30 to me. A fine that you have to pay in to them, never mind any fine we might incur, normally 31 things like that should be to your benefit, but instead they are dragging you down in the 32 beginning, it's hard to see how this 10,000 is justified at all, I'd like clarification how that works. 33 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thanks councillor. I agree with you and Cllr Vance and Cllr Ryan's 34 sentiments, but I would be very disappointed that this was not flagged to the elected members

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 53

1 earlier, and the official will have to take that on the chin. Okay I'll let you back in Sean. 2 DIRECTOR QUIRKE: Just to deal with the items. I suppose at the time we considered that 3 however lose, we had a system, that we were getting prices in advance, the Department didn't 4 agree with that and what can I say. They are right in the end, we didn't have a strong enough 5 system, but we weren't losing any money, we're still getting the same price today as we were 6 before we joined LA quotes. The 10,000 back in 2008 I think consisted of some set-up costs for 7 LA Bitumen and subsequently it was 2,000 per annum, so we had 10,000 in 2008 and five 8 consecutive years where we weren't in it at 2,000 per annum, the ongoing cost of 2,000 per 9 annum, at least, it may well go up, but there is a system there now, so every load we got would 10 have a reference from LA Bitumen. It's the same price, but there is an audit trail and anyone that 11 has been audited knows the audit trail is important. You have to be able to show you went 12 through the system. We were getting the same value when bitumen suppliers sent in their prices, 13 their e-mail would say these are the same rates as are up on the website of LA Bitumen, so ... 14 15 In relation to other finds, no, that was a spot-check we had, it was comprehensive, about 500 16 queries at the end of it. There are no other fines in roads, that's all I can tell you. 17 18 Other Councils I'm not sure, I asked the question at the time and I was told that some other 19 Councils were being looked at as well, but I couldn't ever get to the bottom of it. 20 Cllr WINTERS: Are they only ones that hadn't registered with LA Bitumen 21 Cllr RYAN: It's LA Quotes. 22 DIRECTOR QUIRKE: There's an LA Quotes and LA Bitumen. Etcetera 10 grand to join LA 23 Bitumen in 2008 and it's 2,000 a year now. So we're paying 2,000 a year every year to get their 24 product. 25 Cllr VANCE: At the same price? 26 DIRECTOR QUIRKE: From the same people, product is the same specification, there isn't any 27 -- it's the same specification for the whole country. In fact it's probably, because there are only 28 three suppliers, if you were to go on price and everybody went to the one supplier they wouldn't 29 be able to supply everybody because everybody is being looking at one time, it did happen 30 previously, there was queuing at a suppliers to try and get loads of bitumen because they were 31 the lowest price, so lowest price isn't; and bringing it down to one supplier isn't necessarily the 32 best. 33 34 In relation to the Audit Committee. I accept that we didn't notify the Audit Committee. The

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 54

1 Department identified a weakness in our system and we dealt with it. So the Audit Committee, 2 they could have looked at what we did I suppose, but we accepted the criticism the Department 3 levelled at us and the sanction they imposed and we fixed it, we signed up for 2 grand a year to 4 LA Bitumen. 5 6 It came out of our discretionary grants, it goes up and down every year, and we just do more or 7 less maintenance depending on what we have, so it wouldn't have had an impact on say surfacing 8 or improvement works, it would have some impact on minor maintenance works in the areas. 9 10 I can only say again in relation to the item raised in October 2014, it was two years after the 11 audit took place and at least a year after the letter from the Department advising us that they 12 were going to reduce our grant, so I didn't associate the two together. It was completely out of 13 my head, maybe I should have been cleverer than that but I wasn't. I have to say there's logic in 14 the decision made. 15 Cllr FORTUNE: You basically inherited it and had to deal with it. 16 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay thanks, we're going to move on to item number 13. As you all 17 know at this stage Mr Eddie Sheehy has announced his retirement on the 7th of April. He's 18 given 42 years service to the public service, 14 of which was as County Manager here in County 19 Wicklow. From my own point of view my dealings with him, he has always been courteous and 20 supportive and very professional in his dealings. I suppose I only got a real look into what he 21 does since I came Chairman, the day-to-day dealings with him as a councillor wouldn't be much, 22 generally speaking. But I'd like to thank him for his courtesy and professionalism he showed to 23 me. I know that there's been ups and downs, good days and bad days, that's the nature of the job. 24 But certainly Mary has a long list of things to do at home I know and it's growing by the day, 25 and I just would wish you a happy and healthy retirement and thank you on behalf of myself and 26 indeed the group that I'm in, for the time and professionalism you've shown. 27 Cllr RYAN: Just on behalf of the Fine Gael group, obviously 14 years is a long time to spend in 28 any one job, as you correctly say it's been an interesting 14 years with some highs and quite a lot 29 of lows, and particularly difficult issues to deal with. I think none more so than the death of the 30 firemen in Bray, which was obviously for everybody involved in this Council an extremely 31 difficult time. 32 33 I think since coming into the role 14 years ago, I know you, Cllr Fortune mentioned about 34 inheriting problems, and you inherited a number of issues and from people closer to it at the time

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 55

1 they tell me that you might have chosen to ignore some of those or deal with them in a different 2 way, but you tend to try to deal with things in the best way possible that you see and that's head 3 on. 4 5 I think some of those difficult issues that have been dealt with over those years have maybe over 6 shadowed an awful lot of good things happening in this Council over those 14 years. I 7 remember standing in the floods in 1986 in Bray on the Dargle, to think it took till now to get a 8 flood defence scheme into Bray to protect the lives and homes of people, it's wrong it took that 9 long, but it's one of the things that Council along with Bray Town Council and the lobbying of a 10 lot of people to try and get funds necessary from OPW to actually make that happen, it's one of 11 the best things that have happened in the Council in the 14 years. 12 13 I also think in terms of the Florentine Centre in Bray, it's a huge thing, we know towns all over 14 Ireland and particularly all over Wicklow have been affected by the downturn in the economy, 15 but also the internet and the like, changing patterns in retail where people want to go to singular 16 places pretty closed in from the weather so they can actually do their, get retail therapy and for 17 the future Bray, the site is critically important, the developers had actually bought it up and left 18 the town fairly derelict and hugely affected negatively. But obviously the Council, Bray and 19 Wicklow supported the purchase of that, that is the future of Bray. 20 21 Greystones Harbour, again and particularly Andrew Doyle asked me to mention the purchase of 22 Clermont, which was something that was really, really important and very progressive and 23 innovative and took a chance in making it happen, but I think people in time to come will look 24 back at the decision. 25 26 On a personal level, just in terms of what I've experienced with your support for the economic 27 think tank, both in Bray and most recent the Wicklow County Council economic think tank, has 28 been fantastic and nothing but support. 29 30 On a personal level every time I've dealt with you I've seen you as being up front, you haven't 31 always given me the answer I want, but that's okay. That's allowed. But what you've given me 32 is respect, hopefully you've got that back from myself and the Fine Gael group here. 33 34 While all the decisions that you have made I haven't altogether agreed with all of them, but I

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 56

1 think you have done them for the absolute right reasons, so on behalf of the Fine Gael group, I 2 do hope you enjoy your retirement and you're a young man, you have a lot more to give, so 3 please God you'll find another role and all our best to your family who have been obviously 4 taking a little bit of the brunt of the times you have experienced in the job. Good luck in the 5 future. 6 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you. I know a lot of the members spoke earlier at the Corporate 7 Policy Group meeting. So once again thanks Eddie. And this is your last meeting. 8 Cllr BRADY: Firstly I want to acknowledge the County Manager is retiring after 14 years and 9 I'm not going to repeat, read from items that were listed on a prepared statement a private PR 10 company or anything like that. I think whilst there has been some welcome improvements in the 11 county over the last five years, I think there is unfortunately been more lows in the county and I 12 think under his stewardship that the Council has been brought into disrepute on many occasions. 13 14 I personally call for an inquiry into the 14 years. But I think for me, the single biggest item that 15 needs to be brought to the fore here today, and the lowest of the lows that this Council over those 16 14 years had to deal with, was the deaths of two members of staff within this Council. 17 18 That in itself would have been a very, very difficult thing to do. But the fact that as part of the 19 subsequent investigations not only was this county building raided as part of the investigation, 20 not only was the manager, or CEO as he is now, arrested as part of that investigation, and not 21 only is there well over a thousand questions still remained unanswered as part of that 22 investigation, I think the final kick to the bereaved families of the two fire fighters came last 23 week by the County Manager during his interview on East Coast Radio, which happened to 24 coincide with the 8th anniversary or 8th birthday of one of the fire fighters away from home. So 25 his remarks were very, very hurtful on East Coast Radio, as well as being totally untrue. 26 27 As someone who sat in on both the Coroner's Court and in the Central Criminal Court and 28 listening to the evidence in both cases, I find it astonishing that Eddie Sheehy would find it upon 29 himself to give his own narrative of events and not the events which were heard in evidence, and 30 certainly not events that were returned in the narrative verdict in the Coroner's Court. 31 32 The County Manager stated that he will never know or we don't know why these two fire 33 fighters entered the building in Adelaide Villas. If he was listening to the evidence and the 34 evidence given by the station officer on the day, Jim Maguire, clearly states he told the two fire

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 57

1 fighters to enter the building and be on the second door, so they could engage with the fire. But 2 the County Manager totally disregards that. He states they were told to stand outside the 3 building, a total and utter blatant lie. And mis-truth was given on East Coast Radio. He says he 4 doesn't know what was going through their heads when they entered the door? Maybe it was the 5 fact that on request -- to make pumps two and three available, maybe that was going through 6 their heads as to why pumps two and three didn't show up to help fight the fire. Or maybe the 7 fact that they didn't have the proper CAFS training, maybe that's what was going through their 8 heads when they entered the fire, maybe it was the fact that they were carrying out orders, as 9 were given to them, as to why they entered into the building, so I think for the fact that the 10 County Manager came out and told total untruths, not only in relation to what happened on the 11 day of the fire, but also the fact that in the Coroner's Court, the following factors were given as 12 contributory factors to the deaths of the two firemen. 13 14 One was watch room equipment, the second was pre-determined attendances and third was 15 CAFS, there was no mention whatsoever of the guys entering the building, or not. These were 16 the contributing factors that were returned in a narrative verdict, before the coroner, with a jury, 17 and that's what verdict was returned. 18 19 I have previously asked, called on Eddie Sheehy to issue an apology to the families for the 20 deaths as he, and I outlined all of this previously, he has sole responsibility. He was the guy at 21 the top. Sole responsibility for the fire service and the operation of the fire service. So I think 22 it's high time now, as I believe this is his final council meeting, that he issues an apology to the 23 families now for the deaths of their loved ones and also issues an apology for the hurtful remarks 24 he made on East Coast Radio last week, those should be his departing words from these 25 chambers here today, an apology to the families for the hurt he has inflicted upon them. Thank 26 you Chairman. 27 Cllr VANCE: On behalf of the Fianna Fail group I wish to acknowledge Eddie Sheehy's work 28 for 42 years in the local authority system. I suppose like all County Managers that he started off 29 at the very bottom and done an awful lot of jobs that are necessary to get to the position and it's a 30 great achievement for anyone to start at the bottom and rise up to be a County Manager. 31 Certainly somebody that worked for 42 years in that particular system I think deserves retirement 32 and certainly everything that goes with that. I think it's fair to say most people around here 33 wouldn't realise this, but for the first few years of Eddie's tenure here it was challenging in 34 regard to myself and Eddie to say the least, we had a few run-ins in regard to certain items we

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 58

1 didn't see eye to eye on. But I think as the years went on there was a mutual respect there, 2 certainly where I didn't agree with some of the ideas that Eddie had, I'm sure he didn't agree with 3 a lot of mine, because as a councillor you always want to do things and to do things cost money, 4 and the problem is there's never enough money for everything that any councillor wants to do 5 and any councillor that has ambition at all wants to do that for his community, so there's always 6 that type of barrier between the officials and the Council as well. 7 8 But I seen it first hand, the effort that he put in, particularly in Greystones, in regard to 9 development of Greystones, I said it many times, he stuck in when the developer up there 10 wanted to hand over the green field site of 20 acres not developed and he stuck to his guns and 11 got the most fantastic sports development up there, with all-weather running track, all-weather 12 surfaces up there, sports field that anyone would be proud of, when effectively he could have 13 walked away and left a 20 acre field and certainly the development of the sports facilities in 14 Greystones, there's not a community in the country that have the type of development that's put 15 and the money put into that particular area, that includes Greystones Harbour, some people are 16 still not happy about it, but I can tell you I regularly used to walk from Bray along the cliff walk 17 there, you actually had to walk through a dump to get to a derelict harbour, when you go and see 18 what's there at the moment, it's a tremendous advancement on what had been there previously. 19 20 In regard to the Florentine Centre as well, I was happy that the Council went in and brought it at 21 probably the most unbelievable value in the country 1.95 million for a site that took 24 million to 22 accumulate, and particularly three houses that are probably worth when done up they would be 23 worth the 1.9 million, that's the best bit of business since I was on the Council that has been 24 done. Hopefully we'll get some development there, I've no doubt that we will as well. Finally 25 the Dargle Protection Scheme got great support from the manager, some people were actually 26 trying to stop it going ahead, I remember going to England to see it. We had councillor there 27 that actually brought a consultant with him to try and stop that river protection scheme going 28 ahead, needless to say that councillor is now on board and claiming credit for it. 29 30 Finally on behalf of the Fianna Fail group, I'd like to say, to wish Eddie Sheehy a long and happy 31 retirement, I think he deserves it, he put in time, the hours and particularly at this particular time 32 I'd like to recognise the support that he got from his wife and his family as well. I think we as 33 public reps and officials, it's impossible to do the type of job we do without the support of our 34 families and the families are the most important part for us. Unless we get the support they give

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 59

1 us we would not carry out the job we do, so I'd like to wish them a very happy retirement as 2 well. Thank you Chairman. 3 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you. 4 Cllr FORTUNE: I have to say in my time in the Council I have to say I have been disappointed 5 with the way the county has developed and evolved, if you put it in football parlance we're still 6 in division 4. I don't like the way things were done, I have had a number of issues, I made a very 7 hard decision on a number of occasions to vote no confidence, I didn't do that lightly, I did it 8 based on what I observed, what I seen, it's a matter of public record, but of course as a councillor 9 I ended up paying for that, because there was a vindictiveness that came across that, where 10 eventually it accumulated in being basically cut out of everything, it's all orchestrated I 11 mentioned it earlier, I'm still not, still there and I classified it at the time as organisational 12 corruption and I believe that. 13 14 I think that this county should be a lot more advanced than it is. I think we have a fantastic 15 county. I think there are so much opportunities to in fact have full employment in this county if 16 it was properly run. I think the local authority has a very serious responsibility, the person that 17 runs it is basically responsible for the whole county, I would have to say that reflecting on it, I 18 would say that it wasn't a great job. Mr Sheehy will be fine, he is retiring, he'll move on, do very 19 well out of that, he could end up in Irish Water, God knows where, he won't mind what I'm 20 saying, but I just can't be dishonest. 21 22 I have to say I haven't found the local authority, the way it's been operated and run, there's a lack 23 of transparency, we talked about it earlier, a simple thing we were talking about earlier we 24 weren't even told. The auditors come in every year, sit up there, read from a script, no mention 25 of that, those kind of things shouldn't happen. I just don't think Wicklow is being looked after 26 well at all. I'm not going to get into the fire end of it, because Cllr Brady mentioned that, but I 27 did hear the interview on East Coast Radio last week, I have to say I was very, very disappointed 28 and I was very surprised at the comment that was passed in relation to the two firemen. 29 30 Also even at that stage, at retiring, and talking about councillors Mr Sheehy wasn't capable of 31 saying every councillor are good councillors, he had to say most councillors are good 32 councillors, the reference being some councillors are not good councillors. Because if some 33 councillor stands up and says the emperor has no clothes occasionally, therefore you are a 34 Maverick, you're against the system, then the inner sanctum that I talked about for years rows in

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 60

1 behind and makes sure it's supported. I saw it first hand at the recent AGM, that's what 2 happened, it's going on today here too when we were discussing the Department. 3 4 So really Mr Sheehy will move on, he'll do fine. I would hope that whoever comes in to run the 5 Council or whoever runs the Council moving forward will have a totally different approach, will 6 get in behind things, make things happen and make the county what it should be. Because that's 7 what we want. We should, as I said earlier, I said it before, this county could be wonderful, this 8 county could have full employment. People in jobs that run local authorities, they are serious 9 roles, very well remunerated, so there has to be a kind of a reference back to how it works. I just 10 think my experience has been that it could have been a lot better, but I wish you well, but I don't 11 believe as an individual you were very fair with me. And I don't mind saying that to your face, 12 I've said it to your face before, you've heard me say it in public, that's about it. 13 14 I wouldn't say it's been a great 15 years at all, lots of issues need to be looked at, we need to look 15 at the corporate governance of this organisation, it needs to be looked at, how things are going, 16 there are great people in this organisation, great people, but they need to be led. There are great 17 people here, but they need to be led. I don't think there's great leadership. 18 CATHAOIRLEACH: Thank you. Cllr Ruttle. Can I ask the remaining speakers to be brief if 19 they can? 20 Cllr RUTTLE: Just I would like to wish Eddie the very best in retirement, obviously 14 years 21 when he was manager here and I always found him to be most helpful, supportive and 22 co-operative in any project I was involved in, he was never behind coming over to west Wicklow 23 seeing what's going on and being there. There are a number of things he was very supportive of 24 like getting a proper water supply into Blessington, which was a huge issue at the time and 25 hopefully will become the seminal point of a scheme in that area, again at a time when negative 26 forces were at the time -- the Blessington greenway, the Council took on the lead role in that, 27 while the director was there Eddie was very much the man pushing behind the scenes. Also 28 issues like Dunlavin playground and state-of-the-art, again he was behind that. Great support 29 and acknowledge and attendance at things like Hollywood Fair, which is a great event to west 30 Wicklow. 31 32 On a broader scope as vice-chairman of KWETB, the drive and initiative to purchase Clermont 33 and move forward with that was a lot of vision going forward in our education field, because we 34 were one of the places that had not got such an institution at all, there was an opportunity, there

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 61

1 were other options at the time, but he grasped that strongly and went forward, that will always be 2 there to prosper and develop. Other things as well, but it's a difficult job, not easy to do it, to be 3 County Manager or CEO, but Eddie was a man -- you are a man of energy and commitment and 4 not afraid to keep going and when you had to do it, to stand up to negative forces that you 5 encountered on certain occasions and issues. 6 7 I wish you well in your future time to Mary, Jane and Robbie, a long and happy life ahead, I'm 8 sure you'll find many fields of endeavour to put in energy, determination and commitment that 9 you have. 10 Cllr BOURKE: I arrived here at the same time as Mr Sheehy. During that time I have seen 11 plenty of ups and downs, I have had the honour of being taken to the High Court by Mr Sheehy, 12 thankfully forgiven and forgotten at this stage, but we've been through a lot and I have seen that 13 the decisions he has taken are always in the best interests of doing the job right, always in the 14 interest of rightness, it mightn't always be fairest, but it was always to do the job right. By the 15 book, I have always noted from talking to other people about Eddie Sheehy he does everything 16 by the book, you get no favours from him, unless it's by the book. If you are entitled to 17 something you'll get it, if it's allowed it will be done. 18 19 There was no strokes with the County Manager, he was very upright I thought in the way he 20 made decisions and implemented them. You mightn't have liked it but you don't always get 21 what you want and everybody got the same treatment no matter who they were. I never saw an 22 inner sanctum operated in the Council. So I'd like to wish him well in his retirement and his 23 wife and family as well. 24 25 I think the tragedy of the fire in Bray certainly has pained him and his family greatly as well, it's 26 no benefit to anybody. It's an awful tragedy for the families that it's continuously revisited and 27 reminded of the loss must be difficult to bring closure on it. It's something that nobody seems to 28 be prepared to let go. At some stage it has to be let go. 29 Cllr MITCHELL: Thank you Cathaoirleach. I'd just say as a person on the Council for 17 years 30 or so, much of the time Eddie has been manager, I'd like to wish him well in retirement. 31 Obviously all of us have differences with different councillors and managers and everybody else, 32 I wouldn't agree with everything that happened, I'd like to say there are quite a number of things 33 particularly in relation to the area I represent in Greystones, which have been difficult to do and 34 very important for the town, particularly as was mentioned in Greystones Harbour, it will be

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 62

1 completed and will be something for the next 100 years where it was wrecked for the last 100 2 years. For instance PPPs done by Dublin City Council who is much better resourced than this 3 Council, has many PPPs that aren't going to be completed and this complex one is going to be 4 completed. 5 6 In addition we have a number of excellent sports facilities to cater for the growth of the town and 7 much of this, both harbour and sports facilities have been paid for by developers, not taxpayers 8 of Ireland, this has made it more complex and sometimes lost, once people use the facilities 9 nobody cares where it came from, but to get them built in the first place was complex, I'd like to 10 thank him on behalf of the people of Greystones. Thank you. 11 Cllr KAVANAGH: I'd like to add that I regret to hear that the CEO will be retiring on a 12 lucrative pension, never having faced an interim disciplinary process for his role in the criminal 13 negligence case which saw the loss of the fire fighters lives and also resulted in fines of half a 14 million euro to this Council which otherwise would have been spent on local services. I concur 15 with Cllr Brady that I think the CEO should apologise to those families before he leaves, he 16 might also want to consider forfeiting some or all of his severance pay to cover the legal 17 expenses incurred to this Council. 18 19 On more than one occasion the CEO brought the county into disrepute and attracted negative 20 attention and I have long been concerned about the impact on this about the loss of inward 21 investment, so hopefully his departure will mean a clean sweep for Wicklow. 22 Cllr SNELL: Thank you, again 42 years is a huge period of time to give to local government, I 23 myself worked for 23 years in a factory in the county here, 70 jobs were lost through decisions 24 by this Council and members of the Council. I still work with officials, I work with elected 25 members who I believe were in the opposition corner to me at that period of time. 26 27 People ask how would you describe being a councillor? I feel like it's a boxing match. When 28 you come in here there's a lot of verbals, a lot of trash talk, sparring, shadow boxing, then you 29 get in and you can test and you have your sporting contest. Some people look at the chief 30 executive as a referee, or look at him as an opponent, irrespective, I believe when the battle is 31 over, that you have to take the gloves off, you say well done, you shake hands and you move on. 32 The greatest of the whole lot in my opinion was Mohammad Ali who had the good courtesy to 33 know when the fight was over. 34

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 63

1 On this occasion I wish Eddie Sheehy, his wife and his children all the best going forward, I'm 2 never afraid to take on any battle with anybody on any issue and I certainly from here on will 3 still stand toe to toe with anybody, but I think you have to realise when the fight is over. Thanks 4 Cathaoirleach. 5 Cllr BEHAN: I'd like to join with Cllr Snell and the majority of members of the Council in 6 wishing Eddie Sheehy a long, happy and healthy retirement and to his wife and children as well. 7 As Cllr Snell said 42 years of public service is a very long time, it is a lifetime and public 8 servants very often, particularly in the last five years came in for a lot of criticism from media 9 and people in private business and very unfairly, I think public service is something that's very 10 much to be desired in people and a person of Eddie Sheehy's undoubted ability could have been 11 extremely successful in the private sector, he chose to work in the public sector and I'm quite 12 sure he gave an enormous amount of service to all people in all of the areas in which he served. 13 I just want to thank him for the service he gave people in this county. 14 15 I, like all of us, have had our disagreements, maybe some of us a bit more than others, I think it 16 arises from the fact that the County Manager and the executive have one particular role in a local 17 authority and public representatives have another and I don't think we would be doing our jobs 18 properly if we weren't disagreeing and arguing, if every time an issue came up the manager 19 agreed with the members or members agreed with the manager I don't the system would 20 function, while a lot of very hard comments have been made here today and each member is 21 entitled to make them, I am quite sure Mr Sheehy is more than capable of answering them, 22 whether he takes the opportunity today or not is a matter for him. 23 24 But I would like to honestly wish him a long happy retirement and thank you for the work you 25 have done for the people of this county. 26 Cllr O'NEILL: Again I have only just been a councillor for a couple of months here and like Cllr 27 Snell, when the fight is over the fight is over. I know that there's been a lot of controversy over 28 the years and I was approached by a paper during the week and asked would I draw conclusions 29 on the County Manager, who I wish the best of luck himself, I hope he has a long and healthy 30 retirement. But I did point out I have been looking in the door here for a long time, 29 years for 31 me to get over the line. But the controversy, long before Eddie Sheehy came to town, there was 32 huge stuff in the west and in this chamber here. I have been calling for, if there is any inquiries 33 of any description I'd appeal to everyone to listen to this, if there has been wrongdoings in the 34 chamber, I know councillors are, don't have a clean hand in this, go back 20 years ago, 25 year

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 64

1 ago we had a situation where a councillor as Chairman of Wicklow County Council sold himself 2 and neighbour some land. 3 4 So if there's going to be an inquiry there's load of stuff. There's been deaths in the county, sadly 5 in the fire station, we had deaths in the west, I won't go into them now, but fellow councillors in 6 west Wicklow will know what I'm talking about. So maybe there was a lot more to it. I would 7 sincerely like to see if there is any inquiries of any description, as I said to the news print, if we 8 go back 30 years I'd be interested in looking at the whole show, long before Eddie Sheehy came 9 around these parts at all. 10 11 There's been hurtful things done in the west Wicklow, we had dumps, illegal dumps, all sort of 12 stuff for a long time. So if there is any further inquiries or anything, so it's the people of Ireland, 13 the people of Ireland will suffer in this, the ordinary people I'm here to represent and the 14 ordinary people of west Wicklow have suffered in connection with decisions by councillors in 15 here as well as maybe officials or whatever. So I'd look to see us moving on here and I do wish 16 Eddie Sheehy, in the six months I've known of him, he has been very courteous in helping me, 17 but I do suggest that we're, again I'd like to say that if there's any inquiries of any description that 18 every councillor in the chamber over the years should answer these serious questions. 19 20 We're talking about in a year's time commemorating men and women of 1916, we have to be fair 21 to everyone right across the board, so thank you. 22 Cllr WINTERS: Thanks Cathaoirleach, this is just an aside because this isn't the time for it, Cllr 23 O'Neill made a very serious accusation I don't want to revisit it at this time now, but certainly at 24 next month's meeting I'd look for further information, but on the matter that we are discussing... 25 Cllr O'NEILL: I'm saying that there was land sold in this chamber here to a Chairman of 26 Wicklow County Council and decided by the members in here that he would be sold the acre of 27 land. 28 Cllr WINTERS: Are you prepared to say which Chairman it was? If it was 25 years ago I 29 wasn't a member of the Council. 30 Cllr O'NEILL: I'm not saying you were. It did happen, on the 1st of April 1996, Chairman of 31 Wicklow County Council got an acre of land with the help of his comrades here in the Council. 32 Cllr WINTERS: I'd like to wish the County Manager all the best in his retirement to him, his 33 wife and children and say nobody's perfect, I'm sure there's things he regrets, but you have to 34 look at the totality of what's been achieved and there have been some good things achieved in the

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 65

1 Council, I think it would be important for the county that we have a positive outlook on as many 2 things as possible, I do wish him a happy, long and healthy retirement. Thank you. 3 CATHAOIRLEACH: Last speaker, thanks everybody for their indulgence we want to let 4 everybody speak. Cllr Thornhill. 5 Cllr THORNHILL: May I, on my own behalf, wish Mr Sheehy, his family the best of luck for 6 the future, I as a newly elected representative only just 7 months, I can only speak on behalf 7 from a personal point of view of any time I ever had anything with Mr Sheehy it was always 8 courteous and as helpful as he could be with me. I will just finish off, I am aware there has been 9 an awful lot of controversies, I wouldn't have been au fait with everything, so I think as Cllr 10 O'Neill referred to maybe if we look at it in totality and looking to the future, that maybe we 11 should learn all of the mistakes that have been made, I'm sure a lot of good things have been 12 done, at the end of the day the future is the future and we have to look forward, so from that end 13 I wish Mr Sheehy the best of luck and his family. 14 CATHAOIRLEACH: I'm going to let in the Brian Doyle. I believe Brian is, will take on the 15 acting CEO position. 16 DIRECTOR DOYLE: Just on my own behalf, on behalf of the staff of the Council, I just want 17 to wish Eddie Sheehy and his family all the very best, I believe under his stewardship and 18 leadership the mission and vision of the Council has been achieved, it has been achieved with the 19 help of the councillors, and as Cllr Behan mentioned as part of that relationship, that all the items 20 that have been delivered here, the members mentioned some of them, it doesn't happen without 21 the relationship working. 22 23 When we look at AFS I believe we have a solid platform for the financial future of the county, to 24 give the councillors the opportunity to put money on the table to spend for the betterment of the 25 county. I think the fact of the matter is the Celtic Tiger could have ruined and has ruined a lot of 26 counties in relation to development, that was not the case in this county, it was because of 27 partnership between the councillors and the executive. I'd like to wish him all the best. 28 Cllr RYAN: One thing I'd like to say, I forgot to mention, I do think we should write to the 29 Minister for Environment and ask him to expedite the process, this idea that there's five Councils 30 in Ireland without chief executives is ridiculous to me, we need leadership, whoever it might be, 31 I think the process has to be speeded up. 32 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay. Eddie. 33 CHIEF EXECUTIVE: Thank you Chairman and thanks to the members, as you've said next 34 month I'll have spent 43 years a public servant, 21 as County Manager, it was a great privilege

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 66

1 for me to work in five different local authorities and in particular it was a privilege to be 2 Wicklow County Manager for the last 14 years. Wicklow is a wonderful county despite some of 3 the negative publicity it gets during the past 14 years and the members have referred to some of 4 the fabulous projects that we have developed together, and I think as Brian said this is down to 5 the co-operation between the management, elected members and staff of the county. 6 7 Hundreds of different projects some of the members referred to, some of the larger ones like N11 8 becoming dual carriageway all the way, Greystones Harbour, Clermont College, Bray Flood 9 Defence, Wicklow Town Port Access, Charlesland schemes, waste water schemes, many fine 10 housing schemes throughout the county, the Shoreline in Bray and Greystones, 20 acre 11 recreational facility at Charlesland was a major coup where it was provided at no cost to 12 Wicklow County Council, a state-of-the-art world class facility there. Lots of skateboard parks 13 and playgrounds, fire stations and libraries and indeed we have a new library being built in 14 Arklow at the moment. 15 16 The Florentine Centre, it was vital that the entire site would come into the ownership of the local 17 authority, it enables us as the economy improves to do something with that and to rejuvenate the 18 town centre in Bray, which is facing such steep competition from Cornelscourt, Dundrum and 19 elsewhere, and again we have another project opened this week which is the new Civil Defence 20 training centre for Greystones. So a lot of successful projects done through the co-operation and 21 support of the elected members, done by the staff of Wicklow County Council and it's been a 22 great privilege for me to be at the helm during that period. 23 24 The work is down to the staff, I think we have a wonderful staff, wonderful management team 25 that can hold its own with anywhere else in the country, I was particularly proud when Wicklow 26 won the Livcom awards a couple of years ago as the most liveable community in the world with 27 the population less that 150,000, that was international recognition of what is wonderful in 28 Wicklow. The local authority, the members, the management, the staff working with the local 29 community to create a better place for citizens to live and people to visit. 30 31 The last six years certainly have been very challenging with pressures on us all to implement 32 government reform, reduce staff, less money and so on and again I think the staff of the Council 33 have responded magnificently, despite being paid less and reduced in number they have stepped 34 up to the mark. I saw that during the snow in 2010/11, during other severe weather events and

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 67

1 indeed there was nothing I have ever asked since I came here to Wicklow from the staff that they 2 weren't willing to achieve and go that extra mile, so I want to absolutely express my thanks and 3 appreciation and admiration to all of the staff who have strived non-stop throughout the period to 4 improve the county and their community. 5 6 I'd like to thank the members for their courtesy throughout the year. Obviously the system that 7 we have in local government does lead occasionally to tensions between management and staff, 8 but that's democracy and it's only right as some of the members have said that we all have our 9 role to do, but in general I've found that when I came to the elected members with an important 10 project that would benefit the county, such as the purchase of Clermont College, they were 11 willing to take that risk and take that chance and certainly the result now is that 350 students can 12 pursue third level courses there that would otherwise have to go out of the county. I think in the 13 future that will increase greatly in co-operation with Carlow IT. 14 15 To finish can I thank all of the staff of the Council, thank the management team who have 16 always been supportive and have worked tirelessly to be innovative and deliver on projects, can I 17 thank you Chairman for your courtesy throughout your period as a councillor, it's been a 18 privilege working with you and the other members during the years. 19 20 To record my appreciation to the various government departments and State agencies that we 21 interact with and provide much of the funding for the work we have to do and the local 22 community groups and voluntary bodies, County Wicklow Partnership, Bray Partnership, 23 Wicklow Tourism all do very important work in co-operation with the County Council, we all 24 have a role to play and I think the team effort achieves a lot more than separately on our own. 25 And indeed thanks to East Coast Radio, the Wicklow People and the Wicklow Voice for their 26 very fair and balanced coverage of the affairs of Wicklow County Council over the years, I 27 mightn't always have agreed with the coverage, but I always found they were willing to hear our 28 side of the story and report in a fair and balanced way. 29 30 Can I take the opportunity to congratulate Brian Doyle on his appointment as temporary 31 manager with effect from the 8th of April. The appointment has been confirmed to me by the 32 Department and I wish him success and every happiness in working with the elected members, 33 as I handover the helm to him and obviously the job will be filled in due course on a permanent 34 basis. There will be an open competition for that, it's a very public process where anybody can

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 68

1 apply, and that's a matter for a few months away I suspect. 2 3 Just again to thank all of the members. I have to say I'm disappointed with Cllr Brady's 4 contribution and his continued attacks on me. I suppose he has become very embittered after 5 failing to win a seat at the last general election and feels he has to be more controversial and 6 more on the attack for the next one and I wish him well with that Chairman. 7 Cllr BRADY: Maybe if you deal with the elephant in the room, there's two dead men and you 8 haven't got the guts or courtesy to apologise for your role in it instead of attacking me, that just 9 sums up the type of man you are. 10 CATHAOIRLEACH: Okay. Thank you members. Sorry for the overrun. 11 12 Meeting concluded at 6pm 13

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 69

A addition 5:16 23:19 24:9 all 1:9,23 2:6,28,33 announced 5:29 54:17 11:2,4,6,8,9,14,16,20, attacks 68:4 ability 63:10 25:1 62:6 3:1,11,25 4:24,33,34 announcement 1:11 21,22,27,30,33,34 attend 9:25 10:14 41:24 able 10:34 30:26 additional 25:1 37:6 5:14 6:13 7:2,24 6:16,17 12:3,8,10,11,18,25,27 46:8 34:11,29 38:12,16 41:6,16 46:23 8:10,28 9:12,30 10:7 annoyed 49:8 13:34,2,24 attendance 60:29 43:14 53:11,29 address 16:6,29 11:3 13:14,21,34 annual 13:24,25 31:19 14:6,7,8,9,12,17,28,3 attendances 57:14 about 3:17,27,29,31 5:27 adhere 27:12 14:12,33 15:30 38:3 41:17 43:26 4 15:15,16,19 attending 21:31 7:10,15,16,17 8:11,21 adjudication 44:28 16:5,12 18:5 48:19 16:20,21 attention 22:5 50:30,31 9:14,19 10:10,11,26 adjust 9:33 19:4,14,23,34 annually 40:34 17:11,12,17,28,29,34 51:30 62:20 13:21,24,30 15:25 admin 8:16 20:7,17,23 21:12 annum 24:9 53:7,8,9 18:2,5,6, attitude 17:34 16:28 17:9,29 administration 8:14,21 22:16,25 23:25,33 another 5:16 13:17 16:7 area 1:20 3:23 4:12 attitudes 18:28 18:19,32 20:13,14 administrative 8:15 24:17,20,21 25:2,21 27:22 34:33 35:20 10:32 11:29,30 attracted 62:19 22:15 25:18 26:16,29 24:10 26:3,23,28 27:11 46:18 47:9 51:1 56:3 13:33,34 audience 8:19 35:31 28:13 29:25 30:1,9,30 administratively 8:8 28:1,17,30 63:17 66:19 14:1,2,28,29,30,31 audiences 36:1 31:29 32:23 administrators 8:22,23 29:6,16,18,19 anseo 1:9 15:25,27,29 16:12 audio 30:4 33:30,32,33 34:9,10 admiration 67:3 30:1,10,14,23,28 31 answer 16:31 17:2,3,14 18:10 21:21 24:1 audit 21:23,31 22:11,18 35:1,5,28,29,30 36:4 admit 4:29 alleviate 16:22 18:30 28:26 46:34 25:23,24 27:14,19 25:10 41:26 37:23 38:34 39:1,4,15 adopt 33:3 39:33 alleviates 15:24 55:31 64:18 28:5,12 29:12 31:17 50:15,16,17 42:23 44:10,14,16,17 adopted 20:2 allocate 42:26 43:25 answered 49:18,19 50:1 38:30 40:9 42:16 51:3,6,29,30 52:2,6 above 8:9 adoption 36:24 allocation 20:26 31:1 answering 63:21 43:8,10 45:27 46:2 53:10,11,34 54:1,11 absolute 43:32 56:1 adult 43:21 42:23 51:1 answers 40:10 58:15 60:25 61:33 audited 53:11 absolutely 37:11,12 advance 53:3 allow 9:25 30:19 31:12 anxious 30:34 areas 1:17 9:20 10:10,15 auditing 38:15 43:9,15 67:2 advanced 15:15 59:14 38:20 any 5:25 8:10,14,32 16:3 11:26,30,31 12:18 auditor 50:30 accept 11:28 49:34 53:34 advancement 58:18 allowed 8:19 55:31 61:17 18:24 21:18 22:3,8 13:19 14:9,13,16 auditors 51:6,7 59:24 acceptable 8:3 advertise 36:21 allows 17:17 24:1 25:10 28:25 15:1,15,19,23 16:32 audits 21:14 22:23,28 accepted 54:2 advice 24:1,17,18,20 allude 52:17 30:15 31:17 33:20 17:1,11,12,17,34 23:9,10,14 28:23,24 accessibility 1:2 20:10 34:9 alluded 15:25 27:28 37:11,24 38:9,22 39:2 18:1,5,9,22 24:32 31:22 23:33 24:1 25:6 advise 20:23,24,25,26 30:29 32:28 43:12,14 47:14 48:17 27:25 28:15 30:10 authorisation 45:30 26:29 27:30 28:30,33 22:8 24:28 50:16 alone 3:11 49:14,15,22 51:1,8,31 33:28 34:15 38:32 authorities 10:24 11:6 31:29 32:25 advised 47:26 along 14:12,16 16:34 52:7,30 53:5,26 54:28 43:6 44:17 46:7 20:1,7 22:24 40:27 accessible 20:7 21:15 advising 19:22 54:11 20:16 43:2 55:9 58:4,5 60:22 48:24 50:26 54:8 60:8 66:1 23:4,5,25 26:29 27:24 advisory 36:6 58:16 63:2,32,33 64:7,12,17 63:12 authority's 24:28 30:13 31:14 advocate 29:12 already 14:17 15:12,17 65:7 aren't 8:11 48:30 62:3 authority 2:25 11:2 accessing 22:4 23:20 aerial 12:15 26:8 28:29 40:30 anybody 8:33 10:11 14:2 arguing 63:18 16:27 19:5,10 30:4,8 accompanied 46:4 affairs 67:26 46:16 18:25 26:12 35:27 arise 10:23 31:31 32:2,11 34:8 accordance 23:17 48:24 affect 39:10 also 1:34 3:10 50:9,11 61:26 63:2,3 arises 63:16 37:27,32 39:23 40:4 account 28:31 affected 10:32 11:27 4:3,11,13,19 5:2 67:34 army 37:12 41:28 45:21 49:25 accumulate 58:22 55:14,18 6:15,16,17,28,29 7:20 anyone's 7:21 around 1:12 7:14 8:10 52:25 57:28 59:16,22 accumulated 59:10 afield 1:28 9:18,28 11:12 12:15 anyone 53:10 57:30 13:16 14:1 16:14 63:17 66:17,28 accurate 1:5 afraid 61:4 63:2 15:27 17:16 58:12 21:9 25:10,25 27:18 avail 31:32 32:12 accusation 64:23 after 1:18 5:31 8:7 9:25 19:14,29,30,31,32 anything 21:4 26:24 31:5 28:3,5,23 30:19,22 available 4:3 9:20 achieve 19:23 29:19 15:3 21:26 25:23 22:3,12 23:23 27:1 42:4,14,18 44:3 46:29 31:22 43:33 44:10 10:5,13,18,20 37:15 40:23 67:2 36:20 48:27 54:10,11 28:3 30:12,25 49:7,8 50:17 56:10 52:19 57:32 64:9 14:18,19 23:34 24:4 achieved 40:14 64:34 56:8 59:25 68:4 31:10,17,22 32:2 64:12 65:7 arranged 21:21 26:26 27:15 33:20 65:18 afternoon 7:11 29:21 33:4,11,19,20 35:6,28 anyway 17:1 37:15 42:18 arrangement 37:6 37:24 39:24,34 50:24 achievement 5:17 20:30 afternoons 10:5 36:8,29 37:13,27 48:21 arranging 23:19 57:5 57:30 again 3:27 9:31 15:27 38:2,24 39:31,32 anywhere 66:25 arrested 56:20 awarded 44:28 achievements 19:17 18:32 20:13 41:2,17 43:20,21 apart 27:14 arrived 61:10 awards 45:26 66:26 achieves 37:10 67:24 27:9,17,32 45:2,8,13,16,20 48:8 apologies 7:8 8:31 art 1:11,19 60:28 66:12 aware 8:6 11:8 23:29,33 acknowledge 56:8 57:27 28:4,9,15,16,17 49:5 52 apologise 6:23,29 arts 42:19,22,23,25,31 24:24 27:18 60:29 29:11,20 30:23 although 15:7 28:2 8:18,32 62:15 68:8 43:1,33,34 44:7 45:6 28:12,28,33 31:9 acknowledged 36:27 31:6,25 32:27 34:34 altogether 55:34 apologised 8:17 46:23 32:24 34:3 42:3 42:9 43:22 35:18 36:23 38:10,28 always 4:3,22 28:16 apology 57:19,22,23,25 aside 7:23 26:8 64:22 49:2,5 51:4,29 65:8 acquire 21:5 41:18,20 43:16 50:29 32:22,24 34:2,6 37:24 appeal 63:33 ask 14:34 15:16,30 17:5 awareness 20:13,25 acre 58:13 64:26,31 51:19 54:10 55:21 42:15 43:4,7 appear 7:16 18:2 43:25 37:3,32 38:30 40:26 24:19 34:2 35:16 66:10 56:7 60:25,28 62:22 51:5,30,31 54:19 appears 15:23 43:26 46:7,29 away 1:33 3:24 4:26 acres 58:10 63:26 64:17 66:19,32 55:31 58:3,5 60:21 appendix 33:31 34:14 49:17,18 51:19,24 29:3,30 42:7 48:2 across 29:3 37:10 40:13 68:3 61:1,13,14,15,20 65:7 40:3 52:23 60:18 62:27 56:24 58:13 68:1 49:33 59:9 64:21 against 6:11 12:27 28:10 67:16,27 application 33:19 65:29 awful 30:22 50:2 55:6 acting 65:15 30:14 59:34 amalgamation 42:3 applications 44:27,28 asked 6:23 7:18 9:33 57:29 61:26 65:9 action 18:34 19:26,27,31 age 2:16 3:8,12 4:1 ambition 58:5 applied 44:20 45:9 17:9 22:23 49:18,34 Access 9:29 16:17 18:34 21:12,14 agencies 20:16 24:31 amend 39:32 44:23 apply 68:1 50:23 53:18 55:21 19:6,10,14,23,31 23:6,13,14,28 67:20 amenities 31:10 appoint 46:12 57:19 63:28 67:1 20:4,24,25,30 25:7,18,30 28:8,29 agenda 5:27 7:2 43:28 among 2:31 appointed 15:14 23:17 asking 17:31 44:23 45:20 21:12,18 34:2,33,34 35:20,29 44:32 amount 9:32 12:17,20,22 appointment 67:30,31 aspect 37:17 40:28 22:5,19,28,29 49:21 51:8 agendas 36:34 16:33 27:14,18,28,29 apportioned 48:23 50:26 aspects 15:30 25:2 23:6,9,13,14,16,19,23 actions 19:22 ago 4:26 7:18 8:23 15:28 31:8,18 37:12,14 41:9 appreciate 34:3 33:12,32 40:28,29 ,26,28 24:12,18,20,28 33:27,28,29,32 20:14,30 27:34 28:5 44:6,7 48:12,24 50:7 appreciated 4:18 45:29 49:5 25:7,31 26:8 28:23 34:8,12,14,15,21,30 31:22 54:33 63:34 51:5,22 63:12 appreciation 34:2 asphalts 51:7 29:12,24,26 31:10,12 36:4,5 64:1,28 66:26 analysing 12:21 67:3,20 aspirational 39:22 35:27 66:9 active 28:22 34:9 agree 6:2 25:22 32:18 analysis 12:9,20,28,32,34 approach 26:32 39:27 aspirations 39:26 Act 19:24 23:3,17,24 actively 1:13 33:3 37:21 43:23 13:6 15:34 20:10 60:5 assess 12:17 31:2 33:9 activities 3:13 35:16 38:1 44:11,20 52:33 53:4 and approached 46:16 63:28 assessment 9:9 10:14 Additionally 25:34 51:8 58:2 61:32 1:2,3,4,5,12,13,15,17, approaches 29:29 11:26,29,31 12:9,10 Adelaide 56:33 activity 43:10 agreed 6:1,13,34 19,20,23,25,28 approaching 10:26 15:10,15,30 AEP 13:24,28 14:5 acts 35:28 7:24,28,31 9:4,7 2:1,8,20,22,25,26,33 appropriate 6:2 11:12,14 16:9,20,26 46:9 AEPs 14:6 actual 40:7 41:23 36:18 37:30 41:31 3:1,3,4,7,13,17,18,28, 51:33 assessments 20:11 35:10 AFA 15:7,11 17:2 46:17,18 48:5 46:33,34 55:34 63:19 30,31,32 approval 24:14 assets 12:16 18:21 AFAs 15:6,8 16:33 actually 13:30 15:10 67:27 4:2,13,17,18,19,22,23 approves 24:10 assist 19:23 22:7 AFS 65:23 16:2,6,28 26:13,19,21 agreement 7:1 40:21 ,24,27,33,34 approving 23:29 24:34,26 25:7 AGM 7:14 49:3 60:1 31:9,27 32:8 39:5 agricultural 11:28 5:1,4,13,22,30 archaeology 33:10,33 assistance 23:20 Alchemy 45:6 40:20,30 ahead 1:11,18 10:24 15:4 6:11,15,17,18,29,30 archive 34:18 35:21,26 assists 23:23 Ali 62:32 41:12,17,26,27 44:15 58:26,28 61:7 7:6,11,15,19,20,23,27 36:29 associate 54:12 America 5:22,30 8:9 46:16 49:22 aimed 45:25 ,30 are 1:2,3,12,13,17 2:25 associated 4:7,11,21 5:2 Andrew 55:21 51:12,16,23 52:6,11 aims 19:16 20:23 24:31 8:3,4,5,7,9,20,26,27 3:12 4:24 5:14,23 assume 16:12,27 17:22 Ann 3:34 4:1 55:10,16,17 air 49:6 9:12,16,18,20,21,22,2 6:3,24 7:17 assured 28:11 Anthony's 2:24 4:31 58:17,25,27 airtime 25:34 5,30,33 8:12,13,16,18,24,26,2 astonishing 56:28 Anthony 1:33 add 15:31 17:5 36:29 alarms 40:7 41:23,24 10:3,4,5,10,15,19, 9,30 9:14,15,20,24,31 attack 44:2 68:6 2:4,18,22,25,28 41:33 62:11 alive 39:21 anniversary 56:24 10:7,10,21 attacking 68:8 4:25,27 19:1 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 70

ANNESLEY 43:11 before 15:16 34:19 35:22 bought 51:22 55:17 23:10 27:34 28:1,8 33:27 34:22 45:18 cleared 46:19 46:27,28,31 38:28 42:12 43:2 bound 28:1 37:2 60:24,26 46:2 clearly 56:34 April 44:32 45:8 54:17 44:1 53:6 57:16 boundaries 10:31 12:21 BLAKE 2:27,28 3:14 carry 16:26 30:6 34:12 cleverer 54:13 64:30 67:31 60:7,12 62:15 63:31 box 14:6 7:31 15:20,21 40:26 59:1 cliff 58:16 Arising 8:2 18:8 21:31 64:8 boxes 11:34 45:5 carrying 57:8 climate 34:8 Arklow 3:10,15,19 10:3 beg 49:16 boxing 62:27,28 BLB 4:19 cartel 52:24,25 closed 10:6 55:16 13:15,17 15:12,13,15 began 20:6 break 39:19 Boghall 4:12 case 16:25 38:12 46:3 closely 24:11 38:10 19:26 21:11 23:10 beggar's 51:12 breakdown 44:1 Bohemians 5:15 48:15 51:15 62:13 closer 54:34 26:16 28:30,34 29:4,5 begin 44:29 bridge 17:19,22 24:34 BOURKE 7:31 42:32 65:26 closet 4:28 32:28 37:1 beginning 14:18 25:26 brief 19:16 23:19 33:1 46:27 52:23,28 61:10 cases 47:30 48:9,10 closure 61:27 42:3,4,16,32 52:32 39:30 45:14 51:26 Brady's 68:3 56:28 clothes 59:33 43:11,16,18,19,21 begs 49:1 52:4 60:18 Bray 1:20 3:20,21,22,23 catchment 10:14 11:26 club 2:11 44:24 45:21 46:31 behalf 4:8,33,34 briefing 32:34 4:12,14,19 6:20 8:6 12:21,32 13:17 clue 52:15 66:14 54:25,27 56:1 57:27 briefly 5:11 38:27 9:6 15:7,11,14 23:10 catchments 11:25,26 cobble 30:9 Article 24:15 58:30 62:10 65:5,6,16 bring 4:30 5:24 20:13,15 30:8,25 32:20 36:34 13:15,16 cognisance 17:8,28,29 Ashford 14:16 16:12 behave 13:16 38:28 39:21 42:25 37:34 42:19 cater 62:6 26:9 23:11 45:6 behaviours 39:19 43:2 44:3 52:8 61:27 43:4,5,8,10,23,24,26, cause 8:17 17:19 18:7 cohesion 24:29 Association 2:5 behind 51:31 bringing 22:5 53:31 27 44:5,13,14 caused 8:4,32 coincide 56:24 ASHTON 19:1 22:27 60:1,6,22,27,28 brings 50:10 45:5,7,21 54:30 centrally 13:14 collaborative 39:27 Aughrim 10:3 15:24 being 11:34 12:1,5 broad 17:14 55:7,8,9,13,17,18,19, centre 21:18,23,32 26:1 colleague 30:30 52:23 23:11 15:7,12,13 18:7,24 broadened 33:11 27 58:16 61:25 28:2,4 35:14 55:13 colleagues 41:16 43:18 Avoca 11:9 15:12 25:13 27:3 29:2,23,31 broader 60:32 66:8,10,18 67:22 58:20 66:16,18,20 collecting 12:22 B 46:17 49:23,33 50:29 broken 26:34 Brian 65:14 66:4 67:30 certain 7:17 9:32 12:22 collection 12:8 baby 21:34 51:22,34 53:19,29 brother 3:32 Brigid's 2:6 16:33 44:21 52:17 collector 1:34 back 2:7 5:24 8:20 14:5 55:30 56:25 brothers 2:33 Broadlough 13:34 57:34 61:5 colour 14:5 15:6 26:23 28:27 59:10,25,32 60:23 brought 22:12 25:26 BRADY 3:20 5:33 certainly 3:1,4 6:30 colourful 3:15 4:18 29:4 34:27 36:19,23 61:11 62:27 66:13,33 28:33 30:18 42:22 6:1,14,15,25,33 15:21,23 25:10 combination 12:31 40:29,31 42:30 47:4 belief 51:12 50:28,30,31 51:29 7:4,34 29:20 43:23 27:14,23,25 28:29 come 3:2 8:20 10:20 11:9 48:34 49:3,14 53:1,6 beliefs 3:16 52:2 56:12,15 56:8 59:26 62:15 29:7,21 30:21,33 31:5 13:13 14:16,25 16:27 55:24,32 60:9 63:34 believe 6:27,29 28:29 58:20,27 62:19 68:7 32:7 39:10,12,22 20:20 32:1 35:25 64:8 32:6 39:18,27 57:22 brunt 56:4 Bus 39:11,12 41:15,28 51:6 54:24 36:22,23 37:32 40:30 background 7:14,17 59:12 60:11 62:25,30 brush 17:14 BURNS 37:5 56:30 57:31,32 42:5 47:1 50:24 10:19 33:1,9 34:21 65:14,17,23 budget 26:7 27:7 31:5,19 C 58:2,13 61:25 63:2 52:17 55:23 59:24 37:10,22 48:26 benefit 5:25,31 14:30,31 44:10 45:3 50:29 cabinets 8:4 64:23 66:31 67:11 62:28 66:16 bad 22:12 54:23 16:21 18:25 22:5 budgetary 50:27 cake 44:29 chair 7:7 32:8 comes 14:2 26:13 27:24 balance 37:5 52:31 61:26 67:10 budgets 42:34 calendar 34:25 chairperson 19:5 30:5 44:9 60:4 balanced 67:26,28 bereaved 56:22 buggies 21:34 calibration 13:8,14 chairs 25:15 comfort 27:1 bank 8:9 25:25 beseech 44:9 build 1:19 39:1 call 5:20 6:6 10:25 11:29 challenge 29:15,18 coming 7:20 16:20,26,34 banks 13:27 best 23:31 34:6,8 building 9:16,22 16:21 37:12 40:7 48:18 challenges 30:22 25:29 29:20 31:28 barrier 58:6 39:23,28 44:29,30,33 23:29 27:22,24 33:28 56:14 challenging 57:33 66:31 40:28 42:10,17 43:7 based 10:30 13:1,9,31 45:1 53:32 55:2,11 56:19,33 57:1,3,9,15 called 9:14 33:8 44:13 chamber 1:12 7:18 49:10 50:5 54:33 60:22 15:28,31 25:23 35:26 56:3 58:23 60:20 buildings 34:18,19,25 47:5,20 57:19 63:32,34 64:18,25 commemorating 64:20 40:33 44:8 47:29 61:13 63:1,29 64:32 built 8:14 11:13 12:21 calling 5:29 23:25 26:25 chambers 57:25 commence 22:24 29:22 48:14 59:8 65:5,13,17,27 17:9 20:24,32 23:34 63:32 championship 2:12,13 commenced 11:1 baseline 35:4 better 5:22 35:30 39:4 27:24 62:9 66:13 calls 23:28 chance 28:19 42:12 commend 26:32 basically 7:10,15,19 16:5 42:25 51:9 60:10 bulk 11:26 came 2:18 3:2 4:22 20:13 55:23 67:11 29:20,31 30:7,12,23 49:11 54:15 59:10,17 62:2 66:29 buried 3:12 26:19 31:11 34:23 change 17:33,34 37:8 basin 10:31 betterment 65:24 bursts 13:27 35:2,29 38:27 49:33 18:1,28,29 38:11 52:7 commended 1:13 basis 21:5 26:21 39:11 between 13:27 16:2 business 4:13 22:4,5 51:6 52:12,13 54:6,21 changed 22:12 52:6 comment 10:27 44:27 43:26 67:34 17:10,25,30 42:5,21 58:23 63:9 56:22 57:10 59:9 changes 13:3 38:9 49:9 59:28 bathrooms 27:24 47:8 48:14 58:6 businesses 21:15 22:3 62:9 63:8,18,31 64:8 changing 55:15 comments 6:18,19,30 battle 28:30 62:30 63:2 65:27 66:5 67:7 31:12 67:1,9 channel 13:21 10:26 14:20,24 63:20 bear 9:12 14:7,10 big 3:1 8:15 13:34 36:1 but 2:2,5,16,31 campaign 32:28 character 3:15 4:18 commissioned 12:16 bearing 32:12 50:10 3:2,6,11,18,23,29 can't 8:20 9:30 16:31 35:10 commitment 61:3,8 beat 5:12 39:5 bigger 8:16 34:10 4:28,29,31 5:22,24 18:18 27:1 32:12 charge 48:4 49:13 committed 3:15 became 3:22 49:2 biggest 42:9 56:14 8:13,18,22,24 9:28,33 39:5 43:16 49:2 50:7 charity 5:32 committees 23:13 41:32 because 1:9 3:4 6:27 biodiversity 33:33 34:33 10:15,20 11:13,27,28 52:7 59:20 cheaper 51:14,21 committing 32:15 7:14,18 9:19,31 10:13 35:11,14,17 14:7,9,24 can 5:34 7:1,2,14,22 check 16:33 47:20 53:15 communication 20:25 11:6 birthday 56:24 15:13,25,26,30 10:3,11 13:17 checks 52:9,19 communities 21:15 24:5 15:8,10,12,14,16,17,2 bit 1:23 6:5 7:16 8:8 16:5,7,20,34 17:5,28 14:16,19,20,23 15:30 children 30:13 43:20 27:19 31:12,13 2 16:1 17:17,22,26,34 25:34 28:4,7 34:20 19:11 20:9,13,14 17:1,2,29 19:12 21:6 63:1,6 64:33 community 1:28 2:4,22 22:15 25:17 29:24,28 35:7,30 37:16 39:15 23:4,25 26:9,29,34 25:16 26:5 27:25,30 chin 53:1 3:22,24 4:12,17 22:30 32:5,10 38:20,23 42:6,7 49:17,19 52:8 27:1,33 28:4,7,9,27 28:2,5 choirs 43:21 24:3 26:4 27:17 39:20 40:20,25 56:4 58:23 63:15 29:16,26 31:29 32:1 29:9,10,11,22,25,28 chose 63:11 30:33 31:2,9 34:9,18 42:2,7,11 43:7,9,19 bizarre 52:20 33:16,20 34:14,20,34 30:5,20,30 31:5,32 chosen 55:1 35:21,27 36:20,29 44:2 47:18 48:17,29 blatant 57:3 35:3,28 37:5,13, 32:17 33:5 34:31 chronology 47:4 37:24,25 38:10 50:3,6,7,27 51:16,23 blindfold 30:19 buying 51:21 35:27 38:21,30 circular 47:16,19 48:14 39:31,33 41:10,13 52:7,14,21 blockage 17:18 Ballywaltrim 3:23,24 39:13,26,28 50:13 42:24 44:8 58:5,14 53:27,29,30 58:3 blocks 17:25 Baltinglass 1:27 11:30 40:21,22,30 circulate 45:29 66:26,29 67:4,22 59:9,26,32 60:6,33 blood 40:12 15:24 17:1 19:17,30 41:21,30,33 circulated 33:4 36:19 companies 51:7 64: blue 11:30 13:34 14:1,12 21:17,23,32 22:11,14 43:4,5,9,26 45:11,15 company 56:10 become 4:28 60:25 68:4 38:1 23:11 25:10,24,34 44:11,12,31 45:2,8,20 circulation 20:24 compare 13:8 41:1 becoming 66:8 board 11:13 19:28 25:16 26:1,2 37:2 39:10 46:6,15,24 circumstances 18:6 compared 13:10 38:21 been 1:18 4:19 5:4,22 26:12 29:6,14 32:14 Barcelona 19:34 cancel 5:30 32:19 49:32 comparison 47:18 11:31 12:3,20 14:3 35:25,29 40:13 20:2,5,9,13,15 candidate 3:11 37:4 citizens 32:6 66:29 comparisons 41:27 15:12,14,17,21,24,27, 46:17,18 58:28 64:21 29:13,18,26 40:21 cannot 44:4 claim 51:31 compensation 45:26 29,31,34 16:2,16 bodies 11:6 36:13,20 Bay 21:11 capable 59:30 63:21 claiming 51:32 58:28 competent 11:2 17:31 20:34 25:26 67:22 Behan 63:5 65:19 capacity 26:25 clarification 42:18 43:23 competition 35:17 52:25 26:16 27:4 body 11:4 Betty 2:24 car 4:2 47:1 50:2 51:10,15,25 66:18 67:34 28:11,12,24,29,33 book 34:19 51:4,7 Billy 1:25,26 2:33 3:7,28 care 1:4 3:29 4:29 19:7 52:32 competitors 42:5 29:12 30:8,10,12 61:15,16 Bitumen 47:5,6,7,9,14 28:33 clarifications 46:6 compile 16:5 40:33 31:28 32:1,15 booklet 40:17 48:8,11,18,20,25 career 2:13 clarified 8:3 compiled 16:12 40:8 33:2,18,27,30 both 1:13,27 2:20 10:31 49:14 cares 62:9 clarify 7:24 8:8 43:27 compiles 40:34 35:13,20,30 36:19 34:8 39:33 55:27 51:11,13,14,16,20 carriageway 66:8 clash 46:12 compiling 2:34 33:30 37:13,16,26 41:8 56:27,28 62:7 53:7,10,12,13,20,22,2 carried 10:15 12:8 class 66:12 35:5 38:8 42:14 43:5,7,12,15,16 bother 46:32 3,30 54:4 13:6,11 14:29 classified 59:11 complaints 21:31 45:4,11,15,19,25,26 bottom 14:12 53:19 Blessington 19:18,30 15:24,26 16:4,10 clean 62:21 63:34 complement 33:27 46:16,3 57:29,30 22:14,15,16,18,21 29:31 30:12 32:1 clear 52:16 complete 14:20 26:17 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 71

completed 11:1 17:26 controversy 63:27,31 critically 55:17 29:11,20 30:28,30 days 8:7,31 14:15,16,25 developing 9:22 12:21 18:29 62:1,3,4 convey 4:34 5:1,2 criticising 29:32 31:7,27,30 32:3 54:23 17:7 completely 44:8 54:12 coordinating 23:20 criticism 54:2 63:8 Coast 6:18 13:16 dead 68:7 development 2:5 5:4 complex 62:3,8,9 copied 49:4 critique 40:20 56:23,25 57:3,24 deal 17:24 18:20,26 28:1 11:12 12:2,11 16:13 compliments 27:10 copper 25:31 cross 20:6 29:1 30:5,10 59:27 67:25 32:2 43:1 53:2 17:8,12,16,20 18:28 32:25 copy 37:33 45:17 crossed 5:15 29:3 Colaiste 1:11,18 54:15,29 55:1,2 56:16 25:29,32 28:3 34:26 composition 36:12 core 40:18,19,20,21 crossing 26:2,3 30:3,4 College 66:8 67:10 68:7 35:2,21 43:20 comprehensive 16:9 corner 13:34 22:12 62:25 crossings 21:27 26:2 Commission 12:9 dealing 18:19 30:25 32:6 58:9,11,13,14,24 53:15 cornerstone 34:9 28:34 Commissioner's 23:18 dealings 54:19,20,21 65:26 computing 13:6 cornerstones 34:6 crowd 1:26 Committee 5:4 6:13 dealt 4:23 48:26 54:1 did 6:12 8:17 16:14,31 comrades 64:31 coroner 57:16 culminated 49:6 15:32 19:6,12,16,28 55:5,30 19:28 22:14,16 27:33 concentrate 11:33 16:32 corporate 37:32,34 cultural 22:34 33:12 20:6,20,31 30:33 31:1 dear 27:33 28:31 32:29 34:24 35:7,13 concentrated 11:29 38:11,16,18,19,31 culture 1:13,17,20 32:3 38:15 41:7,26 dearest 2:32 36:18 37:3 40:4 43:2 concern 5:21 27:11 39:8,12,16,24,30 culvert 17:18,19,22,25 43:21 50:15,16,17 death 3:1,8,20,28 4:8,13 45:29 48:8 39:12 40:27,31 curbs 30:7 51:3,29,30 52:2,6 5:3 54:29 49:13,17,22,28,29 concerned 6:4 21:24 41:2,3,8,12,21,26 current 10:19 11:33 53:34 54:1 deaths 6:19 56:16 50:17,23,24,25 51:19 43:7 50:27 62:20 45:30 46:34 50:4 14:33 16:13 23:25,30 Compass 45:6 57:12,20,23 64:4,5 53:29 54:2 59:7,27 concerns 21:27 51:26 56:6 60:15 38:2 Connolly 9:6 decided 16:32 21:11 22:3 63:30 64:30 conclude 19:18 correct 8:28 51:20 currently 11:33 15:7 Consultancy 24:20 37:15 64:26 didn't 3:29 8:34 41:8 concluded 68:12 correctly 47:30 54:28 23:18 26:1 Consulting 9:26 decision 13:1 17:21 42:4,6,12,18 44:20 conclusions 63:28 correspondence 7:11 cut 37:14 59:10 Cornelscourt 66:18 18:17 47:11 54:14 47:3,11,14,31 concur 62:14 45:13 Callary 45:6 Coroner's 56:27,30 55:24 59:7 48:20,21,29,32,33 condolences 2:24 corruption 59:12 Carlow 67:13 57:11 decisions 9:21 55:34 49:7,11,18,19,27 50:6 3:14,18,25 cost 7:10 14:30 27:6 Carnew 23:12 Corpus 2:17,22 61:13,20 62:23 64:14 51:11,23 53:3,4,34 confidence 13:2 49:7 48:19 50:34 53:8 Castlebar 35:23 Council's 20:15 24:25 dedicated 2:4 4:22 29:32 54:12 57:6,7 58:1,2 59:7 58:3 66:11 Cathaoirleach's 28:7 49:23 31:4 59:7 confirm 7:6,27,30 46:8 costs 53:6 CAFS 57:7,15 Council 1:3,7,33 2:32 dedication 43:20 differ 17:32 confirmed 67:31 could 5:22 7:1 14:29 22:6 CASEY 7:28 37:21 3:24 4:33 6:31 7:10 deemed 21:5 difference 17:10 27:34 confused 42:7 52:12 28:7 29:1 30:18,34 39:30 41:9,31 45:2 8:2,15 9:15,28 10:6 deepest 1:28 3:7,13 47:8 congratulate 67:30 31:29 37:6 39:3 51:26 15:34 16:3 defences 12:16 differences 17:25 61:31 congratulations 5:11,17 44:31 45:8 47:32 CATHAOIRLEACH 19:11,13,21,24,31 defend 18:8,9 different 9:34 12:28,31 conjunction 14:27 19:12 48:20 50:14 51:19,24 1:9,15,17,24,32 20:3,4,5,17,23,24,25, defended 18:25 14:5,6 17:15,29,30,33 connected 35:32 52:1,2 54:2 57:1 2:26,27 3:26 26,31,32 defending 18:8,10,12 18:1 30:17,18 35:20 connection 45:16 64:14 58:12 59:19 60:7,8,10 4:6,15,25,31 21:1,14,21,22,24 defer 45:1,4 36:1,13 38:34 39:5 connections 20:32 63:10 65:8,25 5:6,10,11,17,28,33 22:10,18,19,20,23,25, deficiencies 50:33 55:1 60:5 61:31 consecutive 53:8 couldn't 8:30 48:4 50:1 6:6,12,15,24,32,34 27,29,32,33 definition 48:5 66:1,7 consequences 11:27,28 53:19 7:3,6,8,23,34 8:1,34 23:3,9,16,21,23,24,26 delighted 18:34 difficult 3:21 28:4 30:20 13:2,7 councillor 2:27 4:15,25 15:20 16:30 18:31 ,33,34 deliver 13:19 19:24 31:34 54:29,31 55:5 consider 9:3,6 7:24 8:34 16:30 25:9 26:10,28 27:31 24:3,4,8,10,11,12,15, 67:16 56:18 61:2,27,33 18:20,21,22,24 26:7 26:10 32:16 52:33 28:13,21,26 31:27 18,19,20,21,30 deliverables 13:8,19 difficulties 3:2 21:18 27:23 32:32 41:7,11 54:21 58:3,4,5,26,28 32:15,16,27,34 36:27 25:3,23 26:7,23 27:7 delivered 20:2 22:6 22:3,5 26:13,14,20 62:16 59:8,31,33 62:27 37:7,9,29,34 Councils 38:34 39:1,2 27:11 65:20 28:34 30:3 considerably 31:24 63:26 64:1,18 67:17 38:17,18,26 40:9,32 40:14 42:3 44:30 delivery 19:21 20:1,23 digital 35:26 consideration 5:26 25:29 councillors 1:12 4:16 41:30 42:29 43:17,28 47:6 52:9,10,19 38:3 41:17 dinner 4:26 41:8 51:9 6:13 9:34 23:29 24:4 44:26,34 53:18,19 65:29 democracy 67:8 direct 42:23 considered 18:7 39:13 25:20 26:22 28:12 Celtic 32:7 65:25 County 1:3,7,33 2:32 departing 57:24 direction 14:3 42:14 53:2 29:16 30:17,18 Central 56:27 3:12,17 4:33 departments 20:17 23:23 directive 10:23 consisted 12:14 20:5 31:7,27 32:28 37:18 Cert 40:15 5:5,23,25,31 67:20 directly 33:2 53:6 40:11,16 43:19 CEO 5:21,25,29 6:16 6:16,20,28 9:15 departure 62:21 directors 19:13 24:4 51:7 consists 19:26 21:14 45:22,31 46:4 50:6 56:20 61:3 10:31,32 15:22,23 dependant 38:11 disabilities 20:1,4,16 constituents 3:31 52:16 59:30,31,32 62:11,15,19 65:15 16:13 17:8 depended 42:4 22:6,33 23:4,20 constructed 12:17 49:3 61:31 63:34 64:5,14 CFRAM 10:14 46:11 19:10,13,21,24,31 depending 54:7 24:16,26 26:14 28:15 construction 11:21 65:19,24,27 CFRAMS 9:14 20:2,3,4,5,15,17,23,2 depth 13:12,20 16:1 29:10 30:1,13,23 15:9,10 counties 39:25 43:33 17:22,26,28 18:2 4,25,26,31,32 derelict 55:18 58:17 31:9,32 constructive 32:8 37:22 65:26 Chairman 4:7,27,33 7:1 21:1,14,21,22,24 describe 62:27 disability consultant 27:6 58:27 countries 35:32 36:1 19:5 25:21,22 27:10 22:10,18,19,20,23,25, described 49:32 19:24,26,27,28,29,31 consultants 11:16 15:14 country's 49:27 30:33 54:21 57:26 27,28,29,32,33 description 63:33 20:6,9,13,26 consultation country 8:23,26,28 9:32 59:2 60:32 23:1,3,5,9,16,21,23,2 64:7,17 21:4,5,27 9:14,15,16,17,24,28 17:15,23,24 24:32 64:1,25,28,30 65:33 4,26,33,34 deserves 37:19 57:31 22:8,24,27,32 11:4 12:4,5,10 35:23 39:23 40:28 67:17 68:6 24:3,4,8,10,11,15,18, 58:31 23:3,6,13,17,24 14:16,19,22,25,32,33 42:9 43:33 47:7 Charlesland 66:9,11 19,2 design 12:26,27 23:31 24:5,6,15,18,20,21,26 15:3,8,11 16:34 17:16 52:27 53:27 58:14,21 Cheshire 28:32 Court 56:27,30 57:11 designated 24:10 ,28,32 25:25,30,31 24:24,32 66:25 Christi 2:17,22 61:11 designed 20:3 26:4,8 27:11,12,23,25 consultations 14:15 coup 66:11 Christine 37:32 38:28 CPG 52:2 designing 38:31 30:1,15 31:14 consultative 20:10 couple 7:18 14:13 39:14 40:2,17,26 Crosscoole 9:3 designs 11:23 12:28 disabled 27:15 consulted 10:25 29:15,21 33:30 63:26 41:30,32 45:14 46:12 Cullen 27:10 37:2,3,30 desired 63:10 disagreeing 63:18 consultees 10:25 66:26 Christmas 34:20 48:27 49:17 52:14 desktop 35:5 disagreements 63:15 contact 3:4 21:28 22:3 course 1:10,25 6:19,30 CHIEF 6:27 46:20 62:29 Cumman 4:4 despite 66:2,33 disappointed 39:8 42:6 contained 20:3 8:22 19:1 44:5 49:9 65:30,33 Cup 5:12 detail 7:17 13:7 33:23 51:27 52:3,34 59:4,27 contains 17:12,16 59:8 67:33 City 62:2 Cyril 4:13 41:16,21 44:27 51:6 68:3 contest 62:29 courses 34:7 67:12 Civil 66:19 D detailed 10:10,13 11:23 disappointing 51:28,33 context 11:29 33:7 41:10 courteous 54:19 64:16 CIE 39:9 daily 21:5,8 26:21 39:11 16:28 24:14 30:29 disciplinary 62:12 47:7 65:8 Clermont 55:22 60:32 dance 4:27 31:28 35:7 41:18 discrepancies 16:2 continue 22:23 24:3 courtesy 54:22 62:32 66:8 67:10 danger 27:2 determination 61:8 discretion 42:26 35:18 44:6 67:6,17 68:8 Cllr 1:12,14,15,31,32 dangerous 22:17 determined 28:5 57:14 discretionary 30:26 continued 47:14,17 68:4 cover 62:16 2:27,28 data 12:8,21,22 13:14 develop 11:17 14:28 48:12,23 54:6 continuing 22:25 coverage 26:21 67:26,27 3:14,20,26,27,34 16:5 35:5,14 38:8 24:30 25:2 33:26 discriminated 30:14 continuously 61:26 covered 11:10 31:29 4:6,7,15,16,21,30 45:13,16,17,18,19,26, 34:31 35:31 39:17,27 discrimination 28:10 contract 24:34 27:8 29:6 covers 26:1 5:10,11,19,20,29,33 27,31 46:2,11 61:2 discuss 6:7,25 21:23,33 contributing 57:16 crack 7:6 6:1,2,5,14,15,25,33 database 35:6 developed 11:26 12:3 37:32 50:25 contribution 28:28 36:31 cracking 9:1 7:1,4,5,7,8,9,28,31,34 date 1:19 2:1 12:20 33:27 14:25 18:23 discussed 31:30 50:29 68:4 crazy 52:22 8:1,2 9:4,7 35:5 35:22,24,26,31 58:10 discussing 60:2 64:24 contributions 29:9 42:8 create 66:29 15:20,21,33 16:4 17:7 daughters 2:24 59:5 66:4 discussion 6:27,32 36:23 contributor 4:12 creating 41:6 18:4 19:4 25:20,21 day 3:18,30 5:13,30 16:7 developer 18:19,20,26 38:18 contributory 57:12 credit 28:31 58:28 26:11,15,28 32:24 34:27 39:21 58:9 discussions 6:12 41:33 control 18:15,30 crew 41:24 27:10,28,31,32 46:5 49:18 54:21,24 developers 16:25 18:17 50:24 controversial 68:5 criminal 56:27 62:12 28:7,21,27,28 56:34 57:11 65:12 55:17 62:7 disgrace 43:32 controversies 65:9 criteria 8:16 42:4 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 72

disgraceful 6:17 drive 60:32 elderly 27:23 31:32 event 12:29,30 63:1,6,10,31 64:8,16 43:4,8,12,19,22,24,26 43:11,15 driven 33:16 elected 26:22 36:12,20 13:26,28,31 14:8,9 65:17,32 ,31,34 disgusted 50:20 dropping 39:9 45:28 46:13,22 50:3 18:7 60:29 Edward's 1:25 44:5,6,7,10,13,17,24 dishing 30:7,8 dual 45:4 66:8 52:34 62:24 65:6 events 12:21 Edward 2:33 3:28 4:34 45:6 46:30 dishonest 59:20 due 28:31 38:8 67:33 66:5,21 67:9,32 13:3,7,10,25 34:7 Eireann 39:12 festivals 42:19 43:1,31 disingenuous 49:17 dump 58:17 election 2:1 3:11 68:5 56:29,30 66:34 England 58:26 44:3,6,11,16,21,30 display 26:1,5 dumps 64:11 electoral 38:30,32 eventually 59:10 Enniskerry 23:11 few 1:14 3:2 8:7 15:27,28 disposal 9:3,6 during 1:1 6:19,30 9:28 elephant 29:25 68:7 ever 53:19 65:7 67:1 Environment 20:24 17:8 19:11 27:11 disregard 6:33 35:21 45:29 56:23 eligible 48:3,5 every 13:26,27 17:8,22 23:34 40:34 41:1 32:12,13 35:14 41:2 disregards 57:2 61:10 63:28 else 8:33 28:27 44:3 48:4 28:19 37:16,17,20 48:29,30 52:11 65:29 57:33,34 68:1 disrepute 56:12 62:19 66:3,22,34 67:18 50:15 61:31 66:25 43:10 50:9 53:9,23 Especially 1:20 3:28,32 field 58:10,12,13 60:33 district 9:34 10:1,3 13:9 dwindle 31:33 elsewhere 66:19 54:6 55:30 59:24,31 21:34 37:24 fields 61:8 27:5 28:34 36:33,34 dynamo 36:28 embargo 29:28 63:18 64:18 67:32 Etcetera 13:7 20:33 fieldworker 1:34 37:3 42:10 43:24 Dags 31:11 embarrassment 43:33 everybody 3:3,17 4:23 24:25 45:20 53:22 fight 28:30 57:6 62:33 districts 9:34 10:31 Dargle 11:9 13:27 15:8,9 embittered 68:4 8:22 25:17 31:14 Exceedence 13:24,25 63:3,27 19:13 27:8 29:6 55:7 58:25 emergency 6:3,5 11:20 32:34 37:33 39:27 Exchequer 48:17 fighters 6:20 56:22,24,33 33:4,5 36:13,19 44:1 David 19:1,5,16 21:3 emperor 59:33 53:28,29 54:30 EXECUTIVE 6:27 57:1 62:13 diversity 32:6 28:21 employ 28:15 61:21,31 65:3,4 62:30 63:16 65:27,33 fighting 26:16 division 59:6 Declaration 19:34 20:5 employed 11:16 29:30 everyone 9:4 21:15 23:5 F figure 29:7 30:34 40:7 document 32:34 33:32 29:14,18,26 employment 18:22 20:30 28:27 29:9,14 30:28 fabulous 66:4 48:16 51:27 34:33 36:12,14,17 Defence 11:9 12:16 55:8 25:1 59:15 60:8 31:12 32:17,25 36:14 face 3:4 60:11,12 figures 38:7,8,12,30 38:1,20 39:14,20 66:9,19 enable 25:1 38:25 63:33 64:21 faced 62:12 40:33,34 41:23 40:2,11,30 41:33 Deirdre's 37:10 enables 66:17 everything 26:26 29:25 facilities 23:4 58:13 file 45:20 42:13,17 44:23 Deirdre 36:27,28 enclosed 45:14 30:34 31:12 33:10 62:6,7,8 filing 8:4 documents 45:16,18 37:9,15,22,28 encounter 26:21 57:32 58:4 59:10 facility 39:34 66:11,12 filled 67:33 does 3:2 8:9 12:6 13:13 Delahunt 22:19 encountered 61:5 61:15,32 65:9 facing 30:22 66:18 final 12:5 56:22 57:22 18:30 29:19 36:28 Department 11:3 16:27 encourage 14:25 31:12 evidence 56:28,29,33,34 fact 14:3 15:31 29:24 finalised 10:18 12:4 37:18 38:20 40:7,30 18:18 29:29 40:34 encouragement 1:14 evolved 59:5 32:28 44:13 47:29 finalising 9:19 44:7 49:16 54:21 41:1,4,16 46:7 encouraging 34:9 exactly 7:24 32:4 51:15 53:27 56:18 financial 22:30 23:25 61:15 67:7 47:16,19,20,26 end 2:13 11:33 16:28 51:15,16 57:5,7,8,9,11 59:15 24:8,14 30:27 65:23 doesn't 10:31 44:31 48:14,17,29,30,31,33 24:34 32:24 38:9,11 example 32:21 34:15,30 63:16 65:25 find 17:1 25:11 35:30 51:13,22,24 57:4 49:6,12,21,23,29 39:31,34 40:29 42:24 47:8 48:1 factored 13:4 38:7 41:20,21 42:12 65:20 51:10,12,23,31,32 41:12,31 48:10 50:28 examples 22:10 33:31 factories 52:28 45:2 50:3,19 51:27,34 doing 8:17 18:5 21:4 52:11,21 53:3 53:4,16 59:19,26 exams 40:15 factors 13:1 57:11,12,16 56:3,28 61:8 27:6,9 28:2 29:31 54:1,2,11 60:2 67:32 65:12 exasperated 16:16,18 factory 62:23 findings 21:23 30:6 37:28 38:25 DEVEREAUX 9:11 endeavour 61:8 excelled 32:20 facts 39:6 49:15 finds 53:15 39:3 47:18 61:13 16:31 ended 35:9 59:9 excellent 25:22 26:29 failed 32:7 fine 7:10 27:32 43:6 63:17 Diaspora 35:32 endorse 37:9 28:18,22 29:21 failing 8:16 68:5 48:14 50:8,20,34 don't 3:16 5:24 6:2 Disclaimer 1:1 endorsed 6:31 32:17,26 42:24 62:6 fair 7:23 57:32 60:11,29 51:4,24 52:30 54:27 8:14,18,29 9:12 11:22 Disposals 9:3 energy 61:3,8 except 10:7 64:20 67:26,28 55:32 56:1 59:18 12:30 17:2,31 18:2,24 DIRECTOR 7:23 20:32 enforcement 20:14 21:33 executives 65:30 fairest 61:14 60:4 66:9 25:11 26:12,19 40:9 42:26 46:23 engage 22:25 57:1 exercise 16:31 17:14 fairly 4:23 7:2 36:17 fines 52:5,7 53:16 62:13 27:3,12 33:33 36:28 47:2 48:34 52:27 engaged 25:12 30:17 18:4 30:21 39:30 51:26 55:18 fingers 5:15 37:15 42:3 43:6 53:2,22,26 60:27 engagement 12:10 exhibition 34:24 fairness 48:10 finish 30:25 65:8 67:15 44:17 46:16,29 48:26 65:16 engineer 21:21 exhibitions 35:17 fait 65:9 fire 6:20 40:6 41:23 49:15 51:1,3,8,31 DLRCC 24:32 25:12,23,24 28:2,5 existence 2:23 fall 33:29 56:22,24,32 52:5,10,15 56:32 Doyle 1:33 2:23,28 4:26 engineers 9:26 13:10 existing 40:3 falls 6:11,14 57:34,1,6,8,11,21 59:6,25 60:10,11,17 55:21 65:14,16 67:30 19:13 20:33 22:29 expanded 25:13 35:31 false 40:6 41:23,24 59:26 61:25 62:13 61:20 63:17,19,34 Dublin 39:11 62:2 24:3,4 38:27 familiar 27:34 28:8,23 64:5 66:13 64:23 Dundrum 66:18 enhance 25:31 expanding 38:29 33:2 34:19 40:28 firemen 54:30 57:12 done 3:23 9:18 Dunlavin 23:12 enhancement 19:22 expected 41:21 families 16:16,23 21:31 59:28 15:9,10,12,17,34 17:7 42:19,20,22,23,27 20:23 expedite 65:29 56:22 57:19,23,25 firmly 6:27 18:12 19:11,17,18 45:5 60:28 enjoy 56:2 expenditure 58:34 61:26 62:15 first 3:5 4:1,22 5:19 9:11 22:15 25:26 28:12 Dunne 4:13 enormous 3:23 63:12 47:17,21,30,32,33 family 1:29,32 2:1,24,28 11:19 14:10,15 18:21 29:5,7,16,17 30:8,10 Dunnes 28:2 enough 8:34 20:14 26:19 48:15 49:22 50:16 3:1,7,12,14,18,20,25, 19:4,9 25:21 26:28 31:18,22,23 32:29 E 37:13 44:4,9 53:4 51:5 28,34 27:11 28:8 29:1,3 33:17 34:15 35:4 each 9:24,28 10:9 11:25 58:4 expenses 51:1 62:17 4:5,8,9,17,24,34 5:3,4 30:28 34:21 36:5,31 37:12,19 12:24 13:33 22:4,6 ensure 1:4 23:4 51:30 experience 15:31 18:19 26:20 31:9 56:3 35:3,22,25 42:33 39:25 44:31 49:28 27:5,8,19 33:5,19 enter 22:6 57:1 25:12 60:10 58:32 61:23,25 57:33 58:8 60:1 62:9 50:4,14 52:9,19 56:1 36:13,33,34 38:16 entered 56:33 57:4,8,9 experienced 55:26 56:4 65:5,13,17 fit 23:30 44:29 57:29 58:22,24 59:6 40:18,20 51:11,32 entering 57:15 expert 46:2 famous 49:3 fits 41:3 61:17 62:2,31 63:25 63:20 entire 66:16 expertise 11:17 fantastic 5:17 36:28,30 fitting 1:14 64:11 65:12 66:20,21 earlier 40:21 47:3 53:1 entirely 18:29 explain 11:10 52:21 55:28 58:11 59:14 five 5:34 7:23,24 8:31 door 26:13 41:20 57:1,4 56:6 59:11,23 60:7 entitled 61:16 63:21 explained 7:16 49:16 far 6:4 9:18 20:34 43:6 19:13 20:9 24:9,14 63:30 early 40:29 43:13 environmental 12:10 explanation 7:22 10:20 farming 3:13 31:18 36:1,12 doors 40:5 eastern 10:31,33 11:30 environs 16:8 22:7 farmland 11:27,28 37:26,29 38:24 53:7 doubling 9:33 43:27 13:16 equal 22:34 express 4:16 5:21 8:19 fasten 25:31 56:11 63:8 65:29 doubt 46:1 58:24 easy 61:2 equally 17:28 37:21 67:2 father 1:25 3:7 4:26 66:1 down 2:20 6:26 9:19 echo 26:11 28:7 31:7 49:24 extend 2:23 3:18,32,34 fault 48:32 fixed 22:13 54:3 12:11 15:23 18:23 43:18 equates 27:5 4:5 13:19 43:29 favours 61:16 flagged 15:31 52:34 19:2 26:24 29:4 economic 22:34 38:10 equipment 30:13 57:14 extensive 48:6 fear 29:2 flexible 46:10 39:10,19 40:25 39:31,33 41:10,13 error 15:7 extensively 16:8 feasible 31:24 flooded 17:20 42:19,20 50:17 55:26,27 errors 1:5 extinct 35:12 feat 2:17 flooding 11:27 14:29 51:23,31,33 52:31 economy 44:3 55:14 essential 43:9 extra 38:30 42:26 43:29 fed 12:1 16:13 17:1 15:26,27,29 53:31 54:6 66:4,24 66:17 establishment 32:32 67:2 fee 47:6 16:15,18,22 17:9,23 download 14:19 education 3:13 24:24 estate 18:10 extraordinary 2:4 37:11 feedback 33:3 41:9 floods 10:23 12:27 13:27 downs 54:23 61:11 46:13 60:33 estates 40:4 extreme 14:9 feel 8:14,18 27:3 32:8 14:34 16:20 17:34 downturn 55:14 effect 67:31 estimate 12:26 extremely 54:30 63:11 34:3 49:24 50:22 18:32 55:7 draft 10:18 12:2,3 16:13 effectively 8:28 10:15,30 estimates 12:34 eye 58:1 51:33 62:27 flow 12:25 13:10 36:23 37:32 38:7 58:12 estimating 13:6 eyes 30:22 feels 68:5 fobbed 49:11 39:30 41:3,8 45:30,34 efficiency 52:20 estimation 12:25 East 6:18 56:23,25 feet 32:23 focus 39:28 40:17 41:29 dragging 52:31 effort 42:24 46:25 58:8 ethos 20:24 57:3,24 59:27 67:25 fellow 44:9 64:5 45:19 drain 35:3 67:24 euro 27:8 31:17 47:22 Eddie's 57:33 felt 8:13 19:23 47:18 focused 11:21,22 51:32 drama 2:6,7 efforts 26:15 62:14 Eddie 3:24 4:11,17 5:29 49:12 follow 13:13 35:16 40:20 dramatic 7:21 eight 26:16 even 3:30 8:9 18:2 30:3 6:16,20,23,25,26,28 ferry 4:3 49:26,27 50:7 draw 21:12 63:28 either 28:16 43:17,22 31:23 36:9 44:18 54:17 56:7,28 festival 5:30 followed 49:13,29 drawing 51:33 51:29 52:16 59:24,30 57:19,27,34 58:2,30 42:3,8,20,22,23,24,25 following 1:1 29:16 42:6 drawn 26:24 41:27 elaborated 35:6 60:20,27 61:3,15,30 ,27,31,33 47:13 57:11 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 73

food 25:9 18:14,15,18,21 20:27 29:3,26,28,29,30 grants 31:32,33 43:34 48:1,4,9 51:19,34 heart 27:33 28:32 footage 2:19 24:8 25:1 26:24,26 31:30 32:4 36:33 49:23 54:6 52:10,16 53:3,7,1 heavy 8:8 football 2:13 59:5 27:8 30:26,34 31:1 37:16 39:16,26 40:10 graphs 13:11 hadn't 35:13 49:8 52:15 hectares 9:3,6 footpath 22:12 26:34 33:20 37:13,26 41:8,28 42:4,6,12,18 grasped 61:1 53:20 heed 27:22 27:1 30:6 42:2,10,15,32 43:34 44:16,21,32 great 1:10,15,16,19 2:8 half 10:7 26:21 32:11 held 1:27 29:24 49:23 footpaths 21:27,32,34 43:7,15,25 44:8,21,25 46:34 47:31 49:26 3:30,31 4:2,12,23 35:22 43:29,30 44:1 helm 6:28 66:22 67:33 30:8 45:2 49:13 50:24 51:5,15,21 5:12,14 28:30,32 62:13 help 3:30 10:20 21:6,14 for 51:31 67:21 53:19,23,30 32:21 35:27 38:7 hand 13:34 14:5,17 22:6 24:5 26:3,24,26 29:9 1:2,11,13,16,18,19,25 funds 38:3 48:28,30,31 55:7,10,16 57:29 39:3,16 49:7 57:30 28:8 50:11 58:8,10 30:31 31:1,6,31 32:9 ,26,33,34 51:33 52:13,15 55:10 58:17,24,34 59:26 58:25 59:18 60:1 63:34 35:29 37:27 39:13 2:5,6,12,16,28 funeral 1:27 3:5 4:1,12 60:6 60:14,16,17,28,29 handled 4:28 57:6 64:31 65:19 3:7,20,28 4:9,21 further 1:28 8:2 10:11 gets 28:32 31:12 66:3 65:34 66:22 handover 67:33 helped 20:20 5:6,19,20,26,30,33,34 11:26,29,31 14:22 getting 26:32 28:3 greater 33:8 hands 29:27 62:31 helpful 40:19 60:21 65:8 6:2,6,11,23 8:18 9:19 15:15 25:27,31 34:31 31:10,34 36:1 37:28 greatest 42:8 62:32 happen 9:18 12:30 13:9 helping 64:16 10:1,7 47:29 52:23 64:12,24 38:22,33 greatly 61:25 67:13 14:22 39:29 49:7,29 her 2:32,33 11:12,26,27,28,31 future 1:20 13:3 14:32 43:1,12,13,28,31 green 28:8 30:5 58:10 50:18 53:29 55:10,23 3:1,6,7,29,30,32 12:4,28 19:12 20:31 22:20 44:1,7 48:25 49:3 greenway 60:26 59:25 60:6 64:30 4:1,2,4,5,22 9:30 13:7,15,19,26,33 29:10 31:2 42:10 51:20 52:25 53:3,5,12 grievance 49:6 65:20 17:31 23:19 26:15 14:16,18,33 49:22 52:7 55:17,19 60:24 ground 11:27 12:14,15 happened 7:12 12:20 28:29,31 32:4,9,15 15:10,11,12,21,22,26, 56:5 61:7 girls 8:10,30 13:9 38:33 34:21 50:22 51:9 37:11,13,15,25 40:26 28,33 65:6,10,12,23 67:13 give 10:5,19 15:34 group 2:6,7 4:8 16:9 52:13 55:11 56:23 here 1:23,34 2:8,25 16:4,7,10,21,22,23 Facebook 36:2 19:16,18 26:23 18:34 57:10 60:2 61:32 3:3,11 4:8 5:14 6:20 17:34,1,14,17,18,23,3 Fail 4:8 57:27 58:30 33:1,3,31 34:20,30 19:6,10,17,26,27,29,3 happening 12:32 39:5 7:2,18 8:10,11 9:16 3 18:14,15,18,2 Farmhouses 34:20 37:15 38:12 39:32 1 55:6 14:16 15:19 16:8 fora 33:9 Fáilte 1:9 44:11,32 45:14 47:1,7 20:5,13,15,20,29,30,3 happens 13:26 18:32 18:4,24 19:10,29 22:7 forces 60:26 61:4 February 7:30 47:24 48:1 56:2,29 59:34 2 21:34 23:6,13,14,28 happiness 67:32 25:18,34 26:28 27:23 fore 32:22 35:2 56:15 Federation 19:28 62:22 65:24 24:6,15,32 25:7,30 happy 8:20 25:24 35:30 29:20,25,26,30 forefront 15:22 Fein 8:21 given 1:18 4:27 8:30 9:29 26:26 27:28,32 54:25 58:16,20,30 30:21,29 31:5,28 foremost 33:17 Fianna 4:8 57:27 58:30 10:27 12:4 16:33 28:22,28,29 29:11 59:1 61:7 63:6,24 32:6,10 33:3,10 35:10 forfeiting 62:16 Film 23:18 20:34 26:21 27:17 31:11,28,30 65:2 37:27 38:28 40:18,25 forgetting 25:18 Finally 25:6 27:28 28:30 28:19 37:13 42:34 32:4,9,14,15 33:23 hard 8:7 52:32 59:7 42:12,19 forgiven 61:12 58:24,30 43:5,15 48:5 52:5 36:6 38:18,19 63:20 43:16,19,27,30 46:5 forgot 65:28 Finance 11:3 18:18 54:18 55:31 56:34 42:15,16 44:11 45:30 harm 16:34 41:32 47:1 49:10 50:2,10,22 forgotten 61:12 31:33 32:1 40:3 57:3,9,11 46:1 50:5 54:26,27 has 4:28 5:29 14:3 51:5,9 5 form 46:4 50:25,29 gives 10:23 52:20 55:32 56:1,7 57:27 15:8,21,24,25,27,31,3 heritage 32:32,33 formal 12:4 15:11 Firstly 56:8 giving 19:4 25:17 31:28 58:30 4 17:8 19:5 33:1,4,7,8,9,10,11,12, 23:6,14 28:24 29:22 Fitzgerald 28:27 32:17,23 34:27 38:33 groups 19:29 23:13 20:29,32,34 21:28 15,17,19,20,21,22,24, formally 10:27 24:10 42:1,2,32 43:2,11 43:32,33 44:4 27:18 32:6 34:11 27:4 29:12,23 31 34:2,6,16,18 42:25 Flood 9:9,20 10:14,18 glad 25:12 36:10,22 37:6,24,25 30:8,10,12 33:30 35:20,21,25,26,29 format 3:21 41:3,8 11:9,12,19,21,22,34 global 13:3 43:15 44:24 45:9 35:20 36:5,6,7,21,29 formed 19:27 12:2,3,5,8,9,11,12,16, globally 35:32 67:22 36:7,14,19,27,34 37:13,16,22,25 44:2 former 3:21 18,26 gloves 62:31 growing 54:24 37:16,19 38:16 39:27 herself 37:24 formula 13:25 13:12,19,20,21,33 goals 38:6 grown 31:24 40:31 43:4,7,15,16 higher 8:27 forum 32:32 33:22 14:3,7,8,9,24,28 goes 14:19 17:8 35:11 growth 62:6 44:26 45:19 46:6 highest 8:29 36:6,9,22,29 15:1,3,8,10,13 39:10 47:4 48:34 guard 4:18 48:19,26 52:5 53:11 highlight 5:23 19:16 forward 25:13 30:30 16:9,19,26 54:6 57:32 guidance 10:21 23:20 54:17,19,24 55:27 highlighted 11:30 16:7 31:6,13 32:5 33:26 17:11,12,17,19 going 1:24 2:23 5:14 6:17 guidelines 38:34 47:19 56:10,12 57:20,25 42:34 50:27 36:19 37:20 40:12 18:5,6,7 37:32,34 9:18 11:21 13:7 guilty 26:12 58:5,23 59:5,16,33 highlighting 26:11 40:18 52:7,17 60:5,33 61:1 40:32 45:15 46:11 16:6,13,22,32 19:2 guns 58:10 hasn't 15:29 37:13 highs 54:28 63:1 65:12 55:8 66:8 25:17 26:1 guts 68:8 have him 2:18,19 3:16 5:30 forwarded 22:18 Florentine 55:13 58:20 28:19,25,27 29:9,14 guy 8:9 57:20 1:10,11,15,16,18,21,2 28:5 46:26 fought 32:28 66:16 30:21 31:17,30,33 guys 25:26 57:15 4,31 3:3,16,17,23 54:19,21,22 58:27 found 4:22 22:3 25:10 Formulate 24:14 32:5,9 33:26 34:14 Gaeilge 1:10,14,16 4:17 5:19,26,33 60:21 61:16,22,25,30 35:13 50:3,20 59:22 Fortune's 46:34 35:9 36:18 37:20 Gael 54:27 55:32 56:1 6:12,34 8:4,8,28,29 62:10,30 63:13,22,24 60:21 67:9,27 Fox 28:7 39:6 40:13,19 43:12 Gaol 34:27 9:11,12,18,26,33 64:16,32 65:2,27,29 founder 3:23 FORTUNE 7:7,8,9 29:11 44:1,19 46:5,32 47:12 Gardaí 21:14,33 10:25 67:32,33 68:6 four 28:8 32:11 33:28 40:17 46:9 48:26,34 48:10 51:5,21 GAA 2:9,11,16 4:26,28 11:1,3,7,12,29,31 himself 2:20 56:29 63:29 36:8,13 52:13 54:15,33 59:4 54:12,16 56:9 GALLAGHER 6:11 12:3,5,14,24 64:1 friend 8:8 Friday 21:17,23 42:7 57:4,5,7 58:26,27 46:20 13:6,10,12 14:34 hindering 21:34 friendly 28:9,10,11 G 59:26 60:2,15,23,33 6 Gentlemen 37:8 15:14,22 hint 18:24 friends 2:2 3:18 gained 50:31 gold 31:11 Georgian 34:29 16:18,19,21,25 hire 48:9 from 1:9,23 2:19,32 3:15 gallery 19:2 gone 8:31 17:11 31:8 GIS 35:6,9 17:7,9,11,25,29,31 hired 48:2 5:3 8:31 9:9 10:23 gaps 42:21 35:14 42:11 43:12 Glasnos 3:15 18:11 19:1,11,17,30 hiring 48:2,8 12:15 14:23 16:6,27 gardens 14:3 44:26 47:3 50:27 Glynn 46:24 20:33,34 his 2:1,2,5,8,11,13,17,24 17:16 18:19,21 gateway 24:34 52:1 God 43:34 56:3 59:19 22:8,18,23,33 25:26 3:15,16,18,25 4:13,18 19:29,30 20:6 gathering 33:32 good 4:20 31:13 32:30 Godfrey 1:26 26:3,9,24,25 5:29,30,31 6:16,17 21:17,31 22:20 26:24 gauge 38:25 35:3 38:12 41:12 GPO 32:29 haven't 12:1 36:31 42:14 42:32 54:17,20,22 27:7,14 28:23 gauging 12:24 42:16 44:4 46:31 Greystones 4:1,4 9:17 44:17 55:30,34 59:22 56:12,23,25,29 29:28,30 31:5 33:5,10 gave 5:26 6:18 9:33 54:23 55:6 56:4 10:3,4,7 19:27 23:10 68:8 57:22,24 58:5,10,32 34:24,25 35:34 14:17 32:27 48:14 59:31,32 62:32 64:34 28:22 29:15 37:2,7 having 6:32 61:22,25 62:12,16,21 36:12,13,14,20,33 63:12,13 65:11 43:34 45:7 55:21 8:5,6,10,11,33 16:15 63:1,6 64:31,32 37:7,19 39:2,12,24 general 10:9 27:7,12 goodwill 5:32 58:8,9,14,15 61:33,34 35:9 36:5 39:20 49:6 65:5,13,17 67:30 68:4 42:4,5,8,10,19,20 67:9 68:5 got 4:1 7:9,16 12:34 62:10 66:8,10,20 50:8,27 62:12 historic 5:13 43:5,8,12,18,26 generally 13:27 14:34 20:33 25:34 H hazard 11:34 13:21 historical 12:21 15:25 44:8,15 46:18,20,21 18:9,20,25 54:22 31:33 37:26,33 42:15 habitat 35:1 he'll 28:19 59:18 60:4 history 5:13 16:21 front 25:11 36:14 51:21 generate 34:7 44:30 45:2 48:17 habitats 33:11 head 52:2 54:13 55:2 19:16,34 20:13 55:30 generated 35:11 49:22 53:9 54:20 had 2:18 3:1,5 4:12,18 heading 4:27 51:1 hold 22:19 66:25 full 6:27 19:23 20:30 generates 43:10 55:32 58:11,25,32 5:4,12,14,15 6:23 headline 11:8 holding 50:11 23:18,26 29:26,30 generating 35:6 60:34 61:21 64:31 8:7,21 15:26 16:2,8 heads 57:4,6,8 home 28:32,33 54:24 36:19,23 47:31,33 generation 46:25 68:8 21:27 22:14 27:6 health 3:2 27:1 49:15 56:24 59:15 60:8 generations 16:23 governance 60:15 28:23 29:2,3,4 30:29 healthy 54:25 63:6,29 homeless 5:32 fully 3:15 25:2 31:17 generous 3:16 government 24:29 48:31 31:10 32:23 34:27 65:2 homes 9:22 55:8 37:21,24 49:34 gentleman 29:1 32:29 62:22 66:32 67:7,20 35:16,17,27,34 36:28 hear 4:31 48:34 49:2,11 honest 48:29 49:7 52:18 function 13:21 63:20 gesture 5:32 grand 53:22 54:3 37:4 38:18 39:18 50:8 59:27 62:11 honestly 63:24 fund 18:12 42:2 get 7:1,4,22,23 8:18,28 grandchildren 2:24 40:6 41:8,24,33 67:27 honour 61:11 funded 33:19 45:4 9:17 14:33 16:6 17:1 grant 42:4,22 43:5 47:31 42:13,33 44:1,28 45:9 heard 3:16 27:3,4 42:14 hope 7:21 22:19 27:4,7 funding 11:3 21:9 25:16 26:23,26 48:12,23 50:6 54:12 46:24 44:17,24 49:32 56:29 35:18 56:2 60:4 16:6,22,27,29 27:1,6 28:26,30 47:18,20,24,29,31,32 60:12 63:29 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 74

hopefully 29:10,22,27 28:11 29:32 32:24 instance 13:15,26 17:18 it's 1:10,14,15,23 3:1 journalists 50:19 land 11:28 16:23 30:26 36:34 39:31 33:17 37:17 38:23 26:2 38:29 48:1 62:2 4:29 5:14,22,33,34 journey 3:30 17:19,20,21 55:32 58:24 60:25 39:15,34 44:22 48:16 instead 48:4 52:31 68:8 6:2,26 8:10,27 junior 26:24 18:4,7,8,9,11,19,23,2 62:21 53:11 55:17,22 58:34 institution 60:34 10:4,14,18 12:6 13:14 jury 57:16 6,28,29 28:3,4 hoping 29:23 34:29 61:34 65:1 67:9,23 instructive 14:1 14:1,30 15:10,12,17 just 1:14 2:6 3:14,20,25 64:2,25,27,31 35:31 importantly 19:11 instrument 14:22 16:5,16,25 17:9,22,26 4:25,33 landowners 14:31 18:17 hospital 3:30 imposed 7:10 48:11,15 instrumental 2:4 18:31 25:16 5:1,11,20,22,24 6:26 lands 9:22 16:28 hour 43:29 54:3 intend 8:34 27:23 26:9,12,19,21,29 7:10 8:2,8 10:26 18:15,19,24 hours 58:31 imposing 48:14 intended 1:3 27:13,33 15:6,33 landscape 35:10 houses 8:15 14:3 15:28 impossible 58:33 intention 24:34 28:4,7,8,11,16,29 16:4,7,14,18,27 23:34 language 1:13,23 7:21 16:15 27:24 31:31 impression 48:16 inter 38:11 29:14,16,17,32 25:17,21,26 26:12,14 49:10 34:22,23 38:29 58:22 improve 20:4 21:6 26:8 interact 67:21 30:1,30 28:7,17,27 large 18:9,10 35:27 51:5 housing 8:14 18:9 27:19 32:19 40:16 interaction 17:30 31:22,28,30,33,34 29:20,21,23,28 largely 40:33 24:6,15,16,25 25:16 41:33 67:4 interest 26:19 35:26 37:5 32:2,5,7,18,24 33:16 30:1,20,25 31:25,29 larger 45:22 66:7 31:29 32:3,8,10,11,14 improved 29:16 38:7 46:24 61:14 35:10,22,27 36:1 32:17 33:7 larvae 35:12 40:4 45:32 66:10 improvement 54:8 interested 1:17 37:4 item 6:26 7:4,9,27,30,33 34:15,20,30 35:21 last 1:33 2:12,23 how 1:27 8:7,29 10:21 improvements 22:10 38:34 39:2,17 52:19 9:3,6,9 42:1 46:12 36:4 37:5,8,11,16 3:2,16,24,30 13:30 14:24 56:10 64:8 48:4 54:10,16 56:14 38:27,28,29 39:4,17 5:3,12,16 6:12,18,30 18:18,23,28 21:6,8 improves 66:17 interesting 25:10 40:11 items 47:21,24,25,27,29 40:26,32 42:2,19,21, 8:2 15:27 19:11 30:20,30 33:18 34:30 improving 27:14 54:28 48:5,32,33 53:2 56:9 justified 52:32 29:15 30:17 34:16,20 35:30 36:15 inaudible 15:19 34:28 interests 36:13 61:13 57:34 65:19 Jack 21:22,26 35:22,34 36:30 39:3,15,21 40:7 include 17:20,21 20:1 interface 24:25 its 2:23 12:24 13:27 James 4:2 37:11,14 45:2 45:8,9 49:2,23 40:5 44:24 46:23 interim 47:19 62:12 19:22,24 20:7 23:25 Jane 61:7 56:7,11,22 57:24 50:15,20 included 15:8,15,16,29 international 43:4,31 66:25 January 7:28 59:27 62:1 63:8 65:3 51:25,27,28,33 25:3 30:20 66:27 itself 14:20 36:17 44:2 Jazz 43:4,24,26 44:5,6,13 66:2,31 68:5 52:12,32 60:9,15 includes 9:21 38:2 58:15 internationally 43:8 56:18 Jenny 42:7 late 1:26,32 3:7 6:12 62:27 including 19:17 24:29 internet 55:15 I'd 1:32 2:23 3:10,27,34 44:12,26,29,34 48:12 however 30:29 53:3 26:4 interventions 14:29 4:4,7,11,21,34 5:11 Jim 3:10,17 56:34 later 2:13 5:27 8:24 huge 1:26 4:12 5:13 inclusion 20:10 30:13 interview 6:17,19,30 6:15 8:31 16:27 19:4 John 19:1,6,18 28:21 34:29 39:26 16:21 20:21 29:23,24 inclusive 22:33 56:23 59:27 25:15,22,29 26:11,28 June 39:12 47:25 laughed 8:22 30:8,10 31:8 incorporated 34:25 into 2:19 6:28 11:13 27:3,32 28:17 30:28 K launched 35:21 37:13,14,26 41:9 increase 67:13 12:1,24 13:4,7 36:29 37:5 keep 9:1 18:34 27:19 law 10:23 11:2 42:16,21,24 46:24 increased 42:2 16:12,13,20 17:1,9 38:27,28,34 28:19 32:29 34:29,30 laying 9:19 55:13 60:24 62:22 incredible 37:19 25:16 27:18 29:10 39:2,13,17,21,24,25,3 61:4 layout 26:1 63:32 incur 52:30 31:8,31 32:15 33:23 0 42:32 43:18 keeping 2:1 51:4,7 leabairt 1:15 hugely 55:18 incurred 62:17 34:26 35:9 36:30 52:6,8,20,23,29,32 kept 2:23 13:14 lead 10:27 16:12 18:24 humour 4:20 indeed 5:1 9:22 10:10 38:23,30 39:19,33 54:22 58:30,32 59:1 key 19:22 27:30 32:25 60:26 67:7 hurling 2:12 4:2 37:26 38:3 43:31 40:12 42:17 46:25 61:22,29,30,32 33:28,30 34:2 35:1 leader 24:29 25:6 hurt 57:25 54:26 66:13 67:1,25 50:5,10 51:20 52:7 62:9,11 63:5,33 36:5 40:23 leadership 60:17 hurtful 6:18,29 56:25 independently 24:5 54:20,33 55:8 64:8,15,17,24,32 65: keyboard 46:29 65:18,30 57:23 64:11 indicators 38:21 40:33 56:12,14 57:9 58:15 I'll 4:30,31 5:19 7:23 kick 45:31 56:22 leads 12:6 15:23 hydraulic 13:6 indictment 2:22 59:26 60:24 62:19 10:13,21 11:10 13:30 kilometres 28:9 learn 40:4 65:11 hydro 13:11 indirect 37:26 64:5 66:16 16:33 19:16 21:3 kind 4:22,23 33:12 34:23 least 43:9 46:22 51:4,8 hydrological 12:9,20 individual 4:20,23 19:32 introduce 19:4 38:15 25:20 26:7 33:1,22,31 35:11 40:19 52:8 53:9 54:11 hydrometric 12:22 35:9 37:11 60:11 41:27 37:32 39:30 41:15 49:1,16,18 59:25 60:9 57:34 hype 39:6 individuals 33:22 introduced 19:34 47:5 42:31 43:2 kinds 35:4 leave 18:1 41:24 42:26 Harbour 9:3 55:21 indulgence 65:3 introduction 33:7 44:26,27,32 46:28 knew 2:28 3:1 44:31,34 51:31 58:15,17 61:34 62:7 industry 44:5 invaluable 26:33 27:9 51:26 53:1 65:34 knocking 26:13 leaves 62:15 66:8 ineligible 47:30,32 investigated 52:25 I'm 1:20 3:27 6:4,25 know 1:10 3:29,30,32 led 2:4 47:4 60:16,17 He's 54:17 48:2,5,15 investigates 50:10 8:10,15,26,27,28 4:1,22 5:22,23,26 left 17:31,32 18:20,26 High 8:8 12:29,30 inflicted 57:25 investigation 6:28 13:7,30 15:29 8:7,17,29,34 9:12 42:22 55:17 58:13 14:9,32 38:1 41:17 influence 9:21 56:19,20,22 16:18,34 18:34 13:34 16:23,31 legal 19:24 46:2 62:16 45:7 57:22 61:11 influenced 13:20 investigations 56:19 25:10,12 26:12 27:34 17:2,9,29 19:1 20:11 legend 14:6 Hollywood 60:29 inform 4:28 9:18 13:17 investigative 50:19 28:8,17,22,27,33 25:23 less 5:24 6:5 8:9,27 33:2 Hotel 21:11 33:33 35:10,14 39:30 investment 5:24 62:21 29:22,23,31 31:9 28:4,12,15,17,18 54:7 66:27,32,33 House 19:30 information 10:9,10,11 invited 46:16 32:22 34:14 36:4 29:5,27 30:1,9,17,25 let 4:31 5:19 25:20 28:17 Hundreds 66:7 12:1 13:12 14:33 involved 2:7 4:19 5:4 39:12,17 42:6,7,17 31:4,30 32:3,19,27 30:9 44:26,27 46:28 I 16:33 17:10,16,25,30 7:14 10:15 11:7 43:6,19 44:23,26 33:1,33 36:30,33,34 50:21 52:18 53:1 idea 31:11 34:23 36:4 18:17 20:25 21:21 20:19 27:12,19 33:2 46:2,31 49:8 50:20 37:18,34 38:27,29,33 61:28 65:3,14 38:12 52:16 65:29 24:30 32:4 36:7 39:27 51:34 51:13 52:3,12 53:18 39:6,10,24 40:13 42:3 letter 22:4,6 46:20 49:22 ideas 58:2 33:30,32,33 52:3 54:30 60:22 54:26 56:9 58:2 43:34 44:17 45:5,8 54:11 identified 17:11 21:32 35:1,9,11,25,28 involvement 34:11 59:11,19,26 61:7 46:6,17,24,28 48: letters 51:6 54:1 41:18,21 involvements 36:10 63:1,11 knowledge 13:9,17 16:16 level 33:8 38:1,2,33 identify 16:3 21:18 36:22 44:16,18,22,32 involving 33:20 42:24 I've 2:32 3:28 30:2 31:10 20:34 39:1 41:17,21 55:26,30 identifying 35:1 52:3,10,11,12,16 inward 62:20 46:16 55:26,30 58:24 known 2:31,32 67:12 ignore 55:1 64:24 inwards 12:1 60:12 64:16 67:9 3:3,10,12,28 4:17 levelled 54:3 illegal 64:11 informative 25:22 28:22 irregularity 51:2 ICAN 35:23 9:20 13:14 14:3 levels 12:23,25 22:26 illegally 27:14 informed 50:15 51:28,34 irrespective 62:30 Ireland 2:6 3:11 10:32 17:11,12,19,34 35:6 libraries 66:13 image 35:12 informing 7:10 22:3,7 isn't 15:10,16 17:2 28:16 12:15 19:28 35:22,24 64:16 library 66:13 imagine 32:13 51:14 informs 17:20 29:23 43:12 53:26,31 44:14 52:9,19 55:14 knows 14:2 43:34 53:11 lie 57:3 imagined 51:20 infrastructure 16:17,18 64:22 62:8 64:12,13 65:30 59:19 lies 16:33 imbalance 42:21 18:21 issue 6:27 7:19,24 15:21 Irish 1:9,10,13,20 34:29 Kare 19:29 21:18,22,31 life 2:4,8 21:9 22:34 immediately 11:23 inherited 54:15,34 16:7,14 26:9,12,15 59:19 28:3 35:23 49:1 61:7 impact 54:7,8 62:20 inheriting 54:34 27:30 31:6 48:27,28 J KAVANAGH 26:28 lifeline 42:15 impacts 16:3 initiated 33:16 49:33 50:10 51:34 jersey 4:30 27:28 44:16,20 50:22 lifetime 38:2 63:7 impaired 30:2,9 initiative 3:22 31:11 57:19 60:24 63:2,18 job 24:34 47:31 48:1,3 62:11 light 30:5 41:13 49:33 impairment 22:1 60:32 issued 47:16,19 48:28,31 54:23,28 56:4 58:33 Keith 4:2 lightly 59:7 impairments 30:5 injured 29:2 50:13 59:1,18 61:2,13,14 Kelly 21:22 42:33 like 1:12,32 2:22,23,28 implement 16:13 66:31 inner 59:34 61:22 issues 5:4 16:6,15,16,19 67:33 Kilcoole 10:3 23:10 3:10,14,27,34 implementation 20:2 innovative 55:23 67:16 17:17,26 20:29 21:19 jobs 5:24 8:26,27 22:15 Kilmac 4:27 4:4,7,11,16,21,34 22:24,27,32 23:3,6 input 9:17 35:28 36:23 24:28 25:17 26:4 57:29 60:8 62:23 Knockrobin 16:14 5:11 6:15 8:5,18,22 24:27,28 33:23 36:7 inputs 17:33 28:31 30:4 36:22 63:17 KWETB 46:14,17 60:32 11:8 13:12 14:7 16:1 implemented 29:14 inquiries 3:31 45:20 38:19 41:11 45:34 join 51:10,14,19 52:20 17:33 18:21 19:4 63:32 64:7,12,17 46:3 51:2,4 52:10 L 20:19 25:15,22,25,29 61:20 53:22 63:5 labour 11:16 implication 49:15 inquiry 56:14 64:4 54:29,34 55:5 joined 25:23 53:6 26:1,11,19,28,33 ins 57:34 57:22,23 59:6 lack 26:15 52:3 59:22 27:3,32 28:17 29:20 importance 25:31 joining 47:6 51:16 lad 43:13 important 1:16 9:19 10:4 insignificant 14:31 60:14,28 61:5 joint 12:28,32 30:28 33:23 34:15 16:4 19:23 27:25 journalist 50:8 36:2,29 37:9 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 75

38:27,28,30 46:30,31 47:4 53:29 38:3 45:10 51:7 39:8 42:12 51:3 move 7:27 12:24 19:9 32:4,9 40:11,21 43:18 39:21,25,30 40:14,20 63:30 64:8 65:10 66:5,24,28 67:7,15 54:33 59:11,26 61:34 30:30 31:6 45:10 45:8 49:4 41:7 42:32 43:11,18 lose 53:3 manager 4:32,33 6:16,21 65:19,20 50:21 54:16 59:18 Museum 35:23 liked 61:20 losing 39:11 53:5 49:4 54:18 met 3:29 21:33 25:24 60:4,33 62:31 Myth 2:8 likely 13:31 14:29 18:5,6 loss 1:29 3:1 4:24 48:17 56:8,20,23,32 29:1 32:23 moving 28:19 32:32 N 38:8 41:18 50:24 61:27 62:13,20 57:2,10,30 58:25 methodology 33:18 34:24 60:5 64:15 name 32:20 48:33 likes 13:9 44:8 lost 6:20 50:6,31 62:8,23 60:21 61:3,19,30 metres 29:2 much 8:13,19 10:20,31 names 33:12 37:29 limited 26:20 lot 3:4,5 8:23 9:21 10:13 63:16,18,19,29 64:32 metrics 15:33 18:31 narrative 56:29,30 57:16 line 12:11 13:13 14:2 12:29 14:7 65:34 66:2 67:31 38:4,7,15,16,23,27,29 25:9,21,27 national 1:21 33:7 23:30 63:31 15:22,24,26 16:15 managers 57:28 61:31 ,31,34 39:4 40:32,33 26:11,12,21,27 35:11,14 38:15,33 lines 13:12 17:30 19:29 22:15 manner 4:23 37:22 41:6,7,18,27,29 28:13,18,20 29:17 41:26 43:21 47:5 links 24:30 25:4 38:3 25:9,22 29:5 30:2,22 manoeuvre 30:19 middle 14:1 22:11 26:2 30:28 31:7,25 nationally 40:34 39:9 41:15 32:1,30 34:19 37:5 many 1:34 2:2,5,18,20,29 might 13:15 18:11,28 33:17,21,33 34:3 nationwide 10:30 33:18 lip 29:27 38:30,31 39:1 46:25 5:14 20:20,29 28:31 26:33 30:26 34:19 36:27 37:9 38:17,22 native 1:17 list 8:14 15:6 32:3 36:18 48:8 50:14 51:21 30:1,6 45:8,9 52:15 36:9 38:9 41:7,12 44:3 45:29 46:28 nature 16:21 54:23 54:24 54:28 55:6,10 56:2,6 56:12 58:9 61:8 62:3 44:34 46:3,14 52:30 49:26 54:21 59:15 near 22:20 listed 15:19 33:10,28 57:29 58:3 59:14 65:1 66:9 55:1 62:16 65:30 60:27 61:30 62:2,7 necessarily 17:17,21 34:14 36:14 42:19 60:10,33 61:12 map 10:32 11:30,31 mightn't 61:14,20 67:27 63:10 67:21 18:1,11,12 51:27 47:25,26,29 51:8 56:9 62:28,32 63:8,20,27 13:34 14:6 18:5 mile 67:2 multidisciplinary 42:24 53:31 listen 63:33 64:6 65:9,11,25 66:20 35:6,9 million 58:21,23 62:14 multiple 34:12 necessary 16:17 55:10 listened 43:2 67:24 mapped 12:25 14:7,12 mind 14:7,10 27:25 municipal 9:34 19:13 57:29 listening 25:8 29:13,17 love 39:24 52:20 18:7 32:12 43:6 52:30 27:5,7 28:12,34 29:6 necessitated 7:20 56:28,33 loved 32:18 57:23 mapping 10:18 13:21,33 59:19 60:11 33:4,5 36:19,33 37:3 neck 28:18 listing 33:32 low 11:27 12:29,31 15:23 14:18,28 15:7,9 mine 58:3 42:10 43:5,24 44:1 need 6:27 7:16 8:23,28 lists 32:10,11 lowest 53:31 56:15 maps 10:20 11:34 13:33 minimum 23:28,30 45:3 9:12 15:10,17 21:8 literally 47:9 lows 54:29 56:11,15 14:5,12,24 16:2 minor 11:7 48:1 50:33 music 42:3,8,33 23:29,33 26:22,23,25 literature 25:4 luck 56:4 63:29 65:5,13 17:32,33 51:4,8 54:8 43:1,11,22 44:24 29:32 31:6 32:8,14 little 1:23 8:9 20:14 lucrative 62:12 mark 2:16 9:9 minute 11:10 45:6,7 46:13,25,29,30 35:3 37:15,18 28:4,7 31:23 32:28 lying 15:23 15:20,21,33 16:30 minutes 1:4 7:27,30 musicians 42:8 40:12,15,16 44:5 33:23 35:12 39:22 Lakers 32:20 18:31 25:25 66:34 43:29 must 4:19 8:4 49:34 46:17 49:12,24 50:22 42:10 56:4 Lalor 21:18,22,32 market 18:29 51:15 mis 51:1 57:3 61:27 51:8 60:14,16,17 live 21:8 24:5 31:10 Lastly 26:7 massive 30:3 51:22 missed 2:1 3:32 15:6 mutual 58:1 65:30 39:19 40:21 66:29 LAWLESS 31:7 46:16 match 13:3,13 62:27 missing 26:34 44:20 myself 30:33 31:29 42:33 needed 29:22 31:18 35:3 liveable 66:26 Leaving 40:14 matches 4:3 mission 19:21 38:6 65:18 46:32 54:25 55:32 needless 58:28 lives 6:20 21:6 29:19 Lee 19:1,5 materials 34:24 mistake 13:2 50:9,11 57:34 62:23 needs 3:31 6:28,29 22:15 55:8 62:13 Leinster 5:12 matter 6:7 7:19 14:23 mistakes 50:20 65:11 Maguire 56:34 29:5,7 30:10,27 31:19 load 53:9 64:4 LEIGH 21:4 22:18 18:18,28 47:3 48:26 mitigated 48:10 Malone 20:19 37:17 40:18 43:22 loads 50:4 53:30 Livcom 66:26 49:8 59:8 61:21 mobility 22:1 26:20 March 1:7,10 7:20 22:25 50:31 56:15 60:15 lobbied 20:29 Lord 3:21,22 4:19 63:22 64:24 65:25 31:33 24:16 35:34 36:29 negative 60:25 61:4 lobbying 55:9 Lots 29:16 35:11 36:9 68:1 mock 40:15 45:28,29 46:1,5 62:19 66:3 local 2:25 10:24 11:6 40:17 50:5,19 60:14 matters 8:2 37:25 modelled 13:10 47:16,25 50:13 negatively 55:18 16:26 17:18,26 18:34 66:12 maximum 23:28 modelling 13:6 17:23 Margaret's 20:20 negatives 8:12 19:5,10 20:34,7,29 M mean 12:28 14:25 modern 1:11 Margaret 20:19 negligence 62:13 21:15,33 22:3,24 machinery 48:8 40:24,25 62:21 moment 5:6 10:18 Mary 54:24 61:7 neighbour 64:2 23:5,12,13,28 machines 48:9 meaning 40:24 12:1,8,11 16:14,15 Matthews 9:7 37:1,29 neither 48:16 24:4,27,29 25:6 mad 8:31 means 8:12 12:34 39:20 28:9 32:10 38:8,24 Maverick 59:34 network 35:23,30 40:13 28:2,15 30:4,8 31:31 made 3:5,21 6:13,19,30 meant 8:20 29:4 32:5 41:3 58:18 66:14 May 1:5 5:14 9:21 11:8 networking 20:29 32:2,11 33:8,9 34:8 9:20 14:18 22:10 measure 12:27 18:5 money 5:21,22,24,32 13:9 14:31 18:14,17 networks 20:32,33 37:27,32 38:10 26:5 27:15 28:29 38:16 39:5 26:8 27:28,29 31:18 21:23 22:8 never 50:11,15 51:29 39:23,31 40:3,27 29:29 33:19 37:24 measurement 38:4 39:4 37:16 43:7,9,12,14,26 38:11,15,32 41:27 52:30 56:32 58:4 41:10,13,28 44:10 42:13 46:4 47:11,29 40:24 41:29 44:11,18,28 46:30,31 44:32 46:3 49:22 60:22 61:21 62:12 45:21 49:25 51:34 49:9 50:10,11 54:14 measurements 13:11 47:11,33 50:14,31 53:9 65:5 63:2 57:28 59:16,22 60:8 55:34 57:24 59:6 41:27 52:26 53:5 58:3,4,15 Maybe 3:17 8:23 11:27 nevertheless 3:2,6 62:14,22 63:16 66 61:20 62:8 63:20 measures 20:10 65:24 66:32 25:29 27:8,13 29:28 new 16:1,17 19:27 20:11 locally 17:24,29 64:23 65:11 measuring 12:23 39:2 monies 42:22,26 30:17,18,20 31:22 26:1 28:8 33:28 located 34:24 magnificently 66:33 meat 52:28 monitoring 12:23 39:3 33:2 38:28 39:26 35:12 36:1 37:17 location 15:31 mail 7:9,20 8:3,32 10:11 mechanism 17:34 month's 64:24 41:6,32 44:13,34 45:8 38:15 40:11,12,16 locations 9:24 47:2,3 53:13 mechanisms 11:22 month 4:26 5:25 6:5 46:14,18,34 54:13 45:17,20,22,27,28 log 35:27 main 4:18 8:27 11:4 media 25:2 45:19 63:8 45:29 65:34 55:5 57:4,5,6,7,8 66:13,19 logged 12:25 18:22 20:9 29:1,3 medium 12:29,30 monthly 45:10 63:15 64:6,15 65:10 newly 65:6 logic 48:2 54:13 maintenance 11:14 meet 30:26 months 5:16 7:18 9:32 68:7 news 64:7 long 3:29 4:3,13 7:4 48:19 54:7,8 meetings 1:3,4 9:30 16:9 14:23 47:13 50:8,14 Mayor 3:21,22 4:19 newspaper 50:3 18:31 27:33 29:13 major 3:3 21:32 27:11 36:8 42:33 63:26 64:16 65:6 McDonald 3:14 next 4:30 5:15 46:29 49:30 54:24,27 66:11 member 2:11 3:23 4:3,4 68:1 5:19,20,29 6:5 26:11 9:15,18,21,32 10:21 55:9 58:30 61:7 majority 63:5 19:6 36:33,34 63:20 more 8:8,16,21,28 37:1,29 12:11 14:13,27 15:32 62:20 make 8:12 10:21,26 64:29 10:9,10,13,14,20 McLoughlin 18:22 24:9 26:7 63:6,7,24,29,30,31 13:1,2 14:15,23 20:20 members 2:25 4:25 19:11 21:15 23:4 37:7,8,21,30 43:30 27:22 28:11 31:18 64:8,12 65:2 21:15 23:4 24:27 5:33,34 7:2,5 8:11 27:6,24 28:4 30:12 46:33 33:4,26 36:8 42:5,16 longer 9:12 25:30 26:5,34 27:18 9:11,29 10:3,6 16:8 31:19,23,24 33:23 Meeting 1:1,7 7:27,30 44:10 62:1 64:24 look 1:18 6:32 29:18 37:8 39:28 19:9,10,26,30 20:11 35:30,31 37:11 8:2 21:11,21,26,28 65:33 68:6 12:28,29,34 42:13 44:27 47:14 25:30 26:3,22 29:20 39:15,22 41:18,27 22:20 23:23 43:24,29 nice 44:18 13:11,15,26 14:7,29 50:9,20 51:22,24 30:26 31:9 32:27,34 42:7,10 44:11,32 44:32 45:8 46:9 night 43:24 15:6 16:19,28 17:2 52:18 55:10 57:5 36:20 37:34 39:31 50:19 51:13 52:8 48:28 49:6,9 50:5 nobody's 64:33 18:8,14,15 24:34 60:6 63:21 40:1 41:7 44:9,31 54:6,29 56:2,11 59:14 51:26 52:12,14 56:7 nobody 61:27 62:9 25:13 26:33 27:14 makes 14:7 44:13 60:1 45:15,22,25,28 62:8,19 63:15,21 64:6 57:22 64:24 68:12 nominated 37:7 46:21 32:15 33:28 36:30 making 3:31 8:26,27 46:7,14,21 50:25 67:24 68:5,6 Mermaid 45:6 non 33:21 36:6 67:3 37:12 40:31 41:2,28 17:21 20:7 23:24 53:34 56:6,16 morning 3:12 4:1 38:18 Michael 44:26,27 none 42:11 54:29 43:28,32 44:2,7 45:20 27:24 45:30 51:32 62:24,25 63:5,19 51:26 Minister 65:29 nor 12:2 48:17 50:6 54:20 55:23 55:23 64:26 65:20,33 most 7:11 19:23 29:14 Ministers 26:24 norm 50:16 60:14 62:29,30 man's 2:16 66:3,5,7,21,28 30:34 31:7 35:1 41:3 Minute's 5:8 normally 10:25 52:30 64:15,24,34 man 4:14 56:2 60:27 67:6,8,9, 42:27 55:27 57:32 Miriam 19:1,2 28:21 north 9:6 13:16 65:10,12,23 61:3 68:9 membership 19:26,32 58:11,21,34 59:31 32:15,28 not 1:3 2:1,6 3:11,27 looked 11:25 27:8 31:19 manage 44:6 men 64:20 68:7 60:21 66:26 MITCHELL 50:33 4:29 6:3,11,32 33:12 44:28 53:19 managed 11:3 mention 26:7 44:13 mostly 12:17 13:21 61:29 8:3,5,10,19 10:18 54:2 59:25 60:14,15 management 9:10 10:15 55:21 57:15 59:24 mother 2:33 4:28 Mohammad 62:32 11:10,20,22,26 12:6 looking 16:22 18:15 11:19,20 65:28 mountains 15:22 Monday 7:30 13:7 14:31 27:28 29:17 31:19 12:2,3,5,11,12 14:28 mentioned 1:18 8:4 mouth 39:4 Murphy 19:4 26:15 15:7,12,15,16 40:27 41:13,26 15:3 20:16 28:2 33:8 11:10,13 15:7 33:15 mouthful 20:5 28:29 29:12 31:30 16:22,34 17:5,17,21 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 76

20:14 22:6 offence 8:4,17,32,34 ordinary 7:27,30 overlooked 43:16 58:8,22,31 61:33,34 33:15,18,27 38:2,3 23:3,28,30,34 26:21 offer 3:14,27 24:1 8:5,6,11,17,30 50:17 overrun 68:10 63:8 66:25 39:24,28 40:27 27:3 28:13,27 offering 34:9 64:13,14 overseas 35:32 parties 6:13 37:4 41:2,17,26,28 29:30,31 30:1 31:9 office 8:10,30,31 25:25 ordination 11:4 overseer 21:22 partly 11:6 plant 48:8 38:20,25,32 26:16 28:30 29:2 organisation 22:26 32:20 25:12,23,24 partners 9:16 10:15 11:6 platform 65:23 39:4,12,15 40:5,14 32:28 40:23 45:25 60:15,16 oversees 36:6,7 parts 34:11 64:9 play 4:2 5:15 27:25,30 42:33 43:14,28,30 officer 8:14 19:14,31 organisational 59:11 overview 10:19 19:11 party 8:21 29:23 33:18 46:29 44:4,9,14,15 46:18,31 20:30 22:19,29 organisations 24:31 own 2:32 4:26,34 9:22,29 pass 1:32 21:3 67:24 notable 20:29 23:16,19,23,26 33:22 34:11 10:1,23 16:25,26 passed 1:33 3:24 4:26 players 2:8 4:3 note 1:4 6:26 26:14 28:23 24:12,19 29:24,26 organise 30:34 17:15 19:1 26:13,19 59:28 playground 60:28 43:24 45:10,13 37:22 46:20,23 organised 2:18 5:22 31:31 34:8 40:31 passing 1:25 2:11 playgrounds 30:12,14 noted 61:15 50:25,29 56:34 45:27 43:6 48:18 54:19 4:22,31 5:1 66:13 notes 10:24 official 1:3 49:9 52:13 other 1:31 2:8,17,27 4:16 56:29 65:5,16 66:25 passion 2:6,8,16,17 playing 2:13 nothing 8:5,12 11:20 53:1 5:2,4 10:4,30 11:6,31 67:24 past 12:17 30:18 46:24 please 25:7 56:3 27:5 39:20 40:25 officials 58:6,33 62:24 13:15 15:19 17:1 owners 16:23 18:28 66:3 pleasure 2:18 42:34 43:31 47:9 64:15 18:25 19:29 23:13,19 ownership 66:16 paths 22:15,16 plenty 11:7 61:11 55:28 67:1 often 13:30 31:20,23 24:32 25:13 28:31 O'BRIEN 1:12 8:1,2 patterns 55:15 poem 43:13 notice 35:29 63:8 29:16,20 30:26 31:27 O'Halloran 21:22 pay 51:13,19,21 52:20,30 point 2:32 7:9,21 8:26,27 notices 24:17 old 42:4 44:30 32:24 33:12,21 37:17 O'Neill 3:26,27 27:31,32 62:16 10:26 15:6 20:19 notified 52:7 once 3:29 18:29 56:7 39:25 40:13 63:26 64:23,25,30 paying 53:23 59:9 25:17 27:22 28:13 notify 53:34 62:8 41:2,11,28 65:10 pedestrian 26:2,3 28:34 30:17 37:14 39:17,24 now 6:32 7:19 13:25 one 4:19,20 8:32 10:4,7 43:6,15,18,32 44:6 O'Sullivan 3:20,21 30:3 40:22 44:15 47:11,12 14:23 15:34 16:18 12:4 13:17,22,24,26 45:5 46:3,7 4:11,17 pen 3:18 54:19 60:25 63:30 18:5 22:11 23:18 14:8 15:25,26 17:9 52:5,9,15,19 October 21:11,33 47:19 pension 62:12 65:7 25:29 28:24 31:33 19:26 53:15,16,18 61:1,2,15 48:27 49:34 54:10 people's 9:17,22 18:28 pointed 21:26 41:9,32 36:19 39:25 43:5,14 22:14,15,16,17,33 66:34 67:18 Okay 1:24 5:10,19,33 27:1 30:22 pointing 8:22 44:23 45:25 48:2 26:3 29:32 30:14 others 33:2 37:1 41:2 6:6,7,12,14 per 17:18 24:9 36:8 points 12:4 20:9 25:25 52:6,7,10 53:9,23 33:29,30,31 34:6,33 44:8 63:15 7:3,6,24,27 9:4,7 53:7,8 27:11 29:21 49:11 55:7 56:20 57:22,23 35:34,20,25 otherwise 18:10 62:14 15:20 16:30 32:32 percentages 13:30 pole 22:11 58:28 64:5,23 67:11 36:12,17,28 67:12 36:33 37:7,29,30,32 perfect 64:33 policies 20:1,10 33:34 number 1:26 2:32 6:26 37:5,9,11,12,20 our 1:17,23 2:25,32 3:13 41:30,31 44:34 45:4 perfectly 48:29 45:28 9:15,21,32 13:33 39:9,11 40:3 45:18 4:24 5:1,2 9:16,29 46:10,12,33,34 53:1 perform 43:14 politics 3:29 15:22,26,28,32 18:10 46:13,14,22 50:23 10:15,23,26,27,32 54:16 55:31 65:32 performance popular 4:14 20:3 35:24 37:14 51:1,17 52:5 11:30 12:4,34 13:9 68:10 38:13,16,21 population 66:27 38:19,29 40:6 53:28,29,31 54:28 16:13 Oliver 1:12 performing 39:23 portrayed 1:3 41:23,24 42:17 55:9,10 56:24 57:14 17:12,15,16,17,20,21, Operations 46:20 perhaps 5:2 position 8:3,8 23:18 25:6 45:17,22 46:12 47:24 60: 24,25,34 18:30 OPW 9:14,18,25,29,31 period 13:30 18:6 31:23 29:28,30,33 37:4 52:5 54:16,34 59:6,7 ones 16:2 19:23 32:18 19:1,5,6,9,16,21,26,2 10:5,15,23 48:19 62:22,25 66:22 46:15 49:25 57:29 60:23 61:32 62:6 53:20 57:23 66:7 8,29,31 11:2,16,25,29 12:9 67:3,17 65:15 66:33 ongoing 24:27 53:8 20:13,23,29,31,34 13:14 14:27 15:4 permanent 67:33 positive 8:12 21:28 25:12 numbers 13:24 14:12 online 14:23 34:18 21:15,23,31 22:10 16:2,31 17:10,21,31 permission 1:19 15:28 65:1 32:5 45:21 35:21,24 36:29 41:3 25:32 26:7,8,23 18:1,5,8,18,20,23 35:3 possession 2:19 numerous 3:6 only 2:1 7:18 10:6 11:30 27:13,24 29:27 55:10 permissions 15:34 23:30 possibility 15:28 38:22 N11 66:7 18:7,9,32 23:4 27:34 30:6,14,19 Ordnance 12:15 person 21:4 24:10 49:14 N81 39:8,10 41:15 28:5 29:24,27 31:34 31:1,2,9,12,19,24 Outpost 45:7 29:30,32 32:23 36:28 possible 1:5 27:30 NAMA 28:4 32:12 34:11 38:33 32:3,4, Oversight 38:15,33 37:10,18 59:16 61:29 29:6,22 37:3 38:25 Newtown 5:12,13 42:6,31 43:32 44:11 ours 39:27 41:26 63:10 41:1,2,6 44:16,23 Newtownmountkennedy 45:34 47:12 50:13 ourselves 13:10 14:27 P personal 16:15 55:26,30 46:8 52:24 55:2 65:2 23:11 52:11,27,28 53:20,27 17:11,16,29 page 24:30 25:2 65:7 post 25:25 26:16 28:30 NFA 12:29 54:10,20 56:19,20,21 out 5:28 7:20 8:19,22 paid 8:28 48:19 62:7 personally 56:14 29:2 32:28 Nolan 3:34 5:10,11 7:28 57:10 63:26 65:6 9:32 10:15 11:30 66:33 persons 23:20 31:32 potential 16:3 9:4 67:8 12:8 13:1,6,11 pained 61:25 perspective 49:25 potentially 16:19,20 Nora 2:33 onto 14:17 19:9 14:3,29 15:6,24,26 paltry 43:30 phase 27:22 35:5,6 17:20 November 6:12 21:17 onus 16:25 32:2 16:4,10,26 17:1,28 panel 8:19 44:28 philosophy 49:1 powers 10:24 47:18 onwards 1:23 18:8,20,29 21:26 paper 3:18 39:16 48:9 phone 3:6 practice 23:31 34:6,8 NRA 48:31 open 10:6,9 30:22 34:27 25:13,17,24,25 51:34 63:28 photography 35:17 practitioners 34:28 O 35:27 47:6,32 51:15 26:5,32 27:17 28:33 paperwork 10:18 photos 21:18 22:7 prayers 2:26 objected 49:3 52:18 67:34 29:14,31 30:6,10,12 paragraphs 7:17 pick 34:14,15 48:32 pre 57:14 objective 9:17 10:19 opened 66:19 31:1 32:1,13,23 parameter 17:23 picked 44:21 predict 12:25 11:1,19 12:5 14:33 operated 59:22 61:22 33:9,18,26,27 parameters 12:24,25,26 piece 18:11 26:34 predicted 13:13 objectives 12:2 29:19 operates 17:22 34:12,14,15,22 35:30 13:22 17:14 pilot 10:30 prefer 44:31 38:6 operation 39:21 45:29 36:14,15,17 38:6 parking 21:27,32,33,34 pink 10:32 preferable 46:14 objects 33:11 52:24 57:21 66:5,20 40:30 26:2 pipe 17:18 premises 22:4,6 obligation 10:24 11:12 67:13,23 41:4,9,20,21,24,3 27:11,12,13,14,15 place 4:1 9:15,24 11:14 preparation 12:12 32:32 32:3 operative 60:22 outcome 11:13 22:18 parks 35:11 66:12 12:5 13:22 23:10,12 36:7 38:10 obligations 32:5 opinion 8:20 27:29 62:32 outline 45:14 parlance 59:5 28:25 30:4,7,21 33:12 prepare 36:21 obliged 17:28 28:15 opponent 62:30 outlined 32:10 57:20 parochial 44:15 39:32 46:1 54:11 prepared 11:34 12:3 observed 59:8 opportune 45:22 outlook 65:1 part 10:32 11:25 12:6 62:9 66:29 21:8 22:4 56:9 61:28 obviously 4:7 8:3,13 opportunities 22:34 outputs 39:33 14:32 23:18,30 24:17 places 35:26 55:16 60:34 64:28 25:26 28:31 29:13 59:15 outs 40:7 25:1 29:24,31 plain 12:18 preparing 33:4 42:14,21 43:2,5 48:32 opportunity 1:15,16 3:10 outset 2:31 30:17,18 32:11,21 plains 12:16 presence 4:18 54:27,30 55:18 56:3 10:25,27 11:7 outside 18:12 48:8 57:2 35:23 36:5,8 38:2 plan 12:5 16:8,10,13 present 6:11 19:10 36:18 60:20 61:31 67:6,33 15:30,31 17:5 25:30 outstanding 47:24 39:23 46:17 48:3 17:8,9,12,16,17,20,25 presentation 9:9,12 occasion 4:9 62:19 63:1 26:3 32:17 39:32 over 2:20 3:2,6,11,30 56:18,19,20,21 58:34 18:8,11 20:2,3 10:13 15:21,33 16:4,5 occasionally 59:33 67:7 41:9,10 60:34 63:22 4:17 5:14,16,21 8:13 65:19 21:12,14 19:2,3,9 occasions 3:6 56:12 59:7 65:24 67:30 9:15,18,21,32 partake 47:6,11 22:24,25,27,32 23:7 25:9,15,17,21 26:29 61:5 opposition 62:25 12:21,23 14:13 participate 22:34 24:14,28 25:29,32 27:3,10,17,32 occur 1:5 13:31 option 48:14 15:27,32 16:22 26:15 participation 23:12 32:33 28:18,22,23,28 occurred 50:33 options 12:2,11 14:28 28:27 34:21,31 35:16 34:10 33:1,4,7,8,11,16,19,2 29:11,13,17,21 30:28 occurrence 12:31 15:3 61:1 46:11 48:19 49:8 particular 5:25 12:26 0,24,26 31:4,8,25,28 50:18,19 orchestrated 59:10 50:13 55:5,6,13,14 13:30 15:29,30 25:34 34:6,10,16,27,33,34 32:18,26,27 33:1 occurrences 12:32 order 7:9,22 14:24 15:34 56:11,15,21 58:10 26:26 33:32 43:6 35:20,29 36:5,7,21,23 36:26 37:8 40:26 occurring 15:27 38:16 60:22 62:31,33 45:32 46:6 47:31 37:11,23,33,34 presentations 9:11 20:6 occurs 12:26 ordering 51:12 63:3,27,31 64:18 48:24 57:31 58:15,31 38:2,7,8,10,11,16,31 presented 24:8 off 30:25 37:14 38:33 orders 5:19,20 67:26 63:16 66:1 39:8,13,16,18,21,30,3 president 2:11 39:4 43:7,14 49:11 6:3,6,15,25 57:8 overall 10:30 13:4 32:34 particularly 8:4 26:32 2,34 40:27,31 41 press 51:28 51:31,32 52:2,29 40:26 30:8 37:17 45:22 plans 11:19,20 12:3,12 pressure 39:9 57:28 62:31 65:8 overlap 33:29 54:29 55:14,21 15:3 18:14 pressures 66:31 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 77

presume 37:33 promotion 20:9 24:5,16,26 26:14,20 20:20 29:18,27 54:10 57:10 59:28 retiring 5:21,25 56:8 pretty 55:16 proofing 24:21 27:2,11,14 32:19,20,22 61:33 65:26 59:18,30 62:11 prevents 21:4 proper 52:25 57:7 60:24 28:1,10,15,34 33:23,26,30,32 relationship 65:19,21 retract 6:29 previous 33:15,27 38:21 properly 59:16 63:18 30:2,5,9,22 34:10,23,25 35:22,28 relatively 11:27 45:27 return 13:30 18:6 42:34 properties 12:18 14:7 31:31,32,34 38:23 39:14,18 44:2,9 51:4 returned 56:30 57:16,17 previously 6:23 29:2 18:10 32:3,9,10,11,13,21,24 55:22 60:4 relevance 40:31 46:6 returns 5:31 53:30 57:19,20 58:18 property 12:17 35:26,29 36:9 39:4 realtime 1:1,2 relevant 21:18 22:7 review 12:8,24 22:24,28 price 51:12,17,20 proposal 5:26 24:8 30:26 42:5,9,17 43:6,29 reason 10:7 24:31 25:2 38:30,32 23:6,9,14 24:17,26 53:5,10,25,28,31 33:3 42:29,30 43:25 45:9,20,30 46:31 reasonable 27:5 50:16 relies 44:8 28:24 29:22 30:17,20 prices 18:29 48:25 proposals 38:28 49:4,27 52:16 53:26 reasons 45:18 56:1 religion 3:29 38:9 41:11,31 53:3,12 46:15,24,26 Planning 1:11,18 11:12 recall 7:14 29:15 48:28 remained 56:21 45:18,23 46:3 priest 2:20 propose 31:1 42:25 15:27 17:7 20:1 receive 7:11 9:9 19:2 remaining 46:22 60:18 reviewed 38:9 41:10 principle 49:7 43:29 46:27 22:29 23:28,29 24:17 received 8:2 32:34 42:6 remark 49:10 reviewing 40:28 print 38:1 64:7 proposed 7:28,30 9:4,7 25:16 35:2,3,10 36:18 43:26 45:17 remarkable 2:17 reviews 30:18 priorities 18:23 33:28 33:22 36:12 37:1 45:32 46:6 recent 49:3 55:27 60:1 37:16,19 revise 40:16 36:22 39:11 42:1 45:17,28 Policy 24:29 32:3 recently 1:24 2:19 19:18 remarks 56:25 57:23 revisit 64:23 priority 18:23 47:26 38:18,19 41:7,32 23:17 28:34 30:13 remember 21:8 22:11 revisited 61:26 privacy 45:13,16,31 proposer 41:30 45:13,16,23,30 46:1 40:4 45:26 28:17 32:22 44:1,3 rewarding 46:25 private proposing 42:21 50:5 51:26 56:7 recognise 58:32 52:14 55:7 58:26 ridiculous 65:30 18:9,10,17,19,20,25 prosecutions 45:26 Port 16:17 66:9 recognises 23:3,25 remind 28:19 right 5:30 7:25 13:34 51:6 56:9 63:9,11 prosper 61:2 PPPs 62:2,3 recognition 66:27 reminded 61:27 14:5,34 18:4 28:1 privately 18:23 protect 34:3 55:8 Promoting 24:20 34:6 recommendations 19:19 reminisced 2:20 49:14,15,19 51:10 privilege 66:34,1,22 protected 18:4 34:26 Q 24:27 25:15,18 remit 31:2 52:10,12 53:4 56:1 67:18 protecting 45:25 quarter 5:34 7:23,24 recommended 39:33 remunerated 60:9 61:13,14 64:21 67:8 proactive 26:32 protection 11:21,22 46:34 42:20 renewed 41:28 45:19 rightness 61:14 probabilities 14:9 34:27 queried 42:12 47:21 recommending 19:22 renowned 43:8 rights 22:34 probability 12:28,31,32 45:13,16,17,18,19,26, queries 48:8 53:16 record 9:20 26:14 34:26 rent 1:34 rip 52:29 13:24,25 14:6 18:6 27,31 46:2,11 query 40:6 42:11 49:12 37:25,27 49:8 51:29 repairs 30:6 rise 45:19 57:30 probably 17:5 20:11,33 58:25,27 question 7:18 10:5 12:6 59:8 67:20 repeat 5:15 31:27 56:9 risen 13:13 32:7 35:1 37:11 38:6 protest 43:3 14:13,34 15:16 16:31 recorded 8:6 35:13 replace 47:32 risk 9:9 10:14 39:21 46:7 47:4 protocol 5:23 6:13 24:16 17:5,31 18:4 44:23 recoup 47:33 replacement 40:5 41:20 11:12,19,34 53:27 58:21,22 proud 34:3 58:12 66:25 49:1,12,17,18,19,24,3 recreational 66:11 report 16:28 23:6,14 12:2,3,5,8,9,12,18 problem 7:19,20 proved 20:31 4 51:1 52:4 53:18 recruitment 29:28 25:15 27:17 38:7 14:28 15:3 16:9,19,26 17:18,19,24 21:32 provide 9:16 11:16,19 questionnaire 14:19 redirect 5:32 40:30 45:10 67:28 18:2 46:9 67:11 43:30 46:28,29 49:28 24:24,25 32:7 67:21 questionnaires 14:17 reduce 54:12 66:32 reporting 11:4 river 10:31,32 11:8,9,31 58:4 provided 23:21 43:7 questions 7:16 17:9 reduced 48:12,23 49:23 repositories 35:24 12:23 13:16,21,27 problems 15:23,25 66:11 18:30 22:8 40:2 46:6 66:33 represent 61:33 64:13 14:2 15:8,12 17:18 16:18,22 22:16 27:34 providers 24:26 49:16 50:22,23 56:21 reduction 50:24 representations 45:31 58:27 28:1,33 29:15 54:34 provides 44:15 64:18 refer 12:14 16:14 18:11 46:4 rivers 12:22 13:11,12,16 procedure 30:14 45:13 providing 9:30 23:19 queuing 53:30 40:7 representative 22:20 14:13 procedures 29:27 39:14 quick 40:2 referee 62:30 33:5 34:22 36:20 road 16:17 27:2 45:17,18,23,25,28 provision 24:16,24 46:21 quickly 7:2 15:23 refereed 2:16 46:13,18,22 65:6 30:3,5,10 47:16 48:1 49:26 50:7 52:1 public 1:3,16 5:21 9:21 quietly 37:22 reference 3:5 17:12 representatives 1:16 50:6,14 process 9:14,16,17,19 10:6,9 11:6 14:15,16 quite 2:32 7:21 14:9 16:8 24:15 46:21 53:10 36:12,13 50:3 63:17 roads 7:24 13:27 18:21 10:1,14,26,27 15:8 18:9,15,21 24:24 31:9,34 35:7,14 41:2 59:32 60:9 represented 24:5 36:9 41:16 47:21 48:31 11:1,3,10,16,17,25,33 26:4 27:12 39:8 46:25 48:5 54:28 referred 12:27 17:24 reps 19:29 58:33 49:1 53:16 12:1,6 15:12,13,16,17 41:15 49:8 50:7 61:32 63:11,21 50:23,30 65:10 66:3,7 request 5:19 6:15 27:4 role 23:26 16:34 54:18 58:33 59:8 Quotes 53:6,21,22 referring 42:19 46:20 28:24,25 42:32 45:30 27:13,19,26,30 17:7,8,10,15,21,22,23 60:12 63:7,9,11,17 QUIRKE 47:2 49:17 reflect 38:9 44:30 46:3 57:5 29:23,32 33:17 54:33 ,26 18:12,24,29,31 65:34 67:34 50:2 53:2,22,26 reflecting 59:17 requested 6:25 23:6 24:9 56:3 60:26 62:12 20:7,10 29:23 publication 34:28 reflection 8:15 requesting 6:24 23:14 63:16 67:9,24 68:8 30:7,18,20 33:3 publications 34:7 R reform 24:29 66:32 requests 18:21 roles 11:2 23:19 60:9 36:17,18,21 45:34 publicised 15:4 radar 50:28 reformed 20:15 require 18:10 roll 6:6 45:28 50:28 51:28,33 publicity 66:3 raided 56:19 refused 15:28 required 38:9 rolled 30:10 33:18 52:3,6,8 62:12 publicly 26:15 railway 14:2 regard 4:11 24:24,29 requirement 38:15 rolling 9:31 36:15 65:29,31 67:34 published 34:19 rainfall 12:21,23,29,30 30:31 31:2 40:32 requirements 23:24 41:4 room 29:25 57:14 68:7 processes 9:28 17:30 pumps 57:5,6 13:7 41:6,15,23 57:34 47:17 rotating 37:6 procession 2:17,19,22 punishing 51:23 raise 7:9 48:8 58:8,20 research 35:5 round 5:15 14:33 procurement 47:17,18 purchase 55:19,21 60:32 raised 26:9 45:34 46:3 regarding 8:3 9:9 22:20 resource 35:28 route 39:11 51:23 48:11 49:26 50:7 67:10 47:25 48:27,28 49:10 47:16 resourced 62:2 routes 39:10,11 52:21 purpose 23:30 52:10 54:10 regardless 31:14 resources 31:6 33:31 rows 59:34 procuring 47:5 49:14 purposes 1:2 16:21 17:33 raises 49:24 regards 2:31 15:24 39:28 40:3,4 rubbish 48:2 produce 11:23 17:32 pursue 67:12 raising 34:2 35:16 16:7,14,15,21 respect 8:29 49:16 55:32 ruined 65:25 32:9 34:34 pushing 8:4 60:27 ramp 22:17 26:15,16 31:22,29 32:4,6 38:33 58:1 rules 52:21 produced 34:25 38:32 put 3:18 4:20 5:26 11:14 ran 34:6 40:21,29 41:20 44:5 respected 1:27 run 10:13 20:9 57:34 produces 17:15 16:17,25 26:3,14 rang 42:12 regeneration 40:5 responded 66:33 59:16,22 60:4,8 producing 8:5,12,13 27:10,18 28:9 30:19 range 42:20 regime 44:30 response 11:20 47:25 running 36:29 41:28 36:5,8 32:22 36:31 37:25 ranging 42:20 region 10:31,33 43:25 49:28 42:23 52:18 58:11 product 49:14 53:24,26 38:12,20,30 42:26 rare 12:31 regional 11:6 responsibilities 11:2 runs 39:11 42:5 59:17 productions 2:8 43:9 44:31 46:25 rate 48:17 register 2:1 19:24 60:5 professional 49:25 54:20 47:7 49:13,25 51:29 rates 47:13 53:13 registered 53:20 responsibility 57:20,21 rural 14:31 16:20 professionalism 54:22,26 58:8,14,15,31 59:5 rather 3:4 34:14 39:6 regret 62:11 59:16 Radio 6:17,18,19,30 proffer 52:11 61:8 65:24 51:34 regrets 64:33 responsible 23:19 59:17 56:23,25 57:3,24 programme 9:10 20:14 putting 26:8 27:2 rating 12:24 regular 21:28 restrictions 23:25 59:27 67:25 41:20 30:4,7,9 51:24 rationale 44:21 regularly 58:16 result 15:11 17:15 22:10 Rathdrum 23:11 programmes 24:29 Padraig 19:1,6,16 22:14 raw 43:1 regulations 24:17 35:2 34:21 38:10 44:23 Rathin 1:11,18 progress 11:7,23 27:9 27:34 28:18,21 31:4 reactive 39:16 49:27 49:22 67:11 Rathnew 2:5,7,11,12 progressed 21:28 Paralympics 32:21 read 5:28 20:11 56:9 reinstated 23:26 resulted 62:13 4:26,28 14:3,16 16:8 progressive 55:22 Park 5:13 59:24 rejuvenate 66:17 results 17:28 23:11 48:2 project 8:22,23 11:1 12:8 Partnership 33:16,17 reading 40:2 relate 48:29,32,33 49:11 resurfacing 50:7,14 Reasonably 3:11 60:22 66:19 67:10 34:10 37:23 46:13,21 ready 9:9 related 38:7,11 48:24 retail 55:15,16 Redcross 5:3 projects 10:30 11:21 65:27 67:22 real 2:5 40:15 43:30 relates 14:5 47:2 48:27 retire 6:17 Reilly 19:1,6 20:3 24:22 66:4,7,20 Patrick's 5:30 54:20 relating 24:17 retirement 5:29,31 6:26 Relief 15:14 67:16 People 1:17 2:22 3:4 realise 25:12 32:22,29 relation 4:25 6:16,17,19 54:17,25 56:2 57:31 Representation 24:15 promised 36:30 8:6,20 9:25 14:17 57:33 63:3 23:33 24:17 37:25 58:31 59:1 60:20 Republic 3:15 promote 1:13,23 24:19 16:16 18:14,25,32 reality 17:32 38:28,31 39:30 40:26 61:22,30 63:6,24,30 Robbie 61:7 25:6 27:29 31:14 20:1,4,16 21:5,6,34 really 4:18,20 11:26 43:23 44:24 45:26,32 64:32 65:2 Robert 5:3 34:7 22:6,33 23:4 14:34 16:23 17:24 48:11,28 53:15,34 Roundwood 45:6 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 78

RPS 9:25 10:5 11:16,25 see 6:26 9:31 12:34 32:19,22,24,25 34:4 somebody 3:17 37:15 statement 19:21 38:6 suite 38:2 45:15 13:6 14:27,34 13:10,13,33 14:5 36:8 38:20,34 39:2 43:33 46:14 48:3 40:18 45:13,16 56:9 sum 34:10 RUTTLE 4:21 9:4 30:28 15:29 25:16,18 42:11 45:3 50:10 51:3 57:31 statements 28:7 40:25 summarise 22:27 42:19,30 52:29 26:8,13 30:20 46:19,21,22 47:3 somehow 51:9 states 42:2 56:34 57:2 summary 19:18 60:18,20 33:22,31 36:15 38:27 49:28 50:30 51:2,14 someone 31:8 49:1 52:21 station 12:24 56:34 64:5 sums 68:9 Ryan's 40:22 52:23,33 39:25 40:3,13 52:11,16,25,31 54:13 56:27 stations 12:23,24 66:13 superb 37:12 RYAN 39:14 40:13 41:16,33 48:9 51:7 57:24 59:14 60:6,7 something 4:29 statistics 39:5 supplied 47:7 44:13 52:4 53:21 52:32 55:2 58:1,17,26 62:15 64:18 65:11,28 8:12,13,24 15:6 17:19 status 10:19 11:33 supplier 53:28,31 54:27 65:28 64:7,15 shouldn't 16:26 59:25 25:11 26:4,9,17,19 statutory 10:24,27 12:4 suppliers 47:7,8 48:18 S seeing 60:23 show 1:17 8:18 14:1,13 27:33 28:16 29:7 14:22 33:21 34:27 53:12,28,30 sad 1:24 4:9 5:1 8:27 seek 25:34,2,3 33:4,26 53:11 57:6 64:8 31:23,30 36:6 supply 53:29 60:24 saddened 4:31 36:20 showcase 34:28 32:2,5,6,7,8,14 38:20 steep 66:18 support 5:16 11:16 sadly 2:1 64:4 seeking 16:29 showed 2:19 54:22 48:4 49:2,32,33 steering 16:9 20:5,15 19:7,21,28 22:30 safely 29:3 seem 47:11,14 52:21 showing 2:18 37:13 50:4,26 52:17 55:22 24:6,15 36:6 24:8,10,14,16,18,27 safety 27:1 49:15 seemed 50:33 shown 14:9 54:26 61:17,27 62:1 63:9 stepped 66:33 25:23 26:22,23 said 2:31 4:21 7:15 seems 6:33 16:1,18 27:4 shows 14:6,7,28 66:17 steps 10:21 14:27 30:25,26 31:17 8:7,10,11,17,21 52:20,29 61:27 side 14:5 35:25 39:9 sometimes 18:32 33:29 stewardship 56:12 65:17 37:17,19,26 28:13,27 29:1,16,22 seen 3:5 31:33 52:13 67:28 62:8 still 2:25 8:24 12:1 17:19 42:27,31,32 43:22 31:7,27 37:9,23 55:30 58:8 59:8 sign 7:6,27,30 48:21 somewhere 50:15 18:1 29:5 38:31 44:6,12 55:26,28 40:13,29 43:18,23 61:10,12 signage 21:27 son 4:4 51:20 52:12 53:5 58:25,32,33,34 60:28 47:24,30 49:8 selected 11:31 36:34 37:1 signed 45:30 48:24 54:3 sons 2:24 4:1 56:21 58:16 59:5,11 66:21 50:13,25,29 51:26 seminal 60:25 significant 12:20 14:30 soon 28:25 29:22 62:24 63:3 supported 44:11 55:19 52:1,27 58:9 60:7,12 send 5:11 51:2 sorely 3:32 stone 30:9 60:1 63:7 64:7 65:33 66:4 sending 5:21 signing 48:18 sort 15:34 18:20 29:14 stop 14:29 58:26,27 67:3 supporter 4:2,29 67:8 senior 2:12,13 5:12 49:9 silence 5:8 64:11 stopping 16:19,20 supporting 42:17 43:6 same 10:3 12:30 sense 11:9 47:14 silent 37:10 sorted 28:33 story 3:17 67:28 44:9 17:14,23 38:32 47:14 51:22,24 similar 24:31 52:10 sought 46:6 straightforward 36:17 supportive 54:20 48:17,25 51:11,17,20 sensitivity 12:34 13:1,3 simple 30:3 59:23 sound 44:14 strange 42:12 60:21,23 67:16 53:5,10,12,13,25,26,2 sent 8:32 41:8 42:13 simultaneously 9:31 south 10:33 42:34 43:1 strategies 19:22 38:6 suppose 16:7 36:5 40:15 7 61:10,21 47:2,25 53:12 since 8:2,3 16:17 21:28 spaces 27:15 strategy 20:26 48:34 53:2 54:2,20 sanction 47:26 48:11,15 sentiments 37:21 52:34 25:34 31:22 36:29 sparring 62:28 street 4:18 18:9,22 57:28 68:4 54:3 separate 15:17 18:12 43:12 54:21,33 58:23 speak 31:29 65:4,6 29:1,2,3 supposed 6:3 17:22 sanctum 59:34 61:22 25:2 34:34 67:1 speaker 65:3 streets 27:33 sure 13:2 16:34 25:10 sat 2:20 43:19 56:27 separately 17:2 67:24 sincere 5:11 speakers 60:18 strength 43:13 26:5 29:18,23 save 51:22 series 15:3 17:32 36:9 sincerely 20:21 64:7 speaking 27:2 29:25 stressing 22:4 32:18,22 39:12 42:13 saved 50:33 51:16 serious 49:21,23,33 single 37:20 56:14 54:22 strictly 18:18 43:19 44:26 46:2 saving 48:20 59:16 60:8 64:18,23 singular 55:15 special 30:9 37:28 41:32 strive 31:13 48:3 51:32 52:18 saw 22:16 44:29 60:1 seriously 8:24 sister 1:25 28:32 species 33:10 35:12 strived 67:3 53:18 58:2 60:1 61:8 61:21 62:13 66:34 servant 65:34 sisters 2:33 specific 10:14 14:13 strives 23:5 63:12,21 64:33 65:11 say 4:19,33 8:20 10:5 servants 63:8 sit 43:16 50:17 59:24 30:29 32:5 strokes 61:19 surely 16:22,25 50:15 11:19 13:9 16:16 served 63:12 site 55:17 58:10,21 66:16 specifically 11:10 31:2 strong 20:32 53:4 surfaces 58:12 18:18 25:29 26:19 service 1:2,4 21:17,31 sites 35:14 specification 49:15 strongly 61:1 surfacing 54:7 27:3 29:11 36:8 37:5 24:24,26 29:27 sitting 32:10 39:20 50:2 53:26,27 structure 40:27 surprise 3:3 40:6 43:19 38:24 39:1,17,34 38:3,21 40:9,33 41:17 situation 6:3,4 32:9,18 specifics 41:15 structures 34:26 45:21 surprised 15:29 40:4 40:9,31 41:32 43:4 54:18 57:21 64:1 speed 13:20 struggle 49:34 42:17 59:28 44:28 45:8 48:20 63:7,9,12,13 situations 32:21 speeded 65:31 stuck 25:16 58:9,10 survey 12:15 13:12 34:22 49:12,16,17,22,32,34 services 19:13,22,30,31 six 31:22,24 37:26 42:19 spend 50:8 54:27 65:24 students 67:11 35:5,7,9,13 50:17 52:13,17,18 20:4,7,23,33 21:12 47:13 50:13,14 64:16 spending 5:21 studied 15:13 18:1 surveyed 34:22 53:4,13 54:7,10,13,28 22:4 23:4,20,25,34 66:31 spent 5:22 62:14 65:34 studies 10:10,19,24 surveying 12:15 57:32,34 58:28,30 24:20,21,25 40:6 skateboard 66:12 split 38:30 11:20 13:2,9 17:7 surveys 12:9,14,15,16,17 59:4,17,18,22,27,31 41:23 48:20 62:14 skills 33:12 34:27,28 spoke 51:26 56:6 18:14 19:17 26:33 60:12,14 61:29,32 serving 4:3 skip 48:2 spoken 30:2 study 10:14,30 11:29 suspect 68:1 62:31 6 session 9:28 slice 44:29 sporting 62:29 13:1,15,19,31 15:9,11 suspend 49:13 saying 8:28 16:19 29:17 sessions 10:9,20 slide 14:1 sports 58:11,12,13 62:6,7 16:1 34:26 suspension 5:19,20 39:26 43:13 44:10 set 5:34 7:23 11:23 slightly 17:15 spot 47:20 52:9,19 53:15 studying 13:15 6:2,6,15,24,25 46:34 48:34 49:8,11 50:11 33:18,22,26 slip 50:28 spots 25:25 stuff 33:13 37:15 40:17 suspicious 52:24 51:10 52:15 59:20,31 36:17,21,30 39:19 slipped 50:26 staff 2:31 3:3,4 4:33 63:32 64:4,12 sustain 44:4 60:11 64:25,30 41:4,8 53:6 smacks 49:28,30 8:3,5,6,7,11,15,16,33 subcommittee 46:13 sweep 62:21 says 8:9 57:3 59:33 sets 17:30,33 33:9 38:6 small 26:33 27:29 31:18 9:25,26,29,30 10:5,6 subcommittees 50:4 sweeps 37:10 scenario 12:27 setting 2:5 33:9 41:6 34:33 43:21 44:29 19:14 20:6,33 23:33 subject 28:31 sympathies 3:27,34 scenarios 12:28 47:17 48:4 51:4 36:15 45:21,25 50:17 submission 25:29 47:29 4:5,24,34 scenes 60:27 seven 31:22,24 smaller 16:32 45:21 56:16 65:16 submissions 10:21 12:8 sympathise 2:28 scheme 11:9 15:8,14 40:5 several 10:25 49:4,5 52:1 snow 66:34 66:5,21,24,28,32 14:15 25:31 26:5 sympathy 1:24,28,32 51:11,14,21 55:8 severance 62:16 social 22:34 25:2 30:33 67:1,3,7,15 submit 14:20 2:27,33 3:7,13,20,32 58:25,27 60:25 severe 66:34 32:14 stage 3:22 4:19 5:24 submitted 47:13 4:8,11,16,21,24 5:1,2 schemes 11:8,14,20 shadow 62:28 soft 44:2 12:10 15:15 16:14 subscribing 50:34 system 17:1 29:18 42:23 66:9,10 shadowed 55:6 sold 64:1,25,26 25:27 28:11 31:34 subsequent 1:2 56:19 47:5 48:18,26 school 1:12,19 shafted 7:15 solely 11:21,22 43:13 46:3 54:17 subsequently 49:4,10 53:3,5,9,12 54:1 schools 1:21 43:21 shake 62:31 solicitor 46:2 59:30 61:12,28 53:7 57:28,31 59:34 63:19 scientific 13:25 shall 11:8 solid 65:23 stages 10:25 12:11 36:17 succeed 29:10 67:6 scope 33:9,11 36:9 37:5 share 39:19 solution 12:6 43:14 47:12 succeeding 8:16 Seachtain 1:10 60:32 she's 26:16 29:12 solutions 12:2 stakeholders 39:28 success 25:22 67:32 Seamus 21:22,26,29 script 59:24 37:11,25 some 1:5 2:18,19,24 3:17 stand 5:6 32:4 57:2 61:4 successful 21:28 63:11 Sean 47:34 53:1 seat 68:5 she 1:26 2:31 5:15 6:18 8:4 63:3 66:20 Seas 45:7 second 11:34 29:32 37:3 3:1,4,6,29,30,31,32 9:29,30,31,33 10:7,19 standard 30:7,14 successfully 20:29 SEA 35:10 40:6 42:9 43:11 4:2,3 28:30,32 36:28 11:8 13:16 14:8 standards 23:29,30,33 such 7:11 14:30 15:16 Shannon 35:25 50:34 57:1,14 37:15,16,17,19,23,24 16:32,34 20:30 21:5 standing 5:19,20 16:17 17:24 18:22 Shay 37:3 secondary 1:19 43:21 40:28 44:12,30 22:10 27:12,26 28:33 6:2,3,6,15,25 8:31 24:25,32 29:32 30:3 Sheehy's 6:20,25,28 seconded 7:28,31 9:4,7 shelf 38:20 30:27 33:1 34:25 55:7 31:34 43:19 49:30 57:27 63:10 41:31 46:33 shock 3:3 4:23 36:21 38:22 39:3 stands 59:33 51:5 60:34 66:18 Sheehy 5:29 seconder 5:33 6:34 42:29 shoes 21:8 32:23 40:19 42:8 43:31 star 31:11 67:10 6:16,23,26,33 54:17 secretary 4:4 shooting 39:4 44:16,17 45:4,34 start 1:14 8:22 9:14,28 suddenly 4:26 56:28 57:19 58:30 section 20:6 23:17 40:3,6 short 7:18 9:11 17:3,14 47:30 48:10 51:2 36:34 50:13 57:30 suffer 8:14 64:13 59:18,30 60:4 sections 39:33 shortly 25:23 26:5 53:6,18 54:8,28 started 4:2 12:1 57:28 suffered 64:14 61:10,11,15 sector 20:6 24:26 31:33 should 1:19 5:32 26:7,13 55:1,5 56:10 starting 8:23 10:4,7 sufficiently 14:31 63:1,6,21,31 64:8,16 43:34 63:11 27:13,14,17,22,23,29 58:2,15,24,25 59:32 39:1,16 suggest 7:1 64:17 65:5,7,13,17 sectoral 36:13 28:9,16 29:6 61: starts 9:24 43:13 46:11 suggestions 52:23 Sheila 4:13 30:6,7,14 31:19,23 stated 16:5 28:29 56:32 suitable 32:13 34:26 Shelbourne 5:13 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 79

Sherwin 44:26 text 1:1,2 14:6 48:10 50:20 51:24 29:7,13,15,24,32 today 3:27 19:9,29 25:34 56:16,22,32,34 Shillelagh 15:26,29 than 3:4 5:24 6:5 18:25 52:10,30 55:1,34 56:1 30:21,30 31:13,17,19 26:28 27:4 30:29 57:5,6,12 59:28 68:7 16:31,33 17:2 28:32 27:6 31:24 34:10,14 57:9,25 59:1 61:20 36:27,28 37:11,16 32:10 33:3 44:31 type 12:17 18:4,7 35:20 Shoreline 66:10 37:11 39:6 42:25 62:9 38:19 51:34 53:5 56:15 43:9 58:6,14,33 68:9 Similarly 13:16 15:12 51:14,34 54:13,29 theme 33:28 39:1,16,18,24,34 57:25 60:2 63:20,22 types 14:29 30:1 38:16 Sinn 8:21 59:14 62:2,19 34:15,25,29,30 40:11,12,16,17,18,19 toe 63:3 typically 36:7 45:32 SI122 10:23 11:13 63:15,21 67:24 35:17,18 41:29 together 19:27 27:10 Tallon 3:10,14 Slaney 10:33 11:31 thankful 20:21 themes 33:29 thinking 14:34 51:13 34:12 39:26 45:7 TDs 26:25 Snell 1:31,32 4:30 16:4 thankfully 16:9 61:12 themselves 12:22 13:11 third 33:15 35:20 42:9 54:12 66:4 Teddy 3:20 18:4 31:27 37:2,29 thanks 1:32 2:26,27 4:6 18:17 27:20 57:14 67:12 told 7:19 53:18 56:34 Thank 3:26 4:7,15,25 62:22 63:5,7,27 5:17 6:15 32:1,20,22 43:20 this 1:15 2:25 3:12 57:2,10 59:24 5:20 9:11 18:31 19:4 Society 22:33 34:29 15:19,20,21,33 49:25 4:1,24,26 tomorrow 14:15 30:25 20:19 25:7,9 Sole 57:20,21 16:4,30 18:32 25:21 then 7:3,6 5:14,16,24,25,27,31,3 43:24 26:10,11,15,26,28 Sorcha 9:30 17:8,30 26:28 27:9,10 12:15,23,25,28,29 4 tonne 47:8 27:30,31,32 28:21,28 Sorry 3:27 7:7,34 8:1 28:18,19 29:11 31:27 15:3 18:14 29:5 6:3,6,12,20,27,28,30 too 2:28 8:13 27:34 49:26 29:9,11 30:28 18:34 39:23 68:10 32:15,16,27,30 33:27 34:9 35:16 7:14 8:23,28 9:19,32 52:4,28 60:2 31:4,6,7,25,26,28 SPC 32:8 36:18 37:19,25,27,28 38:22 37:14,29 41:30 45:21 10:13,27,30 11:9,29 took 4:1 23:10,12 26:17 32:17,34 36:27 SPCs 25:16 41:8 39:14 40:17,26 41:30 48:23 49:14 59:34 13:6,14,19 14:1,6,8 54:11 55:7,8,23 58:21 37:2,9,28,34 38:17,26 Square 9:6 46:12 50:2 52:33 62:28 15:11,13,16,21,29 60:26 39:14 40:2,32 42:28 State 1:11,19 18:25 54:16 56:7 63:3 therapy 55:16 16:1,4,12,28 17:10,14 tool 14:23 45:10,15 46:5 50:31 36:13 49:27 60:28 64:22 65:3,33 67:2,25 there's 7:1 8:24 9:32 18:8,12,17,24,25,28,2 top 8:8 13:34 29:29 36:1 51:9 54:22,25 56:6 66:12 67:20 that's 7:2,5,21,23 12:20,22,25,30 16:25 9 19:5,12,21,29 38:2 42:20 43:25 57:25 59:2,3 60:18 Stores 28:2 8:17,27,28 10:32 17:5,18,25 18:24 20:1,3,6,14,19,31,34 47:32 57:21 61:29 62:10,22 Strategic 22:25 32:2 11:13 22:12,16 25:17,30 21:21,26,27 22:14 topics 35:26 There 1:12,26,33 4:12 33:19,26 38:1 39:15 12:4,10,16,22,26,32 27:25 28:3,13,24 23:1 topographical 12:14 6:27 7:16,18,19,20 41:7 13:3,8,14,21,27,33 29:5,16 40:7,18 41:2 those 6:23,29 12:24,25 total 45:9 57:3,10 8:13,24,26,32 Structural 48:28,30 14:1,3,10,22 15:7,11 43:24 45:17 49:1,12 13:24 14:12 20:33 totality 64:34 65:10 9:25,26,30 52:13,15 16:6,7 17:18,19,23,26 50:4,10,19 51:1,22 21:23 26:4 28:12 totally 42:16 43:23 49:16 10:5,10,20,30 Sunbeam 19:30 18:4,12,29 19:12 52:28 53:22 54:13,23 29:9 33:28 36:22 56:25 57:2 60:5 11:8,14,28,34 Sunday 7:11,20 42:6 22:17 25:11 58:4,5,14 59:22 60:17 39:20 40:4,34 47:30 tourist 5:4 12:16,28 Susan 8:32 26:4,24,26 27:33 62:28 63:27 48:33 49:16 52:21 towards 11:33 14:3 14:3,17,18,19,23,30,3 T 28:10 29:7,9,15,18,30 64:4,11,17,33 65:29 55:1,5,6 56:15 57:24 41:12,31 2 15:3,10,11,16,30 table 5:26 29:29 30:22 31:2,17,23 68:7 59:25 62:15 town 2:8 3:17 15:13 16:8 16:3,9,15,16,18,19 65:24 32:1,6,8,14,23 thereabouts 9:6 though 18:2 36:9 18:22 17:30 20:14 take 1:4,24 3:10 6:6 33:9,10,23 34:10,33 therefore 13:17 23:5 thought 7:11 22:14 25:9 21:14,17,22,23,26,31, 22:11,12,16 7:1,2,3 9:24 17:28 35:14 36:6,15,26 49:19,32 59:33 35:12 45:22 61:19 34 22:11,14,16,18,23 25:7,11,15,34 26:2,24 18:17 25:16 that 1:11,13,17 2:16,18 these 5:23 9:24 10:6 thoughts 2:26 25:10,11,25 26:1 28:2 27:17,34 28:1,7,29 26:9,12,19 28:25 3:22,27 4:4,20,28 12:28 13:33 14:28,34 thousand 14:8 27:8 31:22 42:3,5,15,17,27 29:7,31 29:6,30 30:21 5:1,15,16,22,23,25,26 18:14 22:5,10 23:12 32:11 42:22 43:30 43:5,8,27 44:30 45:3 30:1,4,6,7,17,27 31: 32:14,17,21 39:32 ,33 25:17 26:33,34 27:26 44:2 56:21 55:9,18 61:34 62:6 Thornhill's 1:14 40:9 43:14 46:15 6:2,14,17,18,19,20,30 28:13,24 32:19 thousands 47:22 63:31 66:9,18 Thursday 42:7 48:2 49:21 53:1 ,34 33:18,28,30 35:24 threatened 49:13 townland 9:3 THORNHILL 1:12,15 62:31 63:2 65:14 7:1,10,12,16,19,20,21 38:16 39:24 40:25 three 1:21 31:23 34:15 towns 22:28 23:9 25:13 4:15,16 32:17 65:4,5 67:11,30 ,22,24,28 41:11 42:33 36:5 45:5 46:21 26:8 27:13 30:20 Tiger 32:7 65:25 taken 6:9 18:14 26:32 8:5,7,10,14,15,17,18, 48:9,29,30 50:28 51:4 47:7,12 52:27,28 31:10,24 35:24 55:13 Tinahely 19:30 23:12 61:11,13 27,28,30,32 53:13 56:32 57:15,24 53:28 57:5,6 58:22 track 58:11 TIMMINS 1:25,28 2:31 takes 11:13 29:14 46:1 9:4,7,20,33 10:13,28 64:9,18 through 3:21 4:1 7:2 traditional 3:7,28 4:8,9,34 8:21 63:22 11:10 12:9,18,28 they'll 5:15 10:13 11:2 14:2 34:18,19,20,22,23,27, 25:20,21 26:11 30:30 taking 9:15 21:18 27:22 13:2,7,9,12,20 they're 7:17 16:8,26,32,34 17:8,11 28 38:27 41:31 42:30 32:29 40:22 56:4 14:2,6,7,22,24,29,32 they've 5:15 20:9 22:16,19 31:31 traditions 33:12 Tolka 5:13 talk 3:6 13:24,30 29:25 15:1,9,10,11,16,21,23 they 1:13 4:2 5:12,14 32:2 33:7,11 tragedy 61:25,26 Tommy 37:2,30 46:27 30:1 41:15 42:7 ,25, 8:11,12,24,26,29,30 34:6,11,14 trail 53:10,11 Tourism 37:17 67:23 62:28 the 9:20,33,34 10:7,23 35:10,16,20,29 36:22 training 20:10 34:7 Transport 39:8,9 talked 7:15 59:23,34 1:1,2,3,4,9,11,12,17,1 11:3,4,9,10,21,22,26, 37:1,6,24,27 38:19 45:27 46:1 57:7 41:15,16 47:16,20 talking 5:27 13:30 15:25 8,19,20,23,24,25,27,2 29 12:1,4,27,29,31,34 39:4 40:3,20 66:20 48:31 16:28 28:13 36:4 8,29,32 13:1,8,10,11,12,13,15 42:11,15,23 43:28 transcribed 1:1 Trojan 26:15 40:21 59:23,30 61:15 2:1,4,5,7,8,11,12,13,1 ,25 14:12,24,25,28,32 44:26 45:2 47:12,21 transcript 1:1,2 Tús 24:34 64:6,20 6,17,18,19,22,28,31 15:4,15,16 48:18,23,25,31 transparency 50:10 52:8 U talks 34:7,24 3:2,3,4,5,6,7,10,12,14 16:20,21,32,33 49:13,29 50:26,27 59:23 ultimately 26:17 36:24 tangent 49:27 ,15,16,17,20,22,23,24 17:22,23,29,33 51:28 52:1 53:12 transpires 7:19 50:9 tank 55:27 ,28,30,32,34 18:2,6,8,10,11,18,20, 57:4,5,7 58 trash 13:12,13 62:28 unanswered 56:21 tapes 2:18 4:3,4,7,8,9,11,12,13,1 21,22 19:18 21:4 throughout 3:12 5:4 travel 27:2 unbelievable 58:21 targets 38:23 40:32 6,17,18,19,21,23,24,2 22:8,11,12 25:24 22:23 50:26 66:10 treat 33:19 uncomfortable 52:4 41:6,7,11 7,31,33,34 26:33 27:3,1 67:3,6,17 treatment 61:21 under 6:20 7:2,3 8:2 task 4:27 5:34,2,3,4,12,13,15,1 thing 5:30 10:4 11:19 throws 16:1 17:28 tremendous 29:12 58:18 11:9,10 14:2 tasks 12:8 30:3 6,21,22,23,25,26,27,2 14:10 44:15,33 48:16 tidal 12:30 13:7 tried 35:29 44:29 15:9,13,17 18:6 19:24 taxpayers 62:7 9,30,3 49:23 51:17 55:13 tide 12:29,30 trip 5:21,25,30,31 23:24 28:2,4 31:2 team 17:31 26:28 66:24 their 1:25 3:31 6:20 9:22 56:18 59:23 65:28 tied 29:27 trips 5:23 33:29,30 39:9 44:30 67:15,24 10:1 13:2,11 16:25,26 things 7:15 8:5,20 13:12 till 55:7 true 2:16,22 39:5 50:28 56:12 65:17 technical 11:17 21:6 22:4,5,6,14 16:34 17:29 25:25 till7 9:25 trumped 5:14 understand 14:24 38:23 technology 20:26 47:3 23:23 26:25,29 26:1,33,34 28:12,13 time 2:11 3:5,16,29 truth 57:3 40:22,24 51:25 teeth 31:31 27:1,32 28:28 29:16 30:6 32:19 4:13,24 5:34 7:14,15 try 9:33 13:19 16:17 underway 15:11,14 tell 3:17 10:21 42:13 31:10,30,31 39:4,26 35:1 36:2 38:29 8:19 10:3,27 12:30 30:19 31:14 34:7,30 undoubted 63:10 43:5,20 50:20 53:16 41:4 43:6 47:13,32 39:5,15 48:1 49:27 19:4 20:30 21:6 44:29 46:7,10 unenviable 4:27 55:1 58:16 50:11 53:12,13,23 50:28 51:5 52:17,31 23:18,26 25:1 27:33 52:8,17,18 53:30 unexpected 3:1 telling 50:5,18 55:16 57:4,6,7,23 54:24 55:2,6,9,11 28:7,25 55:2,10 58:27 unfairly 63:9 tells 49:2 65:3 67:4,6,25 58:3 59:6,25 29:1,3,13,24,26,30,31 trying 27:19 31:11 unfortunately 3:24 7:14 template 41:4 them 2:20 3:5 5:14,16 60:6,15,23,29 61:2,32 30:30 32:10 35:3 32:4,19 40:22 43:14 27:12 50:6 56:11 temporary 67:30 9:31,33 10:25 11:33 64:11,33,34 65:2,11 38:24 39:17,34 41:12 49:34 51:30 58:26 unhappy 49:5 ten 13:24 20:14 16:15 18:19 19:27,28 think 1:14,15,16,26 2:5 42:6,33 46:11 47:2,6 turn 23:24 units 32:9,12 tend 11:7 39:16 55:2 21:26 22:3,7,8 3:16,22 5:22,24 48:9,19 49:30 50:22 twice 3:29 universal 23:31 24:18 tensions 67:7 26:23,25 27:18,26 6:2,27,29 7:21,23 51:32 52:1 53:2,18,29 two 6:19 8:12 9:11,16 universally 23:5 tenure 57:33 30:9,19 32:13 13:8 14:5 16:4 17:34 54:26,27,31 12:11,31 13:26 unless 34:2 50:10,18 terms 18:22,23 29:25,28 33:29,31 34:27 36:14 18:2,4,24,32 21:8 55:34,23,30 57:2 17:29,30,32,33 19:22 58:34 61:16 30:4 39:22 44:14 38:28 22:15 times 9:33,34 12:17 33:15,27,31 35:4 unsure 16:6 46:20 48:16 55:13,26 39:2,19,21,25,33 26:9,12,16,21,22,25 41:23 56:4 58:9 36:18 37:4 40:2 until 23:17 26:13,19 test 13:1 62:29 41:3,18 42:12 43:25 27:2,13,17,29,30 tirelessly 67:16 47:13 48:32,33 49:11 29:26 32:23 35:13 testament 1:27 44:9,12,24 47:29 28:10,16 51:11,16 54:10,12 42:18 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 80

untimely 3:8 5:1 visually 30:2,9 we've 17:11 32:7 33:11 whatsoever 43:12,15 wife 2:24 4:13 58:32 38:20,25 40:30 48:3 untold 49:2 vital 20:31 21:1 66:16 34:15 50:4,6 61:12 57:15 61:23 63:1,6 64:33 65:21 66:28 67:18,32 untrue 6:18,30 56:25 voluntarily 47:13 weakness 54:1 wheelchair 21:18 22:17 wildlife 33:10 35:12 works 8:8 11:8,23 16:26 untruths 57:10 voluntary 42:16 67:22 weaknesses 40:14 28:1,9,10,11,30 will 2:1 3:18,32 5:25,31 32:1 37:22,23 47:16 unusual 7:11 50:18 vote 1:32 3:20 4:7,11,21 wear 32:23 29:1,4 30:19 9:15,19,20,24,25,26,2 52:32 54:8 60:9 upcoming 31:5 6:9 33:5 43:2,16,17 weather 55:16 58:11 wheelchairs 21:34 26:20 8,29,30,31,34 workshop 39:18 40:19 updates 39:2 59:7 66:34 28:10 30:2 10:3,5,6,9,13,20 41:11 upgrade 40:3 votes 1:24,31 2:27 5:2 web 24:30 35:26 when 3:2 4:2 7:15 11:14,33 12:4,24 world 66:12,26 upon 56:28 57:25 vulnerable 35:1 website 14:17,19,20 8:4,11,22 9:24 13:8,10,33 worldwide 43:14 upright 61:19 VANCE 4:6,7 6:2 7:1,5 24:30 25:3 36:30 10:20,26 12:3,6 13:1 14:13,18,22,23,24,27, worried 8:15 ups 54:23 61:11 9:7 43:4,23 51:10 41:1 50:34 52:20 17:26 18:7,20,32 29,32 15:3,30 16:2,12 worth 58:22,23 upwards 1:23 52:20,29,33 53:25 53:13 22:14 23:29 26:20 17:10 worthwhile 29:21 30:21 urban 14:30 57:27 websites 10:10 14:18 27:23 30:1,5,6 36:4,8 18:7,8,9,14,23,24,29 47:4 urge 39:13 Vibece 19:31 week 1:10,33 3:24 4:30 39:24,25 40:24,30 19:16,18 21:5 23:3,4 worthy 42:27 use 8:15 17:23 18:17 Vibeke 22:19 5:3,31 6:18,30 26:17 41:13 44:9 46:1 47:5 24:3,11 25:1,2,3,11 would 2:28 3:3,23 23:28 62:8 Villas 56:33 28:5 35:18,22 42:6,16 49:1,3,34 50:17,29 26:3,4 27:4,8 28:11 4:16,17,20 7:15,21 used 5:23 12:25 Voice 3:3 20:34 27:3 44:34 56:23 57:24 51:19 53:12 57:4,8 31:1,5 33:15,22,26, 8:14,31 9:34 13:13 13:14,15,24 38:34 67:25 59:27 63:28 66:19 58:9,12,17,22 willing 27:29 46:14 16:12,16,27 17:19,21 42:4 47:12 58:16 W weekend 5:12 34:30 60:2,21,25 61:4 67:2,11,27 20:19 22:14 25:31 useful 8:26 39:18 wait 50:8 weeks 9:15 14:13,23 62:27,30,33 63:3,27 win 68:5 27:6 30:21,25,33 useless 8:26 waiting 8:14 18:34 50:19 15:32 65:23 66:25 67:9 window 41:20 31:9,13,17,23 36:15 user 21:17 walk 21:8 27:33 58:16,17 welcome 1:9 18:34 19:28 where 11:13,14,34 12:23 windows 40:5 37:9,15 38:24,25 users 21:31 walked 21:17,26 58:13 31:8 56:10 13:8 14:23,28,30,31 wish 5:34 54:25 57:27 39:18 40:9,19 41:7 uses 8:26 walking 29:15 welcomed 31:25 16:6,19,32,33 58:30 59:1 60:10,20 42:21 43:11,25 using 12:15 16:2 17:14 wall 39:20 well 1:26,27 2:31,33 17:11,18 18:10 27:30 61:7,22,30 63:1,24,29 44:9,18,30 45:29,31 33:33 47:12 walls 12:16 3:5,7,10,11,12 28:3,24,32 64:15,32 46:7,14 47:9,31,32 usual 50:18,19 want 3:14,18 5:20,27,28 4:21,28 8:6,18,34 29:4,5,6,29 30:8 65:2,5,13,17,27 67:32 48:3,19 usually 12:30 13:1 51:8 7:9 9:25 10:9,11 9:26 14:24,32 15:32 31:10,34 32:4,18,21 68:6 49:4,7,12,16,21,24,25 utilise 25:2 14:15,34 17:31 20:11 16:12 17:31 19:2,7 34:23 35:4 37:15,26 wishing 63:6 50: utter 57:3 21:4 25:6,18 20:6 21:28 22:13 38:21,23,24 39:22 with 1:14 2:28 wouldn't 6:2 20:33 41:21 Una 1:25,27,29 2:31 26:5,14,32 25:30 26:4,30 40:14,15,17 44:18 3:2,4,16,27 46:28 49:26 50:30 3:3,4,5,8,28 4:8,22 28:21,27,28 29:31 27:10,11,22,25 30:3 45:2,5,31 48:2 50:30 4:7,11,19,21,23,24 53:28 54:7,21 57:33 5:1 30:12 31:7,25,28 31:6,11,29 32:29 33:5 51:2,22 52:14 53:8 5:2,24 6:2,5 8:21 60:14 61:32 65:9 United 5:12,13 36:33 37:8 38:24 34:2 35:17 36:15 55:15 58:2 59:9,19 9:12,28 11:20 wrecked 62:1 V 39:22,23 40:2,23 42:8 38:12,23 39:3 40:1,16 62:1,9 64:1 6 13:3,9,10 14:6,17,27 write 40:25 65:28 vacant 32:12 38:29 43:29 44:10,13 45:14 41:4 42:3,16 43:27,28 whereby 35:2 17:17,24,32 written 7:17 40:25 value 47:11,21,31 52:26 48:9,18 50:15 44:34 45:14 46:7 whether 8:16 14:30 16:1 18:2,19,20,26 wrong 8:24 12:34 53:12 58:21 51:15,28 55:15,31 48:19,34 51 25:16 27:7 31:32 19:12,29 20:1,4,16,32 48:32,33 50:4,9 55:8 values 14:7 39:17,18,20 56:8 58:3 60:7 61:21 went 16:8,18,34 22:15 33:33 38:25 43:26 21:17,21,26,27,28,33 wrongdoings 63:33 40:18,19,20,22 41:11 62:16 63:13 64:23 38:18 47:21 53:11,28 45:2 46:17 52:4,9,12 22:34,6,8,16,20,23,25 wrote 47:24 49:4,5 various 7:15 10:10 13:22 65: 58:1,20 61:1 63:22 ,29,33 WALSH 3:34 28:21 40:2 20:16 23:23 25:16 wanted 5:26 29:4,5 37:6 were 3:5 7:19 8:23,32 which 1:20,27 2:12,16 23:4,12,17,20,31 44:23 31:32 34:7,11,21,24 42:30 51:10 58:10 11:10 16:32,33 19:23 6:13 9:17,28 24:3,4,5,10,11,16,19, We're 1:24 5:26 6:32 35:16 42:24 47:12 wants 58:4,5 20:9 22:5,7 25:24 10:7,23,31,32 24,26,28,30,31 25:7,1 10:15,25,26,31 50:26 52:2 67:20 wardens 27:13 29:16,17 34:26 37:7 11:13,34 12:5,24,27 withdrawn 39:12 16:5,6,13,22,28 varying 20:16 47:21 warming 13:3 40:20 44:21 45:34 13:19,20 14:8,15,17 within 11:25 25:15 19:2,10 28:25 vastly 16:20 warrant 14:32 47:12,13,18,25 15:14 16:12,13,27 31:10,13 39:17 56:16 29:25,27 30:7,25 velocity 13:20 wary 16:27 48:5,9,30 49:14 17:15,17 18:1,6 without 20:33 29:2 32:32 34:11,29 35:23 venues 9:16 was 1:26,27,34 50:15,33 51:12,28,29 19:18,26 20:2,5 22:33 50:5,8 58:33 65:20,30 36:4,8,17 38:8 39:9 verbals 62:28 2:4,6,7,8,11,12,16,17, 52:2,9 26:3 27:4,5 28:22 witness 26:14,20 40:22 41:13 verbatim 1:4 20,23,31 53:3,5,12,19,28,30 32:3 33:29 36:23,31 woman 3:31 37:12 43:14,24,28 44:9 verdict 6:31 56:30 3:4,10,12,15,21,22,30 54:12 56:9,25,29,30 38:2 39:32 40:33 women 64:20 45:34 46:5 48:25 57:16,17 ,31,34 57:2,8,9,11,15,16 41:17 42:5 43:25 won't 11:23 17:33,34 50:2,19 51:5,32 verification 13:8 4:2,3,4,11,13,19,23,2 58:25 59:6,23 45:27 48:27 49:6 18:1,11 20:9 31:27 52:18,25 53:5,23 versus 12:29 14:30 45:3 7,31 5:13,16,17 6:13 60:2,11,26,34 61:1,21 50:16,33 51:6,8 54:18 34:3 42:17 43:17,22 54:16 59:5 64:17,20 very 3:1,8,10,16 7:10,11,14,15,18,19 62:2 while 1:4 3:6 14:31 46:12 59:19 64:5 WHITMORE 15:33 4:9,14,18,31 5:11 8:3,5,6,7,11,13,19,20, weren't 48:30 53:5,8 18:11,18 27:34 31:31 won 2:6,11,12,13 28:30 17:7 38:22 44:20 6:18,29 8:9,27 9:11 22,31,32,33 10:23,30 59:24 63:18 67:2 33:23 40:18 55:34 66:26 Wicklow's 34:18 35:21 12:31 15:23,33 16:1 15:9,26,28,33 16:9 west 3:33 31:5 35:24 60:27 63:20 wonder 28:24 41:3 17:14 18:31 21:27 19:34 20:1,2,14,19,30 39:9,10 42:31 whilst 56:10 wonderful 60:7 Wicklow 1:3,7,20,28,33 25:9,10,21,22 21:27,32 22:11,12 60:22,29 63:32 who's 28:32 66:2,24,27 2:7 3:11,13,33 26:11,26,29 23:17 25:12,21,26 64:5,6,11,14 who 1:12 2:20,23,25 wondering 15:33 16:5 5:14,23,24,25,31,32 27:5,10,11,13,25,30 wasn't 8:19,20 28:10 westerly 42:27 3:5,10 4:11,13,23 38:22 9:15 13:34 14:16 28:18,19 29:21 39:8 43:2 49:18,32 wetlands 34:18,33 5:34 9:25 12:6 18:14 woods 28:19 15:22 16:7 18:34 30:21,28,29 50:22 54:13 59:18,30 35:2,3,4,6 19:28 20:19 22:7 word 32:25 19:5,9,10,12,21,23,31 31:4,7,13,18,25,28 64:29 what's 9:14,18 25:26 24:11 27:3 29:12 words 1:14 57:24 20:3,4,7,15,17,19,23, 32:12,13,24 waste 66:9 38:32 39:5,6 40:13 30:2,3 31:8,31 work 3:23 24,25,26,31,32 33:1,2,17,21 36:1,27 watch 6:20 57:14 44:20 50:9 51:4 32:11,14,20,29 33:17 8:7,10,17,29,30 9:25 21:1,12,14,21,22,24 37:9,22 38:10,17,22 water 13:13,21 15:23 58:18 60:23 64:34 36:18 44:20 45:5,20 15:10,24,26 22:10,19,20,23,24,25, 41:4 42:10,17 43: 59:19 60:24 66:9 what 7:16,24 8:11,20 46:2,18,33 51:3 19:11,12,17,29 27,28,29,32,33 via 14:20 way 7:17 8:3,6,33 9:31 10:18,21 11:29 56:3,27 61:21 20:16,20,31,34 21:28 23:3,5,9,10,12,13,16, vice 60:32 11:6 13:25 18:23 12:14,20,26,34 62:2,25,32 63:29 22:29 24:3,4,11,31 21,23,24,26,28,33,34 victories 5:14 20:21 27:6 28:8,17 13:2,8,10,13,19,30 67:3,15 25:7 27:6,9,18 24:3,4, victory 5:12 37:23 39:3,19 40:12 14:6,25 15:34 16:28 whoever 32:19 60:4,5 29:9,19,31 30:8,10,12 Williams 5:3 view 2:32 8:17 24:19 47:18 49:3,8,19,27 17:7,10,28 18:5,7,8 65:30 31:2,4,8,17,18 32:30 WINTERS 50:2,23,29 38:19 39:24 44:15 51:2 55:2 59:5,6,22 21:4 26:5 28:2,5,27 whole 3:32 9:32 13:19 34:15 35:5,7,10,11 52:1 53:20 54:19 65:7 61:19 66:8 67:28 29:17 30:25,30,34 17:15,23,24 29:12 36:22,28 64:22,28,32 viewing 14:18 ways 50:5 52:2 31:7,14,27 34:3,10 32:13 34:10,30 37:10 37:12,18,19,28 38:31 WLAAG 19:34 20:15 vigilant 27:13 we'd 16:28 43:34 35:4 36:4 37:9 40:27 44:4 45:27 44:7 47:31 57:27 21:11 23:25,34 village 2:8 25:11 we'll 5:6 7:3,6,23,27 38:6,25 46:2,25 53:27 59:17 62:24 63:11,24 24:3,5,8,9,11,19,31 villages 22:28 23:9 25:13 9:1,16 10:26 14:12 39:34,2,12,22,26 62:32 64:8 66:1,24 67:21,23 25:1 26:8 31:10,24 17:5,32 18:1,15 19:9 40:13,16,22,23,24,31 whom 46:22 worked 1:25,26,33 3:7 X 41:7,33 42:4,7,30 why 7:11,17 14:1 17:1 18:25 35:18 43:34 vindictiveness 59:9 22:23 25:7 28:26 Y vision 22:32 33:26 60:33 29:19 30:34 32:2,18 43:18,23, 42:11,18 44:21 45:20 57:31 62:23 67:16 whatever 3:31 26:34 49:1,12,13,24,25,26,2 worker 19:7 24:34 25:1 year's 26:7 64:20 65:18 34:29 36:20,21,34 year 2:23 5:15 6:12 9:18 visit 66:29 37:1 38:12 39:17,31 28:3 30:2,20 50:24,31 7,28,29 56:32 57:6,9 working 2:25 12:1 35:18 64:15 wider 34:8 36:20 36:10,21 37:6,23 13:24,26 14:8 24:14 visitors 35:34 42:5 40:9 41:17 45:1,4,10 31:23,24,25,33 visual 22:1 30:5 46:8,10,34 58:24 Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie Wicklow County Council Meeting – 2 March 2015 81

34:28,29 35:22,34 you'll 9:12 33:31 56:3 your 3:29 14:23 16:5 47:7,26 48:16,20,21 1995 19:34 2015 1:7 22:23,24,28,32 36:8,30 38:11,24 61:8,17 18:4 21:8 26:13 50:6,14,16,34 1996 64:30 37:33,34 38:7,9 39:31 40:1,29 you're 8:16 27:2 49:5 27:4,9,17,28 51:11,13,14,16,19,21, 1st 1:9 7:20 35:34 64:30 2016 11:2 41:13,32 43:10 44:10 51:20,21 56:2 59:34 29:11,13,17 23,24,27 2002 33:8 2019 38:34 45:2 48:10,27 you've 26:8 46:30 54:26 31:1,4,6,14 45:29 52:3,20,29,32 2003 20:2 22nd 47:19 50:6,18,28 51:11,13 55:31,32 60:12 65:33 50:2 52:31 55:26 53:6,7,8,23 66:27 2004 20:3 33:15 37:14 29th 21:17,32 53:23 54:3,6,11 59:24 you 1:9 2:31 3:26 56:2,3,7 60:11,12 0012 9:6 2005 19:24 22:24,28,32 2nd 1:7 7:30 64:34 67:6 4:7,15,20,25 61:7 62:29 67:17 100 26:23 62:1 23:3,17,24 24:28 2pm 10:4,7 years 1:18,26,34 5:19,20,26,27,28 6:24 68:8 100th 2:23 2006 15:9 350 67:11 2:5,13,18,20,29,32 8:12,18,20,22,23,27,2 yourself 15:31 16:14 120 40:7 41:23 2007 15:9 22:28 23:9 3pm 9:24 10:9 3:2,6,30,34 4:17,26 8,32,33,34 27:2 37:21 12th 7:27 28:24 34:21 3rd 6:12 6:28 8:23,24 9:21 9:11,12,18,31 yourselves 9:29 26:9,33 13th 21:11 2008 22:25 47:5 48:34 400 29:4 12:22,23 13:26,27 10:9,11,14,19,20,21 Yeah 16:19 37:33 42:30 147 34:22 50:13 53:6,7,23 500 29:2 42:20,25 43:31 15:22,26,27,28 11:8 13:8,26,33 45:10 46:28 150 66:27 2009 33:15 34:25 47:21 48:5 53:15 16:20,22 17:8 19:11 14:5,6,13,15,16,17,18 Yes 43:28 17th 1:9 2010 10:23 34:28,34 583 47:9 20:14,20,30 24:9 ,19,20,23,25 Z 189 48:16 66:34 584 47:9 26:15,16 28:32 29:15 15:6,16,25,30 16:5,14 zone 13:20 1916 64:20 2011 11:1 35:2 6pm 68:12 31:18,22,24 32:7 17:33 18:31,34 zones 18:22 1950 2:13 2012 47:8,16,18,19 50:13 7th 54:17 34:21,31 35:5,16 19:2,4,10,16,19 21:8 1950s 2:7 2013 21:11,17 24:16 800 43:32 44:4 37:14,26 38:21,24 22:11 ... 4:29 5:27 6:31,33 1960 2:19 35:18 38:8 8th 56:24 67:31 42:23 51:11,16 53:8 25:7,9,10,11,13,26 7:6,33 53:13 64:24 1970 2:14 47:24,25,26 48:12 935 48:23 54:10,18,27,28,33 26: 000 7:10 24:9 27:4,5,6 1972 43:12 2014 21:23,33 24:9 945 48:11 yesterday 7:9,16 47:2 young 3:8,11 4:3 29:7 30:34 31:17 1980 4:22 38:8,12 48:24,27 9th 21:23 45:28 46:1,5,8 yet 12:3 36:31 43:16 43:13,20 56:2 35:34 42:5,26 43:25 1985 3:22 51:19 54:10 yield 14:31 17:10 younger 36:1 1986 55:7

Premier Captioning & Realtime Ltd. www.pcr.ie