Short and Long-Term Outcomes of the Manchester Procedure for Pelvic Organ Prolapse and the Impact of Major Levator Ani Muscle Defects
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Short and long-term outcomes of the Manchester Procedure for Pelvic Organ Prolapse and the impact of major Levator Ani Muscle defects PhD thesis by Sissel Hegdahl Oversand, MD 2018 Department of Gynaecology, Oslo University Hospital, Ullevål and University of Oslo, Faculty of Medicine, Norway © Sissel Hegdahl Oversand, 2018 Series of dissertations submitted to the Faculty of Medicine, University of Oslo ISBN 978-82-8377-335-4 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without permission. Cover: Hanne Baadsgaard Utigard. Print production: Reprosentralen, University of Oslo. # " !$ ! ." '&*&0# &)),(*&0#),!(-/**),. &0.),(#'/-&0/&-#)(- *&0#),!(*,)&*- -/,!#&'(!'(.) *&0#),!(*,)&*- ."'("-.,*,)/, *)*-/,!,3#(.,(&+/&#.3)(.,)& )/.)''-/,-#(*)*-/,!,3 )-.^ .#0(-- *.#(.-&.#)( -/,!#&.(#+/- (.)'#&0&/.#)(.))&- *.#(. ,*),.0&/.#)(.))&- )/.)''-/,- (0196,6(8, 3(8420*(1498*42,7 !(80,386,5468,+498*42,7 42510*(80437 -..#-.#&(&3--(*)1,&/&.#)(- &!#-&.#)((,-,"."#- !$! -"),.(&)(! .,' #&/,,.- *,0&() &'0/&-#)(-(#'*.)(*,)*,.#0 -../- #'*.) &'0/&-#)(-)()( 3,*)-.)*,.#0)/.)'- (.)'#&(*.#(. ,*),.)/.)'-)(3, ., (.#0.#--/*)*,*#,-1#."'#( )/-)(."'("-., *,)/, ! '."))&)!#&)(-#,.#)(- B #89+=+,70.3(3+789+=54591(80437 07703.+(8( !,1:0* 6.(3!641(57,"9(380-0*(80437*(1,! !">>>>> $6(375,603,(1%186(7493+ "9,780433(06,7 $,1,5/43,038,6:0,; #86,3./87(3+10208(80437 #8(80780*(1(3(1=7,7 #-/--#)() ,-/&.- ! " ! ! **(#2#."*&0#),!(*,)&*-+/(.# #.#)(*)* + -3-.' **(#2."*&0# &)),#-.,--#(0(.),3-"),. ),' * # **(#2."*&0#),!(*,)&*- /,#(,3#()(.#(( -2/&+/-.#)((#,-"),. ),' *#-+ **(#2-"),. ),'*"3-##("%&#-. ),."*)*-/,!,3 #(.,(&+/&#.3)(.,)&,!#-.,3*,.'(.) !3()&)!3 )-&)/(#0,-#.3")-*#.& " C .@=OGJCHJ=K=FL=<AFL@AK*@L@=KAKO9K;9JJA=<GML9LL@==H9JLE=FL G>!QF=;GDG?Q)KDG/FAN=JKALQ"GKHAL9D9F<9LL@= 9;MDLQG>'=<A;AF= /FAN=JKALQG>)KDG:=LO==F 9F< AJKLG>9DD#OGMD<DAC=LGL@9FC>GJE=J"=9<G>L@=/JG?QF=;GDG?Q/FAL DD=FGJKL9<>GJ9O9C=FAF?EQAFL=J=KLAFL@=>A=D<O@AD= =FL@MKA9KLA;9DDQL=9;@AF?E=L@=HJAF;AHD=K9F<KCADDKG>*=DNA;)J?9F *JGD9HK=KMJ?=JQMKAF?F9LAN=LAKKM=J=H9AJK -@=O9K9DKGL@=GF=O@G KL9JL=<E=GFEQ9;9<=EA;;9J==J:Q9KCAF?E=LGAFN=KLA?9L=*=DNA; )J?9F*JGD9HK=KMJ?=JQGML;GE=KG>OGE=FJ=?AKL=J=<AFL@= =H9JLE=FL8KAFL=JF9DIM9DALQ;GFLJGDJ=?AKLJQO@A;@K@=AFLJG<M;=<AF #LO9K@GO=N=JFFQ-HQ<KD9M?L@=F"=9<G>L@==H9JLE=FLG> !QF=;GDG?QO@G:9;CAF G>>=J=<E=9LJ9AFAF?HGKALAGF9LL@= /JG?QF=;GDG?QMFAL9F<L@MK9DDGO=<E=LG:=;GE=9H9JLG>L@AK OGF<=J>MD9F<AFKHAJAF??JGMH #9E>GJ=N=J?J9L=>MDFFQ #@9N=:==F=PLJ=E=DQDM;CQLG:=9KKA?F=<OAL@L@=OGJD<YK:=KL<MGG> KMH=JNAKGJK 'QE9AFKMH=JNAKGJ,MF=-N=FFAF?K=FAK@A?@DQ CFGOD=<?=9:D=HJ=;AK=9F<@9J< OGJCAF? 1@=F@=K9QK@=YDD:=MF9:D= LG?AN=>==<:9;CGFEQOGJC<MJAF?L@=O==C=F<MKM9DDQ<M=LG@AK CJGF=J:9KK;D9JAF=L@AKJ=KHGFK=OADDF=N=JL@=D=KKHGHAF:Q -MF<9Q ,MF=@9KOGJC=<LAJ=D=KKDQLGL=9;@E=9;;MJ9;Q9F<L@= AEHGJL9F;=G>C==HAF?=N=JQL@AF?MF<=JLA?@L;GFLJGDLGKM;@9<=?J== L@9L@=@9KDGKL CADGK<MJAF?L@=K=Q=9JK #9EKG?J9L>MD>GJL@=BG: QGM@9N=<GF=,MF=@GH=>MDDQ#@9N=E9F9?=<LGAEHJGN=9F<L@9LQGM 9>L=JL@=K=@9J<Q=9JKKLADDOADD:=9JOGJCAF?AFL@=K9E=MFAL9KE= #9E D HJ=H9J=<>GJ9DEGKL9FQL@AF?L@GM?@#OADDF=N=JBGAFQGM>GJ9K;A >A EGNA= 'QKAF;=J=?J9LALM<=9DKG?G=KLGEQ;G KMH=JNAKGJFF=LAF=-L9>>O@G OAL@@=J=PLJ9GJ<AF9JQAFL=DD=;LM9D;9H9;ALQ9F<=PL=F<=<J=K=9J;@ =PH=JA=F;=@9K:==FG>AFN9DM9:D=KMHHGJL "=JMFAIM=;GE:AF9LAGFG> =PLJ=E==>>A;A=F;Q9F<?GG<@MEGJ@9KK=N=J9DLAE=KE9<=E=K==L@= DA?@LAFL@=<9JCF=KK -@=@9K:==FL@=AF<GEAL9:D=GHLAEAKLG>GMJLJAFALQ .@9FCQGMFF=LAF=#@9N=D=9JFLAF;J=<A:DQEM;@>JGEQGM 'Q9HHJ=;A9LAGF9DKG?G=KLGEQ;G 9ML@GJK #F?JA<0GDD]Q@9M?OAL@@=J GMLKL9F<AF?9F9DQLA;9DKCADDK@9K:JGM?@LF=O9KH=;LKLGEQOGJC &=AN -9F<NAC@9KAF:=LO==FAFKHAJAF?HGDALA;9D<AK;MKKAGFK?AN=FAFN9DM9:D= KMHHGJLGFKL9LAKLA;9DAKKM=KOAL@9HJ9?E9LA;9HHJG9;@O=DD9<9HL=<>GJ9 ;DAFA;A9FDAC=E= #9DKGOGMD<DAC=LGL@9FCB]JFMKMF<'9JAL&A=F?.@GE9K.@9MDGO !MJA'9B9C9F<'AJA9E(Q:=J?O@G9K<=H9JLE=FL9<EAFAKLJ9LGJK@9N= >MF<=<EQJ=K=9J;@9F<?AN=FE=L@=HGKKA:ADALQLGH=J>GJEH9JL LAE= J=K=9J;@O@AD=E9AFL9AFAF?EQ;DAFA;9DHGKALAGF DDG>QGM@9N= J=KH=;L=<L@=AEHGJL9F;=G>J=K=9J;@9F<@9N=@=DH=<HJGL=;LEQLAE= <=KA?F9L=<>GJJ=K=9J;@>JGEAFL=JJMHLAF?;DAFA;9DL9KCK .GEQ;GDD=9?M=K9LL@=/JG?QF=;GDG?Q/FALO@G>GJE9OGF<=J>MD ?JGMHO@=J==N=JQGF=K@9J=KL@=AJCFGOD=<?=9F<K@9JH=D:GOK9J=FGF =PAKL=FL DDG>QGM@9N=HD9Q=<AEHGJL9FLJGD=KAFH=J>GJEAF?L@=KLM<A=K O@A;@>GJEL@AKL@=KAK -H=;A9DL@9FCKLGEQ>JA=F<)D=O@GMF;GMFL9:D= LAE=K@9K<JGHH=<O@9L=N=J@=@9KAF@AK@9F<K9F<?AN=FE= L=;@FGDG?A;9D>AJKL 9A< E #9E9DKG<==HDQAF<=:L=<LGEQOGF<=J>MD>JA=F<K9LL@=_KG;A9DG>>A;=`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≥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