Thoroughbred Racehorse Mitochondrial DNA Demonstrates Closer Than Expected Links Between Maternal Genetic History and Pedigree Records M.A
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
J. Anim. Breed. Genet. ISSN 0931-2668 ORIGINAL ARTICLE Thoroughbred racehorse mitochondrial DNA demonstrates closer than expected links between maternal genetic history and pedigree records M.A. Bower1, M. Whitten2,*, R.E.R. Nisbet3, M. Spencer4, K.M. Dominy5, A.M. Murphy6, R. Cassidy7, E. Barrett1, E.W. Hill8 & M. Binns2,† 1 McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK 2 Department of Veterinary Basic Sciences, Royal Veterinary College, London, UK 3 Sansom Institute for Health Research, University of South Australia, Adelaide, SA, Australia 4 School of Environmental Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK 5 Department of Medical and Molecular Genetics, School of Medicine, King’s College London, Guy’s Hospital, London, UK 6 Department of Veterinary Basic Sciences, Royal Veterinary College, London, UK 7 Department of Anthropology, Goldsmiths College, London, UK 8 School of Agriculture, Food, Science and Veterinary Medicine, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland Keywords Summary General Studbook; maternal lineage; The potential future earnings and therefore value of Thoroughbred foals mitochondrial DNA; pedigree records; untested in the racing arena are calculated based on the performance of thoroughbred horse. their forebears. Thus, lineage is of key importance. However, previous Correspondence research indicates that maternally inherited mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) M.A. Bower, McDonald Institute for does not correspond to maternal lineage according to recorded pedigree, Archaeological Research, University of casting doubt on the voracity of historic pedigrees. We analysed mtDNA of Cambridge, Downing Street, Cambridge CB2 296 Thoroughbred horses from 33 maternal lineages and identified an 3ER, UK. Tel: 01223 339330; Fax: 07990 interesting trend. Subsequent to the founding of the Thoroughbred breed 514733; E-mail: [email protected] in the 16th century, well-populated maternal lineages were divided into sub-lineages. Only six in 10 of the Thoroughbreds sampled shared mito- Current Address: *Max Planck Research chondrial haplotype with other members of their maternal lineage, Group on Comparative Population Linguistics, despite having a common maternal ancestor according to pedigree Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary records. However, nine in 10 Thoroughbreds from the 103 sub-lineages Anthropology, Leipzig, Germany sampled shared mtDNA with horses of their maternal pedigree sub-line- †Equine Analysis Systems, Lexington, KY age. Thus, Thoroughbred maternal sub-lineage pedigree represents a more 40347, USA accurate breeding record than previously thought. Errors in pedigrees must have occurred largely, though, not exclusively, at sub-lineage foun- Received: 30 March 2012; dation events, probably due to incomplete understanding of modes of accepted: 16 June 2012 inheritance in the past, where maternal sub-lineages were founded from individuals, related, but not by female descent. kept of all Thoroughbreds since the establishment of Introduction the breed to inform breeding choices (Huggins 2000). Horse racing is one of the most popular sports world- These records are held in the General Studbook of wide. The majority of horse races involve the Thor- England (GSB), the first edition of which was pub- oughbred breed, founded in the British Isles in the lished at the end of the 18th century (Weatherby 16th and 17th centuries. Native British mares were 1791). The GSB represents the oldest and most crossed with imported Middle Eastern stallions to give complete record of animal breeding in the world. rise to the elite Thoroughbred we know today (Bower However, recent scientific research comparing the et al. 2011). Extensive pedigree records have been mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) of Thoroughbred horses © 2012 Blackwell Verlag GmbH • J. Anim. Breed. Genet. (2012) 1–9 doi:10.1111/j.1439-0388.2012.01018.x Thoroughbred racehorse maternal genetic history M. A. Bower et al. has called into question the voracity of the pedigrees foundation events. If maternal sub-lineage is a more recorded in the GSB (Hill et al. 2002; Harrison & Turri- accurate indicator of maternal genetic ancestry than on-Gomez 2006) and thus the validity of the General lineage alone, it would suggest that the GSB is a more Studbook as a record of genetic inheritance. Mito- accurate record of past breeding choices than previ- chondrial D-loop DNA is highly variable and has been ously demonstrated, if only at the sub-lineage level. used extensively for phylogenetic reconstruction of domestic horse origins (Jansen et al. 2002; McGahern Materials and methods et al. 2006; Lei et al. 2009), including the Thorough- bred (Bower et al. 2011). However, it is also a power- Mitochondrial DNA sequences for n = 296 Thorough- ful tool in pedigree reconstruction (Bowling et al. bred horses were included in this study and comprised 2000; Luı´s et al. 2006; A´ lvarez et al. 2012). n = 196 Thoroughbred horse mtDNA sequences Because mitochondrial DNA is maternally inher- generated in the study and 100 mtDNA sequences ited, it follows that horses from the same maternal from the Hill et al., study (Hill et al. 2002). Maternal lineage according to pedigree records should share the lineages and sub-lineages were numbered following same mitochondrial sequence. An analysis of 100 the Lowe Family Figure system (Lowe 1913; Bobinski Thoroughbreds showed that eight of 19 maternal lin- 1953). Pedigrees were traced back to the founding eages contained horses with more than one mito- mare of the maternal lineage of each individual chondrial haplotype, despite being related by direct (Bobinski 1953; Weatherby 2010). Close relatives female descent according to the General Studbook (less than three generations) and individuals for (Hill et al. 2002). Subsequently, in a much larger whom pedigree records were not available were study, Harrison & Turrion-Gomez (2006) identified 28 excluded (n = 10). of 33 Thoroughbred lineages that had horses with mtDNA different to that of the founding female of DNA isolation, amplification and sequencing their maternal lineage, suggesting extensive errors in pedigree records. This has been attributed to confu- Whole genomic DNA was isolated from pulled sion of mares at the foundation stages of the breed hairs according to Allen et al. (1998) and from blood and variability in how accurately or ably early samples using a Nucleon DNA Extraction Kit breeding records were kept, prior to the formalization (Amersham Biosciences UK Limited, Little Chalfont of the breeding record in 1791, although some are Buckinghamshire, UK) following the manufacturer’s attributable to more recent recording events (19th instructions. century – 1980). Amplification of the equine mitochondrial D-loop Subsequent to the founding of the Thoroughbred was performed by PCR. Reactions were performed in breed, well-populated maternal lineages were divided 12.5 ll consisting of 1 ll of DNA extract, 19 HiSpec into sub-lineages (e.g. Lowe Family 1a, 1b etc., Lowe additive (Bioline, UK), 19 PCR buffer (Bioline UK 1913). A sub-lineage was formed where a lineage Limited, London, UK), 2.41 mM MgCl2,25lM each of branched from multiple maternally related horses dNTP and 0.25 U Immolase hot start DNA polymerase (e.g. multiple daughters of a given mare). Being a (Bioline). 0.4 lM of each primer was used. Forward sub-section of a maternal lineage, sub-lineage horses primer: 5′ACCCTGGTCTTGTAAACCAG, reverse primer: should share mtDNA, not only with their sub-lineage 5′TGGTTGCTGATGCGGA. (Hill et al. 2002). Thermo- founder, but also with their original maternal lineage cycling conditions were as follows: initial activation at founder, or tap-root mare. However, if horses share 94°C for 10 min was followed by 39 cycles of 94°C for mtDNA with members of their maternal sub-lineage 1 min, 52°C for 1 min and 72°C for 1 min. Sequenc- but not their maternal lineage, this would indicate ing reactions were carried out in both directions using that sub-lineages represent multiple foundation the Big Dye® Terminator v3.1 cycle (Applied Biosys- events involving horses not related by female descent. tems®, Life Technologies Ltd., Paisley, UK) sequencing We hypothesized that the majority of the errors in kit and internal sequencing primer 5′GTTATGTGT- the GSB pedigree records were occurred at sub-line- GAGCATGGGC. Sequencing products were analysed age founding events. To investigate this, we surveyed on an ABI 3100 Genetic Analyzer, and base calling ® 296 Thoroughbred horses (the largest Thorough- was performed using ABI Prism AB DNA Sequencing bred mtDNA data set available in the public domain Analysis Software v5.1.1. (Applied Biosystems®) All to date). We compared mtDNA and sub-lineage PCR amplicons were sequenced in two directions, pedigrees to investigate whether errors in Thorough- sequences were proof read and compared, and contigs bred pedigrees occurred at maternal sub-lineage were constructed using Mega 4 (Kumar et al. 2004). 2 © 2012 Blackwell Verlag GmbH • J. Anim. Breed. Genet. (2012) 1–9 M. A. Bower et al. Thoroughbred racehorse maternal genetic history All unique sequences were re-amplified and rese- sub-divided into 103 sub-lineages. In some cases, indi- quenced using high-fidelity Taq polymerase (Platinum vidual sub-lineages are under-represented in the data; Taq HiFi; Invitrogen, Life Technologies Ltd., Paisley, therefore, where sample number is below n = 3, UK) to confirm haplotype signature. Sequences were results are not discussed; however, low sample num- deposited in