Phenotypic Diversity of Thuridilla Hopei (Vérany, 1853) (Gas- Tropoda Heterobranchia Sacoglossa)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Biodiversity Journal, 2014, 5 (2): 117–130 MONOGRAPH Phenotypic diversity of Thuridilla hopei (Vérany, 1853) (Gas- tropoda Heterobranchia Sacoglossa). A DNA-barcoding ap- proach Giulia Furfaro1, Maria Vittoria Modica2, Marco Oliverio2, Juan Lucas Cervera3 & Paolo Mariottini1* 1Dipartimento di Scienze, Università degli Studi di “Roma Tre”, Viale Marconi 446, 00146 Rome, Italy; e-mail: [email protected]; [email protected] 2Dipartimento di Biologia e Biotecnologie “Charles Darwin”, Università di Roma “La Sapienza”, Viale dell’Università 32, 00185 Rome, Italy; e-mail: [email protected]; [email protected] 3Departamento de Biología, Facultad de Ciencias del Mar y Ambientales, Campus de Excelencia Internacional del Mar (CEI•MAR,) Universidad de Cádiz. Polígono Río San Pedro, s/n, Ap.40. 11510 Puerto Real (Cádiz), Spain; e-mail: [email protected] *Corresponding author ABSTRACT The sacoglossan Thuridilla hopei (Vérany, 1853) shows highly diverse chromatic patterns. Based on the morphological examination of specimens from different Mediterranean locali- ties, we have observed that in spite of this great variability in colours of T. hopei, two major chromatic morphotypes are related to bathymetry. Specimens from deeper water exhibit blue darker and more uniform patterns than individuals from shallower water, which show a more variable, dashed and spotted arrangement of light blue, yellow, orange, white and black pigmentation. A molecular genetic analysis using the mitochondrial COI and 16S rDNA markers has confirmed that all these extremely different chromatic morphotypes belong to a single specific entity, i.e. T. hopei, a sacoglossan with a wide distribution, from Macaronesia in the Atlantic, to the easternmost Mediterranean Sea. KEY WORDS Sacoglossa; Thuridilla hopei; colour morphotypes; Mediterranean Sea; Atlantic Ocean. Received 28.01.2014; accepted 21.03.2014; printed 30.06.2014 Proceedings of the Seventh Malacological Pontine Meeting, September 9th-10th, 2013 - San Felice Circeo, Italy INTRODUCTION Cladophora vagabunda (Linnaeus) van den Hoek (Marín & Ros, 2004; Händeler & Wägele, 2007; The plakobranchid sacoglossan genus Thuri- Händeler, 2011) and it retains functional algal chloro- dilla Bergh, 1872 is represented in the northeastern plasts from its food for few days (Marín & Ros, Atlantic and in the Mediterranean Sea by two 1989, 2004). The aposematic chromatic pattern of species, T. hopei (Vérany, 1853) (Carmona et al., this slug is related to the presence in its tissues of 2011; Malaquias et al., 2012) and the amphiatlantic toxic compounds like the diterpenoids thuridillin A, T. mazda Ortea et Spinosa, 2000, recently recorded B and C and nor-thuridillin (Gavagnin et al., 1993; from the Azores (Malaquias et al., 2012). The brightly De Rinaldis, 2012). coloured T. hopei lives from the lower intertidal During the last decade, the high levels of in- down to about 35 m depth, and generally is found traspecific chromatic variation of T. hopei has been crawling on hard substrate. It feeds suctorially well documented in literature (Trainito, 2005; on photophilous algae, in particular on Derbesia Händeler, 2011; Carmona et al., 2011 and refer- tenuissima (de Notaris) Crouan et Crouanand ences therein), as well as depicted in the Sea Slug 118 GIULIA FURFARO ET ALII Forum (Australian Museum, Sydney, Available University). DNA was extracted using a standard from http://www.seaslugforum.net/). It is worth of proteinase K phenol/chloroform method with mentioning that the Macaronesian specimens of T. ethanol precipitation, as reported in Oliverio & hopei, have long been ascribed to the Caribbean T. Mariottini (2001). A fragment of the mitochondrial picta (Verril, 1901), due to a similar colour pattern 16S rDNA was amplified by PCR using the univer- (see Cervera et al., 2004; Malaquias et al., 2009), sal primers 16Sar-L and 16Sbr-H (Palumbi et al., until Carmona et al. (2011) demonstrated by genetic 2001), while a fragment of the mitochondrial cy- data that they belong to T. hopei. tochrome oxidase I (COI) was amplified using the We have observed and documented the chro- universal primers LCO1490 and HCO2198 (Folmer matic variability of T. hopei at different Mediter- et al., 1994); for PCR conditions see Prkić et al. ranean localities, particularly along the Italian coast. (2014). All amplicons were sequenced by Genechron Interestingly, we observed that the distribution of Centre of Sequencing, ENEA (La Casaccia, Rome, different chromatic phenotypes is related to ba- Italy) or by European Division of Macrogen Inc. thymetry, as previously reported by Cattaneo-Vietti (Amsterdam, The Netherlands), using the same (1990) and Händeler (2011). Specimens from deeper PCR primers. water exhibit dark blue and more uniform patterns Forward and reverse sequences were assembled (“bluish” form according to Händeler, 2011: 37) and edited, and the resulting consensus sequences than individuals from shallower water, which show of each specimen were readily aligned by hand. a more dashed and spotted arrangement of light BLAST search was always conducted for each se- blue, yellow, orange, white and black pigmentation quence. Published sequences (COI and 16S) of Thuridilla were downloaded from theGenBank. (“rosy” form according to Händeler, 2011: 37). Dif- Although the definition of a phylogenetic hypothe- ferent colour types have been usually considered as sis for the genus Thuridilla was not within the aims chromatic morphotypes of T. hopei, despite the con- of this paper, nevertheless, phylogenetic relation- sistent chromatic differences linked to their ba- ships among the Thuridilla sequences were inferred thymetry (Carmona et al., 2011). to have a phylogenetic framework for the estima- Therefore, we wanted to either confirm or deny tion of the genetic distances: we used neighbour- the conspecificity of “bluish” and “rosy” forms by joining (NJ) and maximum likelihood (ML) (both genetic data, being the significance of chromatic bootstrapped over 1000 replicates), by the software differences difficult to evaluate based on morpho- MEGA 5.0 (Tamura et al., 2011) and Bayesian logical data alone. In this study we applied a molecu- Inference (BI) by the software MrBayes (with 5*106 lar analysis, using two mitochondrial markers, the generations, and 25% burnin) by MrBayes 3.2.2 barcode COI and the 16S rDNA, to the different (Ronquist et al., 2012). Sequences of the Atlantic colour morphotypes of T. hopei, to test the hypothe- Elysia timida Risso, 1818, retrieved from the sis that “bluish” and “rosy” specimens of these GenBank, were used as outgroup. Nodes in the phy- snails belong to the same species and confirm the logenetic trees were considered ‘highly’ supported lusitanic distribution of this sacoglossan sea slug. with Bayesian posterior values ≥96% and bootstrap values ≥80%; nodes with Bayesian posterior values of 90–95% and bootstrap values of 70–79% were MATERIAL AND METHODS considered ‘moderately’ supported (lower support values were considered not significant). Collection data, vouchers and accession num- Genetic divergence among the barcode COI bers are listed in Table 1. Italian specimens from sequences was observed (p distance) and estimated several localities were collected by hand during using the Kimura-2-parameters nucleotide substi- SCUBA diving at different depth. Each specimen tution model (K2p distance). was photographed in situ and/or in aquarium, then fixed in ethanol. A piece of tissue was dissected from the foot for RESULTS AND DISCUSSION DNA extraction, and the remaining animal was de- posited at the Department of Biology and Biotech- Animals were observed and sampled at seven nologies “Charles Darwin” (La Sapienza Rome localities of the Tyrrhenian Sea (Table 1). Phenotypic diversity of Thuridilla hopei (Gastropoda Heterobranchia Sacoglossa). A DNA-barcoding approach 119 Species Voucher ID Locality COI 16S References MNCN Menorca, Carmona et al., Elysia timida HQ616847 --------------- 15.05/53680 Spain (MED) 2011 MNCN Carmona et al., Elysia timida Menorca, Spain (MED) --------------- HQ616818 15.05/53680 2011 Thuridilla NW-Sulawesi, Händeler & ZSM:20033615 --------------- EU140889 albopustulosa Indonesia Wägele, 2007 Thuridilla bayeri --------------- --------------- DQ471279 DQ480208 Bass, 2006 Thuridilla bayeri --------------- --------------- --------------- DQ480206 Bass, 2006 Thuridilla bayeri --------------- --------------- --------------- DQ480207 Bass, 2006 Thuridilla bayeri --------------- --------------- --------------- DQ480207 Bass, 2006 NW-Sulawesi, Händeler & Thuridilla bayeri ZSM:20033612 --------------- EU140886 Indonesia Wägele, 2007 Lizard Island, Wägele et al., Thuridilla carlsoni --------------- HM187640 --------------- Australia 2010 Lizard Island, Händeler & Thuridilla carlsoni --------------- --------------- EU140877 Australia Wägele, 2007 Lizard Island, Händeler & Thuridilla carlsoni --------------- --------------- EU140878 Australia Wägele, 2007 Thuridilla carlsoni --------------- --------------- --------------- DQ480214 Bass, 2006 Lizard Island, Wägele et al., Thuridilla gracilis --------------- HM187641 --------------- Australia 2010 Hamahiga, Okinawa, Takano et al., Thuridilla gracilis --------------- AB758972 --------------- Japan 2013 Lizard Island, Händeler & Thuridilla gracilis --------------- --------------- EU140884 Australia Wägele, 2007 Lizard Island, Händeler & Thuridilla gracilis --------------- --------------- EU140885 Australia Wägele, 2007 Lizard Island,