DOCSLIB.ORG

"Tell Me, Doctor, Is Epidemiology Dangerous!" Michel C

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
"Tell me, doctor, is epidemiology dangerous!" Michel C. Thuriaux confess that I was disconcerted Epidemiology is not limited only to by this question. In trying to reply Hippocrates said ... infectious diseases, not by a long way. I had first of all to think about "Whoever would study medi­ Our food and the manner in which we what epidemiology is, how it is cine aright ... must consider the eat affect our health. James Lind in the used and why. In one of the effect of each of the seasons of 18th century and Kanehiro Takaki in Ioldest texts on epidemiology, Hippo­ the year and the differences the 19th showed the role played by crates of Cos stresses the importance - between them .. The effect of food in the fight against scurvy and in order to fight the diseases which water on the health must not be beri-beri. At the beginning of this attack communities - of studying the forgotten . .. When a physician century, Joseph Goldberger studied place (where?), the time (when?) and comes to a district previously the deficiencies which affected poor the characteristics of those communi­ unknown to him, he should people in the United States and which ties (who? how?). consider both its situation and provoked insanity in sufficient numbers The epidemiology of the environ­ its aspect to the winds ... Then. to fill the asylums; as a result he ment and of lifestyles were thus think of the soil. whether it be developed methods which are still already subjects of concern about 25 bare and waterless or thickly being applied in the epidemiology of centuries ago. Even older texts found covered with soil and well ­ disorders related to nutrition. in the Indus Valley discussed similar watered . Lastl y consider the In the same way, our general life­ preoccupations as regards water life of the inhabitants them­ styles and our working conditions supplies and improvements in sani­ selves: are they heavy drinkers affect health. Last century, in the tation. The development of health and eaters and consequently Mulhouse region of France, Louis­ statistics in the 17th century made it unable to stand fatigue. or - Rene Villerme had already described possible to give better and more being fond of work and exercise the effects of their working conditions systematic answers to the question: - eat wisely but drink sparingly? on the health of the cotton workers. how many? which had been more or . A physician who under­ Closer to our own time, in the 1950s, less evaded until then. Various other stands these subjects well . .. the epidemiological studies of Richard factors have since contributed to the would know what epidemics to Doll and Austin Bradford Hill drew development of epidemiology over the expect. both in the su mmer and attention to the active role of tobacco last 200 years. in the winter. and what particu­ in lung cancer. These studies provided The evolution of medicine and lar disadvantages threatened an the basis for the works which have public health in the course of the last individual who changed his made us better able to identify the risks century led to a better knowledge of mode of life ... He wou ld be involved in tobacco and to develop infectious diseases and ways of fighting very successful in the practice of programmes to combat smoking. them. (The application of this know­ medicine." ledge is always topical, and resulted in the eradication of smallpox ten years ago, while these methods continue to be applied today, for example, in the fight against AIDS). But even before the existence had been proved, during the second half of the 19th century, of infectious germs and the laws governing their transmission, "the study of water and habits" had already made it possible to take action on the factors that influence health. In 1849 John Snow, after studying the water supply sources in a London district hard hit by cholera, removed the handle of a pump that supplied water which he considered dangerous. Two years earlier, Ignaz Semmelweis caused a sharp drop in the number of women dying in childbirth in Vienna's hospital by calling for midwives and doctors to wash their hands before examining mothers-to-be. 4 WORLD HEALTH, June 1989 major health care programmes in the policies that would be needed to attain "Our food and the manner in which we eat affect our health., A meal for poor United States. them. They are now striving on a So we can say that epidemiology regular basis to collect the vital children in India. helps us to identify the factors which information which will enable them to Photo T. P. Singh influence our health (by giving answers measure their progress towards the Facing page: /gnaz Semmelweis (181~ to the questions where, when, who, goals. On the basis of this information, 1865) and his hygienic basin how much?). The most important they will then t!y to develop their own encountered the hostility of colleagues question still remains: and then? In new programmes and policies or to who saw no reason for doctors to wash order to reply effectively, it is necessary: improve existing ones. All these will their hands before examining women - "Firstly, to know how to draw con- entail considerable changes and in labour. clusions that result from these readjustments, which are unlikely to be Photos WHO replies (that is the role of the effected without a great deal of heart­ analyses carried out by epidemi­ searching. Finally, epidemiological methods ology); Let me come back to the question have been applied to the development - "And secondly, to want to apply which began this article. All political and use of the health services, whether those conclusions in support of action is risky, and no change can by comparing methods of intervention programmes and policies - or to come about without risk. In the case of (efficacity of the cervical smear in the develop new ones - that will make Semmelweis mentioned above, the risk struggle against cancer of the neck of better health possible (the role of proved to be only too real. Exposed to the uterus) or ways of promoting political decision). the hostility of colleagues who could health, or of establishing what types of It is therefore essential that epidem­ not forgive him for insisting on their service and staff can most efficiently iological knowledge and political will washing their hands before examining take charge of health care activities. support each other. The member women in labour, he died insane and Studies of this type have, for example, countries of WHO recently established in misery in 1865. Without necessarily made it possible to confirm the precise health goals and drew up wishing to go quite so far, it might be effectiveness and usefulness of various useful to recall that, to the degree that categories of personnel in family it supports health policy or even just planning programmes in several coun­ All photos in th is issue which are not marked politics generally, epidemiology is tries. One such study provided the WHO or © for copyright are entries in wHo's neither totally harmless, innocent, nor under-pinning for the setting up and 40th anniversary International Photo without risk. And perhaps that is not evaluating of nurse practitioners in Competition. such a bad thing. • WORLD HEALTH , June 1989 5 .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • C Semmelweisâ•Žs 19Th-Century Cure for Deadly Childbed Fever Ignored
    Headwaters Volume 29 Article 3 2016 Dr. Ignác Semmelweis’s 19th-Century Cure for Deadly Childbed Fever Ignored in Vienna’s Maternity Wards: His Sympathy for Women Victims and Their Newborns Costs Professional Standing Anna Lisa Ohm College of Saint Benedict/Saint John's University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.csbsju.edu/headwaters Part of the History of Science, Technology, and Medicine Commons, and the Women's History Commons Recommended Citation Ohm, Anna Lisa (2016) "Dr. Ignác Semmelweis’s 19th-Century Cure for Deadly Childbed Fever Ignored in Vienna’s Maternity Wards: His Sympathy for Women Victims and Their Newborns Costs Professional Standing," Headwaters: Vol. 29, 23-35. Available at: https://digitalcommons.csbsju.edu/headwaters/vol29/iss1/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@CSB/SJU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Headwaters by an authorized editor of DigitalCommons@CSB/SJU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. ANNA LISA OHM ____________________________________ Dr. Ignác Semmelweis’s 19th-Century Cure for Deadly Childbed Fever Ignored in Vienna’s Maternity Wards: His Sympathy for Women Victims and Their Newborns Costs Professional Standing For some 19th-century women ready to give birth, even a public street was preferable to a bed in an accredited hospital delivery ward where statistics suggested a massacre of women and newborns throughout Europe and the United States. Puerperal septicemia, commonly called childbed fever, was the culprit, and nobody in the world’s medical or scientific community at the time knew how to control its epidemic proportions.
    [Show full text]
  • Ignaz Semmelweis: a Victim of Harassment?
    main topic Wien Med Wochenschr https://doi.org/10.1007/s10354-020-00738-1 Ignaz Semmelweis: a victim of harassment? Sonja Schreiner Received: 4 November 2019 / Accepted: 10 February 2020 © The Author(s) 2020 Summary Ignaz Semmelweis’ (1818–1865) discovery 1865, his relatives (including his wife) and friends of the endemic causes of febris puerperalis is a strik- took him from Budapest to Vienna. He thought he ing example of the role of pathology in medicine. was going to spend some time relaxing, but in fact Transdisciplinarity encounters Semmelweis’ biogra- was led into a newly built asylum for the mentally ill, phy, which is neither linear nor totally focused on the Niederösterreichische Landesirrenanstalt.When medicine. He completed the philosophicum (artis- he realized what was happening, he tried to escape. terium), studying the septem artes liberales (1835–1837) Badly abused, he died from sepsis caused by open in Pest, comprising humanities and natural science. wounds and a dirty straightjacket 2 weeks later. This After moving to Vienna, he began to study law, but article will show Semmelweis to be a multilingual turned to medicine as early as 1838. In 1844, he grad- author of scientific literature and (open) letters; it will uated with a botanical doctoral thesis composed in present him as a researcher who became a victim of Neo-Latin, showing linguistic and stylistic talent and harassment and what is referred to as the “Semmel- a broad knowledge of gynecology and obstetrics. The weis reflex” (“Semmelweis effect”); and it will focus style and topoi demonstrate the interchangeability of on his afterlife in (children’s) literature, drama, and what he learnt during his propaedeuticum.Nowa- film.
    [Show full text]
  • Ignaz Semmelweis and the Birth of Infection Control M Best, D Neuhauser
    233 Qual Saf Health Care: first published as 10.1136/qshc.2004.010918 on 2 June 2004. Downloaded from HEROES AND MARTYRS OF QUALITY AND SAFETY Ignaz Semmelweis and the birth of infection control M Best, D Neuhauser ............................................................................................................................... Qual Saf Health Care 2004;13:233–234. doi: 10.1136/qshc.2004.010918 orldwide, sepsis is the cause of death in about 1400 people each day.1 Many of these people develop Wsepsis from infections acquired as patients while in a hospital. Infections acquired in the hospital are called nosocomial infections. They are the most common complica- tions of hospitalized patients, with 5–10% of patients in acute care hospitals acquiring at least one infection. Nosocomial infections occur in 2 million patients per year in the United States, causing 90 000 deaths and resulting in $4.5–5.7 bil- lion in additional patient care costs.2 INFECTION CONTROL Influenza virus, Legionnaires’ disease, bacterial meningitis, measles, West Nile virus, tularemia, hepatitis A, rotavirus, Norwalk virus, multidrug resistant Pseudomonas, super- resistant Klebsiella, methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), and vancomycin resistant Enterococcus are just a few of the infectious organisms and diseases that may be contracted while in hospital. Infection control is essential to limit the spread of these diseases. Cross-infection of patients by the contaminated hands of healthcare workers is a major method of spreading infectious agents. Hand hygiene is noted to be the single most important factor for infection control. Even today, hand washing is performed only one Figure 1 Postage stamp of Ignaz Philipp Semmelweis, 1818–1865. third to one half as often as it should be.3 Issued in Austria in 1965 on the 100th anniversary of his death.
    [Show full text]
  • The Development of the Germ Theory of Disease and the Impact That Discovery Has Had on Human Health Human Population Growth Over the Millennia
    Determinants of the Quality of Human Life Humans have always been interested in infectious diseases even before they knew their cause. In this course we will examine the development of the Germ Theory of Disease and the impact that discovery has had on human health Human population growth over the millennia Causes of Death, 1900-1984 1900 1984 Increasing life expectancy Decreasing pediatric death-rate Again, more data comparing 1900 with 2000 “The Triumph of Death”; Depictions of plague or ‘The Black Death’ from the mid-sixteenth century. Girolamo Fracastoro • Fracastoro, a careful observer of disease transmission – obvious that some diseases were the same regardless of patient – specific diseases passed person to person had same symptoms • “On Contagion”, 1546 – mentions “seminaria” or seeds of disease. – before microbial world • Three general patterns: – Direct contact only – Fomes (fomites) – At a distance Fracastoro’s “Incurable Wound” on rabies, humans not the only ones, but they always die Anton van Leeuwenhoek and his microscope (1632-1723) Recipe for making mice J.B. van Helmont ∼ 1620 AD “If a dirty undergarment is squeezed into the mouth of a vessel containing wheat, within a few days (say 21) a ferment drained from the garments and transformed by the smell of the grain, encrusts the wheat itself with its own skin and turns it into mice. And what is more remarkable, the mice from the grain and undergarments are neither weanlings or sucklings nor premature but they jump out fully formed.” p • Sugar metabolism: Fermentation – with O2 = CO2 + water = – W/O O2 organic acids or alcohol – was considered a chemical process due to unstable molecules – The “ferment” – Schwann, yeast = Etoh – L.
    [Show full text]
  • Infection Control Through the Ages
    American Journal of Infection Control 40 (2012) 35-42 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect American Journal of Infection Control American Journal of Infection Control journal homepage: www.ajicjournal.org Major article Infection control through the ages Philip W. Smith MD a,*, Kristin Watkins MBA b, Angela Hewlett MD a a Division of Infectious Diseases, Department of Internal Medicine, University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, NE b Center for Preparedness Education, College of Public Health, University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, NE Key Words: To appreciate the current advances in the field of health care epidemiology, it is important to understand History the history of hospital infection control. Available historical sources were reviewed for 4 different Hospitals historical time periods: medieval, early modern, progressive, and posteWorld War II. Hospital settings Nosocomial for the time periods are described, with particular emphasis on the conditions related to hospital infections. Copyright Ó 2012 by the Association for Professionals in Infection Control and Epidemiology, Inc. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. Approximately 1.7 million health careeassociated infections One of the few public health measures was the collection of (HAIs) occur in the United States each year.1 Hospital infection bodies of plague victims. The bodies were left in the street to be control programs are nearly universal in developed nations and have picked up by carts and placed in mass graves outside of town.3,4 significantly lowered the risk of acquiring a HAI since their inception Other infection control measures included hanging people who in the mid 20th century. As we debate the preventability of HAIs, as wandered in from an epidemic region into an uninfected area, well as the ethical and logistic aspects of patient safety, it is impor- shutting up plague victims in their homes, and burning clothing tant to recall the historical context of hospital infection control.
    [Show full text]
  • Epidemiology Explore Lab Science What Is Epidemiology?
    Epidemiology Explore Lab Science What is Epidemiology? Epidemiology is the study of patterns, causes, and effects of disease in a defined population. It is essential for identifying the risk factors of a disease and, ultimately, to prevent outbreaks. Hippocrates The Greek physician Hippocrates is believed to be the first epidemiologist. He was the first to link environmental exposures to disease. He didn’t have it quite right though - he believed that sickness was caused by an “imbalance of humors:” blood, yellow bile, black bile, and phlegm. To treat sickness he believed you must add or remove a humor, one of the treatments being blood letting. The four humors. Epidemic vs Endemic Hippocrates was the first to make the distinction between epidemic and endemic diseases. The former being newly established disease in a population and the latter being disease that is always present at some capacity in a population. For example, Zika is currently considered an epidemic. While STDs can be considered endemic in certain parts of the world. Girolamo Fracastoro In the 16th century an Italian doctor by the name of Girolamo Fracastoro hypothesized that it was actually small, living particles that cause disease, not humorism. He wrote a book promoting personal and environmental hygiene as a way to prevent disease and introduced the idea of non-living things, such as clothing, harboring infectious agents. Germ Theory The Germ Theory suggested by Fracastoro wasn’t proven until a powerful enough microscope was invented to provide visible evidence of the living particles, or microbes. In 1675, Anton van Leeuwenhoek was the first to observe single cell organisms using one of his handmade microscopes.
    [Show full text]
  • Semmelweis: a Social Epidemiologic Update on Safe Motherhood Julie Cwikel, Ph.D
    THEMES AND DEBATES Lessons from Semmelweis: A Social Epidemiologic Update On Safe Motherhood Julie Cwikel, Ph.D Abstract human transmission vector) who inadvertently In this historical review, Ignaz Semmelweis’ infect their patients, then a change in behavior is study of handwashing to prevent puerperal fever is required, challenging behavioral science and described and used as a benchmark from which to social epidemiology to prove their efficacy. 1 2 The identify salient issues that are informative to quintessential study in social epidemiology today's women’s health activists working for Safe occurred in Vienna in 1847 when Dr. Ignaz Motherhood. The epidemiology of contemporary Semmelweis (1818-1865) introduced institutional excess maternal mortality is reviewed.Using the and behavioral guidelines for handwashing in conceptual framework of social epidemiology, the order to reduce the rate of puerperal fever among paper addresses four issues that were problematic women delivering in the Obstetrical Clinic in the in Semmelweis’ era. New tools in public health Vienna General Hospital, the Allgemeines are presented that can help to solve critical, still Krankenhaus. Semmelweis took an challenging problems to reduce excess maternal interventionist stance and applied his correct mortality, nosocomial infections, and puerperal interpretation of numeric data to change the fever at childbirth: 1) progress in behavioral behavior of his fellow physicians within a medical methods to promote health behavior change, 2) the organization. Research, in this case, was introduction of participatory action research, 3) challenged to prove its value in the real world by the diffusion of evidence-based public health taking “robust evidence” and translating it into an practice and 4) understanding how politics and effective public health policy.
    [Show full text]
  • Ignaz Semmelweis, Carl Mayrhofer, and the Rise of Germ Theory
    Medical History, 1985, 29: 33-53. IGNAZ SEMMELWEIS, CARL MAYRHOFER, AND THE RISE OF GERM THEORY by K. CODELL CARTER* Research interests in late nineteenth-century medicine focused heavily on aetiology- a subject that one contemporary writer called "the chief science of medicine"., The quest for necessary causes of specific diseases characterized not only research on the infectious diseases but also on psychological disorders and the deficiency diseases.2 In a sense, all of these investigations rested on the assumption that each specific disease had a necessary cause. In fact, this assumption would have been false given the symptomatic and anatomical characterizations that prevailed inmedicine until the late nineteenth century; any physical state such as a collection of symptoms or an anatomical lesion can, in principle, be caused in many different ways. The adoption of aetiological characterizations for specific diseases, which made it true by definition that each characterized disease had a necessary cause, was, therefore, essential to research of this kind. In an earlier paper I argued that Ignaz Semmelweis's account of childbed fever, like the aetiological accounts of the infectious diseases that were generated a few decades later, also rested on the assumption that a single necessary cause could be identified for every case of this disease.3 No one who originally responded to Semmelweis's work, including those who are generally identified as his supporters, accepted this assumption, and, indeed, nearly everyone explicitly rejected it.4 This hostile reaction suggests that the approach was unfamiliar, that Semmelweis may have been among the first to have adopted it.
    [Show full text]
  • Semmelweis and Childbed Fever: the Scientific Method at Work
    Learning Target: SC.10.11.10.01 Designs a scientific investigation to answer an original question ✓Identify examples of scientific investigations ✓Identify each step of the scientific method Mini-lesson One Semmelweis and Childbed Fever: The Scientific Method at Work The Question It is the year 1847. A Hungarian physician working in Vienna, Ignaz Semmelweis, makes an interesting observation. Rich Viennese women who give birth in his hospital and receive the finest care from highly trained physicians are dying from childbed fever in far greater numbers than poor women who give birth in a nearby birthing center run by midwives. Why is the death rate four times as high in the hospital compared to the birthing center? The Hypothesis Semmelweis notices that the hospital physicians travel from patient to patient without changing their smocks or washing up. The blood on their clothes and body signifies that their services are in high demand. Neither he nor his fellow doctors know at the time that disease is spread by microscopic pathogens. But Semmelweis begins to suspect that bloody clothes and hands may in some way be responsible for the childbed fever deaths. He decides to change his behavior. We can state his hypothesis as follows: If I clean up before delivering a child, then the mother will be less likely to fall ill and die. The Experiment Semmelweis begins to wash his hands in chlorine solution between patients and prior to delivering babies. The results are dramatic: deaths from childbed fever among his patients falls from thirteen percent to two percent. _____________ Semmelweis eventually returns to Hungary and replicates his experiment in another hospital.
    [Show full text]
  • Case Studies Skills Practiced
    Case Studies Skills Practiced Effectively Raising questions, communicating formulate problems Reaching reasoned conclusions What is a Case Study? 1. Introduce the situation or problem. 2. Give background information - describe previous research or give students reading beforehand. Supporting data can range from data tables to links to URLs, quoted statements or testimony, supporting documents, images, video, or audio. 3. Evaluate, ask questions, come up with potential solutions. 4. Report out, summarize, make recommendations, reflect. Case Study Example PART I Ignaz Semmelweis, a young Hungarian doctor working in the obstetrical ward of Vienna General Hospital in the late 1840s, was dismayed at the high death rate among his patients. He had noticed that nearly 20% of the women under his and his colleagues' care in Division I of the ward (the division attended by physicians and male medical students) died shortly after childbirth. Semmelweis noted that this death rate was four to five times greater than that in Division II of the ward (the division attended by female midwifery students). Case Study Example PART II One day, Semmelweis and some of his colleagues were in the autopsy room performing autopsies as they often did between deliveries. One of Semmelweis' colleagues, Jakob Kolletschka, accidentally punctured his finger with the scalpel during an autopsy. Days later, Kolletschka became quite sick, showing symptoms not unlike those of “childbed fever.” His friend's subsequent death strengthened Semmelweis' resolve to understand and prevent childbed fever. Case Study Example PART III In an effort to curtail the deaths in his ward due to childbed fever, Semmelweis instituted a strict hand washing policy amongst his male medical students and physician colleagues in Division I of the ward.
    [Show full text]
  • Ignaz Semmelweis & the Importance of Washing Your Hands
    How-To-Do-It Ignaz Semmelweis & the Importanceof Washing Your Hands Walter E. Brown,Jr. RobertP. Williams We all know that washing hands is of master of midwifery (Robinson an important act of personal hygiene 1929). to protect us from infections with mi- Medical students routinely exam- croorganisms. Is there any published ined patients in the First Clinic in evidence that washing hands does Vienna. In the Second Clinic, the mid- wives were trained and held respon- any good? In this articlewe briefly ex- Downloaded from http://online.ucpress.edu/abt/article-pdf/52/5/291/45020/4449112.pdf by guest on 25 September 2021 amine studies by Ignaz Semmelweis sible for patient care. Childbed fever that show its importance.This work is raged in the First Clinic, with a mor- an early contribution to the germ tality rate of about 10 percent-four theory of disease. At the end of the ar- times as great as that of the Second ticle, there is an experiment demon- Clinic. Semmelweis knew the mid- strating the evidence of his antiseptic wives did not attend autopsies. Nor practice. did they do patient examinations as Until the middle of the 19th cen- frequently as the medical students. It tury, hand washing by physicians and was appalling that more women were students was hasty and superficial dying in the hospital attended by phy- (Slaughter 1950). They washed their sicians than those attended by mid- hands with tap water and dried them wives. on their handkerchiefsor waved them One of Semmelweis's teachers died in the air; the surgeons then went di- suddenly from a small wound re- rectly to the wards to examine pa- ceived while performing an autopsy.
    [Show full text]
  • Ignaz Semmelweis
    Dr. Semmelweis The “Savior of Mothers” he need for hand washing, at home; however those that as obvious as it may be were taken to the hospitals due Ttoday, was not recognized to poverty, illegitimacy, or as a means of disease prevention birth complications, suffered a before the middle 1800’s. shocking mortality rate of 25 to 30 percent. Ignaz Philipp Semmelweis, a Hungarian physician, called the Semmelweis was not the first to "savior of mothers", made an make the connection of important discovery in 1847. He iatrogenic (doctor induced) proved statistically that the disease associated with child By Jay Hardy, CLS, SM (ASCP) incidence of puerperal fever, birth. In 1795, Alexander also known as childbed fever Gordon of Aberdeen, Scotland could be drastically cut by use of suggested that the fevers were hand washing standards for infectious processes, and that doctors and nurses in obstetrical physicians were the carrier, and Jay Hardy is the founder and clinics. president of Hardy Diagnostics. After studying microbiology at Puerperal fever, California State Universities at which can lead to a Fullerton and Long Beach, he more serious completed his Medical septicemia, is now Technology internship at Santa Barbara Cottage Hospital. known to be caused by either Group A The company began in 1980, or Group B shortly after Hardy served as a Streptococcus. Medical Technologist and microbiologist at Goleta Valley At that time in Hospital in California. Europe, most women delivered It was not uncommon to have a mortality rate of up to 30% in the obstetrical wards of Europe in the mid 19th century.
    [Show full text]