CITY of ELK GROVE SHORT RANGE TRANSIT PLAN FISCAL YEARS 2014-2020 Prepared By: Sacramento Area Council of Governments
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CITY OF ELK GROVE SHORT RANGE TRANSIT PLAN FISCAL YEARS 2014-2020 Prepared by: Sacramento Area Council of Governments Prepared For: City of Elk Grove ELK GROVE SHORT RANGE TRANSIT PLAN FISCAL YEARS 2014-2020 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Prepared by: Sacramento Area Council of City of Elk Grove Governments 1415 L Street, Suite RAQUEL CHAVARRIA, TRANSIT PLANNER 300 EDWARD COVIELLO, TRANSIT PLANNER Sacramento, CA 95814 JEAN C. FOLETTA, TRANSIT MANAGER Tel: 916.321.9000 Fax: 916.321.9551 BETH MARASIGAN, ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT www.sacog.org KARA REDDIG, ASSISTANT TO THE CITY MANAGER RICHARD SHEPARD, PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR Prepared for: City of Elk Grove Sacramento Area Council of Governments (SACOG) 8401 Laguna Palms Way SHARON SPROWLS, SENIOR PROGRAM SPECIALIST (PROJECT MANAGER) Elk Grove, CA 95758 LAURA BELL, ASSISTANT RESEARCH ANALYST VICTORIA CACCIATORE, PLANNING ANALYST RENÉE DEVERE-OKI, SENIOR PLANNER TINA GLOVER, ASSOCIATE RESEARCH ANALYST GAYLE GREENE, ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT III CLINT HOLTZEN, ASSISTANT PLANNER AMY MARTIN, TRANSIT PLANNING INTERN CHRISTINE O’ROURKE, ASSISTANT PLANNER GARY TAYLOR, SENIOR PLANNER BARBARA VAUGHANBECHTOLD, ASSOCIATE PLANNER THIS SRTP WAS COMPLETED AS PROJECT #14-003-17 OF THE SACOG OVERALL WORK PROGRAM (OWP) WITH GENEROUS FUNDING PROVIDED BY CALTRANS THROUGH THE STATEWIDE OR URBAN TRANSIT PLANNING STUDIES GRANT PROGRAM. City of Elk Grove Short Range Transit Plan Page i ELK GROVE SHORT RANGE TRANSIT PLAN FISCAL YEARS 2014-2020 THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary ES-1 Chapter 1—Introduction 1-1 Chapter 2—Planning Context 2-1 Chapter 3—Overview of Existing Fixed Route Service 3-1 Chapter 4—Overview of Existing e-van Service 4-1 Chapter 5—Transit Demand Analysis 5-1 Chapter 6—Goals, Objectives, Policies, and Prior Recommendations 6-1 Chapter 7—Staffing and Administration 7-1 Chapter 8—Marketing 8-1 Chapter 9—Fleet and Facilities Plan and Financial Analysis 9-1 Chapter 10—Service Alternatives 10-1 Appendix A1—Detailed Commuter Route Analysis A1-1 Appendix A2—Detailed Local Route Analysis A2-1 Appendix A3—Detailed Boarding and Alighting Counts A3-1 Appendix B—Copy of 2013 e-tran On-Board and Online Surveys B-1 Appendix C—Example Rider Guide – Yuba-Sutter Transit C-1 Appendix D—Engineering Drawings for Blue Line LRT Extension D-1 City of Elk Grove Short Range Transit Plan Page i LIST OF FIGURES FIGURE 2.1 ELK GROVE STUDY AREA 2-2 FIGURE 2.2 CONCENTRATION OF 2010 POPULATION 2-8 FIGURE 2.3 CONCENTRATION OF 2010 POPULATION UNDER AGE 18 2-9 FIGURE 2.4 CONCENTRATION OF 2010 POPULATION AGE 65 AND OVER 2-10 FIGURE 2.5 FAMILIES IN POVERTY 2-11 FIGURE 2.6 HOUSEHOLDS WITH ONE OR NO VEHICLES AVAILABLE 2-12 FIGURE 2.7 CONCENTRATION OF NON-WHITE 2010 POPULATION 2-13 FIGURE 2.8 ELK GROVE: 2008 EMPLOYMENT DENSITY 2-15 FIGURE 3.1 ELK GROVE: TRANSIT SYSTEM 3-2 FIGURE 3.2 E-TRAN PARK AND RIDE LOTS 3-12 FIGURE 3.3 AVERAGE DAILY RIDERSHIP BY COMMUTER ROUTE 3-14 FIGURE 3.4 AVERAGE WEEKLY RIDERSHIP ON COMMUTER ROUTES TO/FROM BUTTERFIELD LRT STATION 3-18 FIGURE 3.5 AVERAGE WEEKDAY RIDERSHIP BY LOCAL ROUTE 3-21 FIGURE 3.6 ROUTE 157 RIDERSHIP PER RUN 3-26 FIGURE 3.7 AVERAGE RIDERSHIP ON ROUTE 160 3-30 FIGURE 3.8 AVERAGE RIDERSHIP ON ROUTE 162 3-30 FIGURE 3.9 ROUTE 151 SCHOOL TRIPPER AVERAGE RIDERS PER RUN 3-32 FIGURE 3.10 ROUTE 152 SCHOOL TRIPPER AVERAGE RIDERS PER RUN 3-32 FIGURE 3.11 ROUTE 153 SCHOOL TRIPPER AVERAGE RIDERS PER RUN 3-33 FIGURE 3.12 WEEKEND SHUTTLE AVERAGE RIDERSHIP PER RUN (SATURDAY) 3-35 FIGURE 3.13 WEEKEND SHUTTLE AVERAGE RIDERSHIP PER RUN (SUNDAY) 3-36 FIGURE 3.14 MAP OF PROPOSED BUS RAPID TRANSIT PROJECT 3-39 FIGURE 4.1 FARE MEDIA USE: DEMAND RESPONSE (OCTOBER 2012) 4-3 FIGURE 5.1 ON-BOARD SURVEY: ZIP CODE 5-1 FIGURE 5.2 ON-BOARD SURVEY: GENDER 5-2 FIGURE 5.3 ON-BOARD SURVEY: AGE (LOCAL) 5-2 FIGURE 5.4 ON-BOARD SURVEY: AGE (COMMUTER) 5-2 FIGURE 5.5 ON-BOARD SURVEY: HOUSEHOLD SIZE 5-3 FIGURE 5.6 ON-BOARD SURVEY: INCOME (LOCAL) 5-3 FIGURE 5.7 ON-BOARD SURVEY: (COMMUTER) 5-3 FIGURE 5.8 ON-BOARD SURVEY: ETHNICITY (LOCAL) 5-4 FIGURE 5.9 ON-BOARD SURVEY: ETHNICITY (COMMUTER) 5-4 FIGURE 5.10 ON-BOARD SURVEY: INFORMATION SOURCE (LOCAL) 5-4 FIGURE 5.11 ON-BOARD SURVEY: INFORMATION SOURCE (COMMUTER) 5-4 City of Elk Grove Short Range Transit Plan Page ii FIGURE 5.12 ON-BOARD SURVEY: ROUTE CROSSOVER 5-5 FIGURE 5.13 ON-BOARD SURVEY: TRIP PURPOSE (LOCAL) 5-6 FIGURE 5.14 ON-BOARD SURVEY: TRIP PURPOSE (COMMUTER) 5-6 FIGURE 5.15 ON-BOARD SURVEY: FREQUENCY OF TRIPS BY PURPOSE 5-6 FIGURE 5.16 ON-BOARD SURVEY: OTHER TRANSIT SYSTEM USE 5-7 FIGURE 5.17 ON-BOARD SURVEY: RIDER LONGEVITY (LOCAL) 5-7 FIGURE 5.18 ON-BOARD SURVEY: RIDER LONGEVITY (COMMUTER) 5-7 FIGURE 5.19 ON-BOARD SURVEY: RIDER FREQUENCY (LOCAL) 5-8 FIGURE 5.20 ON-BOARD SURVEY: RIDER FREQUENCY (COMMUTER) 5-8 FIGURE 5.21 ON-BOARD SURVEY: VEHICLE AVAILABILITY (LOCAL) 5-8 FIGURE 5.22 ON-BOARD SURVEY: VEHICLE AVAILABILITY (COMMUTER) 5-8 FIGURE 5.23 ON-BOARD SURVEY: E-TRAN ALTERNATIVE (LOCAL) 5-9 FIGURE 5.24 ON-BOARD SURVEY: E-TRAN ALTERNATIVE (COMMUTER) 5-9 FIGURE 5.25 ON-BOARD SURVEY: ATTITUDES TOWARD E-TRAN (SYSTEMWIDE) 5-10 FIGURE 5.26 ON-BOARD SURVEY: PATRON-REQUESTED IMPROVEMENT TO E-TRAN 5-11 FIGURE 5.27 ON-BOARD SURVEY: SUMMARY OF RESPONDENT COMMENTS 5-12 FIGURE 7.1 CITY OF ELK GROVE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS ORGANIZATION CHART 7-2 FIGURE 7.2 PERCENT OF OPERATING BUDGET SPENT ON ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS FY 09/10 – FY 11/12 7-5 FIGURE 8.1 E-VAN RIDER GUIDE 8-3 FIGURE 8.2 E-TRAN WEBSITE HOMEPAGE 8-5 FIGURE 8.3 SIGN AT E-TRAN BUS STOP IN ELK GROVE 8-7 FIGURE 8.4 CRC BUS STATION PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION 8-8 City of Elk Grove Short Range Transit Plan Page iii THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK City of Elk Grove Short Range Transit Plan Page iv LIST OF TABLES TABLE 2.1 EMPLOYERS IN ELK GROVE WITH 150+ 2-3 TABLE 2.2 STUDY AREA POPULATION AND HOUSEHOLD PROJECTIONS, 2010 TO 2020 2-4 TABLE 2.3 COMMUNITY PROFILE 2-5 TABLE 2.4 ELK GROVE WORKER FLOWS (2010) 2-14 TABLE 2.5 RECENT AND PLANNED DEVELOPMENTS, JOB CENTERS, AND POINTS OF INTEREST 2-16 TABLE 3.1 E-TRAN CURRENT FARE TYPES AND PRICES 3-4 TABLE 3.2 PEER AGENCY COMMUTER FARE PRICES 3-5 TABLE 3.3 FARE MEDIA USE: COMMUTER ROUTES (MAY-DECEMBER 2012) 3-5 TABLE 3.4 FARE MEDIA USE: LOCAL ROUTES (MAY-DECEMBER 2012) 3-6 TABLE 3.5 FIXED ROUTE AND COMMUTER BASE OPERATING STATISTICS 3-7 TABLE 3.6 LOCAL FIXED ROUTE AND COMMUTER PRODUCTIVITY INDICATORS 3-8 TABLE 3.7 FIXED ROUTE AND COMMUTER COST-EFFICIENCY INDICATORS 3-8 TABLE 3.8 LOCAL FIXED ROUTE AND COMMUTER ADMINISTRATIVE PERFORMANCE INDICATORS 3-9 TABLE 3.9 E-TRAN FIXED ROUTE ON-TIME PERFORMANCE 3-9 TABLE 3.10 E-TRAN COMMUTER ROUTES TO/FROM DOWNTOWN SACRAMENTO 3-10 TABLE 3.11 E-TRAN PARK-AND-RIDE LOTS 3-13 TABLE 3.12 WEEKDAY COMMUTER ROUTE PERFORMANCE 3-14 TABLE 3.13 MOST USED BUS STOPS: COMMUTER ROUTES 3-15 TABLE 3.14 COMMUTER ROUTES TO/FROM BUTTERFIELD STATION 3-17 TABLE 3.15 BUTTERFIELD LRT STATION CONNECTIONS 3-18 TABLE 3.16 WEEKDAY COMMUTER ROUTE PERFORMANCE 3-19 TABLE 3.17 CURRENT E-TRAN AND RT SCHEDULES AT MATHER/MILLS LRT STATION 3-20 TABLE 3.18 WEEKDAY LOCAL ROUTE PERFORMANCE 3-22 TABLE 3.19 TYPICAL LOCAL ROUTE TRANSFERS, BY PERCENTAGE 3-22 TABLE 3.20 MOST USED BUS STOPS IN ELK GROVE: LOCAL ROUTES 3-23 TABLE 3.21 SUGGESTED TIMEPOINT ADJUSTMENTS FOR ROUTE 154 3-23 TABLE 3.22 SUGGESTED TIMEPOINT ADJUSTMENTS FOR ROUTE 156 3-24 TABLE 3.23 SUGGESTED TIMEPOINT ADJUSTMENTS FOR ROUTE 157 3-26 TABLE 3.24 MIDDLE SCHOOL AND HIGH SCHOOL BELL TIMES 3-27 TABLE 3.25 SUGGESTED TIMEPOINT ADJUSTMENTS FOR ROUTE 159 3-27 TABLE 3.26 WEEKDAY PERFORMANCE ON NEIGHBORHOOD ROUTES 3-29 TABLE 3.37 CAPITAL COST ESTIMATE FOR PROPOSED BRT SYSTEM 3-40 TABLE 3.28 OPERATIONS, COST, AND REVENUE DATA FOR BRT PROJECT 3-41 TABLE 3.29 FTA PROPOSED NEW STARTS AND SMALL STARTS POLICY GUIDANCE 3-42 City of Elk Grove Short Range Transit Plan Page v TABLE 4.1 E-VAN CURRENT FARE TYPES AND PRICES 4-3 TABLE 4.2 E-VAN OPERATIONS AND ADA REQUIREMENTS 4-4 TABLE 4.3 E-VAN BASE TRANSIT OPERATING STATISTICS 4-7 TABLE 4.4 E-VAN PERFORMANCE INDICATORS 4-8 TABLE 4.5 E-VAN DEMAND RESPONSE ON-TIME PERFORMANCE 4-8 TABLE 4.6 E-VAN WEEKEND RIDERSHIP BY DAY AND ROUTE 4-11 TABLE 4.7 PURPLE ROUTE STOPS AND SCHEDULE 4-13 TABLE 4.8 PEER AGENCY DEMOGRAPHICS AND SYSTEMWIDE OPERATING MEASURES (FY 11/12) 4-15 TABLE 4.9 PEER AGENCY DEMAND RESPONSE OPERATING STATISTICS (FY 11/12) 4-16 TABLE 4.10 PEER AGENCY DEMAND RESPOND PERFORMANCE INDICATORS (FY 11/21) 4-16 TABLE 5.1 STATUS OF NEEDS IDENTIFIED THROUGH THE UNMET TRANSIT NEEDS PROCESS , 2008-2012 5-14 TABLE 5.2 ELK GROVE SRTP OPEN HOUSE: RECOMMENDATIONS, QUESTIONS AND CONCERNS 5-15 TABLE 6.1 TRANSIT-RELATED POLICIES, CITY OF ELK GROVE GENERAL PLAN, 2003 6-2 TABLE 6.2 CONTRACTUAL PERFORMANCE STANDARDS 6-3 TABLE 6.3 CITY PERFORMANCE TARGETS 6-4 TABLE 6.4 RECOMMENDATIONS FROM 2013 TDA TRIENNIAL PERFORMANCE AUDIT 6-5 TABLE 6.5 RECOMMENDED POLICIES AND STANDARDS FROM 2008 SRTP 6-6 TABLE 6.6 PEER AGENCY MISSION STATEMENTS 6-7 TABLE 7.1 CONTRACTOR TURNOVER RATES FY 09/10 – FY 11/12 7-5 TABLE 7.2 PEER COMPARISON, VEHICLE SERVICE HOURS PER FULL-TIME EQUIVALENT (VSH/FTE) 7-6 TABLE 9.1 PROJECTED PURCHASED TRANSPORTATION COSTS BASED ON CURRENT MV CONTRACT 9-2 TABLE 9.2 E-TRAN BUDGETED (2013-14) AND PROJECTED OPERATING COSTS 9-3 TABLE 9.3 OPERATING REVENUE ASSUMPTIONS 9-3 TABLE 9.4 OPERATING REVENUES 9-4 TABLE 9.5 ESTIMATED FISCAL AND FLEET IMPACTS OF SERVICE CHANGE ALTERNATIVES 9-7 TABLE 9.6 E-TRAN BUDGETED AND PROJECTED CAPITAL COSTS 9-9 TABLE 9.7 FLEET REPLACEMENT SCHEDULE 9-10 TABLE 9.8 PROJECTED CAPITAL REVENUE 9-11 TABLE 10.1 RECOMMENDATIONS SUMMARY 10-1 City of Elk Grove Short Range Transit Plan Page vi EXECUTIVE SUMMARY City of Elk Grove Short-Range Transit Plan Update This transit planning document has been prepared for the City of Elk Grove to meet state and federal planning requirements, and to provide a management tool and recommendations for operating the City’s transit system.